1798/97 10C 16 Stars on Reverse MS65 NGC....
Condition Census 1798/7 16 Stars JR-1 Dime, MS651798/97 10C 16 Stars on Reverse MS65 NGC. JR-1, R.3. Nicely centered on the planchet with excellent peripheral details and full borders, although the centers show considerable weakness on each side. Both sides exhibit frosty luster beneath deep golden-brown and iridescent toning. The overall appearance is highly pleasing with only a few tiny surface marks hidden in the devices.
Die State. The obverse has considerable die lapping evident in the form of missing hair details. The reverse has a short crack or spine to the right from star 10 over the eagle's head. This early die state piece shows a straight die line from star 3 to star 10, visible in the fields and intermittently on the bust.
Condition Census. This splendid Gem is most likely in the Condition Census, perhaps at a high level. In October 1973, Stack's sold an example reported in the dime book as the finest the authors had seen. The Scanlon coin later appeared in the Lovejoy sale, graded MS62 NGC. We have handled several Mint State examples of this variety in our auctions, but relatively few in Gem condition.
Obverse Die. Overdate with a small 8 over a large 7, the tail of the 7 visible well below the 8. 13 stars are arranged with seven left and six right. Stars 6 and 7 are much closer than all others on the left, and stars 11 and 12 nearly touch on the right. The date is low and the serif of the 1 is far from the missing low curl which has been lapped away. The top of the 8 is far from the drapery. Stars 1 and 13 are distant from the curl and drapery, and stars 7 and 8 are closer to the bust and Liberty.
State a. Die scratch from star 3 to star 10. State b. Die scratch disappears and clash marks appear.
Reverse Die. The constellation has 16 stars arranged in two rows of 7, with a single star on either side of the eagle's head. Each of the 16 stars is from a defective punch, with an extra short point. Only four berries appear in the branch, lacking the top inside berry. All letters in the legend are properly spaced, with a leaf point just left of the I.
State a. Perfect die, may not exist. A small die chip on cloud 8 may or may not be constant. State b. Faint die crack from star 10 to the right, over the eagle's head. State c. Diagonal die line from left tail feather to the border.
Heritage Commentary. The two 1798 overdates share a common obverse die that was first used for JR-1. The reverse is the same die that was earlier used for 1797 quarter eagles. For these coins, the emission sequence is 1797 BD-1 quarter eagle; 1798/7 JR-1 dime; 1798/7 JR-2 dime. Although from entirely different die pairs, we assume that the 1798 overdates were coined before the 1798 normal dates. For a discussion of the shared reverse dies, refer to the listing for the 1797 quarter eagle.
Four different reverse dies were prepared with 16 stars in the constellation, as illustrated below. The particular star arrangements for these four dies, including this die variety; and three quarter eagle varieties, are each slightly different. 1796 BD-1 and BD-2 quarter eagles are No Stars obverse types, 1796 BD-3 is the With Stars obverse type; and 1797 BD-1 is the only 1797 quarter eagle variety.
Consignor Commentary. This piece is very likely in the Condition Census.
Provenance. Stuart Levine (8/1/2003).
From The Ed Price Collection.(Registry values: P6) (NGC ID# 236F, PCGS# 4468)
Service and Handling Description: Coins & Currency (view shipping information)
Guides and Pricing Information:
Find Auction Prices for Comparable Items: