Heritage Auctions - World's Largest Collectibles Auctioneer

Session 1

Colonials

1652 SHILNG Pine Tree Shilling, Small Planchet--Damaged--NGC. VF Details. Crosby 22-L, Noe-17, W-840, R.3. 69.9 gn. Each side near 12 o'clock has an area of flattened, scuffed, and recolored surface. The legends are nonetheless complete except for a featureless E in ENGLAND and a couple of weakened nearby letters. Mostly steel-gray with clear designs and a mildly granular appearance. Listed on page 37 of the 2010 Guide Book.

(c. 1828) TOKEN American Plantations 1/24 Part Real, Restrike MS62 PCGS. Newman 5-D, W-1160, R.5. The prominent die break at the upper right obverse confirms the restrike variety. Light green-gray overall with darker spots at the margins and also on certain central areas, such as the horse's front hooves and the figure's head and waist. Listed on page 39 of the 2010 Guide Book. Population: 6 in 62, 5 finer (2/10).

(1694) TOKEN London Elephant Token, Thick Planchet MS62 Brown PCGS. Hodder 2-B, W-12040, R.2. The reverse appears to read LONDON GOD PRESERVE, since the designer chose to begin the legend at the top rather than the left side, as more normally seen on coinage. This glossy milk-chocolate example has some minor planchet roughness, with a bit of original mint red clinging to the peripheries. Listed on page 2010 Guide Book. Population: 10 in 62 Brown, 20 finer (2/10).

1723 1/2P Hibernia Halfpenny MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. Large 3, Pellet Before H, 11 Harpstrings, Breen-150, W-13470, Martin 4.14-Fb.1, R.3. Considerable peripheral copper-orange gives way to blue-brown at the centers. A lustrous Gem example of the popular Hibernia halfpenny.

1773 1/2P Virginia Halfpenny, Period MS64 Brown PCGS. CAC. Newman 22-S, W-1550, R.5. Orange-red luster outlines design elements, especially on the reverse, although PCGS refers to the color only as Brown. Devoid of marks, and the strike is crisp save for some softness on the central reverse. Listed on page 43 of the 2010 Guide Book.
From The Classic Collection.

1773 1/2P Virginia Halfpenny, Period MS64 Brown PCGS. Newman 24-K, W-1570, R.1. Beautiful chocolate patina with a strong overlay of deep blue on each side. Tremendous luster covers both sides of this piece. A noticeable rim-to-rim lamination runs through the center of the obverse, with a few tiny die chips at the bottom of the bust. There is also a minute die crack at the top of the reverse that adds a little flavor to this sharply struck example. Listed on page 43 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1773 1/2P Virginia Halfpenny, Period MS65 Red and Brown NGC. CAC. Newman 25-M, W-1580, R.2. Both violet-mahogany and copper-orange hues are present on this well struck Gem. Minimally marked with considerable eye appeal. Listed on page 43 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1773 1/2P Virginia Halfpenny, Period MS63 Red PCGS. Newman 23-Q, W-1560, R.3. Remarkable "Red" color with only minor spotting visible in the pale copper-orange fields, though a degree of turning is noted on the cheek. A well struck Select coin that is housed in a green label holder. Listed on page 43 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1773 1/2P Virginia Halfpenny, No Period MS64 Brown PCGS. Newman 4-G, W-1460, R.3. Glimmers of the original gold color radiate from the hair and legends. Seemingly unabraded aside from a faint pinscratch in the field near the nose. Die rust (as struck) near the lower hair tresses, with a few crude raised die scratches (as made) near the bust truncation. Listed on page 43 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1776 $1 Continental Dollar, CURENCY, Pewter--Genuine--NCS. Breen-1089, Crosby Pl. VIII, 15, Newman 1-C. The coin shows VG Details and evidence of environmental damage and has been bent. The usually seen variety with the CURENCY misspelling. This piece is ungraded by NCS, merely declared genuine, certainly an important consideration. The actual grade is assigned by the Heritage team of professional graders. The surfaces have gray-brown color with darker steel patina, and there is also evidence of corrosion. Listed on page 81 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1787 1/2 C Massachusetts Half Cent XF45 PCGS. Ryder 5-A, R.3. Pleasingly detailed for the grade and issue, with deep teak surfaces that show subtle violet accents. A meandering planchet flaw extends from the head of the Indian's arrow through his nearby foot and to the rim. Listed on page 57 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1788 1C Massachusetts Cent, Period XF40 PCGS. Ryder 1-D, R.3. A sharp and nearly unabraded example. The obverse has light verdigris near the legends and devices, and a couple of planchet streaks (as produced) are on the lower reverse. Listed on page 57 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1787 COPPER Connecticut Copper, Draped Bust Left AU58 NGC. M. 33.15-r.1, W-3605, R.2. The B in LIB is entered over an errant cinquefoil. A chocolate-brown state copper with noticeable luster across its unabraded surfaces. Distributed trivial laminations are as made and characteristic of the type. Listed on page 60 of the 2010 Guide Book.

Federal Contract Coinage

1787 1C Fugio Cent, STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils, Pointed Rays VF25 NGC. Newman 8-X, W-6750, R.3. A late state coin with massive die break through MIND YOUR BUSINESS. Moderately worn but with considerable gloss remaining on the chocolate-brown surfaces. Listed on page 83 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1787 1C Fugio Cent, STATES UNITED, Eight-Pointed Stars XF45 NGC. Newman 15-Y, R.2. This variety shows the ornament over the right edge of the upright of the recut I in BUSINESS, and 8-pointed stars after UNITED and STATES. A crack from the rim at 4 o'clock travels to the sundial. A uniformly struck light-tan Choice XF. A couple of obverse planchet defects do not detract.

1787 1C Fugio Cent, STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils, Pointed Rays MS61 Brown PCGS. Newman 12-X, W-6820, R.3. Strong blue and violet overtones enhance the eye appeal of this otherwise chocolate-brown Fugio cent. Die cracks are noted around the sun on the obverse and up into the rings from near 6 o'clock on the reverse. Minimally abraded for the grade assigned with glossy luster. Listed on page 83 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1787 1C Fugio Cent, STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils, Pointed Rays MS64 Brown NGC. Newman 12-X, W-6820, R.3. A satiny and unabraded example of this famous early Federal type. Any planchet issues are inconsequential, and the centers are well struck since incompleteness is limited to the margins at 3 and 9 o'clock. Glimpses of faded Red outline design elements, although open areas are medium brown. Listed on page 83 of the 2010 Guide Book. Census: 28 in 64 Brown, 16 finer (2/10).

Colonials

1783 SHLNG Chalmers Shilling, Short Worm--Plugged--NGC. VF Details. Breen-1011, W-1785, High R.5. This slate-gray and charcoal shilling has pleasing detail aside from that lost due to a plug that affects the ON in ONE and the LIS in ANNAPOLIS. All Chalmers silver pieces are very scarce to extremely rare, depending upon variety. Listed on page 49 of the 2010 Guide Book.

(1785) COPPER Bar Copper MS62 Brown PCGS. Breen-1145, W-8520, R.4. Although little is known of the Bar "cents," it is thought that they were produced in England. The 1785 date associated with these pieces represents their first appearance in circulation in New York. The beauty of these pieces is their simplicity of design. The 13 bars represent the 13 states, while the interlocking letters USA conceptualize the unity of a young nation.
This lovely Bar copper has smooth medium brown surfaces with a few splashes of darker brown toning. The letters on the obverse and bars on the reverse tend toward olive-brown. Listed on page 70 of the 2010 Guide Book. Population: 3 in 62 Brown, 9 finer (2/10).

1789 TOKEN Mott Token, Thin Planchet, Engrailed Edge MS64 Brown PCGS. Ex: Roper. Thin Planchet, Engrailed Edge. Breen-1025. In his Encyclopedia, Breen lists this variety as "very rare." A scarce edge variant of this popular Early American issue. This is a lustrous, golden-brown beauty with no post-striking problems. From an early state of dies, with no indication of a die break from the upper left corner of the clock. The eagle is sharper than usually seen, although the neck is indistinct. The reverse is misaligned about 5% toward 6:30, which greatly aids in tracing the coin's pedigree. Listed on page 70 of the 2010 Guide Book.
Ex: Roper Collection (Stack's, 12/1983), lot 338; 2001 FUN Sale (Heritage, 1/2001), lot 6085, where it sold for $4,370; 2007 FUN Sale (Heritage, 1/2007), lot 217, where it brought $13,800.

(1792-94) TOKEN Kentucky Token, Plain Edge MS64 Brown PCGS. Breen-1155, W-8800, R.1. Among all of the Colonial American issues, the Kentucky token is one of the most plentiful in Mint State grades. Examples are seen frequently. This piece is a splendid Choice Mint State coin with dark brown toning and splashes of blue iridescence. Listed on page 71 of the 2010 Guide Book.

1783 TOKEN Georgivs Triumpho Token AU58 PCGS. CAC. Baker-7, W-10100, R.3. The portrait perhaps more closely resembles King George III, but the Georgivs Triumpho is believed to be among the earliest Washington issues, perhaps commemorating the end of the Revolutionary War. Like most examples seen, the present piece has a large vertical die break in front of the standing reverse figure. It is a splendid and partly lustrous chocolate-brown near-Mint token with no consequential marks or carbon. Listed on page 75 of the 2010 Guide Book. Population: 6 in 58, 1 finer (1/10).

1791 1C Washington Large Eagle Cent MS65 Brown PCGS. Baker-15, W-10610, R.2. A glorious specimen of this elusive issue that is very difficult to find in full Gem grades as seen here. The strike is exceptional for this issue. Note the complete epaulet on Washington's shoulder, a device which is so often poorly defined on most examples. The surfaces show scattered handling nicks, including a tiny nick on Washington's cheek on a horizontal line back from the lower edge of his nose which will serve for an identifier. On the reverse, the eagle shows complete feather definition on his wings, legs, and neck, areas which are frequently poorly struck. No problematic spots or carbon issues. Any collector lucky enough to purchase this coin will cherish it for years to come. Listed on page 77 of the 2010 Guide Book. Population: 4 in 65 Brown, 1 finer (2/10).

1795 1/2P Washington Grate Halfpenny, Large Buttons, Reeded Edge MS65 Brown NGC. Baker-29A, W-10955, R.1. Dark brown surfaces show traces of reflectivity, with bold design features. This highly appealing Gem will find considerable demand from colonial collectors and Washington enthusiasts. Listed on page 79 of the 2010 Guide Book.

Undated MEDAL Washington Success Medal, Large Size, Reeded Edge--Obverse Scratched--NGC. AU Details. Baker-265B, W-10900, R.6. No break from Washington's nose. Mingled olive and golden-brown colors with a curved indentation in the planchet at the right (as seen from the obverse). Scratches in the field to the right of the portrait account for the details grade.

Undated MEDAL Washington Success Medal, Large Size, Reeded Edge AU58 PCGS. CAC. Baker-265, with the familiar obverse die break from 11 to 3 o'clock across Washington's nose. This moderately circulated piece is toned medium brown and is virtually devoid of marks. The reverse exhibits nearly unbroken luster. The all-seeing eye is incompletely brought up, as always. Listed on page 80 of the 2010 Guide Book. Population: 3 in 58, 7 finer (2/10).

Half Cents

1793 1/2 C Genuine PCGS. C-1, B-1, High R.3. The PCGS number ending in .95 suggests Scratched as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AG specimen that is scratched and corroded. A thin vertical scratch is noted on the left obverse field near the profile. Slight rim dings are apparent at 5 and 7 o'clock on the obverse. The surfaces are moderately rough, as expected for a well circulated example. The date is clear, as are most peripheral letters. A budget example of this desirable first year and single year type. MRB Fair 2.(Registry values: P8, N8)

1793 1/2 C VG8 PCGS. C-3, B-3, R.3. The Y in LIBERTY and the cap are close, and on the reverse, the lowest right leaf points to the C in AMERICA. A significantly worn yet pleasingly smooth example of this popular first-year half cent, with golden accents adding a touch of lightness to the rich brown surfaces. MRB Good 5.(Registry values: P8)

1793 1/2 C VF25 PCGS. C-2, B-2, R.3. Obverse with die defect at the top left of the 9 in the date, reverse with 2 in the denominator nearly touching the ribbon. The reverse is rotated approximately 45 degrees clockwise from "coin turn."
Half cents and large cents were the only Federal coinage denominations struck at the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia in 1793, and both enjoy immense collector popularity. This example of the smaller denomination has moderate wear but few serious abrasions. Deep teak-brown hues dominate the fields, while the worn high points offer lighter caramel color. An entirely pleasing survivor. MRB Fine 12.(Registry values: P8)

1794 1/2 C Fine 15 PCGS. C-7, B-7, R.5. Manley Die State 1.0. The usual heavy die crack is visible from the rim through the right side of E of UNITED through the tops of two leaves to the stem. A pleasing medium brown Choice Fine displaying appropriate definition and no significant abrasions. MRB Fine 12.(Registry values: P7)

1795 1/2 C Lettered Edge AU55 NGC. C-1, B-1, R.2. Manley Die State 1.0 without a bulge through the AME in AMERICA. A splendidly detailed and partially lustrous example of the widely sought Liberty Cap, Bust Right design type. Medium brown overall, although protected areas are chocolate-brown. The fields are uncommonly mark-free, and the portrait has only a few small ticks. Minor spots are noted within the E in AMERICA and on the obverse rim near 9 o'clock. Most 1795 half cents are corroded and/or heavily circulated, which makes a lightly circulated example highly desirable. MRB XF40.(Registry values: P6)

1795 1/2 C Lettered Edge, Punctuated Date VF25 PCGS. C-2a, B-2a, R.3. The Lettered Edge half cents were struck on the heavier planchets first introduced in 1793, while late in 1795 the lighter Plain Edge coins were introduced due to an increase in copper prices. This pleasing dark-olive piece has minor handling marks on otherwise smooth surfaces. MRB Fine 15.(Registry values: P6)

1795 1/2 C Plain Edge AU55 NGC. C-6a, B-6, R.2. Pleasing chestnut-brown and sepia tones accompany some minor maroon patina and faint traces of corrosion on both sides of this delightful half cent. The surfaces have a few insignificant handling marks as so often found, but the overall appearance and desirability of this piece are high. MRB VF30.
Ex: Lester Merkin (10/1972), lot 514.(Registry values: P6)

1796 1/2 C With Pole Genuine PCGS. C-2, B-2, High R.4. The PCGS number ending in .97 suggests Environmental Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of a Fair specimen that is corroded and damaged. The date and pole are clear, and a majority of the legends are readable. Darkly toned and somewhat rough with a patch of fine pinscratches on the centers of both sides. Liberty's cheek has a circular depression. The 1796 is the rarest date of the half cent denomination, and examples are eagerly sought regardless of condition. MRB Fair 2.(Registry values: P9, N9)

1797 1/2 C 1 Above 1, Plain Edge XF45 NGC. C-1, B-1, R.2. Manley Die State 2.0. A deep brown half cent that has noticeable satin luster and only a hint of granularity near the top of the cap and on the reverse border between 12 and 3 o'clock. Devoid of mentionable marks. MRB VF30. NGC C-1 Census: 4 in 45, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

1804 1/2 C Plain 4, No Stems MS63 Brown PCGS. C-13, B-10, R.1. Manley Die State 2.0, the usual state for this variety. The C-13 half cent is the only 1804 variety of the Plain 4, No Stems style, with demand strong from variety and date collectors. This piece, housed in a green label PCGS holder, has lovely chestnut and dark chocolate surfaces with splashes of deeper steel toning. MRB AU55.(Registry values: P4)

1804 1/2 C Spiked Chin AU53 NGC. C-8, B-7, R.1. The most available of the Spiked Chin half cent varieties of 1804. Faintly blue-brown surfaces are lightly worn but minimally abraded. The lower obverse shows planchet flaws near the issue's hallmark ridges to the right of Liberty. MRB XF40.(Registry values: P4)

1805 1/2 C Small 5, No Stems--Double Struck--VF20 PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. Manley Die State 1.0. Designated by PCGS as "Obverse Double Struck in Collar", although we believe that the first strike was uniface obverse and widely off center toward 1:30. The second strike was well centered, and removed most design elements of the first strike, although Liberty's profile is clearly seen within the hair from the second strike, and the curve of a planchet is noted beneath the ribbon loop. A chocolate-brown half cent with bold legends and only a few faded thin marks on the upper right obverse field. MRB Fine 12.

1806 1/2 C Small 6, No Stems MS62 Brown NGC. CAC. C-1, B-3, R.1. The only No Stems die marriage for the year and a once-hoarded issue that can occasionally be located at the Uncirculated level. This well struck example has glimpses of faded mint color in the protected areas. MRB MS60. Census: 7 in 62 Brown, 4 finer (2/10).
Ex: Central States, Rarcoa Sale (5/1969), lot 31; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2004), lot 7007.(Registry values: P4)

1808/7 1/2 C VF25 PCGS. C-2, B-2, R.3. The more available of two overdate die pairs for the year, though still scarce across all grades. A midrange piece with olive accents against chocolate-brown surfaces. MRB Fine 12.(Registry values: P5)

1808/7 1/2 C VF25 PCGS. C-2, B-2, R.3. An engraver's scratch extends from the right stem end toward the right foot of the last A in AMERICA. Even medium brown color bathes both sides of this appropriately defined overdate representative. Minimally marked. MRB Fine 15. Population for the issue: 9 in 25, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

1809 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-3, B-4, R.1. When a Mint State 1809 half cent is encountered, odds are great that it is an example of the C-3 die marriage. It is this variety that is seen more often than all others in MS60 or finer grades. This example shows a narrow rim break in the dentils over the D, as always, but that rim break is sometimes invisible due to centering issues. Here is a boldly defined Gem with full satiny cartwheel luster, deep steel toning, and hints of faded mint color on the reverse. MRB MS62. Census: 5 in 65 Brown, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

1826 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Manley Die State 2.0. This is a rare early die state with a crack from the border to star 1 and the drapery, and with weak clash marks on the reverse. The crossing die file marks to the right of the date immediately identify this variety. They are always present, though may be weak in later die states. This wonderful Gem has sharp design definition with satiny luster and lovely dark brown surfaces. Both sides have additional iridescent toning that adds to its overall eye appeal. MRB MS62. Census: 4 in 65 Brown, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

1828 1/2 C 13 Stars MS65 Brown PCGS. CAC. C-3, B-2, R.1. Though labeled Brown, this coin shows considerable reddish-peach color through the margins. The well struck centers are more violet-brown. MRB MS63.(Registry values: P1)

1828 1/2 C 13 Stars MS65 Brown NGC. C-3, B-2, R.1. The latest die state. A pleasing Gem with bluish-brown surfaces and traces of orange around the devices. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1828 1/2 C 13 Stars MS65 Brown NGC. C-3, B-2, R.1. The usual late die state. This lovely sepia toned Gem has traces of iridescence over satiny surfaces. The design elements are bold and the entire presentation is highly appealing. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1828 1/2 C 13 Stars MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-3, B-2, R.1. This fairly early die state has visible repunching of star 7, and faint clash marks on the reverse. A highly lustrous Gem, this piece has full cartwheel luster with frosty surfaces and considerable original mint color, blended with attractive olive-brown. Here is an excellent piece for a type set or specialized half cent collection. MRB MS63. Census: 11 in 65 Red and Brown, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1828 1/2 C 13 Stars MS66 Red and Brown NGC. C-3, B-2, R.1. Manley Die State 3.0. This remarkable Premium Gem has a predominantly Red reverse, and the obverse retains the initial orange-gold near design recesses. The cheek and open obverse field are toned. The major devices are well struck, with minor softness relegated to the dentils and upper left stars. MRB MS63. Census: 2 in 66 Red and Brown, none finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1829 1/2 C MS64 Brown PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. Frosty surfaces exhibit light to medium brown patina with only a few insignificant contact marks. MRB AU55.(Registry values: P3)

1829 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Hints of violet combined with light brown toning, accompanying considerable light orange mint color on both sides of this splendid Gem. This early die state example has weak, but full, obverse and reverse borders. While Mint State 1829 half cents are encountered quite frequently, few survive with original mint color. MRB MS63. Census: 4 in 65 Red and Brown, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

1833 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Manley State 2.0 as usual. A lovely Gem with reflective, satiny surfaces and light brown toning. A splash of darker color is evident on each side of this appealing piece. MRB MS62.(Registry values: P1)

1833 1/2 C MS65 Brown PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. Manley Die State 2.0, the usual die state for all 1833 half cents. Housed in a green label PCGS holder, this Gem has reflective surfaces, sharp design details, and satin luster. The obverse has a blend of olive-brown and steel-blue. The reverse is lighter tan with considerable original orange. MRB MS60. Population: 21 in 65 Brown, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1834 1/2 C MS65 Brown PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. Manley Die State 3.0, and scarcer than earlier die states. Predominately golden-brown, although the reverse has powder-blue and rose tints, and a blush of steel-gray crosses the upper obverse. A gorgeous Gem that has a penetrating strike and impressively unabraded and spot-free surfaces. MRB MS60. Population: 12 in 65 Brown, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1834 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. An early die state with perfect obverse and reverse dies, and frequently seen in this state. This pleasing olive-brown Gem has traces of faded orange luster. MRB AU55.(Registry values: P1)

1835 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Sharply struck from clashed dies. This Gem has olive-brown surfaces with considerable blue and iridescent toning. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1835 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-2, B-2, R.1. Manley State 2.0. Splashes of faded orange luster accompany the chestnut-brown surfaces of this sharply defined Gem. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1835 1/2 C MS65 Brown PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. A late die state with obverse and reverse clash marks. An intricately struck and satiny example that displays prominent clash marks in front of the profile. Toned chocolate-brown with an occasional glimpse of red and a few toning flecks near the letters in HALF CENT. Certified in an old doily label holder. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1835 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Prominent obverse and reverse clash marks are visible on this Gem example. Both sides have medium brown surfaces with traces of orange luster. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1835 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-2, B-2, R.1. Manley Die State 2.0. Sharply detailed with reddish-brown surfaces that host iridescent toning on both sides. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1835 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. A late die state with prominent clash marks on each side. This sharply defined Gem is fully lustrous with faded orange toning and splashes of steel-brown toning on the obverse and the reverse. MRB MS63. Census: 24 in 65 Red and Brown, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1835 1/2 C MS66 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Both sides have light clash marks. This Premium Gem has mostly brilliant, fiery orange mint color, with streaks, splashes, and lines of dark olive and ebony patina. Quite possibly from the Elmer Sears hoard that was discovered circa 1935, when these coins were but a century old. MRB MS63. Census: 4 in 66 Red and Brown, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1849 1/2 C Large Date MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-4, R.2. Blue-brown and violet with fragments of tan at the periphery. A boldly impressed and highly appealing Gem. MRB AU55. Census: 8 in 65 Brown, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

1853 1/2 C MS65 Brown PCGS. B-1, C-1, R.1. A well struck Gem that has a seemingly pristine reverse and a well preserved portrait. Hints of rich copper-gold color enliven the chocolate-brown surfaces. The obverse has a blush of powder-blue iridescence at 9 o'clock. A small die lump near the cheekbone is characteristic of the issue. MRB MS60+. Population: 35 in 65 Brown, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS65 Brown PCGS. B-1, C-1, R.1. A beautiful Gem half cent, with glossy mahogany-brown surfaces that reveal steel-green border accents. Both sides are mark-free, and there are a mere handful of carbon specks found on the lower half of the obverse. Certified in a green label holder. MRB MS60. Population: 35 in 65 Brown, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS65 Brown PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. This boldly defined Gem has frosty cartwheel luster with dark steel-brown surfaces. Faint traces of orange luster are evident on the reverse. MRB MS62.(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. This boldly detailed Premium Gem has frosty luster with rich dark chocolate surfaces and excellent eye appeal. MRB MS62.(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. CAC. C-1, B-1, R.1. This frosty Premium Gem has rich bluish-brown surfaces with full cartwheel luster. It is a sharply detailed piece with excellent eye appeal. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. The design motifs on both sides of this Premium Gem are boldly detailed. The surfaces have lovely medium brown luster with full mint frost. Traces of original orange color remain. MRB MS62.(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. A penetratingly struck golden-brown beauty with refreshingly smooth surfaces and an occasional glimpse of original orange iridescence. MRB MS60+.(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Splashes of orange mint color accompany the light blue and olive-brown surfaces of this sharply defined Premium Gem. MRB MS63.(Registry values: P1)

1853 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Both sides of this lovely Premium Gem have considerable mint red with pleasing medium blue-brown surfaces. MRB MS63.(Registry values: P1)

1854 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. An early die state with a short horizontal die line left of the 1 in the date from a misplaced punch. Later die states have that feature fading away. The subdued dark brown surfaces host sharp design elements with traces of faded mint red and iridescence. MRB MS60. Census: 12 in 66 Brown, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1854 1/2 C MS64 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Ample peach and orange elements prevail on each side of this near-Gem, though the central reverse shows green-brown elements. Well struck and attractive with few overt abrasions. MRB MS64.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P1)

1854 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. CAC. C-1, B-1, R.1. This wonderful Gem retains more than half of its original orange luster, with the balance a pleasing olive-brown. Only the presence of a few microscopic surface flecks prevents a higher grade. MRB MS64.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS65 Prooflike NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. NGC omits a color designation. This beautiful Gem is well struck except for the denticles, and the consistently flashy fields offer blended light rose and sky-blue toning. The NGC online census report (2/10) fails to list any Prooflike pieces, which suggests the present coin is unique with a Prooflike designation. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. B-1, C-1, R.1. Mellowed to an even chocolate-brown color, with pleasing, defect-free surfaces. Abundant traces of original mint red luster remain in the crevices on each side. MRB MS63.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Smooth and lustrous olive-brown surfaces serve as a base for the frosty cartwheel luster on this Premium Gem. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. This distinctive piece has intermingled olive-brown, ebony, and faded red color on each side. MRB AU50.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS66 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. A wonderful Premium Gem with smooth olive-brown surfaces and considerable original faded orange luster. MRB MS62.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Mostly reddish-brown on the obverse and largely auburn-orange on the reverse. A handful of tiny marks are present on the sharply struck portrait. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. A wonderful Gem with considerable original orange luster, especially on the reverse. This piece is boldly defined and possesses excellent eye appeal. Splashes of olive- and reddish-brown toning are visible on both sides. MRB MS64.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Bright orange color accompanies turquoise and bluish-brown patina on this sharp example. MRB AU55.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS64 Red NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. The only variety known. Lustrous copper-orange surfaces display some undisturbing toning spots, more so on the obverse. Nicely struck and revealing no mentionable marks. MRB MS64. Census: 77 in 64 Red, 9 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS65 Red NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Ex: Foxfire. This example has fully lustrous mint red color on both sides with excellent eye appeal. Like nearly every example of this date in similar quality, a few minor black flecks can be seen on both sides, with a small greenish corrosion spot at the upper reverse. Otherwise, both sides have pristine surfaces. MRB MS63+.(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS65 Red NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Bright copper-orange luster dominates the upper and lower reaches, while the centers show peach infusions. A survivor with surprisingly smooth surfaces, pleasingly detailed on the portrait but with a degree of weakness at parts of the dentils. MRB MS64. Census: 9 in 65 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1855 1/2 C MS65 Red PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. A gorgeous fire-red Gem type coin that has essentially mark-free surfaces. The devices are well struck, although portions of the dentils are softly brought up. Carbon is microscopic aside from one small spot on the second S in STATES. Encapsulated in a first generation holder. MRB MS63. Population: 24 in 65 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1856 1/2 C MS65 Brown PCGS. C-1, B-1, R.1. Manley Die State 1.0. An example of the early die state with the rust lump on the top of the I in UNITED. Pleasing medium brown surfaces with excellent design definition. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P2)

1856 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. Manley Die State 1.0. This is the scarce early die state (per Manley), or the scarce variety (per Breen), with a tiny rust lump on the top of the I in UNITED. Breen considered it a separate variety and called it R.5. Today, most collectors agree with Manley that it is merely a die state. Attractive surfaces with medium brown and steel toning. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P2)

1857 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.1. A light brown Gem with hints of lavender and iridescent toning on both sides. The design features are a trifle weak. MRB AU55.(Registry values: P2)

1857 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.2. The borders display slightly faded orange-red, while the fields and major devices are brown with a hint of lilac. This lustrous Gem is sharply struck except for the occasional incomplete denticle. Unmarked and virtually devoid of carbon. An outstanding representative of the final date of the denomination. MRB MS63.(Registry values: P2)

1857 1/2 C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. C-1, B-1, R.2. This lustrous Gem is approximately 50% Red, with areas of peach iridescence competing for territory with steel-gray. A good strike despite minor inexactness on LIBERTY. Free from marks aside from a solitary tick on the central reverse. The lowest business strike mintage of the Braided Hair type. MRB MS63.(Registry values: P2)

Proof Braided Hair Half Cents

1840 1/2 C Second Restrike PR65 Red and Brown PCGS. Ex: Eliasberg. B-3, High R.6. This gorgeous Gem proof ranks high in the Condition Census, and may qualify as the finest known example of the 1840 Second Restrike half cent. It is boldly defined with pale lilac toning over brilliant orange mint color on the obverse, with deeper lilac and blue toning on the reverse. The remarkable Eliasberg cabinet contained a selection of proof only half cents, including many Gem and near-Gem specimens. MRB PR64.
Ex: Clapp Estate (1942); Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr.; Eliasberg Estate (Bowers and Merena, 5/1996), lot 453; in the estate of Osipowicz Tadek since 1996. Possibly earlier from Thomas Elder before 1907.(Registry values: P3)

1845 1/2 C Restrike PR65 Brown NGC. SR-22, B-3, R.6. Small date; Small berries, file marks at RICA. Early state of the reverse die with file marks clear, and diagonal striae fully visible. This is the plate coin in the second edition of Cohen. Number 14 of 19 examples listed by Richard Coleman in his Monograph of Second Restrike Proof Half Cents. The date has the digit 5 leaning to the right and distinctly recut.
The obverse has intermingled olive and chocolate-brown tones while the reverse is fully olive. The fields are mildly reflective and not deeply mirrored, as expected on these Proofs. Some design weakness is noted, especially on Liberty's hair strands over the ear, and on some of the leaves in the wreath. A mild abrasion has left a thin line of bright copper color from the top of Liberty's head to the border just below star 9. This example appears to qualify as Series V in Breen's notation. MRB PR60.
Ex: Stack's (4/1962), lot 235; 1976 ANA (Stack's), lot 195; Superior (10/1977), lot 151; Julian Leidman (7/18/1978); The Jules Reiver Collection (Heritage, 1/2006), lot 19136.(Registry values: P4)

1848 1/2 C First Restrike PR64 Brown NGC. B-2, High R.5. Both sides of this sharply detailed near-Gem proof have rich and deep violet, emerald, and blue toning. The fields have full but shallow mirrors around lustrous devices. A few minor blemishes include small marks on Liberty's cheek. Only a little over 30 of these First Restrike 1848 half cents are thought to exist today. MRB PR60. Census: 3 in 64 Brown, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

Large Cents

1793 Chain 1C AMERI. Fine 15 PCGS. S-1, B-1, R.4. Easily distinguished by the lack of periods and the wide date on the obverse and the AMERI. reverse. This is a sharply defined Choice Fine example, including the obverse design elements that are nearly always weak. Even the date digits are strong, as are all of the reverse features. Medium brown patination covers both sides, which are devoid of significant contact marks. Uniformly distributed microporosity, a usual characteristic of early large cents, shows only under a loupe and is completely undisturbing. This moderately circulated, problem free piece is an excellent choice for a midgrade large cent or type collection. MRB Fine 12.(Registry values: P5)

1793 Chain 1C AMERICA Fair 2 PCGS. Appears to be S-3, B-4, Low R.3. The obverse is nearly smooth. On the reverse, the chain, ONE CENT, and the fraction show, along with partial definition in the legend. The only noticeable mark on the medium brown surfaces occurs in the center of the obverse, and it is not all that bad. A good example for the budget-minded collector. MRB Basal State 1.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1793 Chain 1C AMERICA VF30 PCGS. S-3, B-4, Low R.3. The bust line is straight, and the R in LIBERTY is large, high, and leans right. On the reverse AMERICA is spelled out. The Sheldon-3 is the most common Chain cent variety, comprising perhaps half of all known examples of the Chain subtype. The charcoal-brown surfaces are a bit glossy, but free of active corrosion. A few shallow hairlines are observed on the right obverse, but they are quite faint to the unaided eye. Overall, this example strikes the viewer as being evenly worn, with a few small blemishes that are insignificant for the grade. A nice midgrade example for a similarly graded date or variety set. MRB VF20.(Registry values: N4719)

1793 Chain 1C AMERICA MS63 Brown PCGS. S-3, B-4, Low R.3. Breen Die State III, the latest die state listed, although we have seen some examples with clash marks even heavier than on this example. This lovely 1793 Chain cent, like most early coins, has considerable character and individuality. It combines outstanding technical quality with an historic provenance that dates back nearly 150 years, one of the longest ownership records of any Chain cent known today. This Chain cent appeared on the April 1869 Levick plate, the first photographic plate of large cents that appeared in the American Journal of Numismatics. The Levick plate was also the first systematic attempt at the classification of large cent varieties. Twelve obverse dies and 10 reverse dies were illustrated in an arrangement of 15 different varieties. The photography was by Joseph N.T. Levick, with the descriptions and arrangements by Sylvester S. Crosby. The achievement was remarkable for the time, as only seven additional die marriages have been discovered in the 141 years since that publication.
R.W. Julian wrote in an article on the 1793 cents in the May 1990 issue of Coins magazine: "There is probably more fascination with the 1793 issues of the Philadelphia Mint than any other coinage of this country, yet the average collector knows little of this far-off year." The 1793 Chain cents, beginning with the famous Chain AMERI cent, were the first federal coins actually struck at the U.S. Mint early that year. The entire production of 36,103 coins (of all five known varieties), took place in early March, although R.W. Julian, Walter Breen, and others speculated that some may have been minted on February 22, marking President Washington's birthday. Julian continued: "The dies were finished around the second week of February 1793 and trial strikes made to see that they worked on the Mint presses. Almost certainly there was a special ceremony connected with these trial strikes, and it has been suggested that it was held Feb. 22, a well known date in American history. Washington's birthday was celebrated even during his lifetime, and what better way to mark the formal beginning of coinage than by holding a ceremony on that special day?"
Based on delivery figures for those coins, and the current rarity of each variety, it is thought that S-3 represented almost half of the entire Chain cent mintage, or nearly 18,000 coins. However, the Chain cents proved unpopular with the public. Commentary ranged from "Liberty in chains" to a bad omen. In his Large Cent Encyclopedia, Breen quoted a letter that appeared in a Philadelphia newspaper on March 18, 1793: "The American Cents (says a letter from Newark) do not answer our expectations. The chain on the reverse is but a bad omen for liberty, and Liberty herself appears to be in a fright." After the supply of copper blanks was exhausted, Mint Director David Rittenhouse ordered a change to the new Wreath design, perhaps in reply to the adverse public criticism. The first Wreath cents were coined less than a month after the last Chain cents.
Of course, today, public dissatisfaction is hardly the case, as the Chain cents are at once the most popular large cents ever produced, and highly desired as the first of their kind. The opportunity to acquire a high grade example of any variety seldom comes along, and the present offering should be considered with extreme enthusiasm. Every Mint State 1793 Chain cent that appears on the market is subject to heavy bidding pressure. There are few pieces available, and they are unable to meet the demand for these amazing coins. The combined NGC and PCGS Census includes the following: MS67 Brown (2); MS66 Red and Brown; MS66 Brown; MS65 Red and Brown; MS65 Brown (5); MS64 Brown (3); MS63 Brown (7); MS62 Brown (4); MS61 Brown (2), and MS60 Brown. Resubmissions reduce the number of certified coins to a net population well below the 27 coins listed here. For example, the present specimen represents both an MS64 Brown and an MS63 Brown in the list above.
Both sides have splendid sepia surfaces with frosty cartwheel luster. A tiny rim bruise below the 7, and another smaller rim bruise left of the date, positively match those seen on the Levick Plate coin. Slight weakness at the center of the obverse, with minutely diminished detail on the chain, account for the conservative XF45 grades that Bill Noyes and Del Bland have given this coin. The certification services consider the worth of any coin, with PCGS grading this coin MS63 Brown. Earlier, when it appeared in the 2003 American Numismatic Rarities sale, it was graded MS64 Brown NGC. In each auction appearance since 1956, this 1793 cent has realized a higher price than in its previous appearance. The combination of an historic U.S. coin, an ever-increasing auction price record, and remarkable preservation makes this a true showpiece, a coin that will be the centerpiece of its next collecting residence.
Ex: Colin Lightbody (Edward Cogan, 12/1866), lot 536; Mortimer Livingston Mackenzie (Edward Cogan, 6/1869), lot 624; L. Bayard Smith; later, Arthur L. Gray; Ted and Carl Brandts (Celina Coin Co.); T. James Clarke (10/1954); R.E. Naftzger, Jr.; Abe Kosoff (4/1956), lot 4, $700; Stack's; Dorothy Nelson (Stack's, 2/1976), lot 3, $8,500; Ed Hipps; Steve Ivy (11/1978), lot 7, $13,250; Robert E. Bender; 1988 ANA (Heritage, 7/1988), lot 43, $22,000; Anthony Terranova; Kevin Lipton; American Numismatic Rarities (7/2003), lot 105, $115,000; Stack's (7/2008), lot 1074; Steve Contursi; Chris McCawley, 1/2009); Dan Holmes (Goldberg Coins, 9/2009), lot 5. The obverse was illustrated on the Levick Plate for variety 2.(Registry values: N10218)

1793 1C Wreath Cent, Vine and Bars--Corrosion--NGC. Fine Details. S-8, B-13, R.3. The layout of the trefoil is distinctive. A well-worn and moderately corroded example of the Wreath cent, yet one that is surprisingly appealing, thanks to light contrasts between the various levels of the chocolate-brown surfaces. MRB Good 4.(Registry values: N2998)

100

1794 1C Head of 1794 VF30 PCGS. S-43, B-32, R.2. The obverse is known as the Short Bust, and is usually recognized at a glance by the lowest hair strand, which is clipped and ends in a point, rather than the usual curl. The surfaces have a blend of dark tan and steel-blue, with minor abrasions and small rim bumps. The strike is imperfectly centered. MRB Fine 15.(Registry values: P1)

101

1794 1C Head of 1794 XF40 PCGS. S-59, B-57, R.3. A splendid cent with smooth deep olive patina and splashes of darker steel toning. Both sides exhibit the usual minor handling marks associated with the grade, but they are mostly inconsequential. A single small mark on Liberty's cheek below the eye may serve to locate the pedigree. MRB VF30.(Registry values: P1)

102

1794 1C Head of 1794 XF40 PCGS. S-51, B-42, Low R.5. This variety is an important die combination in the 1794 series. The Closed Wreath reverse of this variety was used extensively, with six different obverse dies. Pleasing olive-brown surfaces with a few small corrosion spots of only minor consequence. Close to the Condition Census for the variety. MRB VF20.(Registry values: P1)

103

1794 1C Head of 1794--Corrosion--NGC. XF Details. S-25, B-15, R.3. Circulation wear is minimal, but this ebony-brown Liberty Cap cent is lightly burnished and has distributed verdigris. Mint luster is noticeable within the hair curls. MRB VG8.(Registry values: P1)

104

1794 1C Head of 1795 AU50 PCGS. S-67, R.3. The circular curl, two die breaks near juncture of cap with hair, and double leaves under D of UNITED and O of OF confirm the variety. This is a highly attractive medium brown piece with well defined design motifs that are nicely centered on the planchet. There are no mentionable post-strike marks, just a couple of inoffensive shallow laminations on the reverse. MRB XF40.(Registry values: N2998)

105

1796 1C Draped Bust, Reverse of 1795 Fine 15 PCGS. S-116, B-36, R.5. Two different nomenclatures exist, the Reverse of 1795 and the Reverse of 1796. The reverse design style is easily recognized by the single leaf at the top of each branch of the wreath. This important example has smooth medium olive surfaces with few imperfections. Weakness at the top of the letters on the reverse is a result of the original planchet type. MRB VG10.(Registry values: N991)

106

1796 1C Draped Bust, Reverse of 1795--Corroded--ANACS. XF Details, Net VF20. S-116, High R.5. This rare variety example has impressive definition, but is porous and has dark olive-brown color. Single leaf wreath termination affirms its status as the Reverse of 1795. MRB VG8.(Registry values: N1793)

107

1796 1C Draped Bust, Reverse of 1795--Obverse Scratched--NCS. XF Details. S-92, High R.3. A medium gray representative with pleasing hair definition and clear legends. Deep brown fields surround lighter lilac-tan devices. A horizontal scratch reaches Liberty's eye, otherwise unmarked and only moderately granular. MRB Fine 12.(Registry values: N1793)

108

1797 1C Reverse of 1797, No Stems VG10 ANACS. S-132, Low R.5. Two different stemless reverse dies were combined with 1797-dated obverse dies to form five different varieties. None of the five are common, and only one is scarce, with the other four all being rarities. Heavy, even wear is seen on each side with even, deep brown patina. MRB Good 5.(Registry values: N491)

109

1798 1C First Hair Style VF20 PCGS. S-161, B-22, R.2. Readily attributed by the prominent cud centered above the TE in STATES. Toned deep walnut-brown with obverse powder-blue undertones. Only lightly abraded, and Liberty's hair has substantial design detail. MRB Fine 12.(Registry values: N491)

110

1798 1C Second Hair Style VF35 PCGS. S-182, B-43, R.4. Non-gold coinage in 1798 was a matter of tenths and hundredths, as only the silver dollar, dime, and cent were struck with that date. This example of the last and smallest denomination has deep chocolate-brown color with considerable gloss. Well struck with light, scattered digs across each side. MRB VF30.(Registry values: P1)

111

1798 1C Second Hair Style--Corroded--NCS. AU Details. S-184, Low R.2. A richly detailed ebony-brown representative. Recessed areas display verdigris, but abrasions are surprisingly few in number and relevance. MRB VF30.(Registry values: P1)

112

1799 1C VF35 PCGS. S-189, B-3, R.2. Breen Die State V. The 1799 is famous as the key to the entire series of large cents; it is the date that every collector desires, and few ever obtain. Fewer than 1,000 of these coins still exist today from an unknown original mintage, and most of those that do exist are in extremely low grade, or damaged in some way. The present piece is an incredible exception to that rule.
Smooth olive and chocolate-brown surfaces are free of all but a few insignificant handling marks. A tiny circular mark joins the tops of E and N in CENT, and a minor lamination mark is evident from the wreath to the F in OF. The date is bold and complete, and LIBERTY, while weak, is also fully visible. The lower reverse is somewhat weak in correspondence with the upper obverse.
This example is a late die state with narrow rim breaks visible in the dentils left and right of the first A in AMERICA. The obverse has a short crack that joins the rim to the top of the drapery at 4:30. The die chip between the E in ONE and T in CENT, seen to some degree on all genuine 1799 Normal Date cents, is boldly visible on this pleasing piece.
We are unable to determine the past provenance of this piece. A review of all the coins listed in the Bland Census and the 2005 Noyes Census, those that have plated auction appearances, finds no matches. Only a single catalog has yet to be examined, and that is the French's (3/1967) catalog of the Dr. Jasper Robertson Collection. MRB VF25.(Registry values: N7079)

113

1800 1C VF35 PCGS. CAC. S-197, B-12, R.1. The distinctive and well known "Q" variety, named for the die breaks near the 00 in the date. Another dramatic die break bonds the IB in LIBERTY. A dark brown Choice VF example. A few minor marks near the profile, but luster shimmers within the hair. MRB VF25.(Registry values: N991)

114

1800 1C 80 Over 79, Style Two Hair VF25 PCGS. CAC. S-194, B-8, R.3. A minimally abraded deep brown medium grade representative of this prominent overdate. Liberty's hair displays a wealth of detail. Inconspicuous verdigris is noted near the hair ribbon. MRB Fine 15. Population: 9 in 25, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

115

1801 1C 100/000 Genuine PCGS. S-221, B-5, R.2. PCGS incorrectly identifies this as a "1/000" reverse, when it is actually a "100/000" reverse. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has been burnished and now displays pleasing brown surfaces. MRB VF20.(Registry values: P1, N1)

116

1802 1C XF40 ANACS. S-232, B-12, R.1. Both sides are bathed in medium brown patina. Nicely centered, and well detailed. A few minute marks are noted on Liberty's neck and in the right (facing) obverse field. MRB VF25.(Registry values: N991)

117

1802 1C AU58 PCGS. S-242, B-19, R.2. Breen Die State III. A late die state with blurred clash marks on the obverse. Although S-242 is quite common, there are no Mint State pieces listed in Del Bland's Census. A more recent Bill Noyes Census lists a single Mint State example, with only nine coins that grade XF or better. Del Bland lists this piece as tied for sixth finest known, and Bill Noyes similarly places it in a sixth-place tie in his listing.
This boldly defined piece, housed in an old green label PCGS holder, has dark chocolate surfaces with some lighter tan on the reverse. Only a few trivial surface marks and minor verdigris detract from its overall appeal. Bland XF45. Noyes XF40. MRB XF40.
Ex: Robert J. Kissner (Stack's, 6/1975), lot 361; C. Douglas Smith; later, Bowers and Merena (11/1992), lot 1176.(Registry values: N1793)

118

1803 1C Small Date, Small Fraction MS62 Brown NGC. S-254, B-13, R.1. An unworn and pleasing example of this popular and available variety, well struck with chocolate-brown surfaces that show small spots of deeper color. The crack across the tip of the bust is visible but not as thick or prominent as is often seen. A handful of light digs appear in the fields, but serious abrasions are virtually nonexistent. MRB AU55.(Registry values: N2998)

119

1804 1C --Scratches--NGC. VF Details. S-266, B-1, R.2. Labeled as S-266a, but this is an early die state with no rim breaks on either side. The 1804 large cent is the second rarest date of all large cents, behind the 1799. Only the 1793 Liberty Cap cent is rarer, although other 1793 large cent designs were also minted. The central reverse of this piece has a number of scratches, including some at the E of CENT. Both sides also have myriad small to medium handling marks. The surfaces have a blend of deep olive and steel. MRB VG10.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

120

1804 1C Restrike MS66 Brown PCGS. CAC. This privately produced piece combines two original U.S. Mint large cent dies that were never used together inside the Mint. The obverse was originally used for 1803 S-261 and the reverse was originally used for 1820 N-12. This gorgeous Premium Gem has fully lustrous light brown surfaces with traces of pale blue toning. MRB MS60+. Population: 7 in 66 Brown, 0 finer (2/10).

121

1806 1C VF30 NGC. S-270, B-1, R.1. Deep steel surfaces display some gloss, with typical handling marks consistent with the grade. The 1806 is a single variety year, placing additional demand on the variety. For that reason, some have described this plentiful die combination as a scarcer issue. MRB Fine 15.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

122

1812 1C Small Date Genuine PCGS. S-290, B-2, R.1. The PCGS number ending in .97 suggests Environmental Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of a Mint State specimen that has been corroded with additional verdigris. Deep brown surfaces also show a number of rose tints. MRB VF20.

123

1812 1C Large Date XF45 PCGS. S-288, B-3, R.2. A pleasing deep brown representative of the conditionally challenging Classic design. Essentially unabraded aside from a couple of subtle marks near the T in CENT. MRB VF30. Population: 3 in 45, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

124

1812 1C Large Date MS63 Brown PCGS. S-289, B-4, R.1. This variety is most easily identified by the reverse, which has a leaf pair protruding well into the space between the words STATES and OF. Deep brown surfaces show violet and blue overtones. Struck softly and with worn dies, as nearly always seen, yet attractively lustrous. MRB AU55.(Registry values: P1)

125

1814 1C Crosslet 4 XF45 PCGS. S-294, B-1, R.1. An attractive ebony-brown representative of the final year Classic cent. No marks are consequential. A subtle spot is near the 18 in the date. Struck slightly off center toward 4:30, affecting only the width of the dentils. MRB VF35.(Registry values: N1793)

126

1817 1C 13 Stars AU55 PCGS. N-15, Low R.4. Golden-brown and medium brown alternate across this briefly circulated and nicely struck Choice AU Matron Head cent. A solitary hair-thin mark runs through the bust tip, but the surfaces are otherwise unmarked. MRB XF45.(Registry values: N491)

127

1817 1C 13 Stars AU55 PCGS. N-2, R.3. Grellman Die State c, with bisecting crack across the reverse, making this a highly desirable Choice AU example. Olive-brown and blue-brown surfaces are glossy with only minor wear concentrated on the high points. MRB AU50.(Registry values: N491)

128

1817 1C 13 Stars MS63 Red and Brown PCGS. N-14, R.1. Die state indeterminate due to strike, but the "drawn" stars suggest that the late state B is possible. Dusky reddish-orange hues mingle with violet and olive-brown colors. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N991)

129

1822 1C MS62 Brown NGC. N-4, R.2. A plentiful variety, the 1822 N-4 can be found in or near Mint State with relative ease. The Noyes Census lists two dozen pieces that grade AU55 or finer. Mahogany-brown surfaces host lighter olive-tan at the lower left reverse. MRB AU55.(Registry values: N1793)

130

1824 1C MS62 Brown PCGS. N-2, R.1. This is the most plentiful of all 1824 cents, but none of this date are routinely available in Mint State. The obverse of this sharply defined piece has blue-green toning over dark brown patina, with lighter tan on the reverse. MRB MS60. Population: 3 in 62 Brown, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

131

1824 1C MS64 Brown PCGS. N-4, R.1. The die crack from the 4 to the last three stars on the right provides confirmation of this variety. 1824 large cents are rare in Mint State, and rarer still with traces of original mint red. This piece has considerable faded red on the obverse, and is a highly desirable example. The surfaces are glossy and the strike is bold. The balance of the obverse and the reverse have dark brown toning. In his Census, Bill Noyes lists ten Mint State examples of the N-4 die combination, with only three grading better than MS60. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N1793)

132

1824/2 1C VF35 PCGS. N-5, R.5. The rarer of the two 1824/2 variants, with the upper left corner of the N in CENT dipping below the near edge of the E. Glossy violet-brown surfaces show golden highlights. MRB VF20.(Registry values: P2)

133

1824/2 1C XF45 PCGS. N-1, High R.1. The later die state with die cracks encircling the reverse. A deep brown Choice XF overdated Matron cent with attractive, unblemished surfaces. The design highpoints display only moderate wear. Accompanied by an old collector's envelope that records the price as $10. MRB VF30. Population: 3 in 45, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

134

1826 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-5, R.1. This sharply detailed cent has full cartwheel luster with a dark chocolate obverse and lighter tan reverse. It is an attractive representative that ranks among the top two dozen known for the die combination. MRB AU55.(Registry values: N1793)

135

1829 1C Large Letters AU55 PCGS. CAC. N-1, High R.3. Noyes Die State B with a light crack reverse die crack near 3 o'clock. Golden-brown and olive-green with substantial luster and no distracting marks. MRB AU50. Population: 6 in 55, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

136

1831 1C Large Letters MS62 Brown PCGS. N-6, R.1. Aside from some minor marks on the cheek, the surfaces on both sides are pleasing with a combination of olive, mahogany, and turquoise patina on both sides. MRB AU50.(Registry values: N991)

137

1832 1C Medium Letters MS65 Brown NGC. N-1, R.2. This plentiful 1832 cent variety is frequently seen in Mint State grades, but usually just MS60 to MS63. The surfaces of this piece are frosty with full cartwheel luster and attractive medium to dark brown color. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

138

1833 1C AU55 PCGS. N-4, Low R.4. A pleasing example of the rarest 1833 large cent variety, sometimes called an 1833/2 overdate, as a trace of a previous digit (a 2 or a 3) is visible below the upper knob of the final 3. This light olive-brown example has a few surface marks that are consistent with the grade. MRB XF45.(Registry values: N491)

139

1833 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-3, R.1. An attractive and highly lustrous certified Gem, this cent has gorgeous golden-brown surfaces with full cartwheels. Only about a dozen finer pieces are known. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

140

1835 1C Head of 1836 MS66 Brown NGC. N-15, R.2. This later die state piece has heavy flowlines extending radially toward the obverse and reverse borders, although the die crack through the tops of UNITED is still strong. The surfaces are highly attractive with intermingled lime-green and steel-brown toning that hosts splashes of original mint red. This piece is listed as seventh finest in Bill Noyes' Census. In an older generation holder. MRB MS60.
Ex: Bowers and Merena (11/1994), lot 2087.(Registry values: N1793)

141

1837 1C Head of 1838 MS65 Brown NGC. N-10, R.1. The so-called "Accessory N" variety, with remnants of a misplaced N in the wreath below NI of UNITED. This lovely Gem has highly lustrous surfaces with rich medium to dark brown toning. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

142

1837 1C Plain Cords, Medium Letters MS65 Brown NGC. N-4, R.2. The obverse has a heavy crack joining stars 3 to 7, and just missing star 8. The Medium Letters reverse is the other half of the attribution. This lovely Mint State piece has golden-brown surfaces with faint traces of original mint red. MRB AU55.(Registry values: P1)

143

1837 1C Plain Cords, Medium Letters MS65 Brown NGC. N-7, R.1. A bold reverse die crack through TATES OF identifies this variety, which has never been seen without it. The present Gem has pleasing medium brown surfaces with hints of turquoise toning. MRB MS60.(Registry values: P1)

144

1837 1C Plain Cords, Medium Letters MS66 Brown NGC. N-16, R.4 This incredible piece may be the finest known 1837 N-16 cent. It is fully lustrous with pale lime, sea-green, and iridescent toning on each side. Only about a dozen Mint State examples are known, mostly in lower grades than this piece. MRB MS63.(Registry values: P1)

145

1838 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-11, R.2. The same dies were used to strike N-11 and N-13, as described in Newcomb's work. Today it is known that both are die states of a single variety. This lovely Premium Gem has chestnut and steel-brown surfaces with full luster and excellent eye appeal. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

146

1838 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-6, R.1. Both sides of this satiny and highly lustrous piece have dark steel patina with considerable original orange luster, especially for a coin that is certified Brown. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

147

1839 1C Booby Head MS64 Brown PCGS. CAC. N-11, R.1. This chocolate-brown and steel-gray Booby Head cent has satin luster and a good strike. Faint thin marks are noted at the top of the neck and on the lower right reverse quadrant. MRB AU55. Population: 15 in 64 Brown, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

148

1841 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-7, R.2. Grellman Die State b with a faint crack just beginning at star 8. A fully lustrous Gem, this pleasing and scarce cent has satiny medium to dark brown surfaces with splashes of original mint red on the reverse. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

149

1842 1C Large Date MS66 Brown NGC. N-6, R.1. Grellman Die State d. A beautiful, sharply defined medium brown cent, this piece has frosty cartwheel luster with considerable faded mint red still visible on both sides. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

150

1843 1C Petite Head, Small Letters MS65 Brown NGC. N-9, R.2. Grellman Die State c. This is the latest die state, with all obverse and reverse rim breaks visible. Lustrous medium brown surfaces host considerable original mint red on both sides. This is an important piece for the advanced specialist. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N991)

151

1846 1C Small Date MS65 Brown NGC. N-9, R.2. Grellman Die State b. The arc line through ICA is extremely weak. This Gem has smooth medium brown surfaces with faded mint red and traces of blue or lilac toning. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

152

1846 1C Small Date MS66 Brown NGC. N-6, R.1 Grellman Die State b, early enough that the repunched 46 is still clearly visible. This Premium Gem has dark chocolate surfaces with considerable mint red, mostly on the reverse. It is a highly attractive and desirable example. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N1793)

153

1849 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-22, R.1. Grellman Die State c, equivalent to N-6. Sharply defined with pleasing tan surfaces and faded red on the reverse. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

154

1849 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-20, R.1. Grellman Die State a with heavy lines across portions of the reverse. This lovely Gem has a medium brown obverse and steel-brown reverse with faint traces of faded mint red. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

155

1849 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-22, R.1 Grellman Die State c, equivalent to N-6. A sharply defined piece with microscopic obverse scratches and faint reverse verdigris. MRB AU55.(Registry values: N1793)

156

1849 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-11, R.1. Grellman Die State a with all points clear, and no evidence of reverse rim breaks. Pleasing tan surfaces exhibit pale green toning around the devices. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

157

1850 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-15, R.2. Grellman Die State a. A sharp impression from the early die state with all attribution markers clearly visible. Both sides have satiny luster with pristine surfaces and lovely iridescent toning. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N1793)

158

1850 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-5, High R.4. Grellman Die State b, the usual state for this elusive variety. This Premium Gem is boldly defined with wonderful surfaces that exhibit frosty luster. Both sides are olive-brown with steel-blue. Easily a Condition Census candidate. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

159

1850 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-19, R.2. Grellman Die State b, equivalent to N-16. A splendid Premium Gem with satiny surfaces, bold design elements, and deep orange mint luster on both sides. An important opportunity to acquire a near Census level 1850 N-19 cent. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

160

1850 1C MS66 Red and Brown NGC. N-7, R.2. Mostly red surfaces have some bluish-brown patina with matte-like surfaces. The central details are sharp with weak peripheral details including flat stars. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

161

1851 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-26, Low R.5. Grellman Die State c, the latest die state. This lovely Gem has rich orange luster on both sides, accompanying frosty turquoise-brown surfaces. Easily in the Condition Census of this scarce variety. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N991)

162

1851 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-41, R.4. Grellman Die State c with a small reverse rim break over ME. Lustrous surfaces exhibit chestnut-brown toning with splashes of mint red on the reverse. A Condition Census example. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N1793)

163

1851 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-14, R.2. Grellman Die State c. The usual late die state, and a lovely representative with bold design features. Both sides have splashes of orange mint luster on blue-brown and violet surfaces. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N1793)

164

1851 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-39, R.3. Grellman Die State b. A lovely Premium Gem example of a variety that was unknown to Newcomb when he did his study in the 1940s. This piece has considerable orange mint luster with violet and turquoise-brown toning. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

165

1851 1C MS66 Red and Brown NGC. N-15, R.4. Grellman Die State b, and a hoard coin in the late state with many Mint State pieces known. This example, a delightful Premium Gem, has mostly bright orange mint luster on the obverse, with deeply faded mint color on the reverse. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

166

1853 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-3, R.1. Grellman Die State a with clash marks and attribution characteristics clearly visible. Pleasing medium brown surfaces retain considerable original mint red on the reverse. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N1793)

167

1853 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-25, R.1. Grellman Die State b, and a hoard coin in this die state. The present Premium Gem has frosty steel and iridescent patina on the obverse, with nearly full mint red on the reverse. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N1793)

168

1853 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-19, R.1. Grellman Die State c. The obverse is slightly misaligned at 9 o'clock as frequently seen on the latest die state. This Premium Gem deep brown toning with pale orange luster. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

169

1853 1C MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. N-13, R.1. This fiery Gem has fully brilliant orange luster with only a trace of olive patina on each side. This is extremely close to a full Red cent, although at a much lower market value. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

170

1853 1C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. N-19, R.1. The 3 in the date is clearly repunched. Brick-red is extensive, although dusky lilac toning is present throughout the portrait and also visits the fields. Encapsulated in an early generation pre-hologram holder. MRB MS62.(Registry values: N1793)

171

1853 1C MS66 Red and Brown NGC. N-13, R.1. Grellman Die State b, and a hoard variety in this die state. Considerable original mint red is evident on both sides of this Premium Gem, blended with pale brown and light blue toning. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

172

1854 1C MS65 Brown NGC. N-22, R.4. Grellman Die State a, late. The die line right of the 4 is dull, and nearly gone. Frosty cartwheel luster and bold design elements are evident on each side of this scarce piece. MRB MS60.(Registry values: N991)

173

1854 1C MS66 Brown NGC. N-21, R.2. Grellman Die State b. The 185 are clearly repunched below. This Premium Gem is sharply defined with satiny luster and splashes of orange mint color mixed with dark blue-brown toning. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

174

1854 1C MS67 Brown NGC. N-23, R.2. Grellman Die State b. A lovely Superb Gem with full cartwheel luster, medium brown color, hints of blue patina, and considerable original mint red in the protected areas. This Census-level piece is probably one of the three or four finest known. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N2998)

175

1854 1C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. N-20, R.3. Grellman Die State a. The top of a misplaced 1 extends up from the border below the right side of the 8. This delightful Gem has considerable original orange mint color with medium brown toning. A solid Condition Census piece. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

176

1854 1C MS66 Red and Brown NGC. N-11, R.2. Grellman Die State b. This lustrous Premium Gem is about evenly divided into orange-red and gray-brown. Devoid of spots or abrasions, and the strike is bold aside from the right-side dentils. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N1793)

177

1855 1C Upright 5s MS65 Red NGC. N-4, R.1. Grellman Die State a. The strike is exacting on the portrait, although selected stars have central softness. Generally orange-gold, with slight mellowing on the neck, the jaw, and the reverse margin at 7 o'clock. Nearly unabraded, and carbon is relegated to the left obverse field. Certified in a former generation holder. MRB MS63.(Registry values: N2998)

178

1856 1C Slanted 5 MS65 Red PCGS. N-2, R.1. Grellman Die State d, or perhaps later. This lovely Gem is fully brilliant with only a few traces of mellow brown and pale blue toning. The remaining orange luster, nearly 100%, is easily sufficient to carry the full Red designation assigned to this piece. A few minuscule abrasions and tiny toning flecks are evident only with a glass. Here is a remarkable opportunity for the date or variety collector to obtain the finest PCGS certified 1856 Slanted 5 cent with full color. MRB MS64. Population: 1 in 65 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

179

1857 1C Small Date MS64 Red PCGS. N-2, High R.1. A small lump under the earlobe, a short line curving up from right top of T in LIBERTY to close over left of Y, and a small lump on top of right foot of CENT attribute the variety. Orange luster adorns this well struck, attractive near-Gem. A few minute marks deny Gem status. MRB MS63. Population for issue: 2 in 64 Red, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2)

Proof Large Cents

180

1831 1C PR63 Brown NGC. N-3, R.6 as a proof. Large cent aficionado Denis Loring grades this coin PR64 and lists it at the top of his roster of 1831 N-3 cents, while our own grade is slightly more conservative. The existing population of 1831 proof large cents includes 30 to 35 coins, and about half of those are the N-3 die combination. This piece carries a reported census back to Homer Downing and before, although it was unplated in the 1952 ANA catalog of Dowining's cents. It may have earlier been in the Dr. French Collection, according to the New Netherlands 1952 catalog, where the cataloger wrote: "Glittering light red Proof. Perfectly centered and well struck, with a gorgeous iridescent surface."
Both sides have mostly greenish-gold toning with considerable iridescence. A few tiny marks are present on each side, but they are entirely inconsequential. Here is an attractive 1831 proof large cent, perhaps the finest that survives. Our provenance is from Loring's notes. MRB PR63.
Ex: Henry C. Hines; Homer K. Downing (New Netherlands, 1952 ANA, 8/1952), lot 2176; Willard C. Blaisdell; R.E. "Ted" Naftzger; Eric J. Streiner; Legend Collection of Proof large cents; American Numismatic Rarities (3/2004), lot 323.(Registry values: P3)

Flying Eagle Cents

181

1857 1C MS64 PCGS. Olive and peach-orange hues prevail on this Choice coin, though a streak of deeper color crosses the tops of the eagle's wings. Weakness is noted through the middle letters of UNITED STATES on the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

182

1857 1C MS64 PCGS. A near-Gem from the first year of regular-issue Flying Eagle cents. The obverse is generally deep peach, while the lighter color close to the rims on that side dominates the reverse. Strong visual appeal overall.(Registry values: N1793)

183

1857 1C MS65 PCGS. This popular issue was initially heavily saved because of its novelty. The Gem presented in this sale is exceptionally well struck for the type. The eagle's plumage is crisp, save for minor softness on the end of the tail feathers. The entire reverse wreath is also sharp. Lustrous surfaces exhibit pretty golden-tan color, and are free of mentionable marks. A wonderful type coin!
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

184

1857 1C MS65 NGC. This attractive Gem displays intense fire-red and red-gold color on the obverse, with more muted mauve and brick-red toning across the reverse. Well struck with lustrous, distraction-free surfaces. The front wing has an interesting die scratch, as made. Seldom seen any finer. NGC has only certified 14 finer examples (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

185

1858 1C Large Letters MS63 NGC. High Leaves Reverse, Closed E in ONE. The obverse doubling on this piece is strike or shelf doubling, as opposed to hub doubling. This pleasing, sharply struck example has lustrous light tan surfaces with hints of iridescent toning.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

186

1858 1C Large Letters MS64 PCGS. High Leaves Reverse, Closed E in ONE. Light golden surfaces exhibit full luster on this sharply defined piece. Housed in a first generation PCGS holder, this cent is an attractive example for a type set or specialized collection.(Registry values: N1793)

187

1858 1C Small Letters MS64 NGC. Low Leaves Reverse. Open E in ONE. An incredible piece for the grade, with highly lustrous golden-tan surfaces and bold design definitions. Both sides have a hint of iridescent toning. Only the presence of a couple tiny spots of carbon prevent a higher grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Flying Eagle Cents

188

1856 1C PR10 PCGS. CAC. Snow-3. Although designated as a proof by PCGS, this is the business strike variety coined in 1856 for distribution to Washington officials. This tan-brown representative is evenly circulated and minutely granular. No marks are remotely consequential save for tiny rim ticks at 4 o'clock on the obverse and 1:30 on the reverse.(Registry values: N1)

189

1856 1C PR58 PCGS. Snow-1, Low R.7. When Rick Snow did his early research, the Snow-1 in copper-nickel was considered extremely rare, with only two known. Others have been found since that time, and today about a dozen examples are believed to exist. The most important aspect of this variety is Snow's belief that they were the first 1856 Flying Eagle cents struck at the Mint that year. In addition to the dozen or so copper-nickel pieces, a small number of others are known in copper or bronze.
At www.indiancent.com, Snow provides a roster of the 12 known pieces including the following grades: PR64 (3); PR63; PR62; AU58 (2); AU55; XF45, and XF40. This piece appears to be a 13th example, as it is different from those in Snow's roster. It has light tan surfaces that are slightly deeper in the fields. A short line of ebony toning from the eagle's neck into the field will provide identification of this piece in past or future auction catalogs.(Registry values: N4719)

190

1856 1C PR63 PCGS. Snow-9. Attractively toned with lemon-tinged centers and rich rose-red toning throughout the peripheries. As is expected of the Snow-9 die pair, the strike is needle-sharp. Outstanding for the grade aside from a single spot beneath the upper crossbar of the E in CENT. Encased in a first generation holder.
The 1856 Flying Eagle Cent is one of the most important issues in the history of numismatics. Not only is it the first small cent date listed in the Guide Book, it was the cause for a major expansion in American numismatics prior to the Civil War. Many folks who had no prior interest in coins took up the hobby when they learned that Flying Eagle cents had been issued that were worth a dollar,100 times their face value.(Registry values: N4719)

191

1856 1C PR63 NGC. Snow-4, R.7. Surprisingly, this glittering proof is not the Snow-9 variety as expected. This piece has the Pointed U obverse of Snow-2, 4, and 5; with the Low Leaves reverse found only on Snow-4. In his reference, Rick Snow records five different compositions that were struck from these dies, including copper-nickel, copper, bronze, nickel alloy, and white metal, the latter unverified. This piece has every outward appearance of the copper-nickel composition, with its light tan color. Snow believes that about 25 of these were struck, all in 1858, and estimates that about a dozen survive today.
Both sides are fully reflective with mirrored fields on tan surfaces that host splashes of gold toning. The design features are boldly struck up. This Select proof has a light cameo contrast between the mirrored fields and lustrous devices.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

192

1858 1C Large Letters PR65 PCGS. Snow-PR1. High Leaves Reverse. Closed E in ONE. Probably only about 50 to 100 proofs of this issue were distributed, giving it equal status with the proof 1857 Flying Eagle cents. These are very rare in proof format. Prior to 1992, PCGS certified all proof 1858 Flyers under a single coin identification number. Once they separated these listings and began recognizing the Small and Large Letters varieties, they began keeping track with Small Letters coins listed under the new number. All previous certified coins were accounted by the Large Letters number, giving this variety the appearance that it is more common. It is likely that the Large Letters proofs were distributed by the Mint in 1858, with the Small Letters coins being restrikes produced and sold at a later date. This Gem is very sharply struck with deep golden-brown color, accented by iridescent toning. Certified in an old green label holder.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2004), lot 5134.(Registry values: N7079)

193

1858 1C Small Letters PR66 NGC. Snow-PR4. The 1858 Small Letters Flying Eagle cents are a one-year subtype, featuring an obverse style that was first used extensively on the pattern small cent coinage of 1858 that preceded the regular issues. Although the Small Letters style with AM in AMERICA separated is the most obvious difference, there are others as well. Snow suggests in his series Guide Book that the Small Letters was initially a pattern design that was found acceptable, and accordingly used alongside the Large Letters-style dies at the beginning of the year.
While the Small Letters business strikes are prized, the Small Letters proofs are vastly rarer, with an estimated mintage currently given at 200 coins. Precious few of those coins survive today in the state of preservation of the current Premium Gem proof. The dies are characterized by the Type Three reverse (Low Leaves, Open E in ONE) that has the denomination strengthened using a Type One denomination punch (E nearly closed), making this a Closed E/Open E reverse type that appears as minor doubling. The Small Letters obverse die (the Large Letters proofs are paired only with the High Leaves reverse) shows numerous parallel apparent die polishing marks through the date area. (Rick Snow's Flying Eagle and Indian Cent Attribution Guide, second edition, volume I has excellent photos of these effects on page 80.)
This extremely rare proof striking is almost never seen in such a superior state of preservation. In fact, NGC has certified only three other coins in PR66, with none finer, while the finest at PCGS are a handful of PR65 pieces (2/10). The fields are deeply mirrored, and the reverse shows evidence of heavy die polishing with slightly attenuated letters in the center. The bright golden-honey surfaces show occasional specks of deep rose patina, all of which add considerable eye appeal to this rare proof issue.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (6/2002), lot 5128, which realized $24,150. (Registry values: N10218)

Indian Cents

194

1859 1C MS65 PCGS. Always in demand as the first year of issue and a one-year type coin. The obverse is sharply struck, with fine detail on the hair strands. The reverse shows only a little softness on the bow. Both sides display lovely honey-tan color, with sea-green toning in the center of the reverse. Virtually blemish-free.(Registry values: N2998)

195

1860 1C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Rounded Bust variety. Lustrous with copper-gold color that is accented with pastel-rose. Both sides are gloriously preserved, with outstanding eye appeal. The striking details are remarkably strong, with the only weakness seen on one of the middle shield stripes. First year of the With Shield subtype. Population: 33 in 66, 8 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

196

1864 1C Copper-Nickel MS65 NGC. A strongly defined Gem example of this final copper-nickel cent issue with lovely light orange luster. A small spot is noted at Liberty's forehead.(Registry values: N1793)

197

1865 1C Fancy 5 MS66 Red and Brown PCGS. A charming Premium Gem with "fancy" or curving flag on the 5 in the date. Sharply struck and impressively lustrous, decidedly more Red than Brown on the obverse, though the mellowing to peach and umber through the central reverse leaves no doubt as to the coin's Red and Brown status. Population: 4 in 66 Red and Brown, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

198

1867 1C MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. Considerable orange mint luster remains on both sides, intermingled with medium brown toning. A pleasing, sharply struck Gem. Population: 48 in 65 Red and Brown, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

199

1869/9 1C MS63 Brown NGC. VP-001, FS-301, Snow-3. This is the variety that was once called an 1869/8 overdate. Additional study has shown that it is a repunched date, rather than an overdate. Regardless of nomenclature, it is a popular and highly desirable variety. This example has deep reddish-brown surfaces with sharp design elements and satiny luster.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

200

1869/9 1C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. FS-301, formerly FS-008.3. Snow-3. The repunched date feature is clearly visible, although NGC makes no mention of the variety on the holder. This remarkable Gem is boldly detailed with substantial deep orange luster and pale blue toning.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

201

1870 1C MS64 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. Bold N. This better date near-Gem is approximately 50% Red, although the devices and open fields are brown. Marks are essentially absent, and carbon is difficult to locate. A good strike, although portions of the reverse periphery are incompletely brought up.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

202

1872 1C MS64 Red and Brown NGC. Broken D hub. Almond and caramel accents around the peripheries cede to magenta and mahogany in the centers of this near-Gem coin, the most elusive issue in the Indian cent series aside from the 1877. The strike is far superior to most examples seen of this date, making this piece a superior potential acquisition. Struck from the Bold N reverse die, as was the majority of the issue(Registry values: N1793)

203

1872 1C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. Bold N. The 1872 is one of the more difficult dates of the Indian Head series to locate. Moreover, most are poorly struck, or are struck through machine oil, resulting in missing details (Richard Snow, 2009). The present Gem exhibits strong detail except for softness in one feather tip and on the second diamond from the bottom, and copper-gold luster peeks through the veil of light tan patina. A few small flecks are noted. Census: 75 in 65 Red and Brown, 8 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

204

1873 1C Open 3 MS65 Red and Brown NGC. This better date Gem is sharply struck, even the feathertips of the headdress. The borders are primarily orange-red, while the portrait and open fields are lilac.(Registry values: P5)

205

1873 1C FS-009.1, Closed 3, MS64 Red and Brown PCGS. Eagle Eye Photo Seal, Card Included. Snow-2. LIBERTY is die doubled, although not as spectacularly as on the famous FS-009 variety listed in the Guide Book. This beautiful near-Gem displays autumn-gold and olive iridescence. Nicely struck save for some softness on the top of the shield.
Ex: Palm Beach Signature (Heritage, 3/2006), lot 126.(Registry values: N1793)

206

1873 1C Doubled LIBERTY, Closed 3 AU50 PCGS. Snow-1. FS-101, formerly FS-009. This dramatic example of hub doubling is rarely found in any grade and an AU, such as this coin, is considered a high grade find. All the letters of LIBERTY are boldly doubled. The surfaces are two-toned with deeper chocolate colored fields and brighter reddish accents over the high points. A number of small to medium-sized abrasions are scattered over each side, as one would expect from 10 points of circulation, and there is a shallow, diagonal planchet lamination at the top left of the E in ONE.(Registry values: P10)

207

1873 1C Doubled LIBERTY, Closed 3 MS63 Brown PCGS. Snow-1. FS-101, formerly FS-009. This popular Cherrypickers' and Guide Book variety is hotly contested whenever a nice specimen appears at auction. Cherrypickers' describes it this way: "This strong doubled die is evident by the doubling on LIBERTY, the entire headdress, the feather spines, and even the eye. This is a Close 3 variety." The reference rates it at 5 for both interest and liquidity, meaning the collector interest is very high and the variety will sell easily. This is unsurprising, considering that the PCGS Indian Cent With Major Varieties collection assigns the variety a whopping 10 points in its Set Composition--the same as for the 1877 cent and the 1888/7 overdate. The present example boasts lovely brown and blue color over each side, with a few faint specks of carbon, mostly on the obverse. The strike is sharp, and only a couple of faint marks appear on the obverse. Population: 4 in 63 Brown, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P10)

208

1874 1C MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. Mostly copper-orange on the obverse with additional gold on the reverse, though both sides also show mahogany, which adds the "and Brown" to the grade. Nonetheless, a highly attractive Gem. PCGS has graded only two finer Red and Brown representatives (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

209

1877 1C VG8 ANACS. A pleasing dark brown example of this ever popular key date Indian cent. The tops of most letters in LIBERTY are visible. The reverse has the weak Ns usually associated with business strikes.(Registry values: N991)

210

1877 1C Fine 15 PCGS. Light tan patination displays faint reddish undertones. All letters in LIBERTY show, LI RTY being the strongest. Devoid of significant marks or spots.(Registry values: N1793)

211

1877 1C --Scratched, Cleaned--ANACS. VF30 Details. A moderately worn example of the famous key Indian cent. Violet-brown surfaces show areas of pink-gold brightness from a past cleaning, and an old staple scratch crosses from the neck into the lower left obverse field.(Registry values: N1793)

212

1877 1C --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Shallow N. A briefly circulated example of the famous key date 1877 cent. Mark-free and partly lustrous. Recolored at one time to orange-gold, but now mostly retoned deep apple-green. Splendidly detailed, and certain to please many numismatists.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

213

1877 1C MS64 Red and Brown NGC. Shallow N. Die Pair 1, per Snow. The 18 in the date nearly touch, and the reverse shows the usual die clashing from the jaw-neck juncture above the O in ONE. Light tan patina is more extensive and deeper on the reverse of this near-Gem. The top diamond is sharp, and parts of the middle diamonds show. Light obverse marks limit the grade, but this is nevertheless a nice example of this key date.(Registry values: N4719)

214

1884 1C MS66 Red PCGS. The lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem display copper-gold color enhanced with splashes of light blue on the obverse. The design elements are sharply struck, except for minor weakness in the second diamond from the top. Minute flecks are visible over each side. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 13 in 66 Red, 3 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

215

1886 1C Type One MS66 Red and Brown NGC. Orange and lavender colors. Sharply struck on the devices, with minor softness of strike on OF AMERICA due to the die alignment. The surfaces are impressively preserved, and are also seemingly free from carbon. Struck from lightly clashed dies.(Registry values: N1793)

216

1897 1C MS65 Red PCGS. Pretty copper-gold color bathes well preserved surfaces that exhibit boldly impressed design features. A couple of light toning spots are located on each side. Truly an outstanding Red Gem Indian cent. Population: 54 in 65 Red, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

217

1898 1C MS66 Red PCGS. CAC. The obverse has bright copper-gold color, while the reverse is more honey-orange. Both sides are well-defined overall with only minor softness noted on the hair ribbon. With just seven finer Red representatives known to PCGS (2/10), a piece of considerable importance to Registry collectors.(Registry values: N1793)

218

1902 1C MS66 Red NGC. CAC. A gorgeous orange-red cent that benefits from a powerful strike and a virtual absence of carbon and contact. The 1902 is plentiful overall, but becomes rare in such exemplary condition. Housed in a prior generation holder.(Registry values: N1793)

219

1903 1C MS67 Red PCGS. The striking details are strong throughout, with nearly full definition on all of the design details. This Superb Gem has bright, unmellowed red mint luster and is essentially bereft of contact. Only a couple of pinpoint flecks and a minor lintmark near the ear deny technical perfection. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 5 in 67 Red, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

220

1909-S 1C MS63 Red and Brown NGC. CAC. Copper-gold luster is minimally impeded by traces of light green and tan. Well struck save for weakness in the feather tips; the diamonds are razor-sharp. Occasional minute marks and flecks do not significantly detract.(Registry values: N991)

221

1909-S 1C MS64 Red NGC. This Choice pumpkin-gold key date Indian cent features blazing luster and a good strike. Essentially void of contact, and scattered minute obverse carbon determines the grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Indian Cents

222

1860 1C PR65 NGC. Rounded Bust. When one thinks of a type date for the copper-nickel cent, the 1860 is not the issue that comes to mind. But this is a wonderful coin and could easily serve as a type piece. An estimated 542 proofs were struck from this hub type. The fields are deeply reflective on each side, and the devices have a light bit of frost (but not enough to qualify the coin as a Cameo). Much of the original whitish-tan color is evident on each side with just a hint of reddish patina. A shallow, barely discernable, straight, thread-like strike through is located in the left obverse field. Census: 16 in 65, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

223

1861 1C PR64 NGC. Even though the official mintage of proofs for this year is 1,000 pieces, probably no more than 400 pieces were actually sold to collectors. This piece has uncommonly deep mirrors in the fields, as many 1861 proofs are shallowly mirrored. A couple of small spots are seen on each side which limit the grade. Even light, reddish patina is seen over each side. Census: 33 in 64, 26 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

224

1862 1C PR64 PCGS. Housed in a green-label PCGS holder, this copper-nickel Indian is a splendid Choice proof with bold design features, light tan surfaces, and slight cameo contrast.(Registry values: N1793)

225

1862 1C PR66 Cameo NGC. The 1862 is the unquestioned date for type purposes in the copper-nickel series. While the mintage of 550 proofs is only marginally higher than other dates, the quality was extraordinarily high. There was also a hoard of 200 proofs that surfaced many years ago. This is an exceptional, deeply mirrored example with sharply contrasting mint frost over the devices. Much of the original "white" color remains, with just a hint of pale reddish patina on each side. An outstanding type coin. Census: 20 in 66 Cameo, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

226

1863 1C PR65 Cameo NGC. The 1863 is much significantly scarcer than the 1862, and it is seldom found with cameo contrast. This high-end example looks like the finest 1862. The fields are deeply reflective and establish a "black" background against the noticeably frosted devices on each side. Like the 1862 above, this piece also retains much of the original "whiteness" of the copper-nickel alloy, with just a bit of reddish patina also present. The only mentionable surface defects are a luster scrape on the neck and a curious hairline-thin crack in the planchet across the high point of the Indian's face--both of which require magnification to discern. Census: 9 in 65 Cameo, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

227

1864 1C Copper Nickel PR65 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Final year of production for copper-nickel Indian cents, which were soon replaced by a bronze composition. From a mintage of 370 pieces, lowest in the copper-nickel series, this Gem proof shows flashy, deep mirrors and razor-sharp striking definition. Quality is usually below-average when compared to the 1862, but not on this coin. Impressive cameo contrast is noticeable on both sides. Population: 22 in 65 Cameo, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

228

1870 1C PR65 Red and Brown PCGS. Shallow N. Copper-orange hues dominate this cent, though a distinct arc of violet along the wreath ensures Red and Brown status. Overall, an attractive Gem with a degree of watery reflectivity to the mirrors, unusual for the issue.(Registry values: N1793)

229

1877 1C --Altered Color--NGC. Proof. A sharply struck specimen of this popular proof Indian cent issue, feted for its association with the elusive business strikes of the same date. Sharply impressed with considerable luminous reflectivity, though the violet and orange toning over each side is not original. Each side shows a brown spot within the fields.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

230

1877 1C PR63 Red and Brown NGC. This reflective satin proof has considerable original orange mint color blended with gold, violet, and iridescent toning on both sides. The design definition is bold, and the eye appeal is excellent. The 1877 is noted as the key date in the Indian cent series, with examples in demand in all grades.(Registry values: N2998)

231

1877 1C PR64 Red and Brown PCGS. Date pressure accounts for the popularity of the proof 1877 Indian cent because of the rarity, especially in high grades, of the business strikes of this date. This attractive example has streaky brown patina over each side, with nicely reflective underlying mirrors. It is a mystery why this coin was graded PR64, since its only apparent surface defects are a couple of small carbon specks.(Registry values: N2998)

232

1877 1C PR64 Red and Brown PCGS. Only slight mellowing of the original orange luster on this glittering near-Gem proof has prevented a designation of Red. It is an attractive and desirable piece with light pink surfaces and a few scattered carbon specks that limit the numerical grade.(Registry values: N2998)

233

1879 1C PR66 Red NGC. Bold copper-gold luster overall with a blush of orange over Liberty's portrait. Crisply defined and beautifully preserved, an amazing Premium Gem proof. Census: 19 in 66 Red, 4 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

234

1880 1C PR65 Red PCGS. Here is a vibrant Gem proof with brilliant orange mint color on both sides. A few tiny flecks of carbon prevent a higher grade. The surfaces are nicely mirrored with noticeable contrast. Population: 62 in 65 Red, 23 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

235

1882 1C PR67 Red and Brown NGC. This is an absolutely outstanding proof Indian cent. The surfaces are essentially perfect and the fields deeply mirrored. While designated as a Red and Brown coin, there really is no brown present. A noticeable accent of pale olive intermixes with the bright orange-red luster. Census: 6 in 67 Red and Brown, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

236

1885 1C PR68 Brown NGC. This stunning "greenie" has amazing lime-green toning with blue accents and traces of original orange color along parts of the border on each side. Mirrored fields frame the lustrous devices. The design motifs are boldly detailed. Census: 2 in 68 Brown, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

237

1893 1C PR65 Red PCGS. A lovely Gem with fully brilliant orange luster and a hint of cameo contrast between the deeply mirrored fields and satiny devices. A splash of deeper orange toning is evident on the Indian's cheek, and a few carbon flecks are visible in the fields. Population: 26 in 65 Red, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

238

1894 1C PR65 Red Cameo PCGS. Light gold color dominates this meticulously struck and radiant Gem, although glimpses of peach or fire-red hue are noted along the right borders. The mildly frosted devices exhibit noticeable contrast with the prominently mirrored fields. Only a slender portion of the original proof production has retained its original Red color. Population: 2 in 65 Red Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

239

1895 1C PR66 Red PCGS. Snow-PR4. The 1 and 9 in the date are lightly repunched. A flashy yellow-gold specimen that has a dash of cherry-red on the base of Liberty's neck. Population: 14 in 66 Red, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

240

1901 1C PR67 Red NGC. An amazing Superb Gem with brilliant orange and and reddish-violet surfaces, the reverse lighter in overall color. This piece is boldly defined with excellent eye appeal. Few similar or finer pieces have been certified with a combined population of 11 and just two finer. Census: 4 in 67 Red, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

241

1909 1C PR67 Red and Brown Cameo NGC. This needle-sharp final year Indian cent proof is much closer to Red than Brown. Light olive-green overall with blushes of orange and ruby-red near the rims. Unabraded, and carbon-free aside from a couple of pinpoint flecks on the lower obverse.(Registry values: N2998)

Lincoln Cents

242

1909 VDB 1C Doubled Die Obverse MS65 Red PCGS. FS-1102, formerly FS-012.1. Doubling is visible as extra thickness on selected obverse lettering. Considerable violet and deep amber elements appear on otherwise copper-gold surfaces.

243

1909-S VDB 1C VF20 NGC. Tan and cinnamon elements add life to the luminous, moderately worn medium-brown surfaces of this 1909-S VDB cent. Considerable detail remains in the protected areas.(Registry values: N1)

244

1909-S VDB 1C VF25 PCGS. Mahogany and olive surfaces have a few splashes of faint, dark corrosion, mainly on the obverse. Otherwise, this is a lovely and highly desirable example.(Registry values: N1)

245

1909-S VDB 1C XF45 ANACS. The high points of the portrait show slight wear, but this chocolate-brown key-date cent displays ample remaining luster. A minor diagonal mark appears on the face, but the surfaces are otherwise impressively unabraded. Housed in a small-format ANACS holder.(Registry values: N991)

246

1909-S VDB 1C --Environmental Damage--NGC. AU Details. Medium yellow-brown surfaces display whispers of bluish-purple, more so on the reverse. Sharply defined, including the date, mintmark, and VDB initials. A few light corrosion patches are not all that bad.(Registry values: N991)

247

1909-S VDB 1C --Recolored--ANACS. MS60 Details. A well-defined example of this Lincoln cent key issue with no trace of wear. The pattern of yellow-orange and green-gold color on each side suggests an artificial process.(Registry values: N991)

248

1909-S VDB 1C MS63 Brown PCGS. Here is a lustrous olive-brown example of the always popular and desirable 1909-S VDB cent. This piece has satiny surfaces and bold design motifs.(Registry values: N991)

249

1909-S VDB 1C MS63 Brown NGC. Both sides of this Mint State piece have satin luster with iridescent toning. A distinctive piece.(Registry values: N991)

250

1909-S VDB 1C MS62 Red and Brown ANACS. A few tiny spots limit the grade of this pleasing S-VDB cent. Both sides have considerable golden-orange luster with olive toning.(Registry values: N991)

251

1909-S VDB 1C MS63 Red and Brown PCGS. Muted copper-gold surfaces show minor carbon and more extensive violet on both sides, particularly the reverse. A well struck Select example of this ever-popular key.(Registry values: N1793)

252

1909-S VDB 1C MS63 Red and Brown NGC. Mellow orange luster with light brown toning are blended together on this Select Mint State piece. It is an attractive example of the ever-popular low-mintage Lincoln cent.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

253

1909-S VDB 1C MS63 Red and Brown PCGS. Substantial light orange mint luster is evident on each side of this pleasing example. Housed in an older green-label PCGS holder. The brown color is scattered across both sides with a few small carbon flecks. The reverse has a couple short scratches at the border about 7 o'clock.(Registry values: N1793)

254

1909-S VDB 1C MS64 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. This is a well-struck example like most of the issue, which shows considerable red remaining around the peripheries, complementing caramel and medium brown shades. A few flecks are undistracting. A nice example for the collector who wants to stay away from the certified Gem and Red categories. The mintmark is in position 3, with the top of the S mintmark about flush with the bottom of the 9s and its left side vertically aligned between the first 9 and the 0.(Registry values: N1793)

255

1909-S VDB 1C MS64 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. The combination of brilliant orange luster and olive-brown toning creates exceptional eye appeal. Both sides have frosty luster and are free of distracting spots or marks. Here is a great opportunity to acquire the famous key date Lincoln cent.(Registry values: N1793)

256

1909-S VDB 1C MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. This boldly struck specimen has satiny luster with considerable mint red and traces of brown toning in a grained pattern, as often seen on this issue. Although shy of full red, this Gem will fit nicely in a high-grade set of Lincoln cents.(Registry values: N1793)

257

1909-S VDB 1C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. The newness of Brenner's design caused many to set aside examples of this first year of issue. The Philadelphia VDB cents are relatively common, but the mintage is very high. The S-mint VDB cents were limited to only 484,000 pieces, thus restricting the number available to collectors. This is a lovely example with the usual bright mint luster. There is little brown evident, but the surfaces (especially the reverse) show mottled color. The devices are sharply struck as always.(Registry values: N1793)

258

1909-S VDB 1C MS65 Red and Brown NGC. Considerable mint orange is apparent on this Gem key-date Lincoln cent, intermixed with occasional blushes of bluish-tan. Sharp definition is noted on the design features, including fully delineated lines in the wheat stalks. The surfaces on both sides are quite clean, revealing no significant abrasions or unsightly spotting.(Registry values: N1793)

259

1909-S VDB 1C --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. Though this key-date cent was cleaned, leaving hairlines on the olive and golden-brown surfaces, the overall eye appeal is considerable. Well struck with few overt abrasions.(Registry values: N1)

260

1909-S VDB 1C --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Sharply struck with only minor wear. The overbright orange of the obverse, accented in lilac and blue, is more subdued on the reverse.(Registry values: N991)

261

1909-S VDB 1C MS66 Red PCGS. Quick, what do the 1793 Chain cent, the 1796 No Stars quarter eagle, and the 1909-S VDB cent have in common? They are, of course, all first-year, one-year types, a sort in which U.S. coinage abounds. The 1909-S is a nonetheless a special coin that is dear (in every sense of the word) to many collectors--foremost, with the legions of present-day collectors who started their numismatic careers going through pocket change and filling up Whitman folders with their latest finds. But while those late-18th-century coins are out of reach in decent shape for all but the well-heeled, a dedicated Lincoln cent aficionado can afford a 1909-S VDB in almost any grade desired, with a sufficient amount of sacrifice. This is a marvelous example that exhibits original orange-red mint luster with no readily discernible marks. The striking details are fully brought up on both sides. Rarely seen in such a superlative state.(Registry values: N2998)

262

1909-S 1C S Over Horizontal S MS65 Red PCGS. FS-1502, formerly FS-012.3. An important repunched mintmark that would be more celebrated if not for the 1909-S cent's rarity on the whole. This Red Gem has charming, slightly subdued copper-orange luster with a small carbon fleck on the lower coat.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P2)

263

1911 1C MS66 Red PCGS. The incredible strike and frosty orange luster combine to create a beautiful Lincoln cent. Only a few tiny spots limit the grade of an otherwise remarkable specimen. PCGS has only certified eight finer Red examples (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

264

1913-S 1C MS64 Red PCGS. Soft copper-orange luster with glints of lemon-gold and minor obverse spotting. A well struck near-Gem with considerable eye appeal. PCGS has graded 45 finer Red representatives (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

265

1914-D 1C --Environmental Damage--NGC. Unc. Details. The lustrous and predominantly sun-gold obverse is highly attractive, despite a fingerprint fragment on the upper half of Lincoln's vest. The reverse is minutely granular and mostly dark gray with glimpses of dusky forest-green at the periphery.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

266

1914-D 1C MS64 Brown NGC. The "brown" on this Brown coin is vibrant blue and lilac, and the NGC holder fails to mention substantial portions of original orange luster on each side. Here is an extremely important opportunity for the Lincoln collector to acquire the famous 1914-D, a key date in the series.(Registry values: N2998)

267

1914-D 1C MS64 Red PCGS. Though it has a higher mintage than several other Lincoln cent keys, this little-saved issue has emerged as the most dramatic hybrid of a low starting population and condition rarity. The dusky orange surfaces of the present coin show few marks, though slight carbon is present at the margins. Well struck and fundamentally pleasing.(Registry values: N4719)

268

1914-D 1C MS64 Red PCGS. This fully struck key date cent has consistent brick-red luster and is impressively free from abrasions. Minor flyspecks preclude a higher grade. The 1914-D is among the most challenging issues to locate in any condition, and most survivors are in well circulated grades. PCGS has certified 58 pieces finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

269

1914-D 1C MS65 Red PCGS. While the 1909-S VDB cent has gained far greater fame across most grades, serious students of the series recognize the 1914-D as more challenging in the higher Mint State tiers, particularly with fully Red surfaces. This Gem has an orange obverse, generally bright, while the reverse shows a duskier peach hue. The strike is remarkably sharp, particularly on the fine details of Lincoln's portrait. A degree of peripheral carbon is most evident in the space between GOD and WE on the obverse. Housed in a green label holder. PCGS has certified just three finer Red representatives (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

270

1919 1C MS67 Red PCGS. This Superb Gem 1919 Lincoln cent has brilliant orange mint luster with exceptional design definition on both sides. Despite an incredible mintage of nearly 400 million coins, few have survived in such remarkable preservation. Population: 58 in 67 Red, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

271

1920-D 1C MS66 Brown NGC. The obverse of this Premium Gem is entirely brown with satiny luster and iridescent toning, while the reverse has virtually full faded orange luster. An important opportunity is presented to the avid Lincoln cent collector.(Registry values: N1793)

272

1920-S 1C MS65 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. Rich reddish-orange luster is evident on both sides, with little brown toning in sight. This piece is about as close to full Red as possible without receiving that designation. Population: 19 in 65 Red and Brown, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

273

1922 No D 1C Strong Reverse Fine 15 PCGS. FS-401, formerly FS-013.2. Die Pair 2. No cents were struck at Philadelphia in 1922 due to enormous Peace dollar production. That fact creates great collector interest for the important 1922 No D, Strong Reverse variety. This medium brown example displays wear on the portrait but the lines in the wheat ears are mostly distinct.(Registry values: P2)

274

1922 No D 1C Strong Reverse XF40 PCGS. CAC. FS-401, formerly FS-013.2. Die Pair 2. A medium brown key date cent with sharp definition on the lines of the wheat ears. The obverse has lesser detail, as always for this important variety, which was struck from a well worn obverse die. The second 2 in the date is nonetheless bold, diagnostic for the issue. Problem-free and pleasing for the grade.(Registry values: P2)

275

1922 No D 1C Strong Reverse AU53 PCGS. CAC. FS-401, formerly FS-013.2. Die Pair 2. The obverse and reverse dies clashed on this pairing, and subsequent die polishing to remove evidence of the clashing inadvertently also removed the mintmark. The reverse die was replaced before more coins were struck, thus this die pair is commonly called the Strong Reverse. Light reddish-brown color covers both sides and there are faint traces of mint luster around the devices. A few minor marks can be found with a magnifier, but this is definitely an above-average example of this rare and widely sought-after variant in the Lincoln cent series.(Registry values: P2)

276

1922 No D 1C Strong Reverse MS64 Red and Brown NGC. FS-401, formerly FS-013.2. Die Pair 2. A collector's delight for anyone who has long coveted this classic mint rarity. Early on, the discovery was made that despite the Mint reports that no Philadelphia cents were struck in 1922, they seemed to be available. Later the riddle was untangled: Apparently in the rush to coin millions of Peace silver dollars in 1922, the Denver Mint was ordered to pick up the slack on cents, but had to use the dies they had in stock already. When one of the 1922-D obverse dies clashed, the clash marks were ground off the die, which also happened to remove the mintmark. More cents were struck using two different reverse dies, one with strong wheat ears; the other reverse was badly worn and hence became known as the "Weak Reverse." This coin is from the Strong Reverse die pairing and shows no trace of the mintmark. An interesting sidenote is included in the fifth edition of Cherrypickers': "die pair #2 is believed to have never had a D mintmark."
Faded mint red is found in the protected areas, with the balance a typically seen bluish-brown. The surfaces are clean and attractive, with no distracting nicks on the devices or fields. Without a doubt, this issue is one of the most difficult to find in Mint State, and locating one so close to a Gem grade (and with some Red color) will represent a triumph for the collector lucky enough to win this lot. Anticipate well-deserved competition when this rarity crosses the auction block. Census: 5 in 64 Red and Brown, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

277

1922 No D 1C Weak Reverse MS64 Brown NGC. Die Pair 3, differentiated from the Weak Reverse Die Pair 1 by the slightly rotated reverse. Michael Fahey describes the Die Pair 3 Reverse in an April 7, 2008 Coin World article. The D mintmark does not readily show on this near-Gem example. Glimpses of orange luster peek through of bluish-brown patination. Although less desirable than the Strong Reverse variety, this is a pleasing piece. Census: 2 in 64 Brown, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N7079)

278

1925 1C MS67 Red PCGS. This splendid Red Superb Gem is a real prize for Registry Set collectors, or perhaps for the many type collectors who wish to upgrade their sets. The surfaces are basically unmarked as expected, with generous amounts of orange-red coloration and an excellent strike for the issue. Population: 55 in 67 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

279

1926 1C MS67 Red PCGS. An absolutely amazing 1926 Lincoln cent, with vibrant and brilliant orange mint luster, accented by light gold and deeper orange color. Here is an important opportunity for the Set Registry collector. Population: 77 in 67 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

280

1926 1C MS67 Red PCGS. This sharply defined Superb Gem has exquisite orange luster with frosty surfaces. Both sides are immaculate, with only microscopic imperfections. Population: 77 in 67 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

281

1926 1C MS67 Red PCGS. An amazing Superb Gem with brilliant orange luster and bold design features. This exceptional example will serve the Set Registry collector well. Population: 77 in 67 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

282

1926-D 1C MS65 Red PCGS. Peach-red and sun-gold alternate across this lustrous and sharply struck Gem. Infrequent minute carbon is all that limits the grade. This conditionally rare Denver Mint issue from the 1920s is usually encountered spotty, toned, or worn. Encapsulated in a green label holder. Population: 45 in 65 Red, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

283

1926-S 1C MS63 Red and Brown PCGS. Copper-gold luster shows through the thin veil of light tan patina. A well struck piece devoid of significant abrasions or spots.(Registry values: N491)

284

1929 1C MS67 Red PCGS. Advanced Lincoln cent collectors know certain early dates, especially P-mints, are "common"--dates such as 1926, 1919, and 1929. But the word common has to have quotes around it because truly Superb Gem examples such as this one are anything but common, especially when one weighs the number of Lincoln cent collectors against the tiny percentage of such coins available. Only 43 other pieces have been so graded by PCGS, and none have been certified finer by either of the major services (1/10). This is an amazing coin. The surfaces retain the original, unmellowed yellow-orange-red the piece had in 1929. We can locate no carbon on either side, and the surfaces are essentially free from any post-striking impairments. Simply amazing quality.(Registry values: N991)

285

1929-S 1C MS67 Red NGC. The obverse is orange-red save for an occasional wisp of powder-blue. The reverse features diverse shades of sun-gold, peach-red, and lilac. Highly lustrous, with splendid eye appeal, and one of the finest known. Census: 2 in 67 Red, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2004), lot 4832.(Registry values: N991)

286

1931-S 1C MS66 Red PCGS. The 1931-S is a key issue among later date Lincoln cents by virtue of its low mintage of only 866,000 pieces. Sharply impressed, the only mentionable variation in the red color is a slight accent of lilac in the area of the O in ONE on the reverse. Population: 83 in 66 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

287

1936-D 1C MS68 Red NGC. This sensational Superb Gem is fully brilliant with frosty orange luster that hosts pale blue and iridescent peripheral accents. This piece is one of just two examples that NGC has certified at the grade level, with none similarly graded at PCGS. Census: 2 in 68 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

288

1944-D/S 1C MS65 Red ANACS. FS-512, formerly FS-021, OMM-2, called "Die 2" on the old ANACS holder. The underlying S mintmark is placed lower relative to the D than on the more famous FS-511. Fresh copper-orange luster with mild to moderate spotting and a solid strike.(Registry values: P2)

289

1945 1C MS68 Red NGC. Virtually flawless surfaces that are beautifully patinated with varying shades of sunset-red and orange color. The single finest '45 Lincoln certified by either major grading service, insuring its appeal among Registry Set collectors. When we last offered this piece in 2003, it was the only MS68 Red certified by either NGC or PCGS. That data remains unchanged today, seven years later. Census: 1 in 68 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

290

1950-S 1C MS68 Red NGC. From a total certified population of 1,178 coins, NGC has certified a single MS68 Red example (2/10), and it is offered here. PCGS has never graded a coin finer than MS67, making this Superb Gem the finest available example of the date. The incredible frosty orange mint luster trumps a slightly weak strike. The specialist will want to actively pursue this offering.(Registry values: N1793)

291

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse--Genuine--PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has been damaged. Well-defined blue-brown surfaces have an unusual tint and gloss. Minor carbon and a series of concentric circles affect the reverse; PCGS apparently considered this an alteration rather than simple damage.

292

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse--Cleaned--ANACS. AU Details, Net XF45. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. Both sides have a distinctive olive-tan appearance with splashes of iridescence. The surfaces have light wear as the grade suggests. The hallmark parallel die lines on the reverse of all genuine pieces are obscured, but visible.(Registry values: N1)

293

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. A lightly worn example of the prominent doubled die variety. Candy-orange and lemon surfaces are over-bright from a past cleaning.(Registry values: N991)

294

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse AU55 NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. This chocolate-brown key date cent has excellent eye appeal, since there are no remotely relevant marks and friction is limited to the cheekbone, jaw, and hair above the ear. The fields still shimmer with cartwheel sheen.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

295

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse AU58 NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. A sharply struck and satiny medium brown near-Mint example of this dramatic doubled die error. Just a trace of friction on the cheekbone precludes a much higher grade. The absence of abrasions ensures the eye appeal.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N991)

296

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse AU58 NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. A sharply defined example of the famous variety, with a trace of wear on the highest design points. Both sides have nearly full luster with chocolate-brown surfaces and traces of iridescence.(Registry values: N991)

297

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse AU58 ANACS. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. A tan-brown near-Mint example of the most famous doubled die mint error in numismatics. Satin luster rolls over minimally abraded surfaces.(Registry values: N991)

298

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse MS64 Brown PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. A lovely olive-brown near-Gem, this piece has traces of original orange luster along the borders and devices. Only a few tiny spots and nicks prevent a higher grade. The always-popular 1955 Doubled Die cent is one of the most famous 20th century coinage varieties.(Registry values: N1793)

299

1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse MS62 Red and Brown PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-021.8. This is a brilliant example that has nearly full red color with only slight mellowing in the form of light brown toning on the high points. Here is a splendid piece for the Lincoln specialist or the generalized collector who appreciates famous varieties.(Registry values: N991)

300

1960-D/D 1C Small Over Large Date MS66 Red NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-025.5. This is a remarkable die blunder with the die first hubbed with the Large Date hub, then with the Small Date hub. In addition, the mintmark was first entered far north of its final position, with the upper left corner of the first mintmark joined to the tail of the 9. This Premium Gem is fully brilliant with vivid orange luster, a remarkable piece. Census: 12 in 66 Red, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

301

1969-S 1C Doubled Die AU55 PCGS. Breen-2252. FS-101, formerly FS-028. The list of U.S. doubled die varieties that can be seen with the unaided eye is short. The 1955 Lincoln cent is a classic, as is the 1972, to a lesser extent. The 1916 Buffalo nickel is plain once one knows where to look, and any number of 20th century overdates, such as the 1942/1 dime, are also technically doubled dies, though not often thought of as such. Often forgotten because of its rarity, but in its own way more important than any of the rest, is the rare 1969-S with doubled die obverse.
The 1969-S doubled die cent is rare regardless of grade, which means it is not as well-distributed as other prominent doubled dies, and as a consequence, its fame is not so great, even though the 1969-S doubled die is listed in the Guide Book. Series specialists are well aware of it, however, and every auction appearance of the variety is met with intense interest.
This still-lustrous example, golden-brown at the margins with richer medium-brown color across the centers, shows only modest wear across the highest design elements. This suggests that the coin circulated only briefly before it was saved as unusual. Lightly abraded on the obverse with the reverse showing weakness on the first letter of E PLURIBUS UNUM; this weakness, which may have resulted from a minor strike-through, should serve as an effective pedigree marker. Population: 4 in 55, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

302

1971 1C Doubled Die Obverse MS64 Red NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-031. All obverse legends are die doubled, most prominently on the IBER in LIBERTY. The obverse is misaligned toward 10 o'clock, a second mint error. Well struck and lustrous with a blush of carbon beneath the Lincoln Memorial.

Proof Lincoln Cents

303

1909 1C VDB PR64 Red and Brown PCGS. This boldly defined Lincoln has exquisite matte proof surfaces with nearly full original red luster, mellowed to reddish-brown and deeper brown on each side. A few minuscule spots are evident on each side, preventing a higher grade. Close inspection reveals the distinctive "wood-grain" appearance that is often associated with the various 1909 cent varieties.
As the first Lincoln cent, and a short-lived variety with initials on the reverse, this 1909 VDB is an important rarity in proof format, with a mintage of just 1,194 coins. Perhaps half of those survive today.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

304

1909 1C PR65 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. While far less rare than its counterpart with the VDB initials, the 1909 proof cents is nonetheless cherished by collectors for its first-year status. One obverse die was carried over from the 1909 VDB issue, and this example is the second obverse die, not a reuse. A couple of tiny die lines from the top of the L in LIBERTY mark this one. This piece has the sharp detail and squared-off rims diagnostic if the issue, with much red remaining. Population: 75 in 65 Red and Brown, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

305

1909 1C PR65 Red and Brown PCGS. This sharply defined Gem proof has satiny surfaces with a blend of violet, dark blue, tan, and reddish-orange toning on both sides. Population: 75 in 65 Red and Brown, 25 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

306

1910 1C PR65 Red and Brown PCGS. Both sides have considerable faded orange luster with splashes of blue-brown toning. Here is an attractive Gem matte proof with bold design details. Population: 51 in 65 Red and Brown, 22 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

307

1913 1C PR65 Red and Brown PCGS. Both sides are sharply defined with satiny luster and exceptional surfaces. The toning includes orange-gold and lime-green, with hints of blue and lilac. Population: 68 in 65 Red and Brown, 15 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

308

1915 1C PR64 Red and Brown PCGS. With a lovely combination of bright gold and light orange, this near-Gem matte proof is virtually full Red, and may deserve just such a designation.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N491)

309

1916 1C PR64 Brown PCGS. Bold design definition with satiny surfaces are evident on this Choice matte proof. The surfaces have dark steel-brown toning with splashes of faded orange mint color. Population: 15 in 64 Brown, 13 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

310

1936 1C Type One--Satin Finish PR65 Red PCGS. A boldly detailed Gem, this Satin Finish proof has brilliant orange color with a few splashes of iridescent toning to increase its overall eye appeal. Advanced collectors who desire both types of 1936 proof Lincoln cents will take delight in this opportunity. Population: 54 in 65 Red, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

311

1936 1C Type Two--Brilliant Finish PR65 Red PCGS. A beautiful orange-gold specimen that dazzles the viewer with strong reflectivity and fiery color. Housed in a green-label PCGS holder. PCGS has only certified 31 finer Red examples (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

312

1937 1C PR66 Red Cameo NGC. Pale copper-gold color prevails on this uncommon Cameo coin, though a hint of lemon appears at the right rims. Sharply impressed with gorgeous mirrors. Census: 15 in 66 Red Cameo, 5 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2)

313

1937 1C PR66 Red Cameo NGC. Deep reddish-orange proof surfaces host obvious cameo contrast on this Premium Gem. Both sides are boldly defined. Only a few trivial imperfections are evident. NGC has only certified 34 full Red Cameo proofs in all grades, with three additional Ultra Cameo pieces. Census: 14 in 66 Red Cameo, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

314

1938 1C PR67 Red PCGS. This brilliant and boldly detailed Superb Gem proof has rich orange mint color with faint contrast between the deeply mirrored fields and the satiny devices. The surfaces are flawless and the eye appeal is grand. Population: 28 in 67 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

315

1939 1C PR67 Red PCGS. This fully brilliant Superb Gem proof has bright orange mint surfaces with deeply mirrored fields around reflective devices. An attractive piece, and a coin for the connoisseur. Population: 27 in 67 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

316

1942 1C PR66 Red PCGS. Brilliant orange surfaces display sharply struck design elements. Nicely preserved, with a few light toning streaks in the lower left obverse. Population: 92 in 66 Red, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N69)

318

1952 1C PR68 Red PCGS. A near-perfect specimen with gloriously undisturbed orange-gold surfaces. Hundreds of proof 1952 Lincoln cents have been submitted to PCGS, but the number of coins qualifying at this lofty level is extremely limited. Population: 5 in 68 Red, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2005), lot 5520, which realized $2,300.(Registry values: N69)

319

1952 1C PR68 Cameo NGC. An amazing Superb Gem proof with fully brilliant orange luster. The contrast is exceptional, and just shy of the Ultra Cameo designation. Census: 7 in 68 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

320

1953 1C PR67 Red Ultra Cameo NGC. Here is an incredible proof 1953 Lincoln cent with fiery orange luster and amazing contrast. It is nearly the finest certified, and destined for a top collection of these coins. Census: 2 in 67 Ultra Cameo, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

321

1956 1C PR67 Red Deep Cameo PCGS. Outstanding reflectivity with absolutely untoned copper-gold surfaces that set up great field-to-device contrast. A stunning Superb Gem specimen. Population: 36 in 67 Red Deep Cameo, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

322

1956 1C PR69 Red Ultra Cameo NGC. Rick Tomaska once noted that proof Lincoln cents from this decade do not generally show great cameo contrast on the reverse, but this magical specimen shows profound field-to-device contrast on both sides. Fully struck, immaculately preserved, and essentially brilliant. None are graded any finer at either service. Census: 2 in 69 Red Ultra Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

323

1957 1C PR68 Red Ultra Cameo NGC. A bold and brilliant piece with rich contrast. The copper-orange surfaces have just a few tiny specks of milky patina below the M and E in AMERICA. A couple of curly lintmarks are noted on the obverse: one just below R in TRUST and the other directly above the 7 in the date, at approximately 3 o'clock. Census: 3 in 68 Red Ultra Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

324

1960 1C Large Over Small Date PR69 Red NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-025. DDO-1. Technically a doubled die variety, as the die received an impression from the Small Date hub, followed by a second impression from the Large Date hub. This near perfect coin has brilliant orange luster with pristine surfaces. Census: 2 in 69 Red, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

325

1970-S 1C Small Date PR69 Red Ultra Cameo NGC. FS-1402, formerly FS-030.2. The proof 1970-S Small Date cent is highly desirable and in great demand, especially when the finest certified piece is offered. NGC and PCGS have combined to certify four of these in PR69 Ultra or Deep Cameo, with none graded finer. This amazing coin has bright orange luster with exceptional contrast. An interesting aspect of this example is microscopic doubling that is visible on IN GOD WE TRUST.(Registry values: P1)

326

1971-S 1C PR69 Ultra Cameo NGC. Glassy reflectivity in the fields is a great backdrop for cameo contrast on the obverse and reverse alike. The pristine, frosted devices are well struck, and the proof surfaces are free of hairlines or handling marks. Census: 8 in 69 Ultra Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

Two Cent Pieces

327

1864 2C Small Motto MS65 Brown NGC. FS-401, formerly FS-000.5. The olive-brown surfaces of this Gem are satiny and pristine with mostly bold design definition. The surfaces lack vibrancy, preventing a higher grade. The 1864 Small Motto was issued at the beginning of this series, prior to the Large Motto coins, and it is the true first-year design type of the denomination. Census: 36 in 65 Brown, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

328

1865 2C MS66 Red PCGS. Fancy 5. The pale copper-orange color of this Premium Gem is essentially unturned with only minor spotting at the borders. The strike is solid, and the surfaces are virtually unabraded. A prominent die crack and cud starts at the second T in TRUST and continues through the arrowhead and ribbon end to the rim. Population: 42 in 66 Red, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Two Cent Pieces

329

1865 2C PR65 Brown Cameo NGC. Plain 5. An electrifying Gem, distinctly contrasted despite the toning of the surfaces to blue and green. The fields still gleam and set off the devices. A gorgeous two cent proof.(Registry values: P3)

330

1866 2C PR66 Red Cameo NGC. While NGC has certified nine total examples of this proof issue as having Cameo contrast, this is the only one so designated to have full Red surfaces (2/10). As such, it is of great importance to the high-end series collector. While both sides show strong contrast, that of the obverse is slightly more impressive, owing to its greater depth of frost on the devices. Light copper-gold surfaces show subtle color variations, including accents in peach and mint, though none of this color veers into Brown territory. In short, a wonderful and important specimen.(Registry values: P2)

331

1868 2C PR66 Red and Brown PCGS. The obverse is decidedly more Red than Brown, with fresh copper-orange color over most of that side. The upper obverse has deep crimson-brown color, however, and while the reverse peripheral zones are "Red," the wreath area offers slight variations on a pale green hue. One of just 600 proofs struck.(Registry values: N1793)

332

1871 2C PR65 Red and Brown NGC. Much sun-gold is present, although the design highpoints and the open fields have mellowed in lilac hues. Well struck and mark-free with only a couple of pinpoint flecks. TRUST is die doubled, as seen on all 1871 proofs.(Registry values: N991)

333

1871 2C PR66 Red and Brown NGC. Remarkably clean, unspotted surfaces display pleasing orange-tan patination imbued with splashes of sky-blue and lavender. The design elements are sharply struck in all areas. The reflectivity of the fields is somewhat subdued by the toning, but this should not be considered a detracting feature on this appealing proof. One of about 960 pieces struck. Census: 21 in 66 Red and Brown, 1 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

334

1871 2C PR66 Cameo NGC. Production of two cent pieces for circulation continued to drop year after year, making it increasingly difficult to find such coins in high grades and lending the proof strikings ever-greater importance. This exceptionally attractive coin has deeply mirrored fields with sharply contrasting frosted devices. The Red and Brown label is curious, as there is little evidence of any brown on this piece. The surfaces are almost perfectly preserved. Census: 21 in PR66 Red and Brown Cameo, only one finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

335

1872 2C PR66 Brown NGC. This fully struck specimen displays beautiful blended apple-green and ruby-red toning. Satiny and essentially flawless. The 1872 is desirable in proof format due to the rarity of Uncirculated business strikes.(Registry values: N1793)

336

1873 2C Closed 3 PR63 Brown PCGS. The 1873 is a proof-only issue and the Closed 3 issue was limited to a mere 600 pieces. The Closed 3 is easily discernable without a glass, as the horizontal shield lines are uniformly strong. The restrike Open 3 coins always show a patch of weakness. Housed in a first-generation PCGS holder; the surfaces are almost completely brown with a trace of underlying red. There are few visible contact marks, but the brown patina has subdued the field mirrors.(Registry values: N1793)

337

1873 2C Closed 3 PR65 Red NGC. Even, light reddish-orange color with subtle lilac accents and only a few scattered, microscopic flecks of carbon. All Closed 3 coins are originals and only 600 pieces are believed to have been struck in this final year of the denomination. Census: 9 in 65 Red, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Three Cent Silver

338

1851 3CS MS66 NGC. This highly lustrous first-year trime sports light golden accents on its silver-gray surfaces. This Premium Gem would fit well in a type or date set. Census: 70 in 66, 7 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

339

1851 3CS MS67 PCGS. First year of issue for this curious denomination. Predictably a larger number of this low denomination were set aside, but few are known or offered for sale at public auction. This example has thick mint frost and each side is covered with light gray-lilac toning with undertones of yellow and rose. Sharply struck throughout. Population: 11 in 67, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

340

1854 3CS MS65 PCGS. Exquisite yellow-green, plum-mauve, and cobalt-blue embraces this satiny and precisely struck Gem. Unabraded and exceptionally attractive. The conditionally rare Type Two design, struck only between 1854 and 1858. Struck from moderately clashed dies. Population: 42 in 65, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

341

1855 3CS MS64 PCGS. The scarcest issue of the short-lived Type Two design, being particularly elusive in Choice and better grades. The surfaces display just very light incipient color. Only minor softness is noted at the borders, but the overall sharpness of this piece is considerably above-average. Population: 44 in 64, 16 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

342

1856 3CS MS65 NGC. A lustrous and well preserved cream-gray Gem. Sharply struck on the major devices; softness is noted on the peripheral elements. A few interesting die lines intersect near the shield border, and clashmarks occur on the reverse. Quite scarce at the MS65 level, and in demand as a high grade example of the scarce Type Two design. Census: 14 in 65, 4 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

343

1857 3CS MS65 NGC. Mellow azure-blue coloration on both sides enlivens the obvious clash marks most prominent beneath the star at 6 o'clock on the obverse. The strike is somewhat soft around the obverse rim through ATES OF, but marks are minimal and the eye appeal is large. More clashing appears on the reverse through the denomination, from the obverse horizontal shield stripes. A lovely and enticing Gem of this issue, from the year the "old coppers" were retired. Census: 32 in 65, 14 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

344

1857 3CS MS66 NGC. Medium jade-green and gunmetal-gray toning invigorates this shimmering and well preserved Premium Gem. The borders show occasional incompleteness of strike, but the devices are crisply impressed. The penultimate year of the Type Two design, which has a double outline around the prominent obverse star. Struck from noticeably clashed dies. Census: 13 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

345

1858 3CS MS64 PCGS. Deep silver-gray patina graces each side, and deep cobalt and crimson shadings adorn the borders. A pleasing Choice three cent silver, housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

346

1858 3CS MS65 NGC. The 1858 three cent silver was more than 1 million coins, but it would be the last time the series would hit that milestone before ending 15 years later. This is an appealing silver-gray Gem with some minor clash marks visible on the reverse. Census: 45 in 65, 29 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

347

1861 3CS MS67 PCGS. CAC. A lovely Civil War example, this frosty gold-toned Superb Gem is housed in an older green label PCGS holder and exhibits a bold strike with amazing eye appeal. The Type Three design was issued from 1859 until the end of the series in 1873, and this piece is a wonderful representative. Population: 24 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

348

1862 3CS MS66 ★ NGC. Both sides have gorgeous bands of toning, light blue-green at the rims through cerulean and strawberry to pale silver-cream. The last color appears in a small circle on the obverse, though the reverse has more of a cone with a broad swath of the upper area showing a similar hue.(Registry values: N1793)

349

1862 3CS MS66 PCGS. CAC. Luminous gold and orange tints visit the borders, but the softly lustrous centers remain silver-white. An excellent Premium Gem example of this last widely distributed three cent silver business strike issue. PCGS has graded just 11 coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Three Cent Silver

350

1873 3CS PR65 Ultra Cameo NGC. The final issue of the three cent silver denomination was coined only in proof, with a mintage of just 600 coins. Quite a number of those survive, but few with the amazing eye appeal of this Gem. Both sides have remarkable contrast beneath light gold toning. Census: 1 in 65 Ultra Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

Three Cent Nickels

351

1865 3CN MS66 PCGS. CAC. Hints of blue toning visit otherwise pale nickel-gray surfaces on this satiny first-year Premium Gem. Both obverse and reverse show prominent die clashing, and the die crack reaching down into Liberty's coronet suggests a near-terminal state for the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

352

1867 3CN MS67 NGC. An untoned, lustrous, and pristine Superb Gem. The strike is generally sharp, although the three denominational columns show occasional softness. More the 3.9 million pieces were coined, but surprisingly few remain in high grades. Struck from multiply clashed dies. Census: 3 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

353

1870 3CN MS66 NGC. This sensational Premium Gem has highly lustrous and fully brilliant gray surfaces with exceptional eye appeal. A few surface marks are entirely inconsequential. Census: 9 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

354

1873 3CN Closed 3 MS66 PCGS. A brilliant and lustrous Premium Gem, noteworthy for its unabraded appearance and the presence of prominent clashmarks (as made) on each side. A good strike with only minor incompleteness near the centers. None have been certified finer at either major grading service. Population: 10 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

355

1873 3CN Closed 3 MS66 PCGS. CAC. Light caramel-gold and olive-gray embraces this lustrous and mark-free Premium Gem. The strike is exacting apart from minor blending on the curls at the base of the bust. An underappreciated issue in Uncirculated grades, and a rarity at the MS66 level. Encased in an old green label holder. Population: 9 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

356

1873 3CN Open 3 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Ebullient luster embraces this Gem three cent nickel that displays just a wisp or two of barely discernible yellow-gold color. Excellent motif definition is apparent on the obverse while the reverse exhibits the typical weakness characteristic of the earlier years of production. No abrasions of consequence, just some light obverse clash marks. Population: 13 in 65, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

357

1875 3CN MS66 NGC. Light peach and gold toning visits the shining surfaces of this Premium Gem. Impressively detailed for a business strike. Census: 17 in 66, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

358

1882 3CN MS66 PCGS. CAC. The three cent nickel series seems fated to be underappreciated and undervalued. The decade of the 1880s is a highly collectible one, and pieces from those years are seldom available as business strikes. The mintage for the 1882 was 22,200 pieces, which is several times the output for other years from the 1880s. However, few were saved. As a result, PCGS has only certified 14 other pieces in MS66 with a mere three finer (2/10). This is a no-questions circulation strike with no reflectivity in the fields. The surfaces are bright and highly lustrous with just a hint of pale reddish patina, and the strike is full.(Registry values: N1793)

359

1883 3CN MS62 PCGS. The production of circulation strike three cent nickels declined to 4,000 pieces in 1883. The light to medium gray surfaces of this MS62 coin exhibit muted luster and sharply struck design elements, including completeness in the lines of the III. A few light flecks are noted on each side. Population: 7 in 62, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

360

1888 3CN MS67 PCGS. CAC. Vibrant luster endows this Superb Gem that displays whispers of golden-gray patination and a well executed strike leaves sharp delineation on the design features. Impeccable preservation further enhances the already magnificent eye appeal. Population: 34 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Three Cent Nickels

361

1865 3CN PR66 Cameo PCGS. This first-year proof is the key to the series with a low percentage of survivors, especially in high grade. Few are seen with the cameo contrast present on this coin, and the fields are unusually deep for this date. Each side shows light golden-rose toning. Population: 22 in 66 Cameo, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

362

1866 3CN PR65 Cameo PCGS. A lovely Gem Cameo proof, this piece exhibits hints of champagne toning over pleasing nickel-gray surfaces. The contrast between the fields and devices is immediately evident. Population: 23 in 65 Cameo, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

363

1867 3CN PR66 Cameo NGC. Excellent field-device contrast enhances nickel-white surfaces. A tiny lint mark appears near the obverse rim at 1 o'clock. Strong overall definition and top-flight eye appeal. Census: 33 in 66 Cameo, 3 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

364

1867 3CN PR66 Cameo NGC. Frosty devices and glassy fields ensure the cameo status of this boldly struck and brilliant Premium Gem. Just 625 proofs were struck. Census: 34 in 66 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

365

1876 3CN PR65 Deep Cameo PCGS. Even though 1,150 proofs were struck in this year, there is a pronounced lack of cameo coinage. PCGS has certified only five Deep Cameos at this grade level, and none higher (2/10). Brilliant throughout, the fields are deeply mirrored, and the wreath and portrait display thick mint frost that gives the coin substantial contrast.
Ex: Baltimore Signature (Heritage, 7/2003), lot 5937, which realized $1,437.50.(Registry values: P2)

366

1877 3CN PR63 PCGS. An attractive example of this important proof-only issue, in this instance certified in an older green-label PCGS holder. The design motifs are sharply detailed, with mirrored fields around lustrous devices, creating slight cameo contrast. A lovely example for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

367

1877 3CN PR66 NGC. The 1877 has the lowest mintage (510+ pieces) of the three proof-only three cent nickel issues. Consequently, high-end specimens such as this Premium Gem are highly prized. Exquisitely struck design elements display a degree of contrast at various angles. Well cared-for surfaces reveal whispers of powder-blue and beige-gold under magnification. Census: 62 in 66, 4 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

368

1877 3CN PR66 Cameo NGC. The 1877 is one of the keys to the proof series of three cent nickels, along with the 1865 and 1878. The reason this date is a key lies in its low mintage of approximately 510 pieces in addition to its proof-only status. This is an exceptionally beautiful example. The surfaces are brilliant throughout and the fields are deeply mirrored, which sets up noticeable cameo contrast against the frosted devices. A shallow contact mark in the lower left obverse field and a couple of light specks of carbon are all that keep this lovely coin from an even higher grade. Census: 47 in 66 Cameo, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

369

1877 3CN PR66 Cameo PCGS. A proof-only issue as are several denominations minted in 1877, this Premium Gem Cameo proof has fully brilliant nickel-gray surfaces with bold design motifs and excellent contrast between the fields and devices. Population: 33 in 66 Cameo, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

370

1878 3CN PR66 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Profoundly mirrored with delightful frost on the contrasting devices. An incredibly appealing Premium Gem specimen with solid preservation for the grade. Population: 65 in 66 Cameo, 9 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

371

1878 3CN PR67 Cameo NGC. An outstanding specimen of this proof-only issue, exquisitely preserved with readily perceptible contrast. Glimpses of pale blue and green-gold color grace the watery fields. Census: 28 in 67 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

372

1880 3CN PR67 NGC. Soft violet, gold, orange, and lavender compete for territory on the nicely preserved surfaces of this Superb Gem proof. Razor-sharp-definition shows on the devices. Census: 42 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

373

1881 3CN PR67 NGC. CAC. This sharply detailed and fully brilliant nickel-gray Superb Gem proof has slight cameo contrast, although insufficient for a Cameo designation. It is a highly appealing piece for a type set or specialized collection. Census: 52 in 67, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

374

1881 3CN PR67 Cameo PCGS. A dazzling, deeply mirrored Superb Gem, brilliant at first glance, though subtle ice-blue toning appears at the obverse periphery. Population: 18 in 67 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

375

1882 3CN PR67 NGC. Remarkable post-striking quality, as demanded of a Superb Gem proof, though a handful of tiny planchet flaws are visible to the unaided eye. Gleaming nickel-white surfaces show just a hint of green-gold color. Census: 60 in 67, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

376

1882 3CN PR67 Cameo NGC. Excellent contrast and preservation, both befitting a Cameo Superb Gem specimen. A touch of honey-gold toning visits the centers. Census: 24 in 67 Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

377

1883 3CN PR66 PCGS. CAC. This satin Premium Gem proof is housed in a first generation holder. It exhibits lovely nickel-gray surfaces and excellent design detail. At first glance this piece resembles a business strike, as proof 1883s often do, but the strike is sufficient to show its proof status.(Registry values: N991)

378

1883 3CN PR66 PCGS. CAC. Bright proof surfaces display barely perceptible golden-brown streaks, and reveal no significant abrasions or unsightly spots. The design elements are sharply struck throughout. PCGS has seen 66 coins grading higher (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

379

1886 3CN PR67 Cameo PCGS. CAC. This charming specimen is tied for numerically finest among Cameo pieces graded by NGC or PCGS (2/10). Gleaming surfaces are minimally toned, though the luster is more cartwheel than reflective. Nonetheless, the sharp strike on the devices and the remarkable preservation on each side attest to the piece's proof status.(Registry values: N1793)

380

1889 3CN PR67 PCGS. Deserving of a Cameo designation, this Superb Gem has brilliant light gray surfaces with satiny, reflective fields and fully lustrous devices. The strike is bold, the surfaces are pristine, and the eye appeal is first-rate. Population: 50 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Shield Nickels

381

1866 5C Rays MS65 PCGS. CAC. Splashes of bluish-violet and gold run over the lustrous surfaces of this lovely Gem and a well executed strike imparts strong definition to the design features. A few small spots do not detract.(Registry values: N2998)

382

1866 5C Rays MS65 NGC. Vibrant luster exudes from the essentially untoned surfaces of this lovely Gem. Some incomplete striking does not detract from the overall eye appeal..(Registry values: N2998)

383

1866 5C Rays MS65 PCGS. An attractive piece, highly lustrous beneath soft blue and greenish-gold patina, that would fit well in a high-grade type set. The Mint's comparative unfamiliarity with copper-nickel as an alloy is evident on the obverse, which has several die cracks (a reflection of the wear and tear the compound inflicted on dies) and soft detail at the left obverse leaves.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

384

1866 5C Rays MS66 NGC. The first Shield nickel issue and the first five cent struck in nickel, the 1866 Rays remains one of the most popular type coins in 19th century numismatics. This Premium Gem is highly lustrous and sharply struck with brilliant, satiny nickel-gray surfaces. Census: 24 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

385

1882 5C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Excellent striking definition is one of several assets for this Premium Gem. Impressive preservation is another, and the swirling gold-tinged luster on each side completes the visual appeal. Population: 71 in 66, 4 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

386

1883 5C MS66 PCGS. A crisply struck final-year example that shows flashy luster and minimal patina. Philadelphia struck fewer than 1.5 million Shield nickels before the transition to the Liberty design. PCGS has graded just nine finer representatives (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

387

1883 5C MS66 PCGS. This outstanding Shield nickel is boldly struck, and displays highly lustrous, marvelously preserved surfaces. A streak of light tan color runs across the reverse. PCGS has graded nine finer examples (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Shield Nickels

388

1866 5C Rays PR65 PCGS. It was long believed that the mintage of 1866 Rays nickels was 125 or so, a number that Breen linked to the number of silver proof sets. However, it is clear now that far more were struck. The 2010 edition of the Guide Book indicates a mintage of 600+ proofs. Nevertheless, this is an important first-year proof. The surfaces are nearly brilliant with just the slightest overlay of ice-blue patina. The devices are noticeably contrasted against the brightly reflective fields, but the Cameo appellation was not give on these first-generation PCGS holders. The center reverse shows slight porosity, a common problem on early nickel products. Population: 85 in 65, 42 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

389

1866 5C Rays PR65 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Outstanding eye appeal for this first-year five cent nickel issue. The fields are profoundly reflective with just a suggestion of golden color, and considerable frost over the silver-white devices fuels the impressive contrast. Each side shows a handful of planchet flaws but no significant post-striking defects. Population: 24 in 65 Cameo, 32 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

390

1867 5C No Rays PR64 Cameo NGC. The first of the No Rays design, this near-Gem Cameo proof has sensational eye appeal for the grade. Both sides are fully brilliant with no evidence of toning. The design details are sharp, and the surfaces are exceptional. Census: 14 in 64 Cameo, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

391

1867 5C No Rays PR65 Cameo PCGS. Reverse IIa. A lightly toned and well struck Gem that is devoid of contact but has a few minute gray flecks. Introductory year of the No Rays subtype. Population: 30 in 65 Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2003), lot 6020, which realized $2,530; Portland Signature (Heritage, 3/2004), lot 5332, which realized $2,875.(Registry values: N2998)

392

1867 5C No Rays PR65 Cameo PCGS. A veneer of delicate golden-brown and purple assumes slightly deeper hues on the reverse of this Gem Cameo. Exquisitely struck throughout and minimally marked. A squiggly lint mark is evident on the upper reverse. Population: 30 in 65 Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

393

1867 5C No Rays PR66 Cameo NGC. Reverse IIa. Excellent striking definition with hints of nickel-blue patina over the gleaming mirrors. A great specimen of this initial No Rays proof Shield nickel issue, carefully preserved with powerful eye appeal. Census: 11 in 66 Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

394

1868 5C PR67 Cameo NGC. Fantastically reflective fields and distinctly contrasted, mildly frosted devices combine for immense eye appeal on this sharp Superb Gem proof. Both sides are virtually untoned, save for a few small dots of sage toning on and close to the rims. Census: 3 in 67 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

395

1908-D $10 Motto MS65 PCGS Secure. A whisper of peach patina visits the pale nickel-gray surfaces. This Premium Gem proof is well-defined overall, though a few of the reverse stars show a degree of softness. Census: 34 in 66, 4 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

396

1871 5C PR66 PCGS. CAC. Though the reflectivity is minor on this Premium Gem, the strike is sharp, an unequivocal sign of this coin's proof status. Minimally toned and carefully preserved. Population: 25 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

397

1873 5C Closed 3 PR65 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Outstanding sharpness and reflectivity with minimal patina. The moderate frost over the devices leads to easily appreciable contrast. Population: 24 in 65 Cameo, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

398

1875 5C PR65 Cameo PCGS. CAC. This is one of the scarce years in the Shield nickel series, and the present piece is a lovely Gem with brilliant nickel-gray surfaces, fully mirrored fields, and lustrous devices. Population: 18 in 65 Cameo, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

399

1876 5C PR66 Cameo NGC. A lovely Premium Gem with brilliant light-gray surfaces and hints of champagne toning on both sides. Few examples of this Centennial issue can match the present piece for its overall quality and eye appeal. Census: 27 in 66 Cameo, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

400

1877 5C PR65 PCGS. Unlike some 1877 and 1878 nickels, this example displays deeply reflective proof mirrors. The devices are also moderately frosted, but not enough to warrant a Cameo designation. Lightly toned and well-balanced from side to side. PCGS has only certified 32 finer non-cameo examples of this proof-only issue (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

401

1877 5C PR65 Ultra Cameo NGC. This low-mintage proof-only issue is the key date in the Shield nickel series. This Gem displays a fully brilliant appearance and notable deep cameo contrast. Well cared-for surfaces exhibit boldly struck design features. Census: 2 in 65 Ultra Cameo, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P3)

402

1878 5C PR61 PCGS. CAC. Strongly detailed for this proof-only issue. A candidate for a significantly higher grade if not for a handful of old pinscratches in the blue-gray fields.(Registry values: N991)

403

1878 5C PR65 PCGS. CAC. A proof only issue from a mintage of 2,350 coins. This Gem is housed in an older PCGS holder, and like many, has satiny nickel-gray luster rather than the expected proof mirrors. Both sides have tinges of peripheral gold.(Registry values: N991)

404

1878 5C PR66 Cameo PCGS. The main draw for the 1878 Shield nickel is its limited availability of only 2,350 pieces, all of which were proofs. Their quality is variable, however, and in the past some have even been listed as business strikes. This is one of the better-produced examples, and it exhibits bright, sparkling fields on each side. The devices display mint frost that is sufficient to give the piece a pronounced cameo effect. Both obverse and reverse are coated in a light layer of reddish-golden patina, but the cameo contrast is evident through the light toning. Population: 18 in 66 Cameo, 3 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2)

405

1882 5C PR65 Deep Cameo PCGS. Only a few tiny spots and even smaller abrasions prevent a higher grade to this gorgeous Deep Cameo proof. Both sides have fully defined design motifs, with lustrous devices and deeply mirrored fields. Population: 1 in 65 Deep Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

Liberty Nickels

406

1884 5C MS65 NGC. A fully struck Gem that possesses coruscating luster and medium golden-brown toning. A magnificently preserved representative of this early and scarcer date. Census: 67 in 65, 16 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

407

1885 5C VF35 NGC. CAC. A slate-gray example of this low mintage date, which is missing from countless Liberty nickel folders and thus is present on many want lists. All letters in LIBERTY are bold except for the I, which is faint but complete.(Registry values: N991)

408

1885 5C VF35 PCGS. Predominantly stone-gray, although the peripheries display glimpses of charcoal patina. LIBERTY is sharp, and no abrasions are obvious. A low mintage key date.(Registry values: N991)

409

1885 5C MS62 PCGS. The key date of the business strike Liberty nickel series, desirable in all grades but a better value in Mint State. This lustrous representative is draped in dove-gray and autumn-gold toning. The strike is exemplary, particularly on the often-mushy left ear of corn. The obverse is remarkably free from contact.(Registry values: N1793)

410

1885 5C MS62 PCGS. CAC. A delightful Mint State example of this extremely important key date issue, an underappreciated rarity in the Liberty nickel series. There is no doubt that current population data is inflated by proofs that were certified as Mint State in years gone by. This piece is a true, unquestioned Mint State example that will see considerable bidding activity.(Registry values: N1793)

411

1885 5C MS64 NGC. Golden-gray lustrous surfaces are imbued with traces of soft bluish-violet and exhibit sharply struck design features, including the often-weak corn ear left of the bow knot. A couple of minor marks are undisturbing. A pleasing and highly desirable key date issue. Census: 60 in 64, 37 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

412

1886 5C MS62 NGC. One of the key dates to the Liberty Head nickel series. The nickel-gray surfaces of this piece display occasional traces of deeper gray and tan. Generally well struck save for softness left of the bow knot. Moderate planchet laminations are visible on the left obverse rim, and verdigris is seen on the reverse edge at 9:00.(Registry values: N991)

413

1886 5C MS64 PCGS. The lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem display soft gold and violet patina that is somewhat more extensive and deeper on the obverse. This is a well struck piece that exhibits good detail even on the elements immediately left of the bow knot, areas that are often weak. A darker toning spot occurs to the lower right of the bow knot. Population: 86 in 64, 39 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

414

1890 5C MS65 PCGS. CAC. The stars on the obverse are boldly impressed and the luster is radiant. A wonderful Gem with no individually mentionable abrasions on the smooth orange-rose surfaces. Population: 42 in 65, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

415

1890 5C MS65 PCGS. A fully lustrous Gem with outstanding light gray surfaces and brilliant mint frost. Splashes of faint gold toning are just beginning to appear on both sides. the strike is acceptable, although a few stars and wreath elements are weak. Population: 42 in 65, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

416

1890 5C MS65 NGC. This pleasing Gem is boldly detailed. The obverse has gold toning with a few tiny carbon flecks and splashes of lilac. The reverse has hints of champagne and blue toning over light gray surfaces. Both sides are frosty and fully brilliant. Census: 38 in 65, 12 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

417

1895 5C MS65 NGC. This sharply defined Gem has frosty nickel-gray luster with faint gold and iridescent toning on each side. The surfaces are exceptional, despite a few planchet flakes. There are no post-mint abrasions of any consequence. Census: 39 in 65, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

418

1900 5C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Lustrous grayish-tan surfaces exhibit sharply struck design motifs. A couple of light peripheral cracks are visible on the reverse. Population: 40 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

419

1902 5C MS66 NGC. CAC. Boldly lustrous with elegant toning that ranges from peach to violet and lavender-blue. Softly struck at the margins but immensely appealing for its Premium Gem grade. Census: 32 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

420

1902 5C MS66 NGC. Rich peach and pink shadings are layered over soft pearl-gray luster. Minor spotting is noted on the central reverse. Soft striking on certain stars and the lower wreath, but the definition is solid elsewhere. Census: 32 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

421

1903 5C MS66 PCGS. The surfaces possess uniform satiny luster, exceptional for this heavily minted nickel issue. A bright, essentially untoned appearance enhances the eye appeal, though a number of peripheral design elements show a degree of softness. Population: 74 in 66, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

422

1903 5C MS66 PCGS. Light pink and peach-gold toning has settled over satiny luster, with glints of pearl-gray peeking through. Well struck overall and carefully preserved. PCGS has graded a mere two finer pieces (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

423

1911 5C MS66 PCGS. A well struck and impressively lustrous Premium Gem. Both sides offer light golden patina with peach and rose accents, though a light fingerprint is present in the left obverse field. Population: 33 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

424

1912-D 5C MS66 NGC. The 1912-D Liberty Head nickel is surprisingly difficult to locate in the better grades of Mint State, in spite of its high mintage. The issue is also popular as the only Liberty Head nickel from the Denver Mint. Lovely, iridescent shades of green, lavender and crimson toning enhance both sides of this exquisite specimen. The strike is sharp, with only slight weakness on Liberty's curls and the left ear of corn, as often seen on this issue. Census: 25 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

425

1912-S 5C MS64 PCGS. Fully lustrous beneath a moderate coating of silver-rose patina on the obverse and orange and violet coloration on the reverse. The strike, while not absolutely full, is decent, and the surfaces display only two or three minor contact marks that limit the grade. A nice example of this much scarcer date.(Registry values: N1793)

426

1912-S 5C MS64 NGC. The lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem display soft gray patination and exhibit well struck design elements, except for the usual softness in the features left of the bow knot. A few minute marks prevent Gem classification. An important key date issue.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

427

1912-S 5C MS64 PCGS. An attractive blend of violet, ice-blue, lavender, gold, and greenish-tan patina adorns the lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem. Sharply struck design features complement the beautiful coloration, with only the left corn ear showing minor softness. Devoid of mentionable contact marks. One of three keys to the always-popular Liberty nickel series with a mintage of only 238,000 pieces.(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Liberty Nickels

428

1883 5C No Cents PR66 Cameo NGC. The initial Liberty Head nickel represents a major engraving blunder at the Mint in 1883, with the word CENTS entirely absent. The omission was soon corrected, but created a desirable one-year subtype of the design. Here is a lovely Premium Gem with excellent contrast and impressive light blue and gold toning on both sides. Census: 59 in 66 Cameo, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

429

1883 5C With Cents PR67 ★ NGC. Bold design motifs and gorgeous toning are the hallmarks of this Superb Gem proof. Both sides have slight contrast, although insufficient for the Cameo designation. Census: 3 in 67 ★ , 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

430

1884 5C PR64 NGC. Both sides are fully mirrored with vibrant gold and iridescent toning. Although with the technical merits of a finer grade, the streaky dark toning on the obverse has limited the grade.(Registry values: N491)

431

1885 5C PR66 NGC. Pale blue toning at the centers gives way to light green, lemon, and violet near the borders on this lovely Premium Gem proof. Both sides have boldly detailed design motifs. This is an important offering with exceptional eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

432

1886 5C PR65 Cameo NGC. Exceptional contrast is visible on both sides of this delightful Gem proof, with rainbow toning to heighten its aesthetic desirability. Census: 13 in 65 Cameo, 26 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

433

1887 5C PR66 NGC. An incredible Premium Gem with lavender and iridescent toning on both sides. This sensational piece will make a nice addition to a high quality collection of proof Liberty nickels. Census: 44 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

434

1888 5C PR65 ★ NGC. The central obverse has delicate lilac toning, with a frame of rainbow iridescence. Similar lilac toning appears over almost all of the reverse, with delicate champagne at the lower right. A splendid Gem proof.(Registry values: N991)

435

1889 5C PR67 NGC. An amazing Superb Gem with noticeable contrast between the fields and devices. Both sides have delicate blue, violet, and yellow toning. Census: 17 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

436

1890 5C PR65 NGC. A mostly brilliant Gem proof with hints of light champagne toning on each side. This pleasing piece will make a nice addition to a specialized collection of Liberty nickels, a collection of design types, or an 1890 proof set.(Registry values: N991)

437

1891 5C PR65 ★ Cameo NGC. Close examination reveals a few lint marks and tiny contact marks that prevent a higher grade. Overall, this Gem Cameo proof is an exquisite piece with pale blue, light green, and vibrant gold toning.(Registry values: N991)

438

1892 5C PR63 NGC. Champagne, blue, and gold toning on the obverse, along with pale blue and champagne toning on the reverse, blend together to create amazing eye appeal on this lower numerical grade proof. A few faint hairlines are mostly hidden beneath the toning.(Registry values: N491)

439

1893 5C PR65 ★ NGC. An incredible Gem proof with the coveted star designation, this piece has deeply mirrored fields and satiny devices. Both sides are primarily champagne toned, with peripheral iridescent accents.(Registry values: N991)

440

1894 5C PR67 ★ NGC. This incredible Superb Gem proof, one of the finest 1894 proof nickels we have seen, presents vibrant gold toning at the centers, with blue and amber near the borders. Census: 1 in 67 ★ , 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

441

1895 5C PR63 ★ NGC. The NGC ★ designation is usually found on higher grade coins, so when a Select proof receives that designation, it is truly a special coin. This beauty has gold toning at the centers, with ice-blue and iridescent toning near the peripheries.(Registry values: N491)

442

1896 5C PR66 ★ NGC. Like many of the proof Liberty nickels in the current sale, this piece has noticeable cameo contrast despite the lack of an NGC Cameo designation. However, they did provide the coveted ★ designation to this Premium Gem. Both sides are attractively toned with light blue at the centers, gradually changing to rainbow iridescence near the borders. Census: 1 in 66 ★ , 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

443

1897 5C PR66 NGC. This amazing Premium Gem proof has ice-blue toning at the centers, with rings of lemon, rose, violet, green, and blue toning on each side. The satiny devices are nicely detailed and contrast well with the mirrored fields. Census: 57 in 66, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

444

1898 5C PR66 NGC. This Premium Gem proof has obvious cameo contrast on the obverse, with lighter contrast on the reverse. The proof surfaces are clearly visible through the lovely champagne and iridescent toning. Census: 44 in 66, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

445

1899 5C PR67 ★ NGC. A stunning Superb Gem proof, and the only PR67 example to carry the important ★ designation for its excellent quality. This piece is effectively the single finest certified 1899 proof nickel. Both sides have deeply mirrored fields with lustrous and sharply defined devices, all beneath impressive rainbow toning.(Registry values: N1793)

446

1900 5C PR66 NGC. A delightful Premium Gem with delicate champagne, light yellow, and pale blue toning over deeply mirrored fields. The sharply defined devices play against the fields to create attractive cameo contrast.(Registry values: N991)

447

1901 5C PR67 ★ NGC. Both sides have sharply defined and lustrous design motifs with deeply mirrored fields beneath splendid lilac, pale blue, and light yellow toning. Census: 1 in 67 ★ , 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

448

1902 5C PR64 ★ NGC. The NGC ★ designation is typically reserved for coins in higher numerical grades, but this near-Gem proof has the eye appeal of a higher grade. That grade is limited due to a few faint hairlines beneath the delicate rainbow toning.(Registry values: N491)

449

1903 5C PR67 ★ NGC. Ice-blue, violet, and light gold toning combine to create an incredible presentation on this Superb Gem proof. Both sides have sharp and lustrous design details, with fully mirrored fields. Here is a remarkable piece with few peers. Census: 3 in 67 ★ , 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

450

1904 5C PR65 NGC. An incredible Gem proof, this nickel has noticeable contrast, despite the lack of a Cameo designation. It has exceptional eye appeal resulting from the blend of delicate gold, violet, blue, and amber toning.(Registry values: N991)

451

1905 5C PR64 NGC. A splash of deeper violet at the upper left obverse accompanies the pale gold, violet, and ice-blue toning of this near-Gem proof.(Registry values: N491)

452

1906 5C PR65 NGC. A lovely Gem, this proof exhibits rainbow iridescence over glittering proof surfaces with fully mirrored fields and lustrous, sharply defined design motifs.(Registry values: N991)

453

1907 5C PR67 ★ NGC. In our opinion, this sensational Superb Gem proof should be assigned the Cameo designation for its obvious contrast beneath the iridescent toning. The surfaces are pristine, with fully mirrored fields and satiny devices. Both sides have lovely gold toning at the center, surrounded by rings of rainbow colors. Census: 3 in 67 ★ , 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

454

1908 5C PR68 ★ NGC. An absolutely stunning Superb Gem proof, this piece has "album-style" toning with concentric rings of rainbow colors extend from the border toward the center on each side. NGC has only certified three PR68 examples of this date, with none finer (2/10), and the present specimen is the only one that has also been awarded the coveted ★ designation.(Registry values: N4719)

455

1909 5C PR67 ★ NGC. Here is a sensational Superb Gem proof with vibrant lemon-yellow toning near the borders, blended with ice-blue, pale violet, and iridescent central hues. Here is an excellent opportunity to acquire an amazing 1909 nickel. Census: 8 in 67 ★ , 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

456

1910 5C PR64 NGC. A pleasing Choice proof with attractive rainbow toning. The fully mirrored fields contrast nicely with the satiny devices.(Registry values: N491)

457

1911 5C PR65 NGC. A sharply struck, satiny Gem proof with pale gold toning over nickel-gray surfaces. Considerable contrast is noted on both sides, although the Cameo designation is absent.(Registry values: N991)

458

1912 5C PR60 NGC. Lightly hairlines beneath pale gold toning.(Registry values: N491)

459

Complete Set of Proof Liberty Nickels 1883-1912 PR65 NGC. A complete set of proof Liberty nickels from 1883 to 1912, including both the No Cents and With Cents varieties for the former year, all graded PR65 by NGC. Toning is primarily gold-orange or olive, ranging in intensity from a thin coat over otherwise nickel-gray surfaces to a deep and dusky layer. Blue or lavender elements also appear on a number of pieces.

460

1883 5C No Cents PR66 Cameo PCGS. A gleaming Cameo Premium Gem proof of this one-year-only design type. Both sides are minimally toned with easily appreciated contrast. Population: 55 in 66, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

461

1883 5C With Cents PR66 Cameo PCGS. CAC. A strongly contrasted specimen of this first With CENTS Liberty nickel issue. Reflectivity is outstanding, and toning is minimal. Population: 23 in 66 Cameo, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

462

1885 5C PR64 NGC. This amazing gold toned near-Gem proof has exceptional eye appeal, with deeply mirrored fields beneath the lovely toning. Obvious cameo contrast is evident, although the toning has prevented a Cameo designation from NGC.(Registry values: N991)

463

1885 5C PR65 NGC. The key date Liberty nickel, with proofs always in demand due to the rarity of business strikes. This Gem proof has a trace of champagne and rose toning over fully brilliant light gray surfaces. Scattered carbon flecks prevent a higher grade.(Registry values: N1793)

464

1885 5C PR65 Cameo NGC. This Gem is a strongly contrasted, no-questions proof from an issue made famous by its association with a low-mintage business strike date. Dappled golden toning elements visit the obverse of this otherwise minimally patinated piece. Census: 25 in 65 Cameo, 42 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

465

1886 5C PR66 NGC. Soft sky-blue, yellow-gold, and lavender patina adheres to the well-preserved surfaces of this lovely Premium Gem. A decisive strike emboldens the design elements.(Registry values: N991)

466

1886 5C PR67 NGC. A lustrous and virtually brilliant Superb Gem. The design elements are reproduced on each side with exemplary proof sharpness. A nearly imperceptible lintmark resides between stars 7 and 8, but post-strike imperfections are absent. Census: 18 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

467

1888 5C PR67 NGC. Excellent reflectivity combined with a measure of cartwheel luster and a touch of frost over the devices. A carefully preserved Superb Gem, largely nickel-white with a touch of mint-green. Census: 11 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

468

1893 5C PR67 Cameo NGC. CAC. From a proof mintage of 2,195 pieces, the present coin is a virtually flawless Superb Gem Cameo. Deeply mirrored fields create a stunning black-on-white cameo appearance with the pearl-white devices. The contrast is so vivid that it makes one wonder what more must be necessary to achieve an Ultra Cameo designation from NGC. Regardless of the answer, this spectacular piece would make an outstanding addition to any collection. Fully struck with only a couple of microscopic blemishes. NGC and PCGS report a combined 17 pieces in PR67 Cameo, and neither has certified any coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

469

1893 5C PR66 Ultra Cameo NGC. The essentially untoned surfaces of this Premium Gem exhibit excellent field-device contrast and are impeccably preserved. A well executed strike leaves razor-sharp definition on the design motifs, including completeness on the elements immediately left of the bowknot. Census: 2 in 66 Ultra Cameo, 1 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2)

470

1894 5C PR66 Cameo PCGS. A veil of pale gold color visits each side of this gorgeous nickel. Exquisitely struck and virtually blemish-free. The devices offer sharp contrast with the mirrored fields. Population: 13 in 66 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

471

1898 5C PR66 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Profoundly mirrored fields with lightly frosted devices that supply remarkable contrast in context. Minimally toned aside from a stark band of gold-orange toning at the center-right obverse that has a faint echo on the reverse. Population: 13 in 66 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

472

1909 5C PR67 PCGS. Liquid peach and orange tints float across the surfaces of this exquisitely preserved specimen. This sharply struck beauty is housed in a green label holder. Population: 34 in 67, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

473

1909 5C PR68 NGC. Soft sky-blue, violet, and gold patination runs over the immaculately preserved surfaces of this wonderful Superb Gem, and a well executed strike imparts much better detail to the devices than ordinarily seen on this issue. The only exception is the typical softness in the left corn ear. Strong field-motif contrast is apparent, especially on the obverse. Census: 7 in 68, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

474

1912 5C PR65 PCGS. Here is an amazing Gem proof in a first generation PCGS holder with exceptional eye appeal. Both sides have glittering mirrored fields surrounding lustrous devices. A hint of delicate gold toning adds to the overall appearance.(Registry values: N991)

Buffalo Nickels

475

1913 5C Type One MS67 PCGS. Soft violet and champagne-gold patination envelops the lustrous surfaces of this attractive Superb Gem. Well struck and impeccably preserved.(Registry values: N991)

476

1913-D 5C Type One MS67 PCGS. CAC. Highly lustrous surfaces display whispers of gold patina imbued with traces of powder-blue on the obverse. A decisive strike leaves strong detail on the design features, and close examination reveals no mentionable marks. Great overall eye appeal. Population: 46 in 67, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

477

1913-S 5C Type Two MS64 NGC. Light gold toning is joined by by splashes of violet on the obverse. Generally well struck and minimally abraded.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

478

1914-D 5C MS65 ANACS. Rich gold toning enhances the brilliant gray surfaces of this Gem '14-D Buffalo. Both sides have excellent design definition. The reverse is slightly deeper hued than the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

479

1914-S 5C MS65 PCGS. This sharply defined Gem has satiny light gray luster with brilliant surfaces and hints of iridescence on each side. Rarely is a finer example encountered, with just 30 finer PCGS certified pieces. Here is an excellent piece for an advanced Buffalo collection.(Registry values: N1793)

480

1915-D 5C MS65 NGC. Whispers of ice-blue and champagne-gold visit the radiantly lustrous surfaces of this sharply struck Gem. Tiny flecks pepper both sides.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

481

1915-S 5C MS65 PCGS. Soft rainbow toning graces the lustrous surfaces of this Gem S-mint. The design elements are sharply struck, including the braid, horn, and bison's head. Well preserved surfaces reveal no contact marks or spots worthy of note. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

482

1916 5C Doubled Die Obverse VG8 NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-016. Prominent die doubling is evident on the 9 and 6 in the date, and all four date digits are apparent. An unmarked steel-gray representative that retains some device definition. The key to a Guide Book collection of Buffalo nickels, rarer than the also famous 1918/7-D.(Registry values: N1)

483

1916 5C Doubled Die Obverse XF40 PCGS. CAC. FS-101, formerly FS-016. While the date area's doubling is most famous on this Guide Book variety, the profile, hair ribbon, and the feathers at the back of the head are also strongly duplicated. As strong as this doubled die is, it was little-publicized until multiple decades after its release, unlike the instantly famous 1955 doubled die cent, often compared to this variety for the strength of the doubling.
This XF survivor is above the curve in terms of preservation, with the date area still clear and the bison's horn fully intact. Though the high points show plain wear, most notably on the bison's shoulder and hipbone, the sage and peach-gray surfaces remain luminous. Minimally marked for the grade with excellent eye appeal. For the variety, Population: 7 in 40, 52 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

484

1916-D 5C MS65 PCGS. Housed in a green-label PCGS holder, this Gem 1916-D nickel is fully brilliant and sharply detailed, with slight weakness over the fore leg. Both sides have light gold toning. Here is an excellent example, with only 11 finer PCGS certified pieces.(Registry values: N1793)

485

1917-S 5C MS64 PCGS. Seldom does any S-Mint Buffalo nickel have the incredible degree of design definition that appears on this piece. The satiny surfaces are slightly subdued, perhaps the reason that the grade was limited.(Registry values: N1793)

486

1918-D 5C MS63 NGC. Light golden-gray patina rests on the softly lustrous surfaces of the select D-mint specimen. Well defined and revealing just a few minute marks and flecks.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

487

1918-D 5C MS64 PCGS. Uncommonly strong luster for this underrated D-mint issue, frosty nickel-white with a touch of peach toning. Great eye appeal for the near-Gem designation.(Registry values: N1793)

488

1918-D 5C MS65 NGC. A delightful MS65 representative of this challenging Denver issue, delicately toned peach and gold at the margins with captivating nickel-blue centers. The smooth surfaces offer attractive luster, and the overall level of detail is above-average. Census: 31 in 65, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

489

1918/7-D 5C Good 6 PCGS. CAC. FS-101, formerly FS-016.5. Though well worn, this nickel has a clear date, and thus a clear overdate. Little else matters on this pearl-gray piece, which shows gold accents and the nub of a horn on the reverse.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1)

490

1918/7-D 5C Good 6 PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-016.5. Medium-gray overall with suggestions of gold and charcoal toward the margins. The overdate is clear enough to be readily identified.(Registry values: N1)

491

1918/7-D 5C VG8 PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-016.5. A pleasing Very Good example of the Guide Book variety. Lightly abraded nickel-gray and slate surfaces show considerable wear, yet the date, particularly the all-important last digit, is clear.(Registry values: N1)

492

1918/7-D 5C VG8 PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-016.5. The underdigit 7 is visible as thickness at the top and throughout the downstroke of the 8 in the date. All legends are sharp on this stone-gray key date nickel. Certified in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1)

493

1918/7-D 5C AU53 NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-016.5. Some coin collectors (and the occasional numismatist who should know better) believe that the so-called "wartime overdates"--the 1918/7-D Buffalo and 1943/2-P Jefferson nickels, the 1942/1-P and D Mercury dimes, the 1918/7-S Standing Liberty quarters--are the result of reengraving, a digit for the later year over that of the earlier--as was actually done at the Mint from the late 19th century until around 1900. But the real result is a dual-hub error, in which two working hubs (raised surface) with differing final digits were mixed up between annealings or work-hardenings of a single working die (incuse surface). This is the source of the overdates from the early to middle 20th century. the same phenomenon was also responsible for the 1960 Large Date over Small Date and Small Date over Large Date cents.
Such occurrences are now all but impossible. Modern Mint technology employs a system of "indexing keyways" or notches on the perimeters of working hubs and dies, to prevent them from mating together incorrectly. The keying system is changed every year to prevent incorrect hubs and dies from being used or combined accidentally.
Such technology was not in place in 1918, however, which permitted the creation of this famous Denver overdate. Both sides of the AU53 representative offered here are sharply detailed, aside from the worn and slightly weak high points. Both sides are richly toned gunmetal-gray with aspects of violet and gold, and soft luster filters through. A noteworthy coin in all respects.(Registry values: N4719)

494

1918-S 5C MS64 PCGS. A weak strike at the centers is typical of nearly every surviving 1918-S nickel. This lovely near-Gem example would be a nice addition to nearly any collection, with blue-gray surfaces, hints of iridescent toning, and satiny luster. PCGS has only certified 30 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

495

1918-S 5C MS64 NGC. Vibrant luster emanates from both sides of this near-Gem S-mint and a well directed strike leaves strong detail on the design elements. Splashes of ice-blue and golden-brown run over each face. A few minute marks preclude Gem status. NGC has seen only 16 examples finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

496

1919-D 5C MS64 PCGS. Blended pearl-gray and straw-gold enrich this satiny and unabraded near-Gem. The date, mintmark, and bison's head are bold, while the centers show the expected moderate incompleteness. Encapsulated in a green label holder.
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2004), lot 5363, which realized $2,185.(Registry values: N1793)

497

1919-D 5C MS64 PCGS. CAC. Pleasingly preserved for an issue that becomes elusive above Select Mint State. Light golden overtones grace lustrous pearl-gray surfaces. The strike is uncommonly sharp, particularly on the braid and the bison's head. PCGS has certified just 68 finer examples (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

498

1920-D 5C MS64 NGC. Solidly struck with above-average luster and quality. The key to this near-Gem is the patina, deep peach and magenta with lighter green-gold at the centers.(Registry values: N1793)

499

1920-S 5C MS63 PCGS. Soft violet, lavender, and orange patination visits the lustrous surfaces of this Select Buffalo nickel. Above-average definition is apparent on the obverse, though the reverse reveals the usual softness.(Registry values: N1793)

500

1920-S 5C MS63 PCGS. CAC. Quicksilver luster enlivens nickel-gray surfaces that show gold and orange elements close to the rims. Well struck with few significant abrasions.(Registry values: N1793)

501

1921-S 5C MS64 ANACS. The 1921-S is among the most difficult Buffalo nickel issues. It is a strike rarity, as with many other mintmarked nickels from 1917-26. The challenge of finding a pleasing piece is often compounded by surface problems such as planchet flaws, die cracks, grease stains, and heavy metal flow--all the result of hurried planchet preparation in the Mint. This coin is refreshingly free from any of those planchet problems. It is also better struck than other examples we have seen of this issue. Both sides are toned a pleasing lilac-rose coloration with bright underlying mint frost. A very attractive example of this scarce issue. In an old ANA cache holder.(Registry values: N2998)

502

1921-S 5C MS64 NGC. Medium intensity golden-gray patination is imbued with an occasional trace of lavender. The design features are generally well impressed save for softness on the bison's head. Devoid of significant marks. Extremely difficult to locate any finer.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

503

1921-S 5C MS65 NGC. The 1921-S has one of the lowest mintages of the Buffalo nickel series (1.557 million pieces). Potent luster endows both sides of this lovely Gem, each of which exhibits relatively sharp delineation. Light golden-gray patination displays hints of lilac and mint-green. Impeccably preserved and highly appealing. Census: 35 in 65, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

504

1924-S 5C AU53 PCGS. CAC. Dappled gold and sage tints drape this modestly worn 1924-S nickel. Though a soft strike has led to incompleteness on the horn and a weak shoulder, the ample remaining luster confirms the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

505

1924-S 5C MS64 NGC. Each side of this near-Gem displays some prooflike tendencies in the fields. Rich orange-gold, lavender, sky-blue, and mint-green patination adorns both faces, and a relatively strong strike delivers better-than-average definition to the design elements. Devoid of mentionable marks or spots.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

506

1926-S 5C MS64 NGC. Gem examples of the 1926-S Buffalo nickel are almost never seen in the marketplace, so for series fans, the near-Gem level is the best they can aspire to for this challenging issue. This is a silver-gray example with tinges of gold and pink. Muted mint luster proceeds from each side, a bit more prominently on the reverse, which also shows the typical worn state of the die. The horn is nevertheless full but incompletely detailed, and a part of a split tail shows. Some caramel and hazel toning streaks appear beneath the bison, adding to the generous appeal. NGC has certified only 11 specimens finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

507

1936-D 5C 3 1/2 Legs VF20 PCGS. CAC. FS-901, formerly FS-019. A midgrade representative of this increasingly popular "weakened foreleg" variety. The nickel-gray surfaces are surprisingly luminous beneath a measure of peach patina. Small marks are visible on the obverse, and the reverse shows a few abrasions on and near the bison's body. Population: 3 in 20, 31 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

508

1937-D 5C Three-Legged XF45 NGC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. Nickel-gray with gold accents and some darker gray around the devices. Contact marks are minimal on this Choice XF example.(Registry values: N991)

509

1937-D 5C Three-Legged XF45 PCGS. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. The bison's hip and hair display moderate wear, but the caramel-gold and gunmetal surfaces retain glimpses of luster. A lightly abraded example of this famous lapped die mint error.(Registry values: N991)

510

1937-D 5C Three-Legged XF45 ANACS. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. A Choice XF piece with orange and olive toning where luster remains. Devoid of relevant marks, and an impressive example of this well known Guide Book variety.(Registry values: N991)

511

1937-D 5C Three-Legged AU50 NGC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. Rich orange-gold overtones influence the dusky nickel-gray surfaces on this Three-Legged nickel. Light wear is present mostly on the high points.(Registry values: N991)

512

1937-D 5C Three-Legged AU55 NGC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. A Choice AU cream-gray and caramel-gold example of this popular die abrasion mint error. Unabraded and exemplary aside from a few minute flecks near the neck and mouth.(Registry values: N991)

513

1937-D 5C Three-Legged AU55 PCGS. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. Orange-gold and powder-blue embraces this lustrous and lightly circulated representative. A loupe locates the occasional unimportant abrasion, but the eye appeal is undeniable.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N991)

514

1937-D 5C Three-Legged AU58 PCGS. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. Light gray surfaces retain considerable luster, and are visited by speckles of olive-tan. A well-executed strike has left its mark on the design elements; in particular, the date, LIBERTY, the Indian's braid, the bison's tail, and the reverse peripheral lettering display sharp detail.(Registry values: N991)

515

1937-D 5C Three-Legged AU58 NGC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. Delicate olive-gold, lilac, and cream-gray toning drapes this shimmering and problem-free key date Borderline Uncirculated nickel. All diagnostics are present, such as the granular back leg of the bison.(Registry values: N991)

516

1937-D 5C Three-Legged AU58 NGC. CAC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. A tan-gray key date nickel with minimal wear on the bison's hipbone and on the tip of the tail. Impressively free from abrasions.(Registry values: N991)

517

1937-D 5C Three-Legged AU58 NGC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. Attractive autumn-gold and gunmetal-gray toning adorns this lustrous and minimally abraded Borderline Uncirculated key date nickel. The patient collector, armed with a strong loupe, will locate infrequent pinpoint carbon.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

518

1937-D 5C Three-Legged MS61 NGC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. A gunmetal-gray key date nickel that has shimmering luster and an absence of consequential marks. Encased in a former generation holder.(Registry values: N1793)

519

1937-D 5C Three-Legged MS62 NGC. CAC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. An appealing Mint State example of the collector favorite and perennial Guide Book entry. Gold and peach overtones visit light nickel-gray surfaces that are pleasingly lustrous but show quicksilver elements on the softly struck high points, such as the bison's shoulder. Still, a minimally abraded piece for the grade and decidedly attractive.(Registry values: N1793)

520

1937-D 5C Three-Legged MS64 PCGS. CAC. FS-901, formerly FS-020.2. A lustrous champagne-patinated example of this popular variety. A well executed strike imparts strong definition to the design elements, including LIBERTY, the horn, and tail. A few minuscule marks and flecks are all that stand in the way of a Gem designation.(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Buffalo Nickels

521

1913 5C Type One PR64 PCGS. CAC. A meticulous strike emboldens the design elements of this near-Gem proof, and soft gold color is slightly deeper in hue on the reverse. This nicely preserved piece is devoid of mentionable marks or carbon. All in all, excellent overall eye appeal, aptly recognized by the CAC green label.(Registry values: N1793)

522

1913 5C Type One PR65 PCGS. This Type One Buffalo nickel, an impressive Gem, is housed in an older green-label PCGS holder. It features full design definition with satiny surfaces beneath intense gold, yellow-green, and violet toning on both sides. Here is a remarkable example of the Type One design for the Buffalo enthusiast or type collector.(Registry values: N2998)

523

1914 5C PR64 NGC. This Buffalo nickel has the needle-sharp strike seen only on proofs of this widely collected type. Light to medium golden-brown and lime-green toning drapes both sides. Certified in a former generation holder.(Registry values: N1793)

524

1914 5C PR66 PCGS. CAC. Strong luster with a satiny texture glows beneath elegant blue and peach patina. This decisively detailed Premium Gem is carefully preserved with impressive eye appeal for a matte proof Buffalo nickel. PCGS has certified 75 finer specimens (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

525

1936 5C Type One--Satin Finish PR66 NGC. CAC. Golden patina is somewhat more extensive and deeper on the reverse of this Premium Gem. Exquisitely struck and preserved.(Registry values: N1793)

526

1936 5C Type One--Satin Finish PR67 PCGS. After an absence of nearly twenty years, proof production of Buffalo nickels resumed in 1936. This is an appropriately satiny Superb Gem that has an exemplary strike and attractive olive-green and caramel-gold patina.(Registry values: N1793)

527

1936 5C Type One--Satin Finish PR67 PCGS. The Satin Finish 1936 Buffalo nickels are similar to some business strikes, except the design definition is so much greater. This Superb Gem is an exceptional representative of the Type One proof coinage, with light gray surfaces and delicate iridescent toning.(Registry values: N1793)

528

1936 5C Type Two--Brilliant Finish PR64 PCGS. A veneer of champagne and violet coloration resides on the luminous surfaces of this exquisitely struck near-Gem proof. Devoid of mentionable marks or spots.(Registry values: N1793)

529

1936 5C Type Two--Brilliant Finish PR66 NGC. An intricately struck Premium Gem with flashy fields and a virtual absence of carbon. Caramel-gold toning is both consistent and light. An outstanding proof type coin.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

530

1936 5C Type Two--Brilliant Finish PR67 PCGS. A brilliant Superb Gem with deeply mirrored fields and sharply defined design motifs. This beauty has pale blue toning with splashes of champagne, slightly deeper on the reverse. Here is an outstanding representative with little need for improvement.(Registry values: N2998)

531

1937 5C PR64 NGC. Both sides of this champagne-gold near-Gem are splashed with bluish-violet in the centers. A scattering of trivial minuscule flecks preclude Gem status.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

532

1937 5C PR65 NGC. Apricot-gold and cream-gray shades dominate this crisply struck Gem. The fields are more satiny than reflective. Examination under magnification reveals a few pinpoint flecks. Encased in a prior generation holder.(Registry values: N991)

533

1937 5C PR66 NGC. Deeply mirrored fields exhibit a degree of contrast with the solidly impressed motifs of this Premium Gem. Whispers of orange-tan visit well preserved surfaces.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

534

1937 5C PR66 PCGS. Honey-gold overall with peripheral rose and olive tints. The final proof date of the type, although business strikes were coined in 1938 at Denver. Struck from widely rotated dies, and housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

535

1937 5C PR67 PCGS. Both sides of this amazing Superb Gem proof are fully brilliant with bright nickel-gray surfaces. The fields are deeply mirrored, while the devices have reflective luster. Even the closest microscopic examination fails to show any marks or spots of consequence. PCGS has only certified 11 finer examples of this proof issue (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

536

1937 5C PR67 NGC. Every aspect of this Superb Gem proof is outstanding, from its bold design definition, to the pristine surfaces, glittering mirrored fields, and lovely gold toning. Only a few tiny carbon flecks are evident under a glass on this impressive nickel. Here is an excellent opportunity for the Buffalo specialist, or proof coin enthusiast to acquire a sensational piece. NGC has only certified 39 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Jefferson Nickels

537

1939-D 5C Reverse of 1940 MS66 Full Steps PCGS. Both reverse hubs were used to create dies for the 1939-D Jefferson nickels, and neither variety is rare, but few can compare to this incredible Premium Gem. It is boldly detailed with five and a half steps. Lovely champagne toning provides excellent eye appeal. Population: 29 in 66 Full Steps, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

538

1944-P 5C MS67 5 Full Steps NGC. Shining surfaces range from pale gold-gray to rich orange on this important Superb Gem. Impressively preserved with solid definition on the steps of Monticello. Census: 10 in 67 Full Steps, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

539

1945-P 5C Doubled Die Reverse MS66 PCGS. FS-801, formerly FS-030. MONTICELLO and CENTS are strongly die doubled southeast. Pale sky-blue and gold adorn this lustrous and unblemished Gem. The steps are strong but not completely defined all the way across. This important Guide Book variety is seldom seen in such high grade. Population: 10 in 66, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1)

540

1946-D/D 5C MS66 Full Steps PCGS. FS-501, previously FS-031. The mintmark is dramatically repunched with the first punch inverted. A medley of yellow-green, pale violet, and light gray coloration adorns the highly lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem. A full strike gives completeness to all the design features, including fullness in the steps. Population: 14 in 66 Full Steps, 0 finer (1/10).

541

1955 5C MS66 5 Full Steps NGC. Peach and sage patina overall with subtle flickers of gold. A softly lustrous example with distinctly above-average detail, as seen on the steps of Monticello.(Registry values: P1)

SMS Jefferson Nickels

542

1966 5C SMS MS69 Cameo NGC. An absolutely stunning Superb Gem, this brilliant light gray piece has excellent contrast between the fields and devices. The obverse and reverse surfaces are entirely untoned. Incredible aesthetic appeal. Census: 1 in 69 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

543

1967 5C SMS MS69 Cameo NGC. The Special Mint Set coins of 1965, 1966, and 1967 (actually beginning in 1964) are rare and highly desired when they exhibit cameo contrast such as the present specimen. This lovely example has brilliant nickel-gray surfaces with light gold and iridescent toning on both sides. Census: 1 in 69 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

Proof Jefferson Nickels

544

1938 5C PR67 Cameo NGC. The wavy steps in Monticello are typical of the first hub used to create Jefferson nickel dies. This Superb Gem cameo proof has incredible eye appeal with pale champagne toning accompanying blue, violet, and iridescent toning. Census: 1 in 67 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

545

1940 5C Reverse of 1940 PR66 Cameo NGC. The straight, parallel steps of Monticello identify the Reverse of 1940, compared to the wavy steps on the Reverse of 1938. This lovely Premium Gem Cameo proof is fully brilliant with deep nickel-gray surfaces. In all grades, NGC has certified just five Cameo proof 1940 nickels, including a single PR64 Cameo and four PR66 Cameo pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

546

1942 5C Type One PR68 NGC. A melange of pale-blue, gold, violet, and crimson colors dominates both sides of this highly attractive Jefferson nickel. A couple of minor, insignificant ticks are noted on Jefferson's cheek and collar. Census: 9 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

547

1942-P 5C Type Two PR68 ★ NGC. This Type Two Wartime Jefferson nickel is an amazing piece with light amber and iridescent toning over fully mirrored fields. The devices are satiny, providing a hint of cameo contrast. Census: 5 in 68 ★ , 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

548

1953 5C Doubled Die Obverse PR69 Cameo NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-032.7. All of the letters of IN GOD WE TRUST along the left obverse border are doubled on this desirable variety. This immaculate specimen is among the finest that we have ever seen or handled. In fact, it is the only NGC example so graded, and tied with one PCGS specimen (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

549

1955 5C PR69 Ultra Cameo NGC. Here is an amazing Superb Gem, equal to the finest that has ever been certified. This piece has incredible field to device contrast with brilliant light gray surfaces. Census: 7 in 69 Ultra Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

550

1956 5C PR69 Ultra Cameo NGC. An absolutely sensational piece, this nearly perfect Jefferson nickel is fully brilliant with highly lustrous and frosty devices within a frame of deeply mirrored fields. There is no evidence of toning on either side. As one of just three similarly graded pieces, this Jefferson nickel is tied for the finest 1956 proof that NGC has ever certified (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

551

1957 5C PR68 Cameo PCGS. An exquisitely detailed Superb Gem that reveals just a few wisps of light tan color. Immaculately preserved, as expected. Population: 27 in 68 Cameo, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N208)

552

1971 5C No S PR68 Cameo NGC. A moderately contrasted example of this famous "No S" proof variety with light golden peripheral shadings framing virtually untoned centers. Impressive eye appeal. Census: 12 in 68 Cameo, 8 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1)

Session 2

Early Half Dimes

553

1795 H10C XF45 PCGS. V-2a, LM-3, R.5. The obverse has a diagonal bisecting die crack. This appealing Flowing Hair half dime combines dark steel and iridescent toning with sharp design features and hints of satiny luster. The sharpness is actually that of an AU coin, and this piece may have been reduced slightly in grade due to a few tiny surface marks on each side.(Registry values: P4)

554

1795 H10C MS61 NGC. V-3, LM-4, R.6. Ex: Ed Price. The Logan-McCloskey plate coin. Liberty has six hair curls at the back of her head, and star 15 is close to the dentils. On the reverse, there are two inner berries and one outer berry under the left (facing) wing. The Logan-McCloskey reference notes that this variety is difficult to obtain in any grade, and it is quite rare in Mint State.
This is a wonderful coin (which we feel is fully Mint State) that Ed Price bought out of a 1979 Bowers and Ruddy auction, where the cataloger described it as:

"1795 V-3. About Uncirculated-50, with original mint brilliance dulling slightly to gray in some areas. A splendid coin which has never been cleaned, dipped, or otherwise treated. The obverse portrait has a bold cameo-like appearance. Small eagle on reverse. A prize piece.
"From Harold P. Newlin's personal collection, Originally described in the Newlin Collection catalog as: 'A rare variety and in beautiful Uncirculated condition.' "

Newlin was, of course, an early, seminal researcher of half dimes, whose collection was sold in the 1880s. We would add that the piece shows full original luster on the high points, with glints of jade and pink in the central obverse and lower reverse along with small flatly struck areas in the center of each side. A couple of stray contact marks on Liberty's neck and in the right obverse field account for the grade. Nonetheless, as a rare early half dime variety with such a splendid pedigree, this is a coin that series specialists should pounce on gleefully when it comes to the auction podium.
Ex: Harold P. Newlin Collection (Bangs & Co., 4/1883); later, Bowers and Ruddy (11/1979), lot 227; Ed Price.(Registry values: P4)

555

1797 H10C 16 Stars MS62 NGC. Ex: Price/LM Plate. V-4, LM-2, R.4. The Logan-McCloskey plate coin. The first 7 in the date is small, while the second one is quite large. The stars are arranged 9 left and 7 right, and on the reverse there is no outside berry below the D of UNITED. A leaf is quite close beneath the first T of STATES.
The obverse die was first used on this die pairing, then subsequently used on the V-3, LM-3 marriage. On the first use here, extensive die clashing developed, most visible before Liberty's face and above her head. A die crack appears from the rim through star 8. The reverse also is extensively clashed--from the juncture of the top two leaves through the O(F), through and below TES, and above and left of the eagle's left (facing) wing--and cracked, most prominently from the rim down through E of UNITED. A small rim cud connects the dentils over ME.
This is a difficult variety that is seldom seen in Mint State. This piece has much delightful luster remaining on pinkish-gold surfaces. A couple of tiny dark spots and planchet voids are as made and undistracting, in any case, but helping to explain the grade. The centers are fairly weakly struck on each side, but there is little sign of post-strike contact on this fascinating and well-preserved coin.(Registry values: P6)

556

1803 H10C Large 8 MS62 NGC. V-2, LM-3, R.3. Attribution of 1803 half dimes is easy, with only two dies each known for obverse and reverse. The Large 8 obverse, with 3 rotated clockwise, narrows the choice to LM-2 or LM-3, while the reverse with a leaf joined to the left diagonal of A3 diagnoses the LM-3 pairing. Although this is the most available die marriage of the year, it is still elusive in the higher grades and conditionally rare in Mint State. This piece shows the strike a bit soft in the centers, with surfaces having mottled gray and deep blue toning. A shallow mark in the right obverse field out from stars 12 and 13 prevents an even higher grade. Census for both Large 8 varieties: 5 in 62, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7)

Bust Half Dimes

557

1831 H10C MS64 NGC. V-5, LM-5, R.1. A near-Gem example of this variety popular with type collectors, strongly lustrous beneath blue-green peripheral hues that yield to tan and silver in the centers. Well struck and attractive.(Registry values: N1793)

558

1831 H10C MS67 NGC. Ex: Eliasberg. V-5, LM-5, R.1. Walter Breen considered the present coin to be a proof. Given its intricate strike, frosty devices, and smooth, flashy fields, Breen's prognosis is understandable. Moderately toned pumpkin-gold and jade-green. Census: 14 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).
Ex: Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr. Collection (Bowers and Merena, 5/1996), lot 917.(Registry values: N4719)

Seated Half Dimes

559

1837 H10C No Stars, Large Date (Curl Top 1) MS65 PCGS. CAC. This precisely struck Gem has medium silver-gray and olive toning with glimpses of golden-brown near the obverse rim. Exceptionally smooth and shimmering with luster. The No Stars type was coined only dated 1837, aside from a small production struck at New Orleans in 1838.(Registry values: N2998)

560

1837 H10C No Stars, Large Date (Curl Top 1) MS66 NGC. The 1837 No Stars, Small Date half dime is an available issue in lower grades, but it is quite scarce at the Premium Gem level. The variety is distinguished by the shape of the 1 in the date, which has a flat top. Popular with type collectors and as a first date of issue. The unadorned obverse gives the issue a medallic quality, and the strike and flawless surfaces are all that can be asked of a 19th century coin.(Registry values: N2998)

561

1837 H10C No Stars, Small Date (Flat Top 1) MS65 NGC. Dramatic cobalt-blue, sun-gold, lavender, and peach-brown dominate this satiny and sharply impressed Gem. A strong loupe locates a few thin marks on the upper field of each side. The 1837 Seated dime is important for a complete design subtype collection, as stars were added to the obverse in 1838.(Registry values: P6)

562

1841 H10C MS66 NGC. Richly toned and impressively preserved for this earlier half dime issue. Deep blue-violet central toning gives way to lighter green and aqua at the borders. Census: 7 in 66, 5 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

563

1843 H10C MS65 PCGS. The partially prooflike fields of this Gem highlight the well struck devices at various angles. Both sides are nicely preserved. Population: 13 in 65, 10 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

564

1849-O H10C AU55 NGC. The obverse has deep gray in the fields, with lighter silver around the devices, matching the light silver reverse. Both sides show evidence of original mint luster. An important, low-mintage date, always in demand.(Registry values: N991)

565

1849-O H10C MS62 NGC. Softly struck at the margins but a decidedly pleasing example of this O-mint half dime issue. Blue, violet, and green-gold toning is layered over a lustrous silver base. Census: 5 in 62, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

566

1853 H10C Arrows MS65 PCGS. CAC. Dappled violet, blue, silver, and pink hues grace this Arrows half dime Gem. Pleasingly detailed with great luster under the toning. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 47 in 65, 37 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

567

1853 H10C Arrows MS66 NGC. A blend of yellow-green and violet coloration graces the lustrous surfaces of this well struck half dime. Mentionable marks are lacking. Census: 53 in 66, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

568

1854 H10C Arrows MS65 NGC. Ex: Eliasberg. A strongly lustrous and boldly defined example that hails from one of the all-time great collections. Champagne overtones grace the fields of this Arrows piece, struck from clashed dies. Census: 52 in 65, 20 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

569

1859 H10C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Well preserved powder-blue surfaces are splashed with reddish-gold and yield a degree of field-motif contrast. Nicely struck throughout. Population: 11 in 66, 11 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

570

1860 H10C Transitional MS62 NGC. Judd-267, Pollock-315, R.4. Long included in the pattern series, the transitional half dime is neither a pattern nor a regular issue. It was a curiosity struck by Mint Director James Ross Snowden as "trade bait" to enhance the Mint Collection. The old starred obverse by Anthony Paquet was paired with the new 1860 reverse. The result was a coin that lacked mention of the issuing authority, thus the sobriquet a "nationless" coin.
All transitional half dimes show a pronounced diagonal die scratch on the lower left portion of the rock. Although this piece was struck as a business strike, the fields are nicely mirrored and flash through the deep layers of gray, blue, and rose toning. The strike is irregular, and light hairlines are evident beneath the toning on each side. Census: 4 in 62, 46 finer (1/10).

571

1862 H10C MS65 PCGS. After specie payments were suspended in late 1860, the hoarding of gold and silver coins became widespread. However, obviously not all were exported or melted. More than a hundred Gems are known of this date with another hundred or so in higher grades, indicating numerous examples were set aside and never returned to circulation after the War was over. This is a splendidly preserved example with original surfaces. Both sides have deep, variegated scarlet and cobalt-blue toning with strong underlying mint luster. Both sides are die clashed, but it is more apparent on the obverse. The design elements are strongly struck throughout. Population: 68 in 65, 56 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

572

1862 H10C MS66 NGC. Light peach toning graces the centers of this otherwise silver-white Premium Gem. A well-defined coin, minimally marked but struck from strongly clashed dies. Census: 39 in 66, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

573

1862 H10C MS67 PCGS. Dazzling luster overwhelms the medium apricot and lilac patina. An intricately struck and nearly immaculate Superb Gem. The 1862 was the final Civil War half dime issue to exceed a mintage of 120,000 pieces. Once specie payments were suspended, fractional currency replaced silver coinage in circulation. Population: 17 in 67, 3 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

574

1865 H10C MS63 NGC. Cobalt-blue, golden-brown, lavender, and ocean-green patina run over the lustrous, sharply struck surfaces of this Select half dime. This is a well cared for piece. Census: 9 in 63, 28 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

575

1868 H10C MS66 PCGS. Deep forest-green and golden-brown toning invigorates this sharply struck and satiny Premium Gem. Examination with a powerful lens fails to locate any abrasions beneath the toning. A low mintage issue that has a production of 88,600 pieces. Population: 9 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

576

1873-S H10C MS66 NGC. Intricately struck and lustrous with exemplary surfaces and attractive rose-red and aquamarine patina. Housed in a former generation holder. Census: 6 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Seated Half Dimes

577

1858 H10C PR63 PCGS. Delicate gold, lavender, blue, and gray shadings embrace each side of this charming Select proof. Excellent strike and eye appeal for this issue with an uncertain but small mintage. Population: 20 in 63, 28 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

578

1859 H10C PR63 NGC. Vivid cherry-red and blue-green toning dominates unblemished well struck surfaces. 1859 is a single-year design subtype (patterns excluded) with hollow obverse stars and a slightly different seated Liberty. Certified in a prior generation holder. Just 800 proofs were struck.(Registry values: P4)

579

1859 H10C PR64 NGC. An attractive specimen of this early wide-release proof Seated half dime issue, minimally hairlined beneath deep violet and rose patina. Excellent strike and eye appeal.(Registry values: P4)

580

1859 H10C PR64 PCGS. Rich blue-green toning visits the margins, while the centers offer golden-yellow patina. Sharply struck with glittering luster and great eye appeal for the grade. Population: 62 in 64, 33 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

581

1867 H10C PR66 PCGS. This incredible Premium Gem is deeply toned in violet and cobalt-blue, with full cameo contrast visible through the toning. It is the lovely patina that prevents an actual Cameo designation. Population: 11 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

582

1867 H10C PR66 PCGS. Impressive reflectivity shines forcefully through uniform layers of aquamarine and golden-rose toning. There is considerable demand for proofs from this year, as a significant number of the already low business strike mintage of 8,000 pieces was melted. Population: 11 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

583

1867 H10C PR67 NGC. Dramatic emerald-blue, ruby-red, orange, and chestnut-gold toning consumes this flashy and unabraded Superb Gem. The strike is sharp save for the usual inexactness on the wreath opposite the left corner of Liberty's rock. A mere 625 proofs were struck, and business strikes were limited to 8,000 pieces. Census: 7 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

584

1867 H10C PR63 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Dappled blue and rose-violet hues appear at the borders of this moderately contrasted Select specimen. Well-defined and attractive despite minor hairlines. Population: 7 in 63 Cameo, 23 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P2)

585

1867 H10C PR66 Cameo NGC. Profoundly contrasted, though not strictly black-and-white save at deep angles. This carefully preserved Premium Gem owes much of its eye appeal to the rich frost over the sharply struck devices, though the mirrored fields also make a significant contribution. Census: 10 in 66 Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

586

1869 H10C PR67 ★ Cameo NGC. Mirrored fields and ice-white devices display dramatic contrast. A precisely struck and flawless Superb Gem. Fully reflective yet completely devoid of toning, a combination that doubtlessly inspired the Star designation. Just 600 proofs were struck. Census: 3 in 67 ★ Cameo, none finer with a Star designation (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

587

1871 H10C PR66 PCGS. Cobalt-blue, lavender, and magenta occupies the obverse, ceding to reddish-gold, sky-blue, and lavender on the reverse. Well preserved surfaces exhibit nicely defined design elements. Strong overall eye appeal. From a scant production of 960 proofs. Population: 14 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

588

1872 H10C PR67 NGC. Ex: P. Kaufman. A perfect combination of technical quality and eye appeal accounts for the desirability of this Superb Gem. Powder-blue and olive-green predominate, although the central reverse displays orange patina. Sparkling reflectivity is fully appreciable as the coin rotates under a light. Powerfully impressed, with no distractions. Census: 4 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).
Ex: Philip Kaufman Collection (Heritage, 5/2003), lot 5870, which realized $4,255.(Registry values: P1)

Early Dimes

589

1796 10C Good 4 PCGS. JR-1, R.3. The mint-made die break beneath star 1 facilitates attribution. Primarily cream-gray with deeper russet-brown and apple-green near the rims. Slightly wavy with several faint marks on the obverse center. First year of the rare two year type. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P7)

590

1796 10C VG8 PCGS. JR-4, R.4. LIBERTY is closely spaced, with ER quite close and TY touching at the top. The top of the 6 is near the bottom of the bust. On the reverse AME nearly touch, and the left branch has four berries, two inner and two outer. Medium gray and bluish-purple toning covers both sides, which are quite clean for a coin that has seen moderate to heavy circulation.(Registry values: P7)

591

1796 10C AU50 PCGS. JR-1, R.3. The JRCS reference notes this obverse characteristic for the JR-1: "Late strikes have arc-like crack in field before face and across throat to shoulder." This coin shows the aforementioned crack, though the state is more properly intermediate than late, since the die cud at star 1 on the obverse affects only two of the star's arms. This lightly circulated example has light to medium toning over still-lustrous surfaces, ranging from orange to gold, blue, and green. Central striking softness is typical for the die pair and hardly a distraction.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P7)

Bust Dimes

592

1814 10C Small Date MS62 NGC. JR-1, R.3. This satiny gunmetal-gray representative is smooth aside from a thin inconspicuous mark beneath the bust tip. The sole Small Date variety of the date, since the other four die pairings have a Large Date. As such, the Small Date carries a sizeable premium over JR-2, JR-3, and JR-4, but not JR-5, since that is the scarce STATESOF variety.(Registry values: N2998)

593

1829 10C Small 10C MS65 PCGS. JR-6, R.3. The obverse has a doubled denticle between stars 3 and 4, and the reverse has a small die break on the top edge of the shield below the first S. This lovely Gem has satiny luster with reflective silver surfaces and delicate champagne toning on each side. A splendid specimen.(Registry values: N4719)

594

1831 10C MS66 PCGS. CAC. JR-5, R.1. Navy-blue, golden-brown, and magenta embrace this satiny and crisply struck Premium Gem. Immaculate aside from a few unimportant ticks on the right obverse field. An important contribution to a high quality Capped Bust type set. Population: 6 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

595

1837 10C MS66 NGC. Ex: Pittman. JR-4, R.1. A bisecting obverse die crack between 12 and 5 o'clock identifies the variety. Variegated gold, magenta, teal, and blue toning covers the well preserved surfaces. Liberty's hair is a trifle soft, but the reverse is razor-sharp. An appealing example of this final-year issue. Census: 6 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: Barney Bluestone, 11/1943, sold for $2.50; John Jay Pittman Collection, Part One (David Akers, 10/1997), lot 577.(Registry values: N4719)

Seated Dimes

596

1838-O 10C No Stars AU58 PCGS. CAC. Just a hint of silver-gray toning over considerable frosty luster. This scarcer Liberty Seated dime is well-struck and virtually blemish-free.(Registry values: N1793)

597

1839 10C No Drapery MS64 PCGS. Soft violet and champagne-gold patina is joined by splashes of cobalt-blue on the reverse. Lustrous with well struck design features and minimally marked. Population: 31 in 64, 32 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

598

1844 10C VF20 PCGS. Soft golden-gray patina imbued with traces of violet envelops this "Little Orphan Annie" dime. Appropriately detailed and showing no significant marks. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N991)

599

1844 10C VF20 PCGS. Each side displays light golden-gray coloration and well defined devices. A few minute marks are undisturbing.(Registry values: N991)

600

1844 10C VF25 PCGS. Ocean-green and pink toning covers both sides of this always-in-demand 1844 representative. The design elements exhibit appropriate detail and the surfaces are quite clean for a coin having seen moderate circulation. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N991)

601

1844 10C VF25 ANACS. Sky-blue, lavender, and greenish-gray patina embraces this "Orphan Annie" representative. A couple of small obverse marks are in concert with the grade designation.(Registry values: N991)

602

1844 10C VF25 ANACS. Bluish and golden-brown shades dominate this relatively clean '44 ten cent. Nicely detailed throughout.(Registry values: N991)

603

1844 10C XF40 ANACS. Low intensity multicolored hues run over both sides of this semibright, well defined, minimally abraded dime. Always in high demand.(Registry values: N1793)

604

1851-O 10C MS62 NGC. Strongly lustrous with a touch of reflectivity beneath rich olive and blue-green patina. Though small and hidden abrasions preclude a finer grade, the eye appeal is as sharp as the strike. Census: 1 in 62, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

605

1854 10C Arrows MS65 PCGS. The generous mintage exceeding 4.4 million coins--and the lowered silver content--enable the survival of delightful Gem examples such as this piece. Generous cartwheel luster is present over gently toned silver-gold surfaces. The strike is full, with moderate die clashing appearing on both sides, and only minor contact seems to have precluded an even finer grade. A super type coin. Population: 18 in 65, 12 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

606

1859-O 10C MS64 PCGS. This near-Gem is well struck and luminous with attractive plum, blue, pink, and peach patina. Nicely preserved. Population: 32 in 64, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

607

1860 10C MS67 NGC. Fortin-106. The obverse is lightly but perceptibly die doubled. A fully struck example, highly lustrous and faintly toned in chestnut hues. Beautifully preserved, and undoubtedly among the finest survivors of this relatively low mintage year. Struck from moderately clashed dies. Population: 2 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1)

608

1863-S 10C AU55 PCGS. CAC. Luster fills the devices and legends of this lightly toned and unmarked better date dime. The 1863-S is scarce in all grades, and when encountered usually grades no better than Very Fine. Population: 2 in 55, 11 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

609

1863-S 10C MS62 PCGS. The 1863-S is rarely seen in Uncirculated grades, even though 157,500 pieces were produced. This bright, satiny example is sharply defined on each side. A number of small abrasions pepper both the obverse and reverse, but none of them are individually significant. Population: 3 in 62, 7 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

610

1867-S 10C MS62 PCGS. Fortin-102. The left flag of the 1 is right of the shield point, and the pendant is left of the center of the 6. The mintage of the 1867-S dime was only 120,000 pieces, and most of those likely circulated in the West, where the tradition of hard money was alive and well after the Civil War. Greer's series reference notes the issue is rare in Mint State.
This piece offers original pinkish-gold toning with glints of ice-blue near the rims on each side. The A in STATES is nearly filled in, and the peripheral strike is fairly soft at the bowknot and the upper left wreath, where an interesting raised die line appears. Marks are minimal, however, and the originality and eye appeal mark this coin as a prize for the specialist.(Registry values: N1793)

611

1871 10C MS65 PCGS. Barely discernible golden-tan color visits the lustrous surfaces of this lovely Gem. The usual weakness is noted on the upper left wreath. Population: 4 in 65, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

612

1872-CC 10C --Improperly Cleaned, Obverse Damage--NCS. VF Details. This cream-gray rare date Carson City dime is cloudy from hairlines. The Liberty cap and the letters OF AMER are flattened. A mere 35,480 pieces were struck, and less than 1% of the production has survived.(Registry values: N1793)

613

1872-CC 10C VF30 PCGS. A textbook example of the grade, with light gray fields and darker charcoal tones in the protected areas, amplifying the remaining details. With an impressively low mintage of only 35,480 pieces, this in-demand issue is understandably scarce. A bit of roughness is noted on the reverse at 2 o'clock, but there are no other deviations from what one would expect. Census: 5 in 30, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

614

1872-S 10C AU58 PCGS. CAC. Ample luster resides in the recessed areas of this near-Mint State S-mint specimen. Whispers of light gold-tan color and well defined devices occupy both sides. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 5 in 58, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

615

1873-CC 10C Arrows VG8 PCGS. Golden-brown, apple-green, and ocean-blue fill the border of this challenging Carson City issue. Five letters in LIBERTY are readable. Marks are noted northwest of Liberty's cap and at 12:30 on the reverse. One of only 18,791 pieces struck. Encased in a green label holder. Population: 11 in 8, 40 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

616

1873-S 10C Arrows MS63 PCGS. Peppered violet toning surrounds the mostly untoned center of the obverse, while the reverse is entirely brilliant. A number of light marks limit the grade, and a few tiny digs on Liberty's knees are barely worthy of note. Dazzling satiny luster graces both sides of this conditionally scarce two-year type coin. Population: 11 in 63, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

617

1875-CC 10C Mintmark Above Bow MS64 NGC. A frosty near-Gem with great eye appeal for this Carson City dime issue. The obverse has green-gold peripheral toning around blue-violet centers. On the reverse, these colors are in roughly the same position but more dappled. NGC has certified 44 numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

618

1876-CC 10C MS65 PCGS. A sharply struck Carson City Gem that should delight almost any toning enthusiast. Rich waves of blue, violet, lavender, and lilac cover the entire obverse and lead to a tiny peach center on the reverse. Population: 36 in 65, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

619

1877 10C MS65 PCGS. Cobalt-blue, lavender, and orange-brown patina resides on the lustrous surfaces of this well struck Gem. A few grade-consistent marks are visible on the obverse. Population: 15 in 65, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

620

1879 10C MS66 ★ NGC. Though not strictly Prooflike, this silver-white example is decidedly reflective in the fields with generous frost over the devices. This lends the coin the excellent eye appeal that determined the Star designation. Carefully preserved and delightful.(Registry values: N1793)

621

1879 10C MS66 NGC. Fully struck and gorgeously toned in soft gold and silver highlights on both sides. This is a low mintage date with only 14,000 pieces produced. A tiny scratch to the right of ONE DIME is mentioned for accuracy. Census: 39 in 66, 33 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

622

1884-S 10C MS63 PCGS. Bright luster emanates from the lightly colored golden tan surfaces of this well struck Select example. A few minute marks limit the grade. Population: 9 in 63, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

623

1886 10C MS65 PL NGC. Frosty devices demonstrate noticeable contrast with the flashy fields. This meticulously struck Gem has an undisturbed reverse and only unimportant obverse contact.(Registry values: N1793)

624

1886 10C MS65 ★ PL NGC. Untoned prooflike fields establish noticeable contrast with the motifs of this lovely Gem. Well struck, except for the usual softness in the hair atop Liberty's head. Pleasingly preserved throughout. This is the only 1886 dime that has received both the ★ and prooflike designations (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

625

1886 10C MS66 PCGS. This crisply struck Premium Gem exhibits dazzling luster despite the rich sea-green, sun-gold, autumn-brown, and powder-blue patina. Encased in a green label holder. Population: 27 in 66, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

626

1887 10C MS66 NGC. Brilliant surfaces display frosty luster and well struck design elements. Nicely preserved throughout. Census: 47 in 66, 5 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

627

1887 10C MS66 NGC. Light gray surfaces display frosty luster and well struck design features. A couple of small marks are visible on Liberty's motif.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

628

1888 10C MS66 PCGS. Soft reddish-orange and jade patina graces the lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem. Two small ticks below the second S in STATES are the only flaws of any note. PCGS has graded only one coin finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

629

1890-S 10C MS64 PCGS. Large S. Lavender and autumn-gold encompass this satiny and sharply struck near-Gem. No marks are perceived beneath the deep toning. Much scarcer in Mint State than its Philly counterpart. Population: 14 in 64, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

630

1891-S 10C MS65 PCGS. CAC. Minimally abraded and fully white with frosty luster. The strike is nice and the overall look will not disappoint the discerning buyer.(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Seated Dimes

631

1858 10C PR65 PCGS. The medium intensity cobalt-blue and lavender toning does not diminish the fairly strong field-device contrast on both sides of this Gem proof. A decisive strike imparts sharp delineation to the design features of this well cared for piece. Population: 8 in 65, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

632

1858 10C PR63 Cameo PCGS. Although close inspection reveals faint hairlines and contact marks that limit the grade, the initial appearance is that of an amazing piece that presents excellent eye appeal. Both sides are mostly brilliant, the obverse showing attractive blue and russet toning near the borders. The devices are satiny and lustrous, contrasting nicely with the mirrored fields. Population: 1 in 63 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).

633

1859 10C PR67 Cameo NGC. The official mintage for the 1859 dime was 800 pieces. However, an unknown number were melted as unsold at year's end, leaving an uncertain amount that were actually sold to collectors. The 1859 is the most available proof of what is essentially a two-year type in proof format, since it was not until 1858 that the Mint began larger scale production of proof coinage for sale to collectors. This is a deeply mirrored proof striking that shows considerable mint luster over the devices even though each side is toned deep rose with cobalt-blue at the margins. Census: 5 in 67 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

634

1864 10C PR65 Cameo NGC. This fully brilliant Gem No Motto dime has a proof mintage of a scant 470 pieces. The white-on-black contrast challenges the Ultra Cameo designation, and the strike is unimprovable. A few minute strike-throughs are of Mint origin. Census: 7 in 65 Cameo, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

635

1866 10C PR65 NGC. CAC. A gorgeous Gem proof, this dime displays central gold toning with blue, violet, and iridescent peripheries. Obvious contrast is evident on both sides, although the degree of toning prevents the Cameo designation. Census: 19 in 65, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

636

1867 10C PR65 Cameo NGC. A touch of lemongrass toning at the right obverse and reverse adds color to otherwise silver-white surfaces. Gleaming fields meet thick frost at the limits of the devices. Census: 4 in 65 Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

637

1869 10C PR66 NGC. Autumn-gold consumes the obverse aside from slender peripheral bands of electric-blue and plum-red. The reverse is mottled cobalt-blue, ruby-red, orange, and sun-gold. One of only 600 proofs issued. Census: 6 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

638

1869 10C PR66 Cameo NGC. A stunning Premium Gem example of this postbellum proof issue of only 600 coins. This piece boasts delightful toning in pastel pink, lilac, saffron, and jade, with the reverse adding sage to the palette in the center. Much field-device contrast adds to the appeal, and mentionable contact is nonexistent. Census: 9 in 66 Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

639

1874 10C Arrows PR64 Cameo PCGS. A moderately contrasted piece with faint gray toning that offers a suggestion of gold. Light hairlines in the fields account for the grade. Population: 7 in 64 Cameo, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1)

640

1875 10C PR65 PCGS. This deeply toned Gem proof has vibrant blue and lilac toning on the obverse, with gorgeous blue and turquoise on the reverse. Here is an incredible example for the toning enthusiast. Population: 14 in 65, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

641

1877 10C PR64 Cameo PCGS. Great reflectivity with just a hint of gold-white toning over the gleaming surfaces. A strongly contrasted specimen with just a few short hairlines visible in the fields. Population: 7 in 64 Cameo, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

642

1880 10C PR64 Cameo PCGS. Both sides show strong contrast and considerable toning, though the two sides differ in appearance. On the obverse, blue and green outer toning yields to gold and orange at the center, whereas on the reverse, the latter colors appear near the rims and the core is essentially untoned. Population: 15 in 64 Cameo, 33 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

643

1884 10C PR67 NGC. While always available for a price as a circulation strike (more than 3.3 million pieces were coined), the proof strikings are available on a much more restricted basis as only 875 pieces were produced. This is a lovely, brightly mirrored example. The obverse is essentially brilliant in the center and surrounded by sea-green margins. The reverse, on the other hand, has a rose-colored center with deep blue peripheral color. Census: 20 in 67, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

644

1885 10C PR66 Cameo NGC. A trace of gold patina is present, but most collectors would regard the present specimen as brilliant. White-on-black contrast is significant, and the strike is good save for moderate softness on the top of the wreath and on Liberty's foot. Just 930 proofs were coined. Census: 22 in 66 Cameo, 33 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

645

1887 10C PR66 NGC. The tobacco-brown and slate centers are framed by ocean-blue and plum-red. A boldly struck and flashy Premium Gem. A mere 710 proofs were issued. Census: 27 in 66, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

646

1888 10C PR66 Cameo PCGS. Fortin-102a, one of his Top 100 varieties. The lower loop of the final 8 in the date is repunched, and the drapery and rock are partly lapped away. Beautiful golden-brown and navy-blue toning ensures the eye appeal. Just 831 proofs were struck. Population: 7 in 66 Cameo, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

647

1888 10C PR67 Cameo NGC. Fortin-103. Of the three proof dies known for this date, this one shows the date level. Usually seen with a die defect in the upper loop of the final 8, but not seen here. Both sides are highly reflective in the fields and the devices display thick mint luster that provides the cameo contrast. The surfaces are essentially brilliant on both obverse and reverse. Census: 8 in 67 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

648

1889 10C PR65 NGC. CAC. Green-gold to orange hues cover the peripheral obverse and all of the reverse. Blue and violet hues prevail at the central obverse. Profoundly reflective beneath the patina and decidedly appealing even by Gem standards. Census: 30 in 65, 47 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

649

1891 10C PR65 NGC. Rose and cobalt-blue toning become more extensive and deeper on the reverse of this well struck Gem proof. Modest field-device variance, especially on the obverse. Nicely preserved.(Registry values: N1793)

Barber Dimes

650

1892-S 10C MS64 PCGS. A smooth near-Gem example of this little-saved first-year issue, richly toned blue-green with golden-tan and umber elements. Well struck and appealing. Population: 24 in 64, 16 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

651

1892-S 10C MS64 PCGS. Bold orange, blue, violet, and silver-mauve hues stand out on this first-year near-Gem. Satiny luster shines through the toning. Population: 24 in 64, 16 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

652

1893-O 10C MS64 Prooflike NGC. A surprisingly reflective representative of this challenging New Orleans issue, frosty on the devices with distinct mirrors beneath pale silver-blue and peach patina. The sole Prooflike representative known to NGC (2/10), with just 17 numerically finer pieces regardless of Prooflike status.(Registry values: N1793)

653

1894 10C MS66 NGC. This boldly struck Premium Gem has a satiny obverse and a fully prooflike reverse. The flashy fields display vibrant rose-red, apricot-gold, and sea-green patina. Essentially perfect aside from tiny obverse field marks near 7 o'clock. Census: 7 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

654

1895-S 10C MS64 PCGS. Light orange-red and powder-blue enriches this coruscating and precisely struck near-Gem. This better-date Barber dime is expectedly scarce in nice Mint State grades. Population: 26 in 64, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

655

1896 10C MS66 NGC. Deep purple, electric-blue, and orange-gold peripheral toning frames a nearly color-free obverse center and partially orange-gold reverse center. Sharply struck and minimally marked. Census: 8 in 66, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

656

1897-O 10C MS65 PCGS. An underrated low-mintage issue from the early O-mint quartet of Barber rarities, the 1897-O had a low production of 666,000 coins. This Gem piece displays lovely pinkish-gold and pastel blue patina. There are few relevant marks on either side, although light roller marks appear on the cheek. Population: 7 in 65, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

657

1899 10C MS66 PCGS. Lavender and olive colors endow this lustrous and boldly struck Premium Gem. A carefully preserved beauty that should appeal to the discerning series enthusiast. Population: 15 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

658

1900-O 10C MS63 PCGS. An attractive turn-of-the-century dime, predominantly light blue-gray with isolated spots of deeper patina. The luster and strike are pleasing. Population: 6 in 63, 28 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

659

1900-O 10C MS65 PCGS. The 1900-O dime is very scarce through near-Gem and rare any finer. Light gray lustrous surfaces on this Gem display wisps of barely discernible gold-tan color and exhibit sharply struck design elements. Some unimportant light grazes do not disturb. Population: 14 in 65, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

660

1902 10C MS66 NGC. The nearly untoned surfaces of this Premium Gem are well defined and possess strong luster. A couple of spots occur in the lower right obverse quadrant and some hair-thin marks are located in the lower reverse field. Census: 11 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

661

1905-O 10C MS67 NGC. It may be a cliché, but the present brilliant Superb Gem looks as if was struck yesterday, rather than more than a century ago. Lustrous and immaculate with a full strike. An unimprovable representative of this later New Orleans issue. Census: 4 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

662

1905-O 10C Micro O MS62 PCGS. It is believed the mintmark punch used on the Micro O dime was actually intended for a quarter die. The difference between the normal mintmark and the Micro O is easily discernable. The normal mintmark is tall and oval-shaped, while the Micro O is much smaller and nearly round. This is a brilliant coin that exhibits bright, satiny mint luster. Both sides show numerous small abrasions that undoubtedly account for the grade. Population: 1 in 62, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

663

1906 10C MS66 PCGS. Highly lustrous and precisely struck with unabraded surfaces and pastel green-gold toning. A high mintage date, but rare in such lofty preservation. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 12 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

664

1908-D 10C MS67 NGC. FS-010.2. This is a very interesting blundered date. The 9 shows a trace of a 0 in the upper loop, and the 0 clearly shows the remnants of an 8. Discovered by Bill Fivaz, the Cherrypickers' Guide postulates that "the date was possibly punched in one digit too far left, then corrected, polishing away any remnants of the first 1." Sounds good to us. In fact, we can't really think of another possible explanation for this oddity. Superb mint luster and attractively toned, the gray centers are surrounded by small amounts of reddish patina at the margins. It is probably not too much of a stretch to say this is the finest known example of the variety.(Registry values: N2998)

665

1911-S 10C MS66 PCGS. Silver-pink and peach hues prevail on this satiny Premium Gem, with an arc of deeper amber across the upper obverse. Carefully preserved and delightful. Population: 43 in 66, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

666

1914 10C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Richly toned across each side, with colors ranging from light gold and orange to deep peach and umber. Carefully preserved with strong luster shining through the patina. Population: 51 in 66, 5 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Barber Dimes

667

1893 10C PR66 PCGS. CAC. Boldly toned with generally blue and watery margins and deeper violet through the centers. A sharply struck Premium Gem with fantastic eye appeal. Population: 24 in 66, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

668

1893 10C PR66 NGC. Rich multicolored toning resides on each side of this Premium Gem proof. Sharp definition characterizes the design features that yield modest contrast with the reflective fields. Devoid of mentionable marks. Census: 46 in 66, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

669

1894 10C PR65 NGC. Only the first year of Barber dime proof coinage exceeded 1,000 pieces, although the 1894 at 972 came close. This silver Gem boasts satiny silver-gold surfaces with only a small contact mark in the right obverse field that perhaps precludes an even finer grade. A nice example for a type set. Census: 54 in 65, 79 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

670

1895 10C PR64 Ultra Cameo NGC. Profound reflectivity is a match for the thick frost on this near-Gem, and the result is an outstanding Ultra Cameo effect. Gleaming silver-white surfaces show minor faults that are trivial in the context of the overall eye appeal.(Registry values: P1)

671

1897 10C PR67 Cameo NGC. In our opinion, this Superb Gem proof is a borderline Ultra Cameo, showing amazing contrast between the fields and devices, perhaps slightly subdued by wispy champagne toning. As it should be, every detail on the central motifs and peripheral letters is fully defined. Census: 18 in 67 Cameo, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

672

1900 10C PR67 NGC. Lavishly toned in golden-brown, aquamarine, ruby-red, and straw-gold. A beautiful and fully struck Superb Gem. A scant 912 proofs were struck, and most survivors are in lesser grades and lack the dramatic patina of the present specimen. Census: 20 in 67, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

673

1904 10C PR65 Cameo NGC. An attractive Cameo Gem, profoundly reflective with decided field-to-device contrast. Gold and orange peripheral shadings appear at parts of the margins, leaving the rest of the piece essentially untoned. Census: 2 in 65 Cameo, 10 finer (2/10).
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

674

1905 10C PR67 PCGS. The coloration is unusual but attractive on this Superb Gem specimen, with deep cinnamon, russet, and cerulean on the obverse and similar colors prevailing on the reverse. Exquisitely struck, and with absolutely impeccable surfaces that show zero evidence of contact. Population: 14 in 67, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

675

1909 10C PR66 NGC. This impressive Premium Gem proof has a splash of silver at the center of the obverse, with a frame of iridescence. The reverse is bright gold at the center, surrounded with blue, green, and rose. A lovely example. Census: 47 in 66, 23 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

676

1912 10C PR66 PCGS. Both sides are richly toned in blues and violets with lighter green accents. An incredibly appealing Premium Gem with generous reflectivity beneath the patina. Population: 21 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

677

1913 10C PR65 NGC. This Gem proof has speckled gold and iridescent toning over its mirrored fields and satiny devices. Cameo contrast is slight, insufficient for the Cameo designation. Census: 21 in 65, 30 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Mercury Dimes

678

1916-D 10C Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an Uncirculated specimen that has been cleaned. This pearl-gray and chestnut-tan key date dime is needle-sharp and devoid of hairlines. Cartwheel luster is unbroken but slightly diminished.

679

1916-D 10C Good 4 PCGS. CAC. Smooth surfaces are generally medium-gray, though the fields around the fasces show rose and gold elements. Both sides exhibit a partial rim, around the top and right sides on the obverse with a fragment at the bottom of the reverse.(Registry values: N1)

680

1916-D 10C Good 6 PCGS. Well-worn but appealing thanks to an absence of abrasions, this D-mint key has gray-gold surfaces overall. The color strengthens to orange close to the rims.(Registry values: N1)

681

1916-D 10C VG10 NGC. Deep lavender and forest-green toning envelop this key date dime. All legends are sharp, and partial vertical lines are visible within the fasces. Sharper than the typical '16-D dime, since the two most frequently seen grades are AG3 and Good 4.(Registry values: N1)

682

1916-D 10C Fine 12 PCGS. Light to medium gray patina bathes both sides of this '16-D dime that exhibits well defined design motifs for the designated grade; the rods of the fasces show detail at the element's margins. A few minute surface and rim marks are in line with a coin having seen moderate circulation. An overall nice example of this desirable issue.(Registry values: N1)

683

1916-D 10C Fine 15 PCGS. This is an unusual middle circulated grade 1916-D Mercury dime, quite elusive as such. This issue is usually found in Mint State grades, or in Good or lower grades, and seldom in between. Both sides are lightly abraded, yet pleasing, with heather, gray, and gold toning.(Registry values: N1)

684

1916-D 10C VF25 PCGS. The silver-gray surfaces of this key date representative display freckles of dark gray on the obverse and the same color palate in the recessed areas of the reverse. An appropriately defined piece that reveals no significant marks. This coin will fit comfortably in a mid- to high-grade circulated collection.(Registry values: N1793)

685

1916-D 10C VF35 PCGS. Soft golden-gray patina imbued with hints of lilac is slightly deeper on the reverse of this Choice VF representative. The design elements are well defined and neither side reveals mentionable contract marks or spots. This piece will fit comfortably in a mid- to high-grade circulated Mercury dime collection.(Registry values: N1793)

686

1916-D 10C --Obverse Damage--NGC. XF Details. The central obverse has a series of overlapping curved marks, but these are relatively inconspicuous to the unaided eye due to rich forest-green, honey-gold, and champagne-rose toning. Much sharper in detail than the typical key date '16-D dime, since a majority of survivors grade between Fair and VG.(Registry values: N2998)

687

1916-D 10C XF45 PCGS. Splashes of cobalt-blue and purple visit the golden-gray surfaces of this key-date representative that displays hints of luster in some of the recessed areas. The design features are appropriately detailed. A few minute marks are in concert with the designated grade. This piece will fit comfortably in a high grade Mercury dime collection.(Registry values: N2998)

688

1916-D 10C AU50 PCGS. CAC. Dappled golden-brown, fire-red, sea-green, and powder-blue toning ensures the originality of this unmarked and lightly circulated dime. The series key due to its low mintage. Most survivors are in heavily circulated grades, unlike the present partly lustrous example. Housed in a first generation holder.(Registry values: N2998)

689

1916-D 10C MS65 Full Bands NGC. A beautiful Gem that has blushes of sea-green, golden-brown, and honey-gold throughout the margins. The devices and fields are minimally toned. The strike is exacting, not only on the important central bands, but also across the peripheral legends.
The surfaces appear immaculate at first glance, and a faint luster graze near the AM in AMERICA is only observed upon thorough study beneath a loupe. Both sides provide imposing luster. The reverse is rotated slightly clockwise, and the reverse legends show occasional evidence of strike doubling.
Collectors of the popular Mercury dime series quickly learn that the key date is the 1916-D. Its mintage of 264,000 pieces is roughly one-quarter of its closest competitor, the 1921-D. Little attention was paid to mintmarks by the general public in 1916, and although many 1916 and 1916-S Mercury dimes were set aside, most 1916-D dimes circulated for years. The majority of survivors grade between Fair and Very Good. Unfortunately, many counterfeits are also known, some of which are genuine 1916 Mercury dimes with an added Denver mintmark.
The 1916-D dime is rare due to the production delays of a related rarity, the 1916 Standing Liberty quarter. Per David W. Lange, in November, 1916, the Treasury Department ordered 4 million quarters. The Mint director and superintendents met and decided that the Denver Mint would strike only quarters until the Treasury order was fulfilled. This decision curtailed production of 1916-D dimes until the change in calendar year ended the issue.
The Mint decision also explains the high mintage of the 1916-D quarter, from the old Barber designs. Midwestern demand for dimes was met by the 1916-S, which had a mammoth mintage of more than 16 million pieces comprised of both the Barber and Mercury types. Census: 24 in 65 Full Bands, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

690

1916-S 10C MS67 PCGS. A flashy Superb Gem that has a generous blush of gold patina on each side. A gorgeously preserved and sharply struck Dime. A light vertical die crack (as made) travels across the upper portrait. Population: 12 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: Atlanta Signature (Heritage, 8/2001), lot 5762, which realized $1,495.(Registry values: N1793)

691

1917-D 10C MS64 Full Bands PCGS. A boldly impressed near-Gem example with effusive luster. The surfaces have a pearl-gray base with generous gold and rose elements. PCGS has graded 41 finer Full Bands pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

692

1917-S 10C MS66 Full Bands PCGS. CAC. A shining Premium Gem with carefully preserved devices that are boldly impressed. Splashes of amber and rose peripheral toning yield to near-brilliance at the centers. Population: 63 in 66 Full Bands, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

693

1918-S 10C MS65 Full Bands PCGS. David Lange (2005) writes that the 1918-S dime "... is notorious for being rare with full center bands," making Full Band Gems such as the present offering a very special coin. Moreover, the lower diagonal band, which is often flat, is sharp on this specimen. Frosty luster resides on its nicely preserved surfaces that yield just a hint of light gold and violet color, primarily on the reverse. Population: 24 in 65 Full Bands, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

694

1920 10C MS67 Full Bands NGC. An absolutely stunning Superb Gem, this 1920 Mercury dime has brilliant ivory mint frost with splashes of darker peripheral toning on both sides. The strike is incredible as expected, and the aesthetic appeal is exceptional. Census: 14 in 67 Full Bands, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

695

1921-D 10C AU50 PCGS. Still-lustrous pearl-gray surfaces show golden overtones at the margins. Smooth for the AU50 designation with light, even wear the main determinant of the grade.(Registry values: N991)

696

1921-D 10C MS60 PCGS. Brilliant and satiny silver surfaces are visible through the light yellowish-gold toning on both sides. Hints of blue-green peripheral toning are evident along parts of each border.(Registry values: N1793)

697

1921-D 10C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Speckles of light gold and soft bluish-violet adhere to the lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem. The design features are well impressed, including those on the periphery, an area this is often weak on this issue. Impeccably preserved and highly appealing. Population: 10 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

698

1921-D 10C MS64 Full Bands NGC. The 1921-D has an impressively low mintage of just over 1 million pieces. Naturally, this and the also-low mintage 1921-P are both keys to the Mercury dime series. This example has subdued, satiny mint luster and we assume that is the reason for the coin not grading even higher. Otherwise the surfaces are untoned and refreshingly free from abrasions. The devices are fully struck in all areas with especially strong definition on the horizontal and diagonal bands on the fasces.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

699

1924-S 10C MS64 Full Bands PCGS. The coinage of San Francisco Mercury dimes in 1924 was a slipshod affair. Fully struck, Full Bands specimens are seldom encountered, making the present offering an important opportunity. The lustrous surfaces are enhanced by wisps of gold and lilac toning, and the sharply struck devices exhibit crisp detail.(Registry values: N2998)

700

1925 10C MS66 Full Bands PCGS. CAC. A lovely Premium Gem with exceptional design definition. The surfaces are brilliant with traces of champagne toning on both sides. The 1925 Mercury dime had a mintage of more than 25 million coins, but few survive that are equal to this piece. Population: 47 in 66 Full Bands, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

701

1925 10C MS66 Full Bands PCGS. David Lange, in his The Complete Guide to Mercury Dimes, notes nearly all coins of this date display an overall softness in striking details. This example is an exception. Aside from the designated fullness in the central reverse, the peripheral areas of both sides are sharply struck. The only hint of softness lies on the central obverse elements, and even those Areas are sharper than usually seen. A few streaks of green toning accent the mostly brilliant surfaces. Population: 47 in 66 Full Bands, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

702

1925 10C MS66 Full Bands PCGS. The 1925 Mercury dime is very scarce in the Premium Gem Full Bands designation. Lustrous, brilliant surfaces, with a few highlights of green and lavender toning, set this coin apart from the ordinary, lackluster examples so often seen of this date. The bands on the fasces are dramatically separated. Population: 47 in 66 Full Bands, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

703

1925 10C MS66 Full Bands PCGS. Vibrant and flawless surfaces beneath a wispy overlay of delicate crimson and emerald-green toning make the present coin a prize for the discerning collector. Choice and better examples of this mid-1920s issue are located without too much difficulty, but the supply of Premium Gem pieces is surprisingly thin, especially in the Full Bands designation. Population: 47 in 66 Full Bands, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

704

1925 10C MS67 Full Bands PCGS. While many Mercury dimes of the 1920s possess strong central detail, David Lange notes the 1925 issue is often weak in this area. The present specimen is clearly an exception to that rule, as the striking details are sharp throughout, including the all-important bands, which are fully split. The mostly brilliant surfaces are accented by streaks of champagne and russet toning. The date is decidedly rare in the MS67 Full Bands designation. Population: 22 in 67 Full Bands, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

705

1925 10C MS67 Full Bands PCGS. Blazing mint luster under attractive streaks of jade-green and delicate lavender toning create stunning visual appeal on this Superb Gem specimen. The grading services have certified only three coins in higher grades with the Full bands designation. Population: 22 in 67 Full Bands, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

706

1925 10C MS67 Full Bands PCGS. A stunning type coin from the 1920s and seldom encountered in this condition. Certain to be of interest to series enthusiasts, type collectors and Registry Set collectors alike. Streaks of emerald-green and rose toning accent both the obverse and reverse of this highly lustrous coin. The present coin is a rare and beautiful specimen of this desirable issue. Population: 22 in 67 Full Bands, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

707

1925-S 10C MS64 Full Bands NGC. The mintage was a plentiful 5 million-plus coins at the height of the Roaring Twenties, but the 1925-S is seldom seen at the Gem Full Bands level. This near-Gem sports silvery centers with amber-gold rims tinged with lilac and ice-blue. The strike is well-impressed throughout, and the eye appeal is generous. Census: 51 in 64 Full Bands, 39 finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

708

1926-D 10C MS65 Full Bands PCGS. Highly lustrous surfaces display a slight milky-blue haze, but are otherwise untoned. The strike is full and the bands on the reverse show full separation. Eye-clean and very pleasing for the grade. Although it is a better produced issue than its nickel and quarter counterparts, fully struck Gem examples are scarce. Population: 72 in 65 Full Bands, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

709

1926-D 10C MS65 Full Bands PCGS. The 1926-D is one of the few mintmarked dimes from the 1920s that has the distinction of being moderately available in both high grade and with Full Bands. This is a bright, highly lustrous example that is essentially brilliant. The striking details are complete, not only on the bands but on the peripheral legends as well. Population: 72 in 65 Full Bands, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

710

1926-S 10C MS63 Full Bands PCGS. Lustrous surfaces are bathed in gunmetal-blue and golden-brown patina and exhibit sharply struck design motifs. A scattering of small marks limits the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

711

1929-S 10C MS67 Full Bands PCGS. Ex: Larry Shapiro. Dazzling luster almost leaps off this satiny-white Gem. The quality of the strike and surfaces are impeccable. The 1929-S is more available in high grade than many early issues, but it is still a condition rarity in Superb Gem. Population: 26 in 67 Full Bands, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: Houston Signature (Heritage, 12/2009), lot 469, which realized $6,900.(Registry values: N1793)

712

1934-D 10C MS67 Full Bands PCGS. Bold autumn-gold and striking silver hues dominate the eye appeal of this sharp Superb Gem, and the lower left obverse adds powder-blue to the mix. Dramatic eye appeal. Population: 37 in 67 Full Bands, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

713

1934-D 10C MS68 Full Bands NGC. An exquisite Superb Gem, this boldly defined 1934-D dime has frosty silver surfaces beneath mottled iridescence on the obverse. The reverse is brilliant with silver-gray luster and faint splashes of champagne toning. This is the finest certified 1934-D dime. Census: 1 in 68 Full Bands, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

714

1939-S 10C MS66 Full Bands PCGS. CAC. Outstanding flashy luster and carefully preserved surfaces with golden tints against the dominant silver-white. This sharply struck Premium Gem is memorably appealing. PCGS has graded 30 finer Full Bands coins (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

715

1940-S 10C MS68 Full Bands NGC. An absolutely stunning Superb Gem, with a bold strike. The typical 1940-S has much less design definition than this piece. It is fully brilliant with a hint of champagne toning over satiny silver surfaces. Census: 2 in 68 Full Bands, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

716

1941-D 10C MS68 Full Bands PCGS. Intense luster radiates from the color-free surfaces of this magnificent Superb Gem. An exquisitely struck immaculately preserved coin. Population: 19 in 68 Full Bands, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

717

1942/1 10C AU55 NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-010.7. Light gray surfaces retain a fair amount of luster and are well defined. An occasional unobtrusive circulation mark does not detract.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

718

1942/1-D 10C AU53 PCGS. CAC. FS-101, formerly FS-010.7. Gold and light blue toning on the obverse cedes to bluish-violet color on the reverse. Well defined and minimally abraded.(Registry values: N991)

719

1944-D 10C MS68 Full Bands PCGS. Radiantly lustrous and virtually untoned. This beauty is one of just a relative handful to be both carefully preserved and decisively struck. Population: 76 in 68 Full Bands, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N991)

720

1945 10C MS64 Full Bands NGC. When Full Bands were first being examined on the various Mercury dime issues in the mid-1970s, Harold Kritzman made the curious discovery that the hugely minted 1945-P was the key to the set with Full Bands. Dealers and collectors began to search for this issue, but few were found in rolls. The one reliable source for fully split 1945-P dimes were coins that were struck slightly off center. This piece has fully split central bands on the reverse as well as completely separated diagonal bands. The obverse is untoned, while the reverse shows just a bit of light reddish patina. A few tiny marks account for the grade. Census: 7 in 64 Full Bands, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

721

1945 10C MS65 Full Bands PCGS. Ex: Jay Eisenberg. An issue guaranteed to set the hearts of Mercury Dime specialists racing. This premium quality 1945-P dime displays central cross bands that are fully split from end to end--an uncommon feature for an example of this generally hurriedly produced wartime issue. Thick, rich, frosty textured luster blankets both sides and is readily appreciable in the absence of all but the tiniest blemishes. Both sides are smooth and unperturbed, with a lovely silver-white sheen. The key to the Mercury dime series at the Gem Full Bands level. Population: 34 in 65 Full Bands, 16 finer (2/10).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (9/2003), lot 6562.(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Mercury Dimes

722

1936 10C PR65 NGC. CAC. Gold-orange peripheral toning yields to pearl-gray at the centers of this sharply struck Gem. Glimmers of reflectivity peek through close to the devices.(Registry values: N1793)

723

1936 10C PR65 NGC. Faint golden-tan, violet, and green patination runs over the luminous surfaces of this Gem proof. Exquisitely struck and devoid of mentionable marks.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

724

1936 10C PR65 PCGS. CAC. A minimally toned and gleaming Gem proof example of this first-year issue. Excellent striking definition with no singularly mentionable flaws.(Registry values: N1793)

725

1936 10C PR66 NGC. This powerfully lustrous Premium Gem boasts remarkably clean surfaces and razor-sharp design definition. Hints of violet and light red add color to this mostly brilliant specimen. The 1936 was the first proof Mercury dime issue and had a low mintage of just 4,130 pieces.(Registry values: N1793)

726

1936 10C PR66 PCGS. A brilliant and intricately struck high grade specimen of this desirable first year proof date. The reverse exhibits pleasing cameo contrast, and Liberty's cap is also frosty, although contrast is minimal between the portrait and obverse field.(Registry values: N1793)

727

1937 10C PR68 PCGS. A razor-sharp and pristine specimen that exhibits pastel rose-red, butter-gold, jade-green, and cream-gray toning. The second proof date of the series, and only the 1936 has a lower mintage. Neither major grading service has certified any examples finer. Population: 22 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

728

1941 10C PR68 NGC. Mostly brilliant, this Superb Gem proof exhibits lovely iridescent toning near the borders. It is sharply defined with excellent eye appeal. Neither NGC or PCGS have graded any finer examples. Census: 51 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

729

1942 10C PR67 Cameo NGC. Any Cameo proof Mercury dime is an important rarity in the 20th century American series. This remarkable Superb Gem has fully brilliant and untoned silver surfaces with deeply mirrored fields and highly lustrous devices. Census: 4 in 67 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

Roosevelt Dimes

730

1965 10C MS68 Full Torch NGC. As the designation suggests, all design elements are bold and sharply detailed. This champagne toned Superb Gem has pristine surfaces and exceptional luster with brilliant mint frost. NGC and PCGS have each graded one example at this level, with none finer (2/10).(Registry values: N208)

SMS Roosevelt Dimes

731

1965 10C SMS MS68 Cameo PCGS. This desirable Special Mint Set dime has amazing contrast, with brilliant light gray surfaces and faint champagne toning. Both sides have deeply mirrored fields and lustrous devices. Population: 12 in 68 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N208)

732

1967 10C SMS MS69 Cameo PCGS. An immaculate example of this final year Special Mint Set striking. These sets were produced at the San Francisco Mint without a mintmark. A hint of gold color is seen on the right obverse field. The devices have a subtle matte-like texture, as made. The reverse legends are moderately strike doubled. Population: 1 in 69 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N208)

Proof Roosevelt Dimes

733

1951 10C PR69 ★ Cameo NGC. It doesn't get any better than this. Here is an amazing NGC ★ designated Superb Gem Cameo proof with immaculate, untoned silver surfaces. Both sides have excellent contrast, the obverse approaching the Ultra Cameo designation. Census: 1 in 69 ★ Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

734

1970 10C No S PR69 Cameo NGC. This piece is fully struck with deep, watery reflectivity in the fields and essentially pristine surfaces. A virtually perfect representative of this popular earlier 'No S' proof variety. Census: 10 in 69 Cameo, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1)

Twenty Cent Pieces

735

1875-CC 20C AU58 PCGS. CAC. Only a trace of wear prevents a full Mint State grade to this entirely original and attractive Carson City coin. The 1875-CC is the only collectible Carson City twenty cent piece. The top of the left (facing) wing is weakly defined, but sharper than often on this issue.(Registry values: N991)

736

1875-S 20C MS63 PCGS. FS-301. The top of an 8 is misplaced in the dentils beneath the prominent 8. This Select Mint State piece is housed in an old green label PCGS holder. It exhibits stunning gold and iridescent toning over satiny silver surfaces. A pleasing example of the most plentiful twenty cent piece for the type collector.(Registry values: N1793)

737

1875-S 20C MS65 PCGS. Aquamarine and golden-brown toning embraces this lustrous and precisely struck Gem type coin. Marks of any size are difficult to locate, even with the assistance of a powerful loupe. Coined at San Francisco only in 1875, the 20 cent piece was criticized for its similarity of appearance to the quarter dollar.(Registry values: N2998)

738

1875-S 20C MS65 PCGS. Lustrous surfaces are covered in soft golden-brown patina framed on the obverse by cobalt-blue and russet and exhibit well struck design features. A handful of grade-consistent grazes fail to detract from the coin's overall eye appeal. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N2998)

739

1875-S 20C MS66 NGC. A spectacular Premium Gem example of this ever-popular odd-denomination type issue. The strike is pleasing, the luster is vibrant and highly frosted. Subtle golden patina at the center of the obverse offsets the essential brilliance found elsewhere. NGC has graded just seven numerically finer examples (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

740

1876 20C MS64 PCGS. CAC. A pleasing near-Gem example of this low-mintage, odd-denomination issue, produced to the extent of only 14,600 business strikes. This piece offers originally patinated surfaces that are light silver with just a slight overlay of central pinkish-gold and pastel ice-blue. A scrape through star 1 and alongside Liberty's rock is the only singular mark, although it likely precludes a Gem grade. A nice type coin for collectors who would prefer an alternative to the ubiquitous 1875-S. Population: 66 in 64, 44 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Twenty Cent Pieces

741

1875 20C PR64 PCGS. A lovely near-Gem housed in a green-label PCGS holder, this example has prominent cameo contrast with faint gold toning over otherwise brilliant silver surfaces. The central obverse and reverse motifs are sharply detailed. Population: 62 in 64, 31 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

742

1875 20C PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. This is an interesting proof example of this curious denomination. The fields are highly reflective, as usually seen on proofs, and semicircular, scribe lines are seen at the top of the obverse. Most of each side is brilliant with a slight accent of reddish patina around the margins. The only grade-limiting mark is located in the field between the eagle's right (facing) leg and wing. Soft mint frost is seen over the devices which contrasts sharply against the depth of mirrored reflectivity in the fields.(Registry values: N2998)

743

1877 20C PR62 Cameo PCGS. An initial glance suggests a much higher numerical grade to this brilliant, untoned proof. Both sides have excellent contrast. Only upon close examination do the faint hairlines and contact marks that limit the grade become obvious. A wonderful example of the first of two proof-only twenty cent piece dates.(Registry values: N2998)

744

1878 20C PR62 NGC. The 1878 twenty cent piece is the final year of issue, although strikes for circulation stopped in 1876. The last two years were proof-only, and the 1878 had a production run limited to 600 pieces. As one would expect, this tiny production makes this a very popular issue. As with many twenty cent pieces, both proofs and business strikes, the fields are exceptionally deep in their mirrored reflectivity. It appears the dies were basined, giving the resultant coins exceptional depth. This piece has hazy gray-white surfaces with slight hairlining. It actually is appears much finer than the stated grade. The devices are fully struck, including the top of the eagle's left wing.(Registry values: N1793)

Early Quarters

745

1796 25C --Polished--NGC. VF Details. B-2, R.3. Among all silver types, the Draped Bust, Small Eagle quarter is perhaps the second rarest, trailing only its half dollar counterpart. The quarter was struck only in 1796 prior to 1804, by which time the Heraldic Eagle reverse was in use. Type demand for the 1796 quarter is so substantial that even heavily worn examples are worth thousands of dollars. The present representative has bold legends and pleasing detail within the eagle's wings and Liberty's hair tresses. The straw-gold surfaces are glossy and faintly hairlined from cleaning, but many collectors would cherish such a richly detailed piece within their type holdings.(Registry values: P7)

746

1806 25C Fine 15 PCGS. CAC. B-10, R.5. The lower left serif of 1 missing, tip of the 5 is in the tail feathers, five large berries, two inside and three outside of branch. Medium gray fields highlight the lighter devices. Appropriately defined and minimally abraded.(Registry values: P5)

747

1806 25C AU55 NGC. B-9, R.1. Tompkins Die State 3/3 with interesting die cracks and clashmarks. Medium forest-green and caramel-gold toning encompasses this briefly circulated and only lightly abraded Draped Bust type coin. The stars above the eagle are typically brought up, as they are opposite the high relief shoulder of the bust, but most of the design is nicely impressed.(Registry values: P5)

Bust Quarters

748

1815 25C "E" Counterstamp MS62 NGC. B-1, R.1. Various theories have been formed over the past century-plus to explain the existence of numerous 1815 and 1825 quarters counterstamped "E" or "L" above the bust. Many numismatists believe the Economite commune in Pennsylvania counterstruck these pieces as a voting measure. The E and L counterstamps represented rival factions within the Economites. This is an unabraded example that exhibits rich blue-green and apricot-gold toning. Luster dominates the borders and devices.(Registry values: P3)

749

1818 25C AU53 PCGS. CAC. B-8, R.3. This sharply struck dove-gray and tan Capped Bust quarter displays noticeable luster within the devices and legends. The reverse is refreshingly unabraded, and the obverse is smooth aside from a thin line on the cheek and a curved mark on the left field.(Registry values: P2)

750

1818 25C MS65 NGC. B-5, R.5. The 1818 B-5 is a rare die marriage, especially in XF grade or finer, and few Mint State pieces are known. The B-5 can be recognized by the repunching on star 9 and defective left bottom serif of the second 1 on the obverse, with star 1 pointing to a drapery fold, while on the reverse OF AMERICA is widely spaced, and a center dot appears between the sixth and seventh crossbar. Blended dove-gray, plum-mauve, and autumn-gold attest to the originality of this satiny and well struck Gem example. Examination with a loupe fails to reveal evenly remotely mentionable marks. The reverse fields are brighter than the obverse, and the piece is sharply struck throughout, save for a small area of softness on stars 5-7.
This is the finest NGC-certified example of B-5 by 20 points. Steve Tompkins' Condition Census in Early United States Quarters 1796-1838 shows this piece to be two points finer than an MS63 that appeared in a Superior auction (1/1988, lot 1380) and to be the finest of the three Mint State examples of B-5 that he enumerates. The second finest-certified that we have ever handled at Heritage is an AU55 NGC coin (3/2008, lot 477).
Ex: FUN Signature (1/2008), lot 2777.(Registry values: P2)

751

1819 25C Large 9 AU53 NGC. B-2, R.3. A low D in UNITED aids attribution. A deeply toned golden-brown and gunmetal-blue example with few marks and only moderate highpoint wear. The obverse has slender peripheral die cracks.(Registry values: P4)

752

1822 25C XF45 ANACS. B-1, R.2. Star 1 points to lower drapery fold and 25 is centered with a square base 2. Multicolored toning is slightly deeper on the reverse of this appropriately defined Choice XF specimen. devoid of significant marks.(Registry values: P3)

753

1822 25C MS62 NGC. B-1, R.2 The Normal Dies 1822 quarter is struck from perfect dies as are all examples of the die combination. The surfaces are reflective with minor marks hidden beneath the deep steel and lighter iridescent toning. Four or five proofs are known, alongside a small quantity of Mint State pieces. Census: 5 in 62, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

754

1824/2 25C VF35 PCGS. B-1, R.3. The 1824/2 is the only die pairing known for the year. This example boasts some muted mint luster still remaining on the surfaces, which are tinged golden with a touch of deeper amber at the lower obverse rim. An interesting die line appears extending backward from the lower arrowhead. Population: 7 in 35, 32 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

755

1825/4/3 25C --Cleaned--ANACS. MS60 Details. B-2, R.2. Well struck and partly lustrous but a bit bright and unnaturally prooflike. This lightly toned Bust quarter is hairlined but lacks individually noticeable marks.(Registry values: P2)

756

1825/4/3 25C MS63 ANACS. B-2, R.2. Designated as 1825/4/2 on the ANACS insert, but this is the variety listed as 1825/4 in the 2010 Guide Book. A lustrous representative with light butter-gold toning and a crisp strike. Smooth for the grade despite a few faint marks on the field near the eagle.(Registry values: P2)

757

1831 25C Small Letters MS64 NGC. B-2, R.2. The last die state identified by Tompkins, with the reverse die crack between UNITED and STATES developing a crack to the rim. Lustrous surfaces show peripheral electric-blue, lavender, and russet toning framing brilliant centers. Well struck and revealing just a few minor handling marks. Census for the issue: 69 in 64, 31 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

758

1832 25C MS62 NGC. B-2, R.2. The Small Arrowheads variety of this conditionally rare date. A satiny and boldly struck example that has light gold centers and a blush of golden-brown and jade-green about the obverse periphery. Census: 10 in 62, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

759

1834 25C MS64 PCGS. CAC. B-2, R.4. An unabraded near-Gem with satin luster and rich golden-brown and navy-blue toning. Well struck save for a few stars. The second scarcest variety of the date. B-2 shares an obverse die with the common B-1, but unlike that marriage, a period is present after 25 C. Population for all varieties: 43 in 64, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

760

1836 25C MS63 ★ NGC. B-2, R.2. The finer of just two 1836-dated quarters to be awarded the Star designation by NGC (2/10), this piece is of the B-2 variety, boldly clashed with a die crack running from top to bottom of the portrait. Though softly struck at the obverse stars, this Select piece has a well-defined center. Minimally toned fields offer a measure of reflectivity, which doubtless influenced the graders who awarded the Star.(Registry values: P3)

761

1838 25C MS62 NGC. B-1, R.1. Essentially untoned with bright, satiny luster and excellent sharpness over all but a couple of the star centrils. A few pinpoint field marks are found to the left of the portrait, yet the overall eye appeal remains solid. An attractive example from the end of the Capped Bust design on quarters. Census: 16 in 62, 48 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P2)

Seated Quarters

762

1840-O 25C No Drapery AU58 PCGS. CAC. Large O. An attractive near-Mint example of the short-lived No Drapery subtype, lightly gold-toned over pale silver on the obverse with the reverse showing spots of peripheral violet-gray. Mildly abraded with just a touch of friction on the high points. Population: 14 in 58, 12 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P6)

763

1840-O 25C No Drapery AU58 PCGS. Large O. The light gray surfaces of this near-Mint State specimen retain a considerable amount of luster and are minimally abraded. A well impressed specimen. Population: 14 in 58, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

764

1840-O 25C Drapery MS62 PCGS. Small O. Medium intensity bluish-gray patination envelops both sides of this well struck O-mint quarter. A few light marks do not detract. Population: 6 in 62, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

765

1841-O 25C MS62 NGC. Lustrous and lightly toned with a typical strike and smooth, unblemished surfaces. The first two stars are repunched, and Liberty's shield is die doubled. Census: 10 in 62, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

766

1841-O 25C MS64 PCGS. Pearl-gray and straw-gold embrace this satiny and dusky near-Gem. Marks are practically absent. The peripheral strike is precise, while the major devices show minor incompleteness. Possibly from the New Orleans Hoard, discovered in 1982 and the source for a number of nice '41-O quarters. Population: 7 in 64, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: Los Angeles Signature (Heritage, 7/2009), lot 576, which realized $3,737.50.(Registry values: P4)

767

1842-O 25C Small Date VF25 PCGS. CAC. Briggs 1-A, the only Small Date die pair. A midrange representative of an elusive variety finally getting its due, this VF25 Small Date 1842-O quarter has strong design definition remaining for the grade, particularly in the shield area. Lavender-gray toning takes up occasional violet and rose elements. Population: 1 in 25, 13 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P8)

768

1844-O 25C MS64 NGC. Orange and gunmetal-gray toning coats the minimally abraded surfaces. A few stars are slightly soft, but Liberty and the eagle are sharply defined. Although somewhat subdued on the obverse, the luster is stronger on the reverse. Larry Briggs (1991) describes the 1844-O as High R.6 in Mint State, and the population data supports that claim. Census: 4 in 64, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

769

1852-O 25C VF25 PCGS. CAC. Dusky blue-gray and gold-orange toning drapes this midgrade O-mint quarter. Aside from a few shallow digs in the fields around the figure of Liberty, the surfaces are minimally marked. Population: 3 in 25, 22 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P7)

770

1853 25C Arrows and Rays MS62 PCGS. The toned type coin collector will find much to love about this piece's patina, dusky peach and lavender with generous rose elements. Well struck with few easily noticed abrasions, and housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P5)

771

1853 25C Arrows and Rays MS64 PCGS. CAC. In 1853, the weight of the U.S. quarter dollar coin was reduced from 6.68 grams to 6.22 grams. This change was signified by the addition of arrows to the obverse design near the date, and rays around the eagle on the reverse. The rays were omitted in 1854, however, making this an important one-year type. This example is well struck and essentially untoned, save for a faint golden cast. Surface marks are absolutely minimal for the grade.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: P5)

772

1856-S 25C XF40 PCGS. CAC. Soft glimmers of luster remain in the protected areas on this XF survivor, filtering through rich violet and gray-gold patina. Well-defined for this elusive San Francisco issue, as evidenced by the strong detail remaining in the centers of the often-weak stars. Population: 2 in 40, 27 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P7)

773

1857 25C MS65 PCGS. Hints of peach and gold color give way swiftly to cloud-white toning, which covers most of the centers on this immensely lustrous Gem quarter. Attractively detailed with a single spot of deep toning below the left edge of Liberty's shield. Population: 40 in 65, 32 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P2)

774

1857-S 25C MS64 NGC. The 1857-S Seated quarter is one of the major rarities in Seated coinage, from a mintage of just 82,000 coins. The combined NGC and PCGS population is a mere six coins in MS64 with exactly one finer piece, and the six Choice examples include possible resubmissions. This piece has a bold strike, deep gray and iridescent toning, and satiny underlying luster. Census: 3 in 64, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7)

775

1858-S 25C XF40 PCGS. Dusky peach and blue-green hues embrace minimally abraded surfaces that still show subtle luster. A small glint of fresh silver is noted at Liberty's foot. Population: 6 in 40, 10 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P8)

776

1860-S 25C VF30 PCGS. With a mintage of just 56,000 pieces and a low survival rate, the 1860-S quarter is a rarity almost regardless of grade. This appealing survivor at the midpoint is richly toned violet-blue overall, with lighter gray at the worn spots on the devices and hints of rose throughout. Population: 5 in 30, 4 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P8)

777

1861-S 25C XF40 PCGS. Rich plum and rose toning cedes to pink and peach at parts of this San Francisco quarter. Where not worn, this piece offers pleasing detail. Population: 4 in 40, 11 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P7)

778

1864-S 25C VF35 PCGS. This Civil War-era date was little-saved at the time of release, and with just 20,000 coins struck, it is little wonder that survivors are scarce regardless of condition. This Choice VF survivor has pale silver-gray centers with gold-orange toning at the faintly lustrous borders. Minimally abraded and attractive. Population: 3 in 35, 10 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P7)

779

1865 25C MS62 PCGS. Faint suggestions of blue add a touch of color to the pale silver-white luster of this pre-Motto quarter. Well-defined overall, if soft on the right obverse stars. Population: 5 in 62, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

780

1867 25C XF45 PCGS. CAC. For a Choice XF coin, this early With Motto piece is amply lustrous beneath deep violet central toning with olive-green fringes. Solidly struck with excellent eye appeal. Population: 5 in 45, 24 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P5)

781

1872-S 25C VF20 PCGS. CAC. Slate and lighter gold-gray hues mingle on this moderately worn S-mint quarter, part of a mintage of just 83,000 pieces. Both sides are remarkably smooth with no singularly mentionable abrasions. A desirable coin for the series enthusiast. Population: 3 in 20, 13 finer (2/10).
From The Clyde Collection of Seated Quarters.(Registry values: P8)

782

1873 25C Arrows MS64 PCGS. A charming near-Gem example of this short-lived type, frosty beneath thick cloud-white toning that takes on gold and orange elements near the rims. Great eye appeal. Population: 32 in 64, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

783

1877 25C MS64 PCGS. Type Two Reverse. Brilliant aside from a hint of almond-gold toning. Meticulously struck and prooflike with virtually mark-free surfaces. An appealing Seated type coin.(Registry values: P1)

784

1877 25C MS66 NGC. Type Two Reverse. White satiny fields highlight well struck, frosted motifs. The untoned surfaces are impeccably well preserved. An outstanding Premium Gem specimen that is somewhat scarce in the better Uncirculated grades. Census: 46 in 66, 36 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: P1)

785

1877-S 25C MS65 NGC. A softly frosted silver Gem of this high-mintage Seated quarter issue, made in the quantity of nearly 9 million coins. Yet few today achieve or exceed the Gem level. This piece offers grayish-gold coloration on both sides and a paucity of mentionable contact. Census: 31 in 65, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

786

1879 25C MS67 PCGS. CAC. Type Two Reverse. Partially prooflike fields establish modest variance with the frosty design motifs of this lovely Superb Gem. Both sides are essentially untoned and devoid of mentionable marks. This is a highly appealing specimen, appropriately designated as such with the CAC green label. Population: 22 in 67, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1)

787

1885 25C MS64 NGC. Blue to violet peripheral tints, slightly stronger on the obverse, give way to near-brilliance at the centers of this Choice Seated quarter. Great eye appeal for the low-mintage issue. Census: 14 in 64, 28 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2)

788

1891 25C MS65 NGC. Strong gold and orange peripheral toning yields to medium-gray at the lustrous centers. A well struck Gem example of this final Philadelphia Seated quarter issue.(Registry values: P1)

Proof Seated Quarters

789

1858 25C PR64 NGC. Glimmers of golden toning visit the rims, and a suggestion of a streak of deeper amber runs nearly in a line following the farthest edge of the eagle's right wing. Despite scattered planchet flaws an a few grade-defining contact marks, the eye appeal holds strong. A solid near-Gem specimen of this underrated issue. Census: 20 in 64, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

790

1859 25C PR64 NGC. Type One Obverse, Type Two Reverse. This deeply toned Choice proof retains slight evidence of cameo contrast beneath its blue, turquoise, and heather toning. A few minor contact marks prevent a higher grade. Census: 38 in 64, 31 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

791

1860 25C PR63 PCGS. Type Two Obverse, Type One Reverse. Outstanding reflectivity with a few minor contact marks and hairlines in the gold-kissed fields. Sharply lustrous with a mild cameo effect. Housed in an old green label holder.(Registry values: P3)

792

1860 25C PR63 PCGS. Type Two Obverse, Type One Reverse. Bold orange and champagne central toning is edged in royal-blue. A well-defined Select proof with hairlines largely hidden by the patina. PCGS has graded 66 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

793

1862 25C PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. This stone-white Civil War near-Gem contrasts icy devices with glassy fields. Delicate die polish lines are apparent once viewed with a loupe, but hairlines are trivial when encountered. A stingy 550 proofs were struck. Population: 4 in 64 Cameo, 5 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P3)

794

1863 25C PR63 Cameo NGC. Rose, gold, and violet peripheral hues grace the margins of this Select piece, while the inner fields and the devices are silver and beautiful. Away from the faintly hairlined fields, the devices are frosted and gorgeous. Census: 5 in 63 Cameo, 20 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P3)

795

1865 25C PR63 PCGS. Splashes of low intensity rainbow-like patination adorn this Select proof quarter. A couple of small, inoffensive obverse marks are all that stand in the way of a finer grade.(Registry values: P3)

796

1865 25C PR64 Deep Cameo PCGS. Occasional wisps of barely discernible light tan patina visit this near-Gem proof quarter, and a decisive strike sharpens the frosted design elements, all of which are highlighted against the mirrored fields. Some unobtrusive handling marks in the fields leave no adverse impact. Population: 4 in 64 Deep Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

797

1866 25C Motto PR66 Cameo NGC. Navy-blue, rose-red, and lime-gold adorn the obverse. Golden-brown and apple-green consume the reverse. Precisely struck and prominently mirrored. A delightful high grade proof from a scant emission of 725 pieces. Introductory year of the Motto type, patterns excluded. Census: 4 in 66 Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

798

1867 25C PR63 PCGS. The obverse is toned in turquoise and lilac, and the reverse has a brilliant center with a frame of blue and iridescent toning. This pleasing piece will serve the type collector or specialist nicely. Population: 43 in 63, 58 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

799

1867 25C PR65 Deep Cameo PCGS. The 1867 is well-known as a low total mintage issue with only 20,000 strikes for circulation plus another 625 proofs. This is a remarkable example that is untoned throughout. The fields are unfathomably deep in their reflectivity and the devices are heavily frosted, thus yielding the Cameo effect so desired. One tiny planchet void is located in the right obverse field. Population: 3 in 65 Deep Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

800

1868 25C PR64 NGC. A degree of field-motif contrast is noted, especially on the obverse. Minimally abraded surfaces exhibit well struck devices and just a touch of peripheral color. Housed in a prior generation holder. Census: 28 in 64, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

801

1868 25C PR64 Cameo PCGS. Strongly contrasted with silver-gray centers that yield to colors at the edges, amber-orange on the obverse with a more violet tone on the reverse. Population: 6 in 64 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

802

1876 25C PR65 NGC. Type Two reverse with narrow bases on the A in STATES. The base of the 6 is lightly repunched. The obverse displays variegated orange-red and aqua-blue toning, while the reverse is bathed in cobalt-blue with glimpses of plum-mauve. Smooth aside from a faint line above the QU in QUAR. Census: 31 in 65, 21 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

803

1877 25C PR64 Cameo PCGS. Type Two Reverse. This near-Gem has darkly mirrored fields and prominent obverse cameo contrast. Brilliant throughout aside from a wisp of tan toning near OF. An intricately struck representative of a proof emission of just 510 pieces. Population: 5 in 64 Cameo, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

804

1882 25C PR65 PCGS. Subtle blue, violet, and green hues embrace this Gem proof, which gleams through the patina. Sharply struck and pleasingly preserved, an attractive specimen in all respects. Population: 35 in 65, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

805

1883 25C PR65 Cameo NGC. This fully brilliant Gem Cameo proof has entirely untoned obverse and reverse surfaces. The design elements are sharp, and the eye appeal is excellent. Here is a wonderful piece for the connoisseur. Census: 17 in 65 Cameo, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

806

1883 25C PR67 Cameo NGC. A brilliant Superb Gem that possesses darkly mirrored fields and thickly frosted devices. A razor-sharp strike contributes further to the quality. Devoid of hairlines, although the obverse field has a hint of a retained lamination and a faint line is noted beneath star 1. Census: 5 in 67 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

807

1884 25C PR65 PCGS. Gold CAC. This absolutely incredible Gem proof has gorgeous gold, violet, and blue toning on each side. The devices are boldly defined and lustrous, with surrounding deep mirrored fields, creating excellent contrast. In addition to meeting the stringent CAC requirements, this piece has been given the coveted Gold CAC sticker for its incredible quality. Population: 32 in 65, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

808

1891 25C PR68 ★ NGC. Cherry-red and jade-green dominate the obverse, while the reverse exhibits ocean-blue borders and lavender-red centers. A pinpoint-sharp strike and hairline-free fields confirm the lofty third party grade. The fields are flashy, but a Cameo designation is absent due to the rich and attractive patina. A gorgeous and unimprovable specimen that would be the cornerstone of many advanced collections of silver proof type sets. A scant 600 proofs were coined for the final year of the long-lived Seated type. Census: 3 in 68 ★ , 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

809

1891 25C PR65 Cameo NGC. CAC. Wonderful cameo contrast is the result of deeply mirrored fields around lustrous devices on each side. The surfaces are mostly brilliant silver, with a delicate frame of gold toning. Census: 12 in 65 Cameo, 33 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

Barber Quarters

810

1892 25C MS65 NGC. Type Two Reverse. A colorful Gem example of this first-year issue, frosty beneath rich toning. Orange and plum peripheral hues yield to pale silver centers.(Registry values: N1793)

811

1892 25C MS66 NGC. CAC. Type Two Reverse. Effervescent luster beneath iridescent toning, with gold, peach, and blue-green hues dominant on each side. Carefully preserved with amazing eye appeal. NGC has graded just 24 numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

812

1892-O 25C MS65 PCGS. Type One Reverse. Rich gold-orange, rose, and violet-silver shadings wash over this first-year New Orleans Barber quarter. Well-preserved surfaces are softly lustrous beneath the patina. Population: 35 in 65, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

813

1892-O 25C MS65 PCGS. Type Two Reverse. Dusky amber and plum hues drape softly shimmering fields and strongly struck devices. A captivating Gem with endless eye appeal. Population: 35 in 65, 10 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

814

1893-O 25C MS66 PCGS. The cream-gray devices are accompanied by dappled golden-brown and emerald-green fields and borders. Sharply defined and lustrous with magnificent preservation. The "sweet spot" of the cheek is remarkably smooth. Exceptional quality for this early New Orleans issue. Population: 9 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

815

1896 25C MS65 PCGS. CAC. Violet, blue-green, and gold-orange hues dominate the eye appeal of this well struck Gem. Excellent eye appeal with only tiny faults in the portrait area. Population: 37 in 65, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

816

1896-S 25C Good 6 ANACS. Semibright surfaces are toned in cobalt-blue, violet, and russet. The design features are well defined; L TY of LIBERTY shows as do RIB of PLURIBUS and UN of UNUM. Liberty's jawline and eye are strong, as is the shield outline. Scattered marks are in line with a coin experiencing heavy circulation.(Registry values: N991)

817

1896-S 25C VG8 ANACS. An unusual feature of any circulated 1896-S quarter is a full rim on both sides. The typical example is lower grade, usually AG or Good, with the borders merged into the peripheral design elements. This piece is fully original, with light tan devices and deeper gray fields.(Registry values: N991)

818

1897-O 25C MS61 NGC. Wisps of greenish-tan and reddish-tan gravitate to the borders and a relatively strong strike brings out good detail on the design elements. Several handling marks are visible on Liberty's cheek and neck. David Lawrence (1994) gives an R.5 rarity rating in Mint State.(Registry values: N1793)

819

1901-S 25C Fair 2 NGC. Though the light gray surfaces are extensively worn, the obverse maintains a partial rim. On the reverse, the merging is complete, but does not extend to the all-important mintmark.(Registry values: N1)

820

1901-S 25C AG3 PCGS. The date and mintmark are easily distinct from the rim, although portions of the reverse peripheral legend have begun to merge into the border. The predominantly cream-gray surfaces are smooth aside from a pair of trivial hair-thin marks on the portrait. The key date of the series, and typically encountered in grades between Fair and VG.(Registry values: N1)

821

1901-S 25C VG8 PCGS. Neither minted in such high numbers as the 1896-S issue nor saved to the same extent as the 1913-S, the 1901-S quarter is key to the Barber series. This is a fundamentally pleasing Very Good representative of the issue, light gray in color with slight deepening around the peripheral devices. The center of the word LIBERTY is gone, though the L and Y are intact and parts of the I and T remain. Few sharp digs are present, though close inspection reveals a number of wispy abrasions, as well as a pinscratch running from the D in GOD into Liberty's cap.(Registry values: N2998)

822

1906-O 25C MS65 NGC. CAC. Apple-green and golden-gray patination bathes the lustrous surfaces of this attractive Gem, and a well executed strike leaves strong definition on the design elements. A few minute grade-consistent marks are unimportant. Housed in a prior generation holder. Census: 22 in 65, 12 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

823

1908 25C MS65 PCGS. Strong and satiny luster dominates the eye appeal of this Gem. Each side is silver-white at first glance, but light green and gold elements appear with close inspection. Population: 31 in 65, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

824

1911-D 25C MS63 NGC. Lustrous surfaces are nearly untoned except for wisps of light peripheral color, including a toning spot below the second L of DOLLAR. Well struck and revealing just a few minor handling marks. Census: 13 in 63, 19 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

825

1912 25C MS66 PCGS. Pastel multicolored toning drapes the lustrous surfaces of this splendid Premium Gem and a decisive strike delivers sharp definition to the design elements. Well preserved and housed in a first generation holder. Population: 16 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

826

1912 25C MS66 NGC. Both sides of this Premium Gem are uniformly toned in variegated, medium intensity apple-green, lavender, gold-orange, and gray. Lustrous surfaces are sharply struck and minimally marked. Census: 7 in 66, 1 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

827

1912-S 25C MS65 PCGS. CAC. Delightfully lustrous with a touch of satin on the obverse. The centers are minimally toned, though liberal forest-green and sage elements are dappled near the rims. Population: 20 in 65, 11 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

828

1913-S 25C Good 4 ANACS. Typical of extensively circulated examples, the reverse border is merged with the tops of the letters around part of its periphery. This attractive light tan representative has deeper toning in the fields.(Registry values: N991)

829

1913-S 25C Good 6 PCGS. Although well worn, the obverse and reverse borders are intact, and the central motifs show some internal detail, including the L and Y in LIBERTY. The devices are light silver and the fields are deep steel.(Registry values: N991)

830

1914 25C MS66 NGC. Whispers of golden-tan adhere to the lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem. Sharply struck except for the usual softness in the upper right shield corner. A few minute marks are noted on the obverse portrait. Census: 12 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

831

1915-S 25C MS66 PCGS. Brightly lustrous for this late San Francisco Barber quarter issue. Both sides are minimally toned and carefully preserved. Population: 12 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Barber Quarters

832

1892 25C PR66 NGC. CAC. Type Two Reverse. This first-year proof issue was both produced and saved in generous numbers, judging from the population reports, a fortunate occurrence for collectors. This Premium Gem proof boasts splendid coloration in shades of emerald, lilac, and cobalt-blue. Visible contact is nonexistent, but the eye appeal is quite evident. In an old-style NGC holder. Census: 35 in 66, 36 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

833

1893 25C PR64 NGC. A strongly reflective, richly toned near-Gem proof specimen from this second-year Barber quarter issue. Strong green-gold and blue hues dominate the eye appeal, though faint hairlines are hidden under the patina.(Registry values: N1793)

834

1894 25C PR66 Cameo NGC. A shimmering Premium Gem with stark black-and-white surfaces on each side. The well-preserved mirrors are exceptionally deep, and the fully struck devices display rich frost. At 972 specimens coined, this issue has the second-highest proof mintage of any Barber quarter and is a perfect early-date, type coin. Census: 13 in 66 Cameo, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

835

1894 25C PR67 Cameo NGC. An incredible Superb Gem Cameo proof with brilliant silver at the center of the obverse, framed by a blend of rose, violet, and blue toning. The reverse is entirely toned in similar hues. It is uncommon for such a wonderful Barber quarter to appear in the marketplace. Census: 13 in 67 Cameo, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

836

1895 25C PR66 Cameo PCGS. Faintly gold-tinged with outstanding contrast for a coin labeled "merely" Cameo. This carefully preserved beauty offers uncommonly high quality for an earlier Barber proof. Population: 14 in 66 Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

837

1896 25C PR68 Ultra Cameo NGC. A strong candidate for inclusion in either an advanced date set or a Superb quality type set, this beautiful proof is free of toning. A powerful strike leaves complete definition on the design elements. The thick mint frost over the devices forms a splendid contrast to the illimitable depth of reflectivity in the glassy fields. This coin really needs to be seen to be fully appreciated. NGC and PCGS combined report 16 1896 Barber quarters at the PR68 Ultra/Deep Cameo grade level, with three Ultra/Deep Cameo examples finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

838

1898 25C PR65 NGC. This Gem proof is considerably contrasted despite the rich green and blue toning over each side, though NGC has declined to award the Cameo designation. Carefully preserved beneath the patina.(Registry values: N1793)

839

1899 25C PR65 Cameo PCGS. A few hundred 1899 quarter proofs out of a mintage of 846 pieces have apparently survived to the present, judging from PCGS/NGC reports. Relatively few of these have the Cameo designation. The present Gem Cameo displays hints of light gold, slightly more so on the reverse. Well preserved surfaces exhibit exquisitely struck design motifs. Population: 8 in 65 Cameo, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

840

1902 25C PR64 PCGS. Both sides of this sharply defined Choice proof have light champagne toning. The fields are fully mirrored and the devices are lightly reflective, with some contrast evident.(Registry values: N1793)

841

1902 25C PR66 NGC. Ex: Eliasberg. The obverse exhibits light peripheral toning and a hint of smudging in the center, while rich violet and aquamarine colors dominate the reverse. Census: 6 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).
Ex: J.M. Clapp, who purchased the piece directly from the Philadelphia Mint, 5/1902; John H. Clapp; Clapp estate, 1942, to Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr.; Eliasberg Collection (Bowers and Merena, 4/1997), lot 1576, which realized $2,750.(Registry values: N2998)

842

1903 25C PR63 Cameo PCGS. Impressively frosted on the devices with the contrast heightened by amber and blue toning that embraces the peripheral mirrors. A few slide marks on the cheek determine the grade. Population: 5 in 63 Cameo, 45 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

843

1904 25C PR67 NGC. A sharply defined and fully brilliant Superb Gem proof, this 1904 quarter has a trace of contrast between the fields and devices, although that contrast is insufficient for a Cameo designation. Rarely do any early 20th century proofs receive such a designation. Census: 36 in 67, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

844

1906 25C PR66 NGC. CAC. Blue-green and gold peripheral elements, slightly stronger on the reverse, frame minimally toned, strongly mirrored centers. An attractive Premium Gem from the brilliant era. Census: 44 in 66, 34 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

845

1906 25C PR66 NGC. CAC. A fully brilliant and precisely struck high grade proof type coin. The lightly frosted devices exhibit mild but consistent contrast with the glassy fields. No more than 675 proofs were issued. Census: 44 in 66, 34 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

846

1906 25C PR66 PCGS. Both sides of this stunning proof have impeccable mirrored fields and frosty devices beneath dappled iridescence. A candidate for a Cameo designation, if not certified as such by PCGS. Population: 31 in 66, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

847

1909 25C PR64 PCGS. Though boldly toned green-gold and cobalt-blue over most of each side, this near-Gem proof also shows ample silver gleams. Minimally hairlined for the PR64 designation.(Registry values: N1793)

848

1909 25C PR64 NGC. Ex: Pittman. Splashes of lilac, electric blue, and deep red highlight the needle-sharp devices. The surfaces appear remarkably clean for the grade, and there is powerful reflectivity throughout. A scant 650 proofs were struck.(Registry values: N1793)

849

1909 25C PR66 PCGS. A lovely Premium Gem proof with a splash of blue and violet on the brilliant obverse. The reverse has delicate gold toning. Population: 27 in 66, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

850

1911 25C PR64 PCGS. A pleasing Choice proof with deep iridescent toning on both sides. The devices are lustrous and the fields are reflective with fully evident contrast. Population: 50 in 64, 85 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

851

1911 25C PR66 Cameo PCGS. Sea-green, copper-gold, and lemon-yellow intermingle on each side of this lovely Premium Gem proof, one of only 543 pieces made in 1911. Much luster radiates from beneath, and the bold strike and good contrast complete an attractive package. PCGS has only certified a handful finer. Population: 12 in 66 Cameo, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

852

1912 25C PR65 Cameo PCGS. Blue-green and gold elements drape otherwise silver surfaces on this Cameo Gem specimen. Sharply struck with uncommon contrast for this late issue. Population: 8 in 65 Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

853

1913 25C PR66 PCGS. Dusky lilac, sun-gold, and apple-green enrich this intricately impressed Premium Gem. Housed in a green label holder. A scant 613 proofs were struck. Population: 27 in 66, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

854

1914 25C PR68 NGC. Gorgeously patinated in swaths of ocean-blue and orange-gold with a blush of lilac on the portrait. The strike is razor-sharp, particularly on the fletchings, claws, and shield corners. A flawless and exemplary type representative. Census: 8 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

855

1914 25C PR66 Cameo NGC. A stone-white Premium Gem that favorably compares frosty devices and flashy fields. A needle-sharp strike throughout, even on the fletchings and the right (facing) shield corner. The lowest proof mintage of the type, as only 380 specimens were issued. Census: 9 in 66 Cameo, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Standing Liberty Quarters

856

1916 25C VF25 PCGS. Deep cream-gray toning blankets this original key date Standing Liberty quarter. All legends are bold, as are portions of the shield and drapery. Every collector of the series knows that only 52,000 pieces were struck, due to delays in design introduction that unexpectedly extended the Barber series for an additional year.(Registry values: N2998)

857

1916 25C --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. This coin just barely deserves a Details grade. Yes, it does show evidence of light cleaning, but it must have been shortly after minting. The surfaces have taken on a light gray patina, but more importantly there are scattered specks of russet around the devices, the kind of color that takes decades to accrue on a coin. The devices are well-detailed on each side with only slight wear over the high points.(Registry values: N2998)

858

1916 25C AU58 NGC. The first year of issue 1916 Standing Liberty quarter is perhaps the most sought-after piece in the entire series, along with the 1918/7-S. Its 52,000-piece mintage is second only to the '18/7-S, that according to J.H. Cline in his Standing Liberty Quarters reference, has an estimated production of about 2,500 coins.
The About Uncirculated 58 example offered here displays bright silver-white surfaces that possess ample luster. Most of the design elements exhibit fairly good detail for an issue that is almost always weakly struck, though the shield is soft, especially the inner one. A few light circulation marks are visible, the most notable being a linear abrasion on the left gate and Liberty's wrist(Registry values: N2998)

859

1916 25C MS63 PCGS. The 1916 Standing Liberty quarter and 1909-S VDB cent are renowned, low-mintage first-year keys in their respective series. But unlike the much-heralded, long-anticipated, and widely hoarded 1909-S VDB, the 1916 quarters slipped quietly into circulation in January 1917, along with a much-larger batch of 1917 Type One quarters from Philadelphia. It is important to note that only 52,000 quarters were minted, compared to 484,000 pieces of the S VDB--a mintage nine times smaller. The collecting public seems to have caught on quickly, however, and snatched up many examples; however, most are in circulated condition, especially the lower circulated grades. This is a splendid coin whose thick mint frost glows through the light golden and lilac toning. Curiously, all the design elements except Liberty's head are fully brought up. An outstanding example of this rare, first-year issue. Housed in a first-generation holder, the insert reads 1916 but the PCGS number is 5706, which is the number for a 1917.(Registry values: N2998)

860

1917 25C Type One MS65 Full Head NGC. CAC. Light peach and pink hues strongly influence the obverse of this Full Head Gem, though they decrease in importance on the reverse. An excellent pick for a similarly toned type set.(Registry values: N1793)

861

1917 25C Type One MS66 Full Head PCGS. Pleasingly detailed and satiny with silver-gray interiors. Golden-tan tints dominate the margins, and the obverse also shows dots of deep crimson close to the rims.(Registry values: N1793)

862

1917 25C Type One MS66 Full Head PCGS. This virtually brilliant Premium Gem features a typically sharp Type One strike. Dazzlingly lustrous fields are practically untouched to the unaided eye.(Registry values: N1793)

863

1917 25C Type One MS66 Full Head NGC. This is an impressive Premium Gem with frosty silver luster and a sharp strike. Both sides have subtle gold toning over ivory surfaces.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

864

1917-D 25C Type One MS65 Full Head PCGS. CAC. Speckled gray-gold and iridescent toning masks the frosty silver luster of this boldly defined Gem. The surfaces have the usual fine-grained appearance found on nearly all 1917 Type One quarters.(Registry values: N1793)

865

1917-D 25C Type One MS65 Full Head PCGS. Lustrous surfaces display golden-gray patination and exceptionally well struck design features. There are no significant marks to report.(Registry values: N1793)

866

1917-D 25C Type One MS66 Full Head PCGS. A rare degree of eye appeal is seen on this gorgeous Premium Gem. Lovely mattelike surfaces display ample frostiness and pinpoint detailing. An edging of reddish-golden-brown toning frames the obverse, while similar coloration affects all but the high points and the lower border of the reverse.(Registry values: N1793)

867

1917-S 25C Type One MS66 Full Head PCGS. Ex: Walser. Dappled golden-brown and emerald-green toning adorns the borders of this lustrous and fully struck Premium Gem. The 1917-S is the scarcest of the three Type One issues for the date, and unabraded examples are desirable. Population: 61 in 66 Full Head, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

868

1917 25C Type Two MS67 Full Head NGC. Despite the large mintage, 1917 Type Two Standing Liberty quarters are scarce in Full Head, Mint State condition. At the Superb Gem level the issue is quite rare. NGC has certified 12 examples in MS67 Full Head, with none finer, while PCGS has graded only seven such specimens, with none finer (2/10). The present coin displays untoned surfaces with soft satiny luster. Complete detail shows on the shield and toes, as well as the all-important head of Liberty.(Registry values: N4719)

869

1917-D 25C Type Two MS65 Full Head NGC. With a mintage of 6.2 million pieces and the first year of the redesigned obverse, it would seem logical that Full Head pieces would be plentiful, but that simply is not the case. NGC has only certified 28 coins in MS65 Full Head, with seven finer (1/10). This brilliant example has exceptional, bright, coruscating mint luster. Just a few tiny marks prevent an even higher grade.(Registry values: N2998)

870

1917-S 25C Type Two MS65 Full Head PCGS. The 1917-S Type Two quarter comes with 3% or fewer that are struck with Full Head detail (Jay Cline, 2007). This piece shows exceptionally sharp detail on the horizontal and vertical shield lines which match the fully defined head on this Gem. Lustrous surfaces display soft golden-gray patina. Some light grazes are visible on the obverse. Population: 54 in 65 Full Head, 18 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

871

1918-S 25C MS62 Full Head NGC. A satiny Mint State piece, this lovely quarter has brilliant silver surfaces with a touch of gold toning on each side. The head details are bold, while the inner shield is weak. Here is an important opportunity for the advanced collector.(Registry values: N991)

872

1918/7-S 25C Genuine PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-008.5. The PCGS number ending in .92 suggests Cleaned as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of a VF specimen that has been cleaned and exhibits reverse damage. A hairlined slate-gray representative of this coveted series key. The reverse damage is minor and consists of two small digs in the O in OF and the O in DOLLAR. The thick downstroke of the underdigit 7 is unmistakable within the 8 in the date.

873

1918/7-S 25C AU55 PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-008.5. The 1918/7-S is the key to the series in better grades. This is partly because only one obverse die bore an overdate, but principally because the variety went undiscovered until 1937. By then, many if not most examples were worn to the point that the date was no longer readable. The present piece, however, appears to Uncirculated upon first inspection. It is lustrous and brilliant with impressively unabraded surfaces. Telltale friction on Liberty's left (facing) leg confirms a momentary encounter with circulation, but the eye appeal is outstanding.(Registry values: N4719)

874

1918/7-S 25C AU55 NGC. FS-101, formerly FS-008.5. Mike Thorne, in the article "The Standing Liberty Quarter: An All-American Gem" in the March 2001 Coins, counsels, "For the collector, the Standing Liberty quarter contains at least one major stopper or two, if you count the 1918/7-S overdate." While he suggests that "if you're not into overdates, then it's easy to bypass" the 1918/7-S, it has long been considered a collector staple, with series enthusiasts chasing any opportunity at a higher-end example, such as the present piece. And AU55 is indeed a high grade for this key. The surfaces are bright and retain generous portions of mint luster around the devices. While much brightness can be seen on each side, there is a slight overlay of light golden patina also in evidence. The only marks of any note are a couple in the reverse fields.(Registry values: N4719)

875

1918/7-S 25C AU58 PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-008.5. A whisper of gold toning near the rims precludes full brilliance, but that only confirms the originality of this lustrous Borderline Uncirculated example. Remarkably unabraded except for a brief thin line above the ER in QUARTER. A trace of wear on Liberty's knee is all that prevents a much finer grade. The center of the head is softly defined, as usual for this key overdate, but the remainder of the strike is crisp. The downstroke of the 7 is apparent to the unaided eye, and it is curious that the variety went unreported for nearly 20 years after its production.(Registry values: N4719)

876

1919-S 25C MS61 Full Head NGC. The 1919-S is an undisputed key to the Standing Liberty quarter series, and it is especially challenging with Full Head detail. This is a pleasing coin for the grade with light gray-rose color over each side, three sprigs in Liberty's cap and a hole in the ear, and minimally abraded surfaces. Census: 3 in 61 Full Head, 39 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

877

1920-S 25C MS61 Full Head NGC. The 1920-S is one of the rarest and most underrated quarters with a Full Head in the entire series. Cline (2007) rates it second or third in the series in terms of value for Full Head pieces. This bright example has a couple of reverse field marks which prevent a higher grade. Census: 4 in 61 Full Head, 56 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

878

1921 25C AU55 NGC. The U.S. Mints concentrated on silver dollar production in 1921, and minor silver denominations were neglected. Thus the 1921 is fairly low mintage, and carries a formidable premium in all grades. Lustrous and lightly toned with unmarked fields and only minor wear on the devices.(Registry values: N991)

879

1921 25C MS66 NGC. The surfaces display frosty mint luster with light gold and gray shadings overall and dots of sage near the rims. Minor striking softness is noted on the shield and head, in the latter case enough to deny a Full Head designation but typical for the issue. The eye appeal is outstanding. Tied for numerically finest known to NGC or PCGS (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

880

1923-S 25C MS61 Full Head NGC. Solidly struck for the issue, though typical softness is noted on the lower shield. A lustrous, faintly gold-tinged coin with few overt abrasions for the grade.(Registry values: N991)

881

1923-S 25C MS66 Full Head PCGS. The 1923-S has long been considered a key to the Standing Liberty quarter series. It is often favorably compared to the higher visibility 1921, and it is just a bit less rare than that date. This is a splendidly preserved example that has lovely rose-violet toning interspersed with lilac with thick underlying mint frost. The head detail is remarkably strong, and there is just one rivet on the shield that is soft. The surfaces are exceptionally clean on each side. Population: 30 in 66 Full Head, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

882

1924 25C MS65 Full Head PCGS. Rich russet and amber peripheral hues give way to lustrous medium-gray at the centers. A sharp Gem with frosty eye appeal. PCGS has graded 40 finer Full Head coins (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

883

1924-S 25C MS65 NGC. Splashes of reddish-gold, purple, and blue toning concentrate mostly at the borders of this lustrous, well struck Gem. Nicely preserved throughout. Census: 59 in 65, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

884

1925 25C MS65 Full Head PCGS. Intense luster exudes from both sides of this lovely Gem, each of which displays hints of champagne-gold and violet patina. Nicely struck throughout. A couple of minor marks on the cheek might well prevent an even finer grade. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N991)

885

1925 25C MS66 Full Head NGC. Attentively struck on both head and shield, a wonderful Premium Gem example of this recessed-date issue. Light golden overtones grace strongly lustrous surfaces. Census: 35 in 66 Full Head, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

886

1926 25C MS64 Full Head PCGS. CAC. Dappled peach-gold and light silver-gray shadings embrace this Choice Full Head quarter. Excellent luster and strong eye appeal for the grade.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

887

1926 25C MS65 Full Head PCGS. Light gold and purple freckles are more prominent on the reverse of this well struck Gem. Devoid of mentionable marks. Population: 86 in 65 Full Head, 24 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

888

1926-S 25C MS66 NGC. Vibrant luster exudes from each side of this beautiful Premium Gem. Pastel multicolored toning is more extensive and slightly deeper in hue on the reverse. Generally well defined except for the usual softness on the shield. There are no marks of consequence. Census: 9 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

889

1926-S 25C MS62 Full Head NGC. Light golden accents grace otherwise silver-white surfaces. While a degree of weakness is noted on Liberty's shield, the details on the head clear the bar for the prized Full Head designation. Vibrantly lustrous with excellent eye appeal and surprisingly few abrasions for the grade. Census: 5 in 62 Full Head, 31 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

890

1928 25C MS64 Full Head PCGS. CAC. Golden overtones add color to this shining near-Gem. Excellent definition on both the head and the often-weak shield. Housed in a green label holder.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N491)

891

1928-D 25C MS67 NGC. An extraordinary Superb Gem. Both sides have fully brilliant centers with bright luster, while the margins are toned in blue and gold. Census: 9 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

892

1928-S 25C MS66 Full Head PCGS. A bold striking with tinges of golden and lilac toning over intensely lustrous surfaces. With its immense eye appeal, this Full Head Premium Gem makes for an ideal type coin. Population: 88 in 66 Full Head, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

893

1928-S 25C MS66 Full Head PCGS. Suitably struck with pretty luster beneath lovely orange-gold toning. Wisps of emerald patina are present at the periphery. Population: 88 in 66 Full Head, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

894

1928-S 25C MS67 Full Head PCGS. Large S. Pastel lime-green and rose-gold toning adorns this lustrous Superb Gem. The head is needle-sharp, and only the usual pair of shield rivets is indistinct. The obverse is immaculate, and the reverse has just a few minute marks on the left (facing) wing. Population: 12 in 67 Full Head, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

895

1929-S 25C MS66 Full Head NGC. Dappled olive-brown and purple toning is confined mostly to the borders of this Premium Gem, especially on the obverse. Lustrous, minimally abraded surfaces exhibit well struck devices, culminating in a Full Head on Liberty.(Registry values: N1793)

896

1930 25C MS66 Full Head NGC. Brightly lustrous with just a hint of golden peripheral toning overwhelmed by the shining silver-white in the centers. Strongly struck and carefully preserved.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

897

1930 25C MS66 Full Head PCGS. Light autumn-gold toning visits this lustrous high grade silver type coin. Immaculate aside from a solitary wispy mark in front of the eagle's beak. A sharp strike that shows a full outline on the two shield rivets near the waist.(Registry values: N1793)

898

1930 25C MS66 Full Head PCGS. Sharply impressed throughout. The bright mint frost is covered with an even layer of yellowish-golden patina, and the surfaces show no mentionable abrasions.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

899

1930 25C MS67 Full Head NGC. Compared to other dates, the 1930 Standing Liberty quarter is an available issue in Full Head designation. However, at the Superb Gem level, examples become quite rare. No coin has been certified finer in the Full Head designation at either of the leading grading services (2/10). The present coin is a magnificent specimen with brilliant lustrous fields and an exemplary strike.(Registry values: N2998)

900

1930 25C MS67 Full Head PCGS. CAC. Philadelphia coined slightly over 5.6 million quarters in 1930, the last year of the design. The Superb Gem offered here is an exemplary survivor from that final issue. Speckles of russet appear at the left obverse and parts of the frosty and boldly struck reverse. Tied for the finest Full Head example certified by either NGC or PCGS (0/10).(Registry values: N2998)

901

1930 25C MS67 Full Head NGC. The 1930 has long considered the ultimate type coin for the series in terms of availability and number of coins in Gem and better grades. That being said, for a "common" coin there are few Superb examples known. Each of the grading services has graded 30 such pieces and none are known finer (2/10). This example has bright, swirling mint frost and each side shows just a hint of even, pale golden toning. As expected from such a high-grade piece, there are no obvious (or not-so-obvious) abrasions present.(Registry values: N2998)

902

1930-S 25C MS66 Full Head NGC. A frosty and virtually untoned Full Head beauty, well-defined overall with just slight weakness on the shield. A carefully preserved coin from an issue difficult to find any finer with a Full Head; NGC has graded just 26 such pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Washington Quarters

903

1932-D 25C MS62 PCGS. Champagne-gold patina is imbued with traces of violet on the reverse. Lustrous surfaces reveal a few minute obverse marks.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1)

904

1932-D 25C MS62 PCGS. A brightly lustrous and minimally toned example of this popular first-year key issue. Well struck with scattered reed marks on the portrait that account for the grade.(Registry values: N1)

905

1932-D 25C MS63 PCGS. Luminous silver-gray through the centers with dappled, subdued orange and olive hues at the flanks. Slight striking softness gives this piece a subtle overall appearance.(Registry values: N208)

906

1932-D 25C MS63 PCGS. CAC. Lustrous champagne-gold surfaces are accented with wisps of violet. We present here a well struck piece that reveals just a few minor grade-defining marks. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N208)

907

1932-D 25C MS63 PCGS. A shining Select example of this popular first-year Washington quarter key, well struck with lovely luster beneath light silver-gray toning on the obverse and peach color on the reverse. Housed in a first-generation holder.(Registry values: N208)

908

1932-D 25C MS63 PCGS. The mintmark is clearly repunched. This first-year issue is popular among collectors because of its low original mintage of only 436,800 pieces. This Select example displays satin luster and attractive speckled toning near the periphery on both sides. A minimal number of trivial marks are consistent with the grade.(Registry values: N208)

909

1932-D 25C MS63 NGC. A fully brilliant example of this key date with pale golden-brown toning along part of the border on each side, with otherwise entirely untoned surfaces. A few tiny abrasions on each side are consistent with the grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N208)

910

1932-D 25C MS64 PCGS. This near-Gem key-date representative has satiny silver luster that is accented by hazy blue color and hints of light gold toning near the obverse border. The reverse is fully brilliant with a light ivory haze. A sharp strike brings out excellent definition on the design elements, as evidenced by the strands in Washington's hair. A shallow, diagonal mark is noted near Washington's jawline. A lovely piece with excellent technical quality and aesthetic appeal.(Registry values: N491)

911

1932-S 25C MS64 PCGS. Satiny luster is light silver-gray over most of each side, though the right obverse and reverse borders show green-gold and orange elements. Well struck with few individually significant marks.(Registry values: N208)

912

1935-S 25C MS67 NGC. Whispers of barely discernible gold and violet patina rest on the highly lustrous surfaces of this well impressed Superb Gem. Immaculately preserved throughout. Census: 31 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N991)

913

1936-D 25C MS67 PCGS. A scarce date in the Washington quarter series, and this Superb Gem is equal to the finest pieces that have ever been certified. NGC and PCGS have combined to grade a mere 16 examples in MS67, with none finer (2/10). This beautiful piece has splendid gold toning near the borders, framing the highly lustrous centers. Population: 10 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

914

1936-D 25C MS67 PCGS. This is one of the finest seen of this scarce and popular date. The luster is radiant throughout, with delicate peripheral gold toning on the obverse, while the reverse sports some pastel blue intermixed with gold. A strong loupe only reveals a few tiny marks on each side. It would be hard to imagine a finer example of this important and elusive date. Such quality will delight even the most advanced specialist of the series, and this coin is worthy of the finest Registry or date collection. Population: 10 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

915

1936-S 25C MS67 PCGS. Bands of apple-green and fire-red endow this beautiful Superb Gem. Bright, swirling mint luster sweeps the exquisitely smooth fields and devices. The 1936-S has a lower mintage than the much heralded 1936-D. A delight for the competitive Registry Set collector. Population: 27 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

916

1937 25C MS67 PCGS. This frosty Superb Gem is an amazing Washington quarter with brilliant silver surfaces and a trace of light gold toning. Neither NGC or PCGS have graded a finer example of this issue. Population: 51 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N208)

917

1940-S 25C MS67 PCGS. A superlative example with brilliant silver surfaces and accents of light gold and iridescent toning. Population: 39 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N208)

918

1940-S 25C MS67 PCGS. This amazing 1940-S quarter is sharply defined and it exhibits gold, violet, and blue toning, blended over frosty silver luster. Population: 39 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N208)

919

1941-S 25C MS67 PCGS. Small S. This amazing Superb Gem exhibits frosty silver luster with splashes of iridescence along the obverse and reverse borders. Population: 33 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

920

1942-D 25C MS68 NGC. Even though more than 17 million pieces were struck of the 1942-D, there are only two examples that have been certified in MS68. On this piece not only are the surfaces seemingly perfect, but both sides also display vivid, multicolored toning. As such this is a marvelous type coin or the ultimate example for this issue in a date and mintmark set.(Registry values: N991)

921

1942-D 25C Doubled Die Obverse AU58 PCGS. FS-101, formerly FS-015. The popular Guide Book variety, with doubling most visible at the left obverse lettering. Gold, amber, and plum peripheral accents yield to silver-white at the margins. Well struck with only slight friction visible on the high points.(Registry values: P1)

922

1945-D 25C MS67 PCGS. A beautiful Superb Gem with frosty silver luster and exceptional eye appeal. Both sides have a trace of champagne toning. Boldly struck with excellent design details. Population: 22 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

923

1950-S/D 25C MS65 NGC. FS-601, formerly FS-022. The line and curve of the D show plainly under the S, giving this Guide Book variety a stylized appearance in the mintmark area. This Gem has pale gold and pink peripheral tints around frosty silver-white centers. For the variety, Census: 14 in 65, 20 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N208)

924

1958-D 25C MS68 NGC. Magnificently toned in variegated apple-green, gold, and magenta colors over both sides. This one obviously spent a long time in a mint set container. A beautifully preserved Superb Gem with a good strike and impressive eye appeal. Unsurpassable in grade. Census: 4 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

925

1964-D 25C MS67 PCGS. CAC. While the amount will never be known, untold numbers (surely many thousands) of the 1964 quarters were melted in the 1979-1980 Silver Boom. It seems odd that of the 704 million pieces struck of the 1964-D, only 30 pieces have been certified at the MS67 level, and none are known finer at either service (2/10). This is a spectacularly toned example that has pale blue and rose centers on each side with darker multicolored toning in a long arc at the margins. As expected, the mint luster is bright and frosted, and the surfaces are virtually perfect.(Registry values: N208)

Proof Washington Quarters

926

1936 25C PR66 PCGS. The first issue of proof Washington quarters, this Premium Gem has fully brilliant silver surfaces with light gold toning over part of the obverse and all of the reverse. PCGS has only certified eight finer examples of this conditionally rare proof.(Registry values: N991)

927

1937 25C PR67 PCGS. This fully brilliant Superb Gem has entirely untoned silver surfaces with fully mirrored fields and reflective devices. It is scarce at this grade level, and extremely rare any finer. Population: 77 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

928

1938 25C PR68 ★ NGC. A mere 14 1938 quarters have been certified in the lofty grade of PR68 by NGC and PCGS combined. Four PR68s, and none finer, have been given NGC's coveted Star, the current piece among them. Luminous surfaces reveal whispers of yellow-gold with lilac accents. Sharply struck and immaculately preserved.(Registry values: N1793)

929

1952 25C PR67 Ultra Cameo NGC. Offered here is an absolutely incredible Superb Gem Ultra Cameo proof 1952 quarter, approaching the finest quality that has ever been certified. Both sides are fully brilliant with black and white contrast. There is no toning on either the obverse or reverse. Census: 4 in 67 Ultra Cameo, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

930

1955 25C PR69 Ultra Cameo NGC. Only the closest inspection reveals a thin frame of light gold toning at the extreme outer borders of this immaculate proof. Both sides have amazing black and white contrast. Census: 8 in 69 Ultra Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

931

1959 25C PR69 Ultra Cameo NGC. While the 1959 quarter is not as rare as the 1959 half in Ultra Cameo, it is still a very elusive coin. This is certainly one of the finest known, which is underscored by the grading services: Only four such coins have been certified by NGC, while PCGS has graded none in PR69 Deep Cameo, and unsurprisingly none are finer (2/10). The fields on this piece are exceptionally deep in their mirrored reflectivity, and the devices are snow-white, the result being strong field-to-device contrast. The surfaces are brilliant throughout and appear perfect.(Registry values: N991)

Early Half Dollars

932

1795 50C 2 Leaves VG8 PCGS. O-113, R.3. A worn but appealing example of this popular die pair, famous for the die break to the right of the date and the reverse blunder with the A in STATES punched over an E. Gold-gray color overall with deepening to slate at the margins.(Registry values: N991)

933

1795 50C 2 Leaves VG8 PCGS. O-105, R.3. Housed in a green label PCGS holder is an attractive 1795 half dollar with light gray surfaces. A few small abrasions are expected at this grade level. A few heavier scratches are visible beneath the left wing.(Registry values: N991)

934

1795 50C 2 Leaves--Graffiti--NGC. Fine Details. O-131, High R.4. A curved scratch rests on the right obverse field, and the obverse center and the field near star 3 display lesser scratches. A small obverse rim bump at 5:30 merits passing mention. Medium sea-green and gold toning. All legends are sharp.(Registry values: N1793)

935

1795 50C 2 Leaves Fine 15 PCGS. O-104, R.4. A small die lump below star 15 identifies the obverse, while a die defect that connects the ribbon knot to the rock above identifies the reverse. Light gray patina with hints of violet covers both sides, and the design elements exhibit appropriate detail. No mentionable post-strike impairments or adjustment marks are visible. An extremely attractive example for a midgrade type or variety collection.(Registry values: N1793)

936

1795 50C 2 Leaves VF30 PCGS. O-113a, R.4. The die crack atop LIBERTY is faint but present. Deep cobalt-blue and lavender patina drapes this impressively unabraded Flowing Hair type coin. One small spot at 2:30 on the reverse will identify this pleasing representative. The dies are moderately rotated.(Registry values: N2998)

937

1795 50C 2 Leaves AU58 NGC. O-103, R.5. The Flowing Hair type is widely pursued even in well worn grades, which is the condition of most survivors. Near-Mint examples are rarities, and invariably cause a stir on the auction floor when one is finally available for bids. The present Borderline Uncirculated piece displays medium variegated golden-russet and powder-blue patina. Luster shimmers throughout the hair and other design elements. The strike is good aside from bluntness on the eagle's claws. Occasional light adjustment marks on the portrait and obverse periphery are of mint origin and will be ignored by the experienced viewer. A significant opportunity for the advanced specialist.(Registry values: N4719)

938

1795 50C 2 Leaves AU58 NGC. O-104, R.4. A die defect lump below star 15 identifies this variety. The M in AMERICA is sharply recut on the reverse. This is the fifth appearance of an NGC AU58 1795 O-104 half dollar in our auctions since 2006, and the five appearances represent four different coins. Only five or six finer pieces have been offered in recent years. This near-Mint example is sharply detailed and nicely centered with full borders on both sides. Satiny luster remains beneath gold and iridescent toning on the obverse and the reverse. Census: 43 in 58, 35 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

939

1795 50C Small Head--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Fine Details. O-128, R.5. This is one of three Small Head obverse dies with the bust narrower than usual, partly due to short locks at the back of Liberty's head. Lightly cleaned, this piece has pleasing gray surfaces with darker peripheral toning and grade-consistent handling marks.

940

1801 50C Fine 12 PCGS. O-101, R.3. The more common of two varieties for the year but scarce in all grades, the O-101 is easily identified by its reverse, which shows a die break or "blob" at the arrowheads. This silver-gray example shows gold and charcoal accents around the peripheral devices. Marks are few, and the coin has a surprising level of gloss given the amount of wear.(Registry values: N991)

941

1802 50C --Obverse Damage--NGC. Fine Details. O-101, R.3. Sole die pair for the year. The lower obverse shows several sets of strong parallel lines as well as tiny rounded pockmarks that seem to form the letters "CO." Otherwise, a light gray Fine example with elements of tan and violet.(Registry values: N1)

942

1803 50C Large 3 AU50 ICG. O-101, R.3. Attributed by large 3 with vertical serif, 1 touching curl, five berries, and 12 arrowheads. Golden-russet, sky-blue, and olive-green adorn this minimally abraded Draped Bust half. Luster shimmers from the hair, shield, plumage, and borders. Light wear on the jaw and shoulder confirms brief circulation, but the devices display pleasing definition.(Registry values: N2998)

943

1807 50C Draped Bust XF45 NGC. CAC. O-108, R.3. This cream-gray Choice XF Bust half has noticeable remaining luster, and bagmarks are refreshingly absent. Faint hairlines on the reverse exergue are of little interest. The centers show slight incompleteness, but the strike is superior for this scarce early silver type.(Registry values: N1793)

944

1807 50C Draped Bust XF45 NGC. O-109a, R.3. The late state of O-109, with die crack across the top of STATES, is more available than the early state, but still scarce. This Choice XF example is luminous with a silver-gray base, but under a light, the surfaces come alive with rich peach-orange and violet toning.(Registry values: N1793)

945

1807 50C Draped Bust XF45 NGC. Ex: Jules Reiver Collection. O-110a, R.3, though labeled simply as O-110. Numerous curved die cracks are now obvious throughout the peripheries. Richly toned in lavender and steel-gray, this attractively defined piece has a reasonable central strike and is not unduly marked for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

946

1807 50C Draped Bust MS62 PCGS. CAC. O-102, R.2. Stars 7, 8, and 13 are close to the L, Y, and bust tip, respectively. On the reverse a leaf points to the extreme right base of the I in AMERICA. This is a lovely coin that shows some prooflike reflectivity in the obverse left field, while elsewhere the somewhat deeper toning diminishes the luster a bit, likely accounting for the grade. The eye appeal is quite high, with tinges of olive, ice-blue, gold, and powder-gray predominating. This piece is tied for the lower end of the Condition Census in Steve Herrman's auction reference. Population for all varieties: 24 in 62, 32 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

Bust Half Dollars

947

1807 50C Large Stars, 50 Over 20 AU55 NGC. O-112, R.1. Tan-gold, lilac, and olive-green envelop the obverse, while the reverse features aquamarine, orange, plum-red, and gold. The fields display faint marks beneath the toning, but the overall appearance is clean. A pleasing example from the inaugural year of the Capped Bust design.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 2/2001), lot 5869; Summer FUN Signature (Heritage, 7/2007), lot 858, which realized $2,760.(Registry values: N1793)

948

1807 50C Bearded Goddess Genuine PCGS. O-111a, R.5. Large Stars, 50 Over 20 Reverse. A famous die state listed in the Guide Book. The PCGS number ending in .95 indicates that Scratched is the reason, or is among the reasons, why the present piece was not graded. In our opinion, this slate-gray coin has the details of a Fine example that has been cleaned and scratched. The scratches are limited to the area between the date and the bust truncation.

949

1808 50C AU53 NGC. O-108a, R.3. The late die state is considered scarcer, and is listed as R.4. This desirable AU example has lustrous silver-gray surfaces with heather toning closer to the borders.(Registry values: N991)

950

1815/2 50C --Scratches, Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. O-101a, R.3. Dull gray from cleaning, and close inspection reveals a number of faint pinscratches, some above the eagle's right (facing) shoulder and others above the cleavage. All legends are sharp.(Registry values: N1793)

951

1815/2 50C --Graffiti--NGC. VF Details. O-101, R.2, the sole die marriage for this low mintage and widely pursued date. Numerous deep pinscratches are present, mostly near Liberty's profile. They are made less obtrusive by a blanket of deep blue-green, rose-red, and straw-gold toning.(Registry values: N1793)

952

1815/2 50C --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. O-101, R.2. An unused die from 1812 was employed for this interesting overdate. The mintage for this coveted issue is a memorably low 47,150 coins, and only one die pairing is known for the survivors. This piece has silvery surfaces that are somewhat overbright from a past cleaning, but much pleasing detail remains, as expected, and this piece should find a nice home in a date or variety collection.(Registry values: N2998)

953

1817/3 50C AU50 PCGS. O-101a, R.2. A spindly die crack from the olive leaves to the M in AMERICA identifies the later die state. Medium intensity grayish-purple toning with subtle gold undertones covers each side. Good detail despite high-point wear. Both sides are quite clean.(Registry values: N1793)

954

1822 50C MS61 ANACS. O-105, R.3. Easily recognized by the reverse, which has small die dots over the back of the eagle's neck. A lustrous example that shows dappled toning over a lustrous base in light silver-gray, green, and sage on the obverse with a more golden cast on the reverse. Solid eye appeal for the grade.(Registry values: N991)

955

1823 50C MS63 PCGS. O-112, R.1. Apple-green and lime-gold toning drapes this lustrous and unabraded Bust half. Each side has a few minute dark spots. Sharply struck save for the right-side stars. Liberty's profile is strike doubled.(Registry values: N1793)

956

1824/4 50C MS62 PCGS. CAC. O-109, R.2. The Recut 4 obverse paired with a reverse that has the R and I of AMERICA joined as well as recutting on the C. This coin offers soft silver-gray luster through the centers with elements of peach, amber, and brown at the margins. Well struck overall and pleasing. For the two 1824/4 die pairs combined, Population: 6 in 62, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

957

1824 50C MS64 PCGS. O-116, R.2. The date is small and wide, with the 2 lower than the other digits. On the reverse, ED and AM are joined at their bases, and AT nearly so. This near-Gem has vibrant surfaces with lots of luster radiating through a light layer of powder-gray. Visible abrasions are nearly nonexistent, save for a small one on the cheek. Population: 47 in 64, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

958

1826 50C MS63 PCGS. O-117, R.2. A shining Select example, solidly struck with gold to orange peripheral toning framing pale silver centers. Smooth with great eye appeal for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

959

1826 50C MS65 NGC. O-105, R.3. As Overton describes it, the date is tall and close, and the 2 has a needlelike point. A die crack connects all of the left-side stars. On the reverse several of the vertical stripes extend upward into the horizontal bars. Much luster proceeds from underneath a light layer of patina on this piece, with powder-gray, pink, and hazel dominating. The strike is bold, and some of the stars are drawn toward the edge through moderate die erosion.(Registry values: N4719)

960

1827 50C Square Base 2 MS63 NGC. O-104, R.1. A die line off the leaves to the left of the eagle's claws confirms the relatively common variety. An attractive Select example for the type or date collector, mildly reflective and richly toned violet, blue, and gold-gray.(Registry values: N1793)

961

1829 50C Small Letters MS64 PCGS. CAC. O-117, R.2. The variety is characterized by the short, stubby v-shaped top of the 5 in the denomination and the filled-in top of the first A in AMERICA. The strike is a little soft on the left stars, but fine detail is present on Liberty's hair. The surfaces are well preserved and accented by attractive wisps of emerald and crimson toning. The issue is quite scarce at the Choice level. Population: 41 in 64, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

962

1831 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. O-104, R.1. A faint die line through the upper berry on the reverse olive branch confirms the variety. Strongly lustrous surfaces shine through light patina that ranges from sun-gold to yellow-green and light blue. Soft peripheral definition, as often seen, but solid eye appeal nonetheless.(Registry values: N2998)

963

1831 50C MS65 NGC. O-108, R.1. Splendid peach-red and powder-blue toning consumes the fields and devices, while the peripheries are aquamarine. Devoid of abrasions, and the strike is generally good. Surely among the finest representatives of the Overton variety, positively identified (per Glenn Peterson) by a curved line beneath the Y in LIBERTY.(Registry values: N4719)

964

1831 50C MS65 NGC. O-102, R.1. This is one of the common varieties of the date, although none can be called common in Gem grades. Both sides are fully detailed with brilliant mint frost and no evidence of toning, save for a short line at the top of the obverse. Census: 55 in 65, 16 finer (2/10) for all varieties combined.(Registry values: N4719)

965

1832 50C Small Letters MS62 NGC. O-116, R.3. The surfaces are unquestionably original with pleasing luster and scattered gray, copper-brown, and blue coloration on both sides. Well struck in the centers and desirable.(Registry values: N1793)

966

1832 50C Small Letters MS62 ANACS. O-103. Star 8 is close to the cap, and the upright of the 5 in the denomination is recut. A ring of green, purple, and orange-red toning encircles the mostly silver-gray centers. The reverse has a few additional patches of deep purple across the middle. This minimally marked and resplendent specimen has great eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

967

1832 50C Small Letters MS64 PCGS. CAC. O-103, R.1. A die lump is noticeable on Liberty's drapery fold between 18 and the clasp, and recutting shows on the upright of the 5 in the denomination. Bluish-purple toning at the peripheries frames the golden-gray centers. This is a well preserved and nicely struck near-Gem. Population for the issue: 83 in 64, 14 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

968

1833 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. O-114, R.2. A broad die scratch between vertical stripes 3 and 4 attributes this Overton pairing. Delicate tan-gold toning visits comprehensively lustrous fields and devices. Well preserved with only minor grazes on Liberty's neck. Population: 82 in 64, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

969

1834 50C Large Date, Large Letters MS65 NGC. O-103, R.2. One of just three Large Date, Large Letters die pairings, despite numerous online and Internet only auctions that list several others in error. Here the 1 in the date is sharply higher than the 8. Interestingly, the O-103 die marriage was used to produce the legendary King of Siam proof specimen. This nicely toned Gem example shows a bit of inescapable striking softness on Liberty's highest curls and on the eagle's left (facing) wing, both hallmarks of the variety.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

970

1834 50C Large Date, Small Letters MS65 NGC. O-106, R.1. The large 4 in the date is crudely recut over a smaller 4, with part of the initial crossbar showing. On the reverse the left side of the M in AMERICA is curved, recut, and joined to the center. This is a glorious Gem with original sky-blue patina encircling the rims and complementing the pinkish-lilac centers. Some of the segments on the obverse rim are joined, as made, at 2:30, apparently due to a slight axial die misalignment.

971

1834 50C Small Date, Small Letters MS63 PCGS. O-113, R.1. The obverse has star 13 recut, and the reverse has a shadow of a doubled E in the motto. This brilliant Mint State example has excellent design definition with entirely untoned silver surfaces.

972

1836 50C Lettered Edge MS63 PCGS. O-101, R.1. Recutting at stars 6 and 7 on the obverse and the N in UNITED on the reverse confirms the variety. Gold-orange central toning elements fade through blue and green toward the rims. Lustrous and attractive.(Registry values: N1793)

Reeded Edge Half Dollars

973

1836 50C Reeded Edge XF40 NGC. Although it may be difficult to appreciate today, the 1836 Reeded Edge represents a quantum leap forward in technology at the U.S. Mint, namely the introduction of the steam-powered coin press and closed collar. Controversy continues today, at least in some numismatic quarters, as to whether the 1836 Reeded Edge coins were regular issues or patterns. This example offers dove-gray surfaces that retain some luster, with attractive copper rim toning and no singular impairments, just moderate wear as expected.(Registry values: N1793)

974

1836 50C Reeded Edge XF40 ANACS. The 1836 Reeded Edge variety is historic for its first use of the new steam press on the half dollar denomination. The very low published mintage of 1,200 pieces has long inspired collectors to hoard the issue, although circulated examples appear on the market fairly regularly. The present coin has pleasing sharpness and rich golden-brown, mauve, and gunmetal-blue toning. A strong loupe reveals faint hairlines.(Registry values: N1793)

975

1836 50C Reeded Edge XF45 NGC. This is the scarcer of the two-year Capped Bust Reeded Edge design type with a 50 CENTS reverse. Bluish-gray patination in the fields highlights the devices, especially on the obverse, and the few scattered marks do not significantly detract. Overall, a nice well defined, Choice XF example(Registry values: N1793)

976

1837 50C MS64 NGC. The 1837 is the most available date for the two year 50 CENTS type. Well struck in the centers, some typical weakness is noted on the peripheral devices, and pronounced die cracks circle the borders. The light gray patina does not obscure the underlying luster.
Ex: Zerbe Collection (Heritage, 7/2003), lot 7516; Fred Miller Collection (Heritage, 3/2004), lot 5817, which realized $3,405.(Registry values: N2998)

977

1837 50C MS65 ★ NGC. Rich aquamarine and golden-brown dominate both sides, although the margins offer lighter olive-green toning. A moderately prooflike Gem that is well struck save for minor softness on the upper stars, the claws, and the reverse exergue legend. Liberty's profile is strike doubled along the chin and neck. Marks are impressively few and far between. The 1837 has vital importance as a type coin, since the 50 CENTS reverse was only struck for two years, and the 1836 is very scarce in all grades. Census: 5 in 65 ★ , 1 finer with a Star designation (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

978

1837 50C MS66 Prooflike NGC. The 1837 Reeded Edge half dollars are the first viable type alternative for most collectors, since the historic 1836 Reeded Edge halves were made in such small quantities, 1,200 examples of the 1836 compared to 3.6 million of the 1837. Famed specialist Jules Reiver, whose collection we auctioned in January 2006, wrote the standard reference on the Reeded Edge halves, but they have failed to capture collector attention in the way that Bust halves have--likely due to the increased mechanization associated with their production. This Premium Gem specimen offers fields that are noticeably prooflike, even through the layers of gray and rose toning with blue at the margins. The strike is full, with peripheral die cracks appearing on each side. One singular mark occurs between stars 9 and 10. A wonderful type coin. Census: 9 in 66 Prooflike, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

979

1839-O 50C AU55 NGC. A modestly worn O-mint Bust half with rich blue, green, and violet patina over the obverse. The reverse has more peach and orange colors through the centers, though a deep version of the green mixes with brick-red in patches at the margins on that side.(Registry values: N1793)

Seated Half Dollars

980

1839 50C No Drapery MS63 PCGS. CAC. The Seated Liberty coinage was very much a phased introduction, with the half dimes and dimes appearing first in 1837, the quarters in 1838, the half dollars in 1839, and the full complement of minor coinage reached with the Seated dollars in 1840. That approach makes the 1839 No Drapery and With Drapery halves one-year subtypes, as well as popular type and date issues. This Select Mint State piece is fully struck, with bright fields, great luster, and soft mint frost on both sides. A few small field marks on the reverse account for the grade, the most obvious above the eagle's right (facing) wing. A couple of bold die cracks appear on the reverse. A super type coin or prize for the series specialist.(Registry values: N4719)

981

1840 50C Reverse of 1839, Small Letters MS63 PCGS. Light gold-gray toning has settled over remarkably reflective surfaces. This Select coin comes from the later "Reverse of 1839" die style, with lettering that seems positively tiny in comparison to its predecessor. For the variety, Population: 18 in 63, 24 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

982

1843-O 50C MS63 PCGS. CAC. Outstanding eye appeal for this O-mint issue. Coruscating silver-white luster dominates, and the devices are uncommonly sharp. Population: 13 in 63, 5 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

983

1853 50C Arrows and Rays MS62 PCGS. CAC. UNITED STATES is die doubled, most clearly on the E in UNITED. Probably FS-50-1853-801 (former FS-004.7), although the Cherrypickers' Guide lists four doubled die reverses with similar diagnostics. Splashes of sea-green and peach toning enrich the subdued but smooth surfaces. A popular single-year type.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

984

1854 50C Arrows MS62 PCGS. Sharply struck and displaying soft golden-gray patination. Wispy handling marks that show under magnification limit the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

985

1857-S 50C AU55 NGC. Medium Mintmark. WB-102. Heavy circulation on the West Coast accounts for the scarcity of the 1857-S half in high grades, even though 158,000 pieces were struck. Only 16 pieces have been certified in higher grades. The surfaces are unquestionably original with light gray patina over each side and an accent of charcoal around the devices and within the recesses. Both obverse and reverse are sharply and evenly struck, and there are no mentionable abrasions.(Registry values: N1793)

986

1858-S 50C MS63 PCGS. WB-103. The obverse die is blundered, with the base of an 8 buried in the rock above the 8 in the date. The reverse has a Medium S, as always with this obverse according to Wiley and Bugert. In Mint State grades, they rate this variety low R.8. Hints of light tan-gold patina visit the obverse of this lustrous well struck Select specimen. Light marks limit the grade. Population for the issue: 6 in 63, 6 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

987

Set of 17 S.S. Republic 1861-O Half Dollars. All pieces graded "Shipwreck Effect Unc." and attributed by die pair, with issuing authority associated with the die pair also listed. Contains "United States Issues" W-01, W-01A, and W-02; "Louisiana Issues" W-03, W-04, W-04A, W-05, W-06, W-07, and W-08; and "Confederate States Issues" W-09, W-10, W-11, W-11A, W-13, W-14, and W-15. Comes in wooden box with brass accents and commemorative plaque.
From The JTR Collection.

988

S.S. Republic Trio of Half Dollars. Three coins, all graded Shipwreck Effect (C) Unc by NGC with S.S. Republic notation and borders. Includes an 1860-O coin labeled "United States Issue," an 1861-O coin (W-03) labeled "Louisiana Issue," and another 1861-O coin (W-09) labeled "Confederate Issue." Comes in wood case with slipcover and informational DVD.

989

1862-S 50C MS63 PCGS. This is an example of WB-5, with a Weak 6 date logotype and a Large S mintmark. "For all their interesting merits, 1862-S half dollars are vastly under-appreciated." Those words are from Bill Bugert in A Register of Liberty Seated Half Dollar Varieties, Volume I. Such underappreciated coins are often the best targets of wise collectors, and this piece presents an important opportunity. The last two auction appearances of a Mint State piece in any of our sales were an MS64 that we sold in June 2008 and an MS62 that we offered in April 2006. In fact, this lovely gold-toned piece is only the 15th Mint State example of the issue that we have presented since 1993. It is boldly detailed with excellent eye appeal. Population: 7 in 63, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

990

1865 50C MS65 NGC. Solidly detailed with strong, swirling luster beneath light silver-gray and peach patina. Excellent surface quality even by Gem standards. An impressive Civil War-era half dollar by any measure. Clashmarks include a faint ES in STATES above the date. Census: 8 in 65, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

991

1868 50C MS64 PCGS. The 1868 is difficult to locate in all levels of preservation. An occasional hint of light tan shows up under magnification, and a well executed striking results in sharp definition on the design features. Die polish lines are evident in the right obverse field as are a few faint hairlines. Population: 4 in 64, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

992

1869-S 50C MS63 PCGS. Coruscant luster swirls around the refreshingly unmarked fields and devices. The striking details are strong overall in spite of minor softness on the centers of the right-side stars. Although the 1869-S mintage was fairly generous at 656,000 pieces, Uncirculated survivors are rare because of the widespread popularity of silver and gold coinage in the West. Population: 4 in 63, 8 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

993

1870-CC 50C Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an XF specimen that has been cleaned and exhibits environmental damage. This is a mildly granular representative of this rare introductory Carson City issue. Toned cream-gray and almond-gold with a slightly bright appearance and one brief thin mark near star 12.

994

1870-CC 50C XF40 PCGS. Though most denominations struck at Carson City in 1870 saw mintages of just a few thousand pieces, there were more than 50,000 1870-CC half dollars produced. That relatively heavy production, however, did not lead to availability today; circulation attrition claimed most pieces entirely, and heavily worn survivors are the rule. By the standards of the issue, this XF example is remarkable. Both sides show light wear beneath a deep layer of russet and lavender-gray patina. Minimally marked and notably appealing, ideal for the discerning Carson City silver enthusiast. Population: 8 in 40, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

995

1872-CC 50C XF40 NGC. Faint champagne and gray toning appear over the light silver surfaces of this attractive example. It is sharply defined, considering the grade, and retains faint traces of luster in the protected areas.(Registry values: N991)

996

1873 50C Arrows MS65 PCGS. Large Arrowheads. Of the Arrows on Obverse, Motto on Reverse half dollar issues, only the two Philadelphia dates 1873 and 1874 have mintages of over a million pieces. The former issue is readily accessible through most grades, even lesser Mint State, though as might be expected, Gems are conditionally rare. This MS65 example has bold luster with slight frost across the well-defined devices. Light gray is the base color, though prominent waves of gold and orange sweep across each side. Additional rouge and violet elements visit the rims. An appealing and instantly memorable survivor. Population: 10 in 65, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

997

1873-CC 50C Arrows Genuine PCGS. Large CC, WB-103. The PCGS number ending in .91 suggests Questionable Color as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has been cleaned and retoned. The strike is sharp, and the purple-gray toning is heavy.

998

1874 50C Arrows MS62 PCGS. Large Arrowheads, WB-102. Violet, rose, and gold peripheral toning cedes to gleaming silver-gray at the centers of this Arrows half. The reverse patina extends farther into the fields.(Registry values: N1793)

999

1874-CC 50C Arrows AU55 PCGS. WB-101. A small tine extends from atop the eagle's head, and there is a die line through ES in STATES. The Randy Wiley-Bill Bugert Seated half reference (1993) calls this issue, with a mintage of 59,000 pieces, "rare in XF and above," and assign this variety a low R.6 in XF/AU. Bluish-gray and golden-gray patina bathes the minimally marked surfaces of this Choice AU specimen. Excellent detail shows on the design elements. Population for the issue: 7 in 55, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1000

1875-CC 50C MS64 NGC. CAC. This Carson City type coin has satin luster and medium almond-gold and cream-gray toning. The strike is above average, and neither side has any obvious marks. Although the 1875-CC is readily collected in grades below VF, Uncirculated examples are both rare and desirable. Census: 23 in 64, 3 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1001

1875-CC 50C MS65 NGC. While available in circulated grades and lower-end Uncirculated condition, the 1875-CC is a condition rarity in Gem condition. Only one other piece has been so graded by NGC with one finer (2/10). This is a lovely, brightly lustrous example that has semiprooflike fields on the obverse. Pale gray surfaces turn to light golden at the margins on each side. The devices are sharply struck throughout, and there are no obvious or mentionable abrasions.(Registry values: N2998)

1002

1877-S 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. Type Two Reverse. Blue-violet and reddish-orange rim toning gives way to soft gray color over the centers. A delightful near-Gem example of this popular type issue.(Registry values: N1793)

1003

1877-S 50C MS65 PCGS. Type Two Reverse. Bold silver-white luster is flashy with an element of reflectivity. Excellent striking definition with just a few tiny marks scattered in the fields. This popular type issue is available in most grades, though understandably elusive in Gem and better. Population: 25 in 65, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1004

1890 50C MS66 NGC. Devoid of toning, the surfaces have a brilliant-white sheen with no distracting abrasions. The strike is sharp, if not absolutely full in all areas, and the eye appeal is expectedly strong for a flashy Seated half at the MS66 level of preservation. Modest hints of brightness are evident in the fields, mostly at direct light angles. The 1890 is the last issue in the Seated half dollar series that had a mintage under 100,000 coins: A mere 12,000 pieces were produced as circulation strikes, plus another 590 coins in proof format. Census: 7 in 66, 7 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1005

1891 50C MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike ANACS. Whispers of electric-blue, purple, and golden-tan concentrate at the margins of this sharply struck half. Light grade-consistent marks occur on the obverse.(Registry values: N991)

Proof Seated Half Dollars

1006

1860 50C PR63 PCGS. Type Two Reverse. Strongly reflective surfaces are awash in blue, violet, and gray patina. A lightly hairlined Select proof, but one with great eye appeal for the grade. Population: 37 in 63, 49 finer (2/10).

1007

1862 50C PR64 Cameo PCGS. Frosty devices compare favorably to the darkly reflective fields. The contrast on the reverse is especially prominent. Wispy die polish lines are prominent, but hairlines are difficult to find. A meager 550 proofs were issued for this popular Civil War date. Population: 6 in 64 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).

1008

1864 50C PR63 Cameo NGC. The borders offer a hint of caramel-gold toning, but this flashy and nicely struck specimen is close to brilliant. The devices exhibit consistent frost, and the few hairlines are limited to the right obverse field. Census: 2 in 63 Cameo, 16 finer (2/10).

1009

1865 50C PR63 PCGS. Mottled multicolored toning adheres to both sides of this Select proof, and a sharp strike emboldens the design elements. Light handling marks that are really only visible under high magnification limit the grade.

1010

1865 50C PR64 PCGS. Variegated walnut-brown and stone-gray adorn this fully struck and flashy near-Gem. Exemplary despite a single small spot near the left (facing) elbow. Only 500 proofs were coined for this historic year, which witnessed the end of the Civil War and the first Presidential assassination. Population: 47 in 64, 19 finer (2/10).

1011

1868 50C PR64 NGC. This lovely proof has splendid gold and iridescent toning that deepens near the borders. The fields are nicely mirrored, presenting excellent contrast versus the lustrous devices, although no Cameo designation has been provided. Census: 40 in 64, 30 finer (2/10).

1012

1868 50C PR65 PCGS. This flashy and meticulously struck Gem is bathed in ocean-blue and pearl-gray. A few faint mint-made roller marks cross the eagle's neck, but no hairlines are apparent. Encased in an old green label holder. A scant 600 proofs were struck. Population: 5 in 65, 1 finer (2/10).

1013

1870 50C PR63 NGC. A gorgeous Select proof with distinct elements of contrast, though these go unacknowledged on the older NGC holder. Rich violet, amber, and gold toning extends from the margins into the fields.

1014

1870 50C PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Judging from PCGS/NGC population figures a fair number of the 1,000 1870 proof half dollars have survived to the present day. The same cannot be said for specimens with the Cameo designation, of which about 30 examples have been certified. Soft gold and bluish-violet patina is slightly more evident on the obverse of this near-Gem Cameo. Generally well impressed and minimally abraded. Population: 3 in 64 Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).

1015

1877 50C PR63 NGC. Type Two Reverse. While the grade is limited to PR63 due to the presence of a few insignificant hairlines and contact marks, this splendid example has the eye appeal of a Gem, and it deserves a Cameo designation. Both sides are mostly brilliant, with vibrant peripheral gold and iridescent toning.

1016

1877 50C PR64 PCGS. Type Two Reverse. Lime-green, ocean-blue, and rose-red bands adorn the borders of this attractively toned near-Gem. Well struck except for the eagle's left (facing) ankle. Just 510 proofs were struck. Population: 24 in 64, 9 finer (2/10).

1017

1878 50C PR63 NGC. Type Two Reverse. Light gold toning visits the borders of this otherwise stone-white specimen. Flashy and unabraded with a suitable strike. A scant 800 proofs were issued.

1018

1878 50C PR68 NGC. Type Two Reverse. The present coin is the single finest certified 1878 proof half dollar. Examination of NGC/PCGS population figures reveals that a goodly number of the 800-piece mintage has survived to the present day, with the vast majority falling into the PR62 to PR65 range. Fewer than 20 specimens are designated Premium Gems, and a solitary coin rates PR67.
The current PR68 displays a beautiful blend of cobalt-blue and lavender around the obverse borders framing the silver-gray central area, while a sliver of beige-gold clings to the reverse margin, ceding to dominant cobalt-blue on the remaining surface. A solid strike brings out virtually full detail on the design features, all of which stand out against the mirrored fields. As expected, immaculate preservation characterizes both sides. These attributes add up to breathtaking, unsurpassable eye appeal. Housed in a prior generation holder.
Ex: Superior Orlando Sale (8/1992), lot 410.

1019

1880 50C PR64 PCGS. CAC. Type Two Reverse. Faint gold color graces much of the obverse, though the reverse shows only suggestions of toning at the rims. A well-defined example with a measure of contrast on each side.

1020

1881 50C PR67 NGC. Type One Reverse. Dramatic blushes of cherry-red, lilac, ocean-blue, and olive-gold endow this intricately struck Superb Gem. Perfect aside from a few faint hairlines on the upper right obverse field. The 1881 has a mintage of just 10,000 commercial strikes and 975 proofs. Census: 4 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).

1021

1881 50C PR66 Cameo PCGS. Type One Reverse, identified by the split berry above the left stand of H in HALF , and very scarce as such. Walter Breen (1988) indicates this reverse is only found with proofs. Whispers of barely discernible light tan color reside on the cameo surfaces of this Premium Gem proof half. Sharply struck and nicely preserved. Population: 3 in 66 Cameo, 1 finer (2/10).

1022

1882 50C PR66 Cameo NGC. The 1882 is one of the key dates in the Seated Liberty half dollar series. As only 4,400 circulation strikes were produced, proofs (1,100 mintage) come under collector pressure. Soft champagne-tan obverse patination cedes to light champagne-gold on the reverse. A nicely struck well preserved Premium Gem proof Cameo. Census: 16 in 66 Cameo, 6 finer (1/10).

1023

1888 50C PR64 Cameo PCGS. WB-101. The tiny proof mintage of 832 pieces has always felt considerable pressure from collectors because of the low business strike total of 12,833 coins. Hints of emerald-green and crimson toning visit the peripheries of this lovely specimen, complementing the bold contrast of the reflective fields and strongly impressed devices. Population: 15 in 64 Cameo, 12 finer (2/10).

1024

1891 50C PR66 NGC. Reddish-blue patina encircles the obverse borders of this Premium Gem proof and covers the entire reverse. While the reflectivity of the obverse fields highlights the motif, any such contrast on the reverse is muted by the depth of the toning. Well struck save for weakness on the upper obverse. A moderate rim mark is visible at 9:00 on the obverse.

Barber Half Dollars

1025

1892 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. A solidly struck example of this first-year Barber half, minimally toned with pleasing luster. Well-preserved for the grade, particularly in the portrait area.(Registry values: N1793)

1026

1892 50C MS64 PCGS. Frosty on the devices with delightful silver-white luster. This well struck near-Gem shows a single diagonal abrasion at Liberty's cheekbone. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

1027

1894-O 50C MS64 PCGS. Peach and orange peripheral hues add color to each side, while the centers are generally silver and sage. A lustrous near-Gem example of this little-saved issue. Population: 52 in 64, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1028

1894-O 50C MS64 PCGS. Pale silver-gray with softly frosted luster. This O-mint half shows typical peripheral striking weakness, but the overall eye appeal is considerable. Population: 53 in 64, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1029

1895-S 50C MS64 PCGS. From a mintage of just over 1 million coins, the 1895-S is reasonably easy to locate in lower grades, but Choice and Gem Mint State examples are highly elusive. This example is fully brilliant with satiny silver luster, exhibiting faint gold and iridescent blushes on both sides. The strike is excellent and the eye appeal is great. Population: 42 in 64, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1030

1902-O 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. A ring of electric-blue, violet, and russet toning encircles the centers, which have a lovely dusting of gold patina. Alluring satiny luster enhances the eye appeal of this sharply struck near-Gem specimen; only the upper right shield corner reveals the usual softness. A graze in the upper right field is the most noticeable mark. Population: 15 in 64, 6 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1031

1904-S 50C Fine 15 PCGS. Light gray color overall with a deeper shade over part of the portrait and along the right obverse rim. Gold accents are present elsewhere. All letters in LIBERTY are visible, though the bottoms of the letters BER are nearly worn away.(Registry values: N491)

1032

1906 50C MS65 PCGS. CAC. Ex: Friend. Philadelphia coined 2.6 million Barber half dollars in 1906, and in this case the mintage actually provides an indication of availability today. Despite its availability, the patience required to acquire Gem business strikes of the Philadelphia issues is generally known only to specialists. Decades ago, collectors chose the far easier route of collecting proofs for these issues, explaining the rarity of business strikes today. Both sides of this sharply struck 1906 half exhibit frosty silver luster beneath moderate toning. The obverse is predominately golden-brown, while the reverse is orange-gold and champagne. Population: 22 in 65, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1033

1907-D 50C MS65 NGC. The 1907-D is one of the more available mintmarked Barber halves. It is also one of the better-produced issues. This piece displays bright, radiant mint luster and is generally brilliant except for a light accent of peripheral golden color. The striking details are strong, but not absolutely complete, and there are no mentionable abrasions. Census: 15 in 65, 6 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1034

1908 50C MS65 PCGS. CAC. The 1908 is curiously scarce and underrated in Gem condition, even though 1.3 million pieces were struck. Both of the major services combined have only certified 24 Gems, and 14 are finer (2/10). This is a splendid, high-end example that has light golden toning over each side and speckled darker color in the area of Liberty's face. The design elements are well, but not quite fully struck on each side, but this slight weakness is offset by the exceptionally clean surfaces and thick mint luster. Population: 13 in 65, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1035

1912-S 50C MS63 PCGS. Pleasingly lustrous with few significant abrasions for the grade. Pale silver surfaces show glints of gold-gray at the margins. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 24 in 63, 72 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1036

1912-S 50C MS65 PCGS. The David Lawrence reference (1991) on the series has the briefest comment about the 1912-S: "Comes nice." And yet that does describe this coin. The mint luster swirls across both obverse and reverse. The striking details are almost complete, and there are no mentionable abrasions. A splendid type coin.(Registry values: N2998)

1037

1913-D 50C MS64 PCGS. This Choice Mint State piece is a delightful example of the most plentiful 1913 Barber half. It is this Denver Mint issue that is most often chosen for coin-a-year sets. The strike is excellent and the luster is brilliant, with frosty silver surfaces and a hint of delicate gold toning. Population: 61 in 64, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1038

1913-D 50C MS65 NGC. Luster cavorts throughout the dusky rose-gold toning, and the crisply struck devices are as smooth as the unmarked fields. About as rare in the MS65 grade as the much lower mintage 1913, and a desirable addition to a high grade collection of the conditionally challenging series. Census: 13 in 65, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1039

1914-S 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. The CAC sticker speaks volumes about this coin. Everything points to an MS65 grade. The mint luster is thick and swirls around each side and is unbroken by the abrasions one would expect on an MS64. Each side is toned pale gray-golden, and the striking details are strong throughout. Check it out. Population: 36 in 64, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1040

1915-D 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. Soft lavender, blue, and dove-gray toning lets the radiant luster of this near-Gem filter through. Except for a few feathers on the eagle's neck and left wing, the design elements are sharply struck. A couple of trivial marks on the obverse define the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Barber Half Dollars

1041

1893 50C PR64 Deep Cameo PCGS. While the 1893 is considered a more available type coin, we have not offered a Deep/Ultra Cameo since our 2008 FUN Sale. This is a lovely, heavily contrasted example that has thick mint frost over the devices that is set against the unfathomable depth of reflectivity seen in the fields. Most of each side is brilliant but the rim on the obverse displays a ring of deeper russet patina. Population: 1 in 64 Deep Cameo, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

1042

1894 50C PR66 Cameo PCGS. A splendid Premium Gem Cameo proof, this 1894 Barber half dollar has exceptional, fully mirrored fields and pristine, satiny devices. The contrast is clearly visible beneath delicate gold and iridescent toning. Population: 15 in 66 Cameo, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1043

1894 50C PR66 Cameo NGC. Bright snow-white overall, the fields are nicely mirrored and unhairlined. The devices show a moderate amount of frosting and provide the cameo contrast. Just a little striking softness is noted on the eagle's right (facing) wing, close to the shied. Very scarce in this lofty grade. The combined NGC and PCGS population reports show a total of 31 pieces graded this high, with 17 certified finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1044

1895 50C PR66 NGC. Dusky plum-red toning cedes to olive-gold across the portrait. This flashy and sharply struck proof half dollar appears perfect aside from a pair of minute spots near the I in UNITED. A meager 880 proofs fell from the dies, the same mintage as the costly 1895 Morgan dollar. Census: 32 in 66, 31 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1045

1895 50C PR66 Cameo PCGS. Brilliant, mirrored fields contrast boldly with the frosty devices to produce a vivid cameo effect on this sought-after 19th century type coin. From a moderate proof mintage of 880 coins, very few examples can match the appeal of this spectacular specimen. Population: 7 in 66 Cameo, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1046

1903 50C PR63 NGC. The luminous surfaces of this Select proof exhibit well struck design elements except for the usual softness in the upper right shield corner. Occasional wisps of yellow-tan color are visible over each side. Fine hairlines preclude a higher grade. Census: 8 in 63, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1047

1905 50C PR65 NGC. From a tiny proof mintage of 727 pieces, the present coin is an exemplary specimen of early 20th century coinage. A low-circulation mintage has put significant pressure on the small supply of proof coins over the years. Complete striking details complement the starkly mirrored fields and no distracting marks are visible to the naked eye. Census: 32 in 65, 41 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1048

1907 50C PR64 PCGS. Caramel-gold and jade-green embrace this undisturbed and attractive near-Gem. The fletchings are well struck, and only the right shield corner shows incompleteness. Just 575 proofs were distributed. Population: 49 in 64, 40 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1049

1910 50C PR64 PCGS. Impressively lustrous with surprisingly strong contrast for the issue, though not enough to warrant a Cameo designation. Faint hairlines in the fields affect the grade more than the eye appeal. Population: 51 in 64, 36 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1050

1911 50C PR64 PCGS. CAC. Boldly toned blue-green and amber at the borders with less color through the centers. A faintly hairlined but strongly mirrored proof beauty, one of just 543 specimens struck.(Registry values: N1793)

1051

1911 50C PR66 NGC. A high quality proof representative that defies any preconceptions about rich layers of color having an adverse affect on a coin's mirrored qualities. This specimen is cloaked in forest-green and autumn-gold toning, yet provides considerable sparkle when held under a light. Census: 23 in 66, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1052

1911 50C PR65 Cameo PCGS. The 1911 is notable for a low emission of proofs with only 543 pieces struck. But it is also generally unavailable in high grades and with cameo contrast. This is a strongly contrasted example that displays deeply mirrored fields and noticeably frosted devices. Each side is well balanced in overall appearance and there is just a hint of light golden toning around the margins of this otherwise brilliant coin. A shallow strike-through is noted in the field above the A in DOLLAR. Population: 11 in 65 Cameo, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1053

1912 50C PR63 PCGS. Hints of light gold color show up under magnification. The design elements are well defined save for the typical softness on the upper right shield corner and adjacent feathers. Some wispy handling marks are visible in the fields.(Registry values: N991)

1054

1912 50C PR66 NGC. From a proof mintage of just 700 pieces, few examples can match the appeal of this exquisite specimen. The surfaces are flawless. Full striking details throughout, with brilliant mirrored fields that create spectacular eye appeal. Census: 16 in 66, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1055

1912 50C PR67 NGC. CAC. Remarkably toned in swaths of fire-red, orange, powder-blue, lemon-gold, and lime-green. This immaculate Superb Gem provides exceptional eye appeal, and the strike is exemplary except for slight inexactness near the right shield corner. Encapsulated in a prior generation holder. Census: 10 in 67, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1056

1913 50C PR66 NGC. Apple-green, peach-red, and caramel-gold encompass this precisely struck and undisturbed Premium Gem. A loupe locates faint contact on the central cheek. Housed in a former generation holder. A mere 627 proofs were coined, and the associated 1913 business strike mintage was also low. Census: 25 in 66, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Walking Liberty Half Dollars

1057

1916 50C MS65 NGC. Typical matte-like surfaces with brilliant mint frost host wisps of gold and champagne toning over an otherwise untoned obverse and reverse. This first-year issue is always a popular choice with type set collectors.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1058

1916-D 50C MS64 NGC. Light golden color overall cedes to orange at the obverse margins and violet at the same zone on the reverse. This first-year near-Gem is softly struck, but the eye appeal is strong.(Registry values: N991)

1059

1916-D 50C MS65 PCGS. This Gem first-year issue has satiny silver-gray centers with cobalt-blue and antique-gold margins. The former color is more prevalent on the reverse. PCGS has graded just 47 finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1060

1916-S 50C AU58 PCGS. CAC. Just a touch of friction affects the softly struck high points of this first-year Walker. Strong silver-gray luster remains with elements of deep peach close to the rims.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1061

1916-S 50C --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. A lovely example, despite its description that we disagree with. Both sides are fully lustrous with deep gold and iridescent toning. The strike is sharp and the eye appeal is excellent.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1062

1916-S 50C MS64 NGC. This near-Gem is awash with frosty luster and endowed with sharply struck design elements. An occasional whisper of gold color is visible on the obverse under magnification. A few inoffensive surface and rim marks barely prevent the attainment of Gem classification. Great overall eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

1063

1917 50C MS66 NGC. Hints of caramel-gold patina visit this otherwise untoned Premium Gem. Lustrous and nearly devoid of contact, but what makes the present piece exceptional is its full strike on the branch hand, a characteristic seldom seen on Walking Liberty halves of any date. Census: 40 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1064

1917-D 50C Obverse MS62 NGC. The luster is impressive, if a trifle dusky where violet-blue and amber-gold hues have settled over the margins. Well struck with few serious abrasions.(Registry values: N991)

1065

1917-D 50C Obverse MS63 NGC. Yellow-gold patina gravitates to the margins of this Select half and a well directed strike leaves relatively strong definition on the design motifs. Faint handling marks define the grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1066

1917-D 50C Obverse MS64 NGC. Softly lustrous surfaces are draped in rich gold-gray toning with touches of orange. Well-defined with few significant marks. NGC has graded 36 numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1067

1917-D 50C Reverse MS64 PCGS. CAC. The price curves of the 1917-D Obverse and Reverse issues cross as the higher Mint State grades are reached, with the Obverse costing more in low grades and the Reverse more in high. This indicates that more Mint State specimens of the Obverse were likely saved. This piece show generous mint luster over silver-gold surfaces, and the strike is adequate, if not full, on Liberty's head--an often-weak area on this issue--as well as her right hand. Good value, and high-end for the grade. PCGS has certified only 37 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1068

1917-D 50C Reverse MS64 PCGS. The 1917-D Reverse is a scarcer issue than the higher visibility Obverse mintmark variant. Few high quality examples were set aside at the time of issue, but this is one of them. Each side is completely brilliant and shows radiant mint luster. The strike is strong overall with no mentionable areas of weakness.(Registry values: N2998)

1069

1918 50C MS63 PCGS. A well struck Select coin with excellent luster. Generally silver-white surfaces show toning, but not in the same place; the obverse has a peach-yellow center, while the reverse has similar but deeper color at the margins.(Registry values: N991)

1070

1918 50C MS64 NGC. Lustrous golden-brown surfaces are laced with wisps of steel-blue. Sharply struck and free of mentionable marks.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1071

1918-D 50C AU58 NGC. Traces of wear are visible on the high points of this brilliant silver representative. The centers are a trifle weak, with surrounding details stronger. Wisps of peripheral iridescence are visible along part of the reverse border.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1072

1918-S 50C MS63 NGC. Pleasing luster exudes from surfaces toned in pastel champagne-gold and ice-blue. The design features, including the branch hand, are sharply defined. A few trivial marks preclude the next highest numerical grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1073

1918-S 50C MS64 PCGS. This piece represents excellent value in this difficult early Walker. The strike is strong, but of course incomplete, as fully struck coins most likely do not exist. The surfaces are original, with variegated golden, lilac, and russet toning on each side. But perhaps the most interesting aspect of this coin is the heavily striated fields that impart bright semireflectivity on each side.(Registry values: N1793)

1074

1919 50C AU53 PCGS. CAC. Gold, orange, and light gray colors merge on this briefly circulated Philadelphia Walker, from an issue of fewer than a million pieces. Both sides are minimally abraded.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1075

1919 50C AU58 NGC. The collector who desires a major challenge should acquire this coin and continue to form a complete matched set. A trace of wear is evident on the high points as expected for the grade. The surfaces are brilliant with nearly full satin luster, and they are mostly untoned, save for a few splashes of iridescence.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1076

1919-D 50C MS62 PCGS. Examples of the 1919-D are just not that available in any grade, and they are especially elusive (not to mention pricey) in better condition even when they are offered. Strike is the problem usually encountered, and on this coin there is some central softness but the details are definitely finer than seen on many examples. The surfaces are brilliant throughout with attractive mint frost. The only mentionable mark is located in the right obverse field.(Registry values: N2998)

1077

1919-D 50C MS62 NGC. The 1919-D is third rarest in mint condition in both the early issues as well as the series overall. As usually seen, this piece shows notable softness on the central devices. However, the bright satiny mint luster is unbroken and swirls over each side. The toning is light gray with bits of golden interspersed and each side is perfectly matched in appearance.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1078

1919-S 50C AU53 PCGS. CAC. Light orange and mauve peripheral tints lead into pale pearl-gray centers on this luminous 1919-S half. Modestly worn over the high points with just a few small abrasions on and near Liberty's figure which contribute to the grade. Still, great eye appeal for this challenging issue.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1079

1919-S 50C AU55 NGC. CAC. Soft gold-orange toning at the margins gives way to luminous silver-gray centers. A well struck example with few abrasions and only modest wear.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1080

1920-D 50C AU55 PCGS. CAC. Still-lustrous surfaces show faint violet accents at the broad silver-gray centers, while the margins show glints of gold. A striking Choice AU example of this challenging issue.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1081

1920-D 50C MS63 NGC. While some may overlook the 1920-D as it is positioned between the 1919 and 1921 issues, specialists know how challenging it is in the context of this difficult and highly collectible series. In overall rarity in mint condition, the 1920-D ranks fifth out of the 65-issue series, and also fifth among early issues. The overall striking details are strong on this piece, with the exception of the head detail of Liberty. The mint luster is satiny and both sides are lightly covered with pale rose and lilac toning. The only mentionable mark is located on the neck of Liberty.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1082

1921-D 50C XF45 PCGS. The 1921-D is famous for having the lowest mintage of any Walking Liberty half, just 208,000 pieces struck, and examples are prized regardless of grade. This Choice XF example, ideal as a centerpiece for an otherwise AU set, has still-lustrous pearl-gray centers framed in subtle gold and amber hues.(Registry values: N1793)

1083

1921-D 50C --Reverse Scratched--NGC. AU Details. From the obverse, this still-lustrous and minimally toned example displays well, showing only light wear. The reverse, however, shows several lengthy staple scratches which account for the details grade. Nonetheless, a readily collectible example.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1084

1921-D 50C AU58 PCGS. The 1921-D is a well-known rarity in this widely collected series. While most of the attention is focused on coins in mint condition, especially those in MS63 and better grades, those pieces are not for everyone. This piece represents excellent value. The surfaces retain almost complete mint luster and visually it would blend in well with an otherwise Uncirculated set. The strike is strong for the issue, and the centers are almost brilliant with golden-blue accents surrounding the rims.(Registry values: N2998)

1085

1921-S 50C AU58 PCGS. CAC. The U.S. Mint furiously coined silver dollars in 1921, to comply with provisions of the Pittman Act. Half dollar production was slighted, and collectors set aside few examples until years later, when the use of coin holders and folders became widespread. The typical 1921-S half is in AG to VG condition, and pieces with nearly full mint luster are coveted by collectors. The present steel-gray Borderline Uncirculated representative is refreshingly unabraded, and although the centers show the expected incompleteness of strike, actual wear from circulation is slight.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

1086

1921-S 50C MS62 NGC. Both sides of this important piece have brilliant silver surfaces with frosty luster. The typical strike shows weakness at Liberty's head, and at the center of each side. While traces of contact are evident on the high points and define the grade, there is no wear visible on either side. Considerable die polish can be seen around the entire obverse periphery, while the reverse has flowlines and minor die cracks. The 1921-S is the key Mint State rarity in the Walking Liberty series, with examples appearing infrequently. Many finer examples will remain inaccessible to collectors for years to come.(Registry values: N4719)

1087

1923-S 50C Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an Unc specimen that has altered surfaces. No trace of wear, though the surfaces show microporosity and odd luster, both in the light silver-gray fields and at the more gold-orange margins.

1088

1923-S 50C AU55 PCGS. CAC. Lightly worn with gold-orange fringe toning surrounding pale pearl-gray centers with considerable remaining luster. This S-mint issue is challenging in better circulated grades despite a mintage of more than 2.1 million pieces.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1089

1927-S 50C MS63 NGC. This beautiful 1927-S half dollar is mostly brilliant with lovely peripheral blue and lilac toning at the left side of the obverse and the lower reverse. Like many issues in the series, this piece is slightly weak at the centers, gaining strength nearer the borders.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1090

1927-S 50C MS64 PCGS. The 1927-S is notorious for its poor strike. The present near-Gem, while not fully defined, certainly displays an above-average impression, evidenced by a degree of detail in the right (facing) hand and adjacent branch (which are usually smooth). Whispers of reddish-gold patina are more widespread on the reverse borders. Lustrous and minimally marked.(Registry values: N1793)

1091

1928-S 50C MS63 NGC. The 1928-S is one of the major strike rarities of the series. This piece shows better-than-average definition on the central high points, but the strike is still far from full (which is not a realistic expectation for a '28-S). The surfaces are unusually clean for the grade, and the soft mint frost has a light layer of golden on each side that gradually deepens around the margins.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1092

1929-D 50C MS64 PCGS. CAC. Softly struck with lovely frosted luster through the silver-gray centers and the gold and orange toning at the margins. Minimally abraded for the grade assigned.(Registry values: N991)

1093

1929-D 50C MS64 NGC. Here is a delightful example of the scarce 1929-D half, a condition rarity that is seldom seen in Gem grades. This piece is fully lustrous with light silver surfaces and splashes of iridescent toning.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1094

1933-S 50C MS64 PCGS. Sharply struck and satiny, with dappled gray and russet patina of medium intensity across each side. A handful of marks in the left obverse field account for the near-Gem grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1095

1933-S 50C MS65 PCGS. The 1933-S Walking Liberty half is an issue that exerts a peculiar fascination for some collectors, perhaps due not only to its status as the last of the pre-short set issues but also as the only 1933-dated U.S. coin with an S mintmark. This is an exemplary Gem striking, with amber and brown at the rims and silver-gold centers. The strike is bold, and marks are few. PCGS has certified 62 pieces finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1096

1933-S 50C MS65 NGC. Medium chestnut-gold toning overlies the lustrous silver-white surfaces of this splendidly preserved Gem. Well struck, particularly for a San Francisco issue. 1933 was the trough year of the Great Depression, which explains both the low mintage and the scarcity of high grade survivors. Encased in a former generation holder.(Registry values: N2998)

1097

1934 50C MS67 NGC. Glowing luster issues through the veneer of golden-gray patina of this Superb Gem and a powerful strike imparts strong definition to the design features. Devoid of mentionable marks. Census: 92 in 67, 8 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1098

1934-D 50C MS65 NGC. Large D. A frosty Gem with decidedly above-average detail on Liberty's head and hands. Minimally toned with exciting eye appeal. NGC has graded just 34 numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N991)

1099

1934-D 50C MS65 NGC. Small D. Uncommonly well-defined on the central devices with fresh and exciting luster. Both sides are minimally toned save for the margins, which show arcs of gold color bordering on yellow-orange.(Registry values: N991)

1100

1934-S 50C MS64 NGC. Here is a desirable 1934-S Walker with bold design definition, satin luster, and toning on both sides. The ivory and iridescent hues provide excellent eye appeal. For the collector of high-grade Walkers, this Choice Mint State piece will be a nice addition at a substantial savings over a Gem specimen.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1101

1934-S 50C MS65 NGC. As one of the leading strike rarities in the middle date series of Walkers, this is an exemplary coin. The striking definition is essentially full with strong head detailing, a fully split hand, and completely brought up skirt lines. The mint luster is strong and frosted, as one would expect, with light golden-rose toning over each side.(Registry values: N2998)

1102

1934-S 50C MS66 ★ NGC. It is interesting to compare and contrast the 1934-S with the 1933-S. Though only separated by one year, what one can expect is significantly different from each issue. It is basically a given that the 1933-S will be fully struck. That is definitely not something taken for granted on the 1934-S. This piece, however, shows striking details that are comparable to most 1933-S halves. Additionally, the mint luster is thick and frosted, and each side has almost brilliant centers. The rim on the obverse shows lovely iridescent toning, while the reverse has just a bit of golden color. This is an outstanding 1934-S for a serious set of Walking Liberty halves. Census: 5 in 66 ★ , 1 finer with the ★ designation (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1103

1935-D 50C MS65 NGC. Outstanding frosty luster with soft yellow-gray toning over each side. Soft detail on Liberty's head and hands, as is often seen for this Denver issue, but the preservation is excellent. NGC has graded five numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1104

1935-S 50C MS66 NGC. The 1935-S is noted as a strike rarity in the middle dates from 1933 through 1940. This piece is definitely above average with full definition on Liberty's head and slight softness on the skirt lines and eagle's leg. The usual strong mint luster is seen throughout and there are no mentionable marks on this nearly untoned, superior example. Census: 50 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1105

1935-S 50C MS66 NGC. A magnificent lemon-gold Premium Gem that boasts sweeping luster and exemplary preservation. The skirt lines are sharp, although the cheek and branch hand are incompletely brought up. The 1935-S is obtainable with patience in MS63 through MS65 grades, but MS66 examples are undeniably rare. Census: 50 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1106

1936 50C MS67 NGC. Glimpses of gold and apricot toning grace this shining Superb Gem. Pleasingly detailed with a single small luster break noted at Liberty's upper gown. Census: 87 in 67, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1107

1936-S 50C MS66 PCGS. Dazzling luster and a hint of gold patina affirm the originality of this pleasing Premium Gem. Liberty's head and skirt lines are crisply struck, although the right (facing) breast has a minor flat area. PCGS has certified just six pieces finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1108

1936-S 50C MS66 NGC. Uncommonly crisp detail for this San Francisco issue, with just a touch of pebbled texture to the light silver-gray surfaces. Remarkable eye appeal in all respects. NGC has graded just 13 numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1109

1937-D 50C MS66 PCGS. Well struck with only minor softness in the hand area and on the eagle's leg. This strongly lustrous Premium Gem, moderately reflective on the obverse, is mostly silver-white with glimpses of blue and gold. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N991)

1110

1937-D 50C MS66 NGC. Bold and frosty luster dominates the eye appeal of this Premium Gem. Hints of gold to peach color bring out the essential silver-white quality of the rest of the surfaces. Central striking softness is a minor concern in context. NGC has graded 32 numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1111

1937-D 50C MS67 ★ NGC. The 1937-D is a curious issue in that it breaks the general rule of full strikes on late date D-mint Walkers. Striking detail as complete as seen on this piece can be a challenge to locate, especially in MS67. The surfaces are remarkably lustrous and lightly toned with an arc of deep golden on the lower obverse. The strike is complete except for slight softness on Liberty's hand (still, almost complete) and weakness on the eagle's breast feathers. The only marks of any note are in the right obverse field and well concealed by moderate toning in that area. The single finest example of the date with the ★ designation (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1112

1937-S 50C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Well struck and shining with subtle gold and peach elements over silver-white surfaces. Minimally abraded with great eye appeal. PCGS has certified just 18 finer pieces (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1113

1937-S 50C MS66 PCGS. Shining luster throughout with near-brilliant margins that take on aspects of lilac and gold in the centers. This Premium Gem is housed in a green label holder. PCGS has graded just 18 coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1114

1938-D 50C MS65 PCGS. CAC. This exceptional Walker nicely represents the key-date of the post-1934 series. It is fully lustrous with frosty silver surfaces and wispy champagne toning. The strike is sharp, and the eye appeal is grand.(Registry values: N991)

1115

1938-D 50C MS65 PCGS. CAC. Pastel chestnut-gold toning visits this lustrous and beautifully preserved Gem. The strike is intricate save for the usual inexactness on the branch hand. A popular low mintage issue. Encapsulated in an old green label holder.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1116

1938-D 50C MS65 PCGS. Well struck overall with just a hint of golden peripheral color adding to the pale silver-gray of the satiny surfaces. Well struck overall, though a degree of the usual softness is noted on Liberty's head and hands.(Registry values: N991)

1117

1938-D 50C MS65 PCGS. Satiny silver-gray centers show elements of violet-blue and gold-orange close to the rims. This Gem has above-average detail for its low-mintage issue.(Registry values: N991)

1118

1938-D 50C MS65 NGC. Both sides have bright silver centers framed in gold and orange, with the toning slightly richer on the obverse. Well struck for this popular low-mintage issue and carefully preserved.(Registry values: N991)

1119

1939-D 50C MS67 NGC. Excellent definition is visible on the design motifs, including the branch hand and gown lines. Lustrous essentially untoned surfaces are impeccably preserved. Census: 86 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1120

1939-S 50C MS67 PCGS. CAC. Bright silver-white luster shows a handful of even shinier patches close to certain reverse design elements, the result of die polishing. Minimally marked but with typical striking characteristics through the centers. Tied for finest known to PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1121

1941 50C MS68 PCGS. The 1941 and 1943 are generally regarded as the best-produced coins in the Short Series for use as a type coin, even though the 1946-D is more available. This is an absolutely splendid example. The devices are fully struck on each side, and the bright mint luster has a pale overlay of color on each side that varies from ice-blue to pale rose. The surfaces are virtually perfect. Predictably, there are no finer examples that have been certified at either of the major services. Population: 13 in 68, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1122

1941-S 50C MS65 PCGS. CAC. Soft and swirling luster is key to this Gem's eye appeal. Light pearl-gray colors grace the reverse and the central obverse, while the latter side also gains gold and orange elements close to the rims.(Registry values: N1793)

1123

1942-S 50C MS66 PCGS. CAC. Small S. Bright silver-white surfaces are carefully preserved on this short-set Premium Gem. While the strike on Liberty's central hand is typically weak, the head is relatively well-defined.(Registry values: N1793)

1124

1944 50C MS67 PCGS. CAC. Rich horseshoe-pattern toning dominates the eye appeal of this shining Superb Gem. The centers and right borders on each side are untoned, but the rest of the coin offers colors from amber to umber, gold, blue, and plum.(Registry values: N2998)

1125

1944 50C MS68 NGC. An absolutely amazing P-mint Walker. The surfaces show bright, intense mint luster that rolls around each side as the coin is slowly rotated beneath a light. Each side is brilliant, but for one notable exception: There is a sliver of deep russet toning on the right side of the obverse. The devices are sharply struck throughout. This is an unimprovable example of this date. Each of the major services has only certified one coin in this grade, and predictably none are finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1126

1944-D 50C MS67 PCGS. Solidly struck with magenta and orange patina on the obverse devices. The left and center parts of the reverse are lustrous and untoned, though a crescent of violet-rose appears to the right.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1127

1945 50C MS67 NGC. An exquisitely struck and radiantly lustrous Superb Gem with great eye appeal. Occasional wisps of tan color visit the margins. Impeccably preserved throughout.(Registry values: N1793)

1128

1945 50C MS67 NGC. A bright Superb Gem with a solid strike. Light peach toning at the margins and the right obverse give way to shining silver-white luster elsewhere. Tied for numerically finest certified by NGC (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1129

1945-D 50C MS67 PCGS. CAC. Ex: Charles Schultz. The famous cartoonist spelled his name Schulz, so this coin is from the "other" Charles Schultz. It is a stunning Superb Gem with frosty silver luster and pale champagne toning. PCGS has never certified a finer piece (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1130

1946-D 50C MS67 NGC. Bold gold-orange luster is mixed with silver on both sides, with the former color dominating the obverse and the reverse showing more of the latter. A lovely Superb Gem example of its challenging short-set issue. Tied for numerically finest known to NGC or PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1131

1946-D 50C MS67 NGC. A frosty short-set Superb Gem, slightly soft through the centers but with sharp eye appeal. Dappled gold and orange tones grace the margins.(Registry values: N1793)

1132

1946-S 50C MS67 NGC. Knob S. Well struck for the issue with effusive luster. The centers are virtually brilliant, though gold and forest-green elements appear at the borders. Tied for numerically finest in the combined certified population (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1133

1946-S 50C MS67 NGC. Trumpet Tail S. Soft violet, yellow-green, and purple obverse toning is joined on the reverse periphery by electric-blue. Generally well defined, including partial detail in the branch hand. Well preserved surfaces show satiny luster.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1134

1947 50C MS67 NGC. The brilliant surfaces of this Superb Gem exhibit sharply struck design features. There are no significant marks to report. Census: 60 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1135

1947-D 50C MS67 ★ NGC. Five examples of this date have been certified by NGC as MS67 ★ with none finer (1/10). Therefore, this top-quality example must be considered by the advanced specialist who is building the finest possible set. Both sides of this Superb Gem have frosty silver luster beneath mottled rainbow toning. The obverse is mostly toned while the reverse is primarily brilliant.(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Walking Liberty Half Dollars

1136

1936 50C PR64 PCGS. CAC. The 1936 is popular as the key issue to the Walking Liberty proof half dollar series. An exacting strike characterizes this near-Gem and light golden-tan patina runs over its luminous surfaces that are devoid of significant marks. These add up to flashy eye appeal, an attribute that did not go unnoticed by CAC.(Registry values: N1793)

1137

1936 50C PR65 PCGS. CAC. A delightful Gem specimen of this first-year proof Walking Liberty half. Both sides are boldly toned gold-gray overall with considerable reflectivity shining through. Uncommonly well-preserved for this perennially popular issue, and housed in a green label holder.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1138

1936 50C PR65 NGC. This is a brilliant silver-gold Gem of this perennially popular first-year key proof issue, made to the extent of only 3,901 pieces. There is little if any contrast between the fields and devices, but a hint of golden color prevails throughout, and only the most minor signs of contact seem to preclude an even finer grade. A super example for a type set or proof date set.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1139

1936 50C PR66 NGC. CAC. The smooth, glassy silver-white surfaces seem to offer no suggestion of other color, but the fields boast powerful reflectivity and the strike appears even a trifle bolder than normal. There is little contrast between the fields and devices, and a single tiny mark on Liberty's cheek is the only observable contact. Examples graded finer are much more difficult to obtain.(Registry values: N2998)

1140

1936 50C PR66 PCGS. A mere 3,901 proof halves were struck in 1936, and unfortunately a rather high percentage were mishandled. As a result, there are far fewer high grade survivors known of this issue, as a percentage of the mintage, than one might expect. This is a mostly brilliant coin with a hazy overlay of golden-yellow patina on each side. A defect-free example of this important first-year proof issue.(Registry values: N2998)

1141

1937 50C PR65 NGC. Specks of light tan toning are visible on both sides of this Gem proof, with the surfaces otherwise brilliant. The fields are nicely mirrored around lustrous and boldly detailed devices.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1142

1937 50C PR66 NGC. Excellent reflectivity with just a touch of gray patina over the mirrors. A strongly detailed Premium Gem proof with great visual appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

1143

1937 50C PR66 NGC. Gleaming fields are virtually untoned. As usual for the era, the devices have a largely brilliant finish as well. Carefully preserved for this earlier issue with high eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

1144

1937 50C PR67 PCGS. A solidly struck Superb Gem with glints of reflectivity that peek through rich gray-gold patina bordered in amber-orange. Great preservation and eye appeal for the toning enthusiast. PCGS has graded nine finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1145

1940 50C PR67 PCGS. The coin shows deep, flashy mirrors in the fields and just the slightest hint of blue and gold-gray patina. An outstanding Superb Gem proof for the type or date collector.(Registry values: N1793)

1146

1940 50C PR68 NGC. Some of the later proof Walking Liberty halves seem quite underrated compared to the first-year 1936, and this 1940 appears to fit that description. This Superb Gem offers delicately toned surfaces in shades of lilac and a cross between saffron and mint-green. The high reflectivity and complete absence of mentionable contact separate this piece from all but a small complement of the surviving population. Census: 52 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1147

1941 50C PR67 PCGS. No AW. Decisively detailed with gleaming and minimally toned fields. An impressive Superb Gem from this penultimate proof Walking Liberty issue. PCGS has graded 13 finer specimens (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1148

1941 50C PR67 PCGS. No AW. The designer's monogram is absent on the present piece, a feature seen on a majority of 1941 proofs due to a lapped reverse die. This is a satiny Superb Gem with appealing light golden-brown and ice-blue toning.(Registry values: N991)

Franklin Half Dollars

1149

1951-D 50C MS66 Full Bell Lines PCGS. Mottled dark red toning attractively speckles the obverse and the reverse peripheries of this well struck Premium Gem. Nicely preserved with only a couple of small imperfections. Population: 67 in 66 Full Bell Lines, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1150

1953 50C MS66 Full Bell Lines PCGS. Ultra frosty and original, being of probable mint set origin, with freckles of amber and olive-gray toning over both sides. From a relatively small mintage of 2.6 million pieces, this specimen can hardly be called a routine Franklin at this extraordinary grade level. Population: 30 in 66 Full Bell Lines, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1151

1963 50C MS65 Full Bell Lines PCGS. This minimally toned and lustrous Gem is remarkably devoid of contact. The reverse exergue has a few minute flan flaws, as made. The series came to an abrupt end in 1963, a consequence of Kennedy's assassination. No Full Bell Lines examples have been certified finer by PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

Proof Franklin Half Dollars

1152

1953 50C PR68 Cameo PCGS. CAC. A starkly contrasted, snow-white Superb Gem that resembles a newly minted proof striking from half a century later. Those in search of a technically and aesthetically unsurpassable 1953 proof Franklin need look no further. A very scarce issue in Cameo at this grade level. Population: 4 in 68 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1153

1953 50C PR66 Deep Cameo PCGS. Fantastic contrast for this earlier proof Franklin half dollar issue. Thickly frosted devices give way to gleaming fields that are virtually untoned save for a few faint milk spots at the margins. Population: 17 in 66 Deep Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1154

1954 50C PR67 Deep Cameo PCGS. CAC. Obvious contrast between the luminous devices and the darkly reflective fields confirms the Deep Cameo designation. This brilliant Superb Gem appears pristine, even when inspected beneath a loupe. Population: 28 in 67 Deep Cameo, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1155

1955 50C PR67 Deep Cameo PCGS. Untoned surfaces exhibit sharply struck motifs that establish excellent variance with the mirrored fields. Well preserved throughout. Population: 42 in 67 Deep Cameo, 16 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N991)

1156

1956 50C Type One PR69 Cameo NGC. The more elusive of the proof Franklin half variants for the issue. The Type One reverse is distinguished by the four feathers on the eagle's left (facing) wing that are clear of the perch. Fully brilliant with sharply struck, satiny motifs highlighted by deeply mirrored fields. Virtually immaculate.(Registry values: P2)

1157

1958 50C PR67 Deep Cameo PCGS. CAC. Delightfully reflective with bold field-to-device contrast. This Superb Gem specimen shows minor milk spotting in the reverse fields. Population: 38 in 67 Deep Cameo, 16 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

SMS Kennedy Half Dollars

1158

1965 50C SMS MS67 Ultra Cameo NGC. Complementing the 1966 Ultra Cameo in this sale, this 1965 SMS in MS67 Ultra Cameo is also an extremely elusive issue in so high a grade and with this degree of contrast. NGC has certified 20 examples in MS67 Ultra Cameo, while PCGS has graded eight coins in MS67 Deep Cameo (2/10). Broad doubling is visible on Kennedy's eye and on the front of the profile from the nose all the way down to the chin, down the neck, and on the rear of the lips. We believe this is likely machine or shelf doubling. The silver-white surfaces on this Superb Gem are pristine and thoroughly appealing.

1159

1966 50C SMS SP66 PCGS. FS-901, formerly FS-013.9. No FG. Frank Gasparro's designer's initials are absent, as struck from a polished reverse die. Brilliant surfaces are impeccably preserved. Some weakness is noted on the lower reverse shield, nevertheless, excellent overall eye appeal.(Registry values: N1)

1160

1966 50C SMS MS68 Ultra Cameo NGC. The 1965 and 1966 Kennedys in the Ultra Cameo or Deep Cameo designation are much more difficult than the other SMS 40% silver Kennedy, the 1967. NGC has certified only seven examples of the 1966 SMS in MS68 Ultra Cameo, with none finer. PCGS has graded four in MS68 Deep Cameo (2/10). This specimen offers pristine silver-white surfaces with excellent contrast and the desired silver-on-black appearance of deeply contrasted silver Kennedys.(Registry values: N991)

1161

1967 50C SMS MS68 Deep Cameo PCGS. 1967 saw the last of the three Special Mint Sets, before the Mint resumed adding mintmarks to coinage and shifted production of proof sets to San Francisco, where it remains to this day. The elusive deep cameo 1967 Kennedy halves are somewhat more available than the 1965s and 1966s. The present piece offers an awesome strike with jet-black fields and nicely frosted devices, virtually indistinguishable from a true proof. A small mark on Kennedy's nose is the only discernible flaw. Population: 6 in 68 Deep Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

Proof Kennedy Half Dollars

1162

1964 50C Accented Hair PR69 Cameo PCGS. This Kennedy half "variety" is in reality a one-year subtype, before modifications to the design were made at the Mint, reportedly to placate Jacqueline Kennedy. It is eagerly sought for type purposes, and by Kennedy specialists for several different Registry Sets at PCGS. Pleasing contrast is noted over both sides of this virtually pristine half. Boldly struck and devoid of toning--and unknown at this grade level in Deep Cameo. Population: 9 in 69 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

Early Dollars

1163

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Three Leaves--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VG Details. B-6, BB-25, R.3. Slightly dull from a cleaning, but this stone-gray and peach-gold example is surprisingly unabraded. The reverse has a few faint adjustment marks, as made. A better die marriage of this coveted Flowing Hair design, since the majority of Three Leaves survivors represent Bolender-5.(Registry values: N1793)

1164

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Three Leaves Fine 12 ANACS. B-5, BB-27, R.1. Stone-gray and electric-blue embrace this desirable crown-sized early silver type coin. The slightly bright surfaces are little abraded save for a cluster of thin marks near the right (facing) wing. The left wing retains much of its initial detail.(Registry values: N1793)

1165

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Three Leaves Fine 12 PCGS. B-5, BB-27, R.1. Specialists know to look for a slender die line or "bar" behind Liberty's upper neck curl, diagnostic for the familiar Bolender-5 marriage. A pearl-gray obverse is paired with lilac-gray and aqua-blue reverse. The obverse is hairlined. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

1166

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Three Leaves--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. B-5, BB-27, R.1. Instant diagnosis is enabled by the extra tine of metal behind Liberty's highest hair curl. The silver surfaces are overbright from a past cleaning, but they are beginning to mellow down a bit as they take on a slight golden hue. A couple of planchet voids, as made, appear on the reverse, one on the rim at 7:30, one beneath the bow.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1167

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Three Leaves XF45 NGC. B-7, BB-18, R.3. The date is widely spaced. The lowest curl is small, touching the innermost point of star 1. The Three Leaves reverse has 14 berries, seven on each branch half, with only one berry on the left branch half between the eagle's wing and the bow. This medium gray Choice XF is well defined and devoid of mentionable contact marks. Adjustment marks are absent.(Registry values: N4719)

1168

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Three Leaves AU50 PCGS. B-5, BB-27, R.1. Die State II. The so-called Head of 1795, Three Leaves variety, with star 1 well away from the lowest hair curl. The extra tine of metal behind Liberty's head diagnoses this most available Flowing Hair variety, of which probably several thousand exist in all grades combined. In this earliest known die state, a small reverse die crack is just beginning from the end of the left stem toward the rim; in Die State III the crack meets the rim.
This piece has a pleasing wealth of detail remaining for the grade, and the deep steel-gray patina mostly conceals a dark area in the right obverse field, apparent struck-in die grease that does not affect either the technical grade or the aesthetic appeal.(Registry values: N4719)

1169

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Three Leaves AU55 PCGS. B-6, BB-25, R.3. Bowers-Borckardt Die State III, dies clashed and lapped, a crack through star 10 on the obverse. These obverse features, combined with the Three Leaves reverse, confirm the variety. The strike is exceptional, as can be seen on Liberty's hair detail and on the eagle's feathers, surpassing the strike on two recent AU55 PCGS coins, both of the more common B-5, BB-27 variety, found in the Permanent Auction Archives; one, in the same die state as this coin, brought $25,300, and the other, in a later die state, brought an amazing $71,875.
Both sides have light gray toning over surfaces that retain considerable luster, even after the passage of more than two centuries. The reverse shows a number of adjustment marks all around the rims as well as across the eagle; these items do not detract from the eye appeal, but add character instead. PCGS has certified 63 finer pieces across all Three Leaves varieties (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1170

1795 $1 Flowing Hair, Two Leaves--Scratches--NGC. XF Details. B-1, BB-21, R.2. This Flowing Hair, Two Leaves example displays well, with the obverse luminous under silver-gray, green, and blue patina. The reverse, similarly toned and lustrous, shows a combination of straight adjustment marks and the curving scratches at the eagle's right side which triggered the details grade.(Registry values: P4)

1171

1795 $1 Draped Bust, Centered--Rim Damage, Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Fine Details. B-15, BB-52, R.2. This lightly toned first-year Draped Bust dollar is hairlined and glossy from cleaning, and faint scratches are present near the wreath stems, date, and lower right obverse field. The obverse has a rim ding at 4 o'clock, with lesser dings on the reverse at 2, 3, 6, and 11 o'clock.(Registry values: N1793)

1172

1795 $1 Draped Bust, Centered AU55 NGC. B-15, BB-52, R.2. One of two Draped Bust varieties for this year. The portrait of Liberty is well centered on this variety, and the highest wave of hair is located under the E of LIBERTY. On the reverse, there are six berries on the olive branch, and there is a leaf under the A of STATES.
This bright Choice AU specimen is nearly untoned, except for occasional wisps of light tan. Traces of luster reside in the protected areas, and the design features display excellent definition. Light adjustment marks are visible on the clouds and at portions of the peripheral areas on each side. The surfaces are quite clean for a lightly circulated, large coin. A splendid Draped Bust Small Eagle dollar. Census: 23 in 55, 46 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1173

1795 $1 Draped Bust, Off Center XF45 ANACS. B-14, BB-51, R.2. The sole Draped Bust die pair with off-center portrait (shifted to the left). Dusky blue-gray surfaces show light but distinct wear, with several digs visible in the right obverse field. Parallel adjustment marks in the portrait area and close to the rim should not be interpreted as abrasions.(Registry values: P3)

1174

1796 $1 Small Date, Small Letters--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VG Details. B-2, BB-63, R.4. Almond-gold and stone-gray overall with hints of charcoal patina on the upper left obverse. Slightly bright, but many collectors would cherish its possession. All legends are bold except for AMERICA, which is faint but nonetheless readable.(Registry values: N1793)

1175

1797 $1 10x6 Stars, Large Letters XF45 PCGS. B-3, BB-71, R.2. Bowers-Borckardt Die State II with lapped borders to the right-side palm leaves. Steel-gray and golden-brown at the centers with cobalt-blue throughout the borders. The eagle's breast feathers exhibit wear, but the wing plumage retains much of its initial detail. Both sides are refreshing unabraded except for a small nick on the reverse rim at 4:30. The scarce 1797 dollars are divided into three different die varieties, which differ sufficiently that each receives a separate Guide Book listing. Population: 31 in 45, 31 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

1176

1797 $1 9x7 Stars, Large Letters AU50 NGC. B-1, BB-73. R.3. Intermediate Die State III-IV. This is a very attractive 1797 dollar that should stimulate strong bidding competition between the type collector looking for a choice specimen and the die variety collector interested a magnificent example of the late die state with the clashed and shattered obverse die. Both the obverse and the reverse have lustrous, medium gray and rose surfaces with a darker splash of color on the left side of the obverse. This specimen has all the attributes of Bowers' Die State III, as follows: "OBVERSE: A few delicate traces of arc-like clash marks are in the field before Miss Liberty's face and are so subtle that only high-grade coins show them; these are from the curved palm leaves on the reverse. The die has developed hairline cracks as follows: From denticles upward to outermost point of star 4, continuing through a point of star 5 to ribbon; crack from ribbon downward through hair curl, hair, bottom curl, to border. Minute crack from denticles downward to star 5. Crack from denticle through two bottom points of star 7 to ribbon. From bottom of 97 of date through bust drapery to star 15, minutely continuing through the centers of stars 14 and 13. From denticle toward (but not touching) star 15. Stars on right develop distended points toward the denticles. REVERSE: No cracks."
This specimen is struck from a slightly later state of the dies. Many of the breaks as described under Die State III extend further than as described. On the reverse, a break is forming from the denticles through the second T in STATES into the wreath. There are numerous adjustment marks on the obverse, with some in Liberty that "blend" with the hair. There is a small planchet flaw from 17 in the date to the rim. The central details are somewhat weak, as expected, and each side has light gray-rose toning with a thin arc of darker color on the left obverse rim. A lovely, problem-free example with a few light adjustment marks in the center of the obverse.(Registry values: N4719)

1177

1797 $1 9x7 Stars, Small Letters AU50 PCGS. B-2, BB-72, R.4. The 9x7 Stars obverse paired with a Small Letters reverse, the sole die pair of its kind for the date and most elusive of the three varieties for the year. While light wear is present across the high design elements of this example, it remains strongly lustrous through a mix of gold and gray hues, with medium-gray more prominent on the obverse and areas of deeper charcoal capturing attention on the reverse. Minor central striking softness is typical. Lightly abraded overall with a hidden vertical pinscratch that travels right-of-center along the portrait.(Registry values: N4719)

1178

1798 $1 Large Eagle, Pointed 9 VF30 PCGS. B-15, BB-112, R.3. This midgrade first year Heraldic Eagle dollar is predominantly stone-gray with lime-green overtones. The strike is slightly soft on the stars above the eagle, but ample design detail is present. The fields are somewhat cloudy, but there are no remotely mentionable marks.(Registry values: N1793)

1179

1798 $1 Large Eagle, Pointed 9, Close Date--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. B-29, BB-119, R.4. Both sides are hairlined, more noticeably on the reverse. Almond-gold overall with dusky dove-gray on the upper reverse. Softly impressed on the eagle's head and nearby stars. Although merely scarce in VF, BB-119 is very rare in XF or finer grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1180

1798 $1 Large Eagle, Pointed 9, Close Date XF40 ANACS. B-27, BB-113, R.2. Steel-blue and caramel-gold toning embraces this richly detailed silver dollar. Luster shimmers from design elements. Smooth overall, although a thin and faintly granular streak is noted above the nose, and a few tiny ticks affect the L in LIBERTY. Housed in an ANA cache holder.(Registry values: N1793)

1181

1798 $1 Large Eagle, Pointed 9 XF45 PCGS. B-27, BB-113, R.2. The obverse is quickly recognized as the 8 is high and leans to the right. This boldly defined dollar has details that approach full AU, especially on the obverse. The toning is fully original, deep steel-blue and gray with light iridescence splashed over the surfaces.(Registry values: N1793)

1182

1798 $1 Knob 9, 5 Stripes VF30 NGC. B-4, BB-92, R.4. This delightful dollar has light gray devices, medium gray fields, and darker gray along the border. The strike is nicely centered on both sides, although the lower reverse border is merged into the field. The quality of this piece is excellent for its rarity and grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P1)

1183

1798 $1 Large Eagle, Pointed 9, Wide Date--Scratches--NGC. VF Details. B-23, BB-105, R.3. Moderately worn with luminous tan-gray central zones surrounded by deep slate-blue. The portrait and surrounding areas show a number of light scratches, and a deeper scratch is visible on the reverse ribbon just to the left of the eagle's neck.(Registry values: P1)

1184

1799 $1 7x6 Stars--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VG Details. B-11, BB-161, R.3. A significantly worn example of this 1799 variety with surfaces that are too glossy after a past cleaning. The peripheral zones have since retoned from light gray to golden-tan and blue.(Registry values: N991)

1185

1799 $1 7x6 Stars--Environmental Damage--NGC. VG Details. B-14, BB-167, R.3. An extensively worn example with elements of environmental damage influencing the blue, green, and gray colors on each side. The right obverse field shows a shallow diagonal scratch. Still, a readily collectible example of the issue.(Registry values: N991)

1186

1799 $1 7x6 Stars--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. B-12, BB-160, R.3. Bowers-Borckardt Die State 1, a rare state without the usual obverse die cracks. A moderately worn example, lightly retoned blue-green and gold after a past cleaning, with a number of small digs and a patch of apparent adjustment marks at the E in LIBERTY.(Registry values: N1793)

1187

1799 $1 7x6 Stars--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF20 Details. B-14, BB-167, R.3. A lovely example for the description, with light silver-gray surfaces and subtle gold toning around most of the devices. Only a few hairlines and other imperfections can be found to suggest that this piece has been cleaned.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1188

1799 $1 7x6 Stars--Improperly Cleaned--NCS. XF Details. B-12, BB-160, R.3. Bowers-Borckardt Die State III. This 18th century Draped Bust dollar has pleasing detail and noticeable luster. The lower right obverse border displays hints of russet-red toning, but most of the piece is untoned. Careful rotation reveals faint field hairlines, and a few minor thin marks are noted near the right-side obverse stars.(Registry values: N1793)

1189

1799 $1 7x6 Stars XF40 NGC. B-8, BB-165, R.3. A die crack and small lumps at the top of the second S in STATES is the usual diagnostic feature of this variety. This example has faint champagne toning over light silver surfaces, with splashes of deeper peripheral color. It is a pleasing piece that retains traces of its original luster.(Registry values: N1793)

1190

1799 $1 7x6 Stars--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. B-14, BB-167, R.3. Bowers-Borckardt Die State IV. The reverse appears unimpaired, while the obverse is mildly granular, particularly on a gray streak from star 3 through the ribbon. Steel-gray and forest-green with glimpses of sun-gold. Mint luster is evident in design crevices.(Registry values: N1793)

1191

1799 $1 7x6 Stars XF45 PCGS. B-11, BB-161, R.3. The reverse is prominently cracked through UNITED and from the rim to the eagle's left wing. Light peach and gold-gray shadings have settled over the subtly lustrous surfaces of this Choice XF coin, which shows a number of small digs in the fields.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1192

1799/8 $1 15 Stars Reverse MS62 NGC. B-3, BB-141, R.3. The 1799/8 overdated obverse die paired with the blundered 15 Star reverse that includes two points projecting from an oversized cloud at the far left. This double-blundered die pair is the sole source of 1799/8 15 Star Reverse coins, which makes it a Guide Book staple. Fortunately for collectors, the variety is accessible (if rare) in Mint State grades. This MS62 piece is one such example, strongly detailed with subtle luster that persists through gold-gray toning with occasional deeper elements. Aside from a few short abrasions in the fields, a minimally marked coin for the grade. Census: 10 in 62, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

1193

1799 $1 Irregular Date, 13 Stars Reverse--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. B-15, BB-152, R.3. The obverse has the Irregular Date layout, and the reverse is a left over die from 1798 with the stars in the Line Pattern. Despite the description that this piece has been cleaned, it is attractive and desirable with hints of rose and blue toning over light gray surfaces.(Registry values: P1)

1194

1799 $1 Irregular Date, 15 Stars Reverse VF25 PCGS. B-4, BB-153, R.4. The famous reverse with greatly enlarged first and last clouds, a futile attempt by the engraver to conceal a blundered star count. An unmarked and impressively detailed example with dark brown and cobalt-blue toning. Minor verdigris is noted near the date.(Registry values: P1)

1195

1799 $1 8x5 Stars VF25 ANACS. B-23, BB-159, R.4. When engraving this die, the engraver may have forgotten the denomination of his work, and after placing eight stars to his right (the left side of the coin), he could only punch five more stars on the other side of the obverse. The 8x5 Stars layout was standard for gold coins at the time. This deeply toned piece has dark gray surfaces with few problems, while the central reverse has adjustment marks in several directions.(Registry values: P1)

1196

1800 $1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Fine Details. B-13, BB-193, R.4. Bowers-Borckardt Die State IV, with terminal die failures that go beyond even those described in the reference. Blue, gold, and rose-gray shadings cover improbably bright surfaces.(Registry values: N1793)

1197

1800 $1 XF40 PCGS. B-13, 18, BB-193, R.2. This is the late die state that was formerly known as B-18, and considered to be quite plentiful. Heavy clash marks are present, and the obverse has a die bulge at about 2 o'clock, causing weakness at RI of AMERICA. The surfaces have natural deep golden-gray toning with hints of lilac and blue in the fields.(Registry values: N1793)

1198

1800 $1 --Whizzed--NCS. AU Details. B-12, BB-184, R.3. This briefly circulated early dollar has been carefully whizzed to convey the appearance of cartwheel luster throughout the fields. A relatively lengthy pinscratch reaches the M in AMERICA, and a couple of thin marks are located near Liberty's ear. Nonetheless, the sharpness of the present coin would make it an important addition to a specialized holding.(Registry values: N2998)

1199

1800 $1 Wide Date, Low 8--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Fine Details. B-10, BB-190, R.3. The sole Wide Date, Low 8 variety for the year. Bright surfaces remain in the centers, but the margins have retoned gold and slate-gray.(Registry values: P1)

1200

1800 $1 AMERICAI XF40 ANACS. B-19a, BB-192, R.2. The AMERICAI variety receives its moniker from the prominent die scratch (as made) near the final A in AMERICA. The present representative has satin luster within protected areas, and is draped in deep steel-blue and walnut-brown toning. The infrequent inconspicuous thin mark barely merits mention.(Registry values: P1)

1201

1800 $1 12 Arrows--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. B-17, BB-196, R.1. Bowers-Borckardt Die State IV. A moderately bright pearl-gray early dollar that has traces of autumn-gold near the right-side obverse rim. The slightly cloudy surfaces are minimally abraded aside from a brief scratch between the lips and star 10.(Registry values: P1)

1202

1800 $1 12 Arrows XF45 NGC. B-17, BB-196, R.1. Bowers-Borckardt Die State IV, "scarce." This variety is usually identified by the collar-like clash mark along the upper edge of Liberty's bosom, although a few are known from perfect dies. The example offered here is a problem-free piece with dark brown and iridescent toning.(Registry values: P1)

1203

1801 $1 XF40 ANACS. B-1, BB-211, R.3. Bowers-Borckardt Die State II. Sea-green, powder-blue, and dove-gray embrace this moderately circulated and problem-free Heraldic Eagle dollar. Most letters in E PLURIBUS UNUM are bold, and all are legible. Traces of luster glimmer from protected regions.(Registry values: N2998)

1204

1802/1 $1 Narrow Date MS62 PCGS. B-4, BB-232, R.3. Bowers-Borckardt Die State II, with a die crack beginning in the obverse field near star 13, crossing the bust line above the drapery, and terminating a short distance to the left. This is the typical die state for the 1802/1 B-4 dollar.
The specimen offered here is a true Condition Census candidate and is probably the third finest known. We offered the Queller Family specimen in April 2008, certified as MS63 NGC, and we have offered one other piece, an NGC MS61. In addition to those coins, an MS63 is recorded in the Bowers Silver Dollar Encyclopedia under notable specimens, a coin that appeared in a 1984 Stack's sale. The impressive Cardinal Collection had an AU58, and the Hesselgesser Collection on the PCGS Set Registry has an AU55.
This amazing Mint State piece has satiny silver luster beneath incredible, fully natural gray-gold toning with splashes of russet, blue, and violet. Both sides have bold design definition with the exception of a few obverse stars that are flat. The strike is nicely centered, with full, even borders. Minor abrasions are visible beneath the toning, but they are entirely consistent with the grade and of no concern.
The Davis-Graves Specimen was described in the 1954 Stack's catalog as "Lustrous and nicely toned, but struck weakly on left side. Unlisted die breaks on obverse make this coin so much the rarer. Left side of 8 recut. Reverse has proof-like surface. Not quite in 'gem' class. Uncirculated."
Ex: Davis-Graves Collection (Stack's, 4/1954), lot 1326.(Registry values: N7079)

1205

1802 $1 Narrow Date VF20 PCGS. B-6, BB-241, R.1. The missing right foot of the T in LIBERTY confirms the variety. Semi-bright gold-gray surfaces display traces of luster in the deep recesses. Aside from the expected wear, the design elements exhibit sharp definition. The few minute marks that are present are consistent with moderate circulation.(Registry values: N1793)

1206

1802 $1 Narrow Date VF25 PCGS. B-6, BB-241, R.1. The date is spaced 18 02, the right foot of the T in LIBERTY is missing, and the first A in AMERICA touches the third feather. Light to medium gray patina bathes both sides and strong definition is apparent on the design features. Devoid of mentionable contacts and of adjustment marks.(Registry values: N1793)

1207

1802 $1 Narrow Date VF35 PCGS. B-6, BB-241, R.1. Deep dove-gray patina blankets this evenly struck and well detailed Draped Bust type coin. Protected areas of the reverse display traces of aqua residue, and a faded thin mark precedes the U in UNITED. The demand for early dollars has risen considerably over the past twenty years, although relatively few numismatists dare to collect the series by die variety.(Registry values: N1793)

1208

1802 $1 Narrow Date XF45 PCGS. B-6, BB-241, R.1. Bowers-Borckardt Die State III, most commonly seen state (lapped die). Subtle luster filters through violet-gray toning with golden-tan edge accents. In the right obverse field, a "bar" of raised metal is not a die feature but actually a post-striking flaw; close inspection shows the "fresh metal" along the bottom edge.(Registry values: N1793)

1209

1802 $1 Narrow Date XF45 PCGS. B-6, BB-241, R.1. A wider space between 8 and 0, a missing right foot in the T of LIBERTY, the first A in AMERICA touching the third feather and connected by a die crack to the fourth feather confirm the variety. Light gray surfaces display traces of luster in the recessed areas and are minimally marked. Strong definition is apparent on the design elements. A highly appealing Choice XF.(Registry values: N1793)

1210

1802 $1 Narrow Date--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. B-6, BB-241, R.1. Light to medium golden-brown throughout except for a blush of navy-blue and plum-red along the lower left obverse margin. Faintly hairlined, but the eye appeal is excellent when viewed only with the unaided eye. Sharply struck and partly lustrous.(Registry values: N2998)

1211

1803 $1 Small 3 XF45 NGC. B-5, BB-252, R.2. The 3 has a thin top and its right corner nearly touches the bust, while stars 6 and 7 are more widely separated than any other pair. Pleasing silver-gray centers emit significant luster, with a single small spot noted above Liberty's hair ribbon. No mentionable abrasions are present, although a bit of central strike weakness appears on the reverse. Neither are any clash marks or adjustment marks seen on this pleasing Choice XF example.(Registry values: N2998)

1212

1803 $1 Large 3 XF40 PCGS. B-6, BB-255, R.2. Bowers-Borckardt Die State II. A rich blanket of cream-gray toning fails to conceal the glimpses of bright luster that emerge from the letters, stars, and other design elements. Surprisingly unabraded despite a small rim nick above the second S in STATES. B-6, the sole Large 3 die variety, presumably constituted the early 1804 delivery that decades later led the U.S. Mint to strike novodel 1804 dollars.(Registry values: P2)

1213

1803 $1 Large 3 AU55 ANACS. B-6, BB-255, R.2. Light golden-brown toning drapes both sides, although the right borders display powder-blue, lemon-gold, and ruby-red patina. Sharply struck and partly lustrous with moderately bright surfaces. The Large 3 variety likely accounted for the 1804 delivery that led to the famous novodel proofs decades later.(Registry values: P2)

Gobrecht Dollars

1214

1836 P$1 Name on Base, Judd-60 Original, Pollock-65, R.1, PR62 NGC. CAC. Silver. Plain Edge. Die Alignment I (the center of Liberty's head is opposite the DO in DOLLAR). This early December striking is noteworthy for the Gobrecht specialist as it lacks evidence of the die clashing seen on later die states. It was apparently struck in the same production run as the fabulous Korein number 47 coin, now impounded in the ANS. The fields are remarkably bright and reflective on this piece. It is John Dannreuther's belief that these coins were struck from polished dies, but the planchets were unburnished and the coins were only struck once. However, it is easy to see how these coins, when found in high grade, have traditionally been called proofs. Coins such as this one are clearly suggestive of a proof striking, and there is a distinct absence of non-reflective pieces among the high-grade examples known.
This is a brightly reflective dollar that has few post-striking flaws for the grade. The centers are generally untoned and there is a thin ring of golden-rose and blue toning around the margins. The striking details are full on each side. A magnificent, high-end example of this historic and numismatically significant dollar.

1215

1836 P$1 Name on Base, Judd-60 Restrike, Pollock-65, R.5--Graffiti, Repaired--NGC. Proof VF Details. Silver. Die Alignment IV (center of Liberty's head opposite the right side of F in OF). While these pieces are believed to have been struck for circulation in March, 1837, apparently someone had different ideas for this piece as a memento. The letters N. and Y. were hand engraved on the left and right side of the date, presumably an abbreviation for New York. There is faint evidence remaining in the left and right fields of hand engraving as well, suggesting this was some sort of presentation piece. However, most of the lettering has been effaced by extensive pin scratches. The devices show even wear over the high points and light gray patina.

1216

1836 P$1 Name on Base, Judd-60 Restrike, Pollock-65, R.5, PR61 NGC. Silver. Reeded Edge. Die Alignment II (center of Liberty's head opposite ES in STATES). This issue has probably generated more debate among Gobrecht specialists than any other (with the possible exception of the Name Below Base). These pieces are termed "restrikes" but the actual Gobrecht restrikes were produced decades later. These pieces differ from Die Alignment I coins in their medallic alignment. They were produced as actual circulating coinage, and in proof format. But that is where specialists begin to diverge in their opinions. Medallic alignment 1836 coins are known in numerous reverse alignments from DA II to DA IV, and some are even below the horizontal plane in what is sometimes known as DA IV+. It was thought for years that the die came loose and rotated, causing the various striking alignments. Recently it has been asserted, but not proved, that the reverse die was removed and replaced several times, each time in a different position and each position representing a different production run. It is easy to imagine the difficulty in proving this theory, yet research continues. It is generally accepted (although not by all specialists) that 600 coins were struck in March, 1837. These coins are all distinguished by a faint die clash mark (once thought to be a die scratch) above the eagle's wing.
The surfaces of this piece display swirling, deep iridescent toning with flashy underlying mirrors from the proof finish. The striking details are complete on each side. The only marks of any note are in the lower reverse field, and there is an interesting strike-through, possibly a piece of wire, through ST.

1217

1839 P$1 Name Omitted, Judd-104 Original, Pollock-116, R.3, PR63 PCGS. Silver. Reeded Edge. Die Alignment IV: Center of Liberty's head opposite right side of F in OF. In December 1839, there were 300 Gobrecht dollars struck for circulation. All known coins of this date (both Originals and Restrikes) are in Die Alignment III or IV, but Originals are only known from Die Alignment IV. Unlike the 1836-dated coins, none are known in Die Alignment I, with the eagle flying upward. Thus it was impossible for the grading services to follow the lead of the 1836 dollars and label Die Alignment I coins as Originals, since none exist. Rather, the coins with little or no reverse die cracking were labeled as Original strikings, while the more heavily cracked pieces (through the tops of MERI, TE, and the bottom of LAR) are considered Restrikes, presumably produced between 1858 and 1885. This particular piece neatly fits into the Original category. Strong magnification shows a hairline-thin crack between the tops of ER, but it is so faint many may not see it.
Original 1839 dollars are generally found in circulated or impaired condition. This is logical, as they were struck in 1839 and released into circulation. Few people had the awareness in 1839 to set aside the recently designed dollar simply because it was dated that year. Presumably, most people who were interested in Christian Gobrecht's design set aside memento pieces from the first year of issue in 1836. The population data from PCGS certainly bears this out: PCGS has only certified 19 Originals in all grades (2/10).
This is a particularly attractive example. The fields are nicely mirrored, and the reflectivity is consistent with proofs of other denominations struck in this era. Each side shows variegated rose and sea-green toning. The striking details are absolutely full, even showing complete definition on Liberty's foot. Magnification shows a few small contact marks in the fields on each side, but none are of singular importance.

1218

1839 P$1 Name Omitted, Judd-104 Original, Pollock-116, R.3, PR64 NGC. Silver. Reeded Edge. Die Alignment IV (center of Liberty's head opposite the right side of the F in OF). The NGC insert does not specify whether the coin is an Original or Restrike, it merely states "J-104." However, there are absolutely no die cracks on the reverse; none through the tops of MERI (as usually seen), none through TE, and no trace of cracking connecting LAR (as seen on later restrikes). This lack of die cracking places this piece as an original striking and one of the 300 coins of this date actually struck in December, 1839. The Smithsonian has an Original, presumably purchased in the year of issue, but it only grades PR60.
Of the 300 pieces struck in 1839, it is estimated that only 60 to 75 pieces exist today. This is undoubtedly one of the finest. The fields show the moderate reflectivity seen on original strikings of Gobrecht dollars from the 1830s. A soft sign for the difference between Restrikes and Originals can often be seen from the appearance of the mirrored fields. Originals have reflectivity that is consistent with a large production proof coin from the 1830s. Restrikes from the 1850s onward display the deep mirroring seen on post-1857 proofs of other denominations. The fields display light die striations, a feature we do not recall having seen on this issue previously. The striking details are strong throughout but not quite full, only lacking absolute high point detail on Liberty's foot and the centrils of stars 1 and 2. Each side has medium-density gray-rose toning with deep blue accents around the margins. We do not see any contact marks on either side of this impressive, high-grade Gobrecht dollar.

Seated Dollars

1219

1845 $1 XF45 ANACS. Powder-blue and straw-gold toning alternate across this lightly abraded and attractively defined No Motto Seated dollar. Luster fills the drapery, plumage, and legends. A mere 24,500 pieces were struck.(Registry values: N991)

1220

1846 $1 AU50 PCGS. A softly lustrous and richly toned AU example of this earlier Seated dollar issue. The obverse has peripheral toning in violet and olive-orange around a medium-gray center, while the reverse has similar but slightly lighter colors combined across that side.(Registry values: N991)

1221

1849 $1 MS63 NGC. Impressive eye appeal for this mid-19th century issue. The luster is strong, and whispers of golden toning grace the margins. Central detail is crisp, though the peripheral elements show trifling softness, and though a handful of wispy abrasions are present in the fields, the surfaces are devoid of overt flaws. Census: 14 in 63, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1222

1850 $1 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has altered surfaces. Both sides show moderate to extensive abrasions, and the fields are oddly reflective beneath gold-gray and violet toning that forms a fingerprint pattern above the eagle's head.

1223

1860 $1 MS63 NGC. Not to be confused with the 1860-O or 1859-O, the two common dates of the type, the 1860 was saved but certainly not in bag quantities like the O-mints. The surfaces on this piece are untoned and the devices are well, but not quite fully struck. Only a few light field marks account for the grade. Census: 18 in 63, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1224

1860 $1 MS64 PCGS. Ocean-blue and lilac toning embraces this well struck and moderately prooflike near-Gem. Marks are scarce and of little relevance. The 1860 is significantly scarcer in Mint State than its New Orleans counterpart, and Uncirculated examples are also more elusive than proofs of the same date. Population: 27 in 64, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1225

1860-O $1 MS63 PCGS. CAC. A sealed Treasury bag of 1860-O dollars is said to have surfaced in the early 1960s, and indeed, there are several hundred examples certified in grades between MS60 and MS62. At the MS63 level, the 1860-O is substantially scarcer, since most Uncirculated survivors are bagmarked. This is a lightly abraded and subdued No Motto silver dollar that features deep jade-green and rose-red toning.(Registry values: N2998)

1226

1860-O $1 MS63 NGC. It is a remarkable stroke of fate that bags of New Orleans Seated dollars survived for more than a hundred years. If not for this hoard of 1859-O and 1860-O dollars, Uncirculated No Motto dollars would be prohibitively rare and limited to the 1846-O and 1850-O issues. This is a bright, lustrous example, common to all 1860-O hoard dollars, that shows just a hint of pale color on each side. The strike is sharp throughout and there are only small, individually inoffensive abrasions scattered about. Census: 44 in 63, 37 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1227

1871 $1 MS64 NGC. Soft golden-gray patination resides on the lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem. This is a well struck piece with a few light grade-consistent marks. The 1871 is the most common circulation-strike date in the later Seated Liberty dollar series. Gem and finer coins are extremely difficult to locate. Census: 35 in 64, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1228

1871-CC $1 AU53 PCGS. The 1871-CC is always a popular coin with Seated dollar collectors, and an AU example is sure to garner much attention from specialists since so few pieces exist in higher grades. Estimates of the number known in all grades vary widely from as few as "less than 50" to as many as 175 pieces. What is not in contention, though, is how seldom this date is located in AU condition. The obverse of this coin is brighter than the reverse and a number of small to medium sized-abrasions are scattered over that side also. Light reddish-golden toning is seen over both obverse and reverse. Population: 5 in 53, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

1229

1872-CC $1 Good 4 PCGS. A well-worn but problem-free example of this popular Carson City Seated dollar issue. Both sides show partial rims and warm gold-gray color. An excellent candidate for the discerning collector of circulated coinage.(Registry values: N991)

1230

1872-CC $1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. The 1872-CC Seated dollar came in with a mintage of only 3,150 coins, but even so a few Mint State pieces are known. The mintage was still higher than for the 1871-CC or 1872-CC, however. This piece is faintly hairlined from an old cleaning, and the mint luster is somewhat diffuse, more so on the obverse than the reverse. The surfaces have retoned in a deep blend of gray, blue, and pinkish-gold. Quite a few unidentified small, raised bumps appear on the obverse around Liberty's pole arm--possibly air bubbles in the planchet.(Registry values: N4719)

1231

1873-CC $1 XF40 PCGS. As the Mint began the transition from Seated dollars to Trade dollars, the former series was produced in small quantities, just sufficient to meet the demand of commerce at the time. Just 2,300 of these coins were originally struck, and few have survived to this day. Nearly every known survivor is damaged in some way, from lightly cleaned to heavily marked. The present piece is a truly important exception to the rule.
This amazing 1873-CC Seated silver dollar is absolutely original with exceptional silver-gray surfaces and few of the imperfections that are so often associated with the issue. Population: 8 in 40, 26 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

Proof Seated Dollars

1232

1840 $1 --Cleaned--PR58 ANACS. It is not known with certainty how many proof dollars were struck in 1840, but the generally accepted range is somewhere between 20 and 40 pieces. All are from the same die pairing. This is an unquestioned proof striking, even though it has its problems. The fields are deeply reflective like only a proof can be, quite unlike the semireflective business strikes from the 1840s. The surfaces show evidence of cleaning and the coin appears to have spent a short amount of time in circulation (or someone's pocket) as evidenced by the "fuzzy" appearance seen in the fields and several field marks on the obverse. Still, a very rare proof Seated dollar and rarely available in any condition.(Registry values: N1)

1233

1846 $1 PR64 NGC. Ex: Pittman/Richmond. This piece has a memorable pedigree that extends back to the "World's Greatest Collection" of legendary numismatist F.C.C. Boyd, along with such later luminaries of numismatics as famed Hollywood actor Adolphe Menjou, John Jay Pittman, and Jack Lee. When we offered the piece in July, 2009, we wrote this about the coin:

"This boldly blundered date has the first impression about 50% below the final date position. In the World's Greatest Collection catalog, Abe Kosoff and Abner Kreisberg cataloged the variety as '1846 over 44.' A half century before that, David Proskey called the variety '1846 over 45' in the Parmelee catalog.
"Proof silver dollars of 1846 exist in two different varieties. David Akers wrote in the Pittman catalog that the 1846 Seated dollars were the only proofs of the 1840s with more than one variety, apparently overlooking the second variety of proof 1845. About 10 to 15 examples of the blundered date proof are known, and about five or six examples of the normal date are known. The known population includes an example in the Smithsonian Institution, along with numerous auction appearances. Our database includes 50 different auction appearances of proof 1846 dollars.
"A wonderful proof, this example is fully and deeply mirrored around satiny devices, all beneath predominant steel-blue toning, with lighter gold and bright silver at the centers."

This piece in PR64 is one of eight coins so certified at NGC, with one PR66 finer. PCGS has graded three PR64 pieces, with one PR65 finer. Although the total at both services stands at 24, we doubt that more than 15 different pieces exist.
Ex: World's Greatest Collection (Numismatic Gallery, 1/1945), lot 135; Adolphe Menjou (Numismatic Gallery, 6/1950), lot 2091; John J. Pittman (David Akers, 5/1998), lot 1674; Richmond Collection (David Lawrence, 11/2004), lot 1511; Estate of Jack Lee Collection (Heritage, 1/2009), lot 3962.(Registry values: N7079)

1234

1851 $1 Restrike PR62 NGC. Ex: Richmond Collection. The 1851 Seated dollar is a confusing date in the series, whose understandability is hampered even more by the infrequency that these pieces were offered. In short, there were 1,300 business strikes produced. That is certain, but after that matters become more cloudy. Allegedly original proofs were struck, but Bowers claims these are really misattributed restrikes or first-strike business strikes. It appears that some 50-100 restrikes were produced in 1858 or later to satisfy collector demand for this date. Much has been made about the centering of the date or its closeness to the rock above the exergual area, but until someone proves definitively that a true, non-die clashed proof with a high date exists, we will assume that the few proofs that are known are all restrikes.
This is a modestly mirrored example that has light, golden-tan toning over each side. A few small contact marks are located in the fields, the most notable are seen to the right of Liberty's shin, another to the left of the eagle's beak, and a third below the left leg of the second A in AMERICA. A lovely example of this very rare and highly sought-after Seated dollar. Census: 4 in 62, 8 finer (2/10).
Ex: Richmond Collection, Part Two (David Lawrence, 11/2004), lot 1516, which realized $24,725.(Registry values: N7079)

1235

1854 $1 PR64 NGC. Vivid aquamarine and olive-gold embraces this fully struck and beautifully preserved Choice proof Seated dollar. A small granular area beneath the first T in STATES provides an identifier as well as a tight cluster of darker spots to the right of the eagle's neck. Struck from the usual proof obverse die with what Bowers (1993) calls "a triangular raised defect or 'island' above and to the right of the numeral 5 in the date." Duncan Lee (2006) suggests the defect is the top of a misplaced 4. It may also represent an upper left fragment of the crosslet of a misplaced 4. The reverse die has a light horizontal die line beneath the E in ONE. As is the case with all pre-1858 proofs of the series, the 1854 is very rare and highly desirable. Census: 7 in 64, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

1236

1858 $1 PR64 NGC. Breen-5456, Reverse of 1857. The mintage of this proof-only issue is variously estimated at from 225 to 300 pieces or a bit more, up considerably from the figure of 80 pieces that was touted by many numismatic scholars, apparently dating all the way back to the famous Chapman brothers coin dealers. It is the sole proof-only issue among Liberty Seated dollars and, as Bowers says, "This is the Liberty Seated series' counterpart to the Proof-only 1895 dollar in the Morgan series." The present-day Guide Book gives a figure of 300 pieces, apparently based on the research of Liberty Seated specialist Weimar White (Bowers, Silver Dollars & Trade Dollars of the United States).
Whatever the true number, this issue is the object of intense desire among numismatists, even those who, to paraphrase Bowers further, will never own another Liberty Seated dollar. And it is certain to remain an elusive rarity in the future. In PR64 condition, NGC and PCGS have certified 17 coins, with 13 pieces finer (4/09). The present example offers lovely pink-champagne and gold surfaces with brilliant luster and a superlative strike. The Reverse of 1857 can be distinguished by a bit of die rust on the L in DOL. and on the rim below. A significant opportunity for the Seated dollar specialists, or just for collectors who genuinely love truly rare coins. Census: 12 in 64, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1237

1859 $1 PR64 PCGS. CAC. Bowers estimated that 800 proofs were issued in 1859. The base of the 1 is repunched, mentioned in Breen-5457 and in Bowers as his Variety 1. This attractive specimen has light silver gray color and is well struck, with scattered hairlines visible under a glass. Population: 42 in 64, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1238

1859 $1 PR65 NGC. Champagne-gold patina in the central areas is framed by electric-blue and lavender and a powerful strike imparts sharp delineation to the design elements. A few minute handling marks are in concert with the numerical grade. Probably fewer than 450 of the 800 reportedly minted were distributed, the rest likely melted. Census: 15 in 65, 23 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1239

1859 $1 PR67 PCGS. CAC. The 2010 Red Book reports that 800 dollars were struck in proof format in 1859. David Bowers writes in his 1993 Silver Dollars and Trade Dollars of the United States that:

"... many Proofs were made this year in the hope that the public, which was becoming increasingly interested in numismatics, would buy them. Today, the issue is quite rare, and it is likely that 450 or fewer were actually distributed. Even that figure might be on the high side. There were hardly 450 numismatists in 1859 interested in buying Proof dollars from the Mint. However, enough coins survive today to indicate that 450 is a reasonable estimate of distribution."

In any event, NGC and PCGS have certified approximately 290 1859 proof dollars, ranging in grade from PR50 to PR67, with the vast majority falling within the PR61 to PR64 range. The two services have assigned the Cameo designation to a few pieces. This is the only non-Cameo PR67 certified by PCGS (2/10).
This Superb Gem displays light gold-beige patination around the peripheries that turns into medium intensity cobalt-blue in the central areas. A splash of purple is visible on the lower half of Liberty, and a blush of lilac occupies the area around the eagle's head and neck. Complementing the exquisite toning pattern is a strong strike that brings out complete detailing on the design elements. Both faces are impeccably preserved, and yield modest field-motif contrast when the coin is tilted slightly under a light source. The only mentionable surface "defects" are a couple of small planchet flakes, one located near the obverse rim beneath the space between the 8 and 5 in the date and another just to the right of star 8. A wonderful proof No Motto Seated dollar.(Registry values: N10218)

1240

1861 $1 PR64 PCGS. This date represents the first Civil War issue that was extensively hoarded, reducing mintages in future years to the point that silver coinage nearly became obsolete. Silver and gold coins did not circulate, and eventually even copper and nickel was hoarded by a concerned public. Proof coins were only available at a premium, and were only acquired by the most serious collectors. This piece is a remarkable near-Gem with full details and excellent contrast on the obverse, all beneath faint champagne toning. Population: 23 in 64, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1241

1862 $1 PR64 NGC. This Civil War issue is difficult to locate in either business strike or proof format. Especially elusive in this respected grade, the present example shows deeply mirrored surfaces. The thin veil of milky patina hardly diminishes the ice-white appearance of both sides. Just a few scattered hairlines are reported in the fields, mostly on the reverse side. With detail that is as sharp as the blade of a sword, this important coin should elicit strong bids from silver dollar specialists. Census: 50 in 64, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1242

1862 $1 PR66 NGC. Splashes of aquamarine, honey, and fire-red invigorate this needle-sharp Premium Gem. Beneath the patina, the surfaces are essentially pristine, and though a few criss-cross lines are visible on the field beneath the eagle's beak, these were on the planchet prior to the strike, so technical grade is unaffected. An uncommonly attractive representative of this Civil War date, thanks to the wonderful patina, and high-end among the survivors from the mintage of just 550 pieces. NGC has certified only 10 coins as PR66 with none numerically finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

1243

1863 $1 PR62 PCGS. This lovely Seated dollar is richly toned in autumn-brown, powder-blue, and plum-mauve shades. Perusal beneath a loupe fails to locate any distractions. The strike is full aside from trivial incompleteness on the peak of the left (facing) wing. A scant 460 proofs were struck for this challenging Civil War date.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1244

1865 $1 PR61 PCGS. One of just 500 proofs for this Civil War-era issue. Though the present example shows significant contact and hairlines in the fields, as well as a mark on the lower part of Liberty's bent arm, the overall eye appeal is better than the grade might suggest. Deep blue-green and gold-gray hues drape pleasingly reflective surfaces.(Registry values: N1793)

1245

1870 $1 PR61 NGC. Cobalt-blue and lavender at the obverse periphery frames the champagne-gold center and dominates the reverse. Sharply struck on the design elements. Faint obverse field hairlines show under magnification.(Registry values: N1793)

1246

1870 $1 PR61 PCGS. Gunmetal-blue, plum-mauve, and apricot-gold toning consumes this precisely struck specimen. The obverse field displays hairlines expected for the grade. The proof 1870 is significantly scarcer than its mintage implies, since many sets went unsold and were melted by the Mint. Encapsulated in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

Trade Dollars

1247

1873-CC T$1 MS62 PCGS. CAC. In 1873, the first year for the Trade dollar series, 124,500 coins bore the CC mintmark. Between 750 to 1,000 pieces have been estimated to exist in all grade levels. Rusty Goe, in The Mint On Carson Street, suggests that about 50 to 75 of these are in Mint State. The latter estimate more or less coincides with certified population figures, as PCGS and NGC have graded approximately 75 Uncirculated examples.
Whispers of bluish-gray and reddish-brown patina visit this MS62 coin. While the hair on Liberty's head and the adjacent stars are soft, the remaining design elements exhibit strong definition. The fields show some prooflike characteristics and yield a degree of variance with the devices. Scattered light handling marksundisturbingubing. All in all, a highly attractive piece for the designated grade. Population: 17 in 62, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1248

1875 T$1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Type Two Reverse. The reverse is missing the olive berry below the right (facing) claw. The low mintage 1875 Trade dollar is scarcer than its Carson City counterpart, yet trades for less at the MS64 level. This piece is a splendid Choice Mint State example with pale yellow toning over frosty silver luster. Population: 18 in 64, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1249

1875-S T$1 MS63 PCGS. Type One Reverse. Large S. This splendid piece has pale yellow toning along the borders over ivory surfaces with frosty mint luster. The design elements are sharp and the surfaces are fully natural. A few minor marks on each side have prevented a higher grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1250

1875-S T$1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Type One Reverse. Large S. An immensely lustrous Choice example of this popular Trade dollar type issue, strongly struck at the centers, though soft at the margins. Shining, slightly frosty surfaces are silver-white with only a suggestion of patina over much of the fields. A small spot of claret along the bottom of the ribbon is the sole exception. PCGS has certified 34 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1251

1875-S T$1 MS64 PCGS. Ex: Daniel D. Biddle. Type One Reverse. Large S. This is an amazing example with fully brilliant silver luster on both sides. The borders display light golden patina. As is the case with most San Francisco issues of the type, the 1875-S has a plentiful mintage. But many of those were melted, circulated, or chopmarked, and today pristine and Choice Mint State examples are elusive.
Ex: Daniel D. Biddle Collection, Part One (Heritage, 9/2005), lot 3793, which realized $2,990.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1252

1875-S T$1 MS64 NGC. Type One Reverse. The Large S Type One reverse is a plentiful variety among 1875-S Trade dollars. This Choice Mint State piece shows weakness on the first three stars, but otherwise has bold design details. the surfaces are fully brilliant and untoned, with satiny luster and excellent eye appeal. NGC has only certified 40 finer pieces.(Registry values: N2998)

1253

1876 T$1 MS64 PCGS. Type One Obverse, Type Two Reverse. A transitional variety of sorts. All Trade dollars from 1873 through 1875 have the Type One obverse, and all from 1877 to 1883 (or 1885) have the Type Two obverse. Only in 1876 do both obverse types appear. This piece is a delightful Choice Mint State example with sharp design details, satiny silver luster, and light golden toning.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1254

1876-CC T$1 MS61 NGC. Type One Obverse, Type Two Reverse. Tall CC. This mostly brilliant Carson City Trade dollar has bright, semireflective fields, ample luster, and is void of distracting marks. The devices are nicely brought up despite slight incompleteness of detail on Liberty's cheek, shoulder, chest, and ear. Much scarcer in Mint State than its San Francisco counterpart. Census: 17 in 61, 22 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1255

1876-CC $1 Doubled Die Reverse--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. FS-801, formerly FS-014. Type One Obverse and Reverse. This boldly doubled reverse die is sometimes called the Doubled Branch variety, as it is the olive branch that is clearly doubled, a hallmark of the variety. This pleasing piece is lightly cleaned, yet retains ample luster and attractive heather toning.(Registry values: P4)

1256

1877-S T$1 MS63 PCGS. Breen-5814, Minute S, which he reported as "very rare." A moderately prooflike and delicately toned Trade dollar with frosty devices and lightly abraded fields. The strike is decidedly above average, since only star 6 lacks full radials, and the eagle's ankles demonstrate exquisite detail. A popular William Barber type coin, scarce in Select Mint State.(Registry values: N1793)

1257

1877-S T$1 MS63 ANACS. Large S. Light to medium chestnut-tan toning graces this lustrous and meticulously struck Select Trade dollar. The obverse field has only wispy grazes, and the reverse is well preserved aside from thin marks beneath the right (facing) wing.(Registry values: N1793)

1258

1877-S T$1 MS64 PCGS. Large S. Cream-gray toning fills the fields and devices, while tobacco-brown toning drapes the peripheries. This is a lustrous and exactingly struck silver type coin. Splendidly free from abrasions, and an excellent value in relation to higher grades. Certified in a first generation holder.(Registry values: N2998)

1259

1878-CC T$1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. The Guide Book mintage of the 1878-CC Trade dollar is given as 97,000 pieces, making it the smallest in the series. But the issue is further reduced by the mention that of the 44,148 Trade dollars that were melted on July 19, 1878, "many of these may have been 1878-CC."
Treasury Secretary John T. Sherman (of later Sherman Silver Purchase Act of 1890 fame) was a hardened foe of the Trade dollar, ordering the discontinuation of the denomination in October 1877. However, as Rusty Goe points out in The Mint on Carson Street, "loopholes in his order allowed San Francisco and Carson City to proceed with trade dollar production after that date." Goe does none of the equivocation that the Guide Book does, stating conclusively that the 44,148 piece melted were 1878-CCs. Goe adds, however:

"It is plausible that the remaining 52,852 pieces circulated domestically, most likely not all in the Carson City area, but nevertheless in the western states. This would explain the incongruity of a low mintage and at the same time a higher survival ratio. If the average percentage of those trade dollars had been exported, coupled with the meltdown of a portion of the remaining coins, the 1878-CC would be super rare. Based on typical attrition rates that might have been fewer than 50 specimens extant."

Goe estimates a surviving Mint State population of from 60 to 75 coins. Even that figure may be a tad high, given that NGC and PCGS combined have certified only 52 Mint State pieces (less duplications).
At any rate, the present near-Gem specimen is one of only seven pieces so certified at PCGS, and there are precisely two coins finer at that service--one MS65 and one MS66 (2/10). Radiant cartwheel luster flows from both sides, and the silver-gray surfaces are tinged with hints of gold. The reverse is semiprooflike. The strike is quite close to full, and there are no singular abrasions. A high-end example for the grade of this elusive issue.(Registry values: N7079)

1260

1878-S T$1 MS63 PCGS. Strong eye appeal for the last large-mintage Trade dollar issue. Faint gold-gray patina has settled over the immensely lustrous surfaces.(Registry values: N1793)

1261

1878-S T$1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Counting the 1878 Morgan and Trade types, San Francisco made about 14 million silver dollars all told, twice as many of the former. And like the 1878-S Morgans, the 1878-S Trade dollars generally show excellent production values. This near-Gem example shows the usual bold strike, with generous luster and a light partial overlay of lilac and blue-gray on the obverse. An excellent potential acquisition for a type or year set. Population: 80 in 64, 35 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1262

1878-S T$1 MS64 PCGS. After the Bland-Allison Act was introduced, all operating Mints were required to begin Morgan dollar production. As a result, the Philadelphia Mint only made proof Trade dollars, and the Carson City Mint made very few of the design. Only the San Francisco Mint continued full scale production, with a mintage of more than 4 million coins, ending business strike Trade dollar coinage for all time. This lovely example is fully brilliant with vibrant silver luster and delicate wisps of light gold toning over otherwise untoned surfaces. PCGS has only certified 35 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1263

1878-S T$1 MS65 NGC. Cartwheel luster dominates this sharply impressed Gem, which has smooth surfaces and medium tan toning. Many 1878-S Trade dollars were exported to the Orient, or melted following passage of the Bland-Allison Act. Gems are both rare and desirable. Census: 24 in 65, 17 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

Proof Trade Dollars

1264

1875 T$1 PR61 Cameo PCGS. Type One Reverse. A thin veil of champagne-gold rests on both sides and sharply struck design elements stand out against mirrored fields. Wispy handling marks showing under magnification limit the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1265

1875 T$1 PR64 Deep Cameo PCGS. Type Two Reverse. A fully brilliant Choice proof that boasts dramatic contrast between the thickly iced devices and the darkly mirrored fields. The eye appeal is outstanding, and the rarity is ensured by a low proof mintage of 700 pieces, most of which lack the exceptional contrast of the present piece. Population: 6 in 64 Deep Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1266

1876 T$1 PR65 NGC. Type One Obverse, Type Two Reverse. This deeply toned Gem Trade dollar displays apple-green, rose-red, sun-gold, navy-blue, and plum-mauve shades once it is rotated beneath a light. The strike is virtually full, and the fields appear undisturbed beneath the blanket of multi-colored patina. Census: 14 in 65, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1267

1876 T$1 PR64 Cameo PCGS. Type One Obverse, Type Two Reverse. This is an exceptionally flashy and deeply mirrored example of this date. Only 1,150 proofs were struck of all types. Both sides display light to moderate golden toning with a darker dab of blue at the top of the obverse, and yet the thick mint frost over the devices is plainly evident as well as the subsequent cameo contrast. Population: 9 in 64 Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1268

1877 T$1 PR64 NGC. A remarkable strike is the first feature of this Choice proof that meets the eye, and that strike is absolutely full. The surfaces are fully mirrored with excellent cameo contrast, although no such designation is assigned by NGC. The toning is delightful with wispy heather surrounded by lilac, blue, and violet accents. Census: 56 in 64, 23 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1269

1879 T$1 PR63 NGC. First of the proof-only dates in the Trade dollar series, the 1879 had a mintage of 1,541 pieces. This example is almost untoned with just a hint of slight reddish patina on each side. The devices are noticeably frosted, and against the depth of mirrored reflectivity in the fields a slight but unacknowledged bit of contrast exists. A pleasing example in this grade range.(Registry values: N1793)

1270

1879 T$1 PR64 PCGS. Orange-gold, slate-gray, plum-red, and electric-blue adorn this beautifully toned and exquisite proof-only Trade dollar. Fully struck and unabraded with a mere whisper of granularity on the reverse field. The lower reverse legends are lightly die doubled, as usual for the date.(Registry values: N2998)

1271

1879 T$1 PR64 Cameo PCGS. There was a Trade dollar boom in 1879, actually late 1879, that was reflected in an enormous production of 581 proofs in December of that year. This is a lovely, high-grade example that is brilliant throughout. The fields are deeply mirrored and the devices show sharply contrasting mint frost that yields the two-toned Cameo effect. A few faint hairlines and a single smudge of dark color near the eagle's right (facing) claw are all that keep this from the PR65 category. Population: 36 in 64 Cameo, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1272

1880 T$1 PR64 PCGS. The 1880 proof-only trade dollar comes from a mintage approaching 2,000 pieces, the highest for the proof series. It is fairly available through the near-Gem level, and even Gem specimens can be acquired without too much difficulty. Wisps of light grayish-tan color complement the well struck devices on this PR64 representative. Minor handling marks deny Gem status.(Registry values: N2998)

1273

1880 T$1 PR64 PCGS. This proof-only 1880 Trade dollar is housed in a green-label PCGS holder. It is a near-Gem with fully brilliant and untoned silver surfaces, save for a thin veil of champagne color on each side. A splendid example that will serve as a nice addition to a type set or specialized Trade dollar collection.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1274

1880 T$1 PR65 NGC. This beautiful Gem proof has brilliant centers with a delightful frame of pale gold, rose, and blue toning on each side. Although undesignated, this is a unquestioned cameo proof with excellent contrast on each side. A small lint mark from the coinage die, located in the upper obverse field, resembles an upper case E. Census: 71 in 65, 61 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1275

1881 T$1 PR64 NGC. In the middle of a run of proof-only dates, the 1881 has a mintage of only 960 pieces. This example shows remarkably deep, watery reflectivity in the fields. We say remarkable because its mirrored effect is undiminished by the light gray-russet toning seen over each side. The surfaces are slightly hairlined, but again this seems to have no effect on the proof flash in the fields. The devices show complete striking definition in all areas.(Registry values: N2998)

1276

1881 T$1 PR62 Cameo PCGS. CAC. One of the popular, end-of-the-series dates that is proof-only with only 960 pieces produced. In spite of the modest grade, this piece presents very well. Each side has dazzling mint brilliance and the fields are deeply mirrored with sharply contrasting thick mint frost over the devices. Both obverse and reverse are hairlined, but there are no obvious or detracting contact marks present.(Registry values: N1793)

1277

1882 T$1 PR63 ANACS. Exquisite arcs of sea-green fill the peripheries, while the centers display only light apricot toning. This fully struck proof-only specimen has substantial frost throughout the devices, although the toning precludes a Cameo designation. The left obverse field displays faint hairlines.(Registry values: N1793)

Session 3

Morgan Dollars

1278

1878 8TF $1 AU50 PCGS. VAM-14.18, R.7. The "Broken 7" 8TF VAM. Die cracks pass (both vertically and horizontally) through the 7 in the date. Per VAMworld.com, "The VAM-14.18 is an ultra rarity with seven to ten known." This is a golden-gray example that displays substantial luster within the legends and devices. The field near the forehead is abraded, and a fingerprint is noted near the cotton bolls.

1279

1878 8TF $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-4. The date and ONE are nicely die doubled on this scarcer VAM. VAM-17 appears to be the most common high grade 8TF variety. This nearly untoned Gem has a moderately prooflike obverse, and both sides are highly lustrous. The fields are gorgeously smooth and the cheek has only a few wispy grazes.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1280

1878 8TF $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. VAM-17. After several months of producing "240 silver dollars a minute" Mint Director Henry Linderman expressed dissatisfaction with several aspects of the design. The most important changes were making the eagle's breast rounded rather than flat, and reducing the number of tail feathers from eight to seven. This is one of the pieces produced as originally designed with the flat breast and eight tail feathers. The mintage was around 700,000 pieces, but relatively few were set aside in such superior state as this coin. The surfaces are brilliant and display flashy mint luster with bright semiprooflike obverse fields. Each side is problem-free, as one would expect from the grade, and the striking details are complete. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 29 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N4719)

1281

1878 8TF $1 MS65 Prooflike NGC. VAM-21. While generally available in most Mint State grades, Prooflike specimens are more difficult, especially in the lofty grade of MS65. Purple and gold peripheral toning is more extensive and deeper on the reverse. Sharply struck and well preserved. Census: 9 in 65 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1282

1878 8TF $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. VAM-14.7. An absolutely beautiful 1878 Morgan, this piece is fully brilliant white with no toning. The fields are deeply mirrored around satiny silver devices that combine to impart a splendid cameo appearance. Here is an excellent opportunity for the advanced collector as NGC and PCGS have only certified 27 of these, with just six finer examples. Population: 27 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1283

1878 7/8TF $1 Strong MS64 PCGS. CAC. VAM-37. A brilliant example of this first-year issue, and showing strong feather definition from the first hubbing. The strike is complete, as one would expect from an 1878, and the surfaces are remarkably clean for the grade.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: P5, N491)

1284

1878 7/8TF $1 Strong MS65 PCGS. VAM-38. This VAM is noted for its faint but extremely wide die doubling on LIBERTY. This lustrous and nearly brilliant Gem has exquisitely smooth fields and a sharp strike. Nearly unobtainable in higher grades.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1285

1878 7/8TF $1 Strong MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. VAM-40, R.5. The N and M of UNUM have broken bases, and this variety is considered one of the difficult 1878 doubled tailfeather varieties. This example is housed in an older green-label PCGS holder.
Here is a delightful doubled tailfeathers 1878 Morgan with seven tailfeathers over five tailfeathers, the change resulting from observations of bird lovers who stated that eagle's have an odd number of tailfeathers. This example has tips of five of the eight feathers from the first hub clearly visible.
While PCGS has no population data based on VAM varieties, it is worth noting that NGC has only certified 43 examples of this variety, including just five prooflike pieces. They have never certified a Deep Mirror Prooflike VAM-40 dollar. Population: 29 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 3 finer for all 1878 7/8 Tailfeather dollars (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

1286

1878 7/8F $1 Weak AU58 PCGS. VAM-44, A Top 100 Variety. Most specialists will agree that the VAM-44 and the late die state VAM-44A 1878 Morgan dollars are the most important die varieties in the entire series. The cotton blossoms and leaves are tripled (tripled die obverse), and the eagle's legs are doubled (doubled die reverse) on this combination variety. We offered a different PCGS AU58 example of this variety in our January 2008 FUN sale, a coin that realized $12,075 and we offered an MS62 PCGS coin at our 2007 ANA sale, which realized $20,700.
Although this piece has light abrasions on its silver surfaces, it is brilliant with traces of gold toning, and it exhibits prooflike obverse and reverse fields.

1287

1878 7TF $1 Reverse of 1878 MS66 NGC. This is the 7 Tailfeathers Reverse, created after the 8 Tailfeathers and the 7/8 Tailfeathers varieties, with the flat-design eagle's breast and parallel top arrow feather. This variety constitutes the majority of 1878 silver dollar production, but high-grade examples are nonetheless elusive. This Premium Gem sports soft, satiny luster with an excellent strike and minimal signs of contact. Census: 25 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1288

1878 7TF $1 Reverse of 1878 MS66 PCGS. VAM-114 with a prominently die doubled R in PLURIBUS. This essentially brilliant Premium Gem has booming luster and an exacting strike. Splendidly preserved and conditionally rare. The obverse field is especially free from contact. Population: 19 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1289

1878 7TF $1 Reverse of 1878 MS65 PCGS. VAM-84. A Top 100 Variety. The "Line Under 8," named for the near-horizontal dash appearing below the first 8 in the date. Also known as "Washed Out L" because of incomplete L in LIBERTY and as "Broken D' because D of DOLLAR is broken at bottom. The brilliant reverse cedes to splashes of deep multicolored toning on obverse margin. Well struck and minimally marked. Population for the variety: 6 in 65, 1 finer (2/10).

1290

1878 7TF $1 Reverse of 1878 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. Untoned surfaces display excellent field-motif contrast on both sides. Sharply struck with no significant marks a few minor grazes denying Gem status.(Registry values: P4)

1291

1878 7TF $1 Reverse of 1879 MS65 PCGS. The 1878 Morgan dollars are known from three different hubs, including the 8 Tailfeathers, 7 Tailfeathers, and Reverse of 1879 hubs. The fourth major type, the 7/8 Tailfeathers type, was the result of double hubbing from the first two types. This piece has the Reverse of 1879, and it is an elusive variety, especially in Gem grades. Just six finer examples are PCGS certified (2/10). The surfaces are fully brilliant with frosty silver luster and untoned surfaces.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1292

1878 7TF $1 Reverse of 1879 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Ex: Larry Shapiro. VAM-200, R.6. The M in UNUM has a peg leg. This obverse die was paired with several reverses, but among those only VAM-200 is the Third Reverse subtype. This flashy and nearly brilliant example has a beautifully preserved obverse and a few scattered marks on the reverse. Sharply defined in all areas. Population: 20 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1293

1878-CC $1 MS65 NGC. A minimally toned Gem with attractively frosted devices. Both sides show a handful of shallow luster grazes, but the only marks of any significance are in the fields.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1294

1878-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. Light autumn-gold patina visits this crisply struck first year Carson City Morgan. The cheek displays only faint grazes, and the fields are impressively unmarked.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1295

1878-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. A semi-prooflike Gem with dazzling luster and light straw-gold toning. Powerfully struck and minimally abraded. Carson City dollars are widely collected, due to their frequent availability in quality Mint State.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1296

1878-CC $1 MS65 NGC. A flashy and fully brilliant Gem. The strike is razor-sharp, and the preservation is impressive despite a few unimportant left obverse grazes.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1297

1878-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. Most collectors cannot realistically expect to obtain an 1878-CC above the Premium Gem level. Few are certified finer, and even if one appears at auction, they would be quite pricey. This MS66 example boasts untroubled silver surfaces with satin luster and enormous eye appeal. PCGS has certified four specimens finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1298

1878-CC $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. Deeply mirrored fields highlight exquisitely detailed devices. Scattered grazes preclude a finer numerical grade, nevertheless this coin yields considerable "flash."(Registry values: P4, N491)

1299

1878-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. As the first year of issue for the Morgan type, many 1878 dollars were set aside. However, in the West silver and gold was always in demand in the channels of commerce and far fewer pieces were saved. This is a coin that shows exceptionally strong contrast between the depth of mirrored reflectivity in the fields and the thick, frosted mint luster over the devices. As almost always seen on this date, the devices are fully struck. A few light abrasions account for the grade, most of which are predictably located on the obverse.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1300

1878-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This green-label PCGS certified Morgan dollar is an amazing example with brilliant and untoned silver surfaces and sharp design definition on the central motifs and the peripheral elements. While a few light abrasions are evident, the overall quality of this near-Gem is remarkable. PCGS has only certified 34 finer examples.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1301

1878-S $1 MS66 NGC. CAC. Cobalt-blue, purple, and golden-brown patination occupies the lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem and a decisive strike imparts sharp detail to the motifs. Nicely preserved throughout.(Registry values: P2, N991)

1302

1878-S $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. The last Trade dollars and the first Morgan dollars were coined throughout the year at San Francisco with a combined mintage of nearly 14 million coins. This incredible Gem is fully prooflike with mostly silver-white surfaces inside a frame of gold and iridescent toning. Census: 26 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1303

1879 $1 MS66 PCGS. This piece appears to have minute doubling on the date, although it is possibly insufficient to gain the attention of VAM collectors. The surfaces are fully brilliant with only the slightest marks. Both sides display a full quota of mint frost, and no evidence of toning. Housed in a green-label PCGS holder. Population: 87 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1304

1879-CC $1 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has been whizzed. Unnaturally lustrous surfaces are pearl-gray in the centers with gold and tan peripheral elements.(Registry values: P7, N7)

1305

1879-CC $1 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an Uncirculated specimen that has altered surfaces. Well-defined with strong apparent reflectivity, though close inspection reveals the same texture on the "fresh metal" abrasions as well as the fields.(Registry values: P7, N7)

1306

1879-CC $1 MS62 NGC. Although the numerical grade of this Carson City rarity is limited, it has exceptional eye appeal that results from brilliant silver surfaces, wispy peripheral rose toning, and satiny luster. This Normal Mintmark variety is always in demand in all grades.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1307

1879-CC $1 MS63 PCGS. This in-demand issue boasts solid eye appeal, and the surfaces appear completely untoned. A loupe reveals only trivial abrasions for the grade, but the lower reverse shows a weakly struck area, revealing itself in the form of roller marks on the device high points from the eagle's legs downward through the mintmark and ONE DO.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1308

1879-CC $1 MS64 NGC. Radiant cartwheels beam on each side of this silver-white near-Gem coin, an example of one of the most popular CC-mint Morgans. A couple of grazes on the cheek and the breast on the reverse are the only singular contact, although they likely preclude a Gem grade. Much appeal emanates from the satiny surfaces, and the next owner will count him- or herself extremely fortunate to possess this marvelous coin. NGC has certified 39 pieces finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1309

1879-CC $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. A sensational Morgan dollar rarity, this 1879-CC is brilliant with silver luster in full view. Fully mirrored fields surround the satiny devices on this important rarity. A few minor bagmarks prevent a higher Gem grade to this impressive dollar. Population: 67 in 64 Prooflike, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1310

1879-CC $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The Normal Mintmark variety is elusive in all grades above XF, and a Select Mint State example with amazing mirrored fields and lustrous devices is a major rarity in the series. This stunning beauty has wisps of gold toning around the borders, more so on the reverse.
Among Carson City Morgan dollars, only the 1889-CC is harder to locate. Here is a desirable 1879-CC Morgan dollar with exceptional eye appeal, especially for its Select Mint State grade. Population: 23 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1311

1879-CC $1 Capped Die MS61 NGC. VAM-3. A Top 100 Variety. Softly frosted silver surfaces appear on this coin, which is strictly Mint State and shows few abrasions for the grade. The luster is fairly diffuse, however. Just a hint of gold appears near the obverse rim. Much eye appeal remains on this example of an ever-popular issue.(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1312

1879-CC $1 Capped Die MS64 PCGS. VAM-3. A Top 100 Variety. Only minor contact, chiefly a patch of abrasions on the neck and a couple of reeding marks on the cheek, seems to keep this piece out of the Gem level. The satiny surfaces are silver-white throughout and offer much appeal. Certified in a green-label holder.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1313

1879-O $1 MS65 NGC. Both sides of this remarkable 1879-O Morgan are highly brilliant with full mint luster. There is no toning on either side. Nearly all of the design elements are bold, with only slight weakness at the centers. NGC has only certified eight finer examples (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1314

1879-O $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. Whispers of gold and orange toning visit the rims of this Choice Prooflike piece, minimally toned otherwise. Moderate mirrors show few significant marks. Population: 34 in 64 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N991)

1315

1879-S $1 MS68 NGC. Copious cartwheel luster radiates from each side of this sumptuous Superb Gem coin, an example of what the San Francisco Mint could do on a good day--or year. Liberty's cheek reveals only a single tiny luster graze, and the surfaces overall are remarkable in their preservation. The strike is equally compelling.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1316

1879-S $1 MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Gleaming silver-white mirrors give way to frosted devices kissed in pink on the obverse. Sharply struck and impressively preserved, a Premium Gem to make the high-end collector take notice. Encased in a green label holder. Population: 47 in 66 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1317

1879-S $1 Reverse of 1878 MS64 NGC. CAC. A Top 100 Variety. Splashes of blue peripheral toning add color to otherwise silver-white surfaces. Both sides show considerable reflectivity, though not to the Prooflike level.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1318

1879-S $1 Reverse of 1878 MS64 PCGS. CAC. A Top 100 Variety. The ever-popular Reverse of 1878, offered here as a near-Gem. Strongly lustrous and minimally toned with considerable frostiness on the central devices. PCGS has graded 47 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1319

1879-S $1 Reverse of 1878 MS64 PCGS. A Top 100 Variety. The ever-popular Reverse of 1878 variant, offered here as a near-Gem. Faint gray toning with a touch of gold has settled over the gleaming surfaces. Well-defined and delightful. PCGS has graded 47 finer Reverse of 1878 pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1320

1879-S $1 Reverse of 1878 MS65 PCGS. A Top 100 Variety. A wisp of almond-gold toning graces the dazzling surfaces of this intricately struck Gem. The 1879-S is common with a Third Reverse, but Second Reverse examples are very scarce. Gems appear underrated relative to their rarity. Population: 46 in 65, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1321

1880 $1 MS66 PCGS. As with most Morgan dollar issues with high mintages (in this case 12+ million pieces), it is remarkable how few examples have survived in high grades. Probably around 100 pieces are actually known in MS66 condition, as certified by PCGS and NGC (2/10). This is an immaculate coin that displays frosted mint luster. Each side is brilliant, and the striking details are complete throughout. Population: 81 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N4719)

1322

1880 $1 MS66 NGC. Smooth silver-gray lustrous surfaces reveal just an occasional unobtrusive graze. The design features are generally well impressed. Census: 37 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N4719)

1323

1880 $1 MS66 Prooflike NGC. This is a remarkable and extremely important Morgan dollar condition rarity. The obverse and reverse surfaces are entirely brilliant with boldly defined devices and excellent cameo contrast. This issue is rare in high grades, and it is rare with prooflike surfaces. The combination of both explains its importance to advanced collectors. Census: 5 in 66 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N4719)

1324

1880 $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Pleasing field-motif contrast shows on both sides of this untoned Morgan. Well struck and revealing just a few grade-limiting marks. Population: 81 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 29 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N991)

1325

1880 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. This boldly defined Gem has deeply mirrored fields with lustrous devices, in combination creating a marvelous cameo appearance. Both sides have vivid gold and rainbow peripheral toning around brilliant centers. Census: 11 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1326

1880-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Richly frosted on the devices with potent cartwheel luster beneath pale silver-gray toning. Outstanding eye appeal, even by Gem standards.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1327

1880-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. A bit of light tan color visits the lustrous surfaces of this pleasing Gem. Nicely struck and devoid of mentionable marks.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1328

1880-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. Lustrous surfaces exhibit well impressed devices, including the hair over Liberty's ear and the eagle's breast feathers. Whispers of yellow-gold concentrate at the margins of this well cared for piece.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1329

1880-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. A thin layer of tan-gold color is slightly more prominent on the reverse of this well struck lustrous Gem. Grade-consistent marks do not disturb. Roller marks are visible in the centers.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1330

1880-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. An occasional wisp of faint tan patina shows on the lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem Morgan. This is a well struck piece with no more marks than what might be expected for the grade designation.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1331

1880-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. Boldly impressed with strong frostiness on the portrait and considerable cartwheel luster in the fields. Color is pale silver-gray with small spots of milky toning. PCGS has certified 27 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1332

1880-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. Lustrous surfaces are nearly untoned save for a wisp or two of light tan. Well struck and revealing just a few grade-consistent marks.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1333

1880-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. VAM-10. 8/7 Dash and Doubled 8. This Van Allen-Mallis variety shows the characteristic dash beneath the second 8 (remains of a low 7 underdigit), with doubling noted at the top of the lower loop of the first 8. A hint of tan toning appears in the reverse fields of this otherwise untoned example.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1334

1880-CC $1 MS66 NGC. Lightly toned and lustrous with a nearly pristine reverse. The 1880-CC is known for striking incompleteness at the centers. The strike on the present example is above average, although faint mint-made roller marks remain partially visible.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1335

1880-CC $1 8 Over Low 7 MS65 PCGS. CAC. VAM-6. A Top 100 Variety. This nearly brilliant Gem has sweeping luster and splendidly preserved fields. The centers show traces of roller marks, as made, but the overall strike is bold.(Registry values: P4)

1336

1880-CC $1 8 Over Low 7 MS65 PCGS. VAM-6. A Top 100 Variety. The green label holder ignores the overdate feature, but the Low 7 is all too obvious within the second 8 in the date. Each side has a whisper of tan toning, but this lustrous Gem is nearly brilliant as well as exquisitely unabraded.(Registry values: P4)

1337

1880-CC $1 8 Over Low 7 MS66 PCGS. VAM-6. A Top 100 Variety. The 8 Over Low 7 variety has the underlying 7 lower in comparison to the VAM-5 8 Over High 7 variety, with a clear area above the 7 but still inside the top loop of the 8, and more of the 7 protruding beneath the 8. This Premium Gem example is among the few dozen finest at PCGS, with silver-white, somewhat prooflike surfaces and good eye appeal. Population: 30 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

1338

1880-CC $1 8 Over Low 7 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. VAM-6. A Top 100 Variety. The second 8 is punched over a low 7. At www.vamworld.com the unusual reverse features are described as "crud in centers of 'CC' mint mark," and "polishing line thru M of AMERICA." Both features are clearly visible, although the line through the M seems extremely heavy to be a die polishing line, in our opinion.
This incredible 1880-CC overdate Morgan dollar is mostly brilliant with excellent cameo contrast. Both sides have light silver centers with a frame of gold and iridescent toning. Census: 31 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

1339

1880/79-CC $1 Reverse of 1878 MS64 PCGS. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. The prominent Reverse of 1878 overdate with the two final underdigits bold. A gorgeous near-Gem example with faint gray toning over both shining fields and frosted devices.(Registry values: P5, N991)

1340

1880/79-CC $1 Reverse of 1878 MS64 ★ NGC. CAC. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. Mounted reverse-up in the holder, the better to showcase that side's rainbow color, violet and magenta at the left border with fades through yellow, green, blue, violet, and burnt orange before startling brilliance at the right. The frosty overdated obverse, by contrast, has only faint gray toning.(Registry values: P5, N991)

1341

1880/79-CC $1 Reverse of 1878 MS64 NGC. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. A Reverse of 1878 overdate, not explicitly described as an overdate on the holder though the underdigits are clear. Bold multicolored toning appears in waves on the obverse, while the reverse has more subdued golden-tan peripheral color around minimally patinated centers.(Registry values: P5, N991)

1342

1880/79-CC $1 Reverse of 1878 MS65 PCGS. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. The underdigits 79 are strong beneath the 80, and the reverse has the Parallel (top) Arrow Feather style of 1878. Lustrous silver-gray surfaces display sharply struck devices and are minimally abraded. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1343

1880/79-CC $1 Reverse of 1878 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. The Reverse of 1878 is much scarcer than the Reverse of 1879. This color-free Gem exhibits outstanding field-device contrast. The design elements are crisply impressed, enhancing even more the coin's eye appeal. A few light grazes likely preclude an even finer numerical grade. Census: 2 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1344

1880-CC $1 8/7 Reverse of 1878 MS64 PCGS. VAM-7. This minor overdate shows a short horizontal feature below the second 8 in the date. Sharply struck, lustrous, and essentially untoned. Light marks preclude Gem status.(Registry values: P5)

1345

1880-O $1 MS64 NGC. Micro O. Faint suggestions of peripheral color yield swiftly to dazzling silver-white on this O-mint near-Gem. Minor striking softness is typical for the issue, but the bold eye appeal is not. NGC has certified just 22 numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1346

1880-O $1 MS64 PCGS. Micro O. Low intensity multicolored toning covers both sides of this lustrous near-Gem and a well executed strike imparts strong detail to the design motifs. Light contact marks preclude a finer grade. PCGS has seen fewer than 25 coins above MS64 (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1347

1880-O $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Ex: Jack Lee. Micro O. Certified in a green-label holder with the impressive Jack Lee pedigree, this splendid Gem Deep Mirror Prooflike coin is from an issue that exceeds 5.3 million coins. Despite that enormous emission from the New Orleans Mint at the turn of the 1880s, this is the sole MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike certified of the issue at PCGS, and there are none such at NGC (1/10).
The challenges involved in finding a Gem Deep Mirror Prooflike example of this issue boil down to circulation, strike, luster and contrast, and bag marks, not necessarily in order of importance.
Concerning circulation, most examples of the large 1880-O production appear to have circulated for at least a short while, so that today the average grade of certified survivors is only MS62 or thereabouts.
Strike is a problem with the issue, if not to the same degree as some later O-mint issues. All 1880-O Morgans have the reverse of 1879, with slanted top arrow feather on the reverse and rounded breast on the eagle. (Bowers comments, "A number of dies were overdated and show small traces of earlier digits. These have not created much attention in the marketplace, save for dyed-in-the-wool specialists." The present piece is one such.) Many 1880-Os show noticeable softness in the hair over Liberty's ear or on the eagle's breast.
Some 1880-O dollars show satiny or greasy luster and/or little to no contrast, neither feature conducive to a Deep Mirror Prooflike certification. Prooflike coins exist, but few of them attain the Gem level.
Bag marks can vary for the issue; some 1880-Os show severe bag marks, although there are many pleasing exceptions.
Any Gem example of the 1880-O dollar is a prize. As of (1/10), only 49 coins, regardless of designation, have been awarded an MS65 grade by PCGS and NGC combined, and none have been graded higher. Of these 49 Gems, only three have received any kind of Prooflike designation, and the present piece is the only Gem to have been designated as Deep Mirror Prooflike, rendering it as possibly the finest known example of the date.
In summary, this coin is a phenomenon that defies several stereotypes in order to reach the summit, the crème de la crème. The strike is pleasingly bold on surfaces that are silver-white, with no trace of color. The devices exhibit thick mint frost, with radiant field mirrors. The few ticks in the field are minor, consistent with the Gem grade--but there are no marks of significance.
With an impressive pedigree, early green-label holder, and a PCGS-certified population of one coin with none finer regardless of designation, this Gem Deep Mirror Prooflike 1880-O Morgan is suited for the finest collection and must be considered among the most important Morgan dollar offerings in this auction.(Registry values: P6, N4719)

1348

1880/79-O $1 MS64 PCGS. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. Micro O. The overdate feature is undesignated on the PCGS holder, though plainly visible with magnification. A lustrous chestnut-gold near-Gem that has a sharp strike and smooth fields.

1349

1880-S $1 MS67 ★ NGC. Large S. A spectacularly appealing Superb Gem with gorgeous patina. The right obverse and rims show mainly gold to orange patina with bands of blue and green, while the reverse has similar, lighter peripheral color. Bright cartwheel luster stops at the frosty devices.(Registry values: P1, N991)

1350

1880-S $1 MS68 NGC. Medium S. A tale of two sides, with the reverse silver-white while the obverse has spectacular original toning. A narrow arc of ocean-blue encircles about three-quarters of the obverse rim, while the center boasts lavish amber-gold deepening to tangerine and cinnamon. The strike is impeccable, and only the most trivial marks appear. A small strikethrough appears to the left of the eagle's neck. NGC has certified only four coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1351

1880-S $1 MS68 NGC. Large S. This is a simply splendid coin, one that appears to fully merit a Prooflike designation, although it is absent. Radiant cartwheel luster drips from both sides. Liberty's cheek shows no visible contact, and only trivial abrasions are present anywhere. NGC has graded only four finer.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1352

1880-S $1 MS67 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Medium S. The 1880-S Morgan dollar is considered available on the whole, even in MS67, but Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces such as this Superb Gem are far more elusive. This example is boldly contrasted with thick frost over the devices and gleaming fields. Arcs of golden-amber toning run along the lower obverse rim and the upper reverse.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1353

1880/9-S $1 MS67 PCGS. VAM-11. A Hot 50 Variety. Traces of a curved object appear within the final digit of the date. Otherwise, a brightly lustrous Superb Gem example of this popular type issue, minimally toned and delightful. For the variety, Population: 23 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

1354

1880/9-S $1 MS67 PCGS. CAC. VAM-11. A Hot 50 Variety. An unidentified object occupies the upper part of the 0 in the date. Fantastic eye appeal, as usual for the date, with a touch of pink central color against otherwise pale pearl-gray surfaces.(Registry values: P3)

1355

1881 $1 MS67 NGC. The 1881 Philadelphia Morgan dollar was made to the extent of more than 9 million coins, and it is occasionally obtainable up to the Gem level. Even Premium Gems may be had for a price, but at the Superb Gem grade the issue becomes markedly elusive. The silver-white surfaces on this marvelous coin are completely devoid of color. Radiant cartwheel luster proceeds from softly frosted, satiny surfaces. Due to the paucity of mentionable abrasions, this piece almost seems to merit an even finer grade. Census: 4 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N4719)

1356

1881 $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Minimally toned with only minor spotting at the gold-tinged margins, most visible as a dot at the S in PLURIBUS. Well-defined devices give way to watery fields. In a green label holder. Population: 60 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1357

1881-CC $1 MS66 NGC. CAC. Lightly frosted over the devices with signature cartwheel luster in the fields. Faintly toned with hints of golden color and excellent overall eye appeal, as befits a Premium Gem.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1358

1881-CC $1 MS66 NGC. Faint hints of yellow appear in the pale silver-gray toning that graces close to half of this Premium Gem. Outstanding eye appeal with the classic Carson City "look."(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1359

1881-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. Impressively frosted on the central devices, which are untoned like the shining fields. A great example of this Carson City Morgan dollar classic.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1360

1881-CC $1 MS66 NGC. Sharply struck with considerable frost over the devices and bright cartwheel luster. Suggestions of pink add a touch of color to this otherwise silver-white Premium Gem.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1361

1881-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. VAM-2 with prominent recutting within the 8s in the date. A hint of gold toning visits the highly lustrous and virtually brilliant surfaces. A sharply struck example of this popular low mintage CC-mint issue. Encased in an old green label holder.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1362

1881-CC $1 MS67 PCGS. This Superb Gem 1881-CC is certified in a green-label holder. The coin is untoned throughout, with soft satin luster. A couple of minor luster grazes appear on the cheek, and the lower wreath is weakly struck. Despite those minor flaws, generous eye appeal is present in large quantity. PCGS has certified three pieces finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1363

1881-CC $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. A profoundly reflective Gem that appears black-and-white at most angles, though a broad patch of strawberry color is visible on the thickly frosted portrait when the coin is tilted to the light. This gorgeous coin is housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1364

1881-O $1 MS65 NGC. A frosty Gem, brilliant save for cobalt-blue and golden-brown toning near the border areas. A boldly impressed example of this O-mint issue which is a condition rarity any finer.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1365

1881-O $1 MS65 PCGS. This issue is a rarity in higher grades, and extremely rare any finer than MS65. The Gem offered here provides an excellent compromise between grade and market price. This piece is brilliant with frosty silver luster and only a sliver of pale gold toning along the obverse border. PCGS has graded just 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1366

1881-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Prominently reflective fields and moderate frost throughout the devices confirm the Deep Mirror Prooflike third party designation. Intricately struck and only lightly abraded with an essentially brilliant appearance.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1367

1881-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Great field-device contrast shows on the color-free surfaces. Exquisitely defined and minimally abraded. Difficult to acquire any finer; PCGS and NGC have seen just 11 coins better (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N991)

1368

1881-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This fully brilliant near-Gem has lustrous central design motifs set atop deeply mirrored fields. There is no toning on either side. Here is a scarce issue at this grade level, one that is extremely rare any finer. PCGS has only certified seven finer deep mirror prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N991)

1369

1881-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Glints of pink and peach appear at certain angles on this otherwise silver-white specimen. Great reflectivity with a well-preserved obverse, though the reverse shows a few lines of reed marks. PCGS has graded seven finer Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N991)

1370

1881-O $1 MS65 Deep Prooflike NGC. Q. David Bowers writes in his A Guide Book of Morgan Silver Dollars: "Many 1881-O dollars have one or both dies with a prooflike surface. However, bagmarks are endemic among these coins, and finding a truly choice example can be a real challenge." Gem Deep Prooflike coins, such as this example, prove fiendishly elusive. A strongly reflective coin with essentially untoned mirrors, this sharp example also has considerable contrast thanks to the moderate frost across the devices. Tied for numerically finest among Deep Prooflike or Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces known to NGC or PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N4719)

1371

1881-S $1 MS67 ★ NGC. Mounted reverse-up in the holder to showcase that side's dramatic crescent toning, which offers dramatic blues and greens on the lower two-thirds. The rest of that side, as well as the obverse, is near-brilliant.(Registry values: P1, N991)

1372

1881-S $1 MS68 NGC. The 1881-S is the commonest Mint State Morgan dollar of the 1878-1904 era. That said, near-pristine examples such as this occur only infrequently. Stunning luster endows the untoned surfaces and a decisive strike leaves sharp delineation on the design elements. An immaculately preserved specimen with outstanding eye appeal.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1373

1881-S $1 MS68 NGC. This fully brilliant Superb Gem has satiny silver surfaces with excellent design definition. The 1880-S and 1881-S Morgan dollars are often chosen for type collections due to their availability in all grades. This impressive piece has mostly untoned surfaces with just a hint of iridescence. Census: 176 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1374

1881-S $1 MS67 Prooflike PCGS. Crisply struck and flashy with blatantly reflective fields. The devices have a degree of frost, and are both sides are brilliant save for an obverse ebony speck at 7 o'clock. Population: 64 in 67 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1375

1881-S $1 MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Frosty on the devices with fantastically reflective fields, this Premium Gem offers optimal eye appeal for the grade. Just a hint of golden peripheral toning adds color to an otherwise black-and-white coin. Population: 73 in 66 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1376

1882 $1 MS66 PCGS. Hints of peach visit the obverse, while the reverse is nearly untoned. Both sides share a sharp strike and potent luster, as well as notable preservation. Housed in an old green label holder. PCGS has graded just six finer pieces (2/10).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2009), lot 4509, which realized $1,552.50.(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1377

1882-CC $1 MS66 NGC. Strongly struck with only a touch of the usual softness at the hair over Liberty's ear. Bold silver-white luster cartwheels across each side. NGC has graded just 49 numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1378

1882-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. The lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem are essentially free of color and exhibit well struck design elements. A light graze or two does not disturb.(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1379

1882-CC $1 MS66 NGC. CAC. A wisp or two of yellow-orange appears on the obverse of this lovely Premium Gem. Well preserved lustrous surfaces exhibit sharp design features.(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1380

1882-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. The obverse of this Premium Gem is nearly untoned, while the reverse displays medium intensity golden-tan patina accented with aqua-green and lavender. Sharply struck, including the central areas. A few inconsequential grazes do not detract.(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1381

1882-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. A faint band of chestnut patina between 12 and 1 o'clock on the reverse precludes complete brilliance, but this thoroughly lustrous Premium Gem has a good strike and a clean appearance. A popular Carson City issue.(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1382

1882-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. VAM-2A. A Hit List 40 Variety. Although undesignated on the green label holder, this Carson City dollar has a clashed n in front of Liberty's neck, a popular feature among VAM enthusiasts. Light gold toning visits this well struck, thoroughly lustrous, and magnificently preserved Premium Gem.(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1383

1882-CC $1 MS66 NGC. The radiantly lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem are devoid of color and exhibit well struck devices. Both sides are remarkably smooth save for some trivial grazes.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1384

1882-CC $1 MS67 PCGS. A Superb Gem CC-mint Morgan dollar ideal for the toning enthusiast. This piece displays dazzling bands of teal, fuchsia, saffron, and sage on the obverse, lit up by coruscating luster. The reverse is largely silver-white, with just an arc of amber-gold to the right. Memorably appealing. Population: 50 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3, N2998)

1385

1882-CC $1 MS66 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. Flashy fields with lightly frosted devices that add contrast to the prooflike effect. This Premium Gem is only faintly toned with striking eye appeal. PCGS has graded only one finer Prooflike example (2/10).(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1386

1882-CC $1 MS65 Deep Prooflike NGC. Outstanding mirrors with bold field-to-device contrast. Blue and violet toning elements appear intermittently on each side. NGC has graded just four finer Deep Prooflike pieces (1/10).(Registry values: P3, N991)

1387

1882-CC $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The upper obverse and lower reverse show crescents of rich peach, while the rest of this Gem is minimally toned. Frosty devices emerge from fields with liquid reflectivity.(Registry values: P3, N991)

1388

1882-O $1 MS65 PCGS. Ebullient luster issues from the untoned surfaces of this Gem O-mint example. A few grade-consistent marks do not detract. Well struck save for softness in the centers. Rarely encountered any finer.(Registry values: P3, N991)

1389

1882-O $1 MS66 PCGS. Premium Gem examples of the 1882-O Morgan dollar are rarely encountered, despite the high mintage and considerable number of survivors in lower grades. This beauty has brilliant satin silver luster with wisps of pale gold toning at the borders. Minor die clashing is visible inside the upper right wreath branch. Population: 19 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P3, N2998)

1390

1882-O/O $1 MS65 ANACS. VAM-7. A Top 100 Variety. The mintmark is repunched widely south, with portions of the first mintmark visible within and below the more prominent second mintmark. Crisply struck and lustrous with clean surfaces aside from faint grazes on the nose. Slate-gray and sun-gold aside from an area of splendid forest-green, violet-red, and orange toning along the left obverse margin.(Registry values: P3, N991)

1391

1882-O $1 MS65 Prooflike NGC. Well struck and flashy with just a few wisps of light golden toning. Pleasing despite a solitary mark beneath the eye and a faint fingerprint fragment beneath the left (facing) wing. Census: 21 in 65 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1392

1882-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Notably reflective fields provide noticeable contrast with white devices. This untoned near-Gem has a clean cheek and scattered tiny marks on the fields. Certified in a green label holder.(Registry values: P3)

1393

1882-O/S $1 MS64 NGC. VAM-3. A Top 100 Variety. The "O/S Flush" VAM. Lightly toned in tan and steel-blue shades. A lustrous and powerfully struck Gem that has immaculate fields and only inconspicuous contact on the cheek.(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1394

1882-S $1 MS68 NGC. Both sides of this satiny Superb Gem are brilliant and lustrous with no evidence of toning. The fields are fully reflective, perhaps sufficient to provide a prooflike designation to this desirable dollar. Census: 79 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1395

1882-S $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. Occasional splashes of gold concentrate at the obverse border. Sharply struck and nicely preserved. Census: 72 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 9 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1396

1882-S $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This beautiful Gem is housed in a green label PCGS holder. Both sides are fully brilliant with a touch of champagne toning. The strike is bold and the surfaces are pleasing, with a few abrasions reflected in the mirrored fields. The devices are satiny and lustrous, resulting in a delightful cameo appearance. Population: 32 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1397

1882-S $1 MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. The 1882-S is one of the more plentiful early Morgan dollars in Mint State. Even Prooflike examples are not that difficult to locate, but Deep Mirror Prooflikes in the lofty grade of MS66 are elusive. The deep mirrors of this Premium Gem yield strong contrast against the frosted, fully struck devices. Both sides are nearly color-free except for barely discernible light gold at the margins and milky-white patches in the field in front of the chin of Liberty. The surfaces show only the slightest marks, as one would expect from an MS66. Census: 9 in 66 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1398

1883 $1 MS67 PCGS. A spectacular Superb Gem with exceptional preservation, a sharp strike, booming luster, and delicate olive-gold toning. A common date in typical Mint State, but rare in the present remarkable quality. Certified in an old green label holder. Population: 53 in 67, 3 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1399

1883 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. A light, intermittent layer of cloud-white toning scarcely dims the reflectivity of this noteworthy Gem. Sharply struck devices offer heavy frost. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 72 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N991)

1400

1883-CC $1 MS67 PCGS. A Superb type coin from the Carson City mint. This is a brilliant example that shows the expected fullness of strike with intricate detailing over Liberty's ear and fully articulated breast feathers on the eagle. Also as expected, the mint luster is thick and frosted, a common trait of CC coins of all denominations. The surfaces lack any mentionable marks, after all this is an MS67, and magnification is required to discern even the smallest luster grazes.(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1401

1883-CC $1 MS67 NGC. Long recognized and pursued as a Carson City type coin, this 1883-CC has all the eye appeal one could wish for from this historic mint. The surfaces are frosted and brilliant throughout, and as expected the fields display the often-seen semiprooflike flash. The striking details are intricately defined on each side.(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1402

1883-CC $1 MS67 PCGS. The disbursement of Carson City Morgan dollars through the GSA in the 1970s has ensured that any collector can acquire certain dates, as long as grade is unimportant. However, the specialist who requires a high grade, sharply struck example will need great patience. This is one of those pieces for the specialist, with brilliant silver surfaces. Satiny luster and full, untoned surfaces add to its eye appeal. PCGS has only certified three finer pieces (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1403

1883-CC $1 MS64 Ultra Deep Mirror Prooflike Cameo ANACS. Excellent Cameo contrast appears on both sides of this near-Gem. Color-free surfaces exhibit well struck devices and are minimally abraded.(Registry values: P2, N491)

1404

1883-CC $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. An outstandingly contrasted Gem with pale silver-white fields that gleam around richly frosted devices. Each side shows a single central mark, one a horizontal line at Liberty's lower cheek, the other a dig or scrape on the eagle's breast.(Registry values: P2, N991)

1405

1883-CC $1 MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Strikingly reflective in the fields with whispers of frost crossing the devices. Toning is generally mild and cloud-white, though a touch of orange is noted at the lower reverse. PCGS has certified two finer Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1406

1883-O $1 MS67 PCGS. A stunning Superb Gem, this 1883-O dollar has frosty silver luster with brilliant and mostly untoned obverse and reverse surfaces. The strike is virtually full and far finer than the usual New Orleans Mint dollar. Here is an excellent opportunity for the connoisseur to acquire the finest 1883-O dollar available. Population: 29 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N2998)

1407

1883-O $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Thickly frosted on the central devices with a sharp strike. Only tiny dots of dark toning add color to each side, though the shining fields do show a thin veil of silver-gray toning. Housed in a green label holder. PCGS has graded only 13 finer Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1408

1883-S $1 MS62 NGC. Light plum-mauve toning adorns portions of the borders of this lustrous and nicely struck example. Tiny marks are distributed, although none are singularly of note. Conditionally challenging, unlike prior San Francisco dates of the series.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1409

1883-S $1 MS63 NGC. Both sides of this Select Morgan are awash in bright luster and each exhibits sharply struck design motifs, including the hair above Liberty's ear and the eagle's breast feathers. A hair-thin mark on the cheek is mentioned for complete accuracy.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1410

1883-S $1 MS64 PCGS. Mint State 1883-S Morgan dollars are elusive, and extremely hard to find in Choice Mint State or finer grades. This sharply struck specimen has frosty silver luster with a ring of light gold and iridescent toning that adds to its overall eye appeal. Here is a wonderful opportunity for the Morgan dollar enthusiast. PCGS has only certified 18 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1411

1884 $1 MS67 NGC. Butter-gold toning visits the rims of this lustrous and well impressed Superb Gem. Uncommonly clean fields and devices confirms the lofty third party grade. The 1884 has a mintage of more than 14 million pieces, and perhaps 20,000 examples have been certified as Mint State, but few of those can compare the present nearly pristine coin. Census: 38 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1412

1884 $1 MS67 NGC. The 1884 is readily available through the Gem level of preservation. Premium Gems become scarce and MS67s such as the present offering are quite challenging. Radiantly lustrous surfaces exhibit crisp design elements and are color free. Both sides are impeccably preserved. Census: 38 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1413

1884 $1 MS66 Prooflike PCGS. Prooflike 1884 dollars have always been a challenging issue and this is borne out by the data from the grading services. PCGS has only certified 4 other pieces in MS66 with one finer, while NGC has graded five also in MS66 with none finer (2/10). This is a brilliant example that has brightly reflective mirrors in the fields. Set against the mirrors is a moderate but noticeable amount of mint frost over the devices. The devices are fully struck throughout, and the only "flaw" of note is a tiny brown dot of color at the top of the eagle's breast.(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1414

1884 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This flashy Gem boasts super reflectivity over silver-white surfaces, with excellent eye appeal. The reverse is nearly free of singular marks, and were it not for a couple of minor luster grazes in the left obverse field, this Gem might attain an even finer grade. A nice example of the issue. Population: 31 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1415

1884 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. All aspects of this coin are reminiscent of full proof Morgan dollars. The fields are fully mirrored around frosty devices, creating excellent cameo contrast. The strike is bold, including sharp central details. Only the diminished depth of the mirrored fields suggests that this brilliant Gem is prooflike rather than proof. Population: 31 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1416

1884-CC $1 MS67 NGC. This Superb Gem displays brilliant and frosty silver luster with an absence of toning on either side, save for wispy tan on the obverse. All of the design elements are sharply detailed, and the eye appeal is first rate. Census: 93 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1417

1884-CC $1 MS66 Prooflike NGC. Amazing reflectivity in the silver-white fields, almost of Deep Prooflike caliber. Thickly frosted silver-white devices are sharply struck and exquisitely preserved. Census: 57 in 66 Prooflike, 6 finer (2/10).
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1418

1884-CC $1 MS64 Ultra Deep Mirror Prooflike ANACS. VAM-4. A spike on the top of the 1 in the date confirms the variety. Whispers of light gold color visit the margins of this near-Gem. Sharply struck and revealing a few minor grazes.(Registry values: P2, N491)

1419

1884-CC $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. VAM-2, showing repunching on the top left of the 1 in the date and above its left base. Also, first C of mintmark doubled on inside. Strong field-motif variance on the untoned surfaces. Boldly struck and minimally abraded.(Registry values: P2, N991)

1420

1884-CC $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. VAM-2 with obvious repunching on the 1 in the date. Flashy fields contrast with a frosty portrait and eagle. All marks are inconsequential, and the eye appeal of this well struck Carson City dollar is exceptional. In a green label holder.(Registry values: P2, N991)

1421

1884-O $1 MS67 NGC. Golden peripheral toning is visible on the obverse, though the reverse restricts this color to the rims. Silver-white and silver-blue hues prevail elsewhere on this shining, slightly satiny Superb Gem.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1422

1884-O $1 MS67 NGC. This Superb Gem is awash with fantastic eye appeal related to intense luster, well struck devices, and impeccable preservation. Both sides are completely untoned. Census: 91 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1423

1884-S $1 AU58 NGC. The 1884-S is famous for its conditional rarity. Unlike the 1878-S through 1882-S San Francisco issues, the 1884-S is very scarce in Uncirculated grades. This is a nearly untoned example with a prooflike obverse and normal cartwheel luster on the reverse. The cheek has a couple of wispy marks.(Registry values: P9, N491)

1424

1884-S $1 AU58 NGC. This silver-gray near-Mint State example retains a generous amount of luster and is well defined. A few light circulation marks are undisturbing.(Registry values: P9, N491)

1425

1884-S $1 AU58 PCGS. Strong silver-white luster shows just a suggestion of gold at the margins. The obverse shows wispy abrasions and a couple of lines of reed marks, but it is the minor friction on the high points that determines the grade.(Registry values: P9, N491)

1426

1884-S $1 MS62 NGC. A decisive strike leaves much better-than-average delineation on the design elements, including near completeness in the hair over Liberty's ear and the eagle's breast feathers. Luminous surfaces are untoned and reveal faint die polish lines in the fields. A few minute marks barely prevent the attainment of the next highest grade.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P9, N2998)

1427

1885 $1 MS67 PCGS. Potent luster, a crisp strike, and a splendidly smooth appearance confirm the lofty quality of the present Superb Gem. A wisp of honey toning denies full brilliance. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 72 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1428

1885 $1 MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. A stunning Premium Gem, profoundly reflective with light silver color that shows faint cloud-gray overlays in parts of the fields. PCGS has graded only one finer Deep Mirror Prooflike coin (2/10). Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P1, N991)

1429

1885-CC $1 MS65 NGC. CAC. Stunningly lustrous with two gorgeous, if disparate looks. The obverse is richly toned in gold and orange, while the reverse of this Gem is closer to brilliant.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1430

1885-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. Flashy cartwheel luster with bold reflectivity, though this is not consistent enough for a Prooflike designation. Silver-white overall with golden peripheral elements and a dot of deep color at the right wreath.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1431

1885-CC $1 MS66 NGC. Faint frost twinkles across the well struck devices on this pleasing Premium Gem. Both sides are virtually untoned, displaying their inherent luster to full effect.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1432

1885-CC $1 MS66 NGC. Hints of peach color appear at certain angles, but head-on this Premium Gem is pale silver-gray. A frosty and delightful example of this Carson City issue which combines a low mintage and high survival rate.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1433

1885-CC $1 MS66 NGC. Rich violet, peach, gold, and silver hues are dappled across each side of this gorgeous Carson City dollar. Fantastically lustrous and carefully preserved beneath the patina.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1434

1885-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. Lustrous and precisely struck with pleasing preservation and barely a whisper of golden patina. The lowest mintage Carson City issue, made collectible courtesy of the GSA auctions of the 1970s.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1435

1885-CC $1 MS66 PCGS. This crisply struck Carson City Morgan provides pleasing luster and has only a glimpse of sun-gold toning. No marks are consequential. A favorite collector issue since the GSA auctions of the 1970s.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1436

1885-CC $1 MS65 Prooflike PCGS. Decidedly reflective in the fields with a profoundly flashy reverse. This Gem is richly frosted on the devices and minimally toned overall save for minor milky streaks at the obverse margins and a few dashes of sage on the reverse. PCGS has graded 29 finer Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N991)

1437

1885-CC $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Thickly frosted devices give way to gleaming silver-white mirrors. Lightly abraded throughout, which accounts for the Select designation.(Registry values: P4, N491)

1438

1885-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Incredibly reflective fields shine through a thin layer of pale cloud-white toning with a touch of gold. Great contrast with the silver-white device-frost furthers the Deep Mirror Prooflike effect.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1439

1885-CC $1 MS65 Ultra Deep Mirror Prooflike ANACS. Thickly frosted devices and glassy fields provide the appearance of a deep cameo proof. A sharp strike despite minor roller marks near the ear and the base of the wreath. Peripheral plum-mauve fills the borders of this well preserved low mintage Carson City Morgan.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1440

1885-CC $1 MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The story of the 1885-CC is a small mintage but large survival, due to preservation of massive amounts in the Treasury hoards. But its story continues as a much in-demand CC-mint issue, and one that is gloriously well produced, making it equally a target of type and date collectors. This Premium Gem piece sports the excellent preservation and deep contrast expected. The paucity of abrasions and high eye appeal add to the allure. Population: 40 in 66 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1441

(20) 1885-O $1 MS65 NGC. An opportunity to acquire a matched certified roll's worth of this popular New Orleans issue. All the silver dollars are lustrous, lightly toned, and generally unmarked with minor to typical incompleteness of strike at the centers.
From The JTR Collection.

1442

1885-O $1 MS67 PCGS. CAC. Low intensity multicolored toning concentrates at the upper obverse and left reverse margin of this Superb Gem O-mint example. Lustrous surfaces exhibit well struck design elements, including the hair above Liberty's ear. Pleasingly smooth with no significant marks.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1443

1885-O $1 MS67 PCGS. Phenomenal frosted mint luster is the strong suit of this superior O-mint type dollar. The striking details are fully defined on each side, and there is just a tinge of pale golden over the otherwise brilliant surfaces.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1444

1885-O $1 MS67 NGC. A well executed strike leaves strong delineation on the design motifs, including the hair at Liberty's ear and the eagle's breast feathers. Vibrant luster emanates from color-free surfaces that lack mentionable impairments.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1445

1885-S $1 MS66 NGC. This is an issue known for strike weakness, but here it is limited to the hair just over the ear, while the eagle's breast is well impressed. The surfaces are free of any mentionable distractions, and radiant cartwheel luster emanates from both sides. Census: 14 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1446

1886 $1 MS67 ★ NGC. The reverse is fully toned in vivid orange, gunmetal-blue, and cream-gray shades. The upper obverse displays waves of sea-green, cherry-red, lemon, and ice-blue, although about two-thirds of the side remains brilliant. Exquisitely struck and preserved. Census: 26 in 67 ★ , 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1447

1886 $1 MS67 PCGS. The rims display butter-gold shades, but the fields and devices remain brilliant. This fully struck Gem has outstanding preservation and exemplary eye appeal. PCGS has certified a mere three pieces finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1448

1886 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The obverse of this Deep Mirror Prooflike Gem is strongly contrasted and minimally toned. The former applies to the reverse but not the latter; pale champagne color at the lower reverse yields to increasingly wild bands of yellow, red, blue, and green. PCGS has graded 25 finer Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1449

1886-O $1 MS61 NGC. A brilliant example of this scarcer O-mint dollar. The surfaces exhibit subdued satiny mint luster, and the striking details are a tad soft as usually seen. Remarkably clean, though, for the grade.(Registry values: P8, N991)

1450

1886-O $1 MS63 PCGS. Autumn-gold toning hugs the design elements of this otherwise gunmetal-gray Morgan dollar. Sharply struck and satiny with the expected faint luster grazes. The 1886-O is a notorious conditional rarity, common in grades through XF but among the rarest issues of the series in Gem.(Registry values: P8, N1793)

1451

1886-O $1 MS64 NGC. Ex: Richmond Collection. Here is one of the famous condition rarities in the Morgan series, despite a mintage of more than 10 million coins. The date is common or scarce in circulated grades and rare in the lowest Mint State grades. However, any example in MS64 or finer grades is a major rarity. This representative is fully brilliant and untoned, with frosty silver luster, and only a few minor marks on each side.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P8, N4719)

1452

1886-S $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. VAM-4. The mintmark is repunched, but to a lesser degree than on the Top 100 VAM-2. This semi-prooflike Premium Gem is well preserved and has delicate almond-gold toning. The strike is sharp, although slightly incomplete on the hair above the ear. A lower mintage issue. Population: 27 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1453

1886-S $1 MS64 Prooflike NGC. This better date near-Gem features flashy luster and a decisive strike. Brilliant save for occasional peripheral lilac toning. Housed in a prior generation holder. Census: 73 in 64 Prooflike, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N991)

1454

1887 $1 MS67 PCGS. CAC. A virtually brilliant Superb Gem whose booming luster, sharp strike, and splendidly preserved fields and devices confirm the lofty third party grade. Population: 65 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1455

1887 $1 MS67 PCGS. Dazzling luster, a precise strike, and virtually immaculate surfaces confirm the Superb Gem quality of this high grade silver dollar. Snow-white save for an occasional trace of olive toning.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1456

1887 $1 Donkey Tail AU53 PCGS. VAM-1A, R.6. A Top 100 Variety. A small die break beneath the right side of the D in DOLLAR explains the "Donkey Tail" nickname. The cheek and the field near the arrowheads are somewhat abraded. Nearly unobtainable in Mint State, and even AU examples are rarities. Population: 11 in 53, 19 finer (2/10).

1457

1887 $1 MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. A flashy and untoned representative that has a pristine reverse and a well preserved obverse. The 1887 is notoriously plentiful, even in better Mint State grades, but high grade DMPL examples are elusive. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 30 in 66 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1458

1887/6 $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-2. A Top 100 Variety. The curve of the base of the underdigit 6 is visible on both sides of the bottom of the 7. An essentially brilliant Gem with booming luster and a remarkably preserved reverse. Just nine coins have been certified by PCGS in higher grades (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1459

1887/6 $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. VAM-2. A Top 100 Variety. The fields are impressively reflective, and this minimally toned near-Gem possesses a precise strike. The reverse is well preserved, and the obverse lacks mentionable abrasions. PCGS has graded 40 finer Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1460

1887/6 $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. VAM-2. A Top 100 Variety. A Choice Prooflike representative with the lower curve of the 6 plain under magnification. Well-defined and pleasingly reflective. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1461

1887-O $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Both sides are shining silver-white with just a suggestion of gray color. This well struck Gem hails from a New Orleans issue that is rare any finer, with just nine such coins known to PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1462

1887-O $1 MS65 NGC. Dappled mustard-gold and violet toning graces the margins of this Gem, while the centers have pale silver-gray luster. Well struck overall but with typical softness at the highest design elements. NGC has certified just three numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1463

1887-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. A moderately contrasted near-Gem that shows only slight hints of color, gold-orange on the obverse rims and small patches of similar color on and near the eagle. This coin, housed in a green label holder, displays well for the grade. Population: 85 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1464

1887/6-O $1 MS62 PCGS. CAC. VAM-3. A Top 100 variety. Discovered later than the 1887/6, the 1887/6-O is scarcer, especially in better Mint State grades. Only a single MS67 is certified by either PCGS or NGC. The present piece is lustrous and generally untoned. Wispy grazes are distributed, and the centers are softly brought up, typical for the variety, issue, and mint.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1465

1887/6-O $1 MS62 PCGS. VAM-3. A Top 100 variety. The prized O-mint overdate, offered here in Mint State. Though the moderately abraded portrait is softly struck, the impressive silver-white luster, bordered in peach-gold, redeems the eye appeal.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1466

1887/6-O $1 MS63 ANACS. VAM-3. A Top 100 variety. This is the highly-collectible New Orleans overdate variety of 1887. The present coin has brilliant silver luster with a lovely frame of gold toning near the borders.(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1467

1887/6-O $1 MS64 PCGS. VAM-3. A Top 100 variety. The Philadelphia and New Orleans Mints coined 1887 over 6 overdate dollars, while none have ever been identified from San Francisco. This near-Gem is fully brilliant with frosty silver surfaces and no toning. The central design elements are typically weak. Population: 99 in 64, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N4719)

1468

1887-S $1 MS65 PCGS. A stunning Gem Morgan dollar with fully brilliant silver surfaces on both sides, enhanced by splendid pale gold toning at the peripheral areas. All design elements are sharp, and the overall eye appeal is exceptional. PCGS has only certified 21 finer non-prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1469

1887-S $1 MS65 PCGS. A wisp or two of barely discernible gold color visits the highly lustrous surfaces of this lovely Gem. An appropriately defined minimally abraded piece. PCGS has graded only 21 coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1470

1887-S $1 MS66 PCGS. This silver-white piece is a Premium Gem example of this moderately difficult issue in the Morgan dollar series, one of the finest certified at PCGS. This piece is free from mentionable abrasions and boasts attractive silver-white luster. Some roller marks from an incomplete strike appear in the centers of both sides, but the clean surfaces and lack of marks more than compensate. Population: 21 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N4719)

1471

1887-S $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. Fully prooflike with deeply mirrored fields that offer excellent contrast with the frosty, sharply struck devices. Only a few scattered marks prevent a higher grade. Occasional splashes of reddish-gold and sky-blue are evident. Prooflike examples of this issue are quite scarce and highly desirable. Population: 17 in 64 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N991)

1472

1888 $1 MS67 NGC. From the enormous mintage approaching 20 million coins, only a few examples reach or exceed the Superb Gem level. This piece well merits the designation, however, with beaming cartwheel luster over frosty ice-white surfaces. The strike is essentially full, and the few contact marks are minor. Census: 44 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2, N4719)

1473

1888 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Outstanding flashy fields show just a dusting of cloud-white toning, while the crisply detailed devices are thickly frosted. This Gem is encased in a green label holder. Population: 40 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1474

1888-O $1 Doubled Arrows MS66 NGC. VAM-9. A Top 100 Variety. This reverse doubled die is most readily visible at the arrowheads, though more minor doubling is visible elsewhere at the lower reverse. Carefully preserved with a hint of peach color over bright surfaces that are otherwise silver-white.

1475

1888-O $1 Doubled Arrows MS66 PCGS. VAM-9. A Top 100 Variety. Although undesignated as such on the PCGS insert, this is the "Doubled Arrows" variety with the doubled die also noticeable on the tailfeathers, lower wreath, and portions of DOLLAR and AMERICA. The date is misplaced in the dentils, with the top of a 1 visible on the dentil beneath the first 8. Lustrous, lightly toned, boldly struck, gorgeously preserved, and one of the finest known for the variety.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1476

1888-O $1 Clashed E MS65 PCGS. VAM-1A. A Top 100 Variety. The E (from LIBERTY) is clashed beneath the tailfeathers. As always for VAM-1A, the E is faint and two-thirds complete, but this nonetheless is one of the most prominent Clashed E varieties in the series. An early die state with a slender crack through the R in PLURIBUS and three obverse rim cuds between 3 and 4:30. Lustrous and brilliant with the usual O-mint minor incompleteness of strike at the centers.

1477

1888-O $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Housed in a green label PCGS holder, this amazing 1888-O dollar has fully brilliant obverse and reverse surfaces with deeply mirrored fields and satiny silver devices. This is extremely rare issue in deep mirror prooflike format, and will be actively pursued at the sale. Population: 56 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1478

1888-O $1 Doubled Die Obverse AU53 PCGS. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. The famous "Hot Lips" VAM with prominent die doubling on Liberty's profile. This VAM is one of five honored with photos in the 2010 Guide Book; the others are the VAM-3 1901 and the VAM-4, VAM-5, and VAM-6 1880-CC. Lightly toned and moderately abraded with ample luster. Population: 29 in 53, 50 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

1479

1888-O $1 Doubled Die Obverse AU55 PCGS. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. This highly regarded variety is known as the "Hot Lips" VAM, although the nose and chin are also widely die doubled. Light golden-brown toning visits the borders of this mostly lustrous and momentarily circulated silver dollar. The eagle's breast and the hair above the ear show a typical strike. Population: 28 in 55, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

1480

1888-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Cobalt-blue, lavender, and gold-orange patina bathes the lustrous surfaces of this Gem S-mint example. Appropriately struck and minimally abraded.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1481

1888-S $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. This is an outstanding opportunity for the advanced Morgan dollar collector. The 1888-S is one of the important condition rarities in the series. In fact, PCGS has only certified two finer examples (1/10). This sharply struck Premium Gem has attractive toning throughout the upper part of the obverse, and the lower reverse displays additional splashes of color. The surfaces are powerfully lustrous and minimally marked. An excellent piece for a Registry Set.(Registry values: P6, N4719)

1482

1888-S $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. A completely brilliant near-Gem whose reflective fields provide contrast with the moderately frosted devices. The strike is sharp, and there are no distracting abrasions. Certified in a green label holder. Population: 43 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1483

1889 $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. Lovely silver-gray luster, lightly toned over with just a touch of pink and gold color. A great Premium Gem representative of an issue rarely found any finer; PCGS has certified just four such pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1484

1889 $1 MS66 Prooflike PCGS. Flashy, untoned, and boldly struck. The cheek is remarkably smooth. The 1889 is plentiful with cartwheel luster, but high grade prooflike pieces are surprisingly rare. The present coin is the single finest PCGS-graded Prooflike example, although the service has certified an additional three pieces as MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P3, N2998)

1485

1889-CC $1 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of a Mint State specimen that has been cleaned. Both sides are fully brilliant with reflective fields. This is an excellent example, despite the surface quality.(Registry values: P9, N9)

1486

1889-CC $1 VF20 PCGS. CAC. Each side shows even wear over the high points, and there are no discernable marks. While a VF20 grade and a CAC sticker may initially seem at odds with each other, all one has to do is examine this problem-free coin to understand.(Registry values: P9, N1)

1487

1889-CC $1 VF20 PCGS. Light to medium gray patination graces the mildly abraded surfaces of this key-date Morgan dollar. The design elements are well-defined, as visible through moderate wear.(Registry values: P9, N1)

1488

1889-CC $1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Light golden toning graces the margins, although the slightly bright surfaces are generally pearl-gray. Ample luster resides in design crevices. Although mildly cleaned, the present key date CC-mint dollar will satisfy most collectors.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P9, N1)

1489

1889-CC $1 VF25 NGC. Though moderately worn, this key Carson City dollar retains considerable luminosity through rich patina. Violet, gold-gray, and light silver hues prevail on the mildly abraded surfaces.(Registry values: P9, N1)

1490

1889-CC $1 VF30 PCGS. Surprisingly lustrous for the amount of wear present, though this is largely close tot he rims, where rich gold and sky-blue hues are present. Paler silver color prevails close to the modestly abraded centers.(Registry values: P9, N1)

1491

1889-CC $1 VF35 PCGS. A luminous Choice VF example of this popular Morgan dollar key, pearl-gray on the obverse with deeper lavender hues on the reverse. Both sides show a measure of tan at the borders.(Registry values: P9, N1)

1492

1889-CC $1 VF35 PCGS. Violet-gray and blue hues with a streak of deep color at the upper left reverse. Distinctly worn but with great eye appeal for the Very Fine category, hence the VF35 designation.(Registry values: P9, N1)

1493

1889-CC $1 XF40 NGC. Medium steel-blue and caramel-gold toning embraces this problem-free and richly detailed representative. Traces of luster cling to the reverse legends. The scarcest Carson City Morgan dollar issue.(Registry values: P9, N1793)

1494

1889-CC $1 XF40 ANACS. Light honey-gold toning adorns the margins of this moderately circulated rare date dollar. Luster still glimmers from the wings and legends. The most desired Carson City issue, as it went principally into circulation, unlike the lower mintage '81-CC and '85-CC.(Registry values: P9, N1793)

1495

1889-CC $1 XF45 PCGS. Light gold toning on each side of this Choice XF provides excellent eye appeal. The strike is strong, and the surfaces are satiny, with nearly full underlying brilliance. Here is an important piece of Morgan dollar history, and a coin that will delight its next owner.(Registry values: P9, N1793)

1496

1889-CC $1 XF45 PCGS. Here is an important example of the famous key-date 1889-CC Morgan dollar, housed in a green-label PCGS holder. Both sides have light silver-gray surfaces with considerable brilliant luster in the protected areas near the devices. Hints of gold toning add to its overall eye appeal.(Registry values: P9, N1793)

1497

1889-CC $1 --Rim Filed, Hair Tooled, Repaired--NGC. AU Details. This hairlined key date Carson City dollar is stone-gray and lackluster. The cheek and jaw are smoothed, and file marks are evident on the dentils above the BU in PLURIBUS. The hair above the ear is tooled with some skill, to disguise minor highpoint wear.(Registry values: P9, N2998)

1498

1889-CC $1 AU53 PCGS. This key date Carson City dollar has substantial cartwheel luster, and the medium tan-gold and ice-blue toning confirms the piece has never been dipped. The eagle's breast and the hair above the ear display light wear, but most design detail is bold. Much nicer than the usually encountered '89-CC.(Registry values: P9, N2998)

1499

1889-CC $1 MS61 NGC. The 1889-CC dollar was struck only in the last three months of the year. The Carson City Mint had reopened from a four-year closure in July, and the dies and planchets needed for production apparently were not ready for another two to three months after that. The issue is known popularly as a rarity, though finding an attractive example for one's chosen grade is the real challenge. This MS61 piece, well-defined with pale silver luster and a few spots of deeper toning, has a mostly clean cheek, and the rest of the devices are minimally marked. The fields show the wispy abrasions which account for the grade, as well as a faint fingerprint behind Liberty's head.(Registry values: P9, N4719)

1500

1889-CC $1 MS62 NGC. To produce the 350,000 pieces of the 1889-CC dollars, three different dies are known each for the obverse and the reverse of the 1889-CC Morgan dollars. On the most common obverse, there is a tiny die line, just about horizontal, that connects the large, leftmost oak leaf with the small corn leaf to its left. Another of the obverse dies has the 9 in the date somewhat higher than the other digits, about 15%, with the 1 in the date minutely doubled below the upper crossbar. Yet a third obverse die shows the date set further right than normal.
Of the three reverse dies, one has a normal CC mintmark, one is set slightly to the right, and the third is tilted somewhat to the left, so that the top serif of the last C is quite near the right underside of the bowknot.
The 1889-CC, although extremely elusive, is a fairly well-produced coin when found. Most boast a well-defined strike. Although Mint State examples are few and far between, many show prooflike surfaces on one or both sides, and even Deep Mirror Prooflike coins are seen.
This example is brilliant throughout and strongly struck throughout. The mint luster is a bit subdued for a higher grade, and there are a few (actually very few) field marks on each side.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P9, N4719)

1501

1889-O $1 Weak "E" Clash AU55 NGC. Weak "E" Clash, VAM-20A. A Hot 50 Variety. The 1889-O VAM-20A is one of the more difficult Hot 50 varieties to come by. Mark Kimpton in his Elite Clashed Morgan Dollars reference opines that the variety: "... couples intense interest with extreme rarity, making it one of the pricier clashed varieties around. Estimates place the premium on the AU grade at 25 X a 'common' value of an 1889-O Morgan!" A PCGS-graded AU55 sold for $1,495 (including Buyer's premium) in the Heritage October 25, 2008 Dallas sale.
The clashed E to the upper left of the bow on this Choice AU specimen is quite strong. Magnification shows soft, barely discernible golden-tan patina on the obverse and both sides display a good amount of luster in the recessed areas. The design elements are well defined despite light high-point wear and neither side reveals marks other than what might be expected for a coin experiencing brief circulation. Census for VAM-20A: 1 in 55, 0 finer (2/10).

1502

1889-O $1 MS65 NGC. The usual O-mint strike weakness is minor here, confined to the area over the ear. But silvery surfaces with lots of frosty luster and only small, grade-consistent abrasions make this an appealing Gem of this issue, seldom seen finer. Census: 45 in 65, 6 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1503

1889-O $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Outstanding reflectivity with mild contrast, thanks to a touch of frost on the well struck devices. The grade is due to wispy marks more than significant abrasions, though the eagle does show one such abrasion on its body. Population: 38 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1504

1889-S $1 MS65 NGC. CAC. Sharply struck with outstanding luster and only the faintest suggestions of patina. This essentially silver-white Gem offers great eye appeal. NGC has graded just 27 numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1505

1889-S $1 MS66 PCGS. The 1889-S is a difficult but obtainable issue in most Mint State grades, despite a low initial mintage of only 700,000 coins. The present example is a marvelous Premium Gem specimen, with radiant cartwheel luster and mostly silver-white surfaces, with just a tinge of pink on the eagle's left (facing) wing. Visible contact marks are few and minor. Population: 61 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1506

1889-S $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This fully struck Choice better date dollar exhibits lightly dappled autumn-gold toning. The cheek has only minor marks, while the reverse is refreshingly unabraded. Rare in DMPL format, and encased in a green label holder. Population: 19 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1507

1890 $1 MS65 PCGS. Exceptionally lustrous with an even overlay of light gray toning on each side. Well, but not fully defined in the centers. A premium example of this high mintage issue that has surprisingly relatively few Gems certified. Only one example graded finer by PCGS.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1508

1890 $1 MS65 NGC. Reddish-gold and aqua-blue hues run over the lustrous surfaces of this well struck Gem. Well cared for on both sides. Extremely difficult to locate any finer.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1509

1890 $1 MS65 PCGS. Scintillating luster across untoned surfaces. Without the aid of magnification we find no distractions worthy of mention. Overall, this specimen exhibits the qualities of a coin grading even finer. Astonishingly, as of (2/10) PCGS has certified only two 1890-P dollars finer--both at the MS66 level.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1510

1890 $1 MS65 PCGS. Potent luster sweeps this well struck and virtually untoned Gem. The fields are refreshingly smooth, and the cheek displays only minor grazes. As of (2/10), PCGS has certified only two pieces above MS65, an MS66 and an MS66 Prooflike.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1511

1890 $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. A narrow band of yellow-green toning rings each side of this near-Gem. Fantastically reflective but with only moderate contrast, owing to the lightly frosted devices. In a green label holder. Population: 74 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1512

1890-CC $1 Tail Bar MS64 Prooflike PCGS. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. This beautifully toned dollar has fully mirrored fields and cameo contrast beneath silver-gray surfaces with remarkable iridescent splashes on both sides. Prooflike and Deep Mirror Prooflike examples are surprisingly rare. NGC and PCGS have combined to certify the following: MS62 PL (2); MS63 PL (4); MS64 PL (2); MS63 DMPL (13); and MS64 DMPL (7). Population: 2 in 64 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

1513

1890-CC $1 Tail Bar MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. VAM-4. A Top 100 Variety. Some numismatists who should know better have long scorned the "Tail Bar" VAM, which can be spotted at a glance without the aid of a loupe. Only about 1 in 20 1890-CC dollars sport a "Tail Bar" reverse. Among those, only a select few qualify as DMPL. Lightly toned and prominently mirrored with clean fields and delicate almond-gold toning. Population: 11 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

1514

1890-CC $1 MS64 PCGS. Smoky-gray and aqua-green patination runs over the lustrous surfaces of this well struck Carson City representative. Nice overall eye appeal.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: P5, N991)

1515

1890-CC $1 MS64 PCGS. An occasional trace of grayish-tan color shows up on the lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem and a well executed strike imparts strong definition to the design elements, including the hair over Liberty's ear. Kept from Gem by a few minor marks.(Registry values: P5, N991)

1516

1890-CC $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Outstanding flashy mirrors and memorable eye appeal, despite scattered abrasions in the fields and on the frost of the devices. Faint cloud-white toning has settled over parts of each side.(Registry values: P5, N991)

1517

1890-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. Deeply mirrored reflectivity is this coin chief hallmark, with thick mint frost and predominantly silver-white surfaces. A thin ring of lilac-gold encircles portions of the rim on each side. The minor abrasions and luster grazes that determine the grade are mostly away from the prime focal areas, and lots of eye appeal is present. NGC has certified only seven Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces finer (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1518

1890-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The fans of Deep Mirror Prooflike Morgan dollars are legion, and they seem to have a special enthusiasm for the coins meeting their criteria. This deeply mirrored silver-white near-Gem would no doubt light their fires, with intense contrast and silver-white surfaces. Only trivial contact appears, away from the focal areas. PCGS has certified 19 DMPL examples finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1519

1890-O $1 MS65 Prooflike PCGS. Fully brilliant silver surfaces are composed of frosty luster on the devices, surrounded by deeply mirrored fields. The result is strong cameo contrast on both sides. Entirely atypical, as the usual 1890-O Morgan has frosty mint luster on the devices and in the fields. Prooflike specimens are seldom encountered. The present coin has an highly unusual combination of prooflike surfaces and strong details. Population: 20 in 65 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1520

1890-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Icy devices provide blatant contrast with the mirrored fields of this New Orleans silver dollar. The strike is above average for the Southern facility. One small spot on the cheek, and the fields display faint abrasions.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1521

1890-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Lightly frosted on the devices but with stronger contrast than might be expected, thanks to the intensity of the silver-white mirrors. A notably appealing coin, housed in a green label holder. PCGS has certified just 17 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N991)

1522

1890-S $1 MS66 PCGS. CAC. Rich tobacco-brown toning adorns the margins of this highly lustrous and meticulously struck Premium Gem. The borders also display glimpses of plum-red and navy-blue. Splendidly devoid of marks, and nearly unimprovable in the present quality. As of (2/10), PCGS has certified a mere six pieces finer.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1523

1890-S $1 MS66 PCGS. This fully brilliant Premium Gem has frosty luster and only a hint of gold toning on the reverse. The design elements are sharp and the eye appeal is exceptional. PCGS has only certified six finer examples of this issue. A grand opportunity for the advanced collector.
From The JTR Collection. (Registry values: P4, N1793)

1524

1890-S $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This green label PCGS dollar is boldly detailed and displays amazing silver brilliance with no toning on either side. The surfaces have a few typical marks expected for the grade, but none of any consequence. Population: 27 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1525

1891 $1 MS65 NGC. The reverse on this silver-white Gem has considerable contrast between frosted devices and reflective fields, creating a fairly prooflike effect. The obverse, while limited in contrast, has frosty surfaces and excellent luster, and neither side shows any singular abrasions. An appealing Gem.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1526

1891 $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. This Prooflike near-Gem is brilliant but for a touch of gold at the lower obverse. Excellent striking definition with more luster grazes than actual marks on the frosted portrait. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 18 in 64 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1527

1891 $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. VAM-2. A Top 100 Variety. The "Doubled Ear" VAM with obvious die doubling to the south on Liberty's earlobe and the hair above the ear. Brilliant and blatantly mirrored with light but consistent frost on the portrait, eagle, and wreath. The portrait is particularly well preserved. As of (2/10), PCGS has certified 19 1891 dollars as MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, with none finer. Two of those 19 have been attributed as VAM-2 by PCGS.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1528

1891-CC $1 MS64 NGC. CAC. VAM-3. A Top 100 Variety. The "Spitting Eagle" is named for a die gouge awkwardly located near the eagle's open beak. This is an impressively lustrous near-Gem with gold-orange patina over the obverse and the peripheral reverse. The date area also shows rose and violet elements.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1529

1891-CC $1 MS64 NGC. CAC. Peripheral orange, russet, and electric-blue toning is deeper and more extensive on the obverse of this lustrous, minimally marked near-Gem. The centers are somewhat weak, as often seen.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1530

1891-CC $1 MS64 NGC. VAM-3. A Top 100 Variety. The so-called "Spitting Eagle," named for a die gouge in close proximity to the eagle's beak. Brightly lustrous centers are largely silver-white with just a touch of blue. Hints of gold are visible at the margins. Well struck and desirable.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1531

1891-CC $1 MS64 PCGS. This lustrous Choice Carson City dollar has delicate chestnut toning and a splendidly smooth obverse field. The centers show slight incompleteness. Encapsulated in an old green label holder.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1532

1891-CC $1 MS64 PCGS. This near-Gem displays a slight golden cast on its lustrous surfaces. A well struck piece with just a few minor grade-defining marks.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1533

1891-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. Potent luster sweeps this untoned and nicely struck Gem. The fields are remarkably smooth, and the portrait displays only minor contact. The '91-CC is the most available of the post-1885 Carson City issues, but is nonetheless scarce at the MS65 level. Encapsulated in a circa-1990 doily label holder.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1534

1891-CC $1 MS62 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. VAM-3. A Top 100 Variety. The familiar "Spitting Eagle" VAM, which is scarce in Deep Mirror format. A brilliant Carson City dollar with flashy fields that provide moderate contrast with the frosted devices. The fields display distributed marks consistent with the grade.(Registry values: P6, N491)

1535

1891-CC $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. CAC. VAM-3. A Top 100 Variety. The well known "Spitting Eagle." Elusive in Deep Mirror Prooflike format. Untoned well struck surfaces display pleasing field-motif variance. Inoffensive obverse grazes limit the grade; nevertheless, a highly appealing coin!(Registry values: P6, N991)

1536

1891-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This incredible Deep Mirror Prooflike 1891-CC dollar is housed in a green label PCGS holder. It is brilliant with no toning on either side. The strike is sharp and the combination of mirrored fields and lustrous devices results in excellent cameo contrast. Population: 47 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1537

1891-O $1 MS65 NGC. A brilliant silver-white Gem of this high-mintage New Orleans issue, made in the quantity of nearly 8 million coins. The MS65 level is nonetheless about the finest obtainable. This piece boasts silvery surfaces with minimal marks and minor strike weakness above the ear, as usual. Census: 73 in 65, 2 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1538

1891-O $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. This flashy and virtually brilliant near-Gem is surprisingly devoid of significant marks. The design elements are much better struck than ordinarily seen, including partial detail in the centers, areas that are often flat. The eye appeal is exceptional. Population: 11 in 64 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1539

1891-O $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. While a few abrasions and hairlines prevent a higher grade, this is an extremely important Morgan dollar, a rarity with prooflike surfaces and cameo contrast. This piece is brilliant with light gold toning along the borders. The contrast is excellent and the overall eye appeal is extremely high. Housed in a green label PCGS holder. Population: 8 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1540

1891-S $1 MS66 PCGS. Another major condition rarity in the Morgan series, with lower grade pieces readily available but seldom seen in Premium Gem or finer grades. NGC and PCGS have combined to grade just 69 MS66 coins and only nine finer pieces. This example is fully brilliant and untoned with sharp design features and frosty luster.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1541

1892 $1 MS65 PCGS. Just over a million 1892-P dollars were struck. Many years ago a dedicated collector pointed out that his set was lacking this relatively obtainable issue, not because he could not locate a Gem but because he could not locate a full strike. Since then we have noted that almost all 1892 dollars lack complete definition over Liberty's ear. This piece also lacks that absolute completeness of strike, but it is otherwise a stunning Gem. The surfaces are brilliant and brightly frosted with no mentionable or noticeable abrasions.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1542

1892 $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-3 with minor die doubling on the reverse legends. This is a pleasing Gem with vibrant luster and only a whisper of almond-gold toning. There are no abrasions of note on either side. The strike, while just a bit short of full, is remarkably strong for this strike rarity. Just two finer pieces have been certified by PCGS (2/10).
Ex: Baltimore ANA Signature (Heritage, 8/2008), lot 2389, which realized $4,025.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1543

1892 $1 MS65 PCGS. This precisely struck Gem has pleasing preservation, dazzling luster, and only a wisp of sun-gold toning. Philadelphia struck at least 8.6 million silver dollars every year between 1878 and 1891, but a drop in the U.S. gold supply changed matters, and high mintages at the facility did not resume until 1896.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1544

1892-CC $1 MS61 ANACS. Canary-gold toning is limited to the rims of this otherwise brilliant scarce date Carson City dollar. Vivacious cartwheel luster sweeps boldly struck surfaces. Distributed marks on the left obverse correspond to the grade.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1545

1892-CC $1 MS62 PCGS. Though not certified as Prooflike, this Carson City dollar displays numerous prooflike attributes, including frost over the devices and considerable reflectivity in the virtually untoned fields. Light abrasions on and near the portrait define the grade.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1546

1892-CC $1 MS63 PCGS. Pleasingly detailed with just a suggestion of peach toning at the outer fields of this silver-white Select coin. Luster grazes, of some number but generally shallow, account for the grade.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1547

1892-CC $1 MS63 ANACS. Softly frosted over the central devices with pillowy detail at the hair over Liberty's ear. Surfaces are untoned save for hints of gold and mauve close to the rims. A line of shallow marks in the field to the left of the profile accounts for the grade.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1548

1892-CC $1 MS63 NGC. An impressively lustrous later Carson City Morgan dollar with frosty elements over well struck devices. Glimpses of orange-gold color at the rims counterbalance the essential silver-white of the centers.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1549

1892-CC $1 MS63 PCGS. CAC. This fully patinated better date CC-mint dollar displays forest-green, electric-blue, cherry-red, and stone-gray shades. A boldly struck and lustrous example with beautifully unabraded fields and only moderate facial grazes.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1550

1892-CC $1 MS63 NGC. Flashy luster radiates from both sides of this Select example, each of which displays whispers of yellow-gold color at the margins. A decisive strike brings out excellent detail on the design elements. Some inoffensive grazes limit the grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1551

1892-CC $1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Small patches of gold-orange peripheral color offset the essential brilliance seen elsewhere on this Carson City dollar. Fantastic luster with the grade largely determined by a scrape at the bottom of the bust.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1552

1892-CC $1 MS64 PCGS. Frosty on the devices with pleasing luster through the lightly toned fields. The obverse eye appeal is suggestive of an even finer grade, though the reverse shows an abrasion at the eagle's lower body.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1553

1892-CC $1 MS65 PCGS. The dies on this penultimate CC-mint issue appear quite advanced, as numerous interesting die cracks appear on both sides. Nonetheless they managed to strike this delightful Gem, which shows few meaningful abrasions, aside from a small scrape near star 13. The surfaces are silver-white with softly frosted luster, although the reverse shows a dash of golden-lilac near the lower rim. PCGS has certified only 20 examples finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1554

1892-CC $1 MS63 Prooflike PCGS. VAM-4 with a clearly repunched second C in the mintmark. A flashy and sharply struck scarce date Carson City Morgan that has only a wisp of walnut-tan toning.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1555

1892-CC $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. VAM-4. The mintmark is nicely repunched. A prominently mirrored and well struck silver dollar with clean fields and a few grazes on the portrait. A better Carson City issue that was notably absent from the various GSA sales. Encased in a green label holder. Population: 42 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 29 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1556

1892-CC $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This amazing Carson City dollar is housed in a green label PCGS holder. It exhibits incredible contrast between deeply mirrored fields and lustrous devices. Those devices are sharply detailed, even at the centers. Here is an excellent opportunity for the advanced collector. Population: 42 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 29 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1557

1892-O $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. The very existence of this coin is difficult to imagine, as prooflike or deep mirror prooflike 1892-O Morgan dollars in any grade are extremely rare. Consider that NGC and PCGS have certified a mere 41 coins with mirrored surfaces in all grades, from a total submission of several thousand examples of the date. Both sides have deeply mirrored fields with excellent contrast, all beneath subtle gold toning. Population: 4 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1558

1893 $1 MS63 PCGS. Well-defined for this lower-mintage issue, though the central obverse shows slight softness. Faint blue tints supply most of the color on this Select piece, though an area of deep forest-green is visible at the upper obverse rim.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1559

1893 $1 MS64 PCGS. A lustrous coin, largely pale silver-gray with a touch of peach and pink color. Slight central striking softness is of little concern to the overall eye appeal.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1560

1893 $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-2 with light repunching above the 3 in the date. Liberty's chin is lightly die doubled. Lovely orange-red and navy-blue toning the borders of this sharply struck and thoroughly lustrous Gem. The 1893 is a much better date due to its low mintage, and is nearly unobtainable above the MS65 level.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1561

1893 $1 MS65 PCGS. This untoned and lustrous Gem has a sharp strike and unabraded fields. The cheek displays minor grazes. Among Philly issues, only the 1894 and the bag-saved 1899 have lower mintages. As of (2/10), PCGS and NGC combined have certified only six examples finer.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1562

1893-CC $1 XF45 ANACS. Apricot-tinged luster aids the eye appeal of this richly detailed semi-key Carson City dollar. The centers are lightly brought up, customary for the issue, but actual circulation wear is limited to the highpoints.(Registry values: P8, N1)

1563

1893-CC $1 AU58 PCGS. A low mintage date, at 677,000 pieces, the 1893-CC is the last Morgan dollar issue from the Carson City Mint. The nearly untoned surfaces of this near-Mint State specimen display strong delineation on the design features and retain a considerable amount of luster. None of the few marks are worthy of individual mention.(Registry values: P8, N208)

1564

1893-CC $1 MS62 NGC. Bold die clashing shows on small portions of both sides of this interesting coin, behind Liberty's cap and inside the right wreath, respectively. This piece is largely silver-white, with sprinkles of gold and amber near the rims. Abrasions are minor for the grade, and the eye appeal is considerable.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P8, N1793)

1565

1893-CC $1 MS63 NGC. The low mintage of the 1893-CC accounts for much of its scarcity, and it was apparently circulated to some degree at the time of issuance. This piece has exceptionally bright mint luster with fields that many would call prooflike. Each side is brilliant except for a thin ring of reddish patina over the rims. The strike is weakly defined in the centers, as often seen on this issue, and there are several abrasions and luster grazes that account for the grade.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1566

1893-CC $1 MS63 PCGS. The reverse of this silver-white Select piece, taken on its own, would approach a Prooflike designation, while the obverse shows little field-device contrast. Radiant cartwheel luster flows from both sides, however, adding to the already considerable appeal of this coin. The last CC-mint issue, and among the most in demand save for two.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1567

1893-CC $1 MS63 PCGS. Sharp design details, frosty silver luster, and brilliant silver surfaces are the hallmarks of this Select Mint State 1893-CC Morgan dollar. It is an attractive and highly appealing representative of the issue, and most desirable among Morgan collectors, and those with an interest in Western history.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1568

1893-CC $1 MS63 PCGS. One of the most popular Morgan dollar issues, the 1893-CC is the final issue from the famous Carson City Mint. All Morgans from that Mint are in demand, but the 1878-CC and 1893-CC are especially desirable as the first and last of their kind. This Select Mint State piece is fully brilliant with untoned, satiny silver surfaces.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1569

1893-CC $1 MS64 PCGS. The last-year Carson City Morgan dollar production was a measly 677,000 coins, and most of those survivors today suffer from bagmarks, other abrasions, or strike weakness that can vary from light to severe. This silver-white near-Gem has tinges of pinkish color that is extremely light, and there are only minor signs of contact, save for a single nick in the center of the eagle's breast. Radiant cartwheel luster completes an attractive package. PCGS has certified only 10 specimens finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1570

1893-O $1 MS64 NGC. The small mintage of 300,000 coins for this issue was occasioned by the August 1893 repeal of the Sherman Silver Purchase Act of 1890. This example shows just a glint of gold over primarily silver-white surfaces. The typical O-mint strike weakness shows on the centers of each side, but abrasions are minor and scattered, while accounting for the grade. An elusive issue so fine, and even more difficult in Gem grade. Census: 30 in 64, 3 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P8, N4719)

1571

1893-S $1 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .92 suggests Cleaning as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of a Fine specimen that has been polished. The surfaces overall are bright with a trace of charcoal patina around the devices. A few light to medium-sized handling marks are seen over each side.(Registry values: P10, N10)

1572

1893-S $1 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an VG specimen that has been polished and damaged.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: P10, N10)

1573

1893-S $1 Good 6 PCGS. An interesting wear pattern is apparent on each side. The left side of the obverse and corresponding area on the reverse rim show less definition, suggesting the coin was struck from dies that were slightly out of alignment. An interesting observation, but of more import on this coin are the original, light gray surfaces with a trimming of charcoal around the margins. A small planchet void on the jawline of Liberty and a milling mark on the nose of Liberty are the only marks of note.(Registry values: P10, N1)

1574

1893-S $1 Fine 12 PCGS. The surfaces of this key dollar are light gray with slightly darker accents surrounding the devices. The only demerits are a rim bump at 9 o'clock on the obverse and two planchet streaks around stars 1 and 2. Otherwise, the surfaces are evenly worn over the high points and evenly balanced in appearance from side to side.(Registry values: P10, N1)

1575

1893-S $1 Fine 12 PCGS. The surfaces are light, at times almost brilliant on each side, with only slight darkening around the devices. Each side shows even wear over the high points, and coupled with the uniformly light color, the coin has a well-balanced appearance from side to side. As expected, magnification will reveal a number of small abrasions, but none are noticeable to the unaided eye.(Registry values: P10, N1)

1576

1893-S $1 Fine 15 PCGS. Always in demand by collectors of this popular series. The 1893-S is avidly sought in all grades as Morgan dollars are pursued in all grade ranges. This piece has unusually bright surfaces. The fields are almost brilliant, while the devices have a bit of orange-tan patina with deeper charcoal color around the margins. Lightly abraded overall with a few more obvious marks concentrated in the centers.(Registry values: P10, N1)

1577

1893-S $1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Each side shows even wear over the high points and light gray-rose patina that deepens slightly around the margins. The surfaces are bright, as one would expect from a cleaned coin, but the toning helps subdue much of the brightness. Both obverse and reverse are free from any mentionable abrasions.(Registry values: P10, N1793)

1578

1893-S $1 VF20 PCGS. This key to the Morgan dollar series has an impressively low mintage to match its unavailability in all grades. This example has bright surfaces overall with a slight two-toned effect, the fields and recesses light gray with contrasting brilliantish-white accents over the high points. A number of small abrasions are scattered over each side but none are individually significant.(Registry values: P10, N1793)

1579

1893-S $1 VF35 PCGS. Autumn-gold and gunmetal-gray compete for territory across this key date Morgan dollar. Substantial design detail remains, and a few faint marks above GOD and beneath the left (facing) wing are of little consequence. The lowest mintage business strike issue. Encapsulated in a first generation holder.(Registry values: P10, N1793)

1580

1893-S $1 --Cleaned--ANACS. AU Details. Net XF40. Collectors with limited budgets are always on the look out for key date coins that will provide considerable detail at an affordable price, and this is one of those coins. The hallmark die scratch in the T of LIBERTY, present on all genuine 1893-S dollars, is clearly visible on this gray toned example.(Registry values: P10, N2998)

1581

1893-S $1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. There is far less evidence of a past cleaning than the caveat on the slab might imply, limited to a small patch on the reverse--making this a mighty appealing choice for many collectors seeking an XF Sharpness example of this popular key date. The surfaces have pretty silver-gray coloration with accents of hazel and gold, and abrasions are consistent with the Details grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P10, N2998)

1582

1893-S $1 AU50 NGC. The 1893-S Morgan is not only the lowest-mintage circulation strike issue in the series--assuming one discounts the 12,000 alleged business strikes of the 1895-P that never surfaced--but it is also the lowest-mintage S-mint, with an emission of 100,000 coins. That production figure is not far behind the 1894-P, with 110,000 pieces made, but the S mintmark on the 1893-S lends it extra cachet, a bit of Old West panache added to an already-attractive issue. All 100,000 coins appear to have been made from a single obverse die, one that shows a couple of tiny but conclusive diagnostics. Bill Fivaz's Counterfeit Detection Guide describes them this way:

"The conclusive diagnostic ... is a small (raised) die scratch running diagonally upward from the top left side of the vertical portion of the 'T' in LIBERTY. There are also two raised 'rabbit ear' die marks in the lower left foot of the 'R' in LIBERTY."

This is an appealing AU50 representative with wear largely confined to the high points, leaving considerable luster in mildly reflective fields which shine beneath layers of silver-gray, gold, and tan toning. Aside from a short line of reed marks on the chin and a handful of miscellaneous abrasions, the devices are largely clean.(Registry values: P10, N4719)

1583

1894 $1 VF20 PCGS. A pleasing mid-grade example of this popular low-mintage issue. Soft lilac-gray patina with gold undertones covers each side of this remarkably clean and well defined specimen.(Registry values: P8, N1)

1584

1894 $1 XF40 PCGS. CAC. With just 110,000 business strikes produced, the 1894 dollar has enduring popularity. This lightly worn, faintly lustrous piece has light blue-gray to peach color overall with splashes of deep sage at the back of Liberty's head.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P8, N1)

1585

1894 $1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. This untoned key date P-mint Morgan is dull from cleaning, and the remaining luster is slightly subdued. No consequential marks are present, and highpoint wear is moderate.(Registry values: P8, N1)

1586

1894 $1 --Cleaned--ANACS. AU Details, Net XF45. Medium golden-brown toning graces the borders of this moderately bright low mintage Philadelphia Morgan. A few minor facial marks and an obverse rim nick at 3:30 are of little import.(Registry values: P8, N1)

1587

1894 $1 AU58 NGC. CAC. The current sale provides a remarkable opportunity for several collectors to obtain an 1894 dollar, with 12 different examples ranging in grade from VF20 to MS64. This pleasing near-Mint example is the only AU58 coin in the sale, and it should garner considerable bidding activity. Both sides have nearly full luster with frosty surface. Light silver-gray surfaces host delicate peripheral gold toning.(Registry values: P8, N991)

1588

1894 $1 MS60 PCGS. This Mint State example offers much appeal, with sprinkles of cinnamon color over both sides but more prominent on the reverse. Full luster is present, and the grade is determined by a small patch of heavy scrapes in the reverse right field between the wing and wreath. Other abrasions are scattered and minor, but this piece is sure to pleasantly surprise its next owner.(Registry values: P8, N1793)

1589

1894 $1 MS61 NGC. One of the keys to the Morgan business strikes, the 1894 is in demand in all grades. This Mint State coin offers whitish-silver surfaces with tinges of gold and powder-gray around the rims. The luster is somewhat diffuse, and some moderate contact of Liberty's cheek helps determine the grade.(Registry values: P8, N1793)

1590

1894 $1 MS62 NGC. Radiant cartwheel luster proceeds from both sides of this silver-white coin, which features softly frosted, satiny surfaces. A few ticks and taps on Liberty's cheek and neck are the chief determinants of the grade, but the strike is well-executed, and much eye appeal is present on this key-date example.(Registry values: P8, N1793)

1591

1894 $1 MS63 PCGS. The mintage of 110,972 coins, second lowest among business strikes, reflects the repeal of the Sherman Silver Purchase Act of 1890 that occurred in August 1893 and the subsequent drawdown in Morgan dollar mintages. Smooth surfaces and radiant cartwheel luster characterize this lovely Select Mint State example of the 1894. A few minor abrasions on the cheek and neck account for the grade, but this coin would fit well into a mostly Gem set due to its high-end eye appeal.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1592

1894 $1 MS63 NGC. Fully brilliant silver surfaces exhibit faint gold toning along the left part of the reverse border, with the balance free of toning. The surfaces are excellent for the grade with only a few marks consistent with the Select Mint State assessment. Here is an excellent opportunity for the avid Morgan collector to acquire a desirable 1894 dollar, combining grade and market price.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1593

1894 $1 MS64 PCGS. Luster sweeps across this powerfully impressed and lightly abraded rare date dollar. A wisp of golden toning denies full brilliance. The 1894 has a mintage similar to that of the key date 1893-S, although the former is more available in AU and better grades.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1594

1894 $1 MS64 PCGS. A single blemish in the left obverse field is the reason that this piece had its grade limited to MS64. Housed in a green-label PCGS holder, this Choice Mint State piece is fully brilliant and untoned with bold design definition. PCGS has only certified 24 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1595

1894-O $1 MS63 PCGS. The appeal is decidedly high-end on this Select Mint State example, with silvery, softly frosted satin luster. A few abrasions on the cheek and the typical O-mint strike for this issue determine the grade, but the radiant cartwheels and untoned surfaces will prove alluring to many Morgan dollar aficionados.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1596

1894-O $1 MS64 PCGS. This fully brilliant near-Gem has slight weakness at the center of the obverse as usual, with stronger reverse details. This is a lovely example with only eight finer PCGS coins certified (2/10). The 1894-O is a scarce date, as are most from the mid 1890s, and it is high on the want list of most collectors.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1597

1894-O $1 MS64 NGC. This near-Gem example of the difficult and elusive 1894-O issue is blessed with several above-average characteristics. Chief among them is the radiant luster, definitely high-end. The surfaces are uniformly silver-white, and for this strike-challenged issue the present coin is again somewhat better than normal. Abrasions are scarcely worth mentioning. NGC has certified only five examples finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1598

1894-S $1 MS64 PCGS. A few wisps of light gold are the only color occurring on the highly lustrous surfaces of this adequately struck S-mint representative. Some minute marks preclude Gem status.(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1599

1894-S $1 MS65 NGC. When found in the higher Mint State grades, the 1894-S is generally a well-produced issue, with good strike and luster. The present Gem is one such, with radiant luster emanating from both sides. The obverse is silver-white with a tinge of gold, while the reverse is uniformly golden and prooflike. A few scattered marks account for the grade but are minor. Census: 40 in 65, 10 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1600

1894-S $1 MS63 Prooflike PCGS. Moderately reflective fields are largely pale silver-white with dots of milky toning. The frosted devices show a few scrapes and abrasions which account for the grade. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 28 in 63 Prooflike, 30 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N991)

1601

1895-O $1 AU55 NGC. Subtle peach peripheral elements yield to lustrous medium-gray on this challenging O-mint Morgan dollar. Both sides show a number of wispy marks but few deep abrasions.(Registry values: P9, N991)

1602

1895-O $1 AU55 NGC. High on want lists of Morgan dollar collectors, the 1895-O is seldom found finer than Choice AU. This brilliant example displays the usual subdued appearance seen on this issue, and each side has a peppering of small abrasions.(Registry values: P9, N991)

1603

1895-O $1 AU58 NGC. The 1895-O is rarely offered in mint condition, and when it is the surfaces are often dull and unattractive. For the savvy collector, an attractive high-end AU may be a better buy. There are significant portions of luster remaining on each side of this near-brilliant example. A bit of striking softness is apparent in the centers, as usually seen. The surfaces are remarkably free from abrasions, making this a coin to seriously consider.(Registry values: P9, N991)

1604

1895-O $1 AU58 NGC. Only 450,000 Morgan silver dollars were coined at the New Orleans Mint in 1895. While production values were generally low for this issue, the present coin is an attractive specimen, with only the slightest traces of wear on the high points of the design. The devices are well detailed for an 1895-O, as the date is noted for its poor strikes. The surfaces are lustrous, and free of distractions. Wayne Miller has noted that high-grade AU specimens of this date are often more attractive than Mint State examples.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P9, N991)

1605

1895-O $1 MS60 Prooflike NGC. This is a remarkable coin in an unusual grade. Series aficionados realize how elusive this issue is; Bowers notes that it alone appears to have been unrepresented in any of the great Treasury releases. The strike is only of middling quality on this example, but it is fully Mint State, with a quicksilver, low-contrast quality to the surfaces like many true proof Morgans. There are many small and scattered abrasions that constitute the grade, but they fail to dampen the high eye appeal. Census: 3 in 60 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P9, N4719)

1606

1895-S $1 XF40 NGC. Faint glimmers of luster enliven blue-gray surfaces that show glimpses of gold. Distinctly worn on the high points but with few overt marks and considerable detail in the protected areas.(Registry values: P8, N991)

1607

1895-S $1 MS64 NGC. This is an issue seldom seen at the Gem level, so an attractive near-Gem such as this piece will be prized by many collectors. Hints of prooflikeness appear on both sides, and few marks are present for the grade. Tinges of saffron and blue appear near the obverse rim under a loupe. NGC has certified 13 finer examples (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1608

1895-S $1 MS64 PCGS. The 1895-S is one of the key issues among San Francisco Mint Morgan dollars. Hints of light tan-gold color are visible under magnification on the lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem specimen. Well impressed except for minor softness in the obverse center. Light grazes preclude Gem status. PCGS has seen only 31 pieces finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P8, N2998)

1609

1895-S/S $1 MS62 PCGS. VAM-3. A Hot 50 Variety. The remains of an original tilted S are visible as a curved "flag" to the top left of the subsequent mintmark, with a curve inside the later punch. The satiny surfaces are untoned, save for a faint ring of gold around part of the reverse rim. A small patch of reeding marks in front of the chin helps determine the grade, along with minor abrasions scattered on the face and neck. The Hot 50 book by Jeff Oxman was reprinted in 2008.(Registry values: P8, N1793)

1610

1896 $1 MS67 NGC. The 1896 Morgan dollar is one of the most underappreciated condition rarities in the entire series. Almost 10 million of these coins were struck, and survivors are easily obtained in grades through MS65, but above that level they are elusive. This Superb Gem is fully lustrous with brilliant silver-white surfaces and sharp design details. Both sides are frosty and untoned. Census: 52 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1611

1896 $1 MS67 NGC. An exacting strike emboldens the design features of this Superb Gem, including the hair over Liberty's ear and the eagle's breast feathers. Whispers of light orange color make an occasional appearance on the obverse. Highly lustrous and impeccably preserved. Census: 52 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1612

1896 $1 MS66 Prooflike PCGS. Peach-gold toning is moderate in intensity and limited to the margins. Well struck aside from the claws. Nearly pristine save for one faint diagonal line on the cheek. Population: 14 in 66 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1613

1896 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Profoundly reflective and mildly contrasted, this Gem has light splashes of cloud-white toning over each side. Housed in a green label holder. PCGS has certified 11 finer Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N991)

1614

1896-S $1 MS61 ANACS. Both the obverse and the reverse are appreciably reflective, though not to the Prooflike level. Lightly frosted devices are softly struck with a handful of significant abrasions.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1615

1896-S $1 MS62 NGC. Light to medium cream-gray and chestnut toning enriches this scarce date silver dollar. The centers are incompletely brought up, but the scattered small marks are inconsequential for the MS62 level.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1616

1896-S $1 MS63 PCGS. CAC. The 1896-S is a difficult but not impossible Morgan dollar issue in this grade, but at the Gem level they are decidedly scarce, with a price to match. This MS63 coin might represent an excellent compromise, with lots of life emanating from vibrant silver-white surfaces that display a few grade-consistent abrasions.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1617

1896-S $1 MS64 PCGS. A trace of caramel-gold toning denies absolute brilliance, but this lustrous and boldly struck Choice Morgan dollar lacks the obtrusive bagmarks seen on so many examples of this much better date. The center of the mintmark is affected by contact, but the center of the cheek is smooth.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1618

1896-S $1 MS62 Prooflike PCGS. The 1896-S is an important condition rarity in any Mint State grade, and a seldom seen rarity in prooflike Mint State. This piece is fully brilliant with exceptional eye appeal. The surfaces are untoned, and the frosty devices contrast nicely with the mirrored fields. Population: 1 in 62 Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1619

1897 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. This Morgan dollar issue is plentiful in Mint State grades, even through the Gem level or finer. However, its availability in Deep Mirror Prooflike is quite the opposite. The date is a rarity in all prooflike grades. Housed in a green label PCGS holder, this example is brilliant and attractive with only slight marks on each side. Population: 24 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3, N1793)

1620

1897-O $1 MS61 PCGS. CAC. An occasional freckle of orange appears on this O-mint representative that displays nearly full luster and is well struck. A few small marks are noted on the obverse, yet a very appealing coin for the designated grade, an observation not lost on CAC.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1621

1897-O $1 MS61 NGC. Plentiful in circulated grades but difficult to locate in Mint State. Golden-orange fringes the margins of this appropriately struck O-mint representative. Marks on the cheek and neck limit the grade.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7, N991)

1622

1897-O $1 MS64 PCGS. The Bowers Guide Book on Morgan dollars succinctly calls the 1897-O issue a "cherrypicker's dream," usually due to deficiencies of strike and luster. This near-Gem example offers softly frosted luster over silver-white surfaces, and the luster is of the moderate cartwheel sort. Liberty's cheek is clean for the grade, and the strike over the ear and on the eagle's breast are a tad better than usually seen for the issue. All of these criteria add up to a coin that possesses much of the appeal of a Gem example, at a price that will be far more affordable. Population: 33 in 64, 13 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N4719)

1623

1897-S $1 MS66 PCGS. Bold cartwheel luster with patches of soft gold color at parts of the margins. Light gray-white toning elsewhere with a decidedly above-average strike. PCGS has graded just 22 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1624

1897-S $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. The fields offer unimprovable reflectivity, and the frosty devices exhibit notable cameo contrast. Precisely struck and attractively preserved. Census: 40 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1625

1897-S $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. Freckled orange-gold and sea-green visits the margins, but the remainder of this lustrous Gem is untoned. The centers show only minor inexactness. Certified in a former generation holder. Census: 40 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1626

1898 $1 MS67 NGC. With a large original mintage approaching 6 million pieces, the 1898 Morgan is readily available in all grades up to the MS65 level. At the Premium Gem level, the issue is scarce, and only about 40 coins have been certified at the Superb Gem level by NGC and PCGS combined (2/10). Intense luster and a solid strike endow this well preserved MS67. An occasional wisp of light tan color shows under magnification.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2, N4719)

1627

1898 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Strikingly mirrored with touches of peach toning at the centers of surfaces that are otherwise largely silver-white. Sharply struck with just a few tiny marks and luster breaks on Liberty's portrait. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 64 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1628

1898-O $1 MS67 PCGS. CAC. Excellent luster endows this Superb Gem. Untoned, sharply struck, and impeccably preserved.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1629

1898-O $1 MS67 PCGS. This magnificent Superb Gem is nearly brilliant, but exhibits a wisp of golden toning on each side. Crisply struck and thoroughly lustrous with an essentially pristine reverse and only trivial obverse grazes.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1630

1898-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Hints of peach and golden color grace the peripheries, with the latter color bold at the left and right reverse. Well-defined overall, if a touch soft at the hair over the ear, with beautiful luster.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1631

1898-S $1 MS65 PCGS. A whisper or two of light gold color visits each side of this Gem S-mint representative. Lustrous surfaces are generally well defined and devoid of significant marks.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1632

1898-S $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. Golden-brown toning frequents portions of the margins, but this flashy Morgan dollar is otherwise brilliant. Nicely struck and impressively unabraded aside from a few wispy marks on the upper reverse field. Population: 39 in 64 Prooflike, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N991)

1633

1898-S $1 MS63 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Though scattered abrasions appear on the frosted devices and in the fields, this coin's fathomless mirrors fortify the eye appeal. Lightly gold-toned overall and housed in a green label holder. Population: 33 in 63 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 40 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N991)

1634

1899 $1 MS66 PCGS. Lustrous surfaces display whispers of gold at the obverse periphery and blushes of steel-gray on the reverse. Nicely struck and revealing no more than a few minor grade-consistent marks.(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1635

1899 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Encased in a green label holder. This brilliant Gem has a crisp strike and nicely reflective fields. Marks are nearly absent save for minor contact near the chin. The 1899 has an unusually low mintage, less than the production of the 1893 dollar. Population: 51 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N1793)

1636

1899-O $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Decisively detailed and virtually black-and-white in appearance, this Gem offers stunning eye appeal for an O-mint dollar. Liberty's portrait shows only a couple of tiny marks on the cheek. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 42 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1637

1899-S $1 MS65 NGC. Dappled peach-red, sun-gold, and gunmetal-blue embrace this lustrous and crisply struck Gem. Splendidly devoid of relevant abrasions. The mintage of the 1899-S is approximately eight times greater than the 1899, yet it is the San Francisco issue that is rarer at the MS65 level.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1638

1899-S $1 MS66 PCGS. This brilliant Premium Gem has satiny silver surfaces with no toning on either side. The fields are reflective, equivalent to the old time "semi-prooflike" description that is seldom if ever used today. Both sides have slight central weakness as usual, with the remaining details boldly defined. PCGS has only certified eight finer pieces (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1639

1899-S $1 MS65 Prooflike PCGS. A minimally contrasted but moderately reflective Prooflike Gem from a challenging San Francisco issue. Faint gray toning overall has a suggestion of gold. Encased in a green label holder. Population: 35 in 65 Prooflike, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1640

1900-O $1 MS67 NGC. A frosty Superb Gem, this 1900-O Morgan dollar is seldom seen so fine. In fact, NGC and PCGS have graded less than 100 of these in MS67, with none finer. This piece has frosty silver luster, pristine surfaces, sharp design details, and brilliant, untoned surfaces. Census: 65 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N2998)

1641

1900-O $1 Doubled Stars MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. VAM-15. A Top 100 Variety. The two stars to the right of the date show distinct die doubling. A remarkably reflective and top-notch example of this popular and important variety, the single finest Deep Mirror Prooflike representative known to PCGS (1/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1642

1900-O/CC $1 MS64 PCGS. VAM-12. A Top 100 Variety. The bold VAM-12 1900-O/CC variant, offered here as an immensely lustrous near-Gem. Light golden-tan peripheral overtones grace the obverse, while the rest of the well struck piece is near-brilliant.(Registry values: P5, N991)

1643

1900-O/CC $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-8A. A Top 100 Variety. Die rust near the overmintmark confirms the middle die state of this popular VAM. Dappled walnut-brown, rose-red, and aquamarine bathes the peripheries of this lustrous, gorgeously preserved, and boldly struck Gem. A keeper for the advanced Morgan dollar collector.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1644

1900-O/CC $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-12, Top 100 Variety. The outline of the partially effaced Carson City mintmark is obvious on each side the prominent O mintmark. A die crack running through the cap to the field under M of UNUM. Bright luster exudes from untoned surfaces that exhibit well struck design features. A few light marks may well preclude an even finer grade. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1645

1900-O/CC $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-8. A Top 100 Variety. Light honey toning graces this lustrous and exactingly struck overmintmarked Gem. The portrait is beautifully smooth, and the fields show only faint abrasions.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1646

1900-O/CC $1 MS65 PCGS. VAM-8. A Top 100 Variety. One of the stronger overmintmark variants, offered here as a lustrous and lightly gold-toned Gem. Well-defined and housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1647

1900-S $1 MS65 PCGS. An attractive Gem with creamy silver-white luster accented in peripheral canary-yellow. Only a few small ticks are visible on Liberty's portrait. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1648

1900-S $1 MS66 PCGS. Bright luster envelops both sides of this Premium Gem each of which displays barely discernible speckles of orange patina. A well executed strike imparts strong definition to the design motifs and close examination reveals no mentionable marks. Population: 91 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1649

1901 $1 MS61 ANACS. Brilliant and fully lustrous with bright silver surfaces. This is a pleasing example of this conditionally challenging date with minimal surface abrasions. Like many of its peers, this is a late die state from a well worn reverse die.(Registry values: P9, N1793)

1650

1901 $1 MS62 PCGS. Although struck from the same facility and only two years later than the 1899, there is a tremendous discrepancy in high grade survival rates for the two issues. The low mintage 1899 is plentiful in MS64, while the 1901 is very rare in such quality. In fact, any Uncirculated 1901 silver dollar is desirable. This is a lustrous, sharply struck, and lightly toned caramel-gold and steel-blue example that has surprisingly few marks.(Registry values: P9, N2998)

1651

1901-S $1 MS64 PCGS. Soft peach and pink accents visit the silver-gray toning that suffuses each side of this well struck near-Gem. Just a few tiny marks separate it from an even finer designation.(Registry values: P6, N991)

1652

1901-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Faint golden toning adorns this lustrous and attractively preserved Gem. A good strike despite minor inexactness on the hair above the ear. As is the case with other S-mint issues from the first decade of the 19th century, the 1901-S is seldom encountered at the MS65 level.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1653

1902 $1 MS67 NGC. This splendid Superb Gem has full silver brilliance and delicate peripheral gold toning on the obverse. The reverse is deeply toned in blue, turquoise, gold, and violet, with full, frosty underlying luster. This attractive piece is tied for the finest that NGC and PCGS have graded. Census: 14 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1654

1902-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Delicate butter-gold patina enriches this lustrous and magnificently unabraded Gem. The strike is above average, and the eye appeal is exceptional.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1655

1902-S $1 MS66 PCGS. Aside from trifling softness at the highest design elements, this is a generally well-defined Premium Gem example of its challenging 20th century Morgan dollar issue. Shining surfaces are pale pearl-gray overall with just a suggestion of pink visible in the fields. The sharp-eyed Morgan dollar enthusiast will want to take a look at this piece. Population: 29 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N2998)

1656

1902-S $1 MS64 Prooflike NGC. Here is a splendid 1902-S dollar with delicate gold toning around brilliant silver surfaces. Both sides are fully lustrous with mirrored fields and satiny devices, creating a splendid cameo appearance. Prooflike 1902-S Morgan dollars are seldom encountered. Census: 3 in 64 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6, N1793)

1657

1903 $1 MS67 NGC. Brilliant surfaces exhibit well struck design motifs, including the hair at Liberty's ear. A couple of minute marks at the temple do not distract. Census: 85 in 67, 2 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2, N2998)

1658

1903 $1 MS66 Prooflike PCGS. Faint golden toning graces the margins of this Prooflike Premium Gem, which is near-brilliant otherwise. Well-defined and carefully preserved. Population: 6 in 66 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2, N1793)

1659

1903-O $1 MS66 PCGS. This magnificent New Orleans Premium Gem has faint chestnut toning, booming cartwheel luster, and an absence of perceptible bagmarks. Trivial inexactness of strike at the centers may be all that limits the grade.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1660

1903-O $1 MS67 NGC. A remarkable Superb Gem, this 1903-O has frosty silver luster with brilliant silver surfaces and only a trace of pale champagne toning. The 1903-O is well known as a one time rarity that was found in large quantities nearly 50 years ago when the Treasury holdings were disbursed. Census: 33 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N2998)

1661

1903-O $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Nearly brilliant save for splashes of crimson-orange toning on the inner edge of the eagle's left wing and in a patch just above it. This boldly mirrored Choice coin is housed in a green label holder. Population: 31 in 64 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N991)

1662

1903-S $1 MS63 NGC. This 1903-S dollar has the two-olive reverse found on several VAM varieties of this issue. This frosty Mint State piece has ivory-silver luster with hints of gold toning along the borders. Here is a lovely piece, and an elusive date in higher Mint State grades.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1663

1903-S $1 MS66 NGC. The 1903-S is a difficult S-mint issue from late in the series, an elusive coin in all Mint State levels. The mintage was measly to begin with, at 1.24 million coins, and hundreds of thousands were likely melted under the Pittman Act meltings after 1918 and in later events. This Premium Gem NGC coin is one of only eight so graded, with one finer, while PCGS has certified 37 in MS66 and three pieces finer (2/10). A casual glance confirms the pristine quality of the surfaces, and a loupe reveals no surprises. The silver-white coloration and radiant luster make this a standout piece, worthy of strong bidding. The strike is excellent. Census: 8 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N4719)

1664

1904 $1 MS65 PCGS. Brilliant and lustrous with a good strike and the occasional minor errant mark. The 1904 is fairly plentiful in MS62 through MS64, but suddenly emerges as an important conditional rarity at the MS65 level. Apparently, a few Uncirculated bags survived the Pittman Act melt but were poorly handled.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P5, N2998)

1665

1904 $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. CAC. The 1904 is seldom located with prooflike fields, and when encountered, such coins tend to be dull and lack contrast. This piece is hardly dull. In fact, it is bright and sparkles with prooflike reflectivity and there is even an ever-so-slight contrast on each side. Fully struck, the coin is lightly toned and has no mentionable abrasions. Population: 15 in 64 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).
Ex: Clarke Marie Collection, Part One (Heritage, 9/2004), lot 8915, which realized $4,830.(Registry values: P5, N1793)

1666

1904-O $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. Outstanding reflectivity for this final New Orleans dollar issue. Above-average striking definition complements the watery reflectivity of the peach-kissed fields. PCGS has graded 20 finer Deep Mirror Prooflike pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1667

1904-S $1 MS63 NGC. Late in the Morgan dollar series, the San Francisco Mint produced 2.3 million silver dollars in 1904, with many or most entering circulation. Mint State coins are elusive. This desirable Select Mint State representative has satin ivory luster with splashes of gold near portions of the border on each side.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7, N1793)

1668

1904-S $1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Lovely golden-brown toning graces the borders of this lustrous and nicely struck Choice better date dollar. Traces of powder-blue appear near the rims, but the fields and devices are essentially brilliant. The reverse is splendidly preserved, while the cheek has a few faint grazes.
Ex: Jack Lee Estate (Heritage, 10/2008), lot 1506, which realized $4,456.25.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1669

1904-S $1 MS64 PCGS. Silver dollars circulated in the West, which had a tradition of hard money prior to World War I. This tradition explains why later S-mint issues are elusive in Mint State: they were welcome in commerce. The present lustrous near-Gem has delicate honey patina and a nice strike.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1670

1904-S $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. Here is an incredible opportunity for the highly specialized Morgan dollar collector. Housed in a green label holder, this 1904-S has fully mirrored fields and satiny devices. Both sides have brilliant silver surfaces with a few small splashes of golden-brown toning. Population: 9 in 64 Prooflike, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1671

1921 $1 MS65 Prooflike NGC. The surfaces display just a hint of pale yellow patina, but otherwise present as brilliant. The strike is full, as seen by examining the wreath on the reverse, and the fields are nicely reflective and well-balanced from side to side. Census: 59 in 65 Prooflike, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N991)

1672

1921 $1 MS66 Prooflike PCGS. The Philadelphia Mint struck more than 44 million Morgan dollars in 1921, yet surprisingly few have been certified as Prooflike by PCGS. And among those, most grade between MS62 and MS64. The present flashy Premium Gem has a razor-sharp strike, light gray-green toning, and outstanding preservation. In a green label holder. Population: 1 in 66 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1, N1793)

1673

1921 $1 MS65 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. While most 1921 Morgan dollars are poorly struck, the present Gem exhibits razor-sharp definition; the hair at Liberty's ear, for example, is fully detailed. Additionally, the deeply mirrored fields yield relatively strong contrast with the design elements. A few grade-consistent marks are undisturbing. Census: 8 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1, N4719)

1674

1921-S $1 MS66 ★ NGC. Excellent striking definition for the final San Francisco Morgan dollar issue, particularly on the often-weak hair over Liberty's ear. Frosty silver-white surfaces show only a few scattered luster grazes and no individually mentionable marks. NGC has graded just one numerically finer representative (2/10).(Registry values: P4, N4719)

1675

1921-S $1 MS66 NGC. This is one of the most important Morgan dollars in the present offering, and it is essentially unavailable any finer, as NGC has only certified one better piece, and MS66 is the top grade for PCGS. This Premium Gem is satiny and fully lustrous with brilliant silver surfaces and no toning. The obverse is prooflike and the reverse is slightly reflective. Census: 53 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P4, N4719)

Proof Morgan Dollars

1676

1878 8TF $1 PR65 NGC. VAM-14.3. The 1878 8 Tail Feather proof Morgan comes from an estimated mintage of 500 pieces. Whispers of cobalt-blue, lavender, and gold patina visit the obverse of this stunning Gem, ceding to bluish and gold hues on the reverse. A powerful strike imparts strong definition to the design elements, enhancing even more the coin's eye appeal. Nicely preserved, including remarkable smoothness on the cheek and neck. Census: 19 in 65, 9 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1677

1878 8TF $1 PR66 Cameo NGC. The proof strikings first made were of course of the first reverse of the new design, the 8 Tailfeathers coins, produced to the extent of an estimated 500 coins. Most of the demand for the issue comes from type collectors, as the first in the series. This Premium Gem Cameo coin boasts strong contrast over quicksilver surfaces that show just a hint of gold on each side. Census: 12 in 66, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1678

1879 $1 PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. A brilliant specimen that approaches a Deep Cameo designation, since the glassy fields exhibit exemplary contrast with the icy and decisively struck devices. The eye appeal is outstanding for the designated grade. Cameos are surprisingly scarce for the proof 1879, and PCGS has certified only a single example as Deep Cameo. Population: 12 in 64 Cameo, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1679

1879 $1 PR65 Cameo NGC. The contrast between the fields and devices is excellent, and is one of the important characteristics of this Gem proof. The fields are deeply mirrored and free of the usual hairlines that so often plague these issues. Similarly, the devices are pristine with frosty silver luster, and the entire presentation resides in a frame of lovely peripheral iridescence. Census: 8 in 65 Cameo, 35 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1680

1881 $1 PR67 Cameo NGC. Excellent strike and eye appeal for this popular issue, with a small proof mintage of 984 pieces. For some unknown reason there seem to be a comparatively high number of 1881 proof dollars that have survived. However, at the PR67 Cameo level there are precious few. Delicate champagne and gold peripheral patina is seen on each side. The mirrored fields shine brightly and show deep reflectivity and the frosted devices on the central devices, giving the coin a strong cameo effect. Only one die pair is known to have been used on proofs of this year. Census: 12 in 67 Cameo, 8 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1681

1882 $1 PR62 PCGS. A razor-sharp specimen with substantial cameo contrast on each side, although PCGS omits any such designation. A loupe reveals light field hairlines. Brilliant save for a solitary pinpoint speck on Liberty's upper jaw.(Registry values: N1793)

1682

1882 $1 PR66 NGC. Splashes of cobalt-blue and purple toning gravitate to the margins of this Premium Gem proof, leaving the central areas essentially untoned. A solid strike results in complete delineation on the design motifs, all of which are highlighted by the mirrored fields when the coin is tilted slightly beneath a light source. Both faces have been well cared for. Census: 30 in 66, 28 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1683

1882 $1 PR67 NGC. A well-produced proof dollar that would make a perfect high-grade type coin. The fields are deeply mirrored, and the devices display light mint frost that gives each side a moderate cameo effect, though curiously, NGC does not acknowledge this. Lightly toned and nearly perfect. Census: 21 in 67, 7 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1684

1882 $1 PR66 Deep Cameo PCGS. The dates usually associated with a proof type coin for the Morgan series are 1896, 1897, and 1898. The 1881 and 1882 proofs were just as well made, but not as many survived the intervening 15 years because of cleaning and other forms of attrition. This is a brilliant example. The fields are deeply reflective and the mirrored flash sets up a "black" background against the thick whiteness of the frosted devices. We do not see any post-striking impairments. Close examination with a glass will show a couple of tiny planchet flakes out of the reverse fields, but these are really microscopic and not discernable to the unaided eye. Population: 4 in 66 Deep Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

1685

1884 $1 PR66 Cameo NGC. Wonderfully preserved with just a hint of rose-gray and golden patina seen at the margins. The fragile fields are deeply reflective and there is a significant amount of frost on the devices which creates a strong cameo contrast on each side. Census: 11 in 66 Cameo, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1686

1886 $1 PR66 NGC. The Morgan dollar saw a production of 886 proofs in 1886. Both sides of this Premium Gem proof display relatively strong field-device contrast, with each showing nearly imperceptible peripheral gold color. A powerful strike leaves crisp delineation on the design elements. Some minute flecks are visible on the lower obverse and reverse. Census: 25 in 66, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1687

1886 $1 PR66 Cameo NGC. VAM-15. The 18 in the date is lightly repunched, and the second 8 has a small dash beneath it. A fully struck and essentially brilliant Premium Gem that has flawless surfaces and noticeable cameo contrast. One of only 886 proofs struck. Census: 6 in 66 Cameo, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1688

1887 $1 PR61 NGC. Decent field-motif contrast is apparent on untoned surfaces with exquisitely impressed devices. Wispy handling marks are not all that bad. Quite nice for the designated numerical grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1689

1888 $1 PR65 Cameo PCGS. Ex: JFS Collection. Breen-5600, described by him as "very rare." It was circa 1888 that the quality of proof coins reached a low level, leading Harlan P. Smith to make a formal complaint about this quality. As a rule, proof coins from this period are not nearly as nice as those of earlier years, but the blazing eye appeal of this specimen marks it as an outstanding exception. Consider this to be an excellent opportunity as it may be a long wait before a similar example appears on the market.
This Gem displays rich gold toning toward the borders and lighter champagne at the centers. The design features are quite sharp, especially at the centers, although a few hair strands over the ear are merged together. Bold contrast completes this Cameo coin. Population: 5 in 65 Cameo, 2 finer (2/10).
Ex: Heritage (1/2005), lot 11966; JFS Collection (Heritage, 1/2006), lot 7047.(Registry values: N4719)

1690

1889 $1 PR64 Cameo PCGS. A splendid Choice Cameo proof, this 1889 Morgan has fully brilliant silver surfaces with a trace of pale champagne toning near the borders. A couple tiny lines on the obverse motif prevent a higher grade. The devices are fully lustrous and satiny while the fields are deeply mirrored.(Registry values: N2998)

1691

1891 $1 PR65 NGC. The obverse of this Gem proof has splashes of gold, blue, and violet toning over the silver surface, while the reverse deeper golden-brown toning. While cameo contrast is evident on each side, the depth of toning has prevented an NGC Cameo designation. Census: 20 in 65, 50 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1692

1892 $1 PR63 PCGS. The proof mintage was overly large for this year owing to the exceptional demand for 1892 silver proof sets (David Bowers, 2006). Whispers of light tan color show around the peripheries of this Select specimen, and the sharply defined design motifs stand out amidst the mirrored fields when the coin is rotated slightly under a light source. Minor handling marks define the grade; nevertheless, very nice overall eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

1693

1894 $1 PR67 Cameo NGC. While the 1895 is the most prominent example of a business strike Morgan dollar's rarity influencing proof prices, it is hardly alone in that respect. The tiny mintage of only 110,000 Philadelphia business strikes in 1894 exerts constant extra pressure on attractive proof examples of that year. Here is particularly attractive specimen with excellent field-device contrast, brilliantly mirrored silver-white fields, considerable mint frost on the devices, and no appreciable patina. A boldly impressed representative of this highly elusive and desirable issue. Among Cameo examples, NGC has graded just eight numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1694

1897 $1 PR68 Cameo NGC. Of the two dies used to strike proof 1897 dollars, this one does not show repunching on the 18 in the date. But that is not the reason a collector would be interested in this coin. It is the phenomenal quality this piece represents that sells itself to the many interested buyers of high quality proof Morgans. For a three-year period from 1896 through 1898, quality reached its peak in the production of proof coinage. And that includes Morgan dollars. This is a stunning example. The coin is brilliant and the fields are deeply reflective with a significant amount of mint frost over the devices that provides cameo contrast. We just do not see any flaws on either side of this magnificent proof. Census: 8 in 68 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N7079)

1695

1898 $1 PR61 NGC. Medium-gray mirrors show a light canary-gold cast. Though numerous hairlines run through the fields, the eye appeal of this proof is far better than the grade might suggest.(Registry values: N1793)

1696

1899 $1 PR66 Cameo NGC. Uncommonly well preserved for the issue as well as the series, this boldly defined Gem is also noteworthy for the appreciable cameo contrast between the fields and devices. Warm olive-gold patina overlays both sides and yields to near-brilliance in the center of the reverse. There is a hint of copper iridescence in the right obverse field, but distracting hairlines and contact marks are nonexistent. Census: 10 in 66 Cameo, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1697

1899 $1 PR68 Cameo NGC. An untoned Superb Gem whose luminous devices contrast favorably with the darkly mirrored fields. Post-strike contact is virtually absent, limited to a couple of nearly imperceptible lines in the right obverse field. The strike is full, even in areas sometimes found weak, such as the hair above the ear, the breast feathers, the claws, and the leaves opposite the wreath bow. A scant 846 proofs were struck, a lower mintage than the famous proof 1895. A remarkable 19th century proof type coin that would be the highlight of many an advanced collection. Census: 8 in 68 Cameo, 1 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N7079)

1698

1900 $1 PR63 NGC. Hints of light tan color occur at the margins of this razor-sharp Select proof. Some faint hairlines limit the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1699

1900 $1 PR65 NGC. Glints of pinkish-gold and aqua appear under a light in the deep silver-gray patination of this Gem coin, one of only 912 proof Morgan dollars struck for the year. Only the most minor signs of contact appear on either side. A popular date in this widely collected series. Census: 32 in 65, 34 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1700

1900 $1 PR66 NGC. CAC. A number of 1900 proof Morgan dollars have survived from the original mintage of 912 pieces, especially through the near-Gem level. Gems and Premium Gems are scarce, however, and finer coins are seen only infrequently. Splashes of reddish-brown patina concentrate at the margins of this PR66 example and are joined by cobalt-blue at the reverse borders. Sharply defined and remarkably smooth, including Liberty's cheek and neck. Census: 19 in 66, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1701

1900 $1 PR66 Cameo NGC. Both sides of this Premium Gem proof are untoned, and each displays pleasing field-device contrast. An exacting strike leaves exquisite delineation on the design features, which is often inadequate on 1900 proof dollars. The surfaces are smooth and devoid of mentionable marks. Census: 14 in 66 Cameo, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1702

1902 $1 PR64 PCGS. CAC. Delicate golden-brown and iridescent toning on both sides of this Choice proof adds to its overall eye appeal. Faint hairlines and contact marks prevent a higher grade. The obverse has a scattering of original lint marks, especially around the date elements.(Registry values: N2998)

1703

1902 $1 PR67 NGC. Exquisite accents of ocean-blue, orange, and sun-gold embrace this Superb Gem proof type coin. The strike is complete aside from inconsequential inexactness on the breast feathers and the hair above the ear. The fields are essentially devoid of hairlines, and the eye appeal is attractive. Unlike their 19th century counterparts, 1902 proofs were produced without significant cameo contrast, and none have been certified by either major service as Deep Cameo or Ultra Cameo. A meager 777 proofs were struck. Census: 11 in 67, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1704

1903 $1 PR65 NGC. The deeply mirrored fields of this Gem proof yield little contrast with the devices, as is the case with the majority of the issue. Apparently, the dies were polished in the motif areas as well as in the fields. Splashes of cobalt-blue and gold-orange are more extensive and deeper on the obverse. Sharply struck and nicely preserved.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1705

1904 $1 PR62 PCGS. CAC. Faint chestnut-brown toning visits this otherwise brilliant specimen. The reverse exhibits cameo contrast, as do Liberty's hair and cap. The centers show only minor incompleteness of strike. Just 650 proofs were struck.(Registry values: N1793)

Peace Dollars

1706

1921 $1 MS65 PCGS. The obverse margins have golden overtones, but the rest of this coin is pale silver-gray and frosty. Softly struck but strongly appealing for this first-year issue.(Registry values: N1793)

1707

1921 $1 MS65 PCGS. A veneer of soft golden-tan patina is is slightly deeper on the obverse of this lustrous Gem. Generally well struck on the design features. A vertical flan mark shows near Liberty's ear.(Registry values: N1793)

1708

1921 $1 MS65 PCGS. Tan-gold toning endows this unmarked and lustrous first year example. The central strike is bold for the high relief date, although incomplete as always except for the very rare proofs. Gem 1921 Peace dollars are as inexpensive now as they have been in many years.(Registry values: N1793)

1709

1921 $1 MS65 PCGS. A satiny and magnificently preserved Gem draped in rich cream-gray and caramel-gold toning. The centers show the indistinctness characteristic of this single year high relief subtype.(Registry values: N1793)

1710

1921 $1 MS65 PCGS. Caramel-gold toning graces this lustrous and lightly abraded introductory year Peace dollar. The strike is above average at the centers, and the scattered minor grazes are of little import.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1711

1922-D $1 MS67 NGC. This fully brilliant Superb Gem has exceptional eye appeal that results from brilliant and satiny silver surfaces and sharp design definition. Like many pieces in the JTR Collection, this example is tied for the finest that has ever been certified. Census: 14 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N7079)

1712

1922-S $1 MS65 PCGS. A well-defined coin with delightful silver-white luster. Uncommonly appealing for this high-mintage issue that is nonetheless a rarity any finer. PCGS has graded just six superior pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1713

1922-S $1 MS66 NGC. This amazing Premium Gem has fully frosty silver luster and bold design definition. Both sides are brilliant and untoned with pristine surfaces. Light die polishing lines on the reverse lead to faint reflectivity on that side. Rarely does a Premium Gem of the 1922-S Peace dollar appear in the numismatic market place. Census: 12 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1714

1923-D $1 MS65 NGC. The mint luster is bright and frosted with occasional golden patina over each side. The striking details are strong throughout, and there are minimal peripheral die cracks on this usually heavily cracked issue.(Registry values: N991)

1715

1923-S $1 MS65 ANACS. Strong luster with broad gold-orange elements and additional peripheral gunmetal-blue and turquoise attributes. Well-defined with subtly frosty qualities, and housed in a small-format holder.(Registry values: N2998)

1716

1924 $1 MS67 NGC. An amazing 1924 Peace dollar with only a few peers, and just two finer pieces that have ever been certified, one at NGC and the other at PCGS. This Superb Gem is fully brilliant with frosty silver luster and a single small splash of rose toning on the reverse.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1717

1924-S $1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Light walnut-tan toning adorns this crisply struck Choice better date dollar. The obverse is satiny, while the reverse provides dazzling cartwheel sheen. The 1924-S is much more elusive than its Philadelphia counterpart from the same year.(Registry values: N991)

1718

1924-S $1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Beautifully toned in subtle shades of olive-gray and caramel-gold. Lustrous and well struck with remarkably smooth fields and only a couple of reportable marks, both concealed beneath the toning on Liberty's jaw.(Registry values: N991)

1719

1924-S $1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Frosty silver-white at its base with whispers of cloud-white patina that turn to cream in the fields. An appealing near-Gem that shows just a few small abrasions on Liberty's portrait.(Registry values: N991)

1720

1924-S $1 MS64 NGC. Excellent luster shows through the thin veil of golden-tan patina. Sharply struck with a few marks that preclude Gem status. A difficult issue to locate any finer.(Registry values: N991)

1721

1924-S $1 MS65 NGC. CAC. The 1924-S is a major condition rarity that is nearly impossible to locate any finer. NGC and PCGS have combined to grade a mere six finer examples of the date. Both sides feature sharp design details, satiny silver luster, and splashes of light gold and iridescent toning. Census: 64 in 65, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1722

1925 $1 MS67 NGC. Butter-gold and powder-blue toning adorns this thoroughly lustrous and attractively preserved high grade silver dollar. The strike is intricate aside from the tops of the TY in LIBERTY. The 1925 has a mintage that exceeds 10 million pieces, but surprisingly few examples remain at the MS67 level. Census: 55 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1723

1925 $1 MS67 PCGS. A magnificently preserved Superb Gem that boasts scintillating luster and a decisive strike. Light sun-gold toning graces both sides. The 1925 is readily available in bagmarked Mint State, but examples of the present extraordinary quality are rare. Population: 69 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2007), lot 7525, which realized $3,737.50.(Registry values: N2998)

1724

1926-S $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Dappled green, gold, and blue hues visit the obverse, though that side's essential silver-white character carries through, as it does on the lustrous and minimally toned reverse. Amazing eye appeal.(Registry values: N991)

1725

1927 $1 MS65 NGC. This satiny Gem has fully brilliant silver surfaces with faint champagne toning on each side. A few tiny blemishes prevent a higher grade. While NGC and PCGS have only graded seven finer pieces, the present Gem provides a good combination of market price and quality. It should bring a price commensurate with its overall appearance.(Registry values: N1793)

1726

1927-S $1 MS64 PCGS. Well-defined with frosty luster at both the minimally toned centers and the blue and gold borders. Liberty's cheek is clean, but an arcing abrasion at the lower left obverse precludes a finer designation.(Registry values: N991)

1727

1928 $1 MS64 ANACS. Strong silver-white luster dominates the centers, though the obverse has fire-orange and green-gold elements around the edges. Well struck with few marks of any significance. Housed in a small-format holder.(Registry values: N991)

1728

1928 $1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. A solidly struck and shining silver-white example of this ever-popular Peace dollar key. Just a few small abrasions, such as a wispy flaw to the left of Liberty's lips, keep this near-Gem from an even finer grade.(Registry values: N991)

1729

1928 $1 MS64 PCGS. Ebullient luster endows both sides of this near-Gem, each of which exhibits sharply struck design elements. An occasional wisp of gold color occurs on the obverse. A few unobtrusive marks barely prevent Gem status.(Registry values: N991)

1730

1928 $1 MS65 NGC. The 1928 has the lowest mintage in the Peace dollar series with only 360,649 pieces struck and examples of this issue have always been in great demand by collectors. This problem-free Gem has light ivory-gray toned surfaces with the usual satiny mint luster. The striking details are complete, but as usual appear to be lightly impressed into the coin; this is especially evident when compared to, say, a 1922 or 1923.(Registry values: N2998)

1731

1928-S $1 MS64 NGC. CAC. Brightly lustrous with glints of gold hovering near the edges of the otherwise silver-white surfaces. A well struck example of this popular issue, famously elusive any finer.(Registry values: N991)

1732

1928-S $1 MS64 PCGS. Dappled light gray patination with subtle gold undertones resides on the lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem. This well struck piece reveals a few minute grade-defining reverse marks. A difficult issue to acquire any finer.(Registry values: N991)

1733

1934 $1 MS66 NGC. Potent luster dominates this brilliant and beautifully smooth Premium Gem. The mintage is less than 1 million pieces, which may explain the rarity of high grade examples. Census: 27 in 66, 5 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1734

1934-S $1 MS61 NGC. Bright silver-white with amazing eye appeal for a "mere" MS61 coin. Close inspection reveals the numerous wispy abrasions which contribute to the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1735

1934-S $1 MS62 NGC. The 1934-S is the key date of the series in grades between AU50 and MS64. Apparently, most of the mintage entered West Coast circulation, since during the Great Depression there was little interest in a silver dollar with a mintage above 1 million pieces. This lustrous example has light honey-gold toning, an unmarked appearance, and a pleasing strike. The eye appeal exceeds the MS62 level, and bidder interest is certain to be substantial.(Registry values: N1793)

1736

1934-S $1 MS63 PCGS. Once considered one of just two key dates along with the 1928, the 1934-S is a rarity in a series with so many conditionally elusive coins. This Select Mint State piece has speckled golden-brown and iridescent toning on both sides. This grade is a popular choice with collectors on a budget.(Registry values: N1793)

1737

1934-S $1 MS63 PCGS. Even though other Peace dollar issues are rarer in Gem condition or as strike rarities, the 1934-S still holds center stage as the preeminent series-rarity. This brilliant example has sparkling, satiny mint luster and is sharply struck with minimal abrasions for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1738

1934-S $1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. The 1934-S Peace dollar is highly desirable in any Mint State category. Ebullient luster endows the essentially untoned surfaces of this near-Gem and a well directed strike leaves relatively strong definition on the design features. Minor grazes preclude the attainment of Gem status.(Registry values: N2998)

1739

1934-S $1 MS64 PCGS. This sharply detailed 1934-S has a full quota of frosty silver luster beneath deep gold and iridescent toning on both sides. Although other issues are rarer in high grade, the 1928 and 1934-S Peace dollars are considered the two key dates, elusive in all grades.(Registry values: N2998)

1740

1935 $1 MS67 NGC. Both sides of this Superb Gem 1935 Peace dollar are fully brilliant and untoned. The strike is sharp with full hair details at the center of the obverse and sharp feather details at the center of the reverse. The frosty surfaces are pristine, with nary a mark of consequence. Here is an incredible piece with extraordinary aesthetic appeal. It is tied with three others for the finest that NGC has certified (2/10), while PCGS has never graded a Superb Gem. For the advanced collector of Superb Peace dollars, the present opportunity should be carefully considered.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

1741

1935-S $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Dazzling luster envelops the untoned surfaces of this lovely Gem and a decisive strike imparts strong definition to the design features. Well preserved with only a few grade-consistent grazes.(Registry values: N1793)

Susan B. Anthony Dollars

1742

1979-S SBA$ MS68 PCGS. Type One mintmark. The 1979-S Anthony dollar marked the first appearance of the San Francisco mintmark on any circulation issue since 1974. This lustrous and gorgeously preserved Superb Gem has apricot and gunmetal-blue patina. Crisply struck and essentially flawless. Population: 3 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N491)

Commemorative Silver

1743

1900 $1 Lafayette Dollar MS64 PCGS. DuVall 1-B. Clean surfaces are the main selling point for this upper-end near-Gem example. Both sides are covered with rich golden-gray toning and the underlying mint luster is satiny.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1744

1900 $1 Lafayette Dollar MS66 NGC. DuVall 1-B. This is an awe inspiring example of this popular, crown-sized early commemorative. Commemoratives have long been one of the most popular series for collectors and the appearance of a premium quality Lafayette has always stirred excitement. Both sides are beautifully toned in scattered emerald-green and russet colors. The underlying surfaces exhibit a vibrant, satiny appearance, being remarkably free of coin-to-coin contact. The typical Lafayette dollar, an issue that was sold in great numbers to the non-collecting general public, is often found lightly circulated and all too often cleaned. Even a pleasing MS63 specimen can be difficult to find. High-end coins, above the grade of MS65, are of the utmost rarity and quickly absorbed by the serious commemorative collector. To this we add that the Lafayette dollar is one of the keys to the U.S. commemorative set in the finer Mint State grades; few coins display surfaces as smooth and blatantly original as those of the present MS66 specimen. Destined for the finest set. Census: 64 in 66, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1745

1921 50C Alabama MS66 NGC. CAC. Light olive-gold overall with infrequent blushes of orange along the borders. Most Alabama halves are softly defined on the eagle's front leg, but the present Premium Gem provides an exception, as substantial plumage definition is evident. Lustrous and nearly unabraded. NGC has graded just seven numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1746

1921 50C Alabama 2x2 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Light silver-gray color through the centers with gold-orange frostiness along the rims. A well-defined example of the popular and lower-mintage variety.(Registry values: N2998)

1747

1921 50C Alabama 2x2 MS66 NGC. This lightly abraded Premium Gem is brilliant and bathed in luster. The 2x2 in the field reverse to Alabama's order of entry into the Union, a precedent established by the Missouri Centennial half issued earlier the same year. Census: 74 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1748

1921 50C Alabama 2x2 MS66 NGC. One of the hallmarks of high-grade Alabama halves is the superlative mint luster, as seen on this piece. In general the surfaces appear brilliant, but there is just the slightest tinge of color on each side when closely examined.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1749

1936 50C Albany MS67 PCGS. Superior mint luster is seen over each side of this lovely, well-preserved half. Most of each side has light gray patina with golden accents around the margins.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1750

1935-S 50C Arkansas MS67 NGC. Cream-gray and golden-brown with slightly deeper toning on the reverse. Precisely struck and coruscating. An unimprovable Superb Gem. Census: 13 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1751

1936-D 50C Arkansas MS67 PCGS. Satiny silver-gray centers are accented by rich peripheral patina, patchy cobalt-blue and orange-tan with slightly deeper intensity on the reverse. Excellent preservation and definition for this second-year D-mint Arkansas issue, one of just 9,660 pieces struck. Population: 20 in 67, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1752

1936-S 50C Bay Bridge MS67 NGC. Satiny and gorgeous with gold and peach tints over otherwise silver-luster surfaces. A well struck and delightful Superb Gem. NGC has graded only nine numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1753

1936-S 50C Bay Bridge MS67 PCGS. Eye-appealing and notable for its vivid orange-gold, lilac, and aqua patina. A needle-sharp Superb Gem with great luster through the toning. PCGS has graded nine coins finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1754

1936-S 50C Bay Bridge MS67 PCGS. Originally toned in autumn-gold, slate-gray, and emerald-green. This shimmering and unabraded Superb Gem is encased in an old green label holder. PCGS has certified just nine examples finer.(Registry values: N1793)

1755

1934 50C Boone MS67 NGC. Bright luster invigorates the yellow-gold surfaces dappled with freckles of golden-brown, and a well directed strike leaves strong definition on the design elements. A few trivial marks are mentioned solely for accuracy. Census: 19 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1756

1935-S 50C Boone MS67 PCGS. CAC. Subtle rainbow coloration covers the highly lustrous surfaces of this Superb Gem commemorative half and a decisive strike delivers sharp definition to the design elements. The few unobtrusive marks are well within the parameters of the designated grade. Population: 19 in 67, 1 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1757

1935/34-S 50C Boone MS67 PCGS. With just 2,004 pieces struck, the dual-dated 1935-S Boone half has the second-lowest mintage of any classic silver commemorative, and if one discounts assay coins, it is tied for first with its D-mint counterpart. This Superb Gem is an avidly pursued condition rarity as well, strongly reflective with peach and forest-green outer toning giving way to a faint hint of gold over the silvery centers. Population: 18 in 67, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1758

1935/34 SET Boone PDS Set MS66 to MS67 NGC. This set includes: 1935/34 MS66, freckled gold-tan and purple on lustrous surfaces; 1935/34-D MS67, splashes of greenish-gold are slightly deeper on the reverse; and a 1935/34-S MS66, veneer of olive-green resides on lustrous surfaces.

1759

1935/34 SET Boone PDS Set MS66 PCGS. Contains the relatively available P-mint as well as the famously low-mintage Denver and San Francisco issues. All coins are softly struck but well-preserved and lustrous beneath light gold-gray toning.

1760

1936 50C Boone MS67 PCGS. The nearly perfect surfaces glow with soft mint frost, and there is a slight presence of ice-blue and golden toning on each side.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1761

1936-D 50C Boone MS67 PCGS. The lustrous surfaces of this Superb Gem display a swath of medium intensity multicolored toning at the upper obverse border and possess well struck design features. A few minor obverse marks are noted. Population: 23 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1762

1937 50C Boone MS67 PCGS. CAC. Peach-gold and lime-green endow this highly lustrous and exemplary Superb Gem. The strike is intricate, and neither side has any visible marks. Population: 72 in 67, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1763

1937-D 50C Boone MS67 NGC. Gold-orange and rose peripheral toning fades into gold-gray and finally silver toward the centers. A lustrous Superb Gem with amazing eye appeal.(Registry values: N2998)

1764

1938-S 50C Boone MS67 NGC. Lime and straw-gold accents grace this satiny and fully struck Superb Gem. Virtually immaculate and essentially unimprovable. Aside from the infamous 1935/1934 issues, one of the lowest-mintage Boone halves. Census: 30 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1765

1936 50C Bridgeport MS67 NGC. This beauty owes much of its appeal to the semireflective fields as well as the subtle iridescent color seen over each side. A lovely Bridgeport. Census: 18 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1766

1925-S 50C California MS66 PCGS. CAC. A lovely Premium Gem example of the timeless California design. Gold-orange and violet peripheral toning gives way to lustrous silver-gray at the centers.(Registry values: N1793)

1767

1925-S 50C California MS67 NGC. CAC. Radiantly lustrous surfaces display multicolored peripheral toning and are impeccably preserved. Sharply struck throughout.(Registry values: N2998)

1768

1925-S 50C California MS67 PCGS. The California Jubilee half, designed by Joseph Mora, has received near-universal acclaim for his design of the '49er miner and the bear. This includes critics as widely disparate as David Bullowa, B. Max Mehl, and Cornelius Vermeule. The sole exception was James Earle Fraser, who recommended that Chester Beach or Robert Aitken redesign the coin. Time has proved the California half to be a collector favorite and high grade examples are scarce and always sought-after. This is a wonderfully preserved piece that has bright, shimmering mint luster and just a bit of peripheral color. Population: 85 in 67, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1769

1925-S 50C California MS67 NGC. Each side displays the usual bright mint luster with a slight reddish tinge. The faces are remarkably clean overall.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1770

1925-S 50C California MS67 NGC. The 75th anniversary of California statehood is commemorated on this half dollar, featuring a miner panning for gold on the obverse, and grizzly bear on the reverse. This lovely Superb Gem has gold and iridescent toning over frosty silver luster. NGC has only certified 14 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1771

1936 50C Cleveland MS67 PCGS. An original silver-gray representative with speckled multicolored toning, and a well executed strike that brings up the design elements. A few minute marks are visible on the obverse portrait. Scarce in this lofty condition. Population: 39 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1772

1936-D 50C Columbia MS68 NGC. The Columbia issues of 1936 were one of several low-mintage sets designed to feed the speculative commemorative market, with production of just 8,000 pieces per mint plus assay coins. Deep russet-gold toning is noted at the periphery, as is paler lavender-champagne patina at the centers. The immensely lustrous surfaces display exquisite preservation, with hardly any marks present on the crisply struck devices. A wonderful treat, with no numerically finer representative graded by either NGC or PCGS. Census: 44 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1773

1935 50C Connecticut MS66 NGC. This modernistic design features Connecticut's famed Charter Oak on the obverse, with a rather ungainly eagle on the reverse. This Premium Gem example boasts lovely amber-gold and powder-gray obverse color, with more intense shades of jade, saffron, and lilac on the reverse. Considerable luster emanates through the deep color. NGC has certified only 67 pieces finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1774

1936 50C Delaware MS67 NGC. Yellow-gold patina assumes deeper shades on the reverse where is is accented with rainbow coloration. Well cared for surfaces are highly lustrous and well struck.(Registry values: N1793)

1775

1936 50C Delaware MS67 NGC. A lustrous sun-gold and stone-gray Superb Gem. Fully struck, and both sides are unabraded save for inconspicuous thin lines beneath the clouds and LIBERTY. NGC has certified only four pieces finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1776

1922 50C Grant No Star MS66 PCGS. CAC. Light blue and gold-orange toning covers much of each side, and additional russet elements appear near the rims. This lustrous Premium Gem offers wonderful eye appeal. PCGS has graded 34 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1777

1922 50C Grant No Star MS66 PCGS. An essentially pristine Premium Gem that has good luster and an attentive strike. Although a small quantity of pieces have been certified finer, it may well be that the present example provides greater value.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2008), lot 1123, which realized $1,035.(Registry values: N1793)

1778

1922 50C Grant No Star MS67 NGC. This is a stunning Superb Gem of this popular Civil War-related commemorative issue, with delightfully toned surfaces in shades of lilac and pastel blue. Grant's cheek and the coin overall are refreshingly free of contact. Census: 25 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1779

1922 50C Grant With Star MS64 PCGS. Bright luster emanates from the essentially untoned surfaces of this near-Gem commemorative half. Sharply struck on the design motifs, and revealing a few minor marks that deny Gem status.(Registry values: N1793)

1780

1928 50C Hawaiian MS65 PCGS. Remarkably abrasion-free, the surfaces are deeply and originally toned with mottled green and pinkish-lilac tone that is quite unusual. When angled beneath a light, the bright, satiny luster is brightly evident through the deep layerings of toning. The Hawaiian half is one of the most actively sought after early commemoratives.(Registry values: N2998)

1781

1928 50C Hawaiian MS65 PCGS. Deep magenta, amber, jade, and blue patination covers the obverse of this Gem, while the reverse offers lighter amber and green shades with an untoned silver center. Perusal with a loupe reveals a remarkable paucity of mentionable contact, although a light also reveals the stunning beauty of the toning. Worth a premium bid from the color aficionados.(Registry values: N2998)

1782

1928 50C Hawaiian MS65 PCGS. This golden-tinged Gem boasts satiny luster with considerable reflectivity and tinges of powder-gray in the obverse center. Even under a loupe there are no singularly mentionable abrasions. Certified in a green-label holder, this Gem may prove a worthy acquisition, as examples certified finer are much more elusive.(Registry values: N2998)

1783

1935 50C Hudson MS64 PCGS. The lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem see wisps of champagne-gold color along the margins. Sharply struck and revealing no serious contact marks.(Registry values: N991)

1784

1935 50C Hudson MS65 PCGS. Strongly lustrous for a Hudson half with a hint of golden toning over otherwise brilliant surfaces. Well struck overall with a few small but grade-defining marks in the area around Neptune.(Registry values: N1793)

1785

1924 50C Huguenot MS67 PCGS. Dazzling mint luster dashes across each side of this exceptionally clean half. Only the slightest bit of peripheral color surrounds the obverse, while numerous dots of color are seen further in from the margin on the reverse.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1786

1925 50C Lexington MS66 PCGS. Each side has attractive olive-gray and rose toning with strong underlying mint luster. While completely speculative, this piece reminds us of coins that have toned in original wooden boxes of issue.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1787

1925 50C Lexington MS67 NGC. Issued in commemoration of the Lexington-Concord Sesquicentennial (1775-1925), this issue is also known as the Patriot Half Dollar, and features the Concord Minuteman on the obverse and Lexington's Old Belfry on the reverse. This popular issue is always in demand as a tribute to the soldiers of the Revolutionary War.
This polychromatic Superb Gem has brilliant satin luster beneath natural speckled golden-brown and iridescent toning. The strike is excellent and the surfaces are pristine. Here is an exceptional, highly appealing example for the connoisseur. Census: 10 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1788

1918 50C Lincoln MS67 PCGS. CAC. Light golden-brown shadings fill the fields, and the left obverse periphery displays russet and sea-green freckles. This intricately struck and highly lustrous Superb Gem is beautifully preserved and exhibits outstanding eye appeal. Population: 84 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1789

1918 50C Lincoln MS67 PCGS. The Lincoln half is one of the unrecognized condition rarities in the series. It is usually found with numerous abrasions on the face of Lincoln, and a coin as clean as this one is a rare find. The mint luster is strong and flashes through the light golden-brown toning seen on each side.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1790

1936 50C Long Island MS67 NGC. Scattered rose-golden toning interrupts the otherwise brilliant surfaces of this highly lustrous coin. Remarkably clean, as one would expect from an MS67.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1791

1936 50C Lynchburg MS67 PCGS. Ex: Troy Wiseman Collection. Superb overall surfaces and mostly brilliant with accents of light golden around the margins on the obverse and outlining the devices on the reverse. Scarce so fine. Population: 55 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1792

1934 50C Maryland MS67 PCGS. It is rare when a Maryland half is as clean as this one on the face of Cecil Calvert. The surfaces are highly lustrous and each side is covered with golden-olive toning. Exceptional quality.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1793

1921 50C Missouri 2x4 MS64 NGC. A luminous and richly toned near-Gem, well struck for the elusive 2x4 variety. Only a handful of scattered, wispy marks are visible on the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

1794

1921 50C Missouri 2x4 MS65 NGC. Lustrous silver surfaces are awash in gold, peach, and blue-violet color. A generally well struck example of this challenging variant. The 2x4 indicates that Missouri was the 24th state to enter the Federal Union. NGC has graded a scant 22 numerically finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1795

1921 50C Missouri 2x4 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Struck to celebrate the centennial of Missouri statehood, this 1921 issue exists with or without a 2x4 in the obverse field. The extra variety identified Missouri as the 24th star on the U.S. flag. This lustrous Gem has frosty silver luster beneath beautiful gold and iridescent toning. Coincidentally, PCGS has only certified 24 finer examples (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1796

1921 50C Missouri 2x4 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Delicate pastel shades of olive, saffron, pink, and ice-blue enrich the lovely surfaces of this Gem Missouri 2x4, more prominently on the obverse. The certified populations thin out markedly at the MS66 level, making this Gem an even more alluring proposition. PCGS has certified two dozen finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1797

1921 50C Missouri 2x4 MS66 PCGS. CAC. One of the keys to the complete silver commemorative series in high grade; it makes no difference that it was created as a marketing ploy, as collectors eagerly seek examples today, only to find that Gem 2 ★ 4s are even more elusive than their "plain" counterpart. This Premium Gem specimen boasts lovely silver-white surfaces that reveal delicate tinges of lilac, gold, and jade around the rims. Population: 24 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1798

1936 50C Norfolk MS68 NGC. The Norfolk has proved to be the most available commemorative in ultra-high grades. The surfaces on this piece are almost perfect and each side displays occasional deep reddish-gold patina interspersed with brilliance.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1799

1939 SET Oregon PDS Set MS67 NGC. A well-matched Superb Gem set. The set includes the 1939, the 1939-D, and the 1939-S. All coins are highly lustrous, sharply struck, and nearly untoned, though the two branch-mint pieces display a splash of deep purple at the border.
From The Cliff Street Collection.

1800

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific MS64 NGC. Softly lustrous with a slightly above-average strike. This coin's greatest attribute is its obverse patina, a delightful, dazzling swirl of gold, lime, blue, and violet.(Registry values: N1793)

1801

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific MS64 NGC. Light purple toning clings to the margins of this near-Gem commemorative and a well directed strike leaves strong definition on the design motifs. There are no marks worthy of mention. Housed in a prior generation holder.(Registry values: N1793)

1802

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific MS65 NGC. Blue-violet and tan-gold peripheral toning gives way quickly to near-brilliant silver centers. Minimally abraded, though a few small marks are noted on Liberty's arms.(Registry values: N1793)

1803

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific MS65 NGC. Peach-orange, rose, and violet-blue peripheral elements give way to lustrous centers in pale silver. Slight striking softness overall, but nothing that would jeopardize the Gem grade.(Registry values: N1793)

1804

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific MS65 PCGS. Whispers of light gray patina visit the lustrous surfaces of this well struck commemorative Gem half. A few grade-consistent marks do not detract.(Registry values: N1793)

1805

1936-S 50C Rhode Island MS67 PCGS. Both sides of this Superb Gem have beautiful pearlescent surfaces with splashes of deep iridescent toning. For the connoisseur who collects the finest possible quality, this Rhode Island half will make a wonderful addition. Population: 14 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

1806

1936 SET Rhode Island PDS Set MS67 NGC. The matched grade set includes a 1936, a pristine Superb Gem toned in pastel ice-blue and apricot shades; a 1936-D, lightly toned although a few peripheral orange-red freckles grace the obverse; and a 1936-S, delicate lime-green and lilac toning aside from a slender band of golden-brown near the obverse rim.

1807

1936 50C Robinson MS67 NGC. Sky-blue and caramel-gold toning drapes this thoroughly lustrous and essentially pristine Superb Gem. An outstanding example of this curious commemorative issue, struck while its senator subject was still serving. Census: 26 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1808

1936-D 50C San Diego MS67 ★ NGC. Attractive aquamarine, olive-gold, peach-red, and lilac toning confirms the NGC Star designation. Lustrous, nicely struck, and close to immaculate save for a brief graze above the 3 in the date. Scarcer than its 1935-S predecessor, since many 1930s numismatists collected commemoratives strictly by type. Census: 13 in 67 ★ , 1 finer with a Star designation (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1809

1936-D 50C San Diego MS67 PCGS. San Diego halves, like Elgin halves, are probably the most intensely lustrous coins in the entire commemorative series. This piece certainly displays that characteristic which highlights the light rose and lime-green toning seen on each side. Population: 72 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1810

1926 50C Sesquicentennial MS65 NGC. This shallow-relief design is notably free from the usual heavy abrasions. The bright mint luster displays a speckling of rich orange-tan toning that is several shades deeper on the reverse.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1811

1935 50C Spanish Trail MS64 NGC. Golden-brown shades embrace this satiny near-Gem. The strike is unassailable, as is the preservation. The Old Spanish Trail (a disastrous Spanish expedition) is among the lowest mintage silver commemorative types.(Registry values: N1793)

1812

1935 50C Spanish Trail MS65 PCGS. Soft yellow-gold and violet patina clings to the margins of this lustrous Gem. Well cared for surfaces possess razor-sharp design features.(Registry values: N1793)

1813

1935 50C Spanish Trail MS65 NGC. Magnification brings out delicate violet and gold patina on this impressively struck Gem. Remarkably smooth lustrous surfaces reveal just an occasional unobtrusive mark. Stunning overall eye appeal. Encased in an older holder.(Registry values: N1793)

1814

1935 50C Spanish Trail MS66 NGC. The Spanish Trail is easily one of the most challenging commemoratives to locate in high grades, primarily because of the open space on each side. This piece displays even, muted gray-golden toning over each side. Only one bagmark is noted, located in the lower left obverse field.
From The Gateway Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1815

1925 50C Stone Mountain MS67 PCGS. A medley of iridescent crimson, orange, and yellow-gold toning at the obverse margins frames mauve and sky-blue centers, while the reverse displays a mixture of pastel ice-blue and champagne-gold. A sharp Superb Gem. PCGS has graded just six finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1816

1936-D 50C Texas MS68 PCGS. CAC. This sensational Superb Gem is highly lustrous with satiny surfaces beneath gorgeous gold, russet, lilac, and green toning. Only slight weakness at the center of the reverse is noted, as always on the Texas half dollars. This is an amazing piece destined for the finest numismatic cabinet. Population: 13 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1817

1947-S 50C Booker T. Washington MS67 ★ NGC. CAC. This Superb Gem is one of the four finest given the Star designation. Both sides are awash with vibrant luster and exhibit sharply struck design elements. Impeccably preserved throughout.(Registry values: N1793)

1818

1948-S 50C Booker T. Washington MS67 NGC. CAC. Vibrant luster embraces this sharply struck Superb Gem and an exacting strike brings out strong detail on the design features. Well preserved and displaying just a touch of light gold color at the margins. Census: 54 in 67, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1819

1949-D 50C Booker T. Washington MS67 PCGS. The obverse shows just a blush of pink near the rims, while the reverse offers a hint of olive and gold, and yet the surfaces are basically untoned on this Superb Gem. Essential contact is nonexistent, and as such this piece is tied with only a dozen others as the finest certified at PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1820

1951-S 50C Booker T. Washington MS67 ★ NGC. Outstanding luster issues from the untoned surfaces of this magnificent Superb Gem designated with the coveted Star. Sharply struck and impeccably preserved. Census: 6 in 67 ★ , 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1821

1951 50C Washington-Carver MS66 PCGS. A moderately lustrous Premium Gem from the first year of the Washington-Carver design. A patch of blue-violet toning appears at the upper obverse, and the surfaces are minimally toned otherwise. Population: 34 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

1822

1954-D 50C Washington-Carver MS66 NGC. Lustrous surfaces are nearly untoned save for a couple of specks of color at the rims. This well struck piece reveals only a small milling mark on Oregon. Census: 19 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

Commemorative Gold

1823

1903 G$1 Louisiana Purchase/Jefferson MS66 NGC. CAC. Decisively detailed with effusive yellow-gold luster. This gorgeous Premium Gem hails from the earliest era of commemorative gold dollars and has come through more than a century virtually untouched.(Registry values: N2998)

1824

1903 G$1 Louisiana Purchase/Jefferson MS66 NGC. Frosty luster endows the yellow-gold surfaces imbued with traces of greenish-gray. This is a sharply struck Premium Gem with no mentionable marks.(Registry values: N2998)

1825

1903 G$1 Louisiana Purchase/McKinley MS64 NGC. A green-gold Choice commemorative gold dollar that has clean fields and potent luster. One hair-thin line is noted on the cheek. The strike is impeccable except for the reverse dentils between 3 and 6 o'clock.(Registry values: N1793)

1826

1903 G$1 Louisiana Purchase/McKinley MS68 NGC. While both varieties of the Louisiana Purchase gold dollars are known to "come nice," this is a coin that defies all expectations. It offers decidedly better preservation and eye appeal than the Gems and even Premium Gems more commonly seen in the marketplace. Peach-tinged yellow-gold surfaces are virtually flawless to the unaided eye. Warmly lustrous fields yield to sharply struck devices that exhibit a twinkling of frost. As one of just four MS68 coins in the combined certified population with none finer (2/10), a definite feather in the cap for the high-end commemorative gold collector.(Registry values: N7079)

1827

1904 G$1 Lewis and Clark MS64 PCGS. CAC. Variegated apricot-gold and mint-green patination endows the lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem commemorative and a decisive strike delivers sharp detail to the design elements. The few light handling marks that preclude Gem classification do not detract from the coin's overall pleasing eye appeal.(Registry values: N2998)

1828

1904 G$1 Lewis and Clark MS64 PCGS. Both sides of this Choice Mint State representative have brilliant lemon-yellow surfaces with frosty gold luster and sharp design details. This lovely gold commemorative marks the centennial of the famous westward journey of explorers Meriwether Lewis and William Clark. Lewis appears above the date and Clark appears above the denomination.(Registry values: N2998)

1829

1904 G$1 Lewis and Clark MS65 PCGS. First of two years for this popular gold commemorative, and a splendid, upper-end example. The surfaces appear at first to be uniformly reddish-gold, but the reverse displays several significant dabs of lilac around the peripheral lettering. The mint luster is satiny and each side is problem-free.(Registry values: N4719)

1830

1905 G$1 Lewis and Clark MS63 PCGS. A satiny peach-gold Select commemorative that is well struck aside from selected portions of the denticles. There are no singularly mentionable flaws, making this a strong candidate for the budget-minded collector.(Registry values: N1793)

1831

1905 G$1 Lewis and Clark MS65 NGC. The two-headed 1904 and 1905 Lewis and Clark gold dollars were the first such in American coinage. The price disparity between the 1904 and 1905 grows increasingly large as the condition ladder is ascended, with the 1905 the clear winner. This Gem offers golden-orange surfaces with tinges of hazel, and the central devices on each side--the explorers' cheeks--are remarkably contact-free. A super example for a gold commemorative set.(Registry values: N4719)

1832

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS64 PCGS. The mintmark is lightly but widely repunched southeast. This tan-gold representative is unabraded and has the look of a decidedly higher grade, but a slender retained lamination (as made) affects the date, the base of the neck, and the opposite peripheral area on the reverse.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 9/2008), lot 11085, which realized $977.50.(Registry values: N1793)

1833

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS65 NGC. CAC. A beautiful green-gold Gem that has booming luster, a bold strike, and an unabraded appearance. An excellent value relative to the next finer grade. Certified in an early generation, pre-hologram holder.(Registry values: N2998)

1834

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS65 NGC. A splendid khaki-gold Gem that boasts dynamic luster and excellent eye appeal. A solitary hairline on the canal worker's cap is all that denies an even finer grade.(Registry values: N2998)

1835

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS66 PCGS. CAC. Lustrous yellow-gold surfaces host splashes of pink toning on each side of this Premium Gem. The gold dollar issue from the Panama-Pacific commemorative set is popular among type collectors who desire a single gold piece from the set.(Registry values: N2998)

1836

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS66 PCGS. This shimmering olive-gold Premium Gem is beautifully smooth, and the strike is complete save for a small and inconspicuous strike-through on the reverse border near 12 o'clock. A hair-thin radial die crack is present behind the eye of the lower dolphin.(Registry values: N2998)

1837

1915-S $2 1/2 Panama-Pacific Quarter Eagle MS64 NGC. Both sides of this Choice Mint State piece have light yellow luster with frosty surfaces. A few minor abrasions explain the grade, as it otherwise has the outward appearance of a full Gem. It is an attractive example from the commemorative issue that Farran Zerbe made famous.(Registry values: N2998)

1838

1915-S $2 1/2 Panama-Pacific Quarter Eagle MS66 NGC. Both sides of this Premium Gem are awash with ebullient luster that radiates from its brass-gold surfaces and a well executed strike leaves strong delineation on the design features. Close examination reveals no marks worthy of mention on this extremely popular quarter eagle commemorative specimen.(Registry values: N4719)

Commemorative Silver

1839

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. Peach, rose, and violet shadings appear at the borders. This is retoning and not simply toning, as a close look at the silver-white centers reveals odd brightness and hairlines. Still, a readily collectible example of this popular issue.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N491)

Commemorative Gold

1840

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS65 PCGS. A generous helping of frosty luster enlivens the honey-kissed yellow-gold surfaces of this Gem. Both sides are well-defined and carefully preserved.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1841

1915-S $2 1/2 Panama-Pacific Quarter Eagle AU58 PCGS. Just a touch of rub is visible on the high points of this Panama-Pacific quarter eagle. The luster and eye appeal remain strong, making this coin a great opportunity for the budget-conscious collector.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

1842

1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Round--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. Warm yellow-orange surfaces have pleasing luster despite the after-effects of a past cleaning. A few small digs and other abrasions are noted in the fields, but the overall eye appeal is considerable. Though not assigned a numeric grade by NGC, that service does note that the coin shows no trace of wear. All things considered, a desirable representative of this famous classic gold commemorative issue, one that enjoys remarkable popularity and demand that far exceeds the number of known survivors, which come from a net mintage of only 483 pieces.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N7079)

1843

1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal--Obverse Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. With their distinctive shape and undeniable scarcity, the octagonal fifty dollar Panama-Pacific commemoratives are forever collector favorites. The present example shows two slightly different looks; while the yellow-orange obverse has had its luster dulled by a past cleaning, the minimally abraded reverse is decidedly more lively. Neither side shows any evidence of wear. This coin could make either a comparatively affordable cornerstone to a classic gold commemorative set or an attractive display piece to show off the reverse of the design in conjunction with another example.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7)

1844

Five-Slot Panama-Pacific Commemorative Coin Display Frame. A copper-and-glass frame for a set of five Panama-Pacific commemorative coins with royal purple interior that has all components present. Minor chipping to upper right glass, ring on back of holder missing, otherwise very good condition. No coins included with this lot.
From The Cliff Street Collection.

Commemorative Silver

1845

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. Light hairlines are visible in the pebbled fields. The centers lack patina, though the margins have begun to retone reddish-gold and brown.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N491)

Commemorative Gold

1846

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS65 PCGS. A lovely Gem example of this popular gold dollar issue. Rich sun-yellow luster takes on orange attributes at the centers. Well struck and delightful.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1847

1915-S $2 1/2 Panama-Pacific Quarter Eagle MS66 PCGS. Rich butter-yellow luster dominates the eye appeal of this Premium Gem commemorative. Both sides show above-average definition overall, though Columbia's head exhibits more typical striking softness. Registry collectors know how elusive this issue is in Superb Gem: PCGS has graded just 19 finer examples (2/10).
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

1848

1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Round--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. With a net mintage of fewer than 500 pieces, the Panama-Pacific fifty dollar round is the marquee rarity of the classic commemorative series, more challenging than the octagonal version that often shares its spotlight and elusive regardless of condition. The present round example, though cleaned in the past and showing dimmed luster and light hairlines as a result, shows no evidence of wear across the devices. The orange-influenced yellow-gold color adds a pleasing note to the eye appeal. All things considered, a readily collectible representative.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: N7079)

1849

1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal--Scratches--NGC. Unc Details. In the broad range of souvenirs offered at the Panama-Pacific International Exposition, the fifty dollar gold coins--sold at twice their face value--surely were among the most expensive. Only a relative handful of attendees and associates were able to afford them, and just 645 examples of the more popular octagonal variety sold. Today, survivors are enduring and popular collectibles. Though this piece shows light pinscratches on the devices, and the reverse exhibits a pair of flaws more akin to staple scratches, the lustrous yellow-gold surfaces are unworn, and the obverse displays well with few significant abrasions.
From The Cliff Street Collection.(Registry values: P7)

1850

Shreve & Co. Copper and Glass Commemorative Coin Frame. A Shreve & Co. frame in copper and glass for holding five Panama-Pacific commemorative coins. Minor fading and wear to cards and ribbon, minor wear to back of holder, otherwise fine condition. No coins included in the lot.
From The Cliff Street Collection.

Commemorative Silver

1851

1915-S 50C Panama-Pacific MS66 NGC. CAC. Impeccably preserved surfaces are enlivened with dazzling luster and crescents of lavender, orange, yellow-gold, and green patina around the margins, framing centers delicately toned in pastel violet-gray. The deign features are sharply struck. A trivial mark is noted in the middle of Liberty's left arm.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

Commemorative Gold

1852

1915-S G$1 Panama-Pacific Gold Dollar MS65 PCGS. CAC. Both sides of this Gem are warmly lustrous, with rich sun-gold color on the obverse and lighter wheat and yellow hues on the reverse. A well struck and attractive Gem example of this popular gold dollar, struck a decade after the last commemorative issue of that denomination.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

1853

1915-S $2 1/2 Panama-Pacific Quarter Eagle MS66 NGC. CAC. A highly desirable Premium Gem example from the first of just two classic commemorative quarter eagle issues. Rich yellow-gold luster shows strong orange accents. Softly struck at the upper obverse, as often seen, but with such impressive preservation and overall eye appeal that this fault is rendered trivial in context.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

1854

1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Round MS65 NGC. CAC. Like modern commemoratives celebrating the Olympic Games, many issues in the classic commemorative series mark events happening close to the year of issue, rather than anniversaries. Several early series, including the World's Columbian Exposition coins, the Louisiana Purchase Exposition gold dollars, and the Lewis and Clark Exposition gold dollars, blur the edges of the category, since their respective expositions themselves honored anniversaries of 100 or 400 years.
By contrast, the Panama-Pacific International Exposition of 1915 celebrated strictly recent events. The rebuilding of San Francisco after the 1906 earthquake figured into the choice of San Francisco to host the World's Fair, as did the construction of the Panama Canal, begun in 1904 and completed in 1914. Still, both developments were fresh in the minds of San Francisco's residents by the time the Exposition opened its doors, particularly the rebuilding; that theme is echoed the name of the "Nine Years After" parade, held at the Exposition in mid-April, a reminder of both all that was lost and how far the city had come.
Though expositions before and after the Panama-Pacific had commemorative coins issued for them, none of the exposition coinage programs was so ambitious as the one struck in 1915. While the half dollar and gold dollar were cues taken from past expositions' commemoratives, the quarter eagle and especially the round and octagonal fifty dollar coins took the classic commemorative series into uncharted territory.
While the fifty dollar commemorative coin is an idea that has gone unrepeated in U.S. numismatics, even in the modern era, survivors remain to offer testimony to a singular chapter in the history of American coinage. High-grade coins such as the present Gem, however, have a supply far too small to meet demand. This lovely coin is immensely lustrous with pale canary-yellow surfaces. While the centers show slight striking softness, most visibly at the owl's legs, the overall eye appeal is remarkable. It will be a fortunate bidder who ultimately wins the contest for this coin.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N10218)

1855

1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal MS63 NGC. CAC. Regardless of other factors, the two variants of the fifty dollar gold Panama-Pacific commemoratives were going to have the lowest mintages among the five types created for the Exposition. Swiatek and Breen mention in their Encyclopedia of United States Silver & Gold Commemorative Coins, "According to Exposition price lists, a single $50 coin could be had for $100, but this price entitled the buyer to the half dollar, dollar and quarter eagle free of charge."
In other words, for every individual round or octagonal fifty dollar gold coin sold by Farran Zerbe's concession, a complete set of the rest of the series would be thrown into the bargain. Of course, the other, much smaller denominations were bought more frequently than the $100, or double face value, that the $50 pieces commanded. The least-expensive Panama-Pacific silver half dollars, which buyers could see minted on the Exposition grounds, right before their eyes, proved the most popular of all.
Yet in relative terms-specifically, the net mintage of each issue as a percentage of the maximum authorized mintage-both varieties of the fifty dollar commemorative outdid their half dollar counterpart, which wound up selling just under 14% of its maximum. By contrast, the round fifty dollar issue's net mintage of 483 pieces is slightly over 32% of its maximum. The 645 octagonal pieces sold represent an even better percentage, 43% on the dot.
Of course, not all of those 645 pieces have lasted to the present day, making survivors such as this Select example all the more elusive. Like many of its fellows, it shows a number of light marks and a dig to the left of the portrait, yet these flaws are minor in the context of the eye appeal. Orange-kissed yellow-gold surfaces are delightfully lustrous. An attractive and important coin.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: P7)

1856

1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal MS63 PCGS. The Panama-Pacific fifty dollar design, which is shared between round and octagonal forms, has a decidedly classical feel, a deliberate artistic choice of sculptor Robert Aitken. The classicist Cornelius Vermeule offered this intriguing assessment of possible inspirations and influences:

"In an overall view, the arresting feature of the giant gold coins was their archaistic treatment of details and relief. Athena's crest, wreath, curls, and aegis imitate the work of an ancient bronze. The bead and reel between the outside rims comes from Greek architecture, and a form of the lettering around the rim recalls Roman sestertii of the Empire or papal medallions of the Cinquecento."

While the sculptor likely did not take all of the above as conscious influences, Vermeule's exposition nonetheless illustrates the debt owed by Aitken to his classical predecessors.
This Select coin is a well struck, pleasingly preserved example of this ever-popular issue. Athena's face and helmet show no singularly distracting flaws, and the entire coin is awash in mint luster. Close examination will note some minor lines, of the type present on the vast majority of this issue. Since much of the Panama-Pacific Exposition coinage was sold to non-coin collectors, time and attrition took a toll on these heavy coins. Many show rim bumps from being dropped or mishandled in some fashion, and problem-free survivors are more elusive than the population numbers might suggest. This coin is an excellent example for the grade and worthy of a place in an advanced collection.(Registry values: P7)

1857

1916 G$1 McKinley MS64 PCGS. CAC. Uncommonly flashy luster for a McKinley dollar of 1916, with a mix of pale and deeper yellows on each side. This lovely near-Gem shows just a few scattered flaws.(Registry values: N1793)

1858

1917 G$1 McKinley MS67 PCGS. CAC. The McKinley Memorial dated 1917 is far more elusive in higher grades than the 1916-dated coins, with a price differential to match. This splendid Superb Gem offers delicate mattelike surfaces that are essentially contact-free. Both sides show glints of jade and cherry along with the predominating orange-gold coloration.(Registry values: N4719)

1859

1922 G$1 Grant No Star MS67 NGC. CAC. Pesky abrasions on General Grant's cheek are the usual culprit that prevent higher grades on these commemorative gold dollars, and this splendid Superb Gem is remarkably few of even the tiniest signs of contact. The lemon-yellow surfaces display generous luster and abundant eye appeal.(Registry values: N4719)

1860

1922 G$1 Grant No Star MS67 PCGS. CAC. Exquisite tones of honey, golden-brown and crimson adorn the flawless surfaces of this Superb Gem commemorative. From a tiny mintage of just 5,000 pieces, Grant No Star gold dollars are traditionally found in high grade, but examples are seldom encountered at this exalted grade level. Population: 123 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1861

1922 G$1 Grant With Star Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .92 suggests Cleaning as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an Uncirculated specimen that has been cleaned. Close inspection reveals disturbed luster and hairlines on the pale yellow-gold surfaces. Still, a readily collectible example of the With Star variety.

1862

1926 $2 1/2 Sesquicentennial MS64 NGC. This near-Gem offers amazing "flash" on its yellow-gold surfaces and has been endowed with an exacting strike. Would probably grade finer were it not for a milling mark on the abdomen.(Registry values: N991)

1863

1926 $2 1/2 Sesquicentennial MS64 PCGS. This lemon-gold near-Gem provides dynamic luster and a full strike. The final gold commemorative issue until 1984.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1864

1926 $2 1/2 Sesquicentennial MS64 NGC. Glowing luster exudes from the peach-gold surfaces of this well struck quarter eagle. A handful of minuscule marks prevents Gem classification. encapsulated in a prior generation holder.(Registry values: N991)

1865

1926 $2 1/2 Sesquicentennial MS64 NGC. Both sides boast flashy luster and highly attractive peach-gold coloration. Sharply struck and minimally abraded. The coin reposes in a former generation holder.(Registry values: N991)

1866

1926 $2 1/2 Sesquicentennial MS65 PCGS. The low-relief design of these Sesquicentennial issues makes them hard to find "nice," meaning well-struck and without major signs of contact on the "high" points. This piece is one such, however, with a good strike and only a couple of obverse marks on Liberty's torso that likely preclude an even finer grade. The issue is much more difficult at the Premium Gem level.(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Commemorative Gold

1867

1903 G$1 Jefferson PR62 Cameo NGC. CAC. Per Breen, the first 100 1903 Jefferson gold dollars struck were in proof format, and housed in "a mounted frame affidavit." He adds that "most of the [100] coins have long since been removed from [their original holders]." The present specimen has glassy fields and radiant devices. The strike is impeccable, and the fields have the expected number of faint hairlines. Census: 2 in 62 Cameo, 6 finer (2/10).

Modern Issues

1868

1997-W G$5 Jackie Robinson Gold Five Dollar MS70 PCGS. A satiny and unabraded example of this coveted low mintage modern commemorative issue. The strike is full, and the surfaces are as issued, with only a few nearly imperceptible pinpoint strike-throughs on the baseball. Population: 36 in 70, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1869

2000-W $10 Library of Congress Bimetallic Ten Dollars MS69 NGC. The surfaces are nearly perfect on this interesting bimetallic coin. There is no trace of toning and we do not see any abrasions on this immaculate circulation strike.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2)

1870

2000-W $10 Library of Congress Bimetallic Ten Dollars MS70 PCGS. Fully struck, satiny, and perfect aside from a minute spot above the first L in DOLLARS. The sole bimetallic commemorative issue, and the first commemorative issue to include platinum as part of its composition. Among the lowest mintage modern commemorative issues, with an Uncirculated production of only 7,261 pieces.(Registry values: P2)

Modern Bullion Coins

1871

1987 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Whispers of faint gold-tan color appear under magnification on the obverse of this boldly impressed MS70 specimen. Fantastic overall eye appeal.(Registry values: N991)

1872

1988 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Vibrant luster issues from the untoned surfaces of this immaculately preserved MS70 silver eagle. Fully delineated design elements further enhance the coin's outstanding eye appeal.(Registry values: N991)

1873

1989-W G$50 One-Ounce Gold Eagle PR70 Deep Cameo PCGS. An utterly flawless representative of this proof one-ounce gold American Eagle issue. The black-gold mirrors are remarkably deep, and the contrast with the frosted devices is absolute.(Registry values: N1793)

1874

1990 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Pristine surfaces display light silver-gray luster. A uniform sharp strike characterizes the design elements.(Registry values: N991)

1875

1991 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Boldly impressed and utterly unmarked with wonderful satiny luster. While the reverse of this attractive coin is virtually devoid of toning, the obverse shows significant milk-spotting at the periphery, most notably to the left of the date and between the R and T of LIBERTY.(Registry values: N991)

1876

1992 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Fully struck and pristine. Radiantly lustrous throughout.(Registry values: N991)

1877

1993 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. A couple of light gold-tan toning spots occur over each side of this perfectly preserved silver eagle. Excellent eye appeal.(Registry values: N991)

1878

1993-W G$50 One-Ounce Gold Eagle PR70 Deep Cameo PCGS. The flawless mirrors offer excellent contrast with the decisively struck and richly textured devices on this mid-date American Eagle one-ounce gold proof. From the original mintage, only a few dozen specimens have achieved absolute perfection in the eyes of PCGS.(Registry values: N1793)

1879

1994 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Brilliant surfaces yield unimprovable preservation. Census: 4 in 70 (1/10).(Registry values: N991)

1880

Five-Piece 1995-W 10th Anniversary American Eagle Set. A five-piece set housed in plastic cases of issue, with plush outer case, box, and literature. The four gold proof denominations, one ounce, half-ounce, quarter-ounce, and tenth-ounce are all represented, but the low-mintage one-ounce silver American Eagle is the key to the lot.

1881

1995-W $1 Silver Eagle PR67 Deep Cameo PCGS. Only 30,125 proof silver Eagles were coined at West Point in 1995, and it is the unquestioned key issue of the entire series. This Superb Gem Deep Cameo proof is fully brilliant with no evidence of toning. The lustrous devices float across the deeply mirrored fields. A few light toning spots are the only distractions.(Registry values: N1793)

1882

1995-W $1 Silver Eagle PR68 Deep Cameo PCGS. The 1995-W is the only silver Eagle prior to 2001 that bears the W mintmark. This piece is a stunning beauty of virtual perfection. Both sides are fully brilliant and untoned with unlimited mirrors and sensational luster on the devices.(Registry values: N2998)

1883

1995-W $1 Silver Eagle PR68 Deep Cameo PCGS. With just 30,125 pieces struck, this West Point proof is the undisputed key to the silver American Eagle series. The present representative has just a suggestion of milky toning in the right obverse field, and the black-and-white contrast of the reverse borders on absolute. Carefully preserved, as expected for the issue, though not at the level of the more commonly seen PR69 Deep Cameo tier.(Registry values: N2998)

1884

1995-W $1 Silver Eagle PR69 Deep Cameo PCGS. As the key to the silver American Eagle series, the 1995-W proof has a formidable reputation enjoyed by few modern issues. This virtually perfect specimen has outstanding black-and-white contrast fueled by remarkable reflectivity and frost. Inspection under magnification reveals only a couple of tiny faults. PCGS has graded just two coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1885

1995-W $1 Silver Eagle PR69 Deep Cameo PCGS. A fantastically appealing specimen of this famous modern-era key, virtually flawless to the unaided eye. The sole identifying mark appears on the obverse, which shows a tiny planchet defect between the R and T of LIBERTY. Just two coins have been assigned the ultimate grade by PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1886

1995-W $1 Silver Eagle PR69 Deep Cameo PCGS. Stone-gray design motifs yield white-on-black contrast when the coin is observed from a direct angle. A powerful strike manifests in complete delineation on the devices. Virtually pristine as would be expected by the designated grade. With a mintage of a little over 30,000 pieces, the 1995-W proof is the key to the series.(Registry values: N2998)

1887

1996 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. A decisively struck and satiny silver American Eagle, certified by NGC as perfect. Pale silver surfaces take on a light gold or peach hue, depending on the angle, and two milk spots are noted in the right obverse field, in a line just above the topmost edge of the Y in LIBERTY.(Registry values: P1)

1888

1999 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. An exactingly struck representative of this decade-old silver American Eagle issue. Both sides are unabraded and post-striking perfect, though perceptive eyes will be drawn to the right obverse, where a small flaw and a tiny streak of dark toning appear on the rim between the T and Y of LIBERTY.(Registry values: N991)

1889

2000 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. This highly lustrous MS70 silver eagle is color free and fully struck. A tiny fleck in the right reverse field is mentioned for complete accuracy. What appears to be a faint hairline in the right obverse field is actually on the plastic.(Registry values: P1)

1890

2006 G$50 One-Ounce Gold Eagle MS70 NGC. NGC described as "First Strikes." A boldly struck, technically flawless example of the 2006 issue, satiny with pale yellow-gold color.

1891

2006 $50 Buffalo One-Ounce Gold MS70 PCGS. PCGS described as a "First Strike." Satiny butter-yellow surfaces are smooth and unimpeachable. The introduction of the Buffalo one-ounce gold coins in 2006 gave the United States a pure gold competitor to similar worldwide issues, such as the Canadian Maple Leaf.

1892

2006-W $50 Buffalo One-Ounce Gold PR70 Deep Cameo PCGS. PCGS described as a "First Strike." This West Point proof embodies perfection for PCGS, with amazing contrast and utterly flawless surfaces.

1893

2006-W $50 Buffalo One-Ounce Gold PR70 Deep Cameo PCGS. PCGS described as a "First Strike." The contrast is as perfect as the rest of the coin on this one-ounce modern pure gold proof.

1894

2007-W $50 One-Ounce Gold Eagle MS70 NGC. NGC described as "Early Releases." A sharply struck coin awarded the ultimate grade by that service. A tiny spot of brightness is noted in the upper left obverse field.

1895

2007-W $50 One-Ounce Gold Buffalo PR70 Deep Cameo PCGS. Outstanding contrast with carefully preserved surfaces that stand up to even the scrutiny of magnification. Great eye appeal for this increasingly popular complement to the American Eagle bullion series.

1896

2007-W $50 One-Ounce Gold Buffalo PR70 Deep Cameo PCGS. A technically top-notch example of this popular modern pure gold issue. Both the thickly frosted devices and the textured-reflective fields are flawless.

1897

Four-Piece 2008-W Buffalo Set PR70 Ultra Cameo NGC. The set includes: $5 Tenth-Ounce; $10 Quarter-Ounce, $25 Half-Ounce; and a $50 One-Ounce. All four coins are flawless and offer unimprovable contrast between the luminous devices and the textured but mirrored fields.

1898

Four-Piece 2008-W American Buffalo Gold Proof Set. A four-piece set housed in deluxe case with information sheet, outer box, and slipcover. Includes the $5 Tenth-Ounce; $10 Quarter-Ounce, $25 Half-Ounce; and a $50 One-Ounce.

1899

2008-W $25 Half-Ounce Gold Buffalo MS70 NGC. NGC designated as "Early Releases." A technically flawless example of this fractional American Buffalo issue with rich butter-yellow luster.

1900

2009-W Proof One Ounce Gold Buffalo. A gorgeous specimen of this popular American Buffalo one-ounce proof issue of recent vintage. Housed in case of issue with box and slipcover.

1901

2009 Ultra High Relief Double Eagle in Original Packaging. A gleaming example of this popular modern issue, housed in the original government packaging: a plastic capsule in a wood box, with cardboard outer box, literature, polishing cloth, informative book, and slipcase. The front of the cardboard box has been separated to provide easy access to the wood box, otherwise very good packaging condition.

Coins of Hawaii

1902

1883 25C Hawaii Quarter MS66 PCGS. CAC. Breen-8033. The first 8 in the date is clearly repunched within the loops. Breen believed this to be an 1883/1383 overdate. Golden-brown and apple-green toning endows this lustrous and well struck Premium Gem. A loupe reveals a thin mark on the cheekbone. PCGS has graded only 12 coins finer, regardless of variety (2/10).

1903

1883 25C Hawaii Quarter MS67 PCGS. CAC. The quarter has the best survival rate of the various Hawaii denominations of 1883, though few pieces have the level of preservation offered by this Superb Gem. Intense luster shines through the pastel powder-blue, lime-green, and peach patina. Population: 12 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).

1904

1883 50C Hawaii Half Dollar MS64 PCGS. Sharply struck and highly lustrous with attractive light tobacco-brown toning that is chiefly confined to the margins. An impressive near-Gem of this scarce Barber-designed single-year type. Certified in a green label holder. Population: 56 in 64, 12 finer (2/10).

Errors

1905

1864 1C L On Ribbon Indian Cent--20% Off Center--MS63 Brown NGC. A boldly impressed representative of the elusive Indian cent error, a simple and clean off-center strike 20% off the planchet in the direction of 11 o'clock. The chocolate-brown surfaces are pleasingly preserved, and Longacre's initial is plain on the back of Liberty's neck.

1906

1972-S Lincoln Cent--Two-Coin Bonded-Mated Pair--PR63 Brown NGC. Not holdered by NGC due to the dimensions of the piece, but accompanied by a photo-certificate from the firm. On a proof press, a coin was first struck in the usual way, but instead of completely ejecting from the dies, it flipped over and partially out. A second planchet entered the dies, and the striking of the second planchet bonded it and the first planchet together. A remarkable error with the two planchets forming nearly a 45-degree angle from the horizontal.

1907

1996 1C Lincoln Cent--Double Denomination on a 1996-P Dime--MS67 NGC. This lustrous and immaculate double denomination mint error has merely a hint of golden toning. The portrait of Roosevelt gazes at 7 o'clock, relative to the Lincoln Memorial. The flame of torch overlaps Lincoln's nose. The dime mintmark is obvious, and the date digits of both the cent and dime are legible, the latter near the IC in AMERICA.

1908

2000 1C Lincoln Cent--Double Denomination on a Struck Dime--MS67 NGC. The P mintmark of the dime is visible near the cent's final A in AMERICA, but the dime date has been effaced by the overstrike. Lustrous and close to stone-white with pristine preservation.

1909

2001 1C Lincoln Cent--Double Denomination on a Struck Dime--MS66 PCGS. Lustrous and unabraded with light chestnut-tan toning. The dime date and mintmark are indistinct, located above LIBERTY. The outline of Roosevelt's head is evident, and he gazes toward 1 o'clock relative to the portrait of Lincoln. A bright, splendid high-grade example of this unusual striking error.

1910

2001 1C Lincoln Cent--Double Denomination on a 2001-P Dime--MS67 NGC. The cent date and dime date partly overlap. The cent date is sharp, while the dime date and mintmark very faint. Roosevelt gazes southwest relative to the portrait of Lincoln. The flame of the torch flickers over the Lincoln Memorial. Completely unabraded and lustrous.

1911

1969-S 5C Jefferson Nickel--Struck on a Dime Blank--MS64 NGC. 2.23 gm. Uncentered toward 9 o'clock, which allows the date and mintmark to be fully present. All of IN GOD WE TRUST and most of E PLURIBUS UNUM are absent. Softly struck at the centers due to the undersized flan. The dies are moderately rotated, a second (albeit minor) mint error.

1912

1989-P Jefferson Nickel--Double Denomination on a 1989 Cent--MS65 Red NGC. The Lincoln Memorial diagonally overlaps Jefferson's portrait. The cent date is fully readable on the nickel reverse near 6 o'clock. The nickel date is essentially complete, although all peripheral legends show distortion from metal flow toward the rim. A scarcer double denomination combination than the cent on dime.

1913

1964 25C Washington Quarter--Double Denomination on a 1964 Nickel--MS64 NGC. The nickel date is clear, as is most of IN GOD WE TRUST. The reverse of the nickel undertype is limited to the top curve of Monticello. A lustrous and lightly toned near-Gem with pleasing preservation. All the quarter legends are clear except for (appropriately) the denomination, which is distorted from unrestrained metal flow toward the rim.

1914

1964 25C Washington Quarter--Double Denomination on a Struck Lincoln Cent--MS66 Red and Brown NGC. From the cent undertype, most of ONE CENT is readable near the quarter's IN GOD WE TRUST. Most of the cent's IN GOD WE TRUST is legible near the quarter's UNITED STATES. The cent types have been effaced by the quarter strike. Lustrous and pristine. The obverse is ruby-red and apricot, the reverse is pumpkin-gold with hints of rose-red.

1915

(1964)-D 25C Washington Quarter--Double Denomination on a 1964-D Dime--MS65 NGC. The dime date is clear near the B in LIBERTY of the quarter. The dime mintmark is effaced by the quarter strike, but the quarter mintmark is bold. The quarter date is absent due to the undersized host, but it is very likely 1964 although it is possible the quarter was struck from 1963-dated dies. 1965 quarters bore no mintmark. Lustrous and untoned with pristine surfaces. An unusual double denomination combination; cents on dimes are seen much more often.

1916

1998-P 25C Washington Quarter--Obverse Die Cap--MS68 NGC. The high, narrow rim characteristic of a die cap is most prominent near 9 o'clock. The obverse strike is razor-sharp on the portrait and legends. The multistruck reverse is indistinct aside from a reversed image of Washington's nose. A unusually high grade for a mint error.

1917

1966 50C SMS Kennedy Half--Struck 35% Off Center--MS66 NGC. This 40% silver Special Mint Set coin is struck off-center due north on the planchet, so that the bottom of the planchet is unstruck and the top of Kennedy's head is off the coin, along with IBERT. A silver-white and pleasing Premium Gem coin of the middle year of the three "regular" SMS issues.

1918

1883-CC GSA Morgan Dollar--Obverse and Reverse Struck Through--MS61 NGC. Both obverse and reverse were struck through an unidentified substance, probably grease. The peripheral obverse and the lower reverse both show strike-throughs, with the center of the wreath and the middle letters of ONE DOLLAR severely weakened.

1919

1921-S Morgan Dollar--Struck 3% Off Center--AU50 PCGS. Morgan dollars are rarely found struck off center or with any other sort of error. This piece shows an arc of empty flan on the left side of obverse and reverse. The surfaces are light to medium gray in color, indicating an original coin that spent years in circulation before it was removed as an error.

1920

1974 Eisenhower Dollar--Struck on a Sintered Planchet--MS65 NGC. Darkened sintered metal appears at the lower right obverse and over much of the reverse on this Eisenhower dollar. Elsewhere, the coin shows distinctly copper-peach color with elements of iridescence.

1921

1979-P SBA Dollar--Struck on a Quarter Planchet--MS65 NGC. 5.57 gm. A subtle error that helps illustrate why the SBA dollar was short-lived. Only the outermost borders of the dollar design are cut off on the pink-tinged planchet, indicative of the two denominations' close size.

1922

2003 One-Ounce Gold American Eagle--Struck Through Obverse--MS69 PCGS. A prominent, slender strike-through cuts across Liberty's legs and lower gown. Aside from this production flaw, it is a near-perfect representative of the year's one-ounce gold American Eagle uncirculated-finish issue.

U.S. Presidents & Statesmen

1923

1897-Dated Grant Medal Struck for the ANS. Bronze, 63 mm, obverse with right-facing Presidential bust of Grant, four stars (for his general's rank) and seal of the Society below. Reverse has image of Grant's Tomb, DEDICATED NEW YORK APRIL 27 1897 around, below ISSUED BY THE AMERICAN NUMISMATIC AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL SOCIETY. Maker Tiffany & Co.

So-Called Dollars

1924

1915 Panama-Pacific Exposition Target Reverse Slug MS66 NGC. CA HK-424A. Gilt bronze, R.7. The peripheral legend is inscribed, IMITATION OF FAMOUS CALIFORNIA FIFTY DOLLAR GOLD SLUG USED BY THE PIONEERS. The fineness is listed as 000 THOU. An immaculate and fully struck facsimile slug from an exposition best known for its quartet of commemorative gold issues.

1925

1920 Wilson Dollar MS62 PCGS. HK-449. Struck in silver. 38 mm. Struck to commemorate the opening of the Manila Mint, the only overseas mint ever established by the U.S. The surfaces exude bright mint frost, and there are just the slightest marks evident. Each side is mostly brilliant but there is a slight bit of red and lilac color evident when closely examined.

World Tokens

1926

(1790s) Am I Not a Man And a Brother Halfpenny Token MS63 Brown NGC. Great Britain D&H-1038C Middlesex - Social Series. Edge: YORK BUILT A.M. 1223. Obverse: male slave in chains. Reverse: clasped hands and peripheral inscription MAY SLAVERY OPPRESSION CEASE THROUGHOUT THE WORLD. The inspiration for the extremely rare 1838 Low-54A Hard Times token. A fully struck and beautiful chocolate-brown example. Impressive despite a few specks of carbon on the right wrist.

Mint Sets

1927

(2) Uncertified 1951 Double Mint Sets. Most coins exhibit rich and attractive original toning, and grade between MS62 and MS66. The typical coin grades MS63 to MS64.

1928

Pair of Uncertified Double Mint Sets. Two double mint sets, one from 1951 and the other from 1953. Coins have moderate to heavy peripheral toning with light or minimal central color. Cents are Red to Red and Brown with varying levels of carbon. Both sets are in vintage holders and mailing envelopes.

GSA Dollars

1929

1879-CC $1 MS63 NGC. An impressive example that remains in its black plastic holder as distributed through the General Services Administration in the 1970s, and now band certified by NGC. This brilliant and fully lustrous Mint State example has frosty silver surfaces with slight reflectivity in the fields. Nearly 3 million Carson City silver dollars were distributed during the 1970s, including only about 4,000 of these 1879-CC dollars. Once coin certification began in the 1980s, many of the GSA dollars were cracked out for submission. That is essentially true of the scarce and rare dates such as this 1879-CC. Over many years we have only handled about 80 of these dollars in their GSA packaging, and many of those were the Capped Mintmark variety. Here is an extremely important opportunity.(Registry values: P7, N2998)

1930

1885-CC $1 MS65 NGC. This Gem is minimally toned with strong cartwheel luster and frosted devices. Band-certified in the black holder of issue. Comes with box and certificate.(Registry values: P4, N991)

1931

1890-CC $1 MS62 NGC. A delightful 1890-CC Morgan dollar remaining in its black case of distribution from the GSA in the 1970s, and now band-certified as MS62 NGC. The surfaces are frosty with brilliant silver luster and accents of delicate gold toning.(Registry values: P5, N491)

Session 4

Patterns

1932

1838 P50C Seated Liberty Half Dollar, Judd-77 Restrike, Pollock-85, High R.7, PR66 Red and Brown NGC. On the obverse Liberty is seated on a rock with shield and pole. A scroll draped across the shield has the inscription LIBERTY in incuse letters. Thirteen stars around and the date below. The reverse has an eagle with wings spread holding an olive branch and four arrows. The legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA around and the denomination HALF DOLLAR below. Struck in copper with a plain edge.
All examples seen of this extremely rare pattern show indications of extensive die rust. Judd-77 is a restrike issue produced for sale to collectors in the 1870s. An early auction appearance was in the Parmelee Collection (New York Coin & Stamp, 6/1890), lot 34. The preceding lot in that sale offered a specimen of Judd-76, from the same dies struck in silver. The issue was unlisted in Adams-Woodin and was not displayed in the 1914 ANS Exhibition. USPatterns.com states that four pieces are known to collectors today.
This is a magnificent specimen, with virtually faultless fields complementing an extraordinary strike. Much original mint red remains, blending gently into pale blue and chocolate-brown. The second finest certified at both services combined. At NGC only this coin, graded PR66 Red and Brown, has been certified and a specimen graded PR67 Red and Brown ★ . PCGS has certified a single coin and that is a PR63 Red and Brown (2/10).
Ex: Stewart Witham; Auction' 81 (RARCOA, 7/1981), lot 315.

1933

1852 PG$1 Gold Dollar, Judd-146, Pollock-174, R.8, PR65 PCGS. The obverse features a line design, described as a circle of six bows by early catalogers, around the central perforation. The legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA around, with 1852 below. The reverse consists of the denomination DOLLAR above and an open wreath below. Struck on an annular silver planchet with a plain edge. While Judd-146 is technically an R.7 issue, its actual availability deserves an R.8 rating. This circumstance is because no less than five examples of Judd-146 have been impounded in museum collections. This issue is less available today than it was circa 1890, before Byron Reed, J.C. Mitchelson, and B. Peyton donated their advanced collections to various institutions. Early pattern collectors were familiar with the issue, and R.C. Davis listed it as number 74 in his pioneering work on patterns. An early auction appearance of Judd-146 was in the R.C. Davis Collection (New York Coin & Stamp, 1/1890), lot 1032. In recent times, a search of auction records has uncovered only three appearances in the last 32 years.
The devices are strongly impressed, with a high wire rim above the date on the inner perforation. Pristine surfaces, with light champagne toning.
As stated above, we believe at most three specimens of Judd-146 are available to collectors today because of the high number of pieces in institutional collections. The pieces that are privately held are:
1. ANA (Stack's, 8/1976), lot 3627.
2. ANA (New England Rare Coin Auctions, 7/1979), lot 1307.
3. The Randolph S. Rothschild Collection (Stack's, 10/2003), lot 1114. The present coin.

1934

1858 P1C Flying Eagle Cent, Judd-203, Pollock-247, R.5, PR64 NGC. CAC. The obverse has a hook-necked eagle flying left with tall wings. The reverse has the denomination within an oak wreath with an olive sprig and a group of three arrows are wrapped into the bottom of the wreath. Struck in copper-nickel with a plain edge. This is a splendid, upper-end example of this popular Flying Eagle cent pattern. The obverse fields are deep cherry-red, while the reverse is primarily orange-red. The fields are deeply reflective and the overall appearance reinforces the upper-end designation given by CAC.

1935

1858 P1C Indian Cent, Judd-211, Pollock-255, R.4, AU55 PCGS. The Pointed Bust subvariety of Judd-211, described as "Rarity-7" by Pollock. The Indian cent obverse of 1859, except dated 1858, and the reverse features a broad oak wreath sans shield, the denomination as usual centered within the wreath. Struck in copper-nickel with a plain edge. Luminous peach and orange surfaces are lightly worn, as if this coin spent a brief time as a pocket-piece or in circulation.

1936

1859 P50C Half Dollar, Judd-238, Pollock-294, R.5, PR67 ★ Brown NGC. The Longacre design for the half dollar that features a bust of Liberty facing right, draped with a ribbon inscribed LIBERTY with a wide wreath of oak and vine on her head. The reverse has HALF DOLLAR in the center and is surrounded by a wreath similar to that seen on the reverse of the 1860 to 1916 dime. Struck in copper with a reeded edge. Of the 30 or so examples that are believed to exist of this pattern, this is undoubtedly the finest. There actually is a second PR67 Brown listed by NGC, but we imagine this is a resubmission of this coin and the second listing has not been dropped from their Census Report. Even though the surfaces are listed as Brown, there are significant portions of mint red around the devices and within the recesses. And rather than brown, the coin is actually predominantly steel-blue. The fields are deeply reflective and there are no mentionable or noticeable marks on either side.

1937

1859 P50C Half Dollar, Judd-241, Pollock-297, R.4, PR61 NGC. The Longacre "French Head of Liberty" design for the half dollar. The reverse displays 50 CENTS encompassed by a cereal wreath that is very similar to that introduced on the issued 1860 Seated dime, although much larger in scale. Struck in silver with a reeded edge. Sharply struck and untoned with moderate cameo contrast and wispy hairlines on the reverse field.

1938

1859 P50C Half Dollar, Judd-241, Pollock-297, R.4, PR63 NGC. The Longacre Liberty Head design for the half dollar, also known as "French Head of Liberty." The reverse has 50 CENTS surrounded by a cereal wreath. Struck in silver with a reeded edge. The obverse is generally untoned with light patina over the reverse. A few light hairlines and small contact marks explain the grade.

1939

1865 $1 One Dollar, Judd-435, Pollock-508, Low R.7, PR64 Red and Brown PCGS. The obverse die is the design adopted for regular-issue coinage of silver dollars in 1865. The reverse die is the design adopted for use in 1866, with a scroll containing the motto IN GOD WE TRUST added above the eagle's head. Struck in copper with a reeded edge. Probably a dozen or so examples of this scarce and popular With Motto issue are believed known. Each side shows significant amounts of original mint red, but it has mellowed just a bit. The devices are sharply struck throughout, and the obverse fields display horizontal striations that were not polished out of the die.

1940

1866 5C Five Cents, Judd-473, Pollock-564, Low R.6, PR65 PCGS. CAC. A bust of Washington faces right with IN GOD WE TRUST above in large letters, and the date below in tiny digits. Paired with a regular issue Shield nickel With Rays reverse, and struck in nickel with a plain edge. Housed in a green label PCGS holder, this Washington nickel pattern is a desirable piece for its association with the first President. Both sides have reflective gray fields with obvious cameo contrast. Population: 3 in 65, 1 finer (2/10).

1941

1866 5C Five Cents, Judd-473, Pollock-564, Low R.6, PR66 Cameo NGC. George Washington appeared on numerous privately minted Early American tokens, but did not appear on U.S. Mint coins prior to the 1866 five cent patterns. The obverse depicts a bust of Washington facing right and has the legend IN GOD WE TRUST. The obverse is muled with a regular issue shield nickel rays reverse. Struck in nickel with a plain edge. This is a brilliant example that has deeply reflective fields on each side that contrast against the thickly frosted devices. A lovely, problem-free example of this popular Washington type.

1942

1868 3CN Three Cent Nickel, Judd-618, Pollock-687, R.4, PR64 NGC. Similar to the regular issue three cent nickel, but the devices on both sides appear smaller relative to the field. In addition, the Roman numerals on the reverse lack the usual vertical "ribs." Struck in nickel with a plain edge. Nicely mirrored fields and lustrous devices are evident beneath pale gold toning.

1943

1868 5C Five Cent, Judd-633, Pollock-705, R.5, PR66 Ultra Cameo NGC. The overall design is similar to the circulating three cent nickel, in larger format and with a V in the central reverse to indicate a five cent piece. But Liberty has small star on her coronet, and the date 1868 is in exergue. The reverse has a wreath with small Maltese cross atop, surrounded by a scroll bearing IN GOD WE TRUST. Struck in nickel with a plain edge. Two obverse die varieties exist, High Date (Pollock-705, as here) and Low Date (Pollock-704). This is a stunning silver-white example with lots of vibrant contrast. The Lemus Collection, Queller Family Collection Part Two example that we handled in January 2009 was a PR65 Cameo specimen (lot 1678) which realized $1,955.

1944

1869 5C Five Cents, Judd-684, Pollock-763, R.5, PR55 PCGS. The obverse design is similar to the adopted three cent nickel, but in larger format, and a star is added to Liberty's coronet. The reverse features a large Roman numeral V inside a laurel wreath. At the top of the wreath are the words IN GOD WE TRUST on a scroll, and a cross rests squarely atop the design. Struck in nickel with a plain edge. This example is lightly rubbed, as if it were carried as a pocket piece, but glimmers of reflectivity remain in fields toned peach and pink. A fundamentally pleasing specimen of this intriguing variety.

1945

1869 5C Five Cents, Judd-684, Pollock-763, R.5, PR64 PCGS. Ex: Benson. Similar to the contemporary three cent nickel, but the Roman numeral V replaces the Roman III, and a Maltese cross and a scroll bearing the motto closes the reverse wreath. Struck in nickel with a plain edge. Caramel-gold and stone-gray toning blends throughout this nicely struck and undisturbed specimen.
Ex: Hollinbeck Stamp & Coin Company, circa 1945, lot 1564; Benson Collection (Ira & Larry Goldberg, 2/2003), lot 1806.

1946

1869 10C Standard Silver Ten Cents, Judd-696, Pollock-775, R.5, PR61 PCGS. On the obverse, a head of Liberty faces right, with three large stars on a Phrygian cap. The reverse is the only Standard Silver reverse dime die of the year: STANDARD SILVER around the upper edge, with 10 CENTS inside an oak and laurel wreath. Struck in silver with a reeded edge. A luminous example of this Standard Silver variant, moderately hairlined with a few small contact marks visible amid the violet and blue-gray hues.

1947

1870 10C Standard Silver Ten Cents, Judd-825, Pollock-915, Low R.7, PR63 PCGS. A figure of Liberty seated faces left. She supports a shield and a Liberty pole stands behind. The reverse shows the denomination 10 CENTS within a wreath of cotton and corn, the inscription STANDARD is above. Struck in silver with a reeded edge. Dense blue-violet toning covers most of each side of this moderately reflective example.

1948

1870 10C Ten Cents, Judd-834, Pollock-924, R.6-7, PR64 Red and Brown PCGS. Attributed to William Barber, the obverse depicts a seated figure of Liberty facing left and supporting a shield in her right hand, an olive branch in her left. A free-standing liberty pole is present behind the shield. Regular dies reverse. Struck in copper with a plain edge. Deeply toned surfaces exhibit ruby-red, orange-gold, and forest-green shades. Exemplary despite a few minute flecks and a small spot on the U in UNITED. Housed in a circa-1990 doily label holder.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 10/2000), lot 8137, which realized $2,185.

1949

1870 10C Standard Silver Ten Cents, Judd-855, Pollock-935, High R.6, PR62 PCGS. The obverse has a representation of Liberty facing right with the statutory legend above and the motto below. The reverse has a small wreath around the denomination, with STANDARD SILVER above and the date below. Struck in silver with a reeded edge. Approximately a dozen examples are known of this Judd number. The surfaces are bright and completely untoned. While lightly hairlined, the fields also display die striations that were not polished away prior to striking. A few stray contact marks and minor planchet flaws are also scattered over each side.

1950

1870 10C Standard Silver Ten Cents, Judd-861, Pollock-949, High R.6, PR63 PCGS. On the obverse the head of Liberty is wearing a diadem with a plain ribbon encircling her hair; the reverse has 10 CENTS in the center surrounded by a thick oak and laurel wreath with STANDARD SILVER 1870 at the margin. Struck in silver with a reeded edge. Sharply struck with brilliant silver-gray surfaces. Mirrored fields around lustrous devices are evident on both sides, with an area of matte gray on the reverse. Population: 2 in 63, 5 finer (2/10).

1951

1870 25C Standard Silver Quarter Dollar, Judd-888, Pollock-987, R.5, PR64 PCGS. Ex: Benson. A bust of Liberty wearing a cap ornamented with three stars facing right, the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA surrounds the figure, and a scroll with IN GOD WE TRUST is below. The reverse reads 25 CENTS 1870 in the center and is surrounded by a wreath of cotton and corn. Struck in silver with a reeded edge. Fully patinated with golden-brown, cobalt-blue, and aquamarine undertones. Smooth save for a few faint grazes on the lower right obverse field.
Ex: Benson Collection (Ira & Larry Goldberg, 2/2003), lot 1821; Baltimore Signature (Heritage, 7/2003), lot 9995.

1952

1870 50C Standard Silver Half Dollar, Judd-990, Pollock-1119, R.8, PR67 ★ Red and Brown NGC. Standard Silver design with Liberty facing right wearing a headband with a star, a scroll below, and UNITED STATES OF AMERICA above. The reverse is similar to the one used in 1869 with 50 CENTS in the center and is surrounded by a wreath of oak and laurel with 1870 below and STANDARD SILVER above. These were sold with the other denominations for $15. Struck in copper with a plain edge. This is undoubtedly the finest example known of this rare Standard Silver pattern. The surfaces appear to be flawless, even under strong magnification. The fields are exceptionally deep in their mirrored reflectivity. The obverse is mostly red with just a bit of peripheral blue. The reverse is the opposite with most of that side blue and just a dab of original red. A spectacular pattern.

1953

1871 10C Ten Cents, Judd-1079, Pollock-1215, High R.7, PR66 Cameo NGC. CAC. A figure of Liberty as imagined by Longacre is seated and facing left with 1871 below. She is wearing an Indian headdress and is supporting a liberty pole with her right hand. Her left hand rests on a globe inscribed LIBERTY. The reverse is the same design used on production issues. Struck in aluminum with a reeded edge.
One of just three or four examples known, with the fourth described in the catalog for the Palace Collections of Egypt (the former Farouk Collection), and the finest of all confirmed examples, with a PR65 PCGS and a "PR60" coin trailing. This specimen is formerly of the Jones Beach Collection among other auction appearances, and also formerly graded PR67, though a subsequent re-evaluation assessed it as PR66 Cameo, where it stands today. The surfaces are dazzling and brilliant with deep reflectivity in the fields set against frosted devices that yield a pleasing cameo effect. Remarkable quality and visual appeal.

1954

1873 25C Quarter Dollar, Judd-1270, Pollock-1412, R.7, PR64 Red Cameo NGC. Regular die trials issue for the Closed 3, No Arrows type of 1873. Struck in copper with a reeded edge. As pointed out on the USPatterns.com website, these pieces were more than likely deliberately struck for sale to collectors as part of complete off-metal sets. It is estimated that four or five exist in copper. This is undoubtedly the finest example known. The mint luster is fully intact and fiery-red over each side. The fields are deeply reflective and further enhance the tremendous eye appeal of this off-metal striking.
From The JTR Collection.

1955

1873 25C Quarter Dollar, Judd-1271, Pollock-1413, High R.7, PR65 PCGS. The obverse and reverse design is the same as that used to coin regular issue Closed-3, No Arrows type 1873 quarter dollars. Struck in aluminum with a reeded edge. This example is fully detailed, with appealing, fully brilliant surfaces that are free from contact or handling marks. There are no dull spots often seen on aluminum patterns, and the reverse displays a small, interesting die crack which extends from the eagle's left (facing) wing onto the shield. This is the only specimen of this variety to be graded by PCGS or NGC. Population: 1 in 65, 0 finer (1/10).

1956

1874 $10 Bickford Ten Dollar, Judd-1374, Pollock-1519, Low R.6, PR65 Brown PCGS. The obverse depicts a bust of Liberty facing left with the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA above and the date below. Liberty wears a diadem inscribed with the word LIBERTY and ornamented with six stars. The weight 16.72 GRAMS, the standard of the metal 900 FINE, and the word UBIQUE are centered on the reverse. Around the periphery is the U.S. denomination DOLLARS 10 and the following international equivalents: STERLING (Pound) 2.1.1; MARKEN 41.99; KRONEN 37.31; GULDEN 20.73; and FRANCS 51.81. Struck in copper with a reeded edge.
This fascinating pattern was born out of Dana Bickford's proposal to create a coin whose value was fixed in relation to that of the world's currencies. Its adoption for circulation would have placed the international monetary system on the gold standard. Most of the specimens we have handled in the past have been gilt, but that is not the case here. Well mirrored surfaces display muted amber color at certain angles and when tilted reveal flashes of blue and rose-violet iridescence.

1957

1874 $10 Bickford Ten Dollar, Judd-1374, Pollock-1519, R.6, PR65 Red and Brown PCGS. Ex: Garrett. The obverse depicts a bust of Liberty facing left with the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA above and the date below. Liberty wears a diadem inscribed with the word LIBERTY and ornamented with six stars. The weight 16.72 GRAMS, the standard of the metal 900 FINE, and the word UBIQUE are centered on the reverse. Around the periphery is the U.S. denomination DOLLARS 10 and the following international equivalents: STERLING (Pound) 2.1.1; MARKEN 41.99; KRONEN 37.31; GULDEN 20.73; and FRANCS 51.81. According to the recent Judd revision, the Latin ubique translates as "ubiquitous, or existing everywhere." Struck in copper with a reeded edge. This pattern was part of an effort to create a gold coin convenient for European trade. Mint Director Henry Linderman apparently approved of Dana Bickford's concept, but Congress failed to pass the appropriate legislation.
Judd-1374 appears at auction every few years, but the examples encountered usually have little or no remaining mint color. Only one coin has been certified with full red color, an NGC MS64. Only two pieces have been certified Red and Brown, the present coin and another by PCGS at the PR65 level. The reverse of this well struck piece retains nearly all of its original salmon-pink color, while the obverse has much Red but shows light lilac-gray toning on the field and cheek. No abrasions are detected, but a couple of tiny carbon flecks are present, with one beneath the serif of the S in DOLLARS to identify the piece. In its Garrett catalog appearance, the cataloger noted, "This is probably the finest known specimen of this issue. Certainly we have never seen an equal or nicer one." An important, well-pedigreed example of this large diameter, high denomination pattern.
Ex: Guttag Brothers to John Work Garrett, 5/27; Garrett Collection Sale 2 (Bowers & Ruddy, 3/80), lot 1092.

1958

1874 $10 Bickford Ten Dollar, Judd-1375, Pollock-1520, Low R.7, PR62 NGC. The obverse depicts a bust of Liberty facing left with the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA above and the date below. Liberty wears a diadem inscribed with the word LIBERTY and ornamented with six stars. The weight 16.72 GRAMS, the standard of the metal 900 FINE, and the word UBIQUE are centered on the reverse. Around the periphery is the U.S. denomination DOLLARS 10 and the following international equivalents: STERLING (Pound) 2.1.1; MARKEN 41.99; KRONEN 37.31; GULDEN 20.73; and FRANCS 51.81. Struck in copper with a reeded edge and gilt. This gilt piece approximates the appearance of what this pattern would look like in gold--an affordable alternative given that only two examples are known in gold (see our recent FUN Sale for photos and information about one of those legendary pieces). There are no obvious or distracting blemishes on either side, but a planchet crack is located just to the left of the date. The gilt has a subtle iridescent streakiness. An exceptionally attractive coin for the grade.

1959

1874 $10 Bickford Ten Dollar, Judd-1377, Pollock-1522, High R.7, PR64 PCGS. The obverse depicts a bust of Liberty facing left with the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA above and the date below. Liberty wears a diadem inscribed with the word LIBERTY and ornamented with six stars. The weight 16.72 GRAMS, the standard of the metal 900 FINE, and the word UBIQUE are centered on the reverse. Around the periphery is the U.S. denomination DOLLARS 10 and the following international equivalents: STERLING (Pound) 2.1.1; MARKEN 41.99; KRONEN 37.31; GULDEN 20.73; and FRANCS 51.81. Struck in nickel with a reeded edge. Only two or three of these pieces are known, and all seem to show the same die crack at 5 o'clock on the obverse. This die crack and the softness in the center of the reverse are undoubtedly from the hardness of the nickel alloy. Moderately reflective, the reverse is lightly toned and there are numerous tiny planchet flakes out of the obverse.

1960

1877 50C Morgan Half Dollar, Judd-1521, Pollock-1685, R.7, PR63 Red and Brown PCGS. The obverse features Morgan's head of Liberty facing left, wearing a cap with ears of wheat and cotton bolls. Two groups of stars surround the bust, seven to the left and six to the right. E PLURIBUS UNUM is inscribed above the head and the date is below. The intricate reverse design displays an eagle on a shield, clutching an olive branch and three arrows. The shield is tightly surrounded by a laurel wreath and a band bearing the motto IN GOD WE TRUST. The peripheral inscriptions are UNITED STATES OF AMERICA above and HALF DOLLAR below. Struck in copper with a reeded edge. The obverse design is George Morgan's famous Liberty head concept, adopted for use on the silver dollar in 1878. The model for the obverse is thought to be Anna Williams, of Philadelphia. USPatterns.com believes three or four examples of Judd-1521 are extant today. The present offering is a rare opportunity to secure this desirable issue.
Attractive orange-red patina covers the mirrored fields, while the central devices are accented with tones of blue and crimson. Reportedly cleaned long ago, the surfaces have retoned nicely. A rare and desirable prize for the advanced collector. PCGS has certified two coins total, this piece and one in PR66 Red and Brown. NGC has also graded two pieces total, each of which is graded PR66 Red and Brown (2/10).
Ex: King Farouk; Palace Collections of Egypt (Sotheby's, 2/1954), lot 1976; 188th Auction Sale (Bolender, 3/ 1955), lot 1480; River Oaks (Bowers and Ruddy, 11/1976), lot 983; Arnold and Romisa Collection (Bowers and Merena, 9/1984), lot 390; Fred/Ward Collection (Bowers and Merena, 11/1995), lot 2279; Pre-Long Beach (Superior, 2/2005); Drew St. John (American Numismatic Rarities, 6/2005), lot 418; (Bowers and Merena, 8/2005); Pre-Long Beach (Goldberg, 2/2006); June Sale (Stack's, 6/2006).

1961

1877 50C Half Dollar, Judd-1524, Pollock-1690, 1692, Low R.7, PR64 NGC. The obverse has a head of Liberty with six stars to the left, seven to the right, and the date below. Liberty wears a wide banded cap with the word LIBERTY, hair tied back with a ribbon. The cap is garnished by wheat and cotton. The reverse has an eagle on a shield inside a band that carries the dual mottoes IN GOD WE TRUST and E PLURIBUS UNUM. Around is the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA with the denomination HALF DOLLAR below. Struck in silver with a reeded edge.
Among 1877 pattern half dollars, this variety is more plentiful than most, with eight different examples currently known, according to Saul Teichman's notes, including one example of Pollock-1692 with the second 7 in the date closer to the border, from a different obverse die. On this Pollock-1690 obverse the second 7 is distant from the denticles. It is believed that eight pieces are known of this rarity.
This Choice proof is a lovely example with delicate champagne toning over brilliant silver surfaces. The fields are fully mirrored, although little contrast is evident between the fields and the devices.

1962

1879 $1 Goloid Metric Dollar, Judd-1626, Pollock-1822, R.4, PR61 PCGS. William Barber's design for the Goloid Metric dollar with a capped head of Liberty on the obverse, paired with a reverse that carries verbose statutory as well as elemental inscriptions. A circle of stars about the central inscriptions breaks the otherwise continuous wording. Struck in goloid (allegedly) with a reeded edge. Some of these pieces have undergone metallurgical testing and their goloid composition has been confirmed. This one has not, and unfortunately there is no way to visually confirm the piece's composition. The surfaces are almost untoned, and each side shows light hairlining and a few shallow field scrapes that explain the grade.

1963

1882 5C Liberty Head Five Cents, Judd-1690, Pollock-1892, R.5, PR66 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Extremely popular as a transitional pattern, Judd-1690 employs an obverse similar to the adopted 1883 Liberty Head nickel, with a slightly different arrangement of the stars. On Judd-1690, the stars behind Liberty's head seem slightly wider spaced than on the adopted design. The reverse is the same as the regular issue of 1883, the infamous No CENTS variety. Struck in nickel with a plain edge.
Judd-1690 enjoyed great popularity with pattern collectors as early as the 1880s. An example was offered at public auction in the Woodside Collection (New York Coin & Stamp, 4/1892), lot 385, "1882 Five Cents: same as adopted type of 1883: nickel: proof; rare." Note the cataloger failed to notice the subtle difference in star placement.
The present coin is a magnificent example, with deeply reflective fields and light golden-steel toning on both sides.

1964

1883 5C Liberty Head Five Cents, Judd-1704, Pollock-1908, Low R.6, PR64 NGC. Ex: Lemus Collection. The obverse is similar in design to the Liberty nickel adopted in this year, except the stars are replaced with the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. The reverse has a central inscription that reads PURE NICKEL, surrounded by a wreath of cotton and corn. FIVE CENTS is separated above and below with seven stars left and six right. Struck in pure nickel with a plain edge. The surfaces are silver-white with good contrast between the radiant fields and well-frosted devices. Some grayish haze covers a portion of Liberty and the obverse field nearby, but the overall preservation is exemplary.
Ex: Bolender Sale (6/1935), lot 1492; Stack's private treaty; Queller Family Collection Part Two (Heritage, 1/2009), lot 1948, which realized $2,300.

1965

1942 Cent, Judd-2063, Pollock-4025, Low R.7--Cracked, Complete Separation--MS62 PCGS. The obverse portrait of Liberty is taken from the KM-198 Columbia two centavos. The reverse wreath was formerly used on Baker-155 Washington medalets. The central reverse states UNITED STATES MINT instead of a denomination. Struck in tan plastic with a plain edge. The present glossy golden-brown specimen is essentially as made, but broke in half during the strike, separating relatively cleanly on an approximately diagonal path between 4:30 and 10:30.

1966

(1982) "1759" Martha Washington "Cent"--Struck on a Dime Blank--MS63 NGC. 2.3 gm. Dies of Judd-2180, but struck with a plain edge on a clad dime Type One planchet. Slightly uncentered toward 3 o'clock, but the legends are virtually intact. The rim is fully raised only on the reverse near 9 o'clock. The strike is a bit soft on the major devices, but the cream-gray surfaces are unblemished. Presumably struck circa-1982 when the cent alloy changed to predominantly zinc.

1967

(1982) "1759" Martha Washington "Cent," Judd-2180, High R.7, MS64 Red and Brown NGC. 2.5 gm. Struck with a plain edge in copper-plated zinc. Orange-gold near the rims, mellowed to light lilac shades at the centers. The Martha Washington design was first used circa-1965 to test the new clad composition for dimes and quarters, and the 40% silver composition for half dollars. The all-purpose designs have since been used on other denominations as well, presumably when their turn came for new alloys.

Gold Dollars

1968

1849 G$1 No L MS62 NGC. Bright yellow-gold luster with well struck devices. Solid eye appeal for this challenging variant. The reverse shows a few shallow pinscratches to go along with that side's die cracks.(Registry values: P4)

1969

1849 G$1 No L MS65 PCGS. CAC. Breen-6000. This No L gold dollar was the first of the year, easily identified by the broad repunching on the lowest two stars below Liberty. This Gem example with lots of prooflike luster over orange-gold fields would make a super type coin. CAC concurs. Population: 27 in 65, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

1970

1849-C G$1 Closed Wreath--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. Essentially the Closed Wreath is the only collectible C-mint gold dollar from this first year of issue. This piece shows unusually cherry-red patina, especially on the obverse. The hair details on Liberty are slightly soft, as usual, but the definition is strong elsewhere. The surfaces are free from any distracting abrasions.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1971

1849-C G$1 Closed Wreath AU58 NGC. Variety 1, the only known variety of the 1849-C Closed Wreath dollar. This near-Mint specimen has bright yellow-gold luster with deeper orange toning at the centers. Light wear is noted on the high points, consistent with the grade. Mint State and high level AU coins are plentiful, but they are also in great demand. Census: 21 in 58, 29 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

1972

1849-D G$1 AU50 PCGS. Variety 1-A, with the mintmark positioned to the left. Celebrated as the first-date-of-issue D-mint gold dollar, the 1849-D enjoyed a large mintage of 21,588 pieces. A number of coins were saved as souvenirs, making the issue quite available today, in the context of the series. An estimated 250-300+ examples are known today in all grades, with 85-95 specimens in AU. The present coin is well struck for a D-mint issue, with the typical weakness noted on the curls below LIBERTY. A crack from Liberty's nose into the obverse field is the only mark of note.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1973

1849-O G$1 Open Wreath MS63 NGC. A lustrous high end example with rich khaki-gold toning and undisturbed cartwheel sheen. The strike is precise, and there are no noticeable marks. A single-year design subtype, since all subsequent New Orleans gold dollars exhibit a close wreath. Census: 47 in 63, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1974

1849-O G$1 Open Wreath MS64 PCGS. Variety One. Because of the existence of a small hoard the 1849-O is now a more available example of this popular first-year New Orleans issue. That being said, it is still most uncommon in MS64. This is an exceptional coin that is sharply defined throughout and the obverse fields are bright and semiprooflike. Rich reddish-gold and lilac color is interspersed on both obverse and reverse. A couple of tiny field marks can be found with a magnifier. Population: 15 in 64, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1975

1850 G$1 MS65 NGC. This boldly detailed Gem 1850 gold dollar has frosty luster with rich yellow surfaces. It is an attractive example and elusive in such high grade. Despite a mintage approaching half a million coins, few have survived in Gem or finer condition. Census: 13 in 65, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1976

1850-C G$1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1, the usual reverse die for this rare Charlotte issue. Careful rotation reveals delicate diagonal obverse hairlines, and a retained horizontal lamination (as made) is noted within Liberty's hair and coronet. Sharply struck and void of noticeable marks.(Registry values: N1793)

1977

1850-C G$1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. Variety 1, the only dies for the year. From a small mintage of just 6,966 pieces, the 1850-C is the second rarest C-mint gold dollar (tied with the 1859-C). Experts estimate a surviving population of 150-250 examples in all grades and most examples seen are well worn. The present coin is sharply struck, with no distracting marks, and no trace of wear. Unfortunately, the natural color of this piece has been disturbed by an improper cleaning.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N4719)

1978

1850-D G$1 MS60 NGC. Variety 2-C, the only variety for the date. From a small mintage of 8,382 coins, the 1850-D gold dollar is a scarce and undervalued issue. The surviving population is thought to number only 110-120 examples in all grades. Doug Winter estimates the Mint State population at 6-7 pieces, but data from the grading services indicates a slightly higher number. The present coin displays the flat strike always seen on this issue, but the fields show a minimum of handling marks for the grade. Census: 5 in 60, 19 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N4719)

1979

1850-D G$1 MS61 NGC. Variety 2-C. This low mintage Dahlonega gold dollar has ample luster throughout the stars and legends, and the surfaces are unmarked aside from a thin line beneath the R in DOLLAR. Prominent clashmarks (as issued) are evident to the right of the prominent 1. Census: 6 in 61, 13 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

1980

1851 G$1 MS65 PCGS. Hints of lime-green enrich the margins of this lustrous and unabraded Gem. A slender toning streak on the lower left obverse field is of no consequence. The strike is full aside from unimportant incompleteness of selected denticles. Population: 67 in 65, 31 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

1981

1851 G$1 MS65 NGC. This frosty Gem has bright lemon-yellow luster with a hint of green. The design elements are sharp, and the surfaces are pristine. A short die crack crosses Liberty's hair below the coronet, down across the cheek, reaching the jaw. The reverse has a few darker toning splashes.(Registry values: N2998)

1982

1851 G$1 MS65 NGC. A sharply impressed yellow gold Gem of the Type One design, which was essential to commerce prior to 1853 due to a shortage of silver coins in commerce. The fields display wispy grazes, but the overall preservation is appealing. Encapsulated in a former generation holder.(Registry values: N2998)

1983

1851-C G$1 --Scratches, Rim Damage--NGC. AU Details. Variety 3. Most easily identified by the short die crack from the rim to the second S in STATES. The 1851-C is the most obtainable of Charlotte gold dollars. This piece is bright from cleaning. Additionally, there are two scratches, one above and one below the bust of Liberty, and a small rim nick is located on the rim at 12 o'clock.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1984

1851-C G$1 AU53 NGC. Variety 1. From an earlier die state without prominent reverse die crack. Dusky yellow-gold surfaces exhibit a subtle radiance. Smooth aside from a few wispy marks on the obverse field.(Registry values: N1793)

1985

1851-D G$1 AU55 NGC. Variety 3-E. From a mintage of 9,882 pieces, the 1851-D is the third most available Type One gold dollar from the Dahlonega Mint. Experts estimate the surviving population at 150-175 examples, with perhaps 60 specimens in AU grades. The obverse design elements are strongly impressed for a D-mint issue. The reverse shows weakness at the center, probably due to a dramatic die crack that quarters the upper section of the coin. The surfaces show some granular texture, but the fields are lightly abraded.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1986

1851-O G$1 MS63 NGC. Excellent central detail with lustrous butter-yellow surfaces that show peripheral orange elements. Minimally abraded for the Select designation and an all-around pleasing piece of Southern gold.(Registry values: N2998)

1987

1852 G$1 MS65 NGC. This sharply defined Gem Mint State gold dollar has frosty honey-gold luster with faint green and rose overtones. The reverse die is lapped with certain wreath details missing. The top of the ribbon bow appears to be floating in the field.(Registry values: N2998)

1988

1852-C G$1 AU55 NGC. Variety 2. The 1852-C gold dollar boasts a low mintage of 9,434 coins, with most survivors seen in the XF range. Experts estimate a surviving population of 250-350 specimens in all grades, with 70-100 examples extant in AU. Doug Winter notes this issue is extremely difficult to locate with clean fields, and the present coin has a few noticeable planchet defects in the obverse field. The details of LA in DOLLAR are blurry due to a die defect seen on most 1852-C gold dollars. Census: 17 in 55, 98 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1989

1852-D G$1 AU55 NGC. Variety 4-F, the only known variety. From a tiny mintage of 6,360 pieces, the 1852-D gold dollar is the third rarest Type One gold dollar from the Dahlonega Mint. Doug Winter estimates a surviving population of 100-110 pieces in all grades, while Q. David Bowers suspects the total may run to 200 examples. Only 40-45 coins are known in AU grades. The present coin is sharply struck for an 1852-D, and a few abrasions on Liberty's nose are the only flaws worthy of mention. Census: 15 in 55, 64 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1990

1853 G$1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Rich butter-yellow color is key to this near-Gem's eye appeal. The strike is strong, though the luster is subdued in the context of the issue.(Registry values: N1793)

1991

1853 G$1 MS66 NGC. More than 4 million gold dollars were produced in 1853, and predictably this date is a popular one for type purposes. Production quality was also high this year, as demonstrated on this piece. The surfaces are remarkably lustrous and the striking details are complete on each side. The only post-production flaws are a couple of barely discernable luster grazes to the right of the 1 in the denomination on the reverse.(Registry values: N4719)

1992

1853-C G$1 --Obverse Scratched--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. The 1853-C is a moderately scarce C-mint issue. This example has several scrapes on the obverse (mostly the lower half), and the reverse rim is abraded between 3 and 5 o'clock. Softly struck on Liberty, as usual, but the peripheral details are strong.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1993

1853-D G$1 --Reverse Damage--NGC. AU Details. Variety 5-G. Each side has bright yellow-gold color with occasional dabs of reddish patina interspersed. The devices are well struck overall. The damage on the reverse that is mentioned on the insert is in the form of several tiny, round marks that surround the 1 in the denomination.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

1994

1853-O G$1 MS63 PCGS. CAC. 1853-O gold dollars can be located with little difficulty through MS62. Select examples such as the current offering will take patience and searching. Lustrous yellow-gold surfaces are well struck and the few marks present are not serious.(Registry values: N1793)

1995

1854-D G$1 MS61 NGC. Variety 6-H. The "slow and steady" Dahlonega Mint made about one-third as many gold dollars in 1854 as in 1853, perhaps due to the added capacity from the newly opened San Francisco Mint. While the D-mint 1854 gold dollar issue was only 2,935 coins, the S-mint dollars totaled 14,632. Due to the low mintage figure and the obvious circulation of most survivors, today AU pieces are rare, Mint State coins very rare.
This Mint State example displays just a bit of central striking softness, with traces of striations in the fields. A few field marks, most notably around the 1 in the denomination, account for the grade. Winter's D-mint gold reference places the 1854-D third in high-grade rarity among the 13 D-mint gold dollars. Even with duplicates discounted, this piece is somewhat below the Condition Census for the issue. Census: 16 in 61, 9 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N7079)

1996

1854-S G$1 AU55 PCGS. CAC. Great eye appeal for this first-year San Francisco gold dollar issue. Peach-tinged yellow-gold surfaces show only minor disturbances and wear. Population: 17 in 55, 62 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1997

1854 G$1 Type Two AU58 PCGS. This sharply defined example has a bold and completely visible date, with the hair and headdress details equally sharp. Both sides have minor abrasions that are consistent with the grade.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N991)

1998

1854 G$1 Type Two MS62 PCGS. Yellow-gold luminous surfaces are blushed with tints of apricot and greenish-gray. The design elements are sharply impressed and neither side reveals mentionable abrasions. Clash marks are visible on both obverse and reverse, as frequently seen on this issue.(Registry values: N4719)

1999

1854 G$1 Type Two MS64 NGC. The year 1854 saw the introduction of the Longacre's Indian Princess design on both the gold dollar and the newly-created three dollar piece, although there were some peculiar differences. It is interesting that while the gold dollars featured a "Small Head" design, the three dollar pieces had the "Large Head" style. The Type Two gold dollars were struck for only three years until the design was altered to mirror that of the three dollar pieces.
Eye-catching satiny luster glistens beneath the reddish-gold patina. A few minuscule abrasions keep this piece from a full Gem grade. Pronounced clash marks are visible on both sides. A sharply struck and attractive representative. NGC has certified only 38 coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2000

1854 G$1 Type Two MS64 PCGS. CAC. The Small Indian Head design gold dollar was introduced in 1854 to replace the earlier Liberty Head, but it only lasted until 1856, and then only at the San Francisco Mint, as officials soon discovered a design flaw. The high points of the obverse were opposite the date, keeping it from a full strike in most cases. Even the present piece, with a better than usual strike, shows some weakness at the 8.
The surfaces are beautiful, with green-gold color and splendid rose patina. Only a few tiny marks appear on each side, along with clear clash marks on both sides. A fine near-Gem example for a type or date set. PCGS has only certified 65 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2001

1855 G$1 MS60 PCGS. A shining and unworn Type Two gold dollar, well struck from strongly clashed dies. The obverse shows a number of long, thin abrasions, including several on the portrait, which account for the grade. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N2998)

2002

1855-C G$1 VF20 NGC. Variety 2. The scarcer of the two die pairings, showing the second 5 in the date positioned further to the right under the A in DOLLAR. This Type Two Charlotte gold dollar lacks the usually seen planchet problems. The only mentionable ripples in the surface are die clashing on the obverse and a shallow, thin scratch in the right field. The devices are evenly worn and each side shows original reddish tinged color.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N1793)

2003

1855-C G$1 AU55 NGC. Variety 1. This example is consistent with the plate in Douglas Winter's 1997 text Gold Coins of the Charlotte Mint as it demonstrates a clashmark-free obverse. The characteristic traits on the reverse include a clashmark between the D in DOLLAR and the 1 in the date, and the final 5 centered below the A in DOLLAR. At the Charlotte Mint in 1855, gold coinage was poorly produced and according to Winter, the 1855-C is the second rarest Charlotte Mint gold dollar in high grades. This piece shows evidence of the poor production of the year in that it has a weak strike that in the centers of both sides; still it is much nicer than most examples a collector is likely to encounter. It has no offensive marks and shows olive-green color with light tinges of copper color at the peripheries. There is even some luster in the protected areas. To say that a 1855-C gold dollar is a handsome coin is unusual, but this one deserves the compliment.(Registry values: N2998)

2004

1855-D G$1 --Polished--NGC. XF Details. Variety 7-J. Only 1,811 gold dollars were coined at the Dahlonega Mint in 1855, making the issue the second rarest D-mint gold dollar, behind the legendary 1861-D. Only 70-80 examples survive today in all grades, and high grade specimens are extremely rare. The present coin appears to have been improperly cleaned at one time, and the surfaces are porous, especially in the center of the reverse. However, much original design detail remains intact. Overall, this coin is an affordable example of this rare and sought-after issue.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N2998)

2005

1855-O G$1 MS62 PCGS. While the 1854 and 1855 P-mint Type Two gold dollars are the ones type collectors turn to, the 1855-O is the most common among the mintmarked pieces. For type purposes, however, its mintage is less than one-tenth of the P-mint issues, and the 1855-O it becomes much rarer in the higher states of preservation. This piece boasts flashy yellow-gold surfaces that contrast with glints of hazel-gray on each side. Unlike many examples, no die clash marks appear on either side. While clash marks do not per se affect a coin's grade, some collectors prefer them, and some most decidedly do not. The strike is only weak on Liberty's hair curls and the 8 in the date. Population: 11 in 62, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2006

1856-S G$1 Type Two--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. A subdued and faintly hairlined straw-gold representative of the sole San Francisco Type Two subtype. Although the luster is impaired, there is minimal evidence of wear on the well struck devices. Moderately granular near the obverse center. Just 24,600 pieces were struck.(Registry values: N1793)

2007

1856-S G$1 Type Two AU53 PCGS. CAC. FS-501. The secondary S is wide to the northeast of the primary S. Yellow-gold surfaces retain luster in the recessed areas. The design features are well defined and the few small marks scattered about do not significantly detract. Popular as the only 1856-dated Type Two gold dollar was struck at the San Francisco Mint, with a production of just 24,600 coins.(Registry values: N1793)

2008

1856 G$1 Slanted 5 MS64 PCGS. This lovely example has satiny green and yellow-gold luster with smooth surfaces that are essentially mark-free. The strike is excellent with sharp hair detail and a strong date. This is the usually seen 1856 Type Three gold dollar. Population: 69 in 64, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2009

1856-D G$1 AU55 PCGS. Variety 8-K. The 1856-D gold dollar, from a mintage of 1,460 business strikes, is a popular rarity, with perhaps fewer than 100 coins known in all grades (Jeff Garrett and Ron Guth, 2006). A mere 23-25 pieces are believed known in AU grades with 4-5 coins in Uncirculated. This places the 1856-D as third of the 13 gold dollars in overall rarity and second in high grade rarity. This Choice AU example displays attractive orange-gold surfaces that retain ample luster. Additionally, the design elements are strongly struck, save for weakness on the U of UNITED and on the lower left reverse wreath. Population: 9 in 55, 19 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N4719)

2010

1857-C G$1 AU55 NGC. Variety 1, the only dies known for the date. Type Three gold dollars were struck in only two years at the Charlotte Mint, 1857 and 1859. With a mintage of 13,280 pieces, the 1857-C is the more available date. Approximately 300-400 examples survive in all grades, with AU specimens accounting for 40-50 pieces from that total. The present coin shows little actual wear, but the striking details are weak, as always seen on this issue. The rough, granular texture of the obverse surfaces is due to poor planchet quality, and is almost always present on the 1857-C. Census: 41 in 55, 46 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N2998)

2011

1857-C G$1 AU55 NGC. Variety 1, the only variety known. This Choice AU specimen is above average in terms of strike and planchet quality, both of which are typically extremely poor on this issue. The design elements are generally well defined, including the letters in LIBERTY. Only the 8 in the date is weak. The couple of planchet flaws are minor, as are post-strike marks. Even yellow-gold patina is apparent over both sides.(Registry values: N2998)

2012

1857-D G$1 AU55 NGC. Variety 9-L, the only variety of this year. Only 3,533 gold dollars were coined at the Dahlonega Mint in 1857. Approximately 120-130 examples are known today, with about three dozen survivors in AU grades. Doug Winter believes the issue is one of the two most underrated D-mint gold dollars, along with the 1850-D. The present coin shows little actual wear, but the striking details are weak throughout, as usually seen on this date. A curious oval of reddish color surrounds the central obverse devices and also colors the reverse borders. Census: 26 in 55, 41 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N2998)

2013

1858-D G$1 VF25 NGC. Variety 10-M. The striking details are weak, as always seen on this scarce, low mintage issue. The slightly reddish tinged surfaces show underlying brightness and each side has numerous small abrasions, most of which are evident only with magnification.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N991)

2014

1859 G$1 MS66 PCGS. Undoubtedly the mintage of 168,244 pieces gives the 1859 gold dollar an illusion of availability that is not born out in reality. It is very scarce in high grades with only six pieces graded MS66 and five others in higher condition according to PCGS (1/10). This is a lovely example that has luminous reddish-gold surfaces. The usually seen die striations are present in the fields, but there is no evidence of the often-seen die clash marks. A small area of porosity in the planchet can be seen to the right of the denomination. The striking details are complete throughout.(Registry values: N2998)

2015

1859-C G$1 --Reverse Repaired--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. The reverse is harshly cleaned and shows repairs at the center and on the rim near 10 o'clock, likely due to removal of solder from former jewelry use. The honey-gold obverse is attractive and only faintly hairlined. From a tiny mintage of 5,235 pieces.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N2998)

2016

1859-D G$1 XF40 PCGS. Variety 11-N. Two reverse dies are known despite the tiny mintage of 4,952 pieces. The sun-gold surfaces are surprisingly devoid of abrasions, and wear is less than suggested by the grade due to a typical late-era Dahlonega strike.(Registry values: N1793)

2017

1859-D G$1 AU58 PCGS. Variety 11-N. In the context of the series, the 1859-D gold dollar is an available date, much easier to locate than its mintage of 4,952 pieces would indicate. An estimated 150-175 examples survive in all grades, with an AU population of 48-60 specimens. The present coin is well struck, with a little softness on the date and denomination, but strong peripheral detail. The surfaces are an attractive greenish-gold, with hints of orange. Population: 22 in 58, 23 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N2998)

2018

1860 G$1 MS63 PCGS. The obverse of this select Mint State piece has brilliant light yellow luster and sharp design details. The reverse has a richer orange appearance. A few minor surface marks keep this from a higher grade. Population: 16 in 63, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2019

1860 G$1 MS64 PCGS. CAC. This low-mintage date (36,514 circulation strikes) is elusive in the better Mint State grades. Indeed, PCGS and NGC have certified fewer than 50 coins in near-Gem and finer condition. Strong luster emanates from the peach-gold and mint-green surfaces of this sharply struck example. Linear marks are visible on the obverse portrait. Population: 14 in 64, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2020

1860-D G$1 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 12-P, the only dies for this year. The 1860-D gold dollar was the penultimate issue of this denomination from the Dahlonega Mint. Only 1,566 examples were struck and the surviving population is estimated at 90-100 specimens in all grades. The 1860-D is famous for its weak strike, and this example is typical, with pronounced softness on the hair, denomination, and date. Most examples of this issue have been dipped or cleaned, and this specimen shows the unnatural brightness imparted by these procedures.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N4719)

2021

1860-S G$1 MS61 NGC. A sharply struck representative that has vibrant peripheral luster and a couple of wispy marks near DOLLAR. A mere 13,000 pieces were struck, and there were no West Coast collectors setting aside examples. Uncirculated survivors are rare. Census: 20 in 61, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2022

1862 G$1 MS64 PCGS. Uncommonly strong orange and peach elements enhance the golden toning of this Civil War-era Choice gold dollar. Luster is largely satiny with suggestions of greater brilliance.(Registry values: N1793)

2023

1862 G$1 MS65 NGC. Partially prooflike fields establish good contrast with the well struck, frosty devices of this Civil War-era Gem. Brass gold color covers both sides, each of which is nicely preserved.(Registry values: N2998)

2024

1867 G$1 MS63 PCGS. Flashy with strong yellow-gold luster and additional elements of violet on the obverse. Excellent detail with considerable eye appeal for the grade. Population: 5 in 63, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2025

1867 G$1 MS67 ★ NGC. The 1867 gold dollar, from a mintage of 5,200 circulation strikes, is rare in any condition. Mintage of all the smaller gold coins of this year were small; so soon after the end of the Civil War, parity between gold, silver, and paper currency had not been achieved, and any gold (or silver) coins that appeared in circulation would be immediately hoarded, exported, or melted, for the most part. The current Superb Gem offering with the NGC Star is among the finest of about 120 examples certified by NGC and PCGS, exceeded only by a single MS68 ★ coin (2/10). Semiprooflike fields highlight the frosty, sharply struck devices, and the surface preservation is impeccable. Visible die clashing appears on each side, and the reverse is rotated about 15 degrees counterclockwise.(Registry values: N1)

2026

1867 G$1 MS68 ★ NGC. Only 5,200 gold dollars were minted in 1867 during the early years of the post-Civil War Reconstruction era. Precious metals were scarcely seen at the time with large scale hoarding of gold and silver. Even copper was hoarded at the time.
The low mintage means that most of those struck had prooflike surfaces as does this piece. Both sides of this amazing Superb Gem have mirrored fields around lustrous devices. The fields exhibit heavy clash marks on both sides. This piece is the only MS68 certified by NGC or PCGS, and it received the additional NGC ★ designation. Census: 1 in 68 ★ , 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1)

2027

1869 G$1 MS63 PCGS. Peach-gold surfaces imbued with hints of sky-blue exhibit pleasing luster and sharply struck design motifs. Some faint handling marks are visible under a loupe. Population: 12 in 63, 26 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2028

1875 G$1 MS61 NGC. With just 400 business strikes produced, the 1875 is the lowest-mintage gold dollar of the post-Civil War era, and an example in any grade is a prize. This MS61 piece shows a degree of reflectivity, not at all unusual for the low-mintage, later-date gold dollars. Sharply struck with a few abrasions in the yellow-gold fields that account for the grade. Census: 4 in 61, 9 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2029

1878 G$1 MS63 NGC. A tiny mintage of 3,000 pieces confirms the scarcity of any 1878 gold dollar. Relatively few pieces were set aside. The present well struck and unabraded example is moderately prooflike, although unlisted as such on the NGC insert. A hair-thin vertical lintmark (as made) passes through the B in LIBERTY. Census: 24 in 63, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2030

1879 G$1 MS67 PCGS. In 1879, Philadelphia produced 3,000 business strike gold dollars for the second consecutive year. This Superb Gem, one of just four MS67 coins graded by PCGS with none finer (2/10), is sharply detailed with immensely lustrous, partially mirrored surfaces. Color ranges from pale green-gold to deeper sun-yellow and amber.(Registry values: N2998)

2031

1880 G$1 MS67 ★ Prooflike NGC. CAC. The mintage for the 1880 gold dollar was a mere 1,600 pieces. Because the mintage was so low, the initial die polish barely had time to diminish before the production run ceased. As a result, an inordinately large number of high grade survivors show prooflikeness in the fields. For example, at the MS67 ★ Prooflike level there are a surprising eight pieces certified by NGC (2/10). One piece is numerically finer, an MS68, but there are no ★ coins in higher grades. This is an absolutely splendid coin. It is easy to see how first-strike prooflikes and proofs were confused 25+ years ago. The fields are uniformly deep in their reflectivity, and there is even a modest amount of mint frost over the devices. The surfaces are bright yellow-gold, and one will need a strong loupe to find any evidence of coin-to-coin contact.

2032

1883 G$1 MS68 NGC. An essentially immaculate representative of this scarce gold dollar date. The strike is full except for a few denticles, and only a single small strike-through (as produced) is seen, northeast of the R in DOLLAR. The RT in LIBERTY is faint due to a lapped obverse die. Just 10,800 pieces were struck. Census: 8 in 68, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2033

1883 G$1 MS67 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. CAC. The impeccably preserved brassy-gold surfaces of this Superb Gem gold dollar yield excellent field motif-contrast. A well executed strike delivers sharp detail to the design elements, though the letters RT of LIBERTY exhibit the usual weakness as made from a lapped die. Additionally, both sides are devoid of the often-seen copper stains. In sum, outstanding eye appeal. One of only four pieces assigned "Deep Prooflike" by NGC (2/10).

2034

1887 G$1 MS65 NGC. The gold dollar denomination was waning by the time this issue came along in the late 1880s, and the production was a token mintage of 7,500 coins. Many were saved, however, by savvy collectors and dealers who saw the proverbial writing on the wall. This is a lovely Gem with golden-orange surfaces and lots of eye appeal. A well-struck piece with few abrasions for the grade. Census: 79 in 65, 73 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2035

1888 G$1 MS67 NGC. This beautiful Superb Gem is flawless aside from a nearly imperceptible green spot near the E in UNITED. The strike shows pinpoint-sharpness, except for RT in LIBERTY, which were weakened by a mint worker's lapping of the obverse die. The 1888 is more available than suggested by its low mintage of 15,501 pieces, but third-party certification rapidly dwindles above the MS66 level. Census: 53 in 67, 3 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2036

1888 G$1 MS62 Prooflike NGC. This issue is seldom found with prooflike surfaces as seen here. Both sides have light yellow-gold surfaces with a few splashes of deeper patina. Census: 4 in 62 Prooflike, 17 finer (2/10).

2037

1889 G$1 MS66 PCGS. Rich peach-gold patina laced with wisps of crimson resides on the radiantly lustrous, impeccably preserved surfaces of this Premium Gem. Exquisitely struck throughout.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2038

1889 G$1 MS67 NGC. An incredible Superb Gem with frosty yellow-gold luster and pristine surfaces. This piece is sharply defined, providing plenty of eye appeal for the connoisseur. All business strike 1889 gold dollars exhibit prominent die doubling at the base of the wreath. NGC has only certified 16 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2039

1889 G$1 MS67 NGC. A well struck and nicely preserved piece that has a shallow Mint-made planchet flaw at 12 o'clock. Along with the three dollar denomination, the production of gold dollars ceased after 1889, aside from a handful of early 20th century commemorative issues. Their small size made them a nuisance in commerce, and the denomination served little use once silver coins returned to circulation in the mid-1850s.(Registry values: N2998)

2040

1889 G$1 MS67 NGC. When it became obvious that the gold dollar denomination would be discontinued numerous high grade examples were set aside as mementoes. This is a splendidly preserved, high grade piece that displays glowing mint luster. The striking details are strong, especially on the reverse, with complete definition on the bow knot. Magnification is required to discern the few tiny marks on this Superb coin.(Registry values: N2998)

2041

1889 G$1 MS67 NGC. Numerous high grade examples are known of the 1889, but few can compare with this piece for color and overall eye appeal. Both sides have an overlay of reddish patina, and the surfaces are exceptionally clean. The mint luster is softly frosted and further enhance the attractiveness of this lovely type coin.(Registry values: N2998)

2042

1889 G$1 MS68 NGC. A flashy canary-yellow example of this popular final-year gold dollar issue, sharply struck and undeniably appealing. On the obverse, which offers a measure of watery reflectivity, only two pinpoint marks are barely perceptible in the fields. Census: 16 in 68, 0 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

Proof Gold Dollars

2043

1884 G$1 PR63 NGC. Breen-6107. The date was first punched in too low, and remnants of the first two digits are plainly evident in the field below 18 in the date. Even though 1,006 proofs were produced, the 1884 is not common as one might at first believe. This example has pronounced orange-peel texturing in the fields on each side. A couple of light contact marks and light hairlining explain the grade of this deeply mirrored proof.(Registry values: P1)

2044

1886 G$1 PR63 PCGS. The 1886 gold dollar has a proof mintage of 1,016 pieces. This places it in the type coin category, and as such it is one of the few proof gold coins available at a relatively modest price. The fields are deeply reflective on both obverse and reverse, and each side is well-matched in overall appearance. The surfaces display deep reddish-gold color with the occasional dab of lilac. A few light hairlines and a couple of contact marks explain the grade.(Registry values: P1)

Early Quarter Eagles

2045

1807 $2 1/2 --Obverse Scratched--NGC. Unc Details. Breen-6124, BD-1, R.3. The only variety known for the year. The 1807-dated obverse die is a new one (not an overdate), and the reverse is left over from 1805. The flag of the 1 lies squarely over Liberty's lowest hair curl, and the apex of the 7 touches the bottom of the bust. On the reverse, UNITED is high and the eagle clutches 13 arrows in its left (facing) talons. The NGC disclaimer stems from the prominent, upside-down, Y-shaped scratch in the right obverse field. Another far less-noticeable scratch appears on the reverse, running from the left (facing) wing down to the rim through the U in UNITED. Despite the no-grade slab, this coin is still remarkably lustrous, with just the slightest hint of "cabinet friction" on the obverse. The central design is slightly softly struck on each side.(Registry values: P5)

2046

1834 $2 1/2 Capped Bust Genuine PCGS. Breen-6137, BD-1, R.6. The last of the Capped Bust quarter eagles, produced to a recorded extent of only 4,000 coins. Bass-Dannreuther estimate that only 20 to 24 examples survive today, due to the high melt rates that these old-tenor coins were subjected to. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has been harshly cleaned. The fields are hairlined on both sides. The color is an appealing golden-orange, however, and a pleasing amount of detail is present, along with some moderate, scattered abrasions. A very rare early gold type coin.(Registry values: P9, N9)

Classic Quarter Eagles

2047

1834 $2 1/2 Classic AU58 NGC. Breen-6138, Small Head, R.1. Flat, less pronounced hair curls at the top of Liberty's head identifies this variety. The yellow-gold surfaces of this near-Mint State example take on apricot, reddish, and mint-green hues. Light circulation marks do not detract.(Registry values: P1)

2048

1836 $2 1/2 Block 8 AU50 NGC. Head of 1834, Breen-6142, McCloskey-B, R.3. A pleasing, briefly circulated example of this scarce and desirable variant. Luminous yellow-gold surfaces exhibit distinct orange elements at the lightly abraded margins.(Registry values: P1)

2049

1838 $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. CAC. Breen-6146, R.2. Only one die pair is known for the 1838 quarter eagle, and although it is priced as a type coin, the issue is substantially scarcer than its 1834 and 1836 predecessors. Usually encountered in VF to AU grades, the 1838 is rare in Mint State, and is seldom encountered with the quality and eye appeal of the present sharply struck piece. Original and lightly marked with attractive honey-gold color. Encapsulated in a green label PCGS holder. Population: 10 in 62, 12 finer (5/08).
Ex: Guadalupe Collection (Heritage, 1/2006), lot 4708; Charleston Collection (Heritage, 6/2008), lot 1805, which realized $8,740.(Registry values: P1)

2050

1838-C $2 1/2 --Bent, Harshly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. Variety 1. This first year of issue is popular in all grades. The Bent designation refers to a surface wave noticeable near OF on the reverse. Both sides are granular from a harsh cleaning and there are several shallow scratches in the fields on each side. The striking details are a bit soft, especially on the reverse, as typically seen.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2051

1839-C $2 1/2 --Obverse Damage--NGC. VF Details. Breen-6149, McCloskey-A, Variety-1, R.3. This popular obverse mintmark issue is highly sought out in all grades. There are several short scrapes above Liberty's head and a single one at the back of the neck. The obverse shows much better definition than the reverse; in fact, about 20 points better. Rich reddish patina is seen over each side.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P5)

2052

1839-D $2 1/2 Genuine PCGS. Variety 1-A, McCloskey-A, R.3. The PCGS number ending in .82 suggests Filed Rims as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of a VF specimen with filed rims that has been cleaned. This low mintage Dahlonega Classic quarter eagle is unduly bright from polishing, has a wandering faint pinscratch near the right side of the portrait, and displays light file marks where the encapsulation allows viewing, most notably at 10 o'clock on the obverse.(Registry values: P4, N4)

2053

1839-D $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. Variety 1-A, McCloskey-A, R.3. Eagerly sought out by collectors as the only D-mint Classic quarter eagle. The surfaces are bright from cleaning, but have taken on a slight overlay of reddish patina that helps give the piece a more natural appearance. The centers are weakly struck on both sides, and the only mark of note connects the bottom of ES in STATES.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2054

1839-O $2 1/2 --Rim Filing--NGC. AU Details. High Date, Wide Fraction, Breen-6152, McCloskey-A, R.3. Still-lustrous yellow-gold surfaces show few significant abrasions, though the upper obverse and much of the reverse exhibit rim filing. Otherwise, an attractive example of this Classic quarter eagle issue with the 'O' mintmark on the obverse.(Registry values: P3)

Liberty Quarter Eagles

2055

1840-C $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned----NGC. AU Details. Variety 1, the only known variety. An important, rare C-mint from the first year of the new Gobrecht design. Only 60-85 pieces are believed known in all grades. This piece was lightly cleaned but is only slightly bright as a result. Curiously, the centers are better struck than the peripheries. A few light marks are scattered about, consistent with the grade, but there are none of the usually seen planchet problems.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2056

1840-C $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Variety 1. Luster beckons from the borders of this attractively detailed Choice AU Charlotte representative. The fields are subdued and void of distracting marks. The mintmark moved to the reverse for the introductory date of the Liberty quarter eagle series. Census: 28 in 55, 41 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2057

1840-D $2 1/2 AU50 NGC. Variety 1-A. The year 1840 saw the first use of the Liberty Head design on Dahlonega quarter eagles. The issue is rare in all grades, due to the small mintage of 3,532 pieces. Approximately 65-70 examples are known today and Doug Winter believes the date is the rarest Dahlonega quarter eagle in AU50 or better grades (5-8 estimated AU survivors). The present coin displays a typical strike for the issue, with weakness present on both sides and more detail evident on the obverse. Some small abrasions on Liberty's face are consistent with the grade. Census: 8 in 50, 14 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2058

1841-C $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Variety 1, as are all known examples of this issue. This lovely near-Mint example has brilliant green-gold luster with pleasing surfaces that show only a few minor imperfections. Only a few finer examples of this rarity are certified. NGC and PCGS have graded just seven Mint State pieces between them. Census: 28 in 58, 6 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2059

1841-D $2 1/2 XF45 PCGS. Variety 2-C. From a tiny mintage of 4,164 pieces, the 1841-D quarter eagle is a scarce coin in all grades. The surviving population is estimated at 75-85 examples, with 28-31 pieces in XF grades. The present coin shows only moderate wear, and the surfaces are highlighted with shades of green and crimson. This specimen was well struck, and much original detail remains intact. No important distractions are noted. Population: 14 in 45, 14 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2060

1841-D $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Variety 2-C. Uncommonly well struck for the popular Georgian branch mint, with blending of design limited to the hair near Liberty's ear. A pale gold Choice AU example with a small area of subdued surface beneath the hairbun. A stingy 4,164 pieces were struck for this challenging Dahlonega date. Census: 8 in 55, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2061

1842 $2 1/2 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .95 suggests Scratches or Rim Dents as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an XF specimen that has been Scratched. Both sides of this lemon-yellow example are moderately abraded, though it is the scrape from the olive branch to the bottom of the shield on the reverse that accounts for the Genuine designation.(Registry values: P2, N2)

2062

1842-C $2 1/2 XF40 NGC. Variety 1, the only known dies for this issue. From a low mintage of 6,729 pieces, the 1842-C is one of the scarcest quarter eagles from the Charlotte Mint. Only 100-125 examples are believed to survive, with approximately 30-35 specimens in XF grades. The present coin shows moderate even wear on all surfaces, with much original detail still evident. No significant distractions are noted. Census: 9 in 40, 39 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2063

1842-C $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Variety 1, the only known variety. From a tiny mintage of 6,729 pieces, the 1842-C quarter eagle is seldom encountered in any grade. The surviving population is estimated at 100-125 examples in all grades. At the AU level coins are decidedly rare, with perhaps 12-16 specimens qualifying for the designation. The present coin is a pleasing specimen, with lightly abraded fields, and attractive yellow-gold color. The strike is typical of the issue, with some weakness on the centers and lower stars. Census: 8 in 55, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2064

1842-D $2 1/2 VF20 NGC. Variety 3-F, the only known variety. The 1842-D is a rare D-mint with only 75-85 pieces known in all grades. The devices are evenly worn over the high points on each side, and the bright surfaces show numerous small to medium-sized abrasions.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2065

1842-D $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Variety 3-F. A moderately circulated example, devoid of consequential contact and toned in green-gold shades that deepen near the rims. Problem-free Dahlonega quarter eagles are limited relative to the demand from Southern gold specialists. Only 4,643 pieces were struck. Census: 5 in 53, 21 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2066

1842-O $2 1/2 XF40 NGC. Light greenish-gold surfaces exhibit minor handling marks that are consistent with the grade. With a mintage of 19,800 coins, the 1842-O is obviously scarce, and strong collector demand is anticipated when this piece crosses the auction block.(Registry values: P2)

2067

1842-O $2 1/2 MS61 PCGS. Antebellum O-mint gold coins form a rewarding collector specialty all their own in U.S. numismatics. The numbers of gold coins produced annually in New Orleans were generally low, due to the relative scarcity of domestic U.S. gold until the historic Gold Rush era. Many early O-mint gold issues are rarer in high grade than commonly thought. However, given the emphasis many collectors place on C- and D-mint gold pieces, some real values can be had among the O-mint coins.
The 1842-O quarter eagle is a case in point. Produced to the extent of only 19,800 coins, the issue has among the lowest mintage figures of any O-mint quarter eagle. Examples are scarce in any grade, and the number surviving in Mint State is far less than the inflated population data would indicate. This specimen displays bright, semiprooflike fields with rich reddish-tinged coloration throughout. The strike is excellent, save for a hint of softness on the eagle's feathers. The numerous small abrasions account for the grade but are individually insignificant. Population: 5 in 61, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2068

1843-C $2 1/2 Large Date, Plain 4 VF25 PCGS. Variety 1, the only known variety. This is a bright reddish-gold example with the expected softness of detail over the high points. The surfaces are remarkably clean, especially considering this piece's extensive use in the channels of commerce. Struck from rotated dies, and housed in a green label holder.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2069

1843-C $2 1/2 Large Date, Plain 4--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details.
Variety 1, the only known variety. Only 50-80 individual pieces are believed known in the AU grade range. As expected, the centers are somewhat softly struck, and as often seen the fields are bright with a slightly semireflective appearance. However, both sides are bright and show evidence of cleaning.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2070

1843-C $2 1/2 Large Date, Plain 4 AU58 NGC. Variety 1, the only dies for the year. From a substantial mintage of 23,076 pieces, the 1843-C Large Date quarter eagle is one of the more available issues from the Charlotte Mint. Approximately 250-350 examples are known today, with a population of 50-80 specimens in AU grades. The present coin features much better striking details than usually found on this date, and the pleasing surfaces are minimally abraded. Census: 24 in 58, 17 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2071

1843-C $2 1/2 Large Date, Plain 4 MS61 NGC. Variety 1. This variety is easily distinguished not only by the Plain 4 but by the visible larger date, with a 1 that nearly touches the lower bust. The C mintmark is repunched along its outside left curve. This piece has excellent eye appeal, with somewhat prooflike surfaces and original greenish-gold color. Minor abrasions constitute the grade. Census: 9 in 61, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2072

1843-D $2 1/2 Small D AU50 PCGS. Variety 4-F. The 1843-D quarter eagle boasts the largest mintage of any D-mint quarter eagle at 36,209 pieces. As might be suspected, the issue remains the most available Dahlonega quarter eagle today, with approximately 250-300 examples known. An estimated 60-75 specimens have been preserved in AU grades, but the date is quite rare in Mint State. The present coin is sharply struck for a D-mint issue and the surfaces are free of distracting abrasions. Population: 28 in 50, 75 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P1)

2073

1843-D $2 1/2 Small D AU58 NGC. CAC. Variety 4-F. The die crack that passes through the F in OF and into the field distinguishes this most common variety of the year. Near-Mint State coins such as the current offering are the best condition most 1843-Ds can be found, as Mint State pieces are rare. Yellow-gold surfaces exhibit well struck devices and are minimally abraded. Census: 46 in 58, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

2074

1843-D $2 1/2 Small D AU58 NGC. Variety 4-D. A band of bright luster fills the peripheries, and both sides are surprisingly free from detrimental marks. The strike is impressive for the remote Dahlonega branch mint, and wear is generally limited to the eyebrow and the hair above the ear. Census: 46 in 58, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

2075

1843-D $2 1/2 Small D MS61 NGC. Variety 4-F. An untoned and only lightly abraded Mint State representative of the legendary Dahlonega Mint. Satin luster shimmers from the borders and devices. The design elements are nearly as sharp as would be expected for a quarter eagle of the same vintage from the Philadelphia Mint. Census: 11 in 61, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

2076

1844-C $2 1/2 AU58 PCGS. Variety 1. The 1844-C quarter eagle is one of more difficult C-mint issues, with relatively few and often well circulated survivors from a mintage of just 11,622 coins. The striking quality of the '44-C is generally poor and these deficiencies can be compounded by various planchet flaws as well. This piece displays characteristic green-gold color with a slight mixture of reddish patina. There is normal softness in the centers and ample evidence of luster can be seen about the devices. Population: 13 in 58, 5 finer (2/10).
Ex: Central States Auction (Heritage, 5/2000), lot 7563.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2077

1845-D $2 1/2 AU58 PCGS. Variety 6-I, the only known variety. The 1845-D quarter eagle is scarcer than its mintage of 19,460 pieces would indicate, particularly in high grade. The surviving population of this issue is estimated at 150-175 pieces, with 28-32 examples in AU grades. The present coin is well, but not fully struck, with sharp stars and denticles. A scratch from Liberty's head to star 12 is the only mark of note. Population: 16 in 58, 8 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2078

1846 $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Rich yellow-orange luster is scarcely dimmed by the light wear crossing the high points. All things considered, an appealing example of this pre-California Gold Rush issue.(Registry values: P2)

2079

1846 $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. The 1846 quarter eagle is extremely rare in Mint State, scarce in all grades, and generally unrecognized for its rarity. More than 30 years ago David Akers wrote these remarkable words concerning the issue:

"This is a very scarce and generally unappreciated date. Its number of appearances at auction (45 [out of 226 auctions between 1921-1975]) is lower than for many of the highly regarded dates in this series such as the 1848 CAL., the 1881, and the 1796 No Stars, to name just a few. As the auction records show, specimens better than EF are extremely rare."

Even today, only a small handful of Mint State coins have been certified, with duplications almost certain. This piece offers bright, semiprooflike fields that border on fully prooflike, an effect enhanced by the die striations in the fields appearing under a loupe. The obverse is fully struck, while the usual softness occurs on the eagle's left (facing) leg. One contact mark above Liberty's head apparently accounts for much of the MS62 grade, as the coin appears that it would otherwise grade even higher. Population: 5 in 62, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2080

1846-C $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1, the only known variety. Production in 1846 was limited to just a few months at the end of the year, and only 4,808 quarter eagles were produced. As a result the 1846-C ranks near the top of the overall and high grade rarities among C-mint quarter eagles. Significant portions of original prooflikeness remains around the devices on each side. Light planchet flaking is seen on each side, as usual, and there are several clashmarks around the eagle on the reverse.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2081

1846-D $2 1/2 XF45 NGC. Variety 7-K. The 1846-D quarter eagle boasts a moderate mintage of 19,303 pieces, and is usually seen in the VF-XF grade range. Reasonably available for a D-mint issue, the total population probably consists of 175-200 examples, with perhaps 58-67 specimens in XF grades. The present coin is well struck, with only moderate wear on the surfaces. Some shallow scratches on the obverse are not distracting, and are consistent with the grade.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2082

1847-C $2 1/2 XF40 NGC. Variety 1, the only known variety. The popularity of the 1847-C lies in its relative availability in most grades and subsequent use as a type coin. This bright yellow-gold example shows contrasting russet-gray patina surrounding the devices. A few short field scratches are seen on each side. The strike is a bit soft in the centers.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2083

1847-C $2 1/2 MS60 NGC. Variety 1. The only variety known. Bright yellow-gold surfaces display luster in the areas around and the interstices of the design motifs. Well struck except for the usual softness on the eagle's legs. Some minute surface and rim marks are noted. Available with little difficulty in circulated grades, but much more difficult in Mint State. Census: 7 in 60, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2084

1847-D $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Variety 9-M. Glowing yellow-gold luster is particularly ample on the reverse. Crisply struck for a Dahlonega issue, although Liberty's eyebrow and hair above the ear show slight wear, as expected of the grade. Light marks near the eagle's beak and the coronet tip are barely worthy of mention. A mere 15,784 pieces were struck.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2085

1847-O $2 1/2 AU58 PCGS. The 1847-O quarter eagle is one of the most poorly struck coins from the New Orleans Mint. This scarce near-Mint State example displays above-average definition, as seen on the stars, Liberty's hair, and most of the eagle's plumage. Only the left (facing) leg is soft. Yellow-gold surfaces retain considerable luster and are minimally abraded. Population: 7 in 58, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2086

1848 $2 1/2 AU50 NGC. Considerable luster remains on each side of this pleasing piece, representing a surprisingly scarce date with a mintage of a mere 6,500 coins. The pleasing yellow surfaces have a few minor blemishes that are consistent with the grade.(Registry values: P2)

2087

1848-C $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned, Rim Damage--NGC. XF Details. Variety 1. A moderately available issue with an estimated 80-100 pieces available in XF condition. The surfaces are lightly hairlined but now show a slight overlay of reddish patina that helps subdue the effect. The exergues display lacquer residue. There are numerous small defects on the rims of each side, and some may warrant closer inspection as they may have been Mint-created.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2088

1848-C $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Variety 1. The 1848-C is one of the more available C-mint quarter eagles, but it still has limited availability in Almost Uncirculated condition with only 28-36 pieces believed extant. This example has the expected soft definition on Liberty's hair curls and the peripheral stars. The surfaces are bright yellow-gold and there are only minor abrasions in the fields.(Registry values: P2)

2089

1848-D $2 1/2 AU58 PCGS. Variety 10-M. Light yellow-gold fields have strong, almost flashy luster. The striking quality is excellent, and only the barest trace of friction affects the high points. A long, thin scrape at the central obverse influences the grade. Population: 28 in 58, 19 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2090

1848-D $2 1/2 MS61 NGC. Variety 10-M. From a small mintage of 13,771 pieces, the 1848-D quarter eagle is still one of the more available issues from the Dahlonega Mint. Doug Winter believes the surviving population may total 175-200 examples, but only 9-11 specimens are in Mint State grades. Population data may be inflated by resubmissions. The present coin is sharply struck and lustrous, with bright semiprooflike fields. A scattering of insignificant handling marks on the reverse is consistent with the grade. Census: 8 in 61, 12 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2091

1849-C $2 1/2 VF30 NGC. Variety 1, the only known variety. A scarce C-mint quarter eagle with only 125-150 examples known. Of those approximately half are in VF. The surfaces are well worn over the high points and appear to be softly struck as well. There are numerous small abrasions peppered over each side, but the only one of note is located between stars 2 and 3. The yellow-gold color has taken on a slight reddish cast.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2092

1849-C $2 1/2 AU53 PCGS. Variety 1, the only known dies for the date. The 1849-C quarter eagle boasts a low mintage of 10,220 pieces, and examples are scarce in all grades today. Estimates of the surviving population range from 125 to 150 pieces. Only 30 to 40 specimens are extant in AU grades. The present coin displays attractive green-gold surfaces, with a minimum number of abrasions. The peripheral design elements are strongly impressed, with a little softness evident on the centers. Population: 8 in 53, 21 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2093

1849-C $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Variety 1, the only known variety. A nicely detailed straw-gold Charlotte representative that has glimpses of orange toning about the stars. Both sides are devoid of noticeable abrasions. A low mintage of 10,220 pieces ensures the rarity of AU survivors. Census: 16 in 53, 42 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2094

1849-D $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Variety 12-M, the least available variety, with the low 1 in the date. From a mintage of 10,945 pieces, the 1849-D quarter eagle is one of the least available quarter eagles of the 1840s in Mint State. Doug Winter puts the total surviving population of the issue at 115-135 examples, with 25-31 pieces remaining in AU grades. The present coin displays better than average surfaces, with attractive orange-gold color. Census: 13 in 53, 95 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2095

1850-C $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned, Scratches NGC. XF Details. Variety 2. A moderately available C-mint quarter eagle in spite of the low mintage of only 9,148 pieces. Of the estimated 175-225 remaining examples, at least one-third are XF. The surfaces are bright from cleaning, and there are several scratches on the obverse but only one we see on the reverse.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2096

1850-C $2 1/2 XF45 PCGS. CAC. Variety 1. The mintmark is located between the claw and arrow feather, touching both. A completely problem-free green-gold Choice XF Charlotte two and a half. A good strike apart from the customary softness on the eagle's left (facing) leg. A mere 9,148 pieces were struck. Population: 18 in 45, 55 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2097

1850-D $2 1/2 AU53 PCGS. Variety 13-M, the only dies for the year. A moderate mintage of 12,148 quarter eagles was accomplished by the Dahlonega Mint in 1850, and the issue is the most available D-mint quarter eagle of the decade. Today, the surviving population is thought to number 125-150 pieces, with more than three dozen specimens in AU grades. The present coin displays unabraded surfaces, with lovely deep green highlights, mixed with lighter shades of golden-brown and crimson. Population: 18 in 53, 36 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2098

1851-C $2 1/2 --Polished, Reverse Scratched--NGC. VF Details. Variety 1. Noticeably bright from a wipe, and a narrow but relatively deep scratch is present on the upper reverse field. The two diagonal obverse strike-throughs are as made, and are frequently seen on this low mintage Charlotte issue.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2099

1851-D $2 1/2 AU53 PCGS. Variety 14-M, the only known dies for this date. A small mintage of 11,264 quarter eagles was accomplished at the Dahlonega Mint in 1851 and the issue is undervalued by most collectors today. An estimated 100-110 survivors are known in all grades, with about two dozen examples in AU grades. The date usually trades in the same price range as several more common dates in the series, such as the 1849-D and 1850-D. The present coin is an attractive example, with only minor abrasions and slight wear on the surfaces. A strike-through (wire?) in the reverse dentils at 10 o'clock is noted. Population: 10 in 53, 11 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2100

1851-O $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. A few faint scratches and other minor imperfections are only visible with close inspection on this near-Mint quarter eagle. This date is relatively plentiful due to the California gold discovery of two years earlier. This piece is sharply detailed with traces of orange toning over the green-gold surfaces.(Registry values: P2)

2101

1852-C $2 1/2 --Mount Removed, Harshly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. Variety 1. The surfaces are glossy from cleaning, and the obverse border between stars 1 and 3 may have been whizzed. Evidence of a former mount is difficult to confirm. A scant 9,772 pieces were struck.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2102

1852-C $2 1/2 AU55 PCGS. Variety 1, the only dies for the date. The meager mintage of 9,772 pieces makes the 1852-C quarter eagle a challenging issue in all grades. Experts believe a total of 115-165 examples of the date survive today, with only about 30 specimens qualifying for an AU designation. The present coin is sharply struck for a C-mint issue, but the surfaces show the mint-made roughness characteristic of the date. Attractive bright greenish-gold color enhances the overall visual appeal. Population: 12 in 55, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2103

1852-C $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Variety 1, the only variety for the year. Because no quarter eagles were minted at the Charlotte Mint in 1853, the small mintage of 9,772 coins from 1852 had to meet the needs of the regional economy for both years. As a result, the 1852-C quarter eagle is usually found in well-circulated condition. Doug Winter estimates the surviving population at 115-165 examples, with 23-32 specimens in AU grades. On the present coin, the strike is well executed on the peripheries, with some softness on the central devices. The surfaces are an attractive green-gold color, with minimal abrasions. Census: 21 in 58, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2104

1852-D $2 1/2 Fine 12 PCGS. Variety 15-M. A tiny mintage of 4,078 pieces ensures the rarity of this Dahlonega quarter eagle. The devices are well worn, but the legends are clear, and the only noticeable mark is a horizontal pinscratch above the eagle.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2105

1853 $2 1/2 MS64 PCGS. Sharply struck and satiny with rich yellow-orange color. An attractive near-Gem that shows a single tiny mark close to Liberty's chin. Population: 58 in 64, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2106

1853-D $2 1/2 VF30 PCGS. Variety 15-M, the only dies known for the date. Only 3,178 quarter eagles were coined at the Dahlonega Mint in 1853. The issue is very scarce today, with an estimated surviving population of just 85-95 pieces. Most examples seen are in the VF-XF range, and Doug Winter suggests perhaps 29-32 specimens are known in VF grades. The present coin shows moderate even wear on the surfaces, with all major design elements distinct and plainly visible. Abrasions are minimal for the grade. Population: 2 in 30, 52 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2107

1854-C $2 1/2 --Harshly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. Although glossy from a wipe, this challenging Charlotte Mint quarter eagle has pleasing definition and lacks visible abrasions. A mere 7,295 pieces were struck.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2108

1854-C $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Variety 1. Splendid canary-gold coloration radiates from both sides of this near-Mint State example. The mintage of the 1854-C was only 7,295 coins, and most certified survivors average XF45 or so, although examples are known up to MS63. The strike is somewhat weak in the centers, as usual for the issue, but the peripheral details are well brought up. We note a small scrape from star 1 to the neck. This is an extremely appealing coin overall. Census: 21 in 58, 19 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2109

1854-O $2 1/2 MS61 PCGS. CAC. A flashy example of this popular O-mint quarter eagle issue with remarkable honey-gold reflectivity. Though a number of light marks and wispy abrasions are visible in the fields, the sharply struck devices are comparatively well-preserved. A high-end representative sure to catch the attention of dedicated Southern gold specialists. Population: 8 in 61, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2110

1855-C $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Variety 1, the only known variety. The 1855-C gold dollar boasts the lowest mintage of any individual date C-mint quarter eagle at 3,677 pieces. The famous 1843-C Small Date has a lower mintage, but it only represents a part of that year's production. A small population, probably not more than 85-105 examples, survives today. The number of specimens in AU grades is in the neighborhood of 24-28 pieces. The 1855-C is noted for its poor strike, but the present coin shows more central detail than most examples. The surfaces are remarkably free of distractions. Census: 9 in 53, 47 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2111

1855-D $2 1/2 XF45 PCGS. Variety 18-M. One of just 1,123 pieces coined of this issue, easily the most difficult condition rarity of the Dahlonega quarter eagles. Only 45-55 pieces are believed known in all grades, and the 1855-D is first in the Dahlonega quarter eagle series in both overall rarity and high grade rarity. This is a pleasing copper-gold XF coin with a notable Mint-made planchet lamination that extends from the obverse rim at 8 o'clock almost to Liberty's ear, but such laminations are commonly seen on 1855-D quarter eagles. Otherwise, the surfaces are free from any distractions. The striking details are weak as usual, with die crumbling seen on the denticles on each side.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2112

1856-C $2 1/2 --Obverse Scratched--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. Numerous criss-cross pinscratches affect the obverse, and both sides are moderately bright. Shallow strike-throughs on the field near star 1, the arrowheads, and the eagle's neck are as produced and are common to this difficult issue.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2113

1856-C $2 1/2 MS61 NGC. Variety 1. A scant emission of 7,913 pieces ensures the rarity of this Charlotte issue, struck at a time when California-mined gold was no longer diverted to East Coast mints. This unmarked representative has light apricot-gold color and occasional granularity from the strike-throughs associated with the '56-C. Census: 8 in 61, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2114

1857-D $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. Variety 20-M. This challenging quarter eagle hails from one of the most historic years in U.S. numismatics. The old "large coppers" were discontinued, and the S.S. Central America sank in a hurricane off the coast of South Carolina. Inland in Dahlonega, Georgia, the fledgling branch mint had been producing modest amounts of gold coins for nearly two decades but was approaching the end of its utility. The production of quarter eagles in 1857 was a mere 2,364 pieces, up from the previous two years (including the amazingly low-mintage 1856-D at 874 pieces) but still a paltry amount. Interestingly for a mint with a generally spotty quality record, it managed to produce the 1857-D quarter eagles with excellent appeal.
This piece offers bright, nearly prooflike fields with traces of die striations evident around the peripheries, and it is remarkably well struck. The surfaces sport yellow-gold color predominating, with generous amounts of lilac and deeper reddish patina interspersed on each side. In MS62 this piece is near the upper end of the Condition Census for the issue, tied with a few other pieces, while NGC and PCGS have each certified a single MS63 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2115

1857-S $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Light yellow-gold surfaces display hints of pink toning and retain nearly full luster. The mintmark is large and fills most of its space, touching the bottom of the central motif and nearly touching the numerator in the fraction.(Registry values: P2)

2116

1858-C $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. This later-date Charlotte two and a half is sharply struck and minimally abraded for the grade. Moderately bright, but no hairlines are readily evident. Rare, as only 9,056 pieces were issued.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2117

1859-D $2 1/2 AU50 PCGS. Variety 21-M, the only known dies for the date. The 1859-D quarter eagle is an extremely popular date because of its low mintage of 2,244 pieces and its status as the last D-mint quarter eagle. The issue is more available today than one would expect, with approximately 120-140 examples known in all grades. An estimated 42-52 specimens survive in AU grades. The pleasing greenish-gold surfaces of this coin are relatively unabraded, unusual for this issue. Population: 9 in 50, 57 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2118

1859-S $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. This low-mintage issue was made after the San Francisco Mint had been open only five years, and the facility was clearly concerned with coining its first Seated dimes, quarters, half dollars, and dollars, all of which were produced in larger quantities than the quarter eagle. (The double eagle coinage was also quite large.) The quarter eagles were struck with the old-style hub featuring larger letters and heavier arrows, although some of the P-mint coins were struck with the new reverse. This piece is well-produced save for minor strike weakness in the centers. Excellent luster appears, and marks are minor and grade-consistent. This MS62 coin is the only one so certified at PCGS, although three examples have been graded finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2119

1860-C $2 1/2 --Obverse Repaired--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1, the sole dies. A richly detailed but cleaned Charlotte quarter eagle. The cheek has been carefully smoothed and has a slightly sunken appearance. Just 7,469 pieces were struck.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2120

1860-C $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Variety 1. A well defined and minimally abraded straw-gold Borderline Uncirculated representative. The reverse field has scattered small strike-throughs of mint origin, as seen on many better grade examples of this elusive late antebellum Charlotte issue. Census: 33 in 58, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2121

1860-C $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Variety 1. The year 1860 saw the last production of quarter eagles at the Charlotte Mint. Only 7,469 examples were struck by the famous facility in its last gasp before the Civil War. Scarce in all grades today, experts believe a total of 155-205 specimens survive, with 35-45 pieces in AU grades. The present coin features the typical sharp strike on the obverse, with the reverse details a trifle soft at the center. A few small abrasions on Liberty's face are consistent with the grade. Census: 33 in 58, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2122

1861 $2 1/2 New Reverse, Type Two MS62 PCGS. CAC. This exactingly struck quarter eagle exhibits the slender arrowheads Type Two reverse, as do most examples of this Civil War date. Refreshingly void of abrasions, although faint mint-made clashmarks are evident.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2123

1861 $2 1/2 New Reverse, Type Two MS63 PCGS. A well struck and lustrous Select quarter eagle. The few grade-defining marks are inoffensive.(Registry values: P2)

2124

1866 $2 1/2 MS62 NGC. This coin hails from the year that Congress passed the Metric Act sponsored by Rep. John Adam Kasson, chairman of the House Committee on Coinage, Weights, and Measures and a man who would achieve later numismatic fame in conjunction with the 1879-1880 gold stella coinage. The mintage of 1866 quarter eagles was a stingy 3,080 pieces plus 30 proofs, and the issue is a rare one in any grade. It is very rare in Mint State; we can account for only nine certified appearances of finer coins than this piece in the last dozen years.
The present coin offers bright yellow-gold color. The fields are noticeably semireflective, with die striations evident in the fields under magnification. On the reverse above the eagle's head, a dark area appears to be a light grease stain struck into surface at time of manufacture. Both the die striations and a soft strike are typical for the issue. This coin is softly defined in the centers, especially on the hair curls and upper arrow and the eagle's left (facing) leg. Only light abrasions are noted overall. Census: 2 in 62, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2125

1868-S $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. CAC. The yellow-gold surfaces of this near-Mint State example retain a fair amount of luster. Some faint circulation marks do not detract. Census: 72 in 58, 25 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2126

1872 $2 1/2 AU58 PCGS. CAC. With just 3,000 business strikes produced, the 1872 quarter eagle is part of a string of underrated post-Civil War dates. This minimally worn yellow-gold example has effusive, partially reflective luster and few significant marks. Population: 9 in 58, 2 finer (2/10).
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2127

1873 $2 1/2 Open 3 MS64 PCGS. This pleasing near-Gem is powerfully struck and splendidly smooth, although careful rotation beneath a lens locates a couple of nearly imperceptible hairlines. The eye appeal is exemplary. Population: 54 in 64, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2128

1877-S $2 1/2 MS62 NGC. This impressive Mint State piece is elusive and desirable. The mintage was a mere 35,400 coins, and few have survived finer than this example. The surfaces are fully lustrous and the design elements are boldly detailed. Both sides exhibit a blend of light yellow and deeper green-gold tones. Census: 56 in 62, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2129

1877-S $2 1/2 MS63 PCGS. Boldly impressed for this San Francisco issue with flashy fields that range in color from straw-gold to wheat and peach. There are no singularly mentionable abrasions, confirming the Select designation. A great example of this challenging issue with a five-figure mintage. Population: 18 in 63, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2130

1878 $2 1/2 MS64 PCGS. Effusive luster is pale yellow-gold with suggestions of canary. A solidly struck near-Gem with noteworthy visual appeal. PCGS has certified just 35 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2131

1878 $2 1/2 MS65 NGC. This sensational Gem quarter eagle is an important condition rarity in the Liberty series. It is boldly detailed on both sides, with lovely orange-gold luster and pristine surfaces. Here is a remarkable coin for the connoisseur, a coin that will be a highlight of any quarter eagle collection. Census: 29 in 65, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2132

1884 $2 1/2 MS60 PCGS. A well-defined, mildly reflective piece that shows no trace of wear, though both sides exhibit extensive wispy abrasions and a handful of more serious marks. Nonetheless, a fundamentally appealing example of this low-mintage issue. Population: 3 in 60, 28 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2)

2133

1885 $2 1/2 MS64 PCGS. A memorably low production figure of 800 business strikes is the first point of attraction for the 1885 quarter eagle. The mintage figure for the double eagle was a tad lower, at 751 pieces, but the quarter eagle is sometimes overlooked. With coinage figures so low, one wonders why the Mint bothered with production at all. The focus in 1885 at the Philadelphia Mint was clearly on Morgan silver dollars, which were churned out to the amount of 17.8 million coins. But for the gold denominations, even the tiny production of 1885 gold dollars, 11,000-plus coins, pales alongside the quarter eagle and double eagle figures.
This piece appears fully deserving of a Prooflike modifier on the insert, although none is present. The strike is full, and only a few small field marks on the obverse prevent an even higher grade. The surfaces throughout show a rich, even coating of reddish-tinged coloration. Population: 7 in 64, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2134

1886 $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. Strongly struck with mildly prooflike fields, as often seen for this low-mintage issue. Canary-gold and butter-yellow surfaces have light to moderate abrasions. Population: 15 in 62, 18 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P2)

2135

1886 $2 1/2 MS63 PCGS. As one would expect from an issue with a mintage of only 4,000 pieces, the fields have a distinctly prooflike glimmer on each side. The striking details are also expectantly complete throughout. Rich reddish-tinted patina covers the surfaces with a few tiny field marks that explain the grade. Population: 13 in 63, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2136

1892 $2 1/2 MS63 PCGS. Rich orange-gold color adorns both sides of this lovely Select quarter eagle and a well executed strike imparts strong definition to the design features. Partially prooflike fields yield modest contrast with the devices at various angles. Scattered marks limit the grade. Housed in a green label holder. Population: 13 in 63, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2137

1894 $2 1/2 MS64 PCGS. A scarcer, low-mintage date with a mintage of only 4,000 pieces. This is a lovely, high-end example that displays swirling mint luster over each side. The bright yellow-gold surfaces are lightly abraded and the reverse has one faint alloy spot below the right (facing) wing. Sharply defined. Population: 19 in 64, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2138

1896 $2 1/2 MS66 NGC. CAC. A gorgeous Premium Gem that has forest-green margins and peach-gold interiors. The strike is unassailable, and no marks are evident. Although a few examples are graded higher, the present example will please even the most demanding numismatist. Just 19,000 pieces were coined. Census: 24 in 66, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2139

1896 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. A lustrous and unabraded apricot-gold representative that boasts dazzling luster and a needle-sharp strike. Only 19,070 pieces were struck, and although a number were set aside in MS62 to MS64 grades, Premium Gems are rarities. Population: 19 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2140

1897 $2 1/2 MS68 NGC. Although not as rare as some of its immediate predecessors, the 1897 had a mintage of a scant 29,700 pieces--significantly lower than any quarter eagle of the following decade. Gem Mint State examples are scarce, and anything better is exceedingly rare. This MS68 representative is one of two graded as such by NGC; they are tied for finest certified, as PCGS reports none at that level (2/10).
Scintillating satiny luster enhances the medium-yellow patina of this exquisitely struck piece. The surfaces look pristine to the unaided eye, and even with a strong loupe this fabulous coin appears nearly perfect. This resplendent representative should suit even the most discerning collector.(Registry values: P2)

2141

1898 $2 1/2 MS67 NGC. Despite a mintage of just 24,000 business strikes, the 1898 quarter eagle is surprisingly accessible in most grades. An MS67 survivor like this coin, on the other hand, is tied for finest in the combined certified population (2/10) and a condition rarity. Bold yellow-orange luster offers peach overtones, and the sharply struck devices are practically flawless to the unaided eye. A noteworthy coin for the high-end type or date collector.(Registry values: P2)

2142

1899 $2 1/2 MS67 NGC. Few late-date Liberty quarter eagles can be considered underrated, but the 1899 is such an issue. Only 27,350 pieces were struck for circulation, and it appears that relatively few were set aside by collectors in superior condition. To date (2/10) the grading services are evenly split (4/4) with coins in MS67 with only one finer. As one would expect the surfaces of this piece are nearly perfect. The soft mint luster is original and shows a slight intermingling of lilac and reddish patina. An exceptional coin for the collector who wants something more than a type piece.(Registry values: P2)

2143

1901 $2 1/2 MS65 PCGS. Fantastic eye appeal graces this Gem quarter eagle, which can be attributed to its beautiful orange, mint-green, and lilac coloration, sharply struck devices, and intense luster. Additionally, both sides display excellent preservation. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2144

1901 $2 1/2 MS66 NGC. Both sides are beautifully toned in variegated apricot-gold and mint-green and traces of lilac. Sharply struck save for a touch of the usual softness in the centers. This is a highly appealing Premium Gem.(Registry values: N1793)

2145

1902 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Even apricot-gold color adorns both sides of this radiantly lustrous quarter eagle and a well executed strike leaves sharp detail on the design elements. A few grade-consistent marks are unimportant.(Registry values: N1793)

2146

1902 $2 1/2 MS67 PCGS. CAC. While common through MS66, 1902 quarter eagles are scarce in Superb Gem and extremely rare any finer. This highly lustrous MS67 displays an olive-gold cast. A powerful strike leaves sharp delineation on the design elements and both sides are impeccably preserved. Population: 32 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2147

1903 $2 1/2 MS66 NGC. Vibrant luster endows both faces of this well preserved yellow-gold Premium Gem, and a solid directed strike leaves sharp definition on the design features. Great overall eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

2148

1905 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Deep peach-gold patination imbued with hints of greenish-gray resides on the radiantly lustrous surfaces of this marvelous Premium Gem. The strike is solid throughout and both sides are well cared for.(Registry values: N1793)

2149

1905 $2 1/2 MS66 NGC. Intense luster endows this yellow-gold Premium Gem tinted with greenish-tan and a decisive strike imparts strong definition to the design elements. A well preserved piece.(Registry values: N1793)

2150

1905 $2 1/2 MS67 NGC. Apparently the demands of circulation were minimal in 1905 as numerous examples of this date are known in Uncirculated grades. However, as with most coins, the number of Superb examples is far fewer than the number of collectors who desire to own such a piece. This extraordinary example has the usual soft mint frost and is strongly struck throughout. The only mark of note is a tiny speck of grease that was struck into the coin at the time of production, located just above the eagle's right (facing) wing.(Registry values: N2998)

2151

1907 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Variegated mint-green and peach-gold patina embraces the highly lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem. This is a sharply struck specimen that has been well cared for.(Registry values: N1793)

2152

1907 $2 1/2 MS66 NGC. Glowing luster emanates from the peach-gold surfaces of this lovely Premium Gem. The design elements show a nice even strike and there are no mentionable marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2153

1907 $2 1/2 MS66 NGC. Vibrant luster exudes from the golden-tan surfaces of this well struck Premium Gem. Neither side reveals noteworthy marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2154

1907 $2 1/2 MS67 NGC. An amazing Superb Gem, approaching the finest ever certified, this sharply defined piece has brilliant yellow luster with hints of green at the borders. The surfaces are pristine and frosty, combining to form excellent eye appeal. NGC has only certified four finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2155

1907 $2 1/2 MS67 NGC. Shining surfaces are pale yellow-gold, and the strike is sharp on this 20th century Superb Gem Liberty quarter eagle. A small peach alloy spot is noted between stars 4 and 5, adding character to the piece. A great example for the type collector, with just four numerically finer examples known to NGC (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Liberty Quarter Eagles

2156

1896 $2 1/2 PR62 Cameo NGC. A tiny mintage of 132 pieces confirms the rarity of the proof 1896 quarter eagle. This is a fully struck representative that has no indication of highpoint friction, although the glassy fields display faint scuffs from non-numismatic storage. A fleeting opportunity to acquire this desirable proof issue in a collectible grade.(Registry values: P2)

Indian Quarter Eagles

2157

1908 $2 1/2 MS64 PCGS. Strong yellow luster with elements of sun-gold. This well struck near-Gem is minimally abraded with solid eye appeal for its first-year issue.(Registry values: N1793)

2158

1908 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Bela Lyon Pratt ably took up the mantle of Augustus Saint-Gaudens with the design of the Indian Head quarter eagles and half eagles, an innovation in coinage design that was as roundly condemned at the time of issue (in most quarters) as it is generally praised today. The first-year 1908 quarter eagle mintage was somewhat more than a half-million pieces. More examples of the new lower-denomination coins were saved, and today examples can be obtained up to the Superb Gem level. This piece's hallmark is rich mint luster that complements a lack of noticeable abrasions. As always seen on the issue, the top of the eagle's wing is weak, but elsewhere the strike is impeccable.(Registry values: N4719)

2159

1908 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. The year 1908 marks the first year of the Indian Head quarter eagle series. Its mintage of more than one-half million pieces and its relatively high survival rate make it a popular coin for type purposes. Even Gem examples can be located with a bit of patience and searching. The issue becomes scarce in MS66 and is seen only infrequently any finer.
The lustrous surfaces of this Premium Gem are endowed with pretty orange-gold and mint-green patina. A well executed strike imparts sharp definition to the design elements, the sole exception being the typical softness on the eagle's shoulder. A few minute reverse field marks are within the parameters of the designated grade. Population: 87 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2160

1909 $2 1/2 MS64 PCGS. The 1909 is available with little difficulty through near-Gem. That said, this MS64 specimen displays highly attractive peach-gold patination imbued with traces of mint-green. Its design elements are sharply impressed, including the eagle's shoulder. A hair-thin mark in the upper-right reverse field is all that stands in the way of a finer grade. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N2998)

2161

1909 $2 1/2 MS64 NGC. CAC. An intricately struck and satiny near-Gem that has the pastel green and apricot toning characteristic of many undisturbed Federal gold coins. Refreshingly free from scuffs or bagmarks. The Liberty quarter eagle series can be completed in the MS64 grade, a task nearly impossible to achieve in any other gold series.(Registry values: N2998)

2162

1909 $2 1/2 MS64 NGC. Softly frosted yellow-gold luster shows glimpses of orange. Each side is carefully preserved with distinctly above-average detail. An attractive example of this popular second-year Indian quarter eagle issue, available for a price in Choice condition but increasingly scarce any finer.(Registry values: N2998)

2163

1909 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Premium Gem, the level of preservation of the present offering, is the finest grade in which the 1909 quarter eagle can realistically be acquired. Indeed, PCGS and NGC have certified none finer than MS66.
The sharpness of strike stands out on this example. The headdress feathers show excellent detail, as does the eagle's plumage, including that on the shoulder. Exceptionally lustrous with attractive apricot-gold patina laced with whispers of mint-green. An inoffensive hair-thin mark is noted to the left of the Indian's neck. Population: 16 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2164

1910 $2 1/2 MS64 NGC. The 1910 is a better date among early Indian Head quarter eagles, with a moderate mintage of 492,000 pieces. The present coin is sharply struck, with intricate detail evident on the headdress and eagle's breast. The surfaces are a pleasing yellow-gold, with hints of honey and brown. A few scattered handling marks near the obverse stars are consistent with the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2165

1910 $2 1/2 MS65 PCGS. Splashes of lilac and mint-green visit the orange-gold surfaces of this Gem, yielding highly attractive patination. Sharply struck design elements, including the peripheral ones that are often weak, complement the pretty coloration. Impeccable preservation rounds out the coin's eye appeal.(Registry values: N4719)

2166

1910 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. The 1910 Premium Gem quarter eagle offered in this lot is one of the few available in this lofty grade level. Both sides display beautiful orange-gold patination intermittently splashed with silver-green and lilac. Added to this is highly attractive luster and a decisive strike that imparts sharp delineation to the design elements. The surfaces are remarkably smooth for the issue, which often reveals distracting abrasions, mint-made spots, and planchet defects (David Akers, 2008). In sum, this example possesses strong eye appeal, an attribute that often eludes the 1910. Population: 7 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2167

1911 $2 1/2 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Well-defined for the issue with bold yellow-gold luster. A near-Gem example of this Indian quarter eagle issue with eye appeal to spare.(Registry values: N2998)

2168

1911 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Quarter eagles of 1911 are readily obtainable through MS63. Near-Gems become a little more difficult to acquire, and Gems are scarce. Coins grading any higher are infrequently seen.
We present in this offering the finest PCGS-certified 1911 quarter eagle. NGC has graded only six specimens in this level of preservation, and none finer (2/10). Rich orange-gold patina imbued with traces of sky-blue and lavender adorns each side. The luster is full and highly pleasing. Aside from a handful of light handling marks the surfaces are smoother than ordinarily seen.
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2169

1911-D $2 1/2 XF45 PCGS. Pleasing orange-gold patination runs over the luminous surfaces of both sides of this Choice XF quarter eagle. The design features exhibit relatively strong definition despite high-point wear. In this regard, we note that the mintmark stands out on this specimen. A few minor marks are noted, more so in the reverse fields.(Registry values: N1793)

2170

1911-D $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. The famous key date, offered here with only a touch of wear across each side. Though a past cleaning has affected the yellow-gold luster and left light hairlines in the fields, the coin displays well. A number of light pinscratches are visible in the upper and right reverse fields.(Registry values: N2998)

2171

1911-D $2 1/2 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. The introduction of third-party grading services more than two decades ago solved an age-old numismatic problem. Counterfeit 1911-D quarter eagles and counterfeits of many other important key date coins, such as the 1909-S VDB cent in particular, were frequently seen before the grading services began operations. Almost immediately, NGC and PCGS, as well as other services, began spotting counterfeit coins and took steps to eliminate them from the marketplace. Today, the best anticounterfeit technique is simply to purchase coins that have third-party endorsements. Genuine third-party certified coins provide the collector with the best defense against counterfeiting.
This piece shows a high wire rim around the right side of the obverse, a characteristic seen on all authentic 1911-D quarter eagles. The mintmark is especially bold on this example, and the surfaces show only slight evidence of cleaning. This piece would fit comfortably in many Uncirculated sets of Indian quarter eagles.(Registry values: N2998)

2172

1911-D $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. A strongly struck example of this 20th century gold classic, amply lustrous with only a trace of wear visible on the yellow-gold surfaces. The faint abrasions on each side have minimal influence on the eye appeal, mostly isolated save for a small grouping to the left of the eagle's legs.(Registry values: N2998)

2173

1911-D $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. This perennially popular key date requires patient searching to locate nice, affordable examples. The mingy mintage of 55,600 coins meant that the issue was rare from the outset, and few examples were saved. This piece would fit well into an Uncirculated set at a considerable savings. The surfaces have nearly full mint luster, and marks are few, even on the exposed Indian's cheek. The mintmark is low relief, but its outline is complete, with a clear central opening.(Registry values: N2998)

2174

1911-D $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Lustrous lemon-yellow coloration and nearly complete, full mint luster are hallmarks of this key date example. A small tick is noted on the Indian's cheek, along with a hint of rub. The strike is boldly impressed, including a clear mintmark. A popular, low-mintage issue, the 1911-D is always in demand.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2175

1911-D $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. When selecting a 1911-D quarter eagle, collectors should consider several factors including strike, surfaces, and eye appeal. A bold strike is paramount, since many of these coins have a weak mintmark. Those with a bold, clearly visible mintmark are most desirable and in great demand. They are the coins that will still be in demand when time comes to part with a collection. Since the fields of all Indian head coins are usually abraded, surface quality is extremely important. Examples with few marks in the fields are the most desirable. Look for smooth and lustrous fields on both sides. Eye appeal is also an extremely important factor, perhaps the most important, as Michael Fuljenz and Douglas Winter write in A Collector's Guide to Indian Quarter Eagles: "The quality of eye appeal seen on the 1911-D Quarter Eagle varies greatly. There are some very handsome coins known in all grade ranges, but most collectors wind-up with an example that is very low-end for the grade. ... An otherwise unexceptional set can be made very desirable with the addition of a very nice 1911-D."
This would be just such a desirable addition to any set of quarter eagles. The all-important mintmark is fully brought up, and the only area of weakness is the lowest feather of the headdress that is usually seen weak. The surfaces are remarkably clean for the grade and exhibit light, even reddish patina.(Registry values: N4719)

2176

1911-D $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Ex: Norweb/Bass. The Norweb Collection was a legend while still owned by its namesake family, and while two decades have passed since the three auctions that dispersed most of it, time has only added to its importance to collectors. Quality and rarity are the chief watchwords; no discussion of early copper, colonials, proof silver, or early and Southern-Western gold would be complete without acknowledging the Norweb influence and legacy. Rarities such as a Gem Proof 1829 Small Planchet half eagle and an 1885 Trade dollar stand out in the auction, as does the famed 1861 Paquet double eagle.
Similarly, Harry W. Bass, Jr. built his knowledge and his collection into formidable forces whose effects on current and future numismatists continue to unfold. While his study of early gold coinage is first to come to mind (especially to those who peruse the early gold listings in this catalog, which are attributed by Bass-Dannreuther numbers), though as with the Norwebs, he also had extensive holdings in Charlotte and Dahlonega gold, as well as classic proof gold.
With all of the emphasis on the two collections' 18th and 19th century rarities, a number of important later pieces in both collections have gone under the radar of many enthusiasts. Doubtless the Norwebs' 20th century holdings would be better-remembered if their 1913 Liberty nickel had been sold at auction and not turned over to the Smithsonian, for example. Similarly, the detailed note-taking of Bass did not extend to 20th century issues, which were less interesting to a student of die varieties than their forebears.
Yet both collections contained a number of important 20th century coins, both recognized at the time of auction and unheralded but now appreciated. This 1911-D quarter eagle was one of the former, a coin that attained considerable individual fame with its modern-era debut at the Norweb auction; it had been sold to the Norwebs by B. Max Mehl, likely in the late 1930s. It was graded MS64 by the auctioneers, who then went on to say, "We have never seen a finer specimen."
From 1988 to 1999, it went from auction block to auction block, with a stay in between in the Bass collection. Its 1999 auction appearance took on a retrospective tone. It rated the MS64 grade of 1988 as "quite conservative" and readily agreed with the then-current PCGS grade of MS65. The 1999 description also took pains to note that while there were other coins graded MS65 known (and two graded MS66), "few can hold a candle to the Norweb-Bass coin."
Between 1999 and January 2005, when Heritage first offered the Norweb-Bass 1911-D quarter eagle, it was elevated in grade from MS65 to MS66, putting it on a numeric par with the other two Premium Gems known to PCGS. Those three coins are still the only examples at that level in the PCGS Population Report with none finer, as of (2/10), as the coin comes full circle again with another Heritage auction appearance.
The coin is instantly memorable, with sharp detail down to the often-weak pendants in the necklace, and even the mintmark is clear when the eye is focused on the area. The surfaces have potent luster of the type more commonly associated with the best type issues. The dominant color is yellow-gold, though a measure of peach-orange visits the reverse margins. Remarkably well-preserved with no marks of any consequence on the portrait; the clean cheek in particular is a revelation. In short, a coin that is sure to be held in high esteem for decades to come.
Ex: B. Max Mehl, believed late 1930s; Ambassador and Mrs. R. Henry Norweb; The Norweb Collection, Part II (Bowers and Merena, 3/1988), lot 2122, where it realized $30,800; The Harry W. Bass, Jr. Collection, Part II (Bowers and Merena, 10/1999), lot 643, where it realized $63,250; The H.R. Luchs Collection (Heritage, 1/2005), lot 30421, where it realized $161,000.
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N10218)

2177

1911-D $2 1/2 Weak D--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. The Denver mintmark is low relief but fully present. This lightly circulated key date Indian quarter eagle is moderately glossy from cleaning, but this only allows collectors with mortgages to complete their set of the popular gold series.(Registry values: P3)

2178

1912 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. A pleasing run of Premium Gem Indian quarter eagles has been consigned to the present sale, providing collectors with an opportunity to improve an existing collection, or begin a new set. The entire design is rare in MS66 or finer grades, and specific dates can be impossible to locate when needed.
This bold representative has brilliant orange-gold luster with frosty surfaces and sharp design elements. Only a few trivial and entirely inconsequential abrasions are evident, preventing a higher grade. Population: 5 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N7079)

2179

1913 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. A sensational Premium Gem, and one of the finest existing 1913 quarter eagles, this piece exhibits frosty luster with brilliant pinkish-gold surfaces. Both sides have bold design motifs. A few abrasions are consistent with the grade. This 1913 Indian two and a half has excellent eye appeal. The mintage of 722,000 coins was the largest of the entire design from 1908 to 1929, yet examples in Gem or finer grades are highly elusive. Here is a great opportunity for the advanced collector to acquire one of the few MS66 PCGS coins certified. Population: 5 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2180

1914 $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. Soft yellow-gold luster with glimpses of peripheral peach and orange. A well struck example with just a few too many wispy abrasions to qualify for Select status.(Registry values: N1793)

2181

1914 $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. Rich sun-gold luster lends this moderately abraded quarter eagle unusually strong eye appeal for the grade. Well struck with complete outlines on the necklace.(Registry values: N1793)

2182

1914 $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. A satiny-frosty piece with decidedly above-average luster and detail. Wheat-gold surfaces are lightly abraded overall, and a long line is noted on the portrait's cheek.(Registry values: N1793)

2183

1914 $2 1/2 MS63 NGC. The 1914 Indian Head quarter eagle has long been popular, due to its low mintage of 240,000 pieces, and the high production values employed in striking this issue. The present coin shows the sharpness of detail observed on most examples of the date. The pleasing yellow-gold surfaces are free of distracting handling marks and exhibit stronger luster than usually seen on a 1914.(Registry values: N2998)

2184

1914 $2 1/2 MS67 PCGS. This is the single finest 1914 quarter eagle in the combined certified population (2/10), but that fact, while impressive, is not the most important aspect of this Superb Gem's condition rarity. For the entire Indian quarter eagle series, the PCGS Population Report shows just four MS67 coins with none finer! Two pieces dated 1908, one coin dated 1929, and this 1914 example are the only options for the collector seeking a PCGS-graded Superb Gem.
Of the three dates, the 1914 is far and away the most elusive, adding an extra element of desirability. Its mintage of 240,000 pieces marks it as the Philadelphia date with the lowest production, and only the famous 1911-D has a lower mintage across all issues. As in the official mintage figures, the 1914 is also the second-lowest representation in the PCGS Population Report, with only about 350 more certification events than the key date. While the close figures can be explained largely by the presence of many circulated 1911-D quarter eagles, the numbers do open up another window on how challenging the 1914 issue can be.
This subtly frosted gold-orange beauty looks every bit the Superb Gem, with impressive detail and remarkable preservation. On the reverse, a handful of tiny marks are visible in the fields, but these minuscule flaws have effectively zero bearing on the eye appeal. This is an important opportunity that may not be repeated for years to come, and the wise prospective purchaser will bid accordingly.
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N7079)

2185

1914-D $2 1/2 MS63 PCGS. CAC. Yellow-gold luster through the centers takes on distinct orange overtones at the rims. Boldly impressed for this Denver issue, particularly on the necklace.(Registry values: N1793)

2186

1914-D $2 1/2 MS64 NGC. CAC. Lustrous yellow-gold surfaces are splashed with mint-green and lilac, being somewhat more extensive on the obverse. Portions of the headdress feathers are weak, as typically seen. The eagle's shoulder and the leg feathers, however, display an above-average strike. Minor marks in the reverse fields deny Gem status.(Registry values: N2998)

2187

1914-D $2 1/2 MS65 PCGS. For most of its 137-year existence the quarter eagle denomination was the red-headed stepchild of U.S. numismatics, too small for the demands of international banking and commerce, too large for many day-to-day transactions. The mintage history of the denomination reflects that national ambivalence, as its production was sporadic, with large gaps. The most notable pause was from 1915 to 1924, an entire decade when no quarter eagles at all were coined. An even longer hiatus occurred from 1808 to 1820, a 12-year period with no quarter eagles made.
Production of the denomination at the Denver Mint was equally spotty. Opening in 1906, the facility made Liberty Head half eagles and eagles in its very first year. But it would be 1911 before Denver made its first quarter eagles with the new Bela Lyon Pratt Indian Head style. The 1914-D quarter eagle would be the next coinage at Denver three years later, and the 1925-D would conclude the quarter eagle run, 11 years after the 1914-D.
Even when the denomination was made, it was produced in fairly small numbers compared to the half eagle; for the entire Indian Head quarter eagle series, not a single issue at either Philadelphia or Denver came close to approaching the 1 million-coin mark.
In the case of the 1914-D quarter eagle, the production was a generous 448,000 pieces, but most of them appear to have circulated--likely in the West, where a hard money tradition that began during the 1850s California Gold Rush would last until the onset of the Depression and the Gold Recall of 1933. The average certified 1914-D quarter eagle grades about MS60. Gem pieces such as the present coin, while occasionally available, are genuinely rare items. PCGS has certified 39 examples at the Gem level, and there are none finer at either service (2/10).
This piece offers bright satiny luster on both sides, with equal amounts of reddish-gold and lilac intermixed. There are no mentionable marks, and in that regard this is a remarkable example. As often seen on the issue, minor strike softness is here confined to the lowest feather of the headdress. A fantastic candidate for a fine type set. Population: 39 in 65, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N7079)

2188

1915 $2 1/2 MS64 NGC. CAC. Strong yellow-gold luster with a generally crisp strike. Distinctly better surface quality and eye appeal than on more commonly seen MS63 coins.(Registry values: N1793)

2189

1915 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. The 1915 quarter eagle, sporting a mintage of 606,000 circulation strikes, is one of the most obtainable dates in high grades. PCGS and NGC have certified several thousand pieces through the near-Gem level of preservation. The population declines precipitously in MS65 and again in MS66, where the two services combined have graded a mere seven specimens, and none finer.
Both sides of this Premium Gem display radiant luster, an extremely unusual trait for the date. The design motifs exhibit virtually complete definition, including the central areas that are sometimes weak. A couple of minute milling marks in the upper right reverse field are mentioned only because they might help in pedigreeing the coin. Population: 3 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2190

1925-D $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. The Indian series of quarter eagles is conveniently divided into two periods. The first are those coins struck from 1908 through 1915, and the second starts in 1925 and continues through 1929. This 1925-D represents the beginning of the second period, and these late dates are usually slightly more common than the earlier pieces.
This stunning Premium Gem has amazing yellow-gold color with lemon highlights. The surfaces are fully brilliant with frosty luster and the design details are boldly defined. Here is a remarkable example, tied for the finest that PCGS has certified. Population: 30 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2191

1926 $2 1/2 MS64 NGC. A brassy-gold appearance is evident over both sides of well struck near-Gem. A few minor marks in the raised exposed fields of the upper reverse preclude Gem status.(Registry values: N1793)

2192

1926 $2 1/2 MS65 PCGS. CAC. Beautiful peach-red toning dominates this well struck and shimmering Indian gold type coin. The reverse is remarkably devoid of contact, and the obverse has only a few delicate field grazes. A colorful contribution to a complete collection of this highly collectible gold series. Encased in a green label holder.(Registry values: N2998)

2193

1926 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. The Indian quarter eagles are interesting coins that feature a raised design sunken below the level of the surrounding fields. Some have called them "incuse" design coins, although that is incorrect. The sunken relief design was a first on any U.S. coin, and will probably never be repeated.
This boldly detailed Premium Gem is a splendid representative with brilliant and frosty yellow-gold luster hosting iridescent accents. It is tied for the finest that PCGS has certified, and a candidate for a top quality PCGS Set Registry collection of the design. Population: 38 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2194

1927 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. The 1927 quarter eagle ranks 12th out of 15 issues for high grade rarity among the Indian quarter eagles, one of the commonest issues. However, PCGS has only certified 17 pieces in MS66, with none finer (2/10). Any opportunity to acquire this date, or any other date in MS66 or MS67 grades is seldom presented, and the collector should be prepared with a strong bid. This piece will be another nice addition to a Set Registry collection. This 1927 is boldly defined with frosty yellow luster and impressive eye appeal. A trace of pale blue and iridescent toning adds to its appeal.
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2195

1928 $2 1/2 MS65 NGC. Whisper of lavender and mint-green reside on the peach-gold, lustrous surfaces of this sharply struck Gem. A minimally marked piece with great eye appeal.(Registry values: N2998)

2196

1928 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. The 1928 comes with a mintage exceeding 400,000 pieces and is readily located through the MS64 grade level. This issue becomes scarce in Gem condition and extremely rare any finer. PCGS and NGC have seen fewer than 25 Premium Gems (a number of which are probably resubmissions or crossovers) and no specimens that grade higher.
A melange of beautiful yellow-gold, rose, light green and apricot runs over the strongly lustrous surfaces of the Premium Gem in the current lot, and a powerful strike manifests itself in sharp detail on the design features. Well cared for surfaces enhance the coin's eye appeal. Population: 10 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

2197

1929 $2 1/2 MS66 PCGS. Here is an incredible condition rarity at the end of the Indian quarter eagle series. Only two issues, 1911 and 1914-D, have lower PCGS populations in MS66 or finer grades. This intense Premium Gem displays amazing eye appeal with frosty yellow luster over both sides. Traces of pale blue toning adds to its overall presentation. With just three coins that PCGS has certified finer than MS65, the opportunity to acquire a suitable high grade piece seldom occurs. Here is just such an opportunity for the advanced 20th century gold collector. Population: 2 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).
From The Atherton Family Collection, Part Two.(Registry values: N4719)

Three Dollar Gold Pieces

2198

1854 $3 AU53 NGC. The yellow-gold surfaces of this three dollar yield luster in the recesses. Well struck and minimally abraded. A strike-through is noted on the chin.(Registry values: N1793)

2199

1854-D $3 --Harshly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1-A. As a first-year branch mint issue of the odd three dollar gold denomination and the only D-mint three, the 1854-D is under intense collector demand at all grade levels. This piece has surfaces that are dulled from cleaning and show obvious hairlines. The piece shows possible tooling around 7 o'clock on the obverse, and a planchet flaw appears to have been smoothed on or near the reverse rim at 7 o'clock. Copper-colored discolorations also appear in both areas, with light orange-gold color prevailing elsewhere. The U in UNITED is weak, diagnostic of the issue, while TED is heavy and doubled. The surfaces are otherwise only lightly marked. The only noticeable abrasions are above and below the RS on the reverse. Despite the problems noted, much pleasing detail remains, and as such this piece may present a good compromise between quality and value for some fortunate collector.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: N7079)

2200

1854-O $3 --Improperly Cleaned--NCS. XF Details. A mildly bright and glossy example with the expected number of tiny marks, including a small cluster left of the 1 in the date. The sole New Orleans issue of the denomination, limited to a production of 24,000 pieces.(Registry values: N1793)

2201

1855 $3 AU55 NGC. Lustrous green-gold surfaces exhibit nearly full mint frost with a trace of wear on the high points the grade suggests. This piece has a few minor grade consistent abrasions that are entirely trivial.(Registry values: N1793)

2202

1855 $3 AU55 NGC. Slight wear on Liberty's hair and forehead confirms the Choice AU designation, but luster is plentiful except across the open fields. The right obverse has a couple of traces of struck-in grease.(Registry values: N1793)

2203

1856-S $3 --Scratched--ANACS. AU Details, Net XF45. Medium S. The viewer's first reaction is, "Where's the scratch?" Patient rotation locates a hair-thin pinscratch on the lower obverse through the bust tip. Moderately circulated but much luster remains. San Francisco threes are scarce.(Registry values: N1793)

2204

1857 $3 AU58 PCGS. CAC. Traces of green patina are visible on the yellow-gold surfaces of this lustrous near-Mint example. Both sides have sharp design details, save for slight weakness on the ribbon bow. Heavy clash marks are evident on both sides. A small mark is noted on Liberty's jawline.(Registry values: N1793)

2205

1858 $3 AU53 NGC. With a low mintage of 2,133 pieces, the 1858 is the rarest P-mint three dollar gold piece of the 1850s. Most examples seen are in VF-XF grades, and the date is seldom encountered at the AU53 level. The present coin is well detailed and shows little actual wear. The surfaces retain much original luster and are lightly abraded for the grade. Census: 13 in 53, 63 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2206

1859 $3 AU53 NGC. CAC. Still-lustrous butter-yellow surfaces show scattered, wispy abrasions. Well-defined where not worn and a generally pleasing example of this early but lower-mintage issue.(Registry values: N1793)

2207

1859 $3 MS60 NGC. The 9 in the date is lightly recut. An unblemished yellow-gold example that has ample luster and a good strike. A very scarce issue, since the mintage was only 15,558 pieces and few among those were set aside, unlike the low mintage dates that close the series.(Registry values: N2998)

2208

1860 $3 AU55 PCGS. CAC. The 1860 is one of the few early threes that is occasionally available in AU. There were 7,036 circulation strikes produced, all on one day, January 31. This piece is atypically choice for the grade with bright yellow-gold surfaces and significant portions of mint luster within and surrounding the devices. A few light handling marks are evident with magnification, as one would expect, but none are singularly noticeable.(Registry values: N1793)

2209

1861 $3 AU53 NGC. Produced in the first year of the Civil War, the 1861 three dollar gold saw a production of only 5,959 coins. Most certified examples today average AU50 to AU55. This example offers attractive golden-orange surfaces with deeper reddish tinges around the peripheries. The few light abrasions are consistent with the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2210

1862 $3 AU55 PCGS. Apricot-gold dominates both sides of this Choice AU three dollar. The design elements are well impressed and luster resides in the recessed areas. Light circulation marks are more prevalent on the reverse. Remnants of die striations, common on this date, are visible in some of the protected areas.(Registry values: N1793)

2211

1866 $3 AU55 PCGS. Rich orange-gold patination displays tints of mint-green, especially on the reverse. The design features are appropriately defined and the few scattered marks are in concert with a coin having seen light circulation. From a mintage of only 4,000 circulation strikes.(Registry values: N1793)

2212

1867 $3 AU53 NGC. CAC. The bright brassy-gold surfaces of this AU53 three dollar exhibit traces of luster in the areas around and in the interstices of the design motifs. The devices show strong definition despite high-point wear, and the few scattered minute marks over each side are in line with a coin having seen some circulation.(Registry values: N1793)

2213

1868 $3 XF40 PCGS. Yellow-gold surfaces imbued with hints of greenish-gray display traces of luster in the recesses of this well defined three dollar. Minimally marked.(Registry values: N1793)

2214

1869 $3 AU53 PCGS. Butter-gold luster brightens the legends and fills the headdress. The wreath and portrait display expected moderate wear. Devoid of consequential marks. A meager 2,500 pieces were struck. Population: 18 in 53, 72 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2215

1870 $3 XF45 PCGS. Peach-gold and mint-green interact over both sides to yield pleasing eye appeal to this Choice XF three dollar. An appropriately defined minimally abraded coin.(Registry values: N1793)

2216

1871 $3 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. One of just 1,300 business strikes coined for this issue. Lightly worn on the high points with the mustard-gold surfaces subdued from a past cleaning.(Registry values: N1793)

2217

1872 $3 MS62 NGC. One of the major rarities in the three dollar gold series, from a mintage of just 2,000 coins. Mint State examples are seldom encountered. Both sides have full prooflike fields, despite the lack of the PL designation. The obverse has a small bulge at 7 o'clock, and the reverse has die polish in the field over the wreath. Census: 10 in 62, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2218

1872 $3 MS61 Prooflike NGC. From a minuscule mintage of just 2,000 pieces, the 1872 three dollar gold piece is an underrated issue among nonspecialists. Q. David Bowers estimates only 20-30 examples are extant in Mint State grades, and this may be a generous estimate given the low number of submissions seen by the grading services. The present coin is a pleasing example, with bright luster and prooflike, reflective surfaces. A couple of shallow handling marks on Liberty's cheek account for the grade. Census: 4 in 61 Prooflike, 4 finer (2/10).

2219

1873 $3 Closed 3--Polished--ANACS. XF45 Details. A moderately circulated example that is bright from a past wipe. A short pinscratch is on the right obverse field. The 2010 Guide Book states that "the mintage of the 1873, Close 3, coins is unknown. Research suggests that Proofs only may have been struck." But grading service Census and population data suggests the Closed 3 is a circulation issue, since only five pieces between PCGS and NGC are certified above MS61. In any event, the issue is rare, even by the standards of the three dollar denomination.(Registry values: N2998)

2220

1873 $3 Closed 3 MS62 Prooflike NGC. The 1873 three dollar gold issue is a mysterious one. Mint records reveal only a production of 25 proofs, although business strikes exist. Later commentators have suggested mintages ranging from 100 to 1,000 pieces. The finest certified are two MS64 pieces at PCGS; this piece is one of three certified MS62 Prooflike at NGC, with one MS63 Prooflike finer (2/10). The prooflikeness on this piece is prominent in spite of the slight granularity and numerous tiny marks seen. The strike is bold but not full. Rich orange-gold color enhances both sides, and the only noticeable marks are in a tight cluster in the field below TA. A marvelous and enigmatic coin.

2221

1874 $3 MS64 PCGS. The 1874 three dollar can be readily located through MS63 and even near-Gems are not that difficult. Finer pieces are rare, however. Variegated peach-gold and mint-green coloration graces the lustrous surfaces of this MS64 and a decisive strike imparts strong definition to the design motifs. A few minor marks preclude Gem status. Population: 92 in 64, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2222

1877 $3 MS61 PCGS. Between the mammoth mintages of three dollar gold coins in 1874 and 1878, there was only one issuance of business strike examples of the denomination, consisting of 1,468 pieces in 1877. While the proof-only dates of 1875 and 1876 are famed, collectors have warmed to the rarity of the 1877 only gradually. This unworn representative, yellow-gold with substantial mirrors in the fields, is well struck with solid eye appeal for the grade. Small but numerous marks are present on each side, and an old pinscratch is noted to the left of Liberty's nose. Population: 5 in 61, 4 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2223

1878 $3 --Obverse Scratched--NGC. AU Details. Considerable swirling luster remains on this three dollar type coin. Moderately abraded with a scratch from the left side of the E in LIBERTY into the hair below, which accounts for the details grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2224

1878 $3 MS60 PCGS. This softly lustrous yellow-gold example shows no trace of wear, though close inspection reveals a number of wispy abrasions and an old pinscratch on Liberty's cheek. Still, a readily collectible example of this popular type issue.(Registry values: N1793)

2225

1878 $3 MS62 PCGS. The 1878 is the most common date for the three dollar gold series, evidenced by the large number certified by PCGS and NGC. The wheat-gold surfaces of this MS62 example displays nearly full luster and well struck design elements. Some minute marks are fewer than what might be expected for the designated grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2226

1878 $3 MS63 PCGS. This peach-gold type coin provides scintillating luster and pleasing preservation. The strike is crisp, and the only a hair-thin line near the 18 in the date merits passing mention. From the familiar reverse with slight die doubling on the ARS in DOLLARS and the right-side cotton leaves.(Registry values: N2998)

2227

1878 $3 MS63 PCGS. A Select example of this popular three dollar gold type issue that offers strong eye appeal in all respects. Rich yellow-gold surfaces have powerful, swirling luster, and the strike is pleasing. The flaws that account for the grade are wispy marks rather than distracting abrasions. The second 8 has traces of white verdigris.(Registry values: N2998)

2228

1878 $3 MS64 NGC. CAC. Well-defined with strong and swirling luster. Both sides have light yellow-gold surfaces with just a few scattered, wispy marks on each side. The 1878 is the latest among three dates commonly collected for type purposes, and it is available for a price in MS64, though such coins are rarely so appealing as the one seen here.(Registry values: N2998)

2229

1878 $3 MS65 NGC. Frosty luster and powerful design features are hallmarks of this remarkable three dollar gold piece. Both sides have brilliant yellow luster with trivial marks that are only visible upon close inspection. The 1878 is the most plentiful three dollar gold piece, and it is often chosen for type collections for that reason. This piece has remarkable eye appeal and will be a splendid addition to any collection. NGC has certified 71 finer examples of this issue (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2230

1878 $3 MS66 PCGS. Although struck for 36 years, the three dollar denomination remains scarce as a gold type. Most dates have meager productions, although the mintage rose to 82,304 pieces for the 1878, since the Treasury expected increased demand as the paper dollar reached parity with its gold equivalent. The anticipated demand was never realized, and subsequent mintages never exceeded 6,000 pieces.
An exquisite apricot-gold Premium Gem with seamless luster and a virtually pristine reverse. Minor recutting is evident within the upper loops of the two 8s in the date, and a loupe reveals die doubling on the outer border of the right-side cotton leaves. Population: 64 in 66, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2231

1879 $3 MS61 ANACS. Only 3,000 business strikes were coined in 1879, a substantial reduction from the previous year's production. This well struck example has substantial luster and surprisingly few visible abrasions. The obverse field near 6 o'clock has a smoothed appearance.(Registry values: N2998)

2232

1879 $3 MS64 NGC. This is a pretty three dollar gold piece with gorgeous rose and iridescent toning over fully reflective fields and lustrous devices. Only 3,000 of these coins were minted in 1879, and survivors are infrequently encountered in higher grades. This piece exhibits outstanding eye appeal. NGC has only certified 20 finer pieces (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2233

1880 $3 MS64 NGC. Some imperfections from the original planchet are visible near the R in AMERICA, but the balance of the obverse and reverse surfaces are remarkable. The fields of this important three dollar gold piece are fully reflective around lustrous devices, resulting in delightful cameo contrast.
Only 1,000 business strikes were coined, along with another 36 proofs. The mintage is responsible for the rarity and desirability of this issue. Collectors everywhere gather together to bid when one of these appears at auction. Census: 49 in 64, 23 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2234

1882 $3 MS63 PCGS. 2 Over High 2, Breen-6396. This dramatically repunched date may actually be diagnostic to all 1882 threes, but is definitely seen on the majority of survivors. The fields are brightly reflective, as expected on this desirable issue of just 1,500 business strikes, with only slight scuffiness in the fields surrounding the portrait. Population: 35 in 63, 33 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2235

1883 $3 --Improperly Cleaned--NCS. AU Details. At first glance, this ultra low mintage (900 pieces) three dollar gold piece appears to be prooflike Uncirculated. But the highpoints of the cheek and hair show light wear, and the luminous fields display fine hairlines when viewed with a powerful loupe and held at obscure angles.(Registry values: N1793)

2236

1883 $3 MS62 PCGS. The 1883 three dollar gold piece boasts a low mintage of just 900 pieces. Mint State specimens are seldom encountered today, with Q. David Bowers estimating a surviving total of only 75-100 examples in Uncirculated grades (an estimate that coincides well with population data from the grading services). The present coin is a pleasing example, with prooflike reflective fields and a sharp strike throughout. A shallow scratch in the obverse field accounts for the grade. Population: 33 in 62, 46 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2237

1885 $3 --Reverse Damage--NGC. AU Details. The 1885 has a minuscule business strike mintage of 801 pieces. The present apricot and sun-yellow example shows no wear on the devices, but the date and nearby field have been repaired, and the 88 is crudely re-engraved. The obverse field has been extensively smoothed, most noticeably in front of the lips.(Registry values: N1793)

2238

1886 $3 --Cleaned--ANACS. AU58 Details. From a paltry mintage of 1,000 business strikes. This piece is sharply struck. Its peach-gold surfaces reveal light hairlines under magnification. A fair amount of luster is evident despite the light cleaning.(Registry values: N1793)

2239

1887 $3 MS64 PCGS. The 1887 three dollar issue has the largest business strike total in the years after the massive mintage of 1878. At just 6,000 pieces, however, that "largest" mintage is still small, though survivors exist in a variety of Mint State grades. This yellow-gold near-Gem is radiant with a handful of light, scattered abrasions. Luster is partially prooflike, unsurprising given the low production tally. Housed in a green label holder. PCGS has graded just 35 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2240

1887 $3 MS65 PCGS. The mintage was given as 6,000 pieces for the 1887 three dollar, which would make it the highest mintage of the 1880s for the series. However, evidence suggests that many pieces may have been melted before they ever left the Mint, and the issue is notably rarer than the 1888 or 1889 coins, which had emissions of 5,000 and 2,300 coins, respectively. Outstanding mint luster is this coin's strong suit, with light, even reddish-gold color. Only under a loupe do a couple of small marks appear in the right obverse field. The strike is a bit soft on Liberty's lowest curls and the bowknot, but the clean surfaces and overall excellent preservation more than compensate. Slight doubling shows on RICA in AMERICA, not unusual for the business strikes. Population: 25 in 65, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2241

1888 $3 MS61 ANACS. Lustrous and unabraded with a precise strike and excellent eye appeal. The ANACS insert notes that the obverse is die doubled, most prominently on UNITED. This feature is likely present on all business strike 1888 threes, since a single obverse die was presumably used to produce the meager 5,000-piece mintage.(Registry values: N1793)

Early Half Eagles

2242

1798 $5 Large Eagle, Large 8, 14 Star Reverse AU50 NGC. Breen-6427, BD-3, R.5. BD-3 is the sole 14 Stars Reverse variety, which receives a separate listing in the Guide Book. As is usual for BD-3, the reverse displays a network of slender die cracks that intersect within the shield. This is an attractive and undipped early half eagle with orange-gold toning where luster resides. The devices show only slight wear, and the strike is good although the eagle's head and nearby stars are incompletely brought up. The right obverse field has a trio of minor mint-made lintmarks, but any post-strike abrasions are inconsequential.(Registry values: P4)

2243

1800 $5 Genuine PCGS. Breen-6439, BD-4, R.4. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU50 coin and it has been cleaned. This variety is most easily distinguished by the closeness of the last star to the bust of Liberty and the repunched M in AMERICA. The damage referred to by the PCGS number appears to be in the form of a couple of more prominent digs and scratches on the obverse: a dig by star 5, a scratch above the 1 in the date, and a scratch along the jawline of Liberty. Still, the green-gold surfaces retain significant mint luster around the outer devices. The strike is a bit soft in the centers.(Registry values: P2, N2)

2244

1802/1 $5 AU58 NGC. Breen-6440, BD-2, High R.4. The 2 in the date is away from the bust, and the ribbon in the eagle's mouth is incomplete. No 1801-dated half eagles are known. Although two obverse dies were made, they both remained unused until 1802, when both were overdated with the 2 over 1 and pressed into service. Those two obverse dies are known as the Centered Overdate and High Overdate in Bass-Dannreuther. The obverses were combined, respectively, with five and three different reverse dies--with only the BD-6 Reverse E paired with both--for a total of eight different matings in all. This piece is sharply struck throughout, including the central hair strands and the eagle's breast feathers atop the shield. There are minimal handling marks, with those few present requiring a magnifier to see. The surfaces are predominantly yellow-gold, complementing rich reddish patina around the device peripheries. A marvelous coin to represent the type.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2245

1806 $5 Round Top 6, 7x6 Stars--Obverse Scratched--NGC. AU Details. Breen-6448, BD-6, R.2. The sole Round Top 6 variety for the year. Despite light wear, both sides retain considerable antique-gold luster. Though a staple scratch crosses the obverse on a horizontal line through Liberty's chin, the reverse is minimally abraded and problem-free, making this an ideal coin to display with that side up.(Registry values: P2)

2246

1809/8 $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. Breen-6458, BD-1, High R.3. This is the only half eagle variety of the date. This sharply defined half eagle has brilliant green-gold surfaces with full luster that is only slightly impaired due to cleaning. The 1809/8 half eagle is a plentiful issue in all grades through the lowest Mint State levels.(Registry values: P2)

2247

1814/3 $5 MS63 PCGS. Breen-6468, BD-1, High R.4. There are no known 1814 half eagles except for those that show the underdigit 3, signaling a carryover from the previous year. However, this obverse die appears to have been unused in 1813, as neither of the known die marriages for that year provides an exact match with the obverse diagnostics. The flag of the first 1 in the date is curled, and the 8 is slightly larger than the other digits and protrudes both above and below the flanking 1s. Star 7 points to the lower edge of the Liberty cap. There is a die-centering dot between the curl and ear. The underdigit 3 fades in later die states, but remnants can usually be seen on both sides at the top of the 4, below the crossbar to the left, and on both sides of the crossbar on the right.
The reverse die was first used for the BD-2 of 1813, with the first S of STATES almost centered over the E in the motto. The eagle has no tongue. The D in the denomination is noticeably double-punched, and the period after is high. Besides the popular overdate feature, this year has extra cachet as this reverse was carried over for the production of the fabulously rare 1815 half eagles, of which less than a dozen are known.
The production of 1814/3 half eagles is recorded as 15,454 coins, an amount only one-sixth that of the previous year. Bass-Dannreuther estimate that perhaps 80 to 100 examples survive today. In any case, the piece is a great conditional rarity in Mint State. This specimen is sharply struck throughout, a nice, clean coin with great luster. The bright yellow-gold color has just a trace of reddish patina. Light die clashing appears in the fields. The last time we handled an MS63 example of this issue was in our 2007 FUN Signature (1/2007, lot 3532) that brought $29,900. We expect this seldom-seen issue could be the subject of fierce bidding, given the popularity of rare-date gold in recent years. Population: 8 in 63, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

Classic Half Eagles

2248

1834 $5 Plain 4 AU58 NGC. CAC. First Head, Breen-6501, McCloskey 1-A, R.3. An entirely pleasing near-Mint example of this first-year Classic issue, radiant yellow-gold with an element of reflectivity in the fields. Well-defined with only minor abrasions and friction.(Registry values: P1)

2249

1834 $5 Crosslet 4 XF40 ANACS. Second Head, Crosslet 4, Breen-6503, McCloskey 5-D, R.4. A midrange example of this very scarce variety, which David Akers stated "is many times more rare than the 1834 Plain 4." The 1834 Crosslet 4 is actually the least available issue of the design type. The surfaces of this coin show light to moderate abrasions and moderate even wear.(Registry values: P3)

2250

1836 $5 AU50 NGC. Second Head, Large Date, Breen-6509, McCloskey 4-D, R.2. The large digit 1 in the date, much larger than the other digits, identifies the obverse, and on the reverse the TES is tight, with a wide OF, and the D in the denomination is almost entirely under the stem. Bright yellow-gold surfaces display luster in the recesses and are minimally abraded. Nicely defined on the devices.(Registry values: P1)

2251

1836 $5 MS61 NGC. Second Head, Large Date, Breen-6509, McCloskey 6-E, R.4. This die pair is easily recognized by the prominent die crack between the numerals 8 and 3 in the date. The sharply struck devices of this impressive specimen show no wear, and the surfaces are pleasing honey-gold with touches of tan. A few handling marks on Liberty's face explain the grade. Census: 42 in 61, 90 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

2252

1837 $5 AU58 NGC. Ex: S.S. New York. Large Date, Small 5, McCloskey 1-A, R.4. The 1837 half eagle is a scarce date when compared to more plentiful Classic Head dates such as 1834 and 1836. Three varieties are known, from a combination of three obverse dies and three reverse dies. This delightful green-gold example has excellent luster and only a trace of wear. The surfaces are excellent for the grade.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1)

2253

1838-C $5 XF40 PCGS. Variety 1, without repunching on the 5 in the denomination. This yellow-orange example has subtle glimmers of luster remaining in the fields. Both sides are moderately abraded overall and several scrapes are visible on the portrait, but the overall eye appeal is solid. Striking softness at Liberty's lower curls and the eagle's wingtips is normal for the issue. A great example of this first-year date, the sole Classic Head half eagle from Charlotte. Population: 25 in 40, 33 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P5)

2254

1838-D $5 --Polished--NGC. AU Details. McCloskey 1-A, R.3. The sole Dahlonega issue of the Classic half eagle design, and thus essential for type collectors of the Georgia facility. The present piece shows friction only on the highpoints of the hair, but both sides are unnaturally prooflike from cleaning.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

Liberty Half Eagles

2255

1839 $5 AU58 NGC. CAC. The Mint first struck Christian Gobrecht's half eagle in 1839. The Liberty Head type, also known as the Coronet or Braided Hair type, became one of the most stable designs of the 19th century. The obverse of this coin did not change for 70 years. The reverse remained essentially unchanged for that entire time. The most significant change the Mint made was to add IN GOD WE TRUST on a scroll.
The 1839 is scarce in AU condition, and relatively few are know in Mint State. Sharply struck throughout, the surfaces are lightly but extensively abraded. The only mark of singular note is a shallow scratch connecting the stars above Liberty's head. Bright yellow-gold color. NGC has graded 31 pieces in AU58, with 38 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

2256

1839-C $5 XF45 PCGS. CAC. Variety 1. The obverse mintmark of this issue adds a curious quaintness, one that associates it in some collectors' minds with the famous 1838-O (and 1839-O) half dollars of similar style. Considerable luster remains on this piece for the Choice XF grade level. and the charming antique-gold coloration and minor, grade-consistent marks complete the broad appeal. Population: 14 in 45, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

2257

1839-C $5 AU50 NGC. Variety 1, the sole variety for the year. While the prominent obverse mintmark has always attracted numismatist's attention, collectors are only beginning to recognize the importance of the 1839-C half eagle as a one-year type coin. A scarce issue, from a small mintage of 17,205 pieces, the 1839-C is known today to the extent of 150-200 examples in all grades. At the AU level, perhaps 22-30 specimens are extant. As is typical of this issue, the reverse features a sharper strike than the obverse. The surfaces show fewer abrasions than the average 1839-C. Census: 9 in 50, 39 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P5)

2258

1839-D $5 VF25 NGC. Variety 1-A, the rarer of the two obverses known for this important issue. The 1839-D and the 1839-C are the only obverse mintmark Liberty half eagle issues, and the portrait of Liberty also differs slightly from later dates. This bright canary-gold representative shows wear throughout the hair, but the eagle's feathers retain rich detail.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2259

1840 $5 Broad Mill AU58 NGC. Sharply detailed with light yellow-gold surfaces. The Broad Mill coins have a slightly larger diameter than later issues, and they are quickly recognized by the distinctive, wide rim on each side.(Registry values: P5)

2260

1840-C $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 1. From a mintage of 18,992 pieces, the 1840-C five dollar gold piece is one of the scarcest C-mint half eagles. An estimated 125-150 examples are extant in all grades, with perhaps two dozen specimens that would qualify as an AU coin. Most of the AU examples are in the AU50 to AU53 range, with AU55 specimens quite rare. The present coin displays a typical strike for the issue, with more detail present on the upper obverse devices than the lower elements. The only flaw worthy of mention is a short scratch on the reverse, below the E in STATES. Census: 14 in 55, 15 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P5)

2261

1840-D $5 Tall D--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 3-B, with the Tall D mintmark. The mintmark was moved to the reverse on the half eagle in 1840, and a substantial mintage of 22,896 pieces was achieved at the Dahlonega Mint. Perhaps 120-140 examples survive today in all grades. The present coin features a decent strike for a D-mint coin, and the surfaces are only lightly abraded. The original color of this piece has been altered by cleaning, an all- too-common occurrence with this date.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2262

1841-C $5 XF40 NGC. Variety 1-C. An unmarked and luminous pale gold representative from the early years of operation at the North Carolina facility. Luster glints from the legends and plumage. Very scarce, as only 21,467 pieces were coined.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2263

1841-D $5 Small D VF35 NGC. Variety 5-D. A better date Dahlonega Mint five from a mintage of fewer than 30,000 pieces. The luminous yellow-gold surfaces lack consequential marks, and the devices display wear appropriate for the Choice VF level.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2264

1842-C $5 Small Date--Harshly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Variety 1, the only dies known for this issue. The 1842-C Small Date half eagle is the rarest five dollar gold coin from the Charlotte Mint. The original mintage was a paltry 4,595 pieces, and the surviving population in all grades consists of only 60-80 examples. Among all C-mint gold coins, only the legendary 1849-C Open Wreath gold dollar is considered rarer than the present issue. Much original detail remains on this specimen, and while telltale traces of cleaning are evident on the surfaces, abrasions are relatively minor for this issue.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P8)

2265

1842-C $5 Large Date VF25 PCGS. CAC. Variety 1. A circulated but original representative of this challenging Charlotte issue. Rich yellow-gold with glimpses of ice-blue and russet in design crevices. No marks are noteworthy.(Registry values: P5)

2266

1842-D $5 Small Date--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 8-E. A boldly struck and only briefly circulated Dahlonega half eagle. The surfaces are luminous, but devoid of consequential contact. A good strike despite minor blending on the forehead curls.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2267

1843 $5 MS60 NGC. This luminous gold-orange piece shows no trace of wear. Excellent detail, though a number of wispy abrasions are apparent on closer inspection. Census: 9 in 60, 67 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

2268

1843 $5 MS61 NGC. An original lemon-gold and olive-green No Motto five. Crisply struck with ample luster and no distracting marks. A scarce design subtype in Mint State. Census: 29 in 61, 38 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

2269

1843 $5 MS65 NGC. The sole finest representative of this date graded by either NGC or PCGS (2/10), and as such a tremendously important coin to the collector assembling a top-flight cabinet of Liberty half eagles. The strike is perhaps the most remarkable facet of this Gem, though the shining, almost flashy luster is of similar importance. A number of small planchet flaws are scattered in the fields, but post-striking flaws are few. Only careful inspection turns up the tiny diagonal abrasion on the cheek, as well as a handful of wispy marks nearby, which account for the final grade.(Registry values: P5)

2270

1843-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Variety 1, with the mintmark located over the right half of the V in FIVE. A bright Charlotte half eagle with orange fields and lime and lilac toning in protected regions. Well detailed for the grade, although Liberty's hair and eyebrow show wear appropriate for the VF level.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2271

1843-D $5 Medium D VF20 ANACS. Variety 10-H. The more common Medium D variant, offered here in the form of a mid-range piece. Despite significant wear, this mildly abraded coin offers considerable radiance in the pale canary-yellow fields.(Registry values: P2)

2272

1843-D $5 Medium D VF35 PCGS. Variety 10-H. Rich yellow-gold toning confirms the originality of this well detailed and moderately abraded Choice VF Dahlonega five. Luster glimmers from design elements, especially on the reverse.(Registry values: P2)

2273

1843-D $5 Medium D XF40 PCGS. CAC. Variety 10-H. The Medium D mintmark is centered over the space between the V and E in FIVE. This pleasing green-gold example has moderate abrasions as expected for the grade. Traces of luster are still visible. Some minor verdigris is trapped within and around certain reverse design elements.(Registry values: P2)

2274

1843-D $5 Small D--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Variety 10-G. The Small D is considered much scarcer than the usual Medium D. A somewhat bright and only moderately abraded Southern gold coin that has pleasing wing detail.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2275

1844-C $5 AU55 PCGS. Variety 1, the only variety for the year. A substantial mintage of 23,631 half eagles was achieved at the Charlotte Mint in 1844, but the coins circulated heavily and attrition reduced the supply of these coins dramatically. The surviving population is estimated at 125-175 examples, with 24-32 specimens in AU grades. High grade coins are rare. The present coin displays the soft strike nearly always seen on this issue, with more detail present on the reverse. The surfaces are a pleasing green-gold, with fewer abrasions than usually seen on this date. Population: 8 in 55, 10 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P5)

2276

1844-D $5 XF45 NGC. Variety 11-H. The typical variety for the issue, identified by a repunched peak to the 1 in the date. This Choice XF Dahlonega five has considerable apricot-tinged luster, and the only consequential mark is a light vertical line on the cheek.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2277

1845-D $5 AU50 PCGS. Variety 12-I. The 1845-D half eagle is a reasonably available date, from a mintage of 90,629 pieces. The best estimate of the surviving population is 225-250 examples, with about 50 specimens in AU. The present coin features remarkable striking detail for a D-mint coin. The surfaces exhibit no distracting marks, with only minimal wear, suggestive of a higher grade. Population: 30 in 50, 91 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2278

1845-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 12-I. The usually found obverse, with the date further left but not as high as the rare 13-I die, where the top of the 1 nearly touches the bust truncation. This example boasts lovely luster remaining on the greenish-gold surfaces, which are well-struck (but not fully struck) even through the centers. Some of the roughness on the planchet is as made. A nice near-Mint example. Census: 66 in 58, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2279

1845-O $5 MS61 PCGS. If these coins bore the Classic Head design rather than the Liberty Head design, it might help collectors understand how truly historic they are. Nevertheless, this issue was made only seven years after the United States opened its first branch mints, including New Orleans, and it was a time when most of the gold in the United States was still mined in Georgia and the Carolinas. The 1845-O half eagle had a production of 41,000 coins, and Mint State examples can be counted on both hands. This piece boasts bright, semiprooflike fields on each side, with lemon-yellow color complementing tinges of light reddish patina. The strike is uniformly strong, although short of full. Several small abrasions peppered over each side account for the grade, but none are noticeable without magnification. A prize for the collector of antebellum O-mint gold coins. Population: 1 in 61, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P7)

2280

1846 $5 Large Date MS63 NGC. Ex: S.S. New York. Part of a substantial mintage of 395,942 pieces, the 1846 Large Date half eagle seems to be slightly more available than the Small Date variety. However, the issue is still a fairly scarce coin in all grades. At the MS63 level, the issue is very rare. The actual size difference of the date in the two varieties is hard to determine, and the best way to distinguish between the varieties is to note the spacing of the different numerals in the date. In the Large Date, there is a gap between the 1 and the 8 that can be seen easily. The outstanding feature of the present coin is its exemplary strike, with fine detail present on all devices. The surfaces are lustrous with semiprooflike fields, and they display a minimum number of handling marks for the grade. Overall visual appeal is outstanding. Census: 11 in 63, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

2281

1846 $5 Large Date MS64 ★ NGC. Ex: S.S. New York. The 1846 half eagle is considerably more difficult to locate than its generous mintage of 395,942 pieces would indicate. The Large Date variety is more available than its Small Date counterpart, but the issue is extremely rare at the Choice level and basically unknown in any finer grade. The differences between the two varieties are subtle, and catalogers only began to systematically distinguish between them in the early 20th century. An early appearance of the Large Date variety was in lot 1102 of the Peter Mougey Collection (Thomas Elder, 9/1910), where Elder noted, "1846 Large date with medium short 6. Very fine; scarce." Today, numismatists find it easier to distinguish the variety by looking at the spacing and location of the numerals in the date, as the size difference between the dates is really quite small.
The present specimen is virtually unimprovable, with extraordinary striking details throughout. The lustrous surfaces are a lovely green-gold color, with no significant distractions. An interesting die crack bisects the reverse from 5 o'clock to 11 o'clock. Census: 2 in 64 ★ , none finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

2282

1846-C $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 1, the only confirmed variety of the date. Made to the tune of only 12,995 coins, the 1846-C half eagle is one of the scarcest C-mint fives due to a fire at the Charlotte Mint in 1845. The few quarter eagles and half eagles made when the facility reopened circulated widely because of the pent-up demand. This near-Mint State coins offers satiny fields that exhibit a hint of reflectivity beneath rich honey-gold obverse color and lighter green-gold reverse color. Nearly full luster is broken only on the highest design points and the surfaces are lightly abraded. A few Mint State pieces are known. Population: 5 in 58, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P5)

2283

1846-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 16-K. Part of the large mintage of 80,294 pieces for the date, the 1846-D Normal Mintmark half eagle is one of the most difficult issues of the series in high grades. The total surviving population of this issue is estimated at 110-130 pieces, with only 12-13 specimens known in AU grades. The present coin has attractive greenish-gold surfaces, with fewer abrasions than usually seen on an 1846-D. Census: 12 in 58, 2 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2284

1846-D/D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 15-L. The 1846-D/D half eagle is a popular issue due to the dramatic, easily seen repunched mintmark. Part of a large mintage of 80,294 pieces, Doug Winter estimates a surviving population of 125-150 examples, with 14-16 specimens in AU grades. The present coin is sharply struck, with attractive luster and only the slightest wear on the high points of the design. Census: 20 in 58, 8 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2285

1846-O $5 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .92 suggests Cleaning as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has been cleaned. Yellow-orange surfaces have muted luster and patches of alloy around selected peripheral devices.(Registry values: P6, N6)

2286

1847-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned, Rim Damage--NGC. VF Details. Variety 1, the only known dies despite a profligate (by Charlotte Mint standards) mintage of 84,151 pieces. Small rim nicks are noted at 12 o'clock on the obverse and at 10 o'clock on the reverse. Moderately bright from a past wipe.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2287

1847-D $5 --Obverse Scratched--NGC. AU Details. Variety 17-I. The 1 and 4 in the date are lightly repunched near their bases. The obverse has four noticeable scratches, including a broad diagonal mark from chin to cheek. A straw-gold Dahlonega No Motto five with ample remaining luster.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2288

1848 $5 MS60 PCGS. Numerous wispy abrasions have surprisingly little effect on the eye appeal of this boldly impressed example. Yellow-gold surfaces show a prominent claret alloy spot at the F of OF and the nearby wingtip. Population: 3 in 60, 19 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P5)

2289

1848-C $5 --Reverse Rim Damage--NGC. VF Details. Variety 1. A slightly glossy Charlotte representative with a minor rim mark at 6:30 on the reverse and an inconspicuous rim crimp at 9:30 on the same side. Unimportant marks affect Liberty's cheekbone and the FI in FIVE.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2290

1848-C $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 1. Despite the high mintage approaching 65,000 coins, the 1848-C half eagle is much scarcer in Mint State than such a figure suggests. This example displays some prooflike luster under a light layer of field chatter on original greenish-gold surfaces. Some of the planchet roughness appears original to the Mint. Census: 31 in 55, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

2291

1848-C $5 MS61 NGC. Variety 1. The 1848-C is a scarce C-mint five, even though 64,472 pieces were produced. It is also a condition rarity, with AU pieces rare and Uncirculated coins unknown until the past 10 years or so. The Condition Census for this issue includes coins that grade 64, 64, 63, 62, 62. This piece would place just below Winter's latest Condition Census (2008) in the third edition of the C-mint reference. This coin has an exceptionally sharp strike. The hair around Liberty's face shows strong definition for the issue, and the only weakness on the reverse is slight softness on the eagle's neck and left (facing) leg. Numerous small field marks appear on each side, none worthy of individual mention. Bright yellow-gold coloration complements just a tinge of reddish patina.(Registry values: P4)

2292

1848-D $5 --Polished--NGC. XF Details. Variety 18-M. Die cracks pass through two arrowheads and reach the eagle's beak. Liberty's neck is softly brought up. An unnaturally luminous representative of this scarce Dahlonega issue.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2293

1849-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned, Reverse Repair--NGC. XF Details. Variety 2, which has the date placed closer to the bust relative to the more available Variety 1. The upper reverse field is smoothed, and this Charlotte five has a mildly bright yellow-gold appearance.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2294

1849-C $5 AU58 NGC. CAC. Variety 1. A high date with the 1 closer to the bust than the denticles identifies this variety. This piece is Die State II, recognized by the die crack that starts at the rim, passes the U in UNITED, and ends at the olive branch. Pleasing orange-gold patina envelops both sides with some satiny mint luster present in the fields. This example is particularly well-struck for a Charlotte Mint piece, with nice definition on the stars and central devices.(Registry values: P3)

2295

1849-D $5 VF30 PCGS. Variety 21-N, the rarest of the four die pairings known for the date. The 1 nearly touches the bust. An original and unblemished Dahlonega five with tan toning in protected areas. Certified in a green label holder.(Registry values: P3)

2296

1849-D $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. Variety 22-L. The mintmark is entered very close to the branch and feather, and the date is punched further to the right than is usual. A dull green-gold Dahlonega half eagle that offers glimpses of luster in design recesses.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2297

1849-D $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. Variety 22-L. The 1849-D is one of the more available D-mint fives, primarily because of the large (relatively speaking) mintage of 39,036 pieces. However, high grade examples are rarely seen, even when cleaned and in high grade such as seen on this piece. The striking details are strong, except for the central hair curls of Liberty and the fletchings of the upper arrow. The surfaces are exceptionally free from abrasions.(Registry values: P3)

2298

1850-C $5 --Rim Filing, Reverse Scratches--NGC. AU Details. Variety 2, which has the mintmark punched furthest left. The reverse rim is faintly filed near 12 o'clock, and scratches are noted through the the E in UNITED and the R in AMERICA.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2299

1850-C $5 --Harshly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 3. The mintmark is slightly weak but nonetheless obvious to the unaided eye. A richly detailed green-gold Charlotte five. The open fields have a granular appearance, although there is no clear evidence of whizzing or repairs.(Registry values: P3)

2300

1850-D $5 --Damaged--NGC. AU Details. Variety 24-P. The 1 in the date is fully beneath the bust tip. The obverse rim has rough marks throughout, and the portrait has scrapes and abrasions. The reverse rim appears filed near 11, 12, and 3 o'clock.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2301

1851-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1, the usual dies for this collectible but elusive Charlotte issue. A bright No Motto five with impressive design detail. A diagonal mark is above the eagle's head, and a pinscratch is right of the U in UNITED.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2302

1851-C $5 AU50 NGC. Variety 1, the "earring" variety. Part of the mintage of 49,176 pieces, the 1851-C half eagle is a scarce coin in all grades. The present coin features the usual obverse with an "earring" or small center hole on Liberty's earlobe. An original and typically abraded yellow-gold Charlotte five that has the expected indistinctness of strike on the right wing, fletchings, and curls. Luster shimmers from protected areas.
Ex: Greenwich Collection (Bowers and Merena, 1/91), lot 167.(Registry values: P4)

2303

1851-D $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 26-R. The 1851-D half eagle is surprisingly difficult to locate when one considers the original mintage of 62,710 pieces. The total number of examples known today is in the range of only 115-135 pieces. Of these, perhaps 25 specimens are in AU grades. The peripheral design elements of this coin are deeply impressed, but the centers are somewhat weak, as is typical for the issue. The eagle's leg feathers are especially ill-defined. The pleasing greenish-gold surfaces are only lightly abraded. Census: 24 in 55, 31 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2304

1852 $5 MS64 PCGS. CAC. An absolutely stunning near-Gem, this Choice Mint State piece is tied for the finest that PCGS has ever examined. NGC and PCGS have each certified a total of 26 coins at this grade level, and NGC also records three finer coins. While the mintage of almost 574,000 coins ranks among the highest of the type, most survivors have seen some time in circulation.
We believe that this coin will hold its own in a side-by-side comparison, even if others are graded higher. It is sharply struck with frosty yellow-gold luster and traces of pale pink toning. Population: 12 in 64, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

2305

1852-C $5 XF45 NGC. Variety 1. Peach-gold toning graces much of this unmarked Choice XF C-mint five. The eagle's neck is softly struck, as are the curls, but the remainder of the design is nicely impressed.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2306

1852-D $5 --Harshly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Variety 27-U. The date is set far left beneath the bust. A thickly hairlined apricot representative of the popular and scarce Dahlonega Mint. Soft design detail is more from the strike than subsequent wear.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2307

1853-C $5 XF45 NGC. Variety 1. Luster glimmers from the design of this untoned Choice XF Charlotte example. No marks are remotely worthy of comment, and the star centrils are crisply struck.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2308

1853-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NCS. AU Details. Variety 1. From an earlier die state. This crisply struck piece shows little actual wear, though the straw-gold surfaces are subdued and mildly granular. A better-detailed survivor from this popular Charlotte half eagle issue.(Registry values: P3)

2309

1853-D $5 Large D--Obverse Damage--NGC. VF Details. Variety 29-V. This mildly bright Dahlonega No Motto half eagle displays faded abrasions near the left-side stars, but remaining luster is substantial for the VF level. The curls and fletchings show a typical strike.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P1)

2310

1853-D $5 Large D XF40 NGC. Variety 29-V. Yellow-orange surfaces are moderately abraded with glimmers of luster in the protected areas. Well struck on the central devices with softer definition on the peripheral elements.(Registry values: P1)

2311

1853-D $5 Large D AU53 NGC. Variety 29-V. The mintmark is large and clear of the nearby devices. The 1853-D is very desirable as a type coin from this popular Southern mint. Peach-gold surfaces display whispers of light greenish-tan and are well struck, except for the often-seen weakness in the first three or four stars. A few scattered marks are unimportant.(Registry values: P1)

2312

1853-D $5 Large D AU58 NGC. Variety 29-V. A honey-gold Dahlonega type coin that boasts an above-average strike, although the fletchings and lovelock are incompletely brought up, as always. A few of the vertical shield stripes are flat from contact, but the obverse is surprisingly unabraded.(Registry values: P1)

2313

1854-C $5 VG8 NGC. Variety 1. A circulated No Motto Liberty five that has moderately bright surfaces and a hint of peripheral rose toning. An affordable entry point into a Charlotte gold collection.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2314

1854-D $5 Large D AU50 PCGS. Variety 31-X. One of the more available D-mint half eagles, the 1854-D claims a large mintage of 56,143 pieces. Experts conclude the surviving population must number in the range of 225-250 pieces, with fewer than 60 specimens available in AU grades. The present coin displays sharp striking details on the central devices, but shows areas of weakness on the dentils. The surfaces are well preserved, with bright green-gold color. Population: 25 in 50, 91 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P2)

2315

1854-D $5 Medium D VF30 NGC. Variety 31-W. Definitely scarcer than its Large D counterpart, and also preferable to the Weak D variety. Orange-gold patination shows traces of sky-blue. Moderately worn and lightly abraded.(Registry values: P3)

2316

1855-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. Luminous from an injudicious wipe, but highpoint wear is minimal, and luster glints from the plumage, shield, and hair. Fewer than 40,000 pieces were struck for this elusive Charlotte issue.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2317

1855-D $5 Large D XF45 NGC. Variety 32-AA, with the large mintmark. The mintage of Dahlonega half eagles was reduced to 22,432 pieces in 1855, and Doug Winter calls the issue "a scarce and underrated coin." Approximately 125-150 1855-D half eagles are known today, with perhaps 46-51 examples surviving in XF grades. The present coin is a pleasing specimen, with lightly abraded surfaces and slight, even wear. Census: 6 in 45, 53 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2318

1856-C $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 1. From a substantial mintage of 28,457 pieces, the 1856-C half eagle is considered a fairly common date by many collectors. Series specialists, like Doug Winter, realize the 1856-C is more difficult to locate than its mintage suggests. Only 150-200 survivors are known today in all grades, with the population of AU graded specimens numbering 35-45 pieces. Despite some weakness on the lower curl and stars, this specimen displays a sharper strike than usually seen on this issue. The surfaces are an attractive green-gold color, with no serious distractions. Population: 6 in 58, 7 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2319

1856-D $5 --Harshly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Variety 33-BB. A difficult Dahlonega emission due to a meager mintage of less than 20,000 pieces. This green-gold example is cloudy from hairlines but abrasions are otherwise surprisingly absent.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2320

1856-S $5 AU55 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America. Medium S. SSCA 6849. This lemon-gold San Francisco No Motto ten has excellent remaining luster for the AU55 level, and is smooth aside from one faint thin mark on the cheek. Housed in a gold label holder. Population: 21 in 55, 19 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P6)

2321

1857-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. Mildly glossy from a cleaning, but this Charlotte representative provides noticeable luster and has an above average strike. No marks merit individual description.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2322

1857-D $5 --Reverse Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. Variety 34-CC. Careful rotation of the reverse reveals faint horizontal hairlines, but the pale peach toning is attractive, and luster fills the legends and eagle. The centers show the usual incompleteness of strike.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2323

1857-D $5 XF45 NGC. CAC. Variety 34-CC, the only known dies for the year. The relatively low mintage of slightly over 17,000 pieces helps to account for the scarcity of this issue. Peach-gold surfaces are accented with greenish-gray and exhibit well defined design features, including the centers that are often weak. Only the arrow feathers are a tad soft. Often-seen laminations are visible on the upper left obverse rim.(Registry values: P3)

2324

1857-S $5 AU55 NGC. CAC. This Choice AU half eagle is attractive with fully lustrous green-gold surfaces and hints of orange toning. The mintmark is shallow but visible. The half eagle was missing from the S.S. Central America or S.S. Republic treasures. Census: 24 in 55, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P6)

2325

1858-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1, the usual die pair for this challenging Charlotte issue. This well struck example has scant indication of wear, and the somewhat bright surfaces are unmarked aside from a reed impression on the reverse rim at 6 o'clock.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2326

1858-C $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. Sharply struck, and the wing feathers exhibit only a trace of wear. Somewhat glossy from cleaning, and a faint vertical pinscratch accompanies the left obverse field.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2327

1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 35-DD. Although still challenging, the 1858-D half eagle is more available in high grades than its mintage of 15,362 pieces would lead one to expect. The total number of known examples is in the 125-150 range, with about three dozen specimens that would grade AU. The present coin is a particularly attractive example, with only slight traces of wear on the high points of the design. Sharply struck for this issue, the centers show the softness always seen on this date. The surfaces retain much original mint luster. Census: 37 in 58, 11 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2328

1859-C $5 AU53 NGC. Variety 1. Moderate abrasions pepper the surfaces on both sides, but a considerable amount of luster remains. The 1859-C half eagle is a noted strike rarity, every example showing weakness around Liberty's hair, more so on the details of the eagle. This piece is no exception; in fact, there are no exceptions, according to Winter, but he maintains that the issue is scarce in AU53 or finer. Census: 16 in 53, 70 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

2329

1859-C $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 1. A substantial mintage of 31,847 half eagles was achieved by the Charlotte Mint in 1859. The surviving population is estimated to be in the range of 175-225 examples in all grades, with AU specimens numbering 35-44 pieces. A curious difficulty arises in grading 1859-C half eagles, as all examples seen are weakly detailed on the reverse. The cause of this anomaly has never been completely explained, but it undoubtedly results from some defect in the die. The present coin features a better-than-average strike for the issue and minimal abrasions for the grade. Census: 26 in 55, 44 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2330

1859-C $5 MS61 NGC. Variety 1. Only a single die pairing is known for this later C-mint issue, despite the somewhat generous production--for the Charlotte Mint--of 31,847 coins. The combination of dies is curious, as while the obverse of this issue is generally well produced, the reverse is notoriously softly struck--the die that made the coins may have been annealed only a single time. The light striations visible in the fields of this Mint State piece impart a definite semiprooflike appearance, even through the consistent reddish-gold color. The obverse is typically sharply struck, while the reverse feather detail is weak, as usual. Two longish contact marks in the right obverse field serve as pedigree markers and help account for the grade. Only five coins are certified finer at NGC and PCGS combined. Census: 8 in 61, 2 finer (2/10).
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2331

1859-D $5 Medium D--Obverse Scratched, Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 36-CC. A light X has been pinscratched into the lower left obverse field, and both sides are mildly bright from a cleaning. Luster fills design recesses. A desirable and low mintage late Dahlonega issue.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P3)

2332

1860-C $5 --Obverse Repaired, Harshly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1. A deep abrasion on the central left obverse field has been crudely smoothed, and the left obverse displays vertical hairlines. Nonetheless, a briefly circulated example of this rare Charlotte issue, struck during the year of Lincoln's pivotal election.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P4)

2333

1860-D $5 Medium D AU53 NGC. CAC. Variety 38-FF. The 1860-D is actually one of the more available D-mint fives in spite of a low mintage of only 14,365 pieces. Of the 145-165 pieces believed known in all grades, it is estimated that 38-42 coins are in AU condition. This is an attractive example for the grade. It is better struck than most D-mint fives, as one would expect from this issue. The surfaces are light reddish-brown with slight traces of luster still seen around the peripheral devices. Each side has a distinctive mark that readily identifies this piece: On the obverse a shallow, vertical mark is located in the field out from the mouth of Liberty, and on the reverse there is a light grease stain that was struck into the planchet at the time of manufacture that is seen above and below the eagle's left (facing) wing.(Registry values: P4)

2334

1860-D $5 Large D--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. Variety 38-EE. A lightly cleaned low mintage Dahlonega five that has peach-tinged luster and a few closely spaced pinscratches near the left (facing) wingtip. The upper right reverse exhibits a faint retained lamination.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.

2335

1861 $5 AU58 PCGS. CAC. Boldly defined on the central details with effusive gold-orange luster. Only a trace of friction keeps this coin from an otherwise well-deserved Mint State grade. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: P3)

2336

1861 $5 MS61 PCGS. Sharply struck with rich lemon-yellow luster. Light abrasions throughout with a handful of more serious marks on the portrait, yet strong eye appeal nonetheless.(Registry values: P3)

2337

1861-C $5 --Polished--NGC. AU Details. Variety 1, the only dies known for the date. The 1861-C half eagle is celebrated for many reasons. It is the final coin produced at the Charlotte Mint. It boasts a tiny mintage of 6,879 pieces. Most of all, it is associated with the Confederacy, as 887 coins were struck after the mint was seized by Southern forces. The surviving population numbers about 150-175 examples in all grades. The surfaces of the present coin show minimal wear and are lightly abraded, but unmistakable signs of polishing are evident.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P6)

2338

1861-D $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Variety 39-EE. The mintage in 1861 was a mere 1,597 coins struck on U.S. government authority, plus a small additional number minted after the Confederate government took control of the facility. Unfortunately, it is impossible to distinguish between the two striking periods.
Bright lemon-yellow surfaces are visible on both sides of this desirable Dahlonega Mint gold piece. The surfaces are lightly abraded with some heavier marks. There is little evidence of cleaning.
From The Lucy Llewellyn Collection of Southern Gold.(Registry values: P6)

2339

1866-S $5 No Motto XF45 NGC. The No Motto variant of the 1866-S has such a low mintage (9,000 pieces) because production stopped when the new dies arrived with the motto above the eagle. This issue is also a condition rarity because hard money was more popular in the Western states, and as a result the finest examples known grade AU58. This is a pleasing Choice XF example that has strong definition for the grade, even reddish color over both sides, and only minor abrasions. A worthy coin for the gold specialist.(Registry values: P8)

2340

1867 $5 --Cleaned--ANACS. AU50 Details. Light wear and abrasions are present on this oddly bright early With Motto Liberty half eagle. The obverse is pale yellow-gold, while the reverse has a more lemony hue.(Registry values: P3)

2341

1867-S $5 VF20 PCGS. A moderately worn yellow-gold example of this challenging With Motto S-mint half eagle. Small digs are noted in the portrait area, and a handful of long abrasions appear in the fields surrounding the eagle. Population: 10 in 20, 44 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2342

1867-S $5 VF20 PCGS. Semibright yellow-gold surfaces display lilac accents at the margins. Good detail is apparent on the design elements, save for areas of high-point wear. Light distributed marks are consistent with the designated grade.(Registry values: P3)

2343

1871-S $5 XF45 NGC. Orange-gold surfaces exhibit traces of luster in the protected areas, more so on the reverse. This well-defined piece has scattered light marks, though their influence on the eye appeal is minimal. Census: 14 in 45, 61 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2344

1872-S $5 XF45 PCGS. Pale yellow-gold overall with suggestions of deeper color away from the mildly lustrous centers. Lightly worn with faint abrasions that appear mostly in the fields and not on the devices. Population: 14 in 45, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2345

1872-S $5 AU55 NGC. Like many of its San Francisco half eagle fellows, the 1872-S is a challenging but underrated issue in better circulated grades. This Choice AU coin remains immensely lustrous despite a measure of wear over the yellow-gold high points. Lightly abraded but decidedly attractive. Census: 19 in 55, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2346

1873 $5 Closed 3 MS62 PCGS. Impressively detailed with light yellow-gold luster. Just a few shallow digs in the fields keep this Closed 3 coin from a finer designation.(Registry values: P3)

2347

1873 $5 Closed 3 MS62 PCGS. CAC. A lustrous example of the Closed 3 variety, similar in mintage to the later Open 3 variant but more challenging in higher grades. Sharply struck with slightly frosted sun-yellow luster. Population: 18 in 62, 17 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2348

1874-CC $5 AU55 NGC. From a mintage of 21,198 pieces, the 1874-CC half eagle is one of the more available Carson City fives, but nearly all specimens seen are in lower circulated grades. At the AU55 level the issue is rare and Mint State examples are extremely rare. Louis Eliasberg only had an XF40 example of this date in his fabulous collection, and Harry Bass settled for an AU58 after 30 years of collecting.
The present coin is a pleasing example, with well detailed design elements that have been eroded by only seven points of even wear. The surfaces are a light greenish-gold color, and no distracting blemishes are noted. This coin possesses considerable charm and significant visual appeal. Census: 15 in 55, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2349

1874-S $5 AU50 PCGS. CAC. Soft yellow-orange luster with glimpses of pink. Lightly rubbed over the high points of the well-defined portrait, but the numerous tiny abrasions that define the grade are not distracting on the whole. Strong eye appeal for this challenging issue of just 16,000 pieces. Population: 7 in 50, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2350

1877-CC $5 XF45 PCGS. Peach-gold luster fills design crevices of this lightly abraded and problem-free rare date half eagle. Only 8,680 pieces were struck for this seldom encountered issue, the fourth lowest mintage Carson City five behind the 1870-CC, 1873-CC, and 1876-CC. Population: 17 in 45, 23 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2351

1878-CC $5 AU55 PCGS. CAC. All Carson City five dollar issues from the 1870s are rare, and the 1878-CC is no exception. Gold bullion depositors preferred payment in double eagles, which were more convenient for accounting purposes. An absence of Old West collectors caused most survivors to remain in circulation for many years. Just one piece has been certified Mint State, which makes an AU example the finest that most collectors can hope to own. The present Choice AU piece has too much friction on the wingtips and eyebrow to command a higher grade, but luster brightens the borders and major devices. No marks are consequential. Population: 5 in 55, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2352

1881-S $5 MS65 NGC. This Gem 1881-S half eagle makes a splendid candidate for a type or date set. Despite the generous mintage approaching 1 million coins, the issue is one that is rare at the MS65 level. The present coin offers pristine surfaces with antique-gold coloration, excellent luster, and a bold strike. A small planchet void appears above the date.(Registry values: P3)

2353

1882-S $5 MS64 NGC. CAC. Bold orange overtones enliven the subtly sparkling surfaces of this near-Gem. Excellent quality for the grade with eye appeal to match. NGC has graded 27 numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2354

1883-S $5 MS63 PCGS. CAC. Vibrant luster exudes from peach-gold surfaces imbued with traces of mint-green and a well executed strike imparts strong definition to the design elements. Scattered ticks preclude a finer grade but do not impede the coin's delightful eye appeal. The 1883-S is difficult to locate in all grades. Population: 22 in 63, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2355

1884 $5 MS63 PCGS. Softly frosted yellow-gold luster develops traces of orange at the margins. Well-defined with two shallow scrapes in the right obverse field that contribute to the grade. Population: 15 in 63, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P3)

2356

1888-S $5 MS62 PCGS. Yellow-gold surfaces display traces of light green and red and are well struck save for minor weakness in some of the star centers. Scattered minute marks result in breaks in the luster flow.(Registry values: P3)

2357

1888-S $5 MS62 PCGS. Well-defined overall, if a trifle soft on Liberty's curls, with distinctive blue-violet color noted close to the rims. Gold-orange hues prevail elsewhere. Light to moderate abrasions account for the grade. Population: 19 in 62, 6 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P3)

2358

1891 $5 MS63 PCGS. CAC. This Select honey-gold half eagle displays nearly full luster and has been in receipt of a decisive strike. Strong eye appeal, despite some grade-limiting marks, a fact recognized by CAC.(Registry values: P3)

2359

1891-CC $5 MS63 PCGS. CAC. The relatively large emission for the Carson City Mint of 208,000 pieces makes this a popular type coin, with survivors available up through the Gem level of preservation, where PCGS has certified a single example. This Select Mint State specimen offers pleasing orange-gold coloration, with a bold strike and minor, grade-consistent marks. PCGS has graded 56 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

2360

1892-CC $5 AU58 NGC. The fields of this near-Mint gold piece are reflective and lustrous, with lovely lemon-yellow hues. A few minor grade consistent abrasions are evident on each side.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2361

1893-CC $5 AU58 NGC. Here is a splendid near-Mint example of the final Carson City Mint half eagle. This piece has lovely yellow luster with hints of iridescence. The design features are sharp and the surfaces are outstanding for the grade.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2362

1895 $5 MS65 NGC. Glowing luster shows beneath the reddish-gold, apricot, and mint-green patination. Sharply struck and revealing a few grade-consistent marks. The 1895 is usually regarded strictly as a gold type coin, but at the MS65 level, it becomes very scarce. Census: 65 in 65, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2363

1895 $5 MS65 NGC. Despite a mintage of more than 1.3 million coins, the 1895 is an important condition rarity. This piece is boldly defined with incredible pinkish-gold luster. Trivial surface marks are evident but they are entirely inconsequential. Census: 65 in 65, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P2)

2364

1900 $5 --Reverse Strike Through--MS64 NGC. Intensely lustrous yellow-gold surfaces display a moderate strike through on the lower reverse. Sharply struck and devoid of significant marks. The NGC insert indicates REVERSE STRUCK THRU MINT ERROR.(Registry values: N1793)

2365

1900 $5 MS64 NGC. CAC. Sharply struck and satiny, this luminous near-Gem has wonderful peach-gold color with considerable orange intermixed. High eye appeal for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2366

1901 $5 MS65 PCGS. A sharply struck Gem example of this turn-of-the-century issue, bold yellow-gold on both sides with a measure of orange on the obverse. Smooth surfaces complete the eye appeal of this coin, ideal for a similarly graded type collection. Housed in a green label holder. PCGS has graded 11 finer examples (1/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2367

1907 $5 MS64 NGC. A sharply struck near-Gem representative of this later Liberty half eagle issue, ideal for a 20th century type set. Bold orange-gold hues deepen to peach at parts of the obverse margins.(Registry values: N1793)

2368

1907-D $5 MS66 NGC. In its second year of operation as the Denver Mint, that facility nearly tripled the previous year's production of half eagles, striking 888,000 pieces of the denomination. This Premium Gem is among the best-preserved survivors of the issue, strongly struck with rich butter-yellow luster that shows undercurrents of orange. Census: 25 in 66, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2369

1908 $5 MS66 NGC. Fully struck in all areas with vibrant mint luster. This is an extraordinary type coin from the final year of the long-running Coronet series. The eye appeal far exceeds the stated grade, which is already considerable. A strong magnifier will reveal a few tiny marks, but none are apparent with the unaided eye. The luster is exceptional, soft, and frosted with a slight bit of reddish patina around the rims. Census: 50 in 66, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Proof Liberty Half Eagles

2370

1885 $5 PR64 Ultra Cameo NGC. Only 66 proofs were produced plus 601,440 coins for circulation. Of that proof production, it is estimated that only 20 or so pieces may exist. Over the past 17 years we have only handled 12 Ultra/Deep Cameo examples. In addition to the stark contrast seen between the fields and devices, one of the first things noticed is the pronounced orange-peel texture of the fields. The grade is explained by a small patch of hairlines in the left obverse field and a short contact mark on the chin of Liberty. Census: 2 in 64 Ultra Cameo, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P4)

Indian Half Eagles

2371

1908 $5 MS64 NGC. Bold lemon-yellow luster and a solid strike are among the best attributes of this first-year Indian half eagle near-Gem. On the obverse, the portrait is remarkably clean, and though a few tiny marks are visible in the surrounding fields, this is an appealing coin that should appeal to the type or date enthusiast.(Registry values: N2998)

2372

1909 $5 MS66 PCGS. Although the 1909 Indian Head half eagles are not series rarities, Akers' recent Handbook points out that the issue is "virtually unobtainable above the MS-65 grade level." Of course, many collectors would be more than proud to own a Gem Indian five dollar, but this Premium Gem piece goes one better. The color is a consistent, mellow orange-gold throughout both sides, with no mentionable distractions, large or small. The strike is much better-executed than normal, and the thick satin luster is a plus. This coin is one of only eight Premium Gem examples certified at PCGS, and there are none finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2373

1909-D $5 MS64 NGC. Sharply struck through the centers with rich gold-orange luster that adds elements of peach close to the edges. Smooth surfaces are distinctly better-preserved than on the more commonly seen Select examples of this type issue. NGC has certified just 67 numerically finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2374

1909-D $5 MS65 NGC. The 1909-D is one of just two Indian half eagles with a mintage of over a million pieces, and its tally of more than 3.4 million coins more than doubles its rival. It is little wonder that the 1909-D should be an important type issue, and indeed it is a "date of choice" in many grades, even MS65, where it is merely scarce and not rare. This Gem has strong yellow-gold luster with elements of wheat at the margins. Die erosion is noted at the margins, but the overall definition is excellent, with only the lowest pendant of the necklace soft. Carefully preserved with great eye appeal. Census: 65 in 65, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2375

1909-O $5 XF40 PCGS. Bright yellow-gold surfaces display faint traces of apricot and mint-green, and the design elements are relatively strong for the grade, though the mintmark is weak. Light abrasions are in concert with a coin having seen some circulation. One of the most difficult dates in the Indian Head half eagle series.(Registry values: N1793)

2376

1909-O $5 XF45 NGC. The brass-gold surfaces of this bright Choice XF O-mint representative display subtle hints of reddish-tan. Minute distributed marks are more or less in line with a coin having seen light circulation, and the design elements retain a good amount of detail. This issue is popular owing to its low mintage (34,200 pieces) and status as the only Indian Head half eagle to be struck at the New Orleans Mint.(Registry values: N1793)

2377

1909-O $5 XF45 NGC. The memorably low mintage was only 34,200 pieces for the 1909-O half eagle, and examples are eagerly sought. This modestly circulated coin shows the light, even wear expected of the Choice XF grade, with antique-gold coloration over surfaces that still show subdued luster around the devices. There are no singular abrasions.(Registry values: N1793)

2378

1909-O $5 AU55 PCGS. The 1909-O is rarely seen in mint condition, making a Choice AU coin such as this one an excellent buy for the savvy collector. Only slight rub is seen over the high points, and significant amounts of mint luster remain on each side. The all-important mintmark is somewhat flat, but it is unmistakably an O.(Registry values: N2998)

2379

1909-O $5 AU55 NGC. Lightly rubbed across each side but with considerable detail and luster remaining on the yellow-orange surfaces. The obverse does not have any singularly mentionable abrasions, and on the reverse, only a small mark below the word OF qualifies. Great eye appeal for the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2380

1909-O $5 AU55 NGC. Although fewer 1929 examples are extant, the 1909-O is the most conditionally challenging issue in the entire Indian half eagle series. This lot offers an attractive, orange-gold and honey-gold colored representative with few sizeable abrasions for the grade. The strike is typical for the issue, there is little perceptible wear except over the highest points of the design. The mintmark is softly impressed.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2381

1909-O $5 MS61 NGC. The 1909-O half eagle's low mintage of 34,200 pieces makes it the key to the Indian Head five dollar series, but its status as the last O-mint gold coin increases its historical appeal in the eyes of many collectors. The old Mint on Esplanade Avenue in New Orleans still stands today, maintained by the Louisiana State Museum (along with four other buildings) coming through Hurricane Katrina in August 2005 relatively unscathed, like most of the French Quarter. This memento of the facility's closure 101 years ago boasts a fully formed mintmark and well-struck surfaces with orange-gold coloration. The scattered fields marks are mostly confined to the reverse, around the motto. Acquisition of this attractive piece would certainly be cause for celebration with coffee and beignets. Census: 64 in 61, 45 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2382

1909-O $5 MS61 PCGS. The 1909-O half eagle represents the swan song of the New Orleans Mint, which closed in 1909 after 71 years of coinage operations. The 1909-O half eagle represents a number of significant milestones in U.S. coinage. It is the only O-mint 20th century half eagle, the last gold coin struck at the New Orleans Mint, and the first half eagle struck in New Orleans since 1894. Due to its small mintage of 34,200 coins and low subsequent survival, it is also the key to the Indian Head half eagle series. This Mint State coin offers bright yellow-gold surfaces that are sharply struck overall. There are numerous small- to medium-sized abrasions that account for the grade, including a tick on the right side of the mintmark. Population: 17 in 61, 38 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2383

1909-O $5 MS63 NGC. The 1909-O half eagle is one of the rarest regular issue coins from the 20th century. Only 34,200 pieces were issued in this final year of production in the New Orleans mint. While occasionally available in VF through AU grades, the number of Uncirculated pieces is always in extremely short supply. In fact, the number certified in mint condition can only be compared to the legendary 1929.
It is interesting to compare and contrast the 1909-O and the 1929. Both are major rarities, but each for different reasons. The 1929 has even fewer Uncirculated coins known. It also has far fewer examples extant in all grades and is all but unknown in circulated condition. The 1929 had a significant mintage of 662,000 pieces, but virtually the entire production was melted and today we are left with an estimated 100 or so examples. The 1909-O, on the other hand, apparently was just not saved. Obviously a few were, but others wore out in circulation, some were melted during the 1930s, and others were exported to Europe. As a result, the 1909-O is an attention-grabber in Uncirculated grades. NGC has only certified 127 coins in mint condition, and PCGS has graded a paltry 59 pieces in Uncirculated. In MS63 NGC has only certified six other pieces, and 16 have been graded higher (1/10).
This is an extraordinarily attractive example of this major rarity. The surfaces are obviously original with each side showing intermixed reddish-gold and lilac patina. As usually seen, the strike is strong throughout with even the lowest feather in the headdress showing almost complete definition. A few small, inconsequential field marks are seen on each side, the most obvious are a small cluster in the reverse field below AM in AMERICA. Specialists in this highly collectible and challenging series will appreciate the opportunity presented by this exceptionally high grade, key issue.(Registry values: N10218)

2384

1909-S $5 MS60 NGC. A desirable Mint State piece with dark patina over yellow-gold luster. Minor abrasions and faint scratches prevent a higher grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2385

1910 $5 MS64 NGC. CAC. Like many higher-mintage Indian half eagle issues, the 1910 is available for a price in grades through MS63, but MS64 coins are more elusive and Gems are conditionally rare. Strongly lustrous surfaces are yellow-gold at the borders of this Choice coin with a more orange cast at the centers. The reverse has a single notable abrasion below the space between STATES and OF.(Registry values: N2998)

2386

1910-D $5 MS63 NGC. CAC. The 1910-D half eagle is borderline scarce in MS63 and a condition rarity any finer, with just 16 such pieces known to NGC (1/10). This Select piece has distinctive eye appeal, with lustrous gold-orange centers giving way to generous amounts of violet-colored alloy close to the rims. Only a few wispy marks preclude an even finer grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2387

1911-S $5 MS62 PCGS. Soft orange-gold luster enhances the eye appeal of this Indian five. Well struck with a selection of grade-defining marks on and to the left of the portrait. The 1911-S issue is generally not found better than MS62, which makes high-end examples in that grade an especially good value.(Registry values: N1793)

2388

1911-S $5 MS62 PCGS. The 1911-S is a scarce S-mint issue in the short-lived five dollar Indian series. Most examples known were not well preserved, like this piece, which is remarkably clean for the grade. The surfaces are bright yellow-gold and sharply struck with just a bit of softness on the lowest feather in the headdress.(Registry values: N1793)

2389

1914 $5 MS62 PCGS. Yellow-orange luster overall, tending to the former color. A well struck example with wispy abrasions that account for the grade.(Registry values: N991)

2390

1914-S $5 MS62 NGC. The peach-gold surfaces of this S-mint representative reveal occasional whispers of apricot and sky-blue and tend to possess brighter luster than usually seen. The design elements are well impressed, a characteristic attribute of the issue. Light marks in the raised exposed fields help limit the grade but are not serious.(Registry values: N2998)

2391

1915 $5 MS64 PCGS. CAC. The 1915 can be acquired through near-Gem, but MS65s are elusive, and anything finer is virtually unobtainable. A mix of yellow-gold, apricot, and mint-green patina resides on the lustrous surfaces of the current MS64 offering. The strike is nearly complete and both sides are minimally marked.(Registry values: N2998)

2392

1929 $5 MS63 PCGS. This 1929 half eagle was struck during the year the Depression era began, the first new coinage of the denomination since the 1916-S production. Although 662,000 pieces were recorded struck, the issue is much rarer than such a mintage would indicate. Most examples never saw the light of day before being melted, as the average certified survivor falls somewhere between MS62 and MS63. Akers states conclusively that "most of the original mintage was destroyed in the Mint."
The present MS63 specimen displays splendid surfaces with orange-gold coloration tinged with lilac near the rims. A few minor marks and ticks on each side account for the grade, but the eye appeal is great.(Registry values: N4719)

Early Eagles

2393

1795 $10 13 Leaves--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Breen-6830, Taraszka-1, BD-1, High R.3. Attributed by star 11 being close to the serif of Y in LIBERTY, the tip of 5 in the date overlapping the bust, and the leaf virtually touches the U in UNITED. This is the more available of the five 1795 varieties and thus popular as a type coin.
Excellent definition is apparent on the design elements of this AU details example, including Liberty's hair strands and drapery and the eagle's wing plumage. Its yellow-gold surfaces display traces of luster in the recessed areas, and minute "blisters" at the margins point to as-made die rust. Light hairlines show under magnification, and faint pinscratch-like marks on Liberty's portrait are visible when examined with a loupe. Parts of the cheek and neck appear to have been smoothed or lightly polished in an attempt to remove these. Some light adjustment marks are visible at the lower right reverse margin. All in all, this is an attractive example for a large, heavy gold coin that saw brief circulation, and as such will fit comfortably in a high-grade circulated type set.(Registry values: P5)

2394

1799 $10 Small Stars Obverse MS62 NGC. Breen-6839, Taraszka-15, BD-3, High R.6. A Mint State example of the rare BD-3 variety. This piece is the later die state with cracks through the B and L of LIBERTY. Harry Bass only found one example of this variety in all his years of collecting.
This piece is possibly the finest known example, comparing quite favorably to the Bass coin that is on loan to the ANA museum. Prooflike greenish-gold surfaces have traces of orange patina near the borders. Both sides are moderately abraded, consistent with the grade. The definition is strong on each side with fine detailing on Liberty's hair curls and the breast feathers of the eagle.(Registry values: P2)

2395

1800 $10 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Breen-6842, Taraszka-23, BD-1, High R.3. BD Obverse State b/Reverse State d. Only the one die marriage is known for the year, with the Y in LIBERTY nearly touching the ninth star and the 1 virtually touching the lowest hair curl. The reverse is a carryover from the 1799 Large Stars BD-10, and it would be used again on the 1801 BD-1 (and reused in a different die state with the 1800 obverse after a different 1801 reverse failed).
The obverse of this piece shows the die crack light above LIB and heavier from the rim through BERT, while the Reverse State d is from the clashing of the obverse denticles above STAT. While the greenish-gold surfaces are a bit on the bright side, this is a splendid early gold type coin that offers many attractions. There are no singular signs of contact on either side, the strike is bold and well-centered, and there are no planchet adjustment marks--a piece worthy of strong bidding despite the minor distraction.(Registry values: P2)

2396

1801 $10 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Breen-6843, Taraszka-25, BD-2, R.2. The more available die pair for the year, offered here with only slight wear. Though a past cleaning has disrupted the yellow-gold luster, the overall eye appeal holds up. A few abrasions are noted on each side, including a vertical pinscratch on Liberty's cheek.(Registry values: P1)

2397

1801 $10 --Damaged--NGC. AU Details. Breen-6843, Taraszka-25, BD-2, R.2. Star 7 has two points close to the cap, and star 1 has one point distant from the hair curl. The BD-2 die combination is the single most plentiful variety in the entire series from 1795 to 1804. It is a variety frequently found in type collections.
This green-gold representative has sharp details and considerable luster on both sides. The obverse has a heavy scratch through the mouth into the right field, with other lesser scratches in that field. Pin scratches outline the entire obverse device.(Registry values: P1)

2398

1801 $10 AU53 PCGS. Breen-6843, Taraszka-24, BD-1, R.5. The 1801 eagle boasts a mintage of 44,344 pieces, and there are two known varieties for the date. The present coin is a representative of the rare BD-1 variety, easily distinguished by the obverse stars, which have thicker, stubbier spines than the more available BD-2 variety. The BD-1 is nicknamed the Horned Beak variety because clash marks on the reverse sometimes produce the appearance of a tiny horn on the back of the eagle's head.
The present coin is a delightful specimen with attractive yellow-gold surfaces and a minimum number of abrasions for the grade. Only light, even wear shows on the high points of the design, and much original detail remains in the feathers on the eagle's breast and the star centrils. John Dannreuther estimates only 40-50 examples of the BD-1 variety survive today in all grades.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: P1)

2399

1801 $10 AU55 NGC. Breen-6843, Taraszka-24, BD-1, R.5. The BD-1 variety is far rarer than the relatively available BD-2, the only other variant for 1801 eagles. The BD-1 obverse is a new die for the year, but the hardy reverse is a carryover from the two previous years, used first for the R.3 1799 BD-10, then for the single-variety BD-1 of 1800. In its final use in 1801, the reverse die was likely already cracked from the previous year's use and it failed in 1801, resulting in this rare variety. Although the mintage of eagles in 1801 is numbered at 44,344 pieces (although some were likely dated 1800), Bass-Dannreuther estimate that 2,500 to 4,000 pieces of the BD-1 were produced, of which some 40 to 50 survive today. On the obverse star 1 has two points facing the lowest curl, and star 8 has one point facing toward the cap. L is close to the cap, and Y is close to star 9. A die crack runs from the edge between 0 and 1 of the date upward to the bust. Another crack runs from star 13 up through the throat and jawline. On the reverse, denticle clashes show above STAT, and a leaf tip touches the right bottom serif of I in AMERICA.
This lightly circulated example has bright yellow-gold surfaces that retain much luster and are free of visible adjustment marks. Despite a number of tiny marks through LIBERTY at the top of the obverse, this elusive piece displays much allure and would be an exciting acquisition for the many specialists pursuing rare early gold.(Registry values: P1)

2400

1803 $10 Large Stars Reverse AU53 NGC. Breen-6846, B. 1-F, Taraszka-32, BD-6, R.7. Six die varieties of 1803 eagles are known, from one obverse and six reverse dies. The BD-6 eagle is clearly the rarest of all six varieties, with only seven examples known to us.
In 1803, the initial punch used for the Small Stars Reverse type (BD-1 through 4) was replaced with a larger star punch (BD-5 and BD-6). BD-5 is also known as the "14 Stars" reverse, with an extra star superimposed on cloud 8, and BD-6, the variety offered here, is the true 13 stars reverse die of the Large Stars type. In 30 years of gold coin collecting, Harry Bass never acquired an example of this variety, the only early eagle that he never obtained. In our June 2008 auction, we offered an MS62 example, and at the time prepared a roster of those pieces known to us. The following is an abbreviated, slightly updated version:

1. MS62 NGC. Heritage (6/2008), lot 2106.
2. MS61 NGC. Heritage (8/1998), lot 7744.
3. AU58 PCGS. Superior (5/2006), lot 1192.
4. AU55. Bowers and Merena (9/1988), lot 538.
5. AU53 NGC. The present specimen. Ex: Superior (6/1981), lot 362.
6. XF45 PCGS. Los Angeles Pre-ANA (Heritage, 7/2009), lot 1297.
7. Net AG3; VG details, ex-Jewelry ANACS. Heritage (3/2003), lot 6347.

This example is an attractive green-gold piece with some luster remaining on both sides. A few scattered surface marks in the field are consistent with the grade. The early gold variety specialist is provided an opportunity to acquire an extremely rare die variety, one that is missing from most collections.(Registry values: P3)

2401

1803 $10 Extra Star AU58 NGC. Breen-6845, Taraszka-30, BD-5, High R.4. A faint outline of the small "extra" star is seen in the last cloud on the reverse. Only one obverse die was used to strike all 1803 eagles, but six reverse dies are known: four with small reverse stars, and two (BD-5 and BD-6) with large reverse stars. This piece is Bass-Dannreuther die state g/b, as evidenced by the die crack on the reverse from the rim to the center of the right wing, a die line (possibly clashing) in the right wing, and a clash mark below the third cloud.
Charming yellow-gold patina coats the lightly abraded surfaces of this near-Mint State example. Liberty's hair is a touch soft, but the reverse is fully defined with complete feather detail on the breast of the eagle. Flashy luster adds to the aesthetic appeal. John Dannreuther (2006) estimates that 90 to 110 examples of this variety are known, but our experience suggests that the number of survivors is even lower.

2402

1804 $10 Crosslet 4 AU58 NGC. Breen-6847, Taraszka-31, BD-1, High R.4. Bass-Dannreuther Obverse State b, Reverse State b, with faint peripheral die cracks on each side. This is the only 1804-dated die pair used to strike eagles for circulation, and 1804 is the last year that appears on early eagles--but it does not follow that the 1804 Crosslet 4 eagle was the last variety struck. As Bass and Dannreuther recount in Early U.S. Gold Coin Varieties, "Actually, [1804] is the last date in the series but not the final coin struck for the circulation series. The reverse used for this coin ... was used after striking this date/variety for the very rare 1-E [die] combination of 1803, BD-6 ... So the mintage totals for this year, already a scant 3,757, undoubtedly include some coins dated 1803!"
Bass and Dannreuther also highlight the Plain 4 version of the 1804 eagle, struck as proofs in 1834 and possibly 1835 for inclusion in diplomatic presentation sets, though they are careful to distinguish those later proofs from their circulating Crosslet 4 counterparts. As for the Crosslet 4 BD-1 pieces, the authors estimate 80 to 100 pieces surviving, many of them impaired, which makes the issue very scarce in any state. Viewed in that context, a near-Mint coin such as the present piece becomes even more impressive. Radiant yellow-gold surfaces are lightly abraded overall with only trifling wear at the high points, though striking weakness is also present there and at several of the obverse stars. Adjustment marks are noted on Liberty's cap. Census: 14 in 58, 29 finer (1/10).(Registry values: P4)

Liberty Eagles

2403

1839 $10 Type of 1838, Large Letters--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. XF Details. The head of Liberty leans forward, and her bust truncation is dramatically curved. Most of the ear is covered. These characteristics identify the Head of 1838, a rare design subtype currently recognized only with a footnote in the Guide Book. This is a lightly cleaned and relatively unabraded straw-gold example that shows glimpses of luster within the plumage and legends.(Registry values: N1793)

2404

1842-O $10 AU53 NGC. Most 1842-O eagles that are encountered are in the Very Fine to Extremely Fine range. Mint State pieces are extremely rare; indeed, NGC and PCGS have seen a mere four Uncirculated examples, none higher than MS63. The yellow-gold surfaces of this AU53 specimen are imbued with traces of mint-green and apricot and exhibit well defined devices. The few minute marks are undisturbing.(Registry values: N2998)

2405

1843-O $10 AU53 PCGS. Light yellow-gold color overall with suggestions of orange. This mildly worn O-mint ten shows only minor ticks and wispy abrasions on each side. Population: 16 in 53, 22 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2406

1844-O $10 AU53 NGC. Yellow-gold surfaces display whispers of mint-green and orange. Generally well defined and moderately abraded. The '44-O becomes extremely difficult to locate in Mint State(Registry values: N2998)

2407

1844-O $10 AU58 NGC. The mintmark is recut within the loop, which corresponds to Winter's Variety One. A sharply struck straw-gold Borderline Uncirculated New Orleans No Motto ten that has unmarked surfaces aside from two minor rim dings, at 7 o'clock on the obverse and 12:30 on the reverse. Census: 49 in 58, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2408

1846 $10 AU55 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. Bright luster fills the legends and surrounds individual stars. Neither side has any individually consequential marks. Scarce in all grades due to a mintage of only 20,095 pieces. The NGC website records five examples with pedigrees to the ill-fated S.S. Republic. Census: 15 in 55, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2409

1846/5-O $10 XF45 NGC. Variety Three. Ex: S.S. Republic. The so-called overdate, paired with a reverse that shows a doubled mintmark. Lightly abraded surfaces offer pale yellow-gold radiance. This piece comes in a wood presentation case with S.S. Republic plate, which also contains an informational disc and a certificate of authenticity. It also comes with a hardcover copy of the book Lost Gold of the Republic.(Registry values: N991)

2410

1846/5-O $10 AU53 NGC. Designated merely as an 1846-O by NGC, but the date location confirms the overdate. The mintmark is lightly repunched north. This is a moderately abraded and original example with radiant lemon-gold color and glimpses of dirt in protected areas. Overdate or not, the 1846-O is significantly scarcer than its '47-O successor.(Registry values: N2998)

2411

1846/5-O $10 AU58 NGC. CAC. Undesignated by NGC as the overdate variety. The obverse shows only a faint suggestion of friction, and the reverse alone has the appearance of a Mint State coin. A number of light to moderate marks are scattered on each side, but this yellow-gold survivor has considerable eye appeal nonetheless. A small rim break is noted above star 8 on the obverse. Census: 5 in 58, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2412

1847 $10 AU58 NGC. Bright yellow-gold surfaces display traces of luster in the recessed areas of the well detailed design motifs. Minuscule circulation ticks are uniformly distributed.(Registry values: N991)

2413

1848 $10 AU55 PCGS. Ample yellow-gold luster remains on each side of this lightly circulated eagle. Scattered moderate abrasions appear on each side, most notably a set of reed marks below star 8 on the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

2414

1848-O $10 XF45 PCGS. Uniform honey-gold patina bathes both sides of this well defined O-mint specimen. Scattered minute marks are not serious. Population: 28 in 45, 32 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2415

1849-O $10 AU53 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. Luminous luster outlines the design of this untoned and minimally abraded rare date New Orleans eagle. The NGC website pedigrees seven '49-O tens to the 1865 S.S. Republic shipwreck. Just 23,900 pieces were struck. Census: 21 in 53, 21 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2416

1850 $10 Large Date AU55 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. Untoned and luminous with a typical strike and a small number of left obverse abrasions. The S.S. Republic sank shortly after the Civil War ended, and took with a large number of Federal gold coins from the prior two decades. Those were well distributed by date and mint, unlike the S.S. Central America which mostly held 1857-S twenties.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2417

1850 $10 Small Date AU55 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. The NGC Census lists just three Small Date 1850 tens from the S.S. Republic, although that 1865 shipwreck surrendered 46 Large Date examples. This is a pale gold No Motto eagle that has a good strike and shimmering luster near the rims. One field scuff near star 3 merits passing mention. Census: 14 in 55, 20 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2418

1850-O $10 XF45 PCGS. CAC. Though softly defined on most obverse design elements, this Choice XF piece has strong detail on the eagle's feathers. Strikingly yellow-orange surfaces show glimpses of original luster as well as an assortment of abrasions. Population: 40 in 45, 26 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

2419

1851 $10 AU55 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. This luminous light yellow-gold No Motto eagle shows minor incompleteness of strike on the claws and fletchings. Small marks are present but require no further elaboration.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 5/2008), lot 3384, which realized $3,220.(Registry values: N1793)

2420

1851-O $10 AU55 NGC. CAC. Bright yellow-gold surfaces retain luster in the recessed areas of the well delineated design motifs; only the stars reveal the usual softness. Scattered circulation marks do not disturb. Infrequently encountered above AU.(Registry values: N1793)

2421

1851-O $10 AU58 PCGS. CAC. A total of 99 examples of the 1851-O eagle were recovered aboard the wreck of the S.S. Republic, making the issue now among the most available tens of the 1850s up to the Mint State level. Uncirculated examples remain rare. Nearly full mint luster remains on this example, which boasts orange-gold surfaces with some tinges of copper color. A few moderate abrasions appear on each side. Population: 16 in 58, 9 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2422

1852 $10 AU55 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. Clean yellow-gold surfaces display some luster in the recesses. Generally well defined, except for the hair around Liberty's ear and the fletchings. Moderate marks are noted on the field near star 2.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 5/2008), lot 3386, which realized $2,990.(Registry values: N1793)

2423

1852 $10 MS60 NGC. The 1852 is generally available in XF or AU, but like all other No Motto issues, it emerges as a rarity in Mint State. The present representative has no obtrusive abrasions, and the strike is bold for the type. Luster is prominent throughout the borders and devices. Census: 7 in 60, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2424

1853 $10 AU58 NGC. Wheat-gold luster overall with elements of yellow. The centers have pleasing detail, though the upper right obverse stars are distinctly soft. Minor friction and wispy abrasions account for the grade. NGC has certified just 37 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

2425

1853 $10 AU58 PCGS. CAC. Just a trace of friction affects the devices on this near-Mint coin, and the honey-gold luster is largely unaffected. Scattered abrasions cross each side. Population: 19 in 58, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

2426

1853-O $10 AU55 PCGS. Yellow-gold coloration adorns each side of this nicely defined Choice AU eagle. Moderate marks are more prevalent on the obverse. Population: 11 in 55, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2427

1854 $10 MS61 NGC. An amazing survivor from a mintage that was limited to just 54,250 coins. As production got underway at the new San Francisco Mint, production figures of gold coins substantially decreased in Philadelphia. This boldly defined Mint State piece has brilliant lemon-yellow luster with a few minor abrasions and hairlines that are consistent with the grade. A lovely piece. Census: 5 in 61, 4 finer (2/10).
Ex: Baltimore ANA Signature (Heritage, 8/2008), lot 3123, which realized $6,900.(Registry values: N4719)

2428

1855 $10 AU58 NGC. Light wheat-gold luster with occasional peach infusions toward the rims. Modest friction affects the well-defined central devices and softer stars. A shallow cut is noted in the field just above Liberty's head. NGC has graded 43 finer examples (1/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2429

1855-O $10 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .92 suggests Cleaning as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an XF specimen that has been cleaned. Yellow-orange surfaces are oddly luminous and bright despite the readily appreciable wear on the devices.

2430

1855-O $10 VF25 NGC. Light yellow surfaces with faint traces of pale green are evident on each side of this desirable Liberty ten. The mintage of 18,000 was low enough to ensure its status as a rarity in the series.(Registry values: N991)

2431

1855-S $10 XF45 NGC. The surfaces on this low-mintage issue of 9,000 coins are unsurprisingly somewhat prooflike, despite 15 points of wear. The surfaces are canary-gold, with deeper tinges of lilac around the devices. A loupe reveals moderately abraded surfaces, including a pair of deep nicks on Liberty's chin. A nonetheless appealing example, with lots of life left. Census: 11 in 45, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2432

1856 $10 AU58 PCGS. CAC. A scarcer, low-mintage date infrequently encountered close to Mint State. A fair amount of luster occurs on the peach-gold surfaces. Well impressed and revealing scattered, relatively inoffensive marks. Population: 19 in 58, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2433

1856-O $10 VF30 NGC. Well defined for the grade, though the reverse shows some of the usual strike weakness. Yellow-gold surfaces exhibit hints of luster in some of the recesses and reveal distributed ticks. A scarce low-mintage issue.(Registry values: N991)

2434

1856-S $10 AU55 NGC. Breen-6923, "Very rare." The Large S mintmark variety, which is scarcer than its Medium S counterpart. The mintmark location is also different, since the Large S does not fit in the customary location above the EN in TEN. A lovely apricot-gold Choice AU No Motto eagle with abundant peripheral luster and no obtrusive marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2435

1856-S $10 AU55 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America. SSCA 6956. Medium S. This apricot-gold No Motto ten has luster consistent with a higher grade. Minimally abraded save for a thin mark on the cheek. Certified in a gold label holder.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2436

1856-S $10 AU58 PCGS. CAC. Medium S. The 1856-S is scarce in all circulated grades and quite rare in Mint State. Considerable luster is apparent on the yellow-gold surfaces of this near-Mint State example and a solid strike imparts sharp detail to the design elements. Distributed minute circulation marks do not detract. Population: 13 in 58, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2437

1857 $10 AU55 NGC. Honey-gold and mint-green patination bathes both sides of this Choice AU eagle, each of which displays traces of muted luster in the recesses. Well defined except for the usual weakness in the star centers. A few light marks are scattered about.(Registry values: N1793)

2438

1857-O $10 AU55 NGC. Heritage has never sold a Mint State example of this elusive and low-mintage issue, and Choice AU and better coins are condition rarities. This AU55 example has strong remaining luster with an element of reflectivity. Lightly worn with minor, scattered abrasions but strong eye appeal. Census: 15 in 55, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2439

1858 $10 XF40 PCGS. Legendary Fort Worth dealer B. Max Mehl promoted the 1858 ten as a great rarity, and in fact the mintage of 2,521 pieces is the lowest production Philadelphia issue of the series prior to 1863. Considerable sun-gold luster outlines design elements, and the few moderate marks on the reverse field are appropriate for the grade and type.(Registry values: N4719)

2440

1858-O $10 AU55 NGC. A mintage of only 20,000 pieces ensures the scarcity of the 1858-O. Less bullion reached New Orleans by 1858 than in years past, since California-mined gold now remained in that state to serve the burgeoning economy. The present honey-gold '58-O ten has noticeable luster and a scarcity of distracting marks. Census: 47 in 55, 46 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2441

1858-S $10 AU55 NGC. Produced in only the fourth full year of operations at the branch mint in San Francisco, the 1858-S eagle saw a limited mintage of only 11,800 coins, most of which clearly circulated. The average certified survivor only grades XF40 or so. This Choice AU example offers mellow sunset-orange coloration over still-lustrous surfaces that show a few moderate abrasions, none singularly distracting. Census: 16 in 55, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2442

1861 $10 AU50 PCGS. CAC. Gold-orange luster is dim but undeniable on this lightly circulated, moderately abraded Liberty ten. Strong central definition yields to slight striking weakness close to the margins.(Registry values: N991)

2443

1865 $10 XF45 PCGS. Glimpses of prooflike luster hug protected areas of the reverse, while the obverse has a slightly subdued straw-gold appearance. Small marks are scattered but none singularly distract. Since gold coins failed to circulate except on the West Coast in 1865, only 3,980 business strike tens were struck, along with just 25 proofs. Population: 17 in 45, 14 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2444

1866-S $10 Motto VF30 PCGS. Light wheat-gold surfaces are surprisingly radiant given the moderate wear and abrasions on each side. Overall, an attractive mid-range example of this low-mintage and minimally saved San Francisco issue. Population: 2 in 30, 26 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2445

1869-S $10 AU53 NGC. From a modest mintage of 6,430 pieces, the 1869-S eagle is an underrated coin today, because many issues of the period had even lower production totals. Garrett and Guth believe the 1869-S is just as rare as its contemporaries, and coins at the AU53 level are very rare. The present coin is sharply struck, with pleasing green-gold surfaces, and remarkably few abrasions for the grade. Census: 13 in 53, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2446

1870 $10 XF45 NGC. The 1870 is a rarity from a mintage of only 3,900 coins, and few of those have survived. Considerable luster remains in the protected areas of this pleasing piece. The surfaces are clearly abraded, as expected for the grade. Both sides are greenish-gold with hints of rose toning. Census: 17 in 45, 49 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2447

1870-S $10 VF20 PCGS. Slightly glossy tan-gold appearance and a cluster of faded vertical marks near the profile. Only 8,000 pieces were struck. Scarce in all grades. Encased in an old green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2448

1871-CC $10 XF45 NGC. Following a small mintage of less than 6,000 coins in 1870, the Carson City Mint produced 8,085 eagles in 1871. Survivors are rare in all grades. This piece has splendid honey-gold color with minor abrasions that are strictly grade consistent. Here is a splendid opportunity for the avid Carson City collector to acquire a rare and important issue. Census: 17 in 45, 33 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2449

1872-CC $10 XF45 PCGS. CAC. While the Carson City Mint in 1872 increased its double eagle output more than 50% over the previous year, from 17,387 to 26,900 coins, it simultaneously managed to roughly halve its eagle output compared to 1871, from 8,085 coins to 4,600 (Guide Book figure; Rusty Goe reports 5,500). To this day, both NGC and PCGS have yet to certify a single Mint State piece, although a handful of AU coins are known. This Choice XF specimen offers wonderfully lustrous orange-gold surfaces, tinged with amber at the rims, that show a few light abrasions consistent with a short spate in circulation. Population: 14 in 45, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2450

1872-S $10 AU50 PCGS. CAC. All S-mint eagles between 1857 and 1878 are rarities. The 1872-S is no exception, since only 17,300 pieces were struck, none of which are certified as Mint State by PCGS. This is a well defined example with noticeable luster and no offensive marks. Population: 14 in 50, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2451

1874-CC $10 XF45 PCGS. A marvelous representative, this Choice XF eagle has light yellow-gold surfaces with a single heavy mark in the left obverse field, and otherwise only minor abrasions. This sharply defined piece retains excellent eye appeal. Population: 33 in 45, 30 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2452

1874-S $10 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. A lightly worn example of this challenging low-mintage issue. Scattered abrasions visit "bright-dull" yellow surfaces rendered that way by a past cleaning.(Registry values: N4719)

2453

1875-CC $10 AU50 NGC. Variety 1-A, probably the only dies for the date, although another variety is rumored. Many Carson City issues of the 1870s can claim low mintages, some much smaller than the 1875-CC eagle with its modest production total of 7,715 pieces. However, the date remains one of the least available Carson City tens. Doug Winter estimates a surviving population of just 65-75 examples in all grades, with only 6-7 specimens in AU condition.
The 1875-CC is notorious for its poor strike, especially on the obverse. The present coin is about average for the date, with weakness on the hair, facial features, and left stars. The reverse displays more detail, but wear shows more on the high points. The surfaces are an attractive medium greenish-gold, and abrasions are minimal for the grade. Census: 7 in 50, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2454

1875-CC $10 AU53 PCGS. Although Carson City struck more than 100,000 double eagles in 1875, their emission of eagles was minimal. Only 7,715 ten dollar pieces were struck, and all went directly into circulation. The typical 1875-CC grades VF to XF. The present example has ample bright luster and a fairly good strike. Moderate marks are scattered, although none require individual mention. Carson City gold coins have greatly increased in popularity over the past two decades, as their history and rarity have been discovered by collectors. Population: 10 in 53, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2455

1876-CC $10 XF45 PCGS. This extremely important Carson City eagle survives from a mintage of only 4,696 coins. It is a lovely piece with excellent surfaces for the grade. While minor abrasions are noted on both sides, they are entirely trivial and inconsequential. Yellow-gold luster is still visible in the protected areas, while faint orange toning remains, especially on the reverse. Population: 21 in 45, 20 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2456

1876-S $10 AU55 NGC. This apricot-gold Centennial year eagle has ample remnants of bright luster, particularly on the eagle and borders. With a mintage of just 5,000 pieces, this is a rare San Francisco issue, and is conditionally very rare at the AU55 level. PCGS has yet to certify any examples above AU53. Census: 7 in 55, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2457

1877-CC $10 VF35 PCGS. Variety 1-A. Only 55-65 pieces are believed known today out of the tiny mintage of 3,332 coins. Of those survivors, approximately half are in the VF grade range. This piece lacks the usually seen heavy abrasions. The surfaces are bright and each side shows only the small marks one would expect from a VF coin. The obverse appears slightly less well defined than the reverse.(Registry values: N1793)

2458

1877-CC $10 VF35 PCGS. Smooth green-gold surfaces host splashes of light orange toning. Both sides have entirely trivial scattered surface marks. We have seen numerous higher grade examples with much heavier abrasions. While moderately worn from its time in circulation, this piece still retains excellent detail. Population: 3 in 35, 28 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2459

1878-CC $10 VF20 PCGS. This Carson City eagle is an excellent example of PCGS's occasional net grading of important rarities. The existing detail suggests a sharpness grade of XF40. The coin has been lightly cleaned with visible hairlines. Splashes of orange toning over the yellow surfaces insure that this desirable piece will be actively pursued.(Registry values: N2998)

2460

1880-CC $10 XF45 PCGS. Hints of luster occur in the recessed areas of this Choice XF ten dollar. The yellow-gold surfaces reveal the expected number of marks.(Registry values: N991)

2461

1880-CC $10 AU55 NGC. The 1880-CC is a very scarce ten, as indicated by its low mintage of only 11,190 pieces. It is infrequently found in Choice AU condition with only a couple of dozen coins known. This is a lovely example that shows bright yellow-gold color overall with a pronounced accent of deep golden-russet around the margins. The coin is well struck and there are the expected handling marks on each side.(Registry values: N1793)

2462

1880-O $10 AU55 NGC. This coin was made in the year that noted collector Charles I. Bushnell died. New Orleans' eagle mintage in 1880 of 9,000 coins was the lowest of the four mints producing the denomination, although the 1880-CC was close at 11,190 pieces. The 1880-O is only the second O-mint With Motto eagle issue, after the 1879-O, which is extremely rare due to the tiny mintage of 1,500 coins. This Choice AU 1880-O boasts splendid luster over orange-gold surfaces that display only light field chatter but no mentionable abrasions. Minor strike weakness is confined to the hair over Liberty's ear. Census: 33 in 55, 40 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2463

1880-S $10 MS63 NGC. Tiny S, Breen-6999. Enough well abraded Uncirculated '80-S tens have returned from European bank holdings to satisfy collector demand, but examples with a relatively unblemished appearance are highly elusive. The present piece is satiny and well struck with the expected number of faint obverse marks. Census: 25 in 63, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2464

1880-S $10 MS63 PCGS. The mintage of the 1880-S is unimpressive at more than 500,000 pieces, but although hundreds of examples are certified as MS61 or MS62, the picture changes any finer. MS63 coins are rare, and only a single NGC MS66 is graded above MS64. The present '80-S is sharply struck and lustrous, but its greatest asset is its relatively few abrasions. Population: 28 in 63, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2465

1881 $10 MS64 NGC. The 1881 ten dollar has a mintage of 3.8 million pieces, and there was also a high number of survivors, many of which are in mint condition. However, few of the survivors attain this level of preservation. This is a lovely example that has rich golden-reddish color and bright mint luster. The striking details are complete on each side and there are no mentionable surface flaws, just as one would expect from a type coin. Census: 36 in 64, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2466

1881-CC $10 XF40 NGC. Dusky orange-gold surfaces show glimpses of radiance in the protected areas. An appealing example of this mid-date Carson City ten with a small cluster of abrasions on the cheek but few overt flaws elsewhere.(Registry values: N991)

2467

1881-CC $10 AU55 NGC. Brass-gold surfaces display tints of red, and retain traces of luster in the recessed areas. Lightly marked and nicely defined.(Registry values: N1793)

2468

1881-S $10 MS63 NGC. While the 1881-S eagle is available in circulated grades, and it is not too difficult to locate an example in lower Mint State condition, it is a challenging date at the Select level. In fact, the issue is unknown in any higher grade. The present example is sharply struck and lustrous, with a typical number of handling marks for the grade. Census: 22 in 63, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2469

1882-CC $10 AU50 PCGS. A lovely example of the low mintage 1882-CC eagle, surviving from a production of only 6,764 coins. This piece has light wear on the high points as expected, but with delightful honey-gold surfaces that retain considerable luster. An important opportunity for the specialist. Population: 20 in 50, 41 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2470

1882-CC $10 AU58 NGC. Variety 2-A. A misplaced date shows the tops of two 8s in the border dentils. An extraordinary 1882-CC gold coin with traces of wear on the highest design points. This piece has nearly full luster with rich green-gold color. The surfaces have a few faint lines and abrasions, but also exhibit evidence of original mirrored surfaces in the protected areas. NGC has only certified four finer pieces, including two in MS61, one in MS62, and a single amazing MS66 Prooflike piece. PCGS has never certified a Mint State example. Over the years we have handled a number of similar AU58 coins, but have never offered a Mint State piece in our auctions. This is an incredible opportunity for the advanced collector. Census: 36 in 58, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2471

1882-O $10 AU58 NGC. CAC. This eagle dates from the year that the Chapman brothers, Henry and Samuel H., successfully auctioned the collection of legendary numismatist Charles I. Bushnell (who had died in 1880) for a record $13,000. In New Orleans the low mintage figures for eagles continued, in the case of the 1882-O only 10,820 coins; the facility's focus was clearly on Morgan dollars. Prooflike luster emanates from the surfaces of this lovely yellow-gold piece, which shows only light field chatter and excellent eye appeal. Census: 46 in 58, 15 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2472

1883-CC $10 AU55 NGC. The presses at the Carson City Mint churned out more than 1.2 million silver dollars in 1883. This emission was more than 1,000 times greater than the production of Liberty tens at the facility that year. This partially lustrous example is crisply struck and has surprisingly unblemished fields. Census: 22 in 55, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2473

1883-S $10 MS61 PCGS. CAC. Specialists are always on the lookout for the 1883-S, since its mintage of 38,000 pieces is uncommonly low and few were saved in Mint State. This example has good cartwheel luster and a sharp strike. Obverse field marks are scattered, consistent with the grade. Population: 13 in 61, 18 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2474

1884-CC $10 XF40 NGC. Both sides yield a brass-gold appearance and exhibit well defined devices. Distributed marks are in concert with a coin having seen some circulation.(Registry values: N1793)

2475

1886-S $10 MS64 PCGS. CAC. A crisply detailed near-Gem example of this high-mintage but little-saved Liberty eagle issue, one of 11 tied for finest certified by PCGS (2/10). Satiny gold devices with tiny peripheral alloy spots frame sharply detailed central devices. Though a number of small marks combine to account for the grade, no one flaw warrants individual mention.(Registry values: N2998)

2476

1888 $10 MS62 PCGS. Crisply detailed with light patina settling over yellow-orange surfaces. Scattered marks and wispy abrasions preclude Select status, though the portrait area is relatively clean. Population: 16 in 62, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2477

1888-S $10 MS63 PCGS. CAC. Rich yellow-orange luster with strong striking definition. An appealing Select example of this San Francisco eagle issue, a condition rarity any finer.(Registry values: N2998)

2478

1890-CC $10 AU53 NGC. Reddish-gold patina runs over both sides of this Carson city ten dollar. Minute circulation marks are not serious.(Registry values: N991)

2479

1890-CC $10 MS62 PCGS. CAC. The 1890-CC ten dollar is relatively common through AU58, but Mint State pieces are much more difficult, especially in the higher levels thereof. Nearly full luster adorns the yellow-gold surfaces of this MS62 example, and a well executed strike imparts sharp detail to the design motifs. Scattered light marks limit the grade. Population: 33 in 62, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2480

1890-CC $10 MS62 PCGS. CAC. This frosty and lustrous Liberty eagle is a scarce issue with a mintage of only 17,500 coins. Both sides are sharply defined including full hair and star details on the obverse and sharp feather details on the reverse. Population: 33 in 62, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2481

1891-CC $10 AU55 NGC. The appeal of this Choice AU is associated with attractive yellow-gold coloration, well struck devices, and modest field-motif contrast, especially on the reverse. The expected number of small marks are visible on each side.(Registry values: N991)

2482

1891-CC $10 AU58 NGC. Yellow-gold with a touch of orange through the centers, with elements of peach appearing at the margins. This strongly struck near-Mint coin is mildly abraded, but the luster is virtually intact.(Registry values: N991)

2483

1891-CC $10 MS61 PCGS. Yellow-gold surfaces splashed with wisps of orange display considerable luster and well defined design features, save for softness in the hair over the ear. Distributed marks limit the grade. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2484

1891-CC $10 MS61 NGC. FS-501, repunched mintmark. Sharply struck and showing a good amount of luster. Scattered marks limit the grade, still, this is a nice piece for MS61.(Registry values: N1793)

2485

1891-CC $10 MS62 PCGS. Strong wheat-gold luster with peripheral peach elements. Though numerous light abrasions preclude Select status, the overall eye appeal remains considerable.(Registry values: N1793)

2486

1891-CC $10 MS62 PCGS. FS-501. The mintmark is sharply repunched east. Well struck and highly lustrous, with lovely reddish-gold and yellow color, and numerous small, scattered contact marks that limit the numerical grade designation of the piece. Very scarce any finer, PCGS has only certified 57 piece in higher grades, the finest three are tied at the MS64 level (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2487

1891-CC $10 MS63 NGC. FS-501. Both Cs in the mintmark are repunched east. Unbroken luster sweeps the moderately abraded apricot and sun-gold surfaces. A precisely struck representative of this popular issue. More '91-CC eagles have survived in Mint State than all other Carson City issues of the denomination combined, but nearly all of those are heavily bagmarked from indifferent storage and shipment.(Registry values: N2998)

2488

1891-CC $10 MS63 PCGS. Coppery hues shimmer off of splendidly lustrous surfaces. The strike is bold and the net eye appeal is substantial. This is a plentiful issue relative to other Carson City tens, but in high grade the availability dwindles. As of (2/10), PCGS has certified only 55 1891-CC tens in MS63 with a staggeringly low three finer pieces--all at the MS64 level.(Registry values: N2998)

2489

1892-CC $10 AU55 NGC. Well-defined for this later Carson City eagle issue with considerable yellow-orange luster remaining. Small marks dot the fields, and a few minor abrasions are noted on Liberty's portrait.(Registry values: N1793)

2490

1892-CC $10 AU58 NGC. Minimally wear shows on the well defined devices of this yellow-gold eagle. Minimally marked and retention of ample luster. Difficult to locate any finer.(Registry values: N1793)

2491

1892-CC $10 MS61 NGC. Antique-gold patination evenly covers each side of this CC-mint product--one of only 40,000 pieces produced in this penultimate year of the Carson City Mint. Few examples of this issue survive in Mint State. In 1892 the efforts of our nation's mints were focused on producing the first-year Barber coinage, minor coinage, silver dollars in moderate amounts, and the first Columbian commemorative half dollars. Considerable bright mint luster is present on this piece, along with moderate abrasions. Census: 22 in 61, 10 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2492

1892-O $10 MS62 PCGS. Peach-gold surfaces display luster in the recessed areas of this generally well struck piece. Distributed light marks are visible over each side.(Registry values: N1793)

2493

1893-O $10 MS62 PCGS. Nearly full luster shows on this O-mint representative. Yellow-gold surfaces reveal distributed marks and are well struck. PCGS has seen only nine coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2494

1893-S $10 MS63 PCGS. MS63 is the highest grade of the 1893-S that most collectors are likely to encounter; finer examples are extremely rare. Apricot-gold and mint-green patina reside on the lustrous surfaces of this attractive Select specimen that exhibits well struck design elements. Scattered minuscule marks define the grade. Population: 40 in 63, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2495

1894 $10 MS62 Prooflike NGC. Flashy fields accompany nicely struck devices. Scattered small abrasions on the obverse field correspond to the grade. Census: 24 in 62 Prooflike, 11 finer (2/10).

2496

1894-S $10 AU58 NGC. A solidly struck and shining yellow-orange example with virtually intact luster. Though a number of light marks are scattered across each side, these have surprisingly little impact on the eye appeal. Census: 34 in 58, 19 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2497

1896 $10 MS63 PCGS. CAC. Yellow-orange luster of varying intensity graces this lustrous Select coin. Wells truck and modestly abraded with an alloy spot on the rim above star 10. PCGS has graded eight finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2498

1900 $10 MS65 NGC. A butter-gold Gem of this popular turn of the century issue. Lustrous and well preserved with an original appearance and a full strike. The reverse is practically pristine. A formidable addition to a quality gold type set. Census: 57 in 65, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2499

1900 $10 MS65 NGC. This yellow-gold example displays a precise strike and energetic luster. The fields exhibit only faint grazes. Although several thousand 1900 tens have been certified in Mint State, just a slender portion of this quantity can compare with the imposing quality of the present Gem. Census: 57 in 65, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2500

1900-S $10 MS63 NGC. Most Liberty ten issues from the 1900s are found with little difficulty in Mint State. Not so for the 1900-S, which when encountered is typically in XF or AU grades. Only a handful of pieces are certified above the MS63 level. This is a lustrous representative with moderate contact on the jaw and left obverse field. Census: 5 in 63, 4 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2501

1901 $10 MS65 NGC. This exemplary Gem displays vibrant cartwheel luster and is intricately struck, but its most important attribute is an absence of bagmarks. A loupe reveals only the occasional faint surface graze. A desirable contribution toward an advanced Federal gold type set.(Registry values: N2998)

2502

1901-O $10 MS62 PCGS. Bold yellow-orange luster with a solid strike overall. Shallow and wispy marks populate the fields and show on the devices, but there are few overt defects relative to the surface area.(Registry values: N991)

2503

1901-O $10 MS63 PCGS. This is a far above-average example of this normally heavily marked issue. The surfaces are bright and satiny, showing rich orange-gold color. The devices are sharply defined on each side of this impressive O-mint. This is definite buy for the collector who is seeking a better date at a type coin price. Population: 47 in 63, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2504

1901-O $10 MS63 PCGS. The 1901-O Liberty eagle is a lower mintage issue with an original production of just 72,041 coins. This piece ranks among the finer examples that survive today. Both sides are sharply defined with pleasing surfaces showing only minor blemishes as expected for the grade. Attractive yellow luster exhibits splashes of orange toning. Population: 48 in 63, 12 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2505

1901-S $10 MS65 PCGS. This thoroughly lustrous gold type coin has a precise strike and beautifully unabraded fields. In fact, both sides are splendidly preserved aside from inconspicuous abrasions near Liberty's jaw. 1901-S has long been the Liberty eagle issue most often encountered in high grades.(Registry values: N2998)

2506

1901-S $10 MS65 NGC. The 1901 and 1901-S eagles are the two obvious candidates for type collectors, due to their high mintages and similarly high survival rates. Both issues are also well made, meaning that an above average example can be found in high grade. The present Gem is one such piece with bold design details, dynamic luster, attractive lemon-gold toning, and a well preserved portrait.(Registry values: N2998)

2507

1901-S $10 MS66 NGC. A sharply struck and lovely khaki-gold Premium Gem dominated by vibrant cartwheel luster. The 1901-S is a plentiful issue, but most Uncirculated survivors are moderately to heavily abraded, unlike the present high grade example. Ideal for an exemplary quality type set.(Registry values: N4719)

2508

1902 $10 MS63 PCGS. Yellow-gold surfaces exude pleasing luster and the design elements are sharply struck. A few light scuffs limit the numerical grade. Scarce in this condition and rare any finer.(Registry values: N1793)

2509

1902 $10 MS63 PCGS. CAC. A lower mintage issue that boasts sweeping luster and an intricate strike. Well preserved for the grade aside from a thin mark on the cheek.(Registry values: N1793)

2510

1902 $10 MS64 NGC. The 1902 is a lower mintage P-mint from the later years of the Liberty series with only 82,400 pieces produced. As a result, the number of survivors in high grades was low with only 25 other pieces in MS64 and two finer (2/10). This example has terrific color and mint luster. Kept from an even higher grade by a couple of obverse abrasions.(Registry values: N2998)

2511

1903 $10 MS65 NGC. A sharply struck example with bold yellow-gold luster and excellent eye appeal. Only a handful of luster grazes and pinpoint marks combine to determine the grade. This 20th century issue's mintage was in the low six figures, and at the MS65 level, there are just 11 pieces in the combined certified population with none finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2512

1903-O $10 MS63 PCGS. Excellent detail for this 20th century O-mint issue. The luster is strong yellow-gold with hints of wheat and straw. PCGS has graded a mere 12 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2513

1903-O $10 MS63 NGC. Honey-gold surfaces exhibit well struck design elements and reveal occasional breaks in the luster flow. Both sides are lightly abraded. Census: 54 in 63, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2514

1903-S $10 MS67 NGC. A mintage of 538,000 ten dollar gold pieces was accomplished at the San Francisco Mint in 1903. While modest when compared to production totals of other denominations of the period, the mintage was quite generous in the context of the series. The issue was not heavily circulated at its time of issue. The date makes a superlative type coin, and examples are prized by series enthusiasts and Registry Set collectors as well.
The present coin is certainly one of the finest survivors of this popular date, and it shares the title of finest certified with seven other examples seen by the leading grading services (2/10). The striking details are needle-sharp throughout, and the flawless fields display vibrant mint luster. This piece is an appropriate choice for the finest collection of Liberty Head eagles.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N7079)

2515

1904 $10 MS63 ★ NGC. One of only two pieces given the Star designation--both MS63. Fantastic eye appeal for the numerical grade, resulting from beautiful yellow-gold color, modest field-motif contrast, and sharply struck design elements. Scattered light marks are not serious.(Registry values: N1793)

2516

1904-O $10 MS63 PCGS. CAC. The New Orleans Mint had a six-figure mintage of eagle coins for the last time in 1904, since the last issue, that of 1906, slipped below that number. This Select example, well-defined with strong yellow-orange luster, has light abrasions overall but considerable eye appeal. PCGS has certified just 15 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2517

1907-D $10 MS64 PCGS. CAC. The 1907-D is the second and scarcest of the two Denver Mint issues of the long-lived Liberty eagle series. It is more than ten times more elusive at the MS64 level than its Philadelphia Mint counterpart. This is a lustrous and unmarked near-Gem with a precise strike and excellent eye appeal. The obverse border is lime-green, while the reverse field is canary-gold. Population: 45 in 64, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

Proof Liberty Eagles

2518

1906 $10 PR67 Cameo NGC. This breathtaking Superb Gem Cameo proof exhibits incredible brilliance, with light yellow devices that appear to float across the watery, mirrored fields. Every detail has completely transferred from the dies to the finished coin. The intricate hair detail on the obverse and the feather detail on the reverse are bold and sharp. The surfaces are pristine and only affected by a few tiny planchet flakes that were probably present before the coin was minted.
The mintage of 1906 proof eagles was a mere 77 coins, second lowest of all the 20th century dates behind the 74 proofs struck in 1907. A single die pair was used for all 77 proofs. A raised die lump at the right center of the 9 immediately identifies the obverse proof die, differentiating true proofs from prooflike business strikes.
Possibly as many as 35 to 40 examples still survive today according to Garrett and Guth. David Akers places the survival at 25 to 30 coins; Walter Breen suggests 30 to 35 pieces. Only a complete census would pinpoint the number known, although such a census has never been attempted, to our knowledge. 1906 proof eagles are rarely encountered in grades better than PR64. The average NGC and PCGS combined grade for all 69 certified pieces is just 63.6. The present offering is only the second PR67 1906 eagle we have offered since 1993, an exceptional opportunity for the connoisseur. Census: 3 in 67 Cameo, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: P1)

Indian Eagles

2519

1907 $10 No Periods MS62 NGC. Overtly yellow-orange surfaces are softly lustrous with elements of alloy. Shallow arcing scrapes are visible at the left obverse, and Liberty's cheek shows a small cut.(Registry values: N991)

2520

1907 $10 No Periods MS62 NGC. Luminous yellow-orange surfaces have a dusky overall look with occasional suggestions of alloy in the fields. Striking softness over the centers is typical for the issue.(Registry values: N991)

2521

1907 $10 No Periods MS62 PCGS. Sharply struck yellow-gold surfaces show the most potent luster in the areas around and the interstices of the design elements. Scattered marks are noted on both sides.(Registry values: N991)

2522

1907 $10 No Periods MS62 PCGS. A mix of peach-gold and mint-green patina resides on the lightly abraded surfaces. Somewhat better struck than ordinarily seen for the issue.(Registry values: N991)

2523

1907 $10 No Periods MS62 NGC. Lustrous yellow-gold surfaces exhibit well struck design features. Minute surface and rim marks limit the grade.(Registry values: N991)

2524

1907 $10 No Periods MS62 NGC. This appropriately struck eagle displays lustrous yellow-gold surfaces. The grade is defined by a few minuscule surface and rim marks. Still, nice for the designated grade.(Registry values: N991)

2525

1907 $10 No Periods MS64 NGC. The first Indian eagles were minted in 1907 with periods punctuating the reverse lettering. The Charles Barber No Periods modification followed, and it was this second group of coins that formed the majority of 1907 tens, with a mintage of 239,406 coins. The No Periods design was struck in 1907 and 1908, and was then followed by the remaining series of Indian tens that had the addition of IN GOD WE TRUST on the reverse. This example is a splendid Choice Mint State piece with full frosty luster and brilliant yellow surfaces with faint orange accents.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2526

1907 $10 No Periods MS66 NGC. While the No Periods 1907 Saint-Gaudens eagle is by far the most available variety for that year and that design, an often-overlooked fact is that Philadelphia struck more than five times as many examples of the old Gobrecht Liberty design. This puts the challenge of high-end No Periods pieces, particularly those above the Gem level such as this MS66 survivor, in a better context. Both well struck devices and shining yellow-gold surfaces are pleasingly preserved. Touches of wheat and orange are noted near the rims. NGC has certified 30 numerically finer examples (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2527

1907 $10 No Periods MS67 NGC. The 1907 No Periods eagle was the third Indian Head type ten struck at the Philadelphia Mint. The first examples were special issues of Saint-Gaudens' original concept and were struck in limited quantities. These pieces, however, had a Wire Rim, which was considered a serious flaw by Mint officials, who realized that it would prevent the coins from stacking properly. After modifications to the rim were made, Charles Barber insisted--almost certainly out of jealousy--that production of these so-called Round Rim pieces be halted so that he could further alter the design. Barber made several minute changes, which included the removal of the periods that bordered the reverse legends.
Collectors familiar with Indian Head eagles know that these first business strikes were probably the best produced of any date in the series. From a mintage of 239,406 pieces, many have survived in high grades. While the population data shows that there are quite a few Gems available, it also reveals that that Superb Gem examples are extremely rare. These pieces are seldom offered at auction, and when they are, they cause a considerable stir. It is amazing that NGC has certified two MS68 examples and PCGS has graded one (2/10). Any collector lucky enough to own a specimen of that quality, however, would surely be reluctant to part with it.
Enticing satiny luster glides across the virtually immaculate surfaces. The surfaces are seemingly perfect, even under magnification. Pleasing yellow-gold patina embraces both sides and complements the powerfully impressed design elements. The 1907 No Periods is a favorite among type collectors because of its status as a first-year issue, its relative availability, and its attractive design. Any collector with deep enough pockets should own an outstanding representative of this issue.(Registry values: N7079)

2528

1908-D $10 No Motto MS61 PCGS. Apricot-gold surfaces tinted with mint-green reveal a few luster breaks associated with light marks. The design elements are well impressed.(Registry values: N1793)

2529

1908 $10 Motto MS66 NGC. Garrett and Guth note for this variety in their Encyclopedia of U.S. Gold Coins, "This date is usually found with satiny luster and a sharp strike. As a date the 1908, With Motto comes very nice and is one of the most available dates in gem grades." As an MS66 coin, this top-flight Premium Gem exemplifies the variety. Impressively detailed devices and broad fields have wonderful yellow-gold texture, and a small alloy streak meanders just to the left of Liberty's eyes. With just seven numerically finer examples certified by NGC (1/10), this date is a condition rarity any better.(Registry values: N4719)

2530

1908-D $10 Motto MS65 PCGS. The 1908-D has an unimpressive mintage of 836,500 pieces. It appears, though, that an attempt was made to actually place much of the production into the channels of commerce as there are at least 300 pieces in circulated grades (most AU58). At the other end of the grading spectrum, only 16 Gems have been certified (13 by PCGS and 3 by NGC), with 19 finer (2/10). This piece shows the same fine-grain texture noted on the Morse coin, but the surfaces are uniformly bright with attractive yellow-gold color. The striking details are strong throughout, and there are no obvious or detracting marks on either side.(Registry values: N7079)

2531

1908-D $10 Motto MS65 NGC. Both the 1908-D With Motto and No Motto eagles are difficult to obtain at the Gem level, although examples of each appear from time to time in the numismatic marketplace. This Gem With Motto ten is an example of an issue that Garrett and Guth rank as "12th rarest of the 32 issues in that lofty grade." Interestingly, NGC has certified only three examples in MS65, but it has graded 11 pieces finer (2/10). This is a flashy Gem with tons of eye appeal and a two-toned appearance, golden-orange predominating with lilac accents on Liberty's cheek. As expected of the grade, contact is minor and undistracting.(Registry values: N7079)

2532

1909-D $10 MS61 PCGS. The yellow-gold surfaces of this D-mint ten dollar displays soft frosty luster and well struck design features. The scattered light marks are fewer than what might be expected for the designated grade.(Registry values: N991)

2533

1909-S $10 AU58 PCGS. The fields are faintly abraded with violet accents against yellow-gold luster. The well struck devices exhibit faint but grade-defining friction.(Registry values: N991)

2534

1910-D $10 MS63 NGC. Vibrant cartwheel luster sweeps this splendidly unabraded and nicely struck ten dollar Indian. Honey-gold throughout save for an occasional glimpse of gray on the highpoints of the eagle.(Registry values: N1793)

2535

1910-D $10 MS66 NGC. Before the mammoth mintage of eagles in 1932, the highest production for the Saint-Gauden ten dollar design came in 1910 at Denver, where more than 2.3 million of the coins were struck. Many were melted, however, making the date available in most grades but a challenge at the highest levels. This MS66 survivor is memorable, a trifle soft on the obverse design definition but immensely lustrous with yellow-gold color overall and a measure of rim toning, rings around both obverse and reverse with a small copper spot just below 9 o'clock on the latter side. NGC has certified only eight numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2536

1910-S $10 AU58 PCGS. Lightly rubbed on the high points but richly lustrous despite this flaw, a lovely yellow-gold near-Mint survivor of a challenging issue. The left obverse field and portrait show several faint abrasions.(Registry values: N991)

2537

1910-S $10 MS61 PCGS. Slight striking softness is visible on the obverse, though the eagle's feathers are well-defined. Areas on and around the portrait of Liberty show a degree of alloy.(Registry values: N991)

2538

1910-S $10 MS61 NGC. The surfaces of this Mint State piece are less abraded than expected for the grade. It has frosty yellow luster with hints of rose and iridescent toning. Although rather plentiful at this grade level, higher grade pieces are elusive.(Registry values: N991)

2539

1911 $10 MS64 NGC. CAC. The 1911 ten dollar, sporting a mintage of more than one-half million circulation strikes, is one of the more obtainable issues in the Indian Head eagle series. Satiny yellow-gold luster resides on both sides, each of which exhibits well struck design elements. Light surface and rim marks preclude Gem classification. Ideal for a high-grade type set.(Registry values: N1793)

2540

1911 $10 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Strong yellow-gold luster with orange overtones on each side, bolder on the reverse. A well-defined piece and decidedly appealing. PCGS has graded 85 finer examples (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2541

1911 $10 MS65 NGC. Bold, satiny luster combines with rich sun-yellow color to give this Gem immediate eye appeal. On closer inspection, the above-average strike and preservation are also noteworthy. The 1911 eagle is more elusive than the typical type issue, yet it is accessible in MS65, if not necessarily finer; NGC has certified just 62 such pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2542

1911 $10 MS65 PCGS. This meticulously struck Gem boasts blended olive-gold and caramel-gold toning. Coruscating luster reveals only trivial surface imperfections. The 1911 Indian eagle is not strictly a type coin, since it is much scarcer than the 1926 or 1932 at the MS65 level. Population: 58 in 65, 27 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2543

1911 $10 MS66 NGC. This Philadelphia date was both heavily minted for the series (over half a million pieces struck) and heavily represented in overseas holdings, so that repatriation in the last quarter to third of the 20th century brought the 1911 eagle into type coin territory. Even type coins can become rarities in high enough grades, however, and anything finer than this Premium Gem absolutely qualifies. Strongly struck devices share a slightly satiny texture with the fields, which are yellow-gold at most angles but reveal a rich peach-orange cast when tilted. NGC has graded 11 numerically finer pieces (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2544

1911 $10 MS66 NGC. Indian eagles in the higher Mint State grades are wonderful type coins that are always the subject of intense collector interest. They of course show the progressive "other Saint-Gaudens design" to marvelous effect, and their status as large and beautiful gold coins also lends added appeal. Collectors are fortunate that this available issue is generally well-produced, with a bold strike and excellent luster. This Premium Gem example is no exception, boasting terrific, frosted, swirling mint luster over fine-grained, pebbly surfaces. The strike is sharp, and there are no mentionable marks on either side. Census: 51 in 66, 11 finer (2/10).
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2545

1911-D $10 AU58 PCGS. Just 30,100 eagles were coined in Denver in 1911, a mintage even lower than the highly coveted 1911-D quarter eagle. This near-Mint representative has nearly full light yellow luster with minor abrasions. While the population reports suggest a large number of Mint State survivors exist today, there is no doubt that many of those are resubmissions of a smaller true population.(Registry values: N1793)

2546

1911-D $10 MS61 ANACS. A few scattered surface marks on the satiny and lustrous yellow surfaces are expected at this grade level. This 1911-D eagle is an important representative of the lowest mintage Indian eagle other than the With Periods coins. The present sale offers the collector a choice between two different examples.(Registry values: N2998)

2547

1911-S $10 MS61 PCGS. A mintage of 51,000 pieces ensures the difficulty of the 1911-S, although any S-mint Indian ten is elusive in Mint State. The present lustrous yellow-gold example has the expected abrasions near the Indian's profile, but the sharp strike and original color confirm the eye appeal. Encapsulated in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2548

1912 $10 MS63 PCGS. Vibrant sun-yellow luster dominates the eye appeal of this Select Saint-Gaudens ten. A well-defined piece that is lightly abraded on and around the portrait.(Registry values: N1793)

2549

1912-S $10 AU58 PCGS. Strong yellow-gold luster with suggestions of canary and orange. Despite minor rub across the high points and faint abrasions, a decidedly appealing survivor.(Registry values: N991)

2550

1912-S $10 MS61 PCGS. Solidly struck with satiny gold-orange surfaces. The portrait area has a number of light marks and abrasions, though the fields are comparatively clean away from the devices.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2551

1913 $10 MS65 NGC. A beautiful green-gold Gem that exhibits booming luster and a sharp strike. The reverse has only a few tiny ticks, and the obverse appears pristine aside from a single faint curved hairline near the profile. The 1913 is far scarcer at the MS65 level than its 1926 and 1932 successors. Census: 81 in 65, 11 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2552

1913-S $10 AU58 PCGS. With just 66,000 pieces struck, the 1913-S is an obvious candidate as a challenging Saint-Gaudens eagle issue, and its survival in better circulated and Mint State grades does not disappoint in that regard. This is an elusive near-Mint representative, uncommonly well-defined with nearly intact yellow-gold luster. Light but distinct rub is noted at the top of the eagle's wing.(Registry values: N1793)

2553

1914-D $10 MS62 PCGS. Dusky yellow-gold overall with undercurrents of straw and orange. A well struck, moderately abraded piece with a measure of alloy and a significant cut on the eagle's near wing.(Registry values: N1793)

2554

1914-S $10 MS61 PCGS. Well struck with dusky luster that brightens on the reverse. Yellow-gold surfaces are moderately abraded and show considerable alloy, particularly on the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

2555

1915 $10 MS64 PCGS. A frosty Mint State piece, this Choice example is housed in a green label PCGS holder. It exhibits brilliant orange-gold luster with excellent design definition. A few insignificant abrasions are evident on each side. PCGS has only certified 49 finer examples of this issue (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2556

1915 $10 MS65 PCGS. The 1915 is among the more available Saint-Gaudens eagle issues in MS65, but it is still scarce at that level and a condition rarity any finer. Both sides of this elegant Gem offer powerful luster. Hints of frost and satin enrich well-preserved peach-gold surfaces. The strike is pleasing, particularly at the often-weak hair over Liberty's ear, and the eye appeal is impressive. An interesting candidate for the 20th century gold type collector who seeks a slightly better date for the series. Population: 42 in 65, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2557

1915-S $10 AU58 PCGS. The cartwheel luster is bright and complete, but a hint of friction is noted on the forehead curl, the front leg feathers, and on the upper left border of the front wing. Only 59,000 pieces were struck, and a majority of survivors are in circulated grades.(Registry values: N1793)

2558

1916-S $10 MS62 PCGS. The S-mint series of ten dollar Indians is a very scarce one. To underscore how difficult it is, the 1916-S is the most readily available issue. And its "availability" is only because of a couple of small hoards that were dispersed in the late 1970s. This piece has subdued mint frost and there are several flecks of grease on each side that were struck into the coin at the time of production. The obverse is sharply struck while there is localized softness at the top of the eagle's wing on the reverse.(Registry values: N1793)

2559

1926 $10 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Strongly lustrous wheat-gold surfaces have a suggestion of frostiness. Well struck and Choice with undeniable eye appeal. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2560

1926 $10 MS65 NGC. The 1926 and 1932 Indian eagles are the two most plentiful dates in the series. The 1926 mintage of just over 1 million coins is the third highest in the series behind the 1910-D and 1932 issues. This frosty and lustrous Gem has brilliant green-gold surfaces, sharp design features, and impressive surfaces. NGC has only certified 53 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2561

1932 $10 MS64 PCGS. Variegated apricot and mint-green toning cover the lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem ten dollar. Sharply struck on the design elements. Minute obverse marks preclude Gem status.(Registry values: N1793)

2562

1932 $10 MS64 NGC. Dazzling luster enlivens this well struck, peach-gold near-Gem ten dollar. A few minute marks preclude Gem status.(Registry values: N1793)

2563

1932 $10 MS64 PCGS. Radiant orange-gold luster is imbued with traces of lilac and sky-blue on the reverse. The design elements are sharply struck, enhancing the coin's pleasing eye appeal. A handful of minute marks precludes Gem status.(Registry values: N1793)

2564

1932 $10 MS64 NGC. All Federal gold issues from the 1930s are great rarities, with a single exception. That is the 1932 eagle, which is the type coin of the series in high grade. The 1932 is available, but high end examples are always desirable, and the present lustrous khaki-gold near-Gem certainly qualifies.(Registry values: N1793)

2565

1932 $10 MS65 NGC. The final collectible Indian eagle is also the only collectible U.S. gold coin from the 1930s. Both sides of this lovely piece have frosty yellow luster with only a few tiny abrasions that are in line with the grade. This is a great opportunity for the Indian gold enthusiast or the type collector.(Registry values: N2998)

2566

1932 $10 MS65 NGC. Here is an incredible Gem for the Indian eagle specialist or for the type collector. Both sides have frosty yellow luster with delicate pink toning around the central motifs. The incredible mintage of more than 4.4 million coins was sufficient that today's collector can easily obtain an example.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2567

1932 $10 MS66 PCGS. Salmon toning splashes enhance the lovely yellow-gold luster of this boldly defined Premium Gem. The 1932 Indian eagle is an important gold piece, with high demand from those who desire a representative gold coin from the 1930s. Only one finer example has been PCGS certified. Population: 86 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

Liberty Double Eagles

2568

1850 $20 XF45 NGC. Well defined after accounting for high-point wear. Yellow-gold surfaces display traces of luster in the recesses and reveal distributed minute marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2569

1850 $20 AU50 PCGS. The 1850 double eagle is popular as the first year of the regular issue for the type and denomination. Traces of luster reside in the recessed areas of this yellow-gold specimen. The design elements are generally well defined. Distributed marks are noted over both sides.(Registry values: N1793)

2570

1850 $20 AU55 NGC. CAC. Bright luster outlines individual obverse stars and dominates the reverse design. The untoned fields and devices display minor marks, but there are no distracting abrasions. The eagle's wings and Liberty's hair show only minor wear.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2571

1850 $20 AU58 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. This first-year double eagle was recovered from the wreck of the sidewheel steamship, lost in a storm off the coast of Georgia in 1865 and found in 2003. She carried a cargo of $400,000 in mostly gold ten and twenty dollar coins when she sank. This well-struck near-Mint State piece has semiprooflike yellow-gold surfaces with minor abrasions scattered over each side.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2572

1850-O $20 XF40 NGC. A doubly popular issue, the first year of regular double eagle production and a coin made in the legendary New Orleans Mint. This example shows some muted mint luster clinging to yellow-gold surfaces that show some mostly light contact marks peppered on each side. The O mintmark is punched high in the die, actually touching the lower tip of the eagle's tail.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2573

1851 $20 AU50 PCGS. Dusky butter-yellow and orange hues prevail on this lightly worn early double eagle. The high points show rub, and the fields show numerous light to moderate abrasions, as well as the odd scrape.(Registry values: N1793)

2574

1851-O $20 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. VF Details. Ample luster glimmers from the legends and eagle of this somewhat glossy twenty dollar piece. The nose, cheek, and obverse rim at 3 o'clock display moderate marks. New Orleans twenties are both scarce and popular.(Registry values: N991)

2575

1851-O $20 XF40 PCGS. CAC. Glimmers of mustard-gold luster accent sun-yellow and orange surfaces. Light to moderate wear with a few small digs on Liberty's cheek and wispy abrasions through the fields, yet strong eye appeal despite these faults. A solid example of this favored earlier O-mint double eagle issue.(Registry values: N991)

2576

1851-O $20 XF40 ANACS. A moderately circulated honey-gold representative of this popular O-mint issue. Luster persists within the plumage, hair, and legends. The only remotely mentionable mark is a small rim ding on the obverse at 3:30. All New Orleans double eagles are scarce and in demand.(Registry values: N991)

2577

1851-O $20 AU50 PCGS. The 1851-O is available with little difficulty through the XF grade level but becomes scarce in AU. Mint State coins are quite rare. The yellow-gold surfaces of this AU specimen retain luster in the recessed areas of the appropriately defined motifs and reveal distributed minute marks that do not detract.(Registry values: N1793)

2578

1852 $20 AU58 PCGS. CAC. The 1852, coming from a mintage exceeding 2 million pieces, is one of the more common Type One double eagles. This near-Mint State example retains luster in the recessed areas of its well struck design motifs. Minor marks take nothing from the overall nice eye appeal.(Registry values: N991)

2579

1852-O $20 --Scratches--NGC. AU Details. The 1852-O double eagle is generally available in Very Fine through About Uncirculated grades but is much rarer any finer. The brass-gold surfaces of this AU Details example display luster in the recessed areas and show relatively good detail. Shallow obverse scratches account for the NGC disclaimer.(Registry values: N1793)

2580

1853 $20 XF45 PCGS. This Choice XF twenty displays a good amount of luster in the recessed areas of its yellow-gold surfaces. Well defined, with distributed inoffensive marks.(Registry values: N991)

2581

1853 $20 AU50 NGC. An exceptional piece for the grade, this 1853 twenty exhibits considerable luster with only trivial surface marks. A die crack joins the bottom of the 3 to the obverse border.(Registry values: N991)

2582

1853 $20 AU53 PCGS. The 3 in the date is lightly repunched, but this is neither Breen-7161 or Breen-7162 (the 1853/2). Substantial luster shimmers in protected regions. The few moderate marks are usual for a lightly circulated Type One twenty.(Registry values: N991)

2583

1853/2 $20 XF45 PCGS. FS-301, formerly FS-008. The diagnostic die lump below the R of LIBERTY is prominent, and the base of the underdigit 2 is evident within the lower loop of the 3 in the date. This evenly struck Choice XF better date double eagle has only two marks of any consequence, near obverse star 11 and on the nose.(Registry values: N1793)

2584

1853-O $20 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details.
The 1853-O is a scarce New Orleans issue with a mintage limited to only 71,000 pieces, most of which entered circulation and stayed there. This piece shows the bright surfaces of a coin that has been cleaned; otherwise each side has deep orange-gold color. While most 1853-O twenties are heavily abraded, this coin only has one mentionable mark and that is a vertical abrasion on the cheek of Liberty.(Registry values: N2998)

2585

1855-S $20 AU58 NGC. The 1855-S double eagle is most often seen in the Extremely Fine to mid About Uncirculated grade range. Whispers of greenish-tan and reddish-gold visit the yellow-gold surfaces of this near-Mint State coin that retains a good amount of luster. Nicely struck and revealing just a few small marks, more so on the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

2586

1855-S $20 AU58 NGC. In its second year of production, the San Francisco Mint achieved a substantial coinage of 879,675 double eagles. Examples in VF, XF, and lower AU grades are easily available, but the issue is scarce at the near-Mint level. The orange and rose-gold surfaces of this coin show relatively few abrasions, and the striking details are quite sharp.(Registry values: N1793)

2587

1855-S $20 MS61 PCGS. CAC. Few 1855-S double eagles were found among coins in the S.S. Central America treasure, and Mint State examples remain important rarities today. This highly lustrous yellow-gold example has some darker high point patina that attests to its originality. It is sharply struck with full obverse and reverse details. The advanced double eagle specialist will be thrilled with this opportunity. Population: 9 in 61, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2588

1856-S $20 MS62 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America. Variety 17J (Split Serif), SSCA 5383. Though the vast majority of the double eagles recovered from the Central America were dated 1857-S, a significant number of earlier pieces also turned up, such as this twenty dollar coin from the previous year. Strongly lustrous yellow-gold surfaces show an assortment of light to moderate abrasions, including two roughly parallel lines to the left of Liberty's chin and neck. Comes with book-style case, certificate of authenticity, and outer box, as well as a paperback copy of Ship of Gold in the Deep Blue Sea.(Registry values: N2998)

2589

1856-S $20 MS62 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America. SSCA 6193. Variety 17P, No Serif, Right S. Strong and flashy luster with the shipwreck coins' "halo" appearance of pale centers framed in rich lemon-yellow. Excellent definition, though the obverse shows a number of wispy marks and a vertical abrasion in the hair behind the coronet.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2590

1857 $20 XF45 PCGS. Considerable luster remains on the well defined yellow-gold surfaces of this Choice XF twenty dollar. Light to moderate marks are scattered over each side.(Registry values: N991)

2591

1857-O $20 AU58 NGC. The 1857-O twenty is most often seen in VF and XF grades. AU50 coins are scarce and higher level AUs are rare. Mint State pieces are extremely rare; indeed, NGC and PCGS have certified only four Uncirculated examples, none above MS63.
Bright yellow-gold color envelops this near-Mint State specimen that displays a good amount of luster, and the design elements exhibit an above-average strike, including the date, obverse stars, and Liberty's hair, elements that are often weak. Small circulation marks are noted, but these are shallower that usually encountered on surviving examples. Census: 24 in 58, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2592

1857-S $20 AU55 NGC. Once upon a time, an 1857-S in Choice AU was an extremely important piece. Today, in the wake of the S.S. Central America treasure discovery, this piece is relegated to type coin status. It is a lustrous and highly attractive example with lovely orange-gold surfaces.(Registry values: N1793)

2593

1857-S $20 MS61 NGC. CAC. Semiprooflike characteristics are visible on the brassy-gold surfaces of this twenty dollar specimen and sharp definition is apparent on the design elements. A very pleasing Mint State example, aptly recognized by CAC. Prior to the discovery of the S.S. Central America, this date was mostly available in the VF to XF grade range. It is unknown whether or not this particular coin came from the shipwreck.(Registry values: N2998)

2594

1857-S $20 MS64 NGC. While the insert does not indicate this piece is from the S.S. Central America, the surfaces are consistent with the examples from that famous shipwreck. Each side has bright mint luster with a glimmer of semireflectivity in the fields. The lighter centers deepen slightly to a rich orange-gold at the margins. The striking details are sharply defined on each side and there are few abrasions to account for the grade. A remarkable Type One twenty.(Registry values: N4719)

2595

1857-S $20 Spiked Shield MS65 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America. SSCA 4028. A gorgeous gold-label Gem recovered from the famous wreck, a coin struck earlier in the year and loaded onto the ship as part of bulk coinage for the financial system. Like many of its fellows, this piece shows remarkably few ill effects from its dramatic history. Pale yellow-gold inner color and more orange rims are in line with the S.S. Central America "look." Both sides show a handful of small, scattered marks overall, though a longer abrasion at the back of Liberty's drawn hair precludes a finer designation. Comes with faux-book case, certificate of authenticity, and outer box, as well as a hardcover edition of America's Lost Treasure.(Registry values: P2)

2596

1857-S $20 Spiked Shield MS65 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America. Variety 20A. SSCA 1092. Although it is difficult to appreciate today from the long lens of more than a century and a half of naval history, a steamship voyage on a vessel such as the S.S. George Law--renamed the S.S. Central America shortly before its last fateful journey--was roughly the parallel of a trip today into low Earth orbit. Few people ever took even one steamship voyage; far fewer still took more than one. Nonetheless, the slow, steady replacement of sailing vessels by steamships accounted for an eightfold increase in the number of emigrants to America between 1840 and 1910.
This Gem example boasts the usual delightful mint luster of the 1857-S double eagles recovered from the S.S. Central America. The surfaces are bright yellow-gold, with a slight, even reddish cast over each side. The strike is full, and the only singular flaws are a couple of shallow field marks, one to the left of the nose, the other to the left of hair. Housed in an oversized brown leather or leatherette case.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: P2)

2597

1857-S $20 Narrow Serif MS64 PCGS. Ex: S.S. Central America. Variety 20C, Narrow Serif. SSCA 4375. A study of the treasure of the S.S. Central America revealed eight different die varieties for the 1857-S double eagle. The present coin is one of the 532 examples of the Narrow Serif variety recovered from the storied shipwreck. The variety gets its name from the thin left serif on the U in UNITED. This specimen displays ample luster and a needle-sharp strike, with a minimum number of handling marks.(Registry values: P2)

2598

1858-O $20 AU50 PCGS. About Uncirculated is the finest grade that the 1858-O double eagle can be located as Mint State examples are extremely rare. While Douglas Winter in his 2006 New Orleans Mint reference indicates that the Uncirculated population increased with the discovery of five such pieces in the S.S. Republic treasure, PCGS and NGC have to date (2/10) certified a paltry three Mint State examples, none finer than MS62.
The yellow-gold surfaces of this AU specimen display a fair amount of luster in the recesses. The design elements exhibit an above-average strike, evidenced by strong detail in all obverse stars, the date, and the shield, areas often showing weakness. Distributed light marks are in concert with a coin having seen brief circulation.(Registry values: N2998)

2599

1858-S $20 MS61 PCGS. CAC. The 1858-S double eagle follows the pattern of many S-mint double eagle issues struck after the S.S. Central America left California for the last time. As outlined by Q. David Bowers in his A Guide Book of Double Eagle Gold Coins, the issue "is readily available in circulated grades such as VF and EF, but is rare AU, especially if with good eye appeal. Mint State coins are rarities and mostly congregate at or near the MS-60 designation."
This MS61 coin is decidedly appealing compared to most of its Mint State peers, thanks to bold yellow-orange luster, but both sides show prominent abrasions, including several on Liberty's cheek and a long line in the space between the U of UNITED and the nearby ribbon. Still, an important coin that will find an appreciative home with the right S-mint double eagle connoisseur. Population: 9 in 61, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2600

1859-S $20 AU53 NGC. The production of this issue was a generous amount exceeding 636,000 coins, although most of them circulated. This AU53 specimen boasts attractive luster over orange-gold surfaces with only light field chatter but no singular abrasions. The reverse is rotated about 20 degrees clockwise.(Registry values: N1793)

2601

1860 $20 AU50 NGC. Radiant and moderately abraded with a combination of yellow-orange and straw colors. Softly struck through the hair in the coronet area but better-defined on the reverse.(Registry values: N991)

2602

1860 $20 AU58 NGC. This yellow-gold piece displays just a whisper of wear that keeps it from a Mint State grade. The strike is boldly executed, and a loupe reveals only scattered, light abrasions. The recovery of the S.S. Republic added about 100 coins to the certified population, some of them in MS64 or MS65, although the present piece gives no indication of its source one way or the other. NGC has certified 59 pieces finer (2/10).(Registry values: N991)

2603

1860-O $20 AU53 PCGS. The 1860-O is one of the rarest New Orleans double eagles, coming from a mintage of only 6,600 pieces. PCGS and NGC combined have graded slightly more than 100 examples, many of which are likely resubmitted or crossed-over coins. A single specimen has been designated Mint State--an NGC MS62. Very Fine and Extremely Fine pieces are typically seen. Low-end About Uncirculated coins are rare and specimens in the higher range of this grade are extremely rare.
Attractive yellow-gold and apricot patination is seen over both sides of this AU53 specimen and considerable luster is visible in the areas around and the interstices of the design motifs. Ordinarily, the 1860-O is not a well struck issue. The first four stars are usually weak, which shows to a certain extent on the present coin. Liberty's hair, however, is somewhat better defined on this piece than ordinarily seen, and the horizontal stripes are very sharp, an unusual characteristic of the date. Most of the eagle's plumage is also strong.
The coin's surfaces, while revealing a few small marks, are free of the deep, detracting marks seen on the majority of 1860-O double eagles. These attributes add up to above-average eye appeal for this particular specimen, a significant point as most survivors are poor in this regard. The aficionado of rare gold coinage will want to give serious attention to this piece as it will be extremely difficult to locate a finer specimen. Population: 10 in 53, 8 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2604

1862-S $20 AU58 NGC. Ex: S.S. Republic. A well-defined example of this Civil War-era issue, satiny and shining with pale straw-gold surfaces. Light abrasions and friction affect the portrait and rims, though the overall visual appeal remains strong. NGC has graded 36 finer examples (1/10). This lot includes a box and certificate of authenticity.(Registry values: N1793)

2605

1863-S $20 XF45 PCGS. A lovely green-gold example, this twenty has bright orange toning with traces of luster in the protected areas. Most survivors are well worn, with the exception of those found in the S.S. Brother Jonathan and S.S. Republic treasures.(Registry values: N991)

2606

1864 $20 AU55 NGC. This scarce Choice AU Civil War double eagle has considerable luster and the expected number of small abrasions on the left obverse field. The portrait and the reverse are relatively unabraded. Unlike the 1865, only a handful of pieces were recovered from the S.S. Republic.(Registry values: N1793)

2607

1864-S $20 AU58 NGC. CAC. Although not marked as a shipwreck coin, this piece likely hails from either the S.S. Brother Jonathan or the S.S Republic, as most examples known previous to those recoveries graded only VF to XF. Glorious cartwheel luster emanates from orange-gold, lightly abraded surfaces with a bold strike and excellent eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

2608

1864-S $20 MS60 NGC. Before recent shipwreck finds yielded large numbers of 1864-S double eagles in AU and lower Mint State grades, the issue was found mostly in VF and XF condition. The new discoveries, possibly including the present coin, greatly increased the high grade populations. Bright brass-gold surfaces laced with light tan characterize the present offering. The design elements are generally well defined, and the fields are lustrous. Typically abraded, including some noticeable marks in the upper left obverse field. Census: 18 in 60, 47 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2609

1864-S $20 MS61 NGC. The 1864-S and 1865-S double eagles were formerly quite rare until the recoveries of the S.S. Republic and S.S. Brother Jonathan. As with the 1857-S double eagles recovered in large quantity from the S.S. Central America, the 1864-S and '65-S double eagles were wonderfully well-preserved. This piece offers bright yellow-gold surfaces with complete luster throughout. The strike is sharp, save for weakness on stars 1-3 and the glory of rays on the reverse. There are no obvious contact marks, just a few shallow luster grazes. While this coin is not marked on the encapsulation, we suspect it is likely from one of the recoveries above. Census: 31 in 61, 16 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2610

1865 $20 MS64 PCGS. CAC. A Choice Mint State example of the rare 1865 double eagle, an issue seldom seen in higher Mint State grades. In fact, this piece is tied with four other submissions for the finest that PCGS has ever certified (2/10). Higher NGC Census totals are due to certification of the S.S. Republic treasure. This wonderful example is highly lustrous with frosty gold surfaces and sharp design features. The surfaces are smooth and essentially mark free.
The obverse die is blundered, with digits visible in the dentils at 6 o'clock. This may be the same as the Misplaced Date Variety 2 recorded in Bowers' Guide Book of Double Eagles, a variety discovered by David Camire in January 2004. That variety is described as having the bottoms of an inverted 18 in the dentils below the 65. However, we also see a remnants of a third digit below the 8, and possible a fourth below the 1. It appears that this blundered die may have the tops of a complete misplaced date in the dentils.(Registry values: N1)

2611

1865-S $20 MS64 PCGS. A Choice 1865-S double eagle, one of several dozen recovered from the S.S. Brother Jonathan, inventory number 479. Like its fellows, this example has generally bright luster in yellows ranging from wheat to canary. Alloy is minor, mostly visible as small dots close to the rims. On the reverse, a die crack runs from the second S in STATES through OF and the first half of AMERICA. Wispy abrasions and grazes in the left field and on Liberty's nose allow positive identification in the auction catalog. Accompanied by a certificate of authenticity and a hardcover copy of the book The Treasure Ship S.S. Brother Jonathan.
Ex: The S.S. Brother Jonathan Treasure Coins (Bowers and Merena, 5/1999), lot 484.(Registry values: N4719)

2612

1868 $20 MS60 PCGS. This Type Two Philadelphia double eagle issue's mintage did not reach six figures, and the date poses a challenge in virtually all grades. Coins up to and including Extremely Fine pieces, however, do not command a substantial premium over type. At the Mint State level, on the other hand, the 1868 twenty is a recognized condition rarity. While this MS60 example comes by its grade honestly, with numerous light and moderate abrasions affecting both fields and devices, the orange-kissed yellow-gold luster is fully intact. A desirable and important survivor. Population: 2 in 60, 5 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2613

1870 $20 AU53 NGC. This coin hails from a year that the Philadelphia Mint managed to produce circulating coins of 16 different types, including 155,185 double eagles. (Several of the smaller-denomination issues were, however, token quantities.) This AU53 twenty shows lustrous yellow-gold color with moderately abraded surfaces and a bold strike.(Registry values: N1793)

2614

1871-CC $20 --Obverse Planchet Flaw--NGC. AU Details. Although not a catalog cover item like the 1870-CC, the 1871-CC is nonetheless a rarity. Just 17,387 pieces were struck, and most of the 200 or so survivors spent years in rough Old West circulation. This is a subdued apricot-gold example with minimal friction and no noticeable obverse marks. Moderate reverse abrasions are noted near the eagle's head, tail, and arrows. A small bullet-shaped lamination is northwest of obverse star 13, apparently caused by a gram or two of slag at the top of the planchet strip prior to the strike. Since the lamination is of mint origin, it does not affect the technical grade, and has only marginal impact on the eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

2615

1872-CC $20 XF40 PCGS. Though not in the same tier of rarity as its CC-mint double eagle predecessors, the 1872-CC twenty is elusive and prized nonetheless, particularly in XF and better grades. This yellow-orange example retains considerable radiance despite a measure of overall wear. The obverse is lightly abraded overall with a characteristically soft strike. On the reverse, several more significant abrasions are visible, including lines of reed marks at the E and R of AMERICA.(Registry values: N1793)

2616

1872-CC $20 AU55 NGC. Rusty Goe, in his The Mint on Carson Street, notes that while coinage at the Carson City Mint increased between 1871 and 1872, the rate of increase in coinage lagged the growth in gold deposits, so that "in 1872, miners requested just 16% of their deposits to be paid in gold coins, with the balance being returned as gold bars or certificates drawn on San Francisco banks." A continuation of this trend would set the stage for the Nevada facility's increasing irrelevance in its later years.
Though the Carson City Mint did not endure, the coins it produced did, and it can be argued that double eagles such as this 1872-CC coin have never been more relevant to collectors. The present example is barely worn and well struck with rich yellow-gold luster. A measure of alloy is noted to the left of the portrait, and below it is a diagonal line of reed marks. The surfaces are lightly abraded elsewhere.(Registry values: N2998)

2617

1873 $20 Open 3 MS62 PCGS. While readily available in circulated grades this issue becomes somewhat more difficult to locate in the lower levels of Mint State. Coins above MS63 are virtually unobtainable. Wheat-gold surfaces retain most of their luster and exhibit well struck design elements. Light scuffs limit the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2618

1873 $20 Open 3 MS62 PCGS. Satiny luster and sharp striking details enhance the appeal of this popular 19th century type coin. The 1873 Open 3 double eagle is readily available in lower grades, but the issue becomes quite scarce in grades above MS62. A scattering of minor handling marks defines the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2619

1873 $20 Open 3 MS62 PCGS. Part of a large mintage of 1.7 million pieces, the 1873 Open 3 double eagle enjoys great popularity with type collectors and series enthusiasts. The present coin displays orange-gold fields highlighted by hints of crimson and turquoise. Some softness is noted on the central obverse devices, as always, but the reverse is sharply struck. A scattering of minor handling marks accounts for the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2620

1873 $20 Open 3 MS62 PCGS. The most available Type Two double eagle, the 1873 Open 3 is extremely popular as a type coin. The present coin features a decent strike, with some softness on Liberty's hair, and bright lustrous fields. Numerous scattered handling marks throughout are common on large gold coins, and are consistent with the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2621

1873-CC $20 XF45 PCGS. CAC. Orange-tinged yellow-gold surfaces remain subtly lustrous despite light wear. Faintly abraded overall, including several marks on the cheek, but few serious flaws are present. A fundamentally appealing example of this earlier Carson City double eagle issue.
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2622

1873-CC $20 AU55 NGC. Variety 1-A, the only known dies for the date. The 1873-CC double eagle enjoyed a mintage of just 22,410 pieces, fairly small for an early Carson City twenty. Doug Winter estimates a total of 400-500 examples may survive today, with 135-150 specimens in AU grades. A few small hoards surfaced in the 1990s to augment the thin supply of high grade examples.
The present coin is an attractive, well-detailed specimen, with yellow-gold surfaces accented by hints of orange. The central curls show some weakness, as often seen on this issue, but the stars are sharp, and the reverse retains fine detail throughout. A few scattered handling marks are entirely consistent with the grade.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2623

1873-CC $20 MS60 NGC. After striking only 3,789 double eagles from Comstock Lode gold in its debut year, by 1873 the Carson City Mint managed to produce 22,410 examples of the denomination, all of them in the Close 3 style. But it seems that gold coins were snapped up into circulation in the West, with its longstanding "hard money" tradition dating from Gold Rush days and before, as soon as they were produced. That is why most CC- and S-mint coins dating from the middle to late 19th century are apt to be typically found in circulated grades.
The average certified 1873-CC double eagle grades only about AU50, and Mint State examples such as this piece are seldom seen in the numismatic marketplace. Full cartwheel luster graces both sides of this orange-gold example, and the eye appeal and abrasions are respectively greater and fewer than one might expect for the MS60 level. A nice example. Census: 12 in 60, 6 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2624

1873-S $20 Open 3 AU58 PCGS. The Open 3 variety is less available than its Closed 3 counterpart. The yellow-gold surfaces of this near-Mint State example display a considerable amount of luster and exhibit nicely defined design features. A couple of small rim marks are noted at 9:00 on the reverse, nevertheless, very pleasing.(Registry values: N991)

2625

1873-S $20 Open 3 AU58 PCGS. Although the surfaces are abraded, consistent with the grade, the rich yellow-gold luster and original olive patina ensures the originality of this near-Mint double eagle. The 1873-S is a plentiful issue among Type Two double eagles, but all issues of this design type are scarce in higher grades. The near-Mint example offered here will make a nice addition to a date or type collection.(Registry values: N991)

2626

1874 $20 AU58 PCGS. Yellow and wheat-gold hues mingle in the luster of this briefly circulated Type Two twenty. The obverse shows alloy spots at the upper rim and a nick directly below the last star on the right.(Registry values: N991)

2627

1874-CC $20 XF40 NGC. Both sides of this CC-mint twenty are bathed in honey-gold patina accented with traces of greenish-gray and reddish-gold. Small marks are more prevalent on the obverse.(Registry values: N1793)

2628

1874-CC $20 AU55 PCGS. CAC. Here is a lovely Carson City Mint double eagle with excellent yellow-gold luster that retains a faint greenish appearance. The surfaces are lightly abraded as expected for the grade. Light wear is visible on the high points, as the AU55 grade suggests.(Registry values: N1793)

2629

1875-CC $20 --Obverse Planchet Flaw--NGC. XF Details. Although designated "Obverse Planchet Flaw," no such flaw is evident. However, the obverse appears to be lightly cleaned, and there are thin scratches on Liberty's forehead and on the field near the nose. Luster is ample for the XF level.(Registry values: N1793)

2630

1875-CC $20 XF45 NGC. Strongly appealing for a Carson City twenty in the XF range, with only a few minor digs noted on and around the devices. Attractive yellow-gold luster remains over much of each side, with hints of peach and orange also visible in the fields.(Registry values: N1793)

2631

1875-CC $20 AU55 NGC. Both sides of this Choice AU Carson City coin retain flashy luster, though the sun-yellow reverse also adds cartwheels. Surfaces are moderately abraded with a single alloy spot noted at Liberty's neck. Despite these imperfections, the coin offers considerable eye appeal for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2632

1875-CC $20 AU55 PCGS. This impressive Choice AU Carson City type coin displays substantial mint luster. The reverse is splendidly unabraded, and although the obverse exhibits distributed small marks, none are of any individual consequence. Encapsulated in an old green label holder.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2633

1875-CC $20 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc. Details. The reverse of this Type Two Carson City double eagle is lustrous and appears unimpaired, but the obverse is a bit bright and displays faint hairlines. The 1875-CC is generally encountered in XF or AU, although Uncirculated examples are obtainable if the buyer is patient.(Registry values: N1793)

2634

1876 $20 MS61 Prooflike NGC. Light Motto, an enigmatic design subtype that only appears on some 1876 Philadelphia twenties. The introduction of the Type Three reverse undoubtedly prevented the spread of the Light Motto to other issues. A boldly struck piece with bright fields and expected obverse abrasions. Census: 8 in 61 Prooflike, 3 finer (2/10).

2635

1876-CC $20 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. A well defined Centennial Carson City twenty that has substantial luster and no consequential abrasions. Slightly bright, but many collectors would be pleased to own this representative of the famous Old West mint.(Registry values: N1793)

2636

1876-CC $20 MS60 NGC. The surfaces are distinctly prooflike on this Mint State example of an issue produced to the extent of 138,441 coins, a generous amount for the Mint at Carson City. The canary-gold surfaces have a peppering of moderate abrasions that appear more to be from coin-to-coin contact in banks bags than from any actual circulation.(Registry values: N2998)

2637

1876-S $20 MS61 PCGS. An Uncirculated khaki-gold double eagle from the final year of the conditionally scarce Type Two design. Lustrous and impeccably struck with the customary number of distributed small marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2638

1877-CC $20 VF30 NGC. One state away, the San Francisco Mint struck more than 1.7 million double eagles in 1877. But Carson City managed only 42,565 pieces, as the facility concentrated on silver coinage that year. The present example retains pockets of mint luster, and although wear is evident on the highpoints, the surfaces are only moderately abraded.(Registry values: N1793)

2639

1877-CC $20 XF45 NGC. The yellow-gold surfaces of this Choice XF twenty dollar retain traces of luster in the recessed areas. Appropriate definition is visible on the design elements despite high-point wear. Distributed small marks are visible over both sides. Many were shipped overseas and have returned to the States in recent decades.(Registry values: N1793)

2640

1877-S $20 MS62 PCGS. If a collector is seeking a type coin, why not buy one that is early in the series? The 1877-S is a well-produced issue and is moderately available in the MS60-62 grade range. This particular coin has lovely, reddish-tinted mint frost. As one would expect from an MS62, there are a number of small to medium-sized abrasions on each side. The strike is sharp throughout.(Registry values: N2998)

2641

1878-CC $20 --Obverse Damage--NGC. XF Details. Variety 1-A, attributed by the vertical die scratch on Liberty's neck and two minute die lumps to the right of the second T in TWENTY. The '78-CC is is one of the rarest Carson City Mint issues. A couple of scratches in the lower right obverse field put this otherwise nice piece in the "Details" category. Nicely defined yellow-gold surfaces display traces of luster in the recesses.(Registry values: N1793)

2642

1878-CC $20 --Rim Filing--NGC. XF Details. At first glance, this is simply a radiant, lightly abraded yellow-gold Carson City double eagle. On closer inspection, however, the upper obverse rim shows evidence of filing, and on the reverse, several similar spots are suspect.(Registry values: N1793)

2643

1879 $20 MS63 PCGS. CAC. This is only the seventh appearance of an MS63 1879 twenty in any our auctions since 1993, and we have never offered a finer example. The auction and certification data shows that this issue is plentiful in all grades through the lowest Mint State levels, including MS61 and MS62, but it is a rarity any finer.
This lovely piece has frosty yellow luster with bold design motifs. The surfaces have a few minor abrasions that are consistent with the grade. A dark area at the top of the fourth vertical stripe on the reverse may aid the numismatist who seeks a provenance for this coin. Population: 13 in 63, 7 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2644

1879-CC $20 AU55 PCGS. This coin was struck out West in the year that Mint Director Henry R. Linderman died at age 53 and Charles E. Barber became chief engraver. The Carson City Mint struck 10,708 double eagles, a stingy total explained by the decision of the new Mint director, Horatio Burchard, and Treasury Secretary John T. Sherman to place the facility on a reduced work schedule while its fate was pondered in Washington. (We cannot resist commenting that the decision took 14 years to come to fruition.)
This is a well-struck example with generous luster remaining on the mellow reddish-orange surfaces. The light abrasions are scattered and individually insignificant. Population: 19 in 55, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2645

1879-S $20 MS60 PCGS. No trace of wear, though alloy appears at a handful of the highest design elements and marks and scrapes are numerous. Yellow-gold luster persevered in the fields.(Registry values: N1793)

2646

1879-S $20 MS61 PCGS. CAC. Here is a beautiful twenty with frosty yellow luster and accompanying light olive and pale rose toning, especially on the obverse. The 1879-S is a condition rarity like so many Type Three double eagles. PCGS has only certified 53 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N1793)

2647

1882-S $20 MS61 PCGS. Though the yellow-gold luster is lighter than is often seen for this San Francisco issue, its strength is undeniable. Solidly struck devices are moderately abraded, as expected for the grade, yet more attractive than the MS61 designation might suggest.(Registry values: N1793)

2648

1882-S $20 MS62 PCGS. Better produced than most 1882-S twenties, the strike only wanes at the top of Liberty's hair curls. The surfaces are bright and exhibit rich orange-gold mint frost. A few small abrasions, most on the obverse, account for the grade. The 1882-S is exceedingly scarce in MS63, making a high-end MS62 such as this piece, an excellent value.(Registry values: N2998)

2649

1883-CC $20 XF40 NGC. Despite the modest grade, this piece exhibits considerable prooflike surface on each side. It is light yellow with excellent eye appeal for the XF grade. The design elements are also boldly defined.(Registry values: N1793)

2650

1883-CC $20 XF45 PCGS. A problem-free butter-gold Choice XF example of this scarcer Carson City date. Luster brightens Liberty's hair and individual stars. Encapsulated in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2651

1883-CC $20 --Repaired, Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. The lower left obverse field shows signs of being smoothed out, and yellow-gold surfaces are extensively hairlined from a subsequent cleaning. Still, a readily collectible example of this Carson City issue.(Registry values: N1793)

2652

1883-CC $20 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Despite a past cleaning, this remains a fundamentally pleasing example of this mid-date Carson City double eagle issue. Yellow-gold luster persists despite a mix of hairlines and light to moderate abrasions.(Registry values: N1793)

2653

1883-CC $20 AU58 NGC. This double eagle issue hails from near the middle of the Carson City Mint's 23-year run, and it was made to the extent of less than 60,000 pieces--a respectable total that reflects a minor resurgence in yields from the fabled Comstock Lode. Radiant cartwheel luster remains on the orange-gold surfaces, with few relevant marks and excellent eye appeal.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2654

1883-S $20 MS62 PCGS. Tall S, one of two mintmark sizes known for the issue. A green-gold and lustrous double eagle with a good strike and the expected scattered minor marks, which include a few thin lines on the cheek.(Registry values: N2998)

2655

1884-CC $20 XF45 PCGS. Luminous yellow-gold with hints of mustard and orange. The strike is pleasing, and few marks are visible in the fields. Excellent quality for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2656

1884-CC $20 AU58 PCGS. CAC. The semiprooflike fields of this near-Mint State 1884-CC issue highlight the devices at various angles. Attractive yellow-gold patina displays hints of apricot and mint-green and a decisive strike leaves sharp definition on the design elements. Minuscule distributed marks are not offensive.(Registry values: N1793)

2657

1884-S $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1884-S is readily available in bagmarked MS61 or MS62, but examples with complete luster and without distracting abrasions are elusive. This Select example has a well preserved reverse, and the obverse displays only minor grazes on the cheek, neck, and right obverse field.(Registry values: N2998)

2658

1885-CC $20 XF40 NGC. CAC. The 1885-CC is one of the more difficult Carson City double eagles of the 1880s. Reddish-gold patination covers this XF specimen and relatively strong detail is apparent on the design elements. There are fewer marks than what might be expected for a large, heavy gold coin that has experienced circulation.(Registry values: N1793)

2659

1885-CC $20 XF40 NGC. All Carson City double eagles are scarce, but the 1885-CC is very scarce, as it has less than one-tenth the mintage of the 1874-CC, 1875-CC, or 1876-CC. Among all twenty dollar issues from the legendary Western facility, only the 1870-CC and 1891-CC have lower mintages. The present XF example has rich orange-gold toning, considerable design detail, and an absence of relevant marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2660

1885-CC $20 AU55 PCGS. The Carson City Mint ceased coinage on March 18, 1885 for four years, and this accounts for the rarity of the 1885-CC. The mintage was 9,450 pieces, a fraction of the 81,139 double eagles struck at the Western facility in 1884. The present example shows slight friction on the cheek, but luster is abundant and no marks are consequential. Population: 30 in 55, 56 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2661

1889-CC $20 Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an AU specimen that has been cleaned and has altered surfaces. The cloudy yellow-gold surfaces show faint hairlines from a past cleaning but the reverse displays substantial cartwheel luster. Well-defined with minimal wear.
Ex: Stack's (3/2009), lot 6137.

2662

1889-CC $20 XF45 NGC. Though worn into the XF range, this yellow-orange representative is remarkably lustrous with few marks, accounting for the 45 numeric grade. A shallow graze is noted in the space below Liberty's chin.(Registry values: N1793)

2663

1889-CC $20 --Rim Damage--NGC. AU Details. The holder design allows viewers to see the crimping of the rim, possibly from placement in a bezel. Light yellow-gold surfaces retain considerable luster despite a measure of wear and the associated wispy abrasions.(Registry values: N1793)

2664

1889-CC $20 AU53 NGC. The 1889-CC is one of the more popular issues struck from the Carson City Mint, though it is not particularly difficult to locate. Traces of luster are visible in the recessed areas of this well defined AU53 example. Light marks are within the confines of the designated grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2665

1889-S $20 MS61 ★ NGC. Outstanding eye appeal for an MS61 coin, as suggested by the Star designation. The moderately abraded obverse is decidedly prooflike, while the yellow-orange surfaces of the reverse trade clean surfaces for more traditional luster. A small alloy spot is noted in the loop of the R in AMERICA.(Registry values: N991)

2666

1890-CC $20 XF45 NGC. Numerous light to moderate abrasions affect each side, yet the remaining detail and luster are both considerable for an XF example. An intriguing wheat-gold candidate for the Carson City collector.(Registry values: N1793)

2667

1890-CC $20 AU53 PCGS. Surprisingly lustrous considering the light, even wear across the well struck design elements. A lightly abraded but attractive yellow-orange example of a Carson City twenty.(Registry values: N1793)

2668

1890-CC $20 AU58 NGC. As the most available Carson City twenty, the 1890-CC is the logical choice for a type coin. This example is certainly above average for the issue. While usually seen heavily abraded, this piece shows only the slightest marks and none are of singular merit. The reddish-gold surfaces are bright and retain generous amounts of mint luster. A lovely CC twenty.(Registry values: N1793)

2669

1890-CC $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1890-CC double eagle is a generally available issue even in the lower Mint State grades, and it is one that is usually well struck. However, many examples are kept from the higher grades by a plethora of abrasions that plague the issue. This coin is a delightful exception, with fully original surfaces displaying faint lilac color interspersed with light reddish-gold. The strike is full, and there are no obvious post-strike contact marks. A small planchet flake, as made, appears to the left of the bust truncation. An appealing type coin to represent the fabled Carson City Mint, and an issue seldom seen finer. Population: 5 in 63, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2670

1891-S $20 MS62 PCGS. Lightly patinated yellow-gold surfaces show suggestions of orange. Though the coin shows a few too many moderate abrasions for a Select designation, it is nonetheless thoroughly Mint State.(Registry values: N1793)

2671

1892 $20 AU55 PCGS. A tiny mintage of 4,430 pieces draws collector attention to the 1892. The 1892-S production, by comparison, was more than 200 times greater. AU55 is the average grade for the 1892, although NGC has certified both a VF25 and an MS68. The present example has minimal wear and considerable luster. Moderate marks are limited to the nose tip and shield. Population: 21 in 55, 46 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2672

1892 $20 MS63 PCGS. Though not so great a rarity as famous earlier dates such as the 1882 or 1885, the 1892 business strike double eagle is decidedly low-mintage, with just 4,430 pieces coined for circulation and few of them saved. This Select representative is sure to be a highlight of the winning bidder's cabinet or showcase. Rich yellow-orange luster rolls off smooth surfaces in shimmering cartwheels, backed up by glints of reflectivity. Sharply struck and instantly memorable, a captivating example of an issue increasingly receiving its due. Population: 3 in 63, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2673

1892-CC $20 XF40 PCGS. Faint traces of orange toning are displayed on the pale yellow surfaces of this desirable gold piece. All double eagles from the Carson City Mint are in demand, regardless of the grade. They are tangible reminders of the old West.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2674

1892-S $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1892-S can be located with little difficulty through MS63, after which it becomes elusive. Apricot-gold and mint-green patina is deeper on the reverse of this Select specimen and a well executed strike leaves sharp detail on the design motifs. Minute marks limit the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2675

1894-S $20 MS62 Prooflike NGC. A well executed strike leaves sharp definition on the design elements, all of which are highlighted by the prooflike fields. Several grazes and marks are noted, but the yellow-gold surfaces still possess considerable eye appeal for the designated numeric grade. Census: 8 in 62 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).

2676

1900 $20 MS63 PCGS. An appealing Select example from this popular later issue, surprisingly elusive in MS63 and better grades despite a mintage of over 1.8 million pieces. Lightly abraded yellow-gold surfaces show a degree of patina from long-term storage. Housed in a small-format PCGS holder.(Registry values: N991)

2677

1900 $20 MS63 PCGS. Rich apricot-gold coloration displays traces of greenish-tan and lustrous surfaces are in receipt of a decisive strike. A few grade-defining but inoffensive grazes are noted.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N991)

2678

1900 $20 MS64 PCGS. Brilliant and frosty yellow-gold luster and sharp design details are immediately evident on this lovely double eagle. While a large number have been certified at this grade, PCGS has only graded 65 finer pieces.(Registry values: N1793)

2679

1901 $20 MS65 NGC. The 1901 is usually available at the price of a type coin, but its availability in Gem condition pales in comparison to the 1904. The mint luster on this piece is rich and softly frosted, and the surfaces are only slightly marked. Close examination with a magnifier is required to discern the pale alloy spots, a characteristic of the hoard coins that were located in Europe several years ago.(Registry values: N2998)

2680

1901-S $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1901-S double eagle is fairly abundant through the MS62 level of preservation. Select coins are more difficult, near-Gems are scarce, and finer examples are very rare. The yellow-gold surfaces of this lustrous MS63 coin are tinted with mint-green and apricot, and exhibit well struck design elements. Light marks limit the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2681

1902-S $20 MS63 NGC. This is a large S-mint production of 1.75 million coins (large, that is, unless one compares it to the total for the 1904-S), and many examples have been repatriated to this country from overseas. This Select example offers cartwheel luster over attractive orange-gold surfaces. The moderate abrasions are characteristic of coin-to-coin contact in Mint bags. NGC has certified 40 pieces finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2682

1903 $20 MS65 NGC. This is an underrated issue at the Gem level, possibly due to its proximity to the enormous double eagle emissions of 1904 at two mints. Gem 1903s are occasionally obtainable, but anything nicer is a real stretch. This specimen offers bold cartwheel luster over orange-gold, problem-free surfaces. NGC has graded only eight coins finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2683

1904 $20 MS64 PCGS. CAC. Satiny and enchanting with waves of peach, orange-gold, and bright yellow. Well-defined with slight patina and great eye appeal for the Choice grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2684

1904 $20 MS64 PCGS. Great luster exudes from the minimally abraded peach-gold surfaces of this near-Gem. The design features are well impressed. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2685

1904 $20 MS64 PCGS. Bold yellow-gold centers give way to peach and orange at the shining margins. A gorgeous near-Gem example of this type set classic, housed in a first-generation holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2686

1904 $20 MS65 PCGS. This lovely orange-gold Gem is imbued with hints of mint-green and displays ebullient luster. A decisive strike imparts virtual completeness to the design elements, and both sides are nicely preserved for the numerical grade. Its desirability is further enhanced by the old PCGS green-label holder. A thoroughly appealing piece.(Registry values: N2998)

2687

1904 $20 MS65 NGC. This boldly detailed 1904 twenty is an excellent candidate for a type collection. It has full design definition on both sides. The surfaces are lustrous and brilliant, with hints of rose toning over bright yellow surfaces.
A fascinating raised die line begins below the BE in LIBERTY, and branches down in a wishbone fashion through the hair curls. Additional raised die lines extend into the hair from the lower edge of the ear.(Registry values: N2998)

2688

1904 $20 MS66 PCGS. The 1904 double eagle is among the most famous type issues in all of U.S. coinage, particularly in grades such as MS63 and MS64. Though Gems and even Premium Gems are available for a price rather than scarce, finer examples are practically nonexistent; PCGS has certified just two such pieces (1/10). Thus, an MS66 coin such as the present piece represents the pinnacle for many collectors. Potent orange-gold luster shows occasional elements of both yellow and deep peach, adding variety to the color. Excellent striking and surface characteristics define the grade, and the smooth cheek of Liberty is particularly noteworthy.(Registry values: N4719)

2689

1904-S $20 MS64 PCGS. CAC. The 1904-S double eagle is readily available through near-Gem, after which the certified population declines significantly. Yellow-gold surfaces display traces of apricot and mint-green, and a sharp strike emboldens the design elements. Pleasing luster and minimally abraded for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2690

1904-S $20 MS64 PCGS. The "other" Liberty double eagle issue of 1904, the S-mint version of the date saw a mintage of over 5.1 million pieces, though it is far more elusive in grades above MS64 than its Philadelphia counterpart. This Choice coin offers bold yellow-orange cartwheel luster and excellent eye appeal. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2691

1904-S $20 MS64 NGC. Boldly impressed in the centers with suggestions of peach against essentially canary-yellow surfaces. An attractive Choice example of this alternative 20th century type issue.(Registry values: N1793)

2692

1906 $20 MS62 PCGS. CAC. This fully brilliant, highly lustrous, and boldly defined 1906 double eagle has a few minor imperfections on each side, with a small splash of dark olive toning and matte finish. Otherwise, both sides have bright yellow mint luster with wisps of pale orange toning.(Registry values: N1793)

2693

1906 $20 MS63 PCGS. Only 69,500 double eagles were minted of this issue, and survivors are rare in higher grades. PCGS has only certified 30 finer pieces (2/10). This green label PCGS specimen has frosty yellow-gold luster with faint olive and orange patina. The strike is excellent. This attractive double eagle will appeal to the type or date collector.(Registry values: N2998)

2694

1906-D $20 MS63 PCGS. The Denver Mint Liberty Head double eagles from its first two years, the 1906-D and 1907-D, are well produced, attractive specimens, by and large. This piece is no exception, with splendid eye appeal that embraces a bold strike, lovely greenish-orange color, and few mentionable abrasions.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2695

1906-S $20 MS64 PCGS. San Francisco certainly stayed neck-and-neck in the fray with the new Denver Mint that opened in 1906, itself producing more than 2 million 1906-S twenties of excellent quality. The issue is nonetheless conditionally scarce at the near-Gem level. The present example displays pristine apricot-gold surfaces with radiant luster and bold eye appeal. PCGS has graded only eight coins finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2696

1907-D $20 MS63 PCGS. Apricot-gold patina imbued with mint-green covers the lustrous surfaces of this sharply struck Select D-mint representative. A well executed strike emboldens the design features. Kept from a finer grade by a few minute marks.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2697

1907-D $20 MS65 NGC. This well struck Gem has comprehensive luster and an essentially pristine reverse. Obverse contact is inconsequential. Only a tiny percentage of Uncirculated '07-D double eagles are of comparable quality. The second and final Denver issue of the Liberty twenty series. Certified in a prior generation holder.(Registry values: N2998)

2698

1907-S $20 MS64 PCGS. The 1907-S Liberty Head double eagle is more difficult to locate than its large mintage of more than 2 million pieces would indicate. The issue is scarce at the Choice level, and quite rare any finer. The present coin is sharply struck and displays bright, lustrous surfaces. Handling marks are minimal and eye appeal is significant for a 1907-S.(Registry values: N2998)

2699

1900 $20 MS65 NGC. Leading off The Vision Collection is this delightful turn-of-the-century Gem, sharply detailed with warm golden luster that occasionally takes on a butter-yellow cast. Both sides are smooth and without significant abrasions, though the portrait and nearby areas show a handful of luster grazes. NGC has graded just four numerically finer pieces (2/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2700

1900-S $20 MS64 PCGS. With a mintage of over 2.4 million pieces, it is hardly surprising that the 1900-S double eagle has survived in quantity, and coins in the lower Mint State grades are readily accessible. Choice examples such as the present piece are scarce, however, and anything finer a rarity. Strong yellow-gold luster has orange overtones, and though a few abrasions are noted at Liberty's neck and in the fields, the surfaces show more trivial luster grazes than actual marks.
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2701

1901 $20 MS65 PCGS. CAC. An elegant Gem survivor from this turn-of-the-century issue, sharply struck with vibrantly lustrous wheat-gold and mint-green surfaces and marvelous visual appeal. The portrait is especially clean, with only a handful of minuscule luster grazes away from the focal points. Higher-grade examples from this low-mintage date are exceedingly elusive, with just three such coins in the combined PCGS/NGC population (1/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2702

1901-S $20 MS64 PCGS. This near-Gem is decidedly above-the-curve for its issue of just under 1.6 million pieces, impressively lustrous with a mix of orange-gold and lighter yellow colors. A number of luster grazes and wispy flaws populate each side, but there are few abrasions that go into the metal with any depth, and most of those coins are in out-of-the-way areas. PCGS has graded only two finer pieces (2/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2703

1902 $20 MS64 PCGS. CAC. The 1902 is one of the lowest-mintage double eagles (31,140 circulation strikes) of the 20th century. It is the rarest Liberty Head twenty struck in that century in terms of its overall rarity, and when found is usually in grades ranging from AU to lower Mint State. MS64 and finer examples are extremely rare.
This near-Gem is virtually fully struck, unusual for this issue that is often seen weak on the stars, hair strands, and eagle's plumage. Both sides have exquisite surfaces with frosty yellow-gold luster, displaying occasional splashes of faint of orange patina. A few light, relatively unobtrusive marks preclude Gem classification. Population: 8 in 64, 1 finer (1/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2704

1902-S $20 MS64 PCGS. The 1902-S is obtainable through the lower levels of Mint State, but near-Gems are elusive, and the issue is rarely seen in Gem. This MS64 coin displays potent luster exuding from peach-gold surfaces laced with tints of light tan. An attentive strike emboldens the design elements, enhancing the coin's eye appeal, and the few marks present are generally undistracting. Population: 54 in 64, 4 finer (2/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2705

1903 $20 MS65 PCGS. The 1903 double eagle had a much lower mintage than its 1904 successor, and high-end survivors are far fewer. This sun-gold Gem example has vibrant cartwheel sheen and undisturbed fields. The cheek displays unobtrusive grazes, and the reverse has a trio of subtle orange freckles. Only two pieces have been certified as finer by PCGS (2/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2706

1903-S $20 MS64 PCGS. Vibrant luster radiates from yellow-gold surfaces showing occasional splashes of apricot. Exquisitely struck on the design elements and revealing just a few minor marks denying Gem status. PCGS has seen a mere eight coins finer (1/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2707

1904 $20 MS65 ★ Prooflike NGC. Combining the star designation and the prooflike designation into a single coin, this 1904 double eagle is an exceptional Gem that will undoubtedly please the connoisseur. The surfaces are entirely mirrored and mark-free, and the devices are fully defined and lustrous, with a trace of contrast. A prize for both the date collector and the top-flight type enthusiast.
From The Vision Collection.

2708

1904-S $20 MS65 NGC. The "other" 1904-dated double eagle type issue, the 1904-S boasts its own substantial mintage of more than 5.1 million pieces, many of which have survived to the present day. Unlike the 1904, the 1904-S grading curve effectively tops out at MS65, with just three numerically finer pieces in the combined certified population (2/10). This Gem offers warm yellow-orange luster and a strong central strike, though the upper obverse stars show a degree of softness.
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2709

1905 $20 MS63 PCGS. Garrett and Guth note for this issue: "Most of the coins seen have been plucked from gold shipments that have returned to the United States in recent years. The average coin grades AU-58 to MS-61. Choice examples of the date are very rare, and none are known at the gem level." This Select example splits the difference; it is clearly a desirable coin on a higher tier than the more commonly seen AU58 or MS61 pieces, yet it is not at a stratospheric price point as is seen with the few known finer examples. A blush of rose color visits wheat and orange-gold surfaces that are immensely lustrous. Strongly struck with just a few abrasions, such as those at Liberty's brow and below her chin, that preclude an even finer designation. Population: 43 in 63, 9 finer (1/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2710

1905-S $20 MS64 NGC. A boldly impressed, brightly lustrous example, pale yellow-gold with flashes of deeper color. Though a few small reed marks and other abrasions are noted on the obverse, the overall eye appeal is strong for the grade. Though this San Francisco issue boasts a mintage of more than 1.8 million pieces, it is elusive in Choice condition and rare any finer, with just seven such pieces known to NGC (2/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2711

1906 $20 MS64 PCGS. CAC. This is a scarce, low mintage issue of just 69,596 business strikes. Michael Fuljenz and Douglas Winter (1999) point out that the typical survivor is most often seen in grades ranging from Choice AU to lower Mint State, an observation corroborated by PCGS/NGC population data. Near-Gem pieces such as the current offering are very scarce.
An above-average strike leaves sharp definition on the design elements, including the centers and lower obverse and upper reverse denticles, areas often showing weakness. Light honey-gold color and shimmering mint luster enlivens each side, and the few grade-defining marks detract nothing from the coin's nice overall eye appeal. Population: 19 in 64, 10 finer (1/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2712

1906-D $20 MS64 NGC. Lustrous yellow-gold surfaces show glints of green and tan, and an exacting strike imparts sharp detail to the design features. Only minor marks keep this attractive piece from attaining Gem classification. The 1906-D is a condition rarity any finer, with just 12 numerically superior coins known to NGC (2/10), and as one of only two years in which Liberty Head double eagles were struck at the new Denver Mint, it enjoys immense popularity.
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2713

1906-S $20 MS64 PCGS. CAC. This issue can be located with little difficulty through the MS63 level. Near-Gem specimens such as that in the present lot are quite scarce, however, and finer coins are extremely rare. Apricot-gold patination with traces of mint-green resides on lustrous surfaces that exhibit sharply struck design elements. A few unobtrusive grazes are all that stand in the way of Gem designation.
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2714

1907 $20 MS65 NGC. An immensely lustrous wheat-gold and canary-yellow Gem from the last year of Longacre's Liberty double eagle design. The strike is sharp, and though a few luster grazes are noted on the obverse, that side has the eye appeal of an even higher grade. Only a few marks scattered in the reverse fields preclude an even finer designation. Census: 17 in 65, 0 finer (2/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2715

1907-D $20 MS65 NGC. Second and last of the D-mint Liberty double eagle issues, the 1907-D has the higher mintage, though it is not until the Mint State levels that it becomes significantly more available than its predecessor. Gem coins of both dates are elusive, and anything finer is rare. This MS65 example of the 1907-D issue has bold orange-yellow luster, tending to the former color on the obverse and the latter on the reverse. Carefully preserved with a strong strike.
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2716

1907-S $20 MS64 PCGS. San Francisco's mintage of double eagles was not split between designs in 1907, and the more than 2.1 million pieces all bore the Liberty design. This near-Gem is in the upper tier of today's survivors, strongly struck with rich gold-orange luster. PCGS has certified just two finer examples (2/10).
From The Vision Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

High Relief Double Eagles

2717

1907 $20 High Relief, Wire Rim--Improperly Cleaned--NCS. Unc Details. Even though light cleaning has subdued the original satiny sheen, this remains an impressive example of what is undoubtedly the most artistically accomplished design to ever be produced in a U.S. mint. The striking details are complete over each side and there are remarkably few contact marks. The wire rim is also complete around each side. Slight reddish patina has begun to return to each side.(Registry values: N4719)

2718

1907 $20 High Relief, Wire Rim--Improperly Cleaned--NGC. Unc Details. The numismatic fervor for the Ultra High Relief and High Relief double eagles of 1907 (although dated MCMVII) never really subsided after their release, although the pattern-issue proof Ultra High Reliefs were and are out of the reach of all but the most well-heeled collectors, due to their tiny production and high cost. The 1907 High Reliefs, however, whether Wire Rim or Flat Rim, are obtainable by advanced collectors willing to budget a sufficient amount toward their purchase.
The Mint in 2009 issued a smaller version of the original Ultra High Relief, although the coin's diameter was much smaller, diminishing their impact. A bill to produce a 2010 palladium version of the Ultra High Relief coins, with diameter 27 mm, appears stalled in a House committee.
These latter-day attempts to create reasonable facsimiles of the originals only serve to reinforce how monumentally relevant their design and artistic impact remain today. While this example shows somewhat diffuse luster from a past cleaning, its Uncirculated details and overall enormous appeal are very much intact. The greenish-gold coloration adds to the allure, and there are scarcely any signs of contact.(Registry values: N4719)

2719

1907 $20 High Relief, Wire Rim MS63 NGC. Augustus Saint-Gaudens was called the "American Michelangelo" by one of the greatest historians of the past century, Henry Steele Commager. Saint-Gaudens' sculpture was greatly influenced by classical tradition that he learned when he went to Rome to escape the Franco-Prussian War in 1870. It was there that he was greatly influenced by what might be called the Neo-Florentine school of sculpture which emphasized the realism and naturalism used by the great sculptors and painters of the Renaissance. Saint-Gaudens along with architects Stanford White and Henry Hobson, and painter John La Farge were all part of this new breed of American artist. All of them were familiar with the tradition of Classical art, but they adapted their talents in each of their fields to a uniquely American style. As Henry Duffy, curator of the Saint-Gaudens National Historic Site wrote:

"All sought to clarify and simplify the art of the past, fusing European tradition with the simple moral tone preferred by Americans. What developed was a cosmopolitan style."

These Classically influenced elements can be seen through all of Saint-Gaudens' works, and it is especially evident in the gold coins he designed at the behest of Theodore Roosevelt. This is a lovely example of the first variant, the Wire Rim. The surfaces display bright, satiny lemon-yellow color with just the slightest tinge of reddish patina. Both sides are exceptionally clean for a coin in this grade with the only noticeable mark located across the rays of the sun on the reverse.(Registry values: N4719)

2720

1907 $20 High Relief, Wire Rim MS64 NGC. Most works of sculpture offer the viewer a realistic representation of the subject. Augustus Saint-Gaudens' career was built on such realistic representations both in sculptural form and his bas-reliefs. Only a few works offer a kinetic aspect. Unsurprisingly these are his best-known works, such as The Puritan, the Sherman Monument, the Shaw Memorial, and of course, the High Relief twenty dollar gold piece. The striding figure of Liberty on the double eagle bears a striking resemblance to the Puritan and the Angel of Victory from the Sherman Monument. Each work uses this sense of movement to bring the viewer into the subject depicted. This kinetic sense is further enhanced by the coin's high relief. This three-dimensional effect enlivens the striding figure of Liberty even more.
The high relief seen on this piece certainly reinforces the kinetic aspect intended by Saint-Gaudens. The surfaces are bright orange-gold and satiny as usual. The wire rim or "fin" as it was called by Mint employees is especially pronounced on the obverse and complete around each side. Both obverse and reverse are minimally abraded.(Registry values: N7079)

2721

1907 $20 High Relief, Wire Rim MS65 ★ NGC. The High Relief twenties of 1907 have endured in popularity among collectors since they were issued. Eighty years later the obverse design was resurrected for gold bullion coins, and they have remained in production ever since. While the design embodied Augustus Saint-Gaudens' ideals of what a classic American coin should look like, the role of Theodore Roosevelt cannot be overlooked. As Roger Burdette pointed out in his address to the ANS in October 2009, Roosevelt was a collector of many things. He collected artists, sculptors, big game trophies, and in fact trophies of all kinds. One could argue that everything Theodore Roosevelt did was related to the enhancement of image. As president, he saw the opportunity to enhance the nation's image through its coinage. He seized that opportunity and opened the door for other sculptors and artists outside the Mint to submit coinage designs. In his memoirs, Roosevelt spoke of adopting those new coins as one of the important achievements of his administration. His day-to-day concern about the designs and their execution is clear in the correspondence between himself and Saint-Gaudens, letters reproduced in numerous books and periodicals since 1920. His pride in the coins was probably best expressed in a note to Saint-Gaudens where he wrote that they were "more beautiful than any coins since the days of the Greeks."
This is a amazing coin and one that exemplifies why Theodore Roosevelt was so proud of these coins. The mint luster swirls around each side and has more of a frosted appearance than the usual satiny finish. The wire rim is complete around each side and in this case is high enough to act as a framing device for the interior tondo design. Strong magnification shows a few tiny contact marks in the right obverse field, but one has to look hard to find them. An exceptional quality High Relief.(Registry values: N7079)

2722

1907 $20 High Relief, Flat Rim MS64 PCGS. As a sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens had a special talent for creating motion and drama in his art. His full creativity and genius can be seen in his bas-reliefs, where his use of both realism and naturalism make these works seem more like a painting than the traditional bas-reliefs done by previous designers. This genius for creating motion and drama can be seen on the twenty dollar gold piece that he worked on intermittently from 1905 until his death in August 1907. The figure of Liberty strides confidently forward toward the viewer with the rays of the sunrise behind, clearly symbolizing the dawn of the American century.
The irony is Saint-Gaudens and Theodore Roosevelt saw America as a rising power on the world stage, but Saint-Gaudens' own future was ultimately cut short by stomach cancer. Nevertheless, this forward-looking coin expressed the optimism the sculptor felt toward America at the dawn of the 20th century, though he would not live to see the High Relief coins, such as this Flat Rim example, that are his greatest legacy. The yellow-orange surfaces of this near-Gem are smooth and lightly patinated. The strike on the sculpted devices is characteristically sharp, and only a few wispy faults preclude an even finer designation.(Registry values: N7079)

2723

1907 $20 High Relief, Flat Rim MS67 NGC. Numismatists are familiar with Augustus Saint-Gaudens' eagle and double eagle, but his oeuvre included statues, bas-reliefs, medallions, cameos, and works in other media. As a teenager he began his career with an apprenticeship to a cameo-cutter before he left for Paris in 1867. Although he was able to make some money selling cameos in New York City, by his own accounts they did not sell well in Paris, where other artists were more skillful. Saint-Gaudens would soon create works on a grander scale, but his experience with cameo-cutting would come in handy when he was commissioned to design medals and, later, coins.
It is impossible to say which of Saint-Gaudens' many works was the most important, but certainly his statue of General William Tecumseh Sherman is one of the most lauded, and the figure of Victory (Nike) in the monument would later be used as a model for the double eagle. This statue also brought Saint-Gaudens into contact with Roosevelt, who was vice president at the time, and their collaboration would later result in the beginning of the American coinage renaissance.
Saint-Gaudens wanted his statue of Sherman to be positioned near Grant's Tomb, which was completed in 1897, for artistic and historical reasons. Roger Burdette (2006) writes, "After a chance meeting on a train returning from the Buffalo Exhibition in May 1901, he sought the intervention of vice-president Theodore Roosevelt in an attempt to secure his preferred location of the statue."
Although Roosevelt was unsuccessful and the statue was placed at the southeastern corner of New York's Central Park, he did not forget his encounter with Saint-Gaudens. Less than four years later, Roosevelt would ask Saint-Gaudens to redesign some of the country's coins. The coins were Saint-Gaudens' final project, and the 1907 High Relief double eagle was the fitting capstone to the artist's distinguished career.
The physical perfection of this coin makes one realize why Theodore Roosevelt was so proud of these pieces and why he used them for presentation purposes. The surfaces are essentially perfect. We just do not see any flaws on either side--they may exist--we simply do not see them. The bright yellow-golden surfaces display radiant mint luster, and the striking details are complete throughout (note the separation of the letters at the top of the reverse from the rim). Few collectors will ever own a High Relief. Even fewer will ever see, much less own an example such as this one. Census: 16 in 67, 3 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N10218)

Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles

2724

1907 $20 Arabic Numerals MS64 PCGS. Frosty yellow-gold surfaces define the eye appeal of this first-year Saint-Gaudens twenty. Well struck with a measure of alloy visible at the high points.(Registry values: N1793)

2725

1907 $20 Arabic Numerals MS64 PCGS. Whispers of greenish-gray visit the peach-gold lustrous surfaces of this near-Gem twenty. Sharply struck, including excellent detail on the Capitol building. Light marks preclude Gem status.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2726

1907 $20 Arabic Numerals MS65 PCGS. The Arabic Numerals twenty from 1907 is the result of design modifications by Charles Barber. It was necessary to lower the coin's relief for single-striking, commercial production. This is the first year of this immensely popular type, and a surprising number of collectors have even attempted (and a few have even completed) a set. This is a lovely example that is strongly struck throughout. The lustrous yellow-gold surfaces have a slight accent of reddish patina on each side.(Registry values: N2998)

2727

1907 $20 Arabic Numerals MS65 PCGS. Attractively toned in rich orange-gold and lime-green shades, characteristic of many undisturbed Federal gold coins. Crisply struck and lustrous with good preservation despite a couple of inconspicuous marks on the eagle's plumage. Certified in a green label holder.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2728

1907 $20 Arabic Numerals MS65 PCGS. This first-year butter-gold Gem has booming luster, and the strike is sharp except for minor blending of detail on the eagle's leg feathers. The obverse field and the entire reverse are beautifully preserved. Housed in a green label holder.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2729

1907 $20 Arabic Numerals MS65 PCGS. The 1907 is among the most common issues of the type. That said, the present Gem will make an ideal piece for a high-grade type or date collection. Its pleasing luster complements the sharply struck devices, including the Capitol building, Liberty's fingers, and the eagle's plumage. Attractive yellow-gold patina adorns both sides. A small linear abrasion in the right obverse field is the most noteworthy mark.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2730

1908 $20 No Motto MS65 PCGS. Pale straw and bold yellow colors dominate the eye appeal of this shining Gem. Well-defined with solid eye appeal, ideal for the type collector. Housed in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2731

1908 $20 No Motto MS65 NGC. Long Rays obverse. A green-gold Gem that has exemplary luster and a slightly above-average strike. Marks are few in number, and none are of individual consequence. The No Motto design was coined for only two years, making this an important example to the MS65-level type enthusiast.(Registry values: N1793)

2732

1908 $20 No Motto MS66 NGC. Frosty luster envelops this yellow-gold Premium Gem. Sharply struck, including excellent detail on the panes of the Capitol building and Liberty's fingers. Devoid of significant marks.(Registry values: N2998)

2733

1908 $20 No Motto MS67 ★ NGC. A breathtaking Superb Gem of this available issue, although one that is hardly common at this grade level. Both sides are expectedly free of all but the most picayune evidence of contact. But what garners this piece the coveted Star designation from NGC is likely the multicolored surfaces, which range from sage at the rims through delicate pastel orange to greenish-gold at the centers. Although undesignated as such, this coin is almost certainly from the legendary Wells Fargo hoard of thousands of high-Mint State pieces. Definitely a keeper coin at the top echelon of all survivors.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2734

1908 $20 No Motto, Wells Fargo Nevada MS66 PCGS. The significance of the massive Wells Fargo hoard is often overlooked by collectors and dealers alike. The presence of thousands of Gem and finer examples guarantees the availability of this popular, two-year type coin. As indicated by the grade, this is an exceptionally clean coin. The surfaces display frosted mint luster and even, light reddish-gold color.(Registry values: P1)

2735

1908 $20 No Motto, Wells Fargo Nevada MS67 PCGS. The strike is strong throughout with full definition on the Capitol building and on Liberty's torch hand. The mint luster is undisturbed and displays a satiny sheen across the splendidly preserved surfaces. A member of an amazing high-quality hoard of 1908 No Motto double eagles that was marketed in the late 1990s under the Wells Fargo moniker. Important as No Motto type coins, these Gem to Superb Gem pieces have been absorbed by the coin market, and like the Carson City GSA dollars, have risen in value in recent years since they are no longer obtainable in quantity.(Registry values: P1)

2736

1908 $20 No Motto, Wells Fargo Nevada MS67 NGC. Short Rays obverse. This exquisite Superb Gem has rich apricot luster and a paucity of post-strike contact. The strike is full except for a trace of incompleteness on the eagle's leg feathers. The No Motto type was coined for only two years, although high grade examples are affordable today courtesy of the Wells Fargo hoard.(Registry values: P1)

2737

1908 $20 No Motto, Wells Fargo Nevada MS67 NGC. Short Rays obverse. This pleasing sun-gold Superb Gem has a decisive strike and a remarkably unabraded appearance. The Wells Fargo Nevada hoard is well known for its outstanding quality, and the present piece is even nicer than the usual representative from that holding, presumably put away at the time of issue more than a century ago.(Registry values: P1)

2738

1908 $20 No Motto, Wells Fargo Nevada MS68 PCGS. The discovery of the so-called "Wells Fargo" hoard of No Motto 1908 double eagles redefined the nature of the type issue, adding numerous high-end coins to the uppermost levels of the population figures, with 10 astounding coins reaching MS69 (1/10). As an MS68, this Superb Gem offers similarly strong eye appeal with just a few more marks that are barely visible to the unaided eye. Bold sun-yellow luster shows orange undercurrents through the centers, and the strike is generally pleasing. A tiny alloy fleck is noted above the rays to Liberty's left.(Registry values: P1)

2739

1908-D $20 No Motto MS64 PCGS. CAC. Exquisitely struck, evidenced by the detail on the Capitol building, Liberty's fingers, and the eagle's plumage. Pleasing luster throughout, and revealing just a few minute marks that preclude Gem classification. Many reposed in European bank vaults, only to return to America decades later.(Registry values: N1793)

2740

1908-D $20 No Motto MS64 PCGS. CAC. Light wheat-gold color through most of the centers with deeper sun-yellow near the rims. A pleasing near-Gem representative of the lower-mintage Denver No Motto 1908 Saint-Gaudens twenty.(Registry values: N1793)

2741

1908-D $20 No Motto MS64 PCGS. Pretty yellow-gold luster emanates from both sides of this near-Gem, while a well executed strike imparts sharp definition to the design elements, including the panes of the Capitol building, the fingers on the branch hand, and the eagle's plumage. Scattered, inoffensive light marks deny Gem status.(Registry values: N1793)

2742

1908-D $20 No Motto MS66 PCGS. This issue has an interesting history, one that has swung from one end of the rarity pendulum to the other. A generous mintage--two-thirds of a million coins--was produced, but most were exported soon afterward, and in time the issue became known as scarce. Rising gold coin prices in the late 20th century, however, led to the repatriation of many examples. Even though the issue today is still by far the scarcest of the No Motto issues, examples are frequently seen, most in the lower Mint State grades. Gem pieces are rare, and the present MS66 piece notably so. PCGS has certified only nine pieces at this grade level, with none finer (2/10).
Gorgeous cascading luster radiates from the orange-gold surfaces tinged with green at the rims. As expected, neither side reveals even the most minute distractions, and both sides show enormous eye appeal.(Registry values: N1)

2743

1908 $20 Motto MS64 PCGS. CAC. A khaki-gold Choice double eagle that possesses sweeping luster and an exacting strike. Thorough inspection locates only a few visible abrasions. The 1908 Motto is conditionally scarce in comparison with the No Motto variety struck earlier the same year.(Registry values: N2998)

2744

1908 $20 Motto MS65 PCGS. Bold yellow-gold luster with an above-average strike and a wire rim around parts of the reverse. Marks are generally light and unobtrusive, though a few minor abrasions are noted on and near Liberty's gown. Unlike the famously available No Motto 1908 twenties, the With Motto pieces had a mediocre mintage and were little-saved; no major hoard has emerged to give collectors broad access to high-grade pieces. Gems such as the present coin are borderline condition rarities, and anything finer absolutely warrants that status; PCGS has certified only 10 such pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2745

1908-D $20 Motto MS64 PCGS. Booming luster and clean surfaces confirm the quality of the present first-year Motto twenty dollar piece. The strike is intricate, even on the breast feathers and panes of the Capitol building. Both sides are impressively unabraded despite a subtle mark on Liberty's jaw.(Registry values: N1793)

2746

1908-D $20 Motto MS64 PCGS. Light wheat-gold color appears at certain angles, though fuller sun-yellow luster emerges as this Choice coin is tilted under illumination. A strongly struck piece with worthy eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

2747

1908-D $20 Motto MS66 PCGS. Denver's production of double eagles in 1908 totaled just over a million pieces, and of those coins, slightly over one-third were struck after the change to the Motto on Reverse variety. The 1908-D Motto twenty is available through most grades, even in Gem, but MS66 coins are another story. This eye-catching Premium Gem has strong orange overtones to the yellow-gold surfaces. Pleasingly detailed and carefully preserved with just a few tiny luster scrapes and two small reed marks below the TW in TWENTY on the reverse. Population: 25 in 66, 3 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2748

1908-S $20 AU53 PCGS. The 1908-S double eagle has a famously low mintage of just 22,000 pieces, and examples are prized regardless of grade. This lightly circulated but plenty lustrous example has bold yellow-gold color. Lightly abraded in the fields with a more significant mark extending from the left obverse rim. Most wear appears on the highest design elements, such as Liberty's knee.(Registry values: N1793)

2749

1908-S $20 AU55 NGC. The 1908-S has the lowest mintage of the Arabic Numerals type, despite the then traditional status of the San Francisco Mint as a high volume producer of double eagles. Only 22,000 pieces were struck, and most went into circulation, since the typical example shows light wear on Liberty's chest and raised knee, as does the present coin. Satiny and attractive with minor contact on the eagle.(Registry values: N1793)

2750

1908-S $20 AU58 PCGS. The low mintage 1908-S is a favorite among gold coin collectors. Most examples lack unbroken mint luster, but the cartwheel sheen is complete on the present piece. The eagle's breast and Liberty's knee betray slight friction. No marks of any consequence are present, and the eye appeal is superior for the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2751

1909 $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1909 seems to be perpetually underrated and overlooked, especially in comparison to its overdate counterpart. The originality of this coin's surfaces are not in doubt with its dominant, rich orange-gold color that has interspersed lilac on each side. The strike is sharp throughout, and there are numerous small abrasions that account for the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2752

1909 $20 MS63 PCGS. Lustrous peach-gold surfaces display strong detail, including the Capitol building, Liberty's fingers, and the eagle's plumage. Grade-consistent marks are inoffensive. Housed in a green label holder.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2753

1909/8 $20 MS62 NGC. The overdate feature was discovered by Edgar Adams just one year after striking. The lower left portion of the 8 is virtually indistinguishable from the 9, making this a prominent overdate on a gold coin in a highly collectible series--all of which explain the popularity of these pieces. The surfaces on this coin are bright and satiny, the striking details are above average, and there are only small abrasions scattered over each side that explain the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2754

1909/8 $20 MS63 PCGS. CAC. FS-301. The 1909/8 is one of few known 20th century overdates and is consequently extremely popular among collectors. The peach-gold surfaces of this Select specimen exhibit strong delineation and give off pleasing luster. A few minute marks, while limiting the numeric grade, take nothing away from the coin's overall eye appeal.(Registry values: N2998)

2755

1909-D $20 MS64 NGC. Produced to the tiny extent of only 52,500 coins, the 1909-D is a significant, in-demand rarity in the Saint-Gaudens series. This near-Gem is far finer than the typical certified survivor, with excellent orange-gold coloration, a well-executed strike, and few abrasions of any relevance. Census: 84 in 64, 5 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2756

1909-D $20 MS64 PCGS. The 1909-D is an important Saint-Gaudens rarity, from a limited mintage of only 52,500 coins. That mintage is the fourth lowest of the entire Saint-Gaudens series behind the 1907 High Relief, 1908-S, and 1913-S issues. This satiny near-Gem has rich yellow luster with smooth surfaces and bold design elements. A few small alloy spots are evident at the lower obverse. PCGS has only certified 20 finer pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2757

1909-S $20 MS65 NGC. The mintmark is lightly repunched and shows two sets of serifs. This lustrous Gem blends olive-green and pale orange toning. Marks are minimal, and the strike is bold aside from minor incompleteness on Liberty's nose and chin. As of (2/10), NGC has certified just nine examples finer.(Registry values: N2998)

2758

1910-S $20 MS64 PCGS. Dusky wheat-gold surfaces are luminous with orange overtones. A desirable S-mint near-Gem example of an issue that becomes elusive any finer.(Registry values: N1793)

2759

1911 $20 MS63 PCGS. Luminous peach-gold surfaces exhibit well struck devices. A few minute marks and grazes are noted.(Registry values: N1793)

2760

1911 $20 MS64 PCGS. The 1911 Saint-Gaudens double eagle is an important rarity in the series from a mintage of only 197,250 coins. Most of those that have survived are in lower grades, and the average certified grade of this issue is less than MS62. This piece is fully lustrous with brilliant yellow surfaces and excellent design details. PCGS has only graded 42 finer pieces (2/10)(Registry values: N2998)

2761

1911 $20 MS65 PCGS. The Encyclopedia of U.S. Gold Coins by Garrett and Guth sums up this date's condition rarity in one sentence: "Like other Philadelphia Mint issues from this period, the 1911 double eagle is very scarce in gem MS-65 grades or finer." In fact, as an MS65 survivor, this gorgeous twenty is a borderline condition rarity. The strike is characteristically solid, but it is the potent luster, swirling yellow-orange with a touch of peach, that elevates the eye appeal. A memorable survivor for the high-end collector. Population: 33 in 65, 9 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2762

1911-D $20 MS66 PCGS. The Denver Mint coined a total of 158,280 quarter eagles, half eagles, and eagles in 1911, and during the same year that facility minted 846,500 double eagles. These large coins are plentiful today. The present example is highly lustrous with full mint frost. A few small marks are hidden in the devices. The strike is bold, with full building details and sharp hair details on the obverse, and with a finely detailed eagle, down to the individual tail feathers. PCGS has only certified six finer pieces.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2763

1911-D/D $20 MS65 PCGS. FS-501, formerly FS-1911.5. The mintmark is boldly repunched east. Sharp design definition, fully brilliant mint luster, light yellow surfaces, and an absence of consequential marks are the important characteristics of this impressive Saint-Gaudens double eagle. Population: 50 in 65, 16 finer (2/10).

2764

1911-D/D $20 MS65 PCGS. CAC. FS-501, formerly FS-1911.5. The mintmark is boldly repunched east. This fully lustrous Gem has a combination of light yellow luster and faint pink toning. The surfaces are pleasing without any distracting marks. Here is an exciting opportunity for the advanced collector to acquire one of the few repunched mintmarks in the series.

2765

1911-D/D $20 MS65 PCGS. FS-501, formerly FS-1911.5. The mintmark is boldly repunched east. A canary-gold Gem that exhibits a powerful strike and unencumbered cartwheel sheen. Splendidly preserved aside from a tick on the eagle's breast and a bright mark unobtrusively located on the top of the front wing. Population: 50 in 65, 16 finer (2/10).

2766

1911-D/D $20 MS66 PCGS. FS-501, formerly FS-1911.5. Perhaps a majority of high grade 1911-D double eagles are this variety, which exhibits minor die doubling on the rays near the branch in addition to a repunched mintmark. This is a lustrous sun-gold Premium Gem with an exemplary strike and remarkably unabraded fields. Population: 16 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).

2767

1911-D/D $20 MS66 PCGS. CAC. FS-501, formerly FS-1911.5. The curve of an initially impressed additional D is noted due east of the primary mintmark. Lustrous and unabraded with dusky chestnut-gold toning. A high grade example of this popular pre-war issue. Population: 16 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).

2768

1911-D/D $20 MS66 PCGS. CAC. FS-501, formerly FS-1911.5. The popular Repunched Mintmark variety, boldly repunched east. This piece has a frosty, mattelike sheen over the golden-orange surfaces, and a loupe reveals only one singular abrasion on Liberty's mouth. The eye appeal and overall preservation are splendid. Population: 16 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).

2769

1911-D/D $20 MS66 PCGS. CAC. FS-501, formerly FS-1911.5. The mintmark is boldly repunched east. An incredible Premium Gem, this repunched mintmark variety is nicely represented. The obverse and reverse are both frosty and sharply define with excellent eye appeal. Design elements are lacking slightly, but the overall appearance is excellent. Population: 431 in 66, 6 finer (2/10).

2770

1911-S $20 MS64 NGC. Bold sun-yellow luster with elements of wheat and orange. This well struck near-Gem has a prominent spot on the eagle's upper wing, but abrasions are few.(Registry values: N1793)

2771

1911-S $20 MS65 PCGS. The branch Mint Saint-Gaudens double eagles struck prior to World War I are the common dates, while the Philadelphia Mint issues are the common dates from the Roaring Twenties. This Gem is fully lustrous with brilliant yellow and orange surfaces. PCGS has only certified 23 finer examples of this issue (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2772

1912 $20 MS63 PCGS. CAC. Well struck with rich yellow-orange luster overall. This Select piece is modestly abraded with a few more significant marks, such as a vertical flaw at the bottom of the eagle's lower wing. A line of alloy spots crosses Liberty's hair as it runs from torch to shoulder, and on the reverse, dots of similar color appear at the D of UNITED and the beginning of IN GOD WE TRUST.(Registry values: N1793)

2773

1913 $20 MS62 NGC. Yellow-gold luster and a sharp strike endow the double eagle. Pleasing for the designated grade despite the scattered light marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2774

1913 $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1913 is a scarcer P-mint from this decade and is seldom found above MS63. This piece is atypical for the issue with much brighter luster than usually seen and stronger definition on the design motifs. There are only light, scattered marks on each side, minimal for a coin in this grade, and the surfaces have a slight reddish patina.(Registry values: N1793)

2775

1913 $20 MS64 PCGS. This lustrous yellow-gold near-Gem has exceptional eye appeal due to an absence of the scattered small marks usual for the type. The strike is bold aside from minor blending on the raised knee of Liberty. A mere nine coins have been certified finer by PCGS (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2776

1913 $20 MS64 PCGS. This is the highest grade one can hopefully expect to obtain a 1913 double eagle, as anything finer than near-Gem is rare. Both sides possess great luster and uniform wheat-gold patination. A well executed strike emboldens the design features. Some linear marks are concealed within the eagle's plumage.(Registry values: N2998)

2777

1913-D $20 MS64 PCGS. This lightly patinated D-mint twenty is strongly gold-orange on the obverse, though the reverse is more yellow. An appealing near-Gem with a single significant abrasion at Liberty's waist.(Registry values: N1793)

2778

1913-S $20 AU58 NGC. A scarcely worn, entirely agreeable example of the famously low-mintage 1913-S twenty. Orange-gold surfaces show a handful of abrasions and depressions, with an arc of weakness through UNITED also noted.(Registry values: N1793)

2779

1913-S $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1913-S is a collector favorite because of its deceptively low mintage only 34,000 pieces. However, unlike many later S and D-mint twenties, this issue was apparently spared from the mass meltings of the 1930s. This is an exceptionally clean coin for the grade, the mint luster is nicely frosted, and the surfaces show variegated orange-gold and yellow color.(Registry values: N2998)

2780

1913-S $20 MS64 PCGS. CAC. The lustrous yellow-gold surfaces of this near-Gem example exhibit a better strike than ordinarily seen and are also devoid of the usually seen copper spots. MS64 is the finest grade most collectors can hope to obtain as Gem and finer coins are extremely difficult to locate. Sharp overall.(Registry values: N4719)

2781

1914 $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1914 is obtainable through the Select level of preservation. MS64s are more difficult, Gems are scarce, and finer pieces are rare. This wheat-gold MS63 displays soft luster and reasonably struck design features. Light marks limit the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2782

1914 $20 MS63 PCGS. The 1914 has the distinction of having the lowest mintage from the Philadelphia Mint. However, it is not as scarce as one might imagine because of a number of hoard coins that increased its availability in the MS62-64 grade range. This is an unusually attractive coin for the grade that shows rich reddish patina over soft, frosted mint luster. The striking details are sharp throughout, and only small abrasions are scattered over each side.(Registry values: N1793)

2783

1914 $20 MS63 PCGS. This highly lustrous and frosty double eagle has excellent surface quality for the grade, with above average design definition. Both sides are bright yellow, with rose highlights on the reverse. Here is an excellent example with a high degree of aesthetic appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

2784

1914 $20 MS63 PCGS. A lovely representative of this important low mintage date. Just 95,250 double eagles were coined at Philadelphia in 1914. Today, examples are scarce in higher grades. This Select Mint State piece has rich orange-gold luster with frosty surfaces. Splashes of orange, pale green, and light pink add to its overall eye appeal.(Registry values: N1793)

2785

1914-D $20 MS66 PCGS. The 1914-D is a common date in grades up to and including MS65. The certified population declines precipitously at the Premium Gem level, and MS67 and finer pieces are virtually unobtainable. Occasional splashes of mint-green visit the lustrous peach-gold surfaces of the present MS66 offering and a solid strike manifests itself in sharp detail on the design elements. Some trivial grade-consistent marks do not detract. Population: 56 in 66, 1 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2786

1914-D $20 MS66 PCGS. Strong sun-gold luster with butter-yellow accents. This D-mint Premium Gem is well-defined for the issue, if a trifle soft on Liberty's torch hand, and the surfaces are remarkably smooth. This issue is a borderline condition rarity in this state and virtually unobtainable any finer; PCGS has graded only one such coin (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2787

1914-S $20 MS65 NGC. This gorgeous Saint-Gaudens double eagle has frosty surfaces with brilliant luster and an attractive blend of lemon and pinkish color. The design elements are bold and the surfaces are pleasing, with only a few trivial marks.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2788

1914-S $20 MS66 PCGS. The 1914-S is one of the more common dates in the Saint-Gaudens double eagle series through the MS65 grade level. Premium Gems, such as the present offering, become more challenging and higher-grade pieces are virtually unobtainable. Lustrous brass-gold surfaces exhibit sharply struck devices and are nicely preserved.(Registry values: N2998)

2789

1915 $20 MS62 NGC. Dark patina is evident on the high points of this double eagle, attesting to its original preservation. Both sides have green-gold luster, with moderate bagmarks that are expected at the grade level.(Registry values: N1793)

2790

1915 $20 MS63 NGC. This butter-gold Select twenty is boldly struck and lustrous. Marks are minimal for the designated grade. A low mintage issue, since gold coins were used primarily for foreign exchange payments, which were made hazardous by World War I.(Registry values: N1793)

2791

1915 $20 MS63 PCGS. A powerful strike leaves virtually complete definition on the design elements, including crispness in the panes of the Capitol building. Lustrous, yellow-gold surfaces reveal a few grade-defining marks.(Registry values: N1793)

2792

1915 $20 MS63 PCGS. Exquisitely struck yellow-gold surfaces display pleasing luster. Scattered minute marks limit the grade.(Registry values: N1793)

2793

1915 $20 MS63 PCGS. CAC. A pleasing green-gold Select example of this lower mintage issue. Shimmering, sharply impressed, and only minimally abraded. The final Philadelphia emission until 1920, since double eagles were primarily used for international payments, and trade was constricted by World War I.(Registry values: N1793)

2794

1915-S $20 MS66 PCGS. One of the most common dates of the series with thousands having been certified through MS65. The population drops considerably in Premium Gem and finer pieces are virtually unobtainable. Lustrous peach-gold surfaces exhibit well struck motifs and are minimally marked.(Registry values: N2998)

2795

1916-S $20 MS64 PCGS. Amazing luster is exhibited on both sides of this delightful twenty. The surfaces have a few grade-consisted marks, but the eye appeal is far finer than the grade would suggest.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2796

1916-S $20 MS64 PCGS. The 1916-S was a scarce date until a hoard of about 4,000 Mint State examples turned up in South America in the early 1980s. Dazzling luster endows both sides of this near-Gem, each of which possesses pretty yellow-gold patina. A sharply struck piece kept from Gem by a few small marks.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2797

1916-S $20 MS65 PCGS. This frosty Gem is an incredible example of the desirable 1916-S double eagle coinage, with sharp design features and excellent surfaces. Both sides have a blend of pale green and deep orange that lends considerable eye appeal.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2798

1916-S $20 MS66 PCGS. Only San Francisco struck double eagles in 1916, and its production of 796,000 pieces was the last output of the denomination until 1920. This Premium Gem example, tied for the finest certified by PCGS (2/10), has strong yellow-orange luster and a decidedly above-average strike. A few marks are noted on the reverse, hidden in the eagle's wing feathers.(Registry values: N2998)

2799

1920 $20 MS64 NGC. Among P-mint twenties from this decade, the 1920 is one of the less frequently seen dates, especially in high grades. This is a bright, lustrous example that is well defined in all areas except on Liberty's nose. The surfaces are orange-gold and there are only minimal abrasions (which are overwhelmed by the dominant mint luster).(Registry values: N2998)

2800

1920 $20 MS64 NGC. The 1920 double eagle issue prices close to type in grades through MS63. At the Choice level, however, the price advances dramatically as collectors flock to it as the highest condition that is not a rarity. This near-Gem has apricot-tinged yellow-gold surfaces with impressive luster. Minor marks appear on the eagle's wing, and on the obverse, an abrasion crosses between two rays to the left of Liberty.(Registry values: N2998)

2801

1920 $20 MS64 PCGS. Curiously, the 1920-S has a mintage that is more than twice that of the 1920-P, yet the 1920-S is a major rarity in the series and the P-mint is a relatively common coin. This is, of course, because of the mass meltings in the 1930s--a plague that struck the S-mint coins but largely passed over the P-mint pieces. This is a bright, golden-orange example that is well struck and largely free from abrasions.(Registry values: N2998)

2802

1920 $20 MS64 PCGS. This near-Gem is the finest 1920 double eagle that collectors can hope to locate. PCGS has graded only one finer and NGC seven better. A decisive strike imparts strong definition to the design features, evidenced by the detail in the panes of the Capitol building and the eagle's feathers. Lustrous yellow-gold surfaces are minimally marked.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2803

1920 $20 MS64 PCGS. Many collectors think of the 1920 double eagle as a common date, and while it is plentiful in lower Mint State grades, Gems are extremely rare, placing additional demand on this near-Gem example. NGC and PCGS have certified exactly eight finer pieces (2/10). This specimen has brilliant and highly lustrous honey-gold surfaces with sharp design details and excellent surfaces. Only a few trivial, grade-consistent marks are noted.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2804

1920-S $20 AU58 PCGS. The San Francisco Mint 1920 double eagle is one of the important rarities in the Saint-Gaudens series, an issue that is in strong demand regardless of its grade. This pleasing piece has nearly full light yellow luster with attractive orange toning along the borders. The surfaces are entirely free of marks of consequence. Light wear is, of course, evident on the highest design points, as the grade suggests. The 1920-S is a date that is frequently missing from Saint-Gaudens collections, no matter how advanced. Here is a great opportunity.(Registry values: N4719)

2805

1920-S $20 MS62 NGC. Though more than half a million double eagles were struck in San Francisco in 1920, the first coinage of that denomination on the West Coast after a three-year hiatus, the coins did not achieve widespread distribution, and it is believed many were melted. In the words of Garrett and Guth, from their Encyclopedia of U.S. Gold Coins: "The 1920-S double eagle is one of the most significant rarities of this series. ... No significant numbers have turned up from overseas hoards, and the few that remain are apparently simply here by chance."
Thus, the 1920-S issue marks not only a return, but also a beginning, the beginning of a series of challenging issues, some rare only in high grades but many rare in virtually all grades. The 1920-S straddles the line between the two; it is only a borderline condition rarity at the MS62 level and above, yet there is not a large pool of survivors in the grade below, either.
Garrett and Guth declare that "Many [1920-S twenties] show minor striking weakness on the lower portion of the obverse ..." and also, "Luster is average for this date." Though Liberty's toes show a degree of striking softness, this example's pale yellow-gold luster rates as decidedly above-average. The coin comes by its MS62 grade honestly, with a number of light field abrasions and a small cut on the top of the eagle's near wing, but the visual appeal is strong for a piece not rewarded with a Select designation. An intriguing candidate for the series enthusiast. Census: 19 in 62, 29 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2806

1922 $20 MS64 PCGS. Boldly lustrous with pale yellow-gold color most influential. This well struck near-Gem shows a few small alloy spots in the area near Liberty's midsection.(Registry values: N991)

2807

1922 $20 MS65 PCGS. Though this post-World War I issue is available in grades up to and including Gem, availability falls off a cliff immediately after; PCGS has certified just seven finer examples (1/10). This impressively lustrous, reddish-gold example is solidly struck and carefully preserved.(Registry values: N2998)

2808

1922 $20 MS65 PCGS. The yellow-gold surfaces of this highly lustrous Gem exhibit sharply struck design features, including Liberty's facial features and fingers, the Capitol building, and the eagle's plumage. A few light grade-consistent marks take nothing away from the coin's overall nice eye appeal. Very rare any finer.(Registry values: N2998)

2809

1922 $20 MS65 PCGS. This Gem exudes stunning eye appeal resulting from radiantly lustrous surfaces covered in beautiful orange-gold patination imbued with hints of rose. A solid strike sharpens the design elements, including Liberty's facial features and fingers, the Capitol building, and the eagle's plumage. A few grade-consistent marks and alloy spots are undisturbing. Extremely rare any finer.(Registry values: N2998)

2810

1922 $20 MS65 NGC. A lustrous Gem representative of this much-favored Philadelphia issue. Lightly patinated wheat-gold surfaces show subtle peach overtones on the obverse. Well struck with only a handful of marks, trivial in themselves, which combine to preclude an even finer designation. NGC has graded only eight numerically superior coins (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2811

1922 $20 MS65 PCGS. The 1922 is one of the most plentiful dates in the Saint-Gaudens double eagle series through MS65. Higher-grade coins are extremely rare. Splashes of lilac visit the orange-gold surfaces of this Gem. The luster is outstanding and the design elements are well impressed. Some grade-consistent marks do not detract.(Registry values: N2998)

2812

1922-S $20 AU58 PCGS. Traces of wear are evident on the high points of this lustrous piece. Both sides have light yellow surfaces with frosty luster and traces of pink toning. Abrasions are minimal.(Registry values: N991)

2813

1922-S $20 MS60 NGC. This is an unusual grade for any Saint-Gaudens double eagle. It is truly Mint State, but with myriad marks on the obverse. The reverse is much better and would probably grade MS62 or MS63 if examined separately. The surfaces are brilliant and fully lustrous.(Registry values: N991)

2814

1922-S $20 MS62 PCGS. Careful examination reveals 10 individual alloy spots on the obverse with others on the reverse, giving this double eagle a distinctive character all its own. Both sides are lightly abraded as expected for the grade, with attractive orange and light yellow surfaces.(Registry values: N1793)

2815

1922-S $20 MS64 NGC. CAC. The 1922-S suffered massive meltings in the 1930s and consequently is a difficult date to acquire, especially in the better Mint State grades. Vibrant luster emanates from the brassy-gold surfaces of this near-Gem and a powerful strike delivers strong definition to the design elements. A few minor ticks preclude Gem status.(Registry values: N2998)

2816

1922-S $20 MS64 PCGS. A refreshingly unabraded near-Gem that has sweeping luster and a customary strike. The mintage of the 1922-S is nearly double that of the 1922, but the branch mint issue is much more elusive, since a high percentage of the production never left Treasury vaults and was melted sometime in the 1930s. PCGS has certified only 12 pieces finer (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2817

1922-S $20 MS64 NGC. Another double eagle issue that is available for a price, but at one time considered a great rarity, the 1922-S is nonetheless elusive at the near-Gem level. This specimen displays bold luster over softly frosted, satiny orange-gold surfaces. There are few relevant marks, although the strike is a bit blunt on Liberty's head and right (facing) foot. NGC has certified only 15 pieces finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2818

1924 $20 MS66 PCGS. Lime-green and khaki-gold toning enriches this shimmering and meticulously impressed high grade gold type coin. Only a few delicate luster grazes on the obverse field preclude an even finer third party grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2819

1924 $20 MS67 NGC. The 1924 double eagle is undoubtedly the single most plentiful issue in the entire series from 1907 to 1933. It had the second highest mintage of any Saint-Gaudens twenty with more than 4.3 million coins. Only the 1928 had a higher mintage that soared to 8.8 million pieces. This Superb Gem is highly lustrous with brilliant lemon-yellow surfaces and exceptional eye appeal. NGC and PCGS have graded a total of only three finer coins (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2820

1924-D $20 --Improperly Cleaned--NGC. AU Details. Though telltale hairlines are visible on close inspection, this lightly worn yellow-gold coin retains remarkably strong luster. A handful of shallow pinscratches are present in the fields.(Registry values: N1793)

2821

1924-D $20 MS62 PCGS. Despite a mintage in excess of 3,000,000 pieces, the 1924-D is very scarce today, since most examples never left the Treasury and were eventually transformed into Fort Knox gold bricks. The present lustrous and well struck survivor of the Federal gold recall has wispy field marks but no singularly objectionable marks.(Registry values: N2998)

2822

1924-D $20 MS64 PCGS. The 1924-D is a median rarity in the Saint-Gaudens series, of comparable rarity to the 1925-D and 1926-S. The issue is generally found in the range from AU55 to MS62, although near-Gems and Gems are occasionally available. This piece represents an important opportunity for the advanced date and mintmark collector. The surfaces possess almost the same luster characteristics as the famous 1923-D. Rich rose-golden patina swirls around both sides, with intermittent dashes of pale lilac. Only a couple of abrasions keep this lovely piece from the Gem level: a pair of marks to the right of Liberty's head, and another across the drapery near the knee. An opportunity for the collector to acquire this difficult issue with exceptional surface preservation and luster. PCGS has certified only 11 examples finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2823

1925 $20 MS65 PCGS. The 1925 double eagle is readily available through the MS66 grade level as significant numbers survived in European banks. The apricot-gold surfaces of the current Gem are laced with whispers of mint-green and give off pleasing luster. An exacting strike sharpens the design elements and close inspection reveals no significant marks.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N1793)

2824

1925-D $20 MS64 PCGS. The mintmarked issues in the 1920s are generally characterized by significant mintages, yet most are elusive. Q. David Bowers wrote: "The 1925-D is another entry in the enticing lineup of later-date Saint-Gaudens mintmarks that once were rare, but today are less so, although it remains very elusive. Most are in the lower Mint State ranges and probably came from French banks in recent decades."
Though Choice pieces are available for a price, Gems and better are very rare. This example is an attractive representative with sharp overall definition. In fact, nearly all aspects of the design are boldly rendered. The surfaces have satiny luster with faint reflectivity in the yellow-gold fields, which exhibit subtle rose highlights. PCGS has graded only six pieces finer. (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2825

1925-S $20 MS63 PCGS. At the height of the Roaring Twenties, the San Francisco Mint turned out a record number of Saint-Gaudens double eagles, specifically 3.77 million pieces, a number exceeded only by the 1924 and 1928 Philadelphia issues. Although some examples circulated for a short period, the vast majority of the mintage was melted around 1937. This Select specimen displays pleasing, softly frosted surfaces that are well but not fully struck. A few small- to medium-sized abrasions appear on each side, but most are on the eagle. The bright orange-gold and lilac color further enhances the appeal. Population: 79 in 63, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2826

1925-S $20 MS65 NGC. Mostly meaningless mintage figures, memorable rarities.
That is a theme with variations that plays over and over again as one listens to the history of the Saint-Gaudens double eagle series from conception through near-total destruction, in the case of many issues. While some of the midseries mintmarked double eagles--1911-D, 1915-S, and 1916-S come to mind--are available in considerable quantities, other mintmarked issues fairly close by are the proverbial "hen's teeth" today. Even then, the causes, influences, and reasons for the rarity of one issue compared to another are often unclear, appearing to be happenstance more than circumstance.
Updating his earlier work on U.S. gold series, David Akers wrote of the 1925-S double eagle in the recent Handbook of 20th Century United States Gold Coins 1907-1933:

"Scarce-to-rare in all grades, the 1925-S is one of the leading condition rarities in the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle series. Even MS-64s are elusive, and the combined population of Gems and Superb Gems is fewer than 10 coins. The 1925-S is the only mintmarked Double Eagle from the 1920s that is easier to locate in circulated condition than Mint State."

A comparison between the certified populations at NGC of the 1925-S and 1926-S is useful in regards to Akers' assertion. For the 1925-S, NGC has certified eight XF45, nine AU50, 16 AU53, 26 AU55, and 99 AU58 examples. This produces a total of 158 circulated 1925-S pieces, along with 200-plus Mint State examples up through MS64. At the MS65 level, however, NGC has certified only two coins, and a single MS66 example tops the list.
For the 1926-S, NGC has certified only four AU55 and 12 AU58 specimens, with well over 600 Mint State examples ranging up through MS67. It appears that, unlike for the 1926-S, the Mint did make a conscious decision to try to circulate examples of the 1925-S--or, at least, a considerable number of 1925-S double eagles entered the channels of commerce in some way, with many of them remaining there through the gold recall of 1933.
When we were researching the MS65 PCGS 1925-S double eagle that appeared in our 2010 FUN Platinum Night sale (1/2010, lot 2325, which brought $218,500), we noted this about the issue:

"In 1947, Dr. Charles Green conducted research in mint records which revealed that 454,700 double eagles were officially released by the San Francisco Mint in 1925. The unusually high number of circulated 1925-S double eagles are evidence of this release. A small number of coins was used in international trade, and preserved in European banks. These European holdings surfaced in later years to provide the bulk of the 1925-S population in lower Uncirculated grades we know today. The few Gem or finer specimens were doubtlessly purchased by collectors directly from the San Francisco Mint and carefully preserved over the following decades. The great majority of the mintage, the third largest of the series, was destroyed after the Gold Recall of 1933."

Thus what we see in this issue in toto is not a bifurcation of the survivors, but rather a trifurcation: numerous circulated survivors; a considerable quantity of Mint State specimens that likely constitute mostly overseas recoveries; and a third, highest echelon, the finest few Mint State pieces such as this one that were likely obtained directly from the San Francisco Mint in the year of issue.
Of course, the only substantiation for this assertion is the gleaming surfaces of this Gem coin itself. The mint luster is bright and softly frosted, and there are no mentionable or noticeable contact marks. Yellow-gold color predominates, with a tinge of reddish patina complementing. Only a touch of high point softness appears on Liberty's nose and toes, and the panels of the Capitol building. Census: 2 in 65, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N10218)

2827

1926 $20 MS65 PCGS. Dramatic lemon-gold and peach toning invigorate this lustrous and exactingly struck Gem. Well preserved despite an obscure mark near the reverse rim near 8 o'clock. Encased in a green label holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2828

1926 $20 MS65 PCGS. FS-101. A strong pivot-point tripled die obverse variety, evident on the designer's monogram and nearby rays, as well as the tip of the 9 in the date. The demand for interesting gold Cherrypickers' varieties can only increase over time, since such pieces carry little if any premium today. This is a beautiful butter-gold Gem that boasts booming luster and an impressively unmarked appearance.(Registry values: N1793)

2829

1926 $20 MS66 PCGS. CAC. The bright, lustrous, mostly orange-gold surfaces yield a well frosted sheen. Expectantly smooth for the assigned grade, the features are also possessed of bold striking detail. A few faint swirls of variegated, yet original color are noted in and around the reverse center. Encapsulated in a green label holder.(Registry values: N2998)

2830

1926-D $20 MS61 ANACS. The 1926-D double eagle was at one time--until the early 1950s, when the 1927-D began setting records--considered to be among the rarest Saint-Gaudens issues. A Stack's cataloger in the 1957 Schmandt Collection/Eastern University sale wrote of the 1926-D that it was the "rarest double eagle," even then the tide was turning in favor of the 1927-D.
Today, although Mint State 1926-Ds are still elusive, examples may be had for a price. This coin is strictly Mint State, but it has somewhat subdued luster on the obverse, while the reverse is bright and satiny. The surfaces are consistently light reddish-gold. Several field marks on the obverse help account for the grade.(Registry values: N4719)

2831

1926-D $20 MS62 PCGS. Q. David Bowers praises the 1926-D twenty in his Guide Book of Double Eagle Gold Coins, noting that "Today the 1926-D double remains very elusive, though hardly in the 'impossible' category. Most were probably retained in the United States and melted in the mid-1930s." He also calls it "one of the key issues of the Saint-Gaudens series, with only a few hundred known to exist." The present piece has straw-gold luster with strong orange overtones. A long abrasion is noted in the left obverse field, and several deep marks, possibly reed marks, affect Liberty's leg. Elsewhere, this coin has strong eye appeal of at least Select quality.(Registry values: N4719)

2832

1926-D $20 MS62 PCGS. In the 1940s, the 1926-D double eagle was believed to be an extremely rare coin. The generous mintage of 481,000 pieces was nearly wiped out in the great Gold Recall of the 1930s. Fortunately, some of that mintage was used in international commerce, and a small number of specimens of the issue have been discovered in European holdings over the years. Today, the issue is still the 10th scarcest date in the 54-coin series.
The strike is sharp on the present specimen, with the pillars of the Capitol dome clearly delineated. Satiny mint luster envelops the coin, and only the scattered handling marks limit the grade. Population: 45 in 62, 74 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2833

1926-D $20 MS63 PCGS. An attractive example of one of the key dates in the Saint-Gaudens double eagle series. It was once considered among the greatest rarities in the series, though in the 1950s and 1960s, many double eagles were found in European bank holdings. The 1926-D was never found in hoard quantities, but enough examples were discovered to topple the coin from its premier spot. In recent times, David Akers rated this issue as the thirteenth rarest coin in the 55-coin series.
Today, the 1926-D is almost always seen in MS60-MS63 grades. Circulated examples are curiously uncommon, and Gem specimens are very rare. Most coins seen are well struck, with only a little softness at the periphery. The present coin rates on the high end of the curve and has an above-average strike with just a touch of softness on the capitol dome and pillars. The fields display a scattering of small contact marks, consistent with the grade. The surfaces have unbroken, satiny luster that complements the bold devices to produce outstanding eye appeal. A beautiful and historic prize for the advanced collector. Population: 50 in 63, 24 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2834

1926-S $20 MS62 PCGS. Virtually full luster emanates from the yellow-gold surfaces of this Saint-Gaudens representative. The design elements are generally well impressed, including the peripheral stars, areas that are often weak on this issue. Scattered surface and rim marks, though small, limit the grade.(Registry values: N2998)

2835

1926-S $20 MS64 PCGS. The 1926-S saw a limited degree of circulation and distribution, and examples are available for a price even at the MS64 level, though anything finer is a condition rarity. This Choice coin has above-average detail and strong yellow-orange luster. Scattered small marks combine to account for the grade. PCGS has graded just 31 better pieces (2/10).(Registry values: N2998)

2836

1927 $20 MS65 PCGS. The 1927 has returned from foreign bank holdings in significant quantity, but a sizeable majority of those pieces are bagmarked due to improper storage. The present Gem, however, is not only lustrous and well struck, but is refreshingly free from consequential marks. Housed in a first generation holder.(Registry values: N1793)

2837

1927 $20 MS66 PCGS. Intense luster shows through the peach-gold patina of this Premium Gem. Minimally marked surfaces exhibit well struck design motifs.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2838

1927 $20 MS67 NGC. Each Philadelphia Mint double eagle issue from 1924 to 1928 is considered a common date, and they are all common in lower grades, but all are scarce or rare in Superb Gem grades. For example, NGC and PCGS have combined to certify a mere 67 examples of the 1927 double eagle in MS67, with none finer.
This remarkable piece has highly lustrous lemon-yellow surfaces with satiny fields and frosty devices. Most of the design details on each side are bold, with some weakness evident on the Washington sky line. Census: 50 in 67, 0 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2839

1927 $20 MS67 NGC. The 1927 Saint was minted in large numbers, 2.9 million pieces. But the reason it is a common type coin is not because of its mintage but rather the survival rate. Apparently very few were melted in the mid-1930s, a fortunate occurrence for collectors today as the 1927 was a wonderfully produced coin. This piece exemplifies those high standards of production. The mint luster is thick, frosted, and has a pronounced reddish tinge, actually more resembling a 1928 than the usual yellow-gold 1927. The striking details are strong throughout and there are no mentionable abrasions on either side. Census: 50 in 67, 0 finer (1/10).(Registry values: N4719)

2840

1927-S $20 MS63 NGC. Although it is a rare issue in its own right, the fame of the 1927-S is further increased by its association with its more-famous sibling, the 1927-D double eagle. In the case of the 1927-S, while a few more examples of the issue have been found and repatriated from overseas hoards in recent decades, it has held up well compared to some erstwhile series rarities such as the 1924-S and 1926-D.
This Select Mint State example has beautiful radiant luster emanating from yellow-gold surfaces that show just moderate abrasions consistent with the grade. The Capitol dome is softly struck, as often seen on this issue, along with Liberty's right (facing) foot and sandal. But the coin boasts much appeal throughout, and this coin would make a splendid acquisition for a fine Saint-Gaudens double eagle set. Census: 15 in 63, 28 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N7079)

2841

1927-S $20 MS66 NGC. In today's market, the 1927-S double eagle is somewhat overshadowed by its close cousin, the 1927-D. While the present coin cannot equal the rarity of the Denver issue, it is still an acknowledged key to the Saint-Gaudens double eagle series. Moreover, unlike the 1927-D, most examples of the current issue are seen in circulated or lower Mint State grades. In higher Mint State grades, this date is quite rare. NGC and PCGS, for example, have certified a total of six 1927-S examples in MS66, and a mere three coins grade finer (2/10).
Fifty years ago, the situation was reversed. In that era, the 1927-S was believed to be a fantastic rarity, considerably more desirable than its Denver counterpart. In 1949, B. Max Mehl believed that there were only three or four specimens known. The coin was generally regarded as the fourth-rarest of the design type, behind the 1924-S, 1926-D, and 1926-S. All of those vaunted issues gradually became more available as individual examples were repatriated from European bank holdings in the 1950s and 1960s. The 1927-S never surfaced in hoard quantities (unlike the 1926-S, for example), and its decline in the rarity rankings has been gradual. In recent times, David Akers ranks it as the 10th-rarest issue in the 55-coin series. Not one single example of the 1927-D issue is believed to have surfaced from those sources, and it holds the preeminent spot in the rarity estimates today.
Probably only 160-170 specimens of the 1927-S double eagle survive today. One is certified XF40 by PCGS, and six pieces have been certified as AU50 by PCGS, which suggests that some 1927-S double eagles were actually spent in West Coast commerce prior to the Great Depression. Most Uncirculated survivors grade between MS61 and MS64.
One of the earliest auction appearances of the 1927-S was in the J.F. Bell Collection (Stack's, 12/1944), lot 990, where it realized a price of $500 on a $300 estimate. Two years later, an example appeared in the World's Greatest Collection (Numismatic Gallery, 1/1946), lot 1043. Abe Kosoff showcased the coin in that sale, and it realized $925, a respectable sum for the time. The 1927-S was so rare in its heyday that even legendary collectors such as Louis Eliasberg and John Jay Pittman settled for AU specimens in their collections.
An MS67 NGC coin from the Museum of Connecticut History was sold in the Long Beach sale (Heritage, 6/1995), lot 6027. That piece later appeared in the celebrated sale of the Phillip H. Morse Collection (Heritage, 11/2005), lot 6698. The present coin also appeared in the Morse sale, as lot 6699. Another spectacular specimen was cataloged in the Thaine B. Price sale (David Akers, 5/1998), lot 116. In that offering, Akers described the piece as being "absolutely fully struck."
The current coin possesses a wonderful mix of apricot and yellow-gold patination and exhibits vibrant luster. The design elements are exceptionally well struck, with the Capitol showing excellent definition. It is devoid of significant marks, save for an inoffensive shallow linear abrasion on Liberty's chest. Interestingly though, a slightly curved mint-made "scrape" is noted on the sun. As it runs parallel to the rim, the feature is probably some sort of mint-made flaw, possibly having to do with ejection from the die. The same feature appeared on the Superb Gem coin in lot 6698 of the Phillip H. Morse Collection mentioned above. This circumstance leads us to believe that these two coins were struck from the same reverse die within a relatively short period of time--an interesting coincidence, since both coins were later discovered in the same collection. This is a magnificent specimen that is sure to generate spirited bidding. Census: 4 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).(Registry values: N1)

2842

1928 $20 MS66 PCGS. Wonderfully patinated in orange-gold and mint-green. Radiant luster and sharply struck devices further enhance the coin's eye appeal.
From The JTR Collection.(Registry values: N2998)

2843

1928 $20 MS67 NGC. An ideal type coin for the high-end collector, this Superb Gem is tied for numerically finest known to NGC or PCGS (2/10). Well-defined devices are just as smooth as the broad and lustrous yellow-orange fields. Only the tiniest luster grazes and pinpoint marks are visible on either side.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.(Registry values: N4719)

2844

1929 $20 --Reverse Spot Removed--NGC. Unc Details. It is hard to tell which reverse spot was removed, as many remain, the result of apparent grease on the die that was struck into the coin, leaving a line of multiple dark spots. Otherwise, this remarkable and highly lustrous piece approaches Choice Mint State, with frosty and highly lustrous yellow and pink-gold toning.(Registry values: N4719)

Proof Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles

2845

1911 $20 PR65 NGC. The 1911 matte proof coinage marked the Mint's return to the proof style of 1908--or one similar, at any rate--after the shinier Roman or Satin Finish of 1909 and 1910. The official mintage figure is given as 100 coins, but some of those pre-Depression figures bear little relevance today. Some proof double eagles may have been turned in for face value when hard times hit in the 1920s and 1930s; others have been lost to the various forms of attrition that proof coinage can be subjected to.
We wrote these words in 2006 in the reference The Coinage of Augustus Saint-Gaudens as Illustrated by the Phillip H. Morse Collection concerning the certified survivors:

"In our estimation, probably 40-50 separate pieces are extant today. When the combined populations of NGC and PCGS coins are considered, that is, 54 pieces, it becomes apparent that a few resubmissions must be included in those numbers. When this seemingly inflated number of certified coins is contrasted to the auction data for the 1911, one is struck by the paucity of actual appearances in public sales--no more than two coins per year have appeared in auctions over the past dozen years."

It is interesting to note that four years later, in 2010, the combined NGC/PCGS population remains exactly the same--54 coins. The 1911 matte proofs have a distinctive mustard color, as does this piece. The grade derives from slight shininess over the obverse high points and a few tiny contact marks on the sun. The surfaces show the typical fine-grained pebbly texture characteristic of the issue.
This Gem matte proof 1911 double eagle of the lovely Saint-Gaudens design represents an important opportunity for collectors seeking a worthy addition to a fine gold type set.(Registry values: N7079)

Territorial Gold

2846

(1842-52) G$1 A. Bechtler Dollar, 27G. 21C., Plain Edge AU50 PCGS. CAC. K-24, R.3. Not specifically described as Plain Edge on the holder, but understood since the Reeded Edge variant is extremely rare. Lightly worn with only minor to moderate striking softness. Orange-gold luster is strong and satiny. An appealing example of this popular Southeastern private gold issue. Listed on page 361 of the 2010 Guide Book.

2847

(1842-52) G$1 A. Bechtler Dollar, 27G. 21C., Plain Edge AU55 PCGS. K-24, R.3. This is an attractive representative of this popular Bechtler issue. The rich orange-gold toning is original, and the wavy surfaces display only a few faint marks. Listed on page 361 of the 2010 Guide Book.
Ex: Santa Clara Bullet Sale (Heritage, 11/2001), lot 1707, which realized $2,012.50.

2848

(1842-52) $5 A. Bechtler Five Dollar, 134G. 21C. AU58 NGC. K-27, Low R.5. Canary-gold luster brightens the legends of this lovely orange-toned Borderline Uncirculated Bechtler five. The strike is consistent throughout, and no marks are remotely worthy of description. Without the often-seen die scratch between the IN in CAROLINA, which suggests the present Territorial gold coin was struck relatively early for the die pairing. Struck from widely rotated dies. Kagin-27 is one of the later products of the Bechtler mint, made after the 1842 death of Christopher Sr., the family patriarch. His son Augustus continued production of gold coinage until 1852. Listed on page 361 of the 2010 Guide Book. Census: 11 in 58, 2 finer (2/10).

2849

(1837-42) G$1 C. Bechtler Dollar, N Reversed--Damaged, Planchet Flaws--ANACS. AU50 Details. K-4, R.4. The N in ONE was entered backwards into the die, and the As in the legend lack crossbars. The Bechtler Mint was popular in the antebellum South despite such private mint blunders. This example appears to be completely unworn, but is wavy and has been cleaned. A lamination is prominent above the 8 C in 28 C, and it exhibits pinscratches from an attempt at improvement. Listed on page 360 of the 2010 Guide Book.

2850

1852 $50 Assay Office Fifty Dollar, 887 Thous. AU50 PCGS. K-13, Low R.5. To paraphrase Kagin's description in Private Gold Coins and Patterns of the United States, this octagonal fifty dollar has the same general devices as the earlier "Humbert" pieces, but the legend around the obverse reads UNITED / STATES / ASSAY / OFFICE / OF GOLD / SAN FRANCISCO / CALIFORNIA instead of referencing Humbert by name. A fineness of "887 THOUS" is noted on the ribbon above the eagle, and the date 1852 is below.
Moffat & Co., which had received a federal contract to produce the ingots of the United States Assay Office, lost Mr. Moffat near the end of 1851, when he sold his share of the firm to Curtis, Perry and Ward. In a comment Kagin termed "revealing" and reprinted in his work, Curtis wrote to Treasury Secretary Thomas Corwin that "From the commencement of the performance of the contract ... M. Moffat has employed himself exclusively in other pursuits, and totally neglected every duty at the Assay Office, having been chiefly engaged in Mining." [sic] It seems that even an owner of the Assay Office had trouble resisting the lure of gold!
Curtis, Perry and Ward received a continuation of the Assay Office contract, and they renamed Moffat & Co. the "United States Assay Office of Gold," the name appearing on the present piece. Though the yellow-gold surfaces show clear evidence of wear and numerous abrasions from circulation, considerable luster remains, and the eye appeal is solid. A remarkable and historic example. This lot includes a hardcover edition of American Coin Treasures and Hoards by Q. David Bowers. Listed on page 364 of the 2010 Guide Book.

2851

1853 $20 Assay Office Twenty Dollar, 900 Thous. MS61 NGC. K-18, R.2. Luster dominates the legends, devices, and scrollwork on the present Uncirculated pioneer gold piece. The strike is crisp throughout aside from moderate incompleteness on the claw and arrows above the shield. Most Assay Office examples are notably abraded from their duty performed in Gold Rush commerce, but the present example is uncommonly devoid of marks. A splendid representative from the waning days of the U.S. Assay Office of Gold, which closed its doors in 1853 in anticipation of the opening of the San Francisco Mint the following year. Listed on page 367 of the 2010 Guide Book.

2852

1854 $20 Kellogg & Co. Twenty Dollar--Repaired, Cleaned--ANACS. AU50 Details. Short Arrows, K-1b, R.5. Kellogg & Co. first issued twenty dollar gold coins on February 9, 1854, in response to requests by local businessmen. Four different die marriages are known for 1854 Kellogg & Co. twenties, all of which are very scarce to rare. This is a straw-gold example with little wear and ample glimmering luster in spite of light hairlining. The cheek shows evidence of repair just below the eye. Minor marks are distributed throughout. Listed on page 374 of the 2010 Guide Book.

2853

1855 $20 Kellogg & Co. Twenty Dollar VF25 PCGS. K-3b, R.5. Even after the opening of the San Francisco Mint, the private gold coinage of Territorial issuers played in an important role in the early California state economy, as evidenced by the moderate wear on this Kellogg & Co. twenty. Though softly struck and significantly abraded, this piece has considerable remaining luster in the yellow-gold fields, and consequently, considerable eye appeal. Listed on page 374 of the 2010 Guide Book.
From The Larry V. Cunningham Collection.

2854

1855 $20 Kellogg & Co. Twenty Dollar--Rim Damage--NGC. AU Details. K-3c, R.5. The Short Arrows reverse is combined with an obverse that has the second 5 entirely left of the lowest hair curl. This piece has considerable luster with bright green-gold surfaces. Traces of orange toning add to its eye appeal. The surfaces have a slightly matte appearance, and also suggest that this coin may have been bent. Listed on page 374 of the 2010 Guide Book.

2855

1849 $5 Moffat & Co. Five Dollar VG10 PCGS. K-4a, R.4. The more commonly encountered die state variety for this Territorial issue, with a prominent die break at the denomination. Attractive peach-gold coloration is accented in aqua-green, sky-blue, and lavender. Nice detail for the grade. About one-quarter of the lettering on the crown is visible. Housed in a green label holder. Listed on page 363 of the 2010 Guide Book.

2856

1852 $10 Wass Molitor Ten Dollar, Large Head, Wide Date AU53 NGC. K-4, R.5. There are three die marriages of 1852 Wass Molitor fives, but Kagin-4 is distinctive for its very wide date. An intermediate to late die state with heavy peripheral die cracks. This yellow-gold example displays glimmers of luster, and the minutely granular surfaces lack consequential abrasions. Listed on page 372 of the 2010 Guide Book. Census: 6 in 53, 14 finer (2/10).

2857

1855 $50 Wass Molitor Fifty Dollar--Repaired, Altered Surfaces--NCS. AU Details. K-9, R.5. Samuel Wass and Agoston Molitor were relative late-comers to the coinage business in California, first producing five and ten dollar gold pieces in early 1852. Like Moffat & Co. before them, their gold issues were well-accepted, because their five dollar gold coins were found to contain $5.04 worth of gold bullion when assayed. When the San Francisco Mint experienced production difficulties in its early years of operation, Wass, Molitor & Co. was one of the firms that helped meet the local demand for coinage. The fifty dollar denomination was struck in 1855, using a design that closely resembles the Liberty Head double eagles of the period.
The coins actually circulated far beyond the boundaries of California, and one piece found its way into the collection of Englishman John G. Murdoch. When the collection was auctioned by Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge in July 1903, lot 679 was the Wass, Molitor & Co. fifty. The lot was purchased by one of the Chapman brothers for the enormous sum of 84 pounds (about $400). To put this in perspective, one of the finest known 1794 silver dollars, the coin that later appeared in the George Earle, Harry Bass, and Phillip Flanagan Collections, brought only 48 pounds at this sale (as lot 835).
The present example, in AU50 Details, shows a few minor contact marks and rim bruises that would be expected with such heavy gold coins, but there are no distracting abrasions. The piece possesses generous appeal, in spite of the distractions noted on the holder. Listed on page 373 of the 2010 Guide Book.

S.S. Central America Gold Bars

2858

Harris Marchand & Co. 18.41 Ounce Gold Ingot. Ex: S.S. Central America. CAGB-127. Serial number 6510, 18.41 oz, 712 fine, stamped value $270.96. An infrequently encountered assayer compared to Justh & Hunter or Kellogg & Humbert, though at just over three dozen ingots recovered, the Harris, Marchand & Co. imprint is more accessible than a number of others. In his A California Gold Rush History, Q. David Bowers lists a number of attributes for the Harris, Marchand & Co. ingots as a class: "Nearly all of the ingots display irregular alignment of numerals and many have irregular letter alignment as well. Most bars have rather rough surfaces ... Save for the finely crafted hallmark and the curved logotype with the company name, most imprinting is rustic."
The hallmark bears further attention; as Bowers notes, Harris, Marchand & Co. "... [original italicized] is the only firm that used a coin-die style hallmark on its ingots." This hallmark takes the form of an all-seeing eye surrounded by rays and flanked left and right by five-pointed stars, which separate the words MARCHAND / ESSAYEUR. The broad circular field is the only significant area on which this ingot shows truly smooth surfaces.
The ingot's main face, read as oriented with the corner cut at upper left, states NO [line below O] 6510 / [curving] HARRIS MARCHAND & CO / [hallmark]. From there, the north face lists the value of $270.96, the south face has [upside down] 712 FINE, and the east face has 18.41 OZ, with dots below both letters. Overall color is light yellow-gold with deep red encrustation at parts of the hallmark, the beginning and end of the curved imprint, a line at the lower right part of the main face, and at the bottom halves of the digits in 712. A memorable shipwreck ingot that offers a different perspective on the California Gold Rush.
Ex: FUN 2002 (Heritage, 1/2002), lot 7904.

California Fractional Gold

2859

1854 25C Liberty Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-105, R.3, MS66 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. A beautiful canary-gold Premium Gem. Boldly struck and flawless. The usual obverse die state with a lapped Liberty missing low relief hair detail. Census: 3 in 66 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).

2860

1856 25C Liberty Round 25 Cents, BG-230, Low R.4, MS65 NGC. A precisely struck orange-red Gem with satin luster and undisturbed surface. Unimprovable quality for this collectible Period One variety. Census: 3 in 65, 0 finer (2/10).

2861

1856 50C Liberty Octagonal 50 Cents, BG-307, High R.5, MS63 NGC. A pleasing green-gold representative of this challenging Period One octagonal half variety. The denominator is boldly repunched. Moderately prooflike, although undesignated as such. Census: 2 in 63, 1 finer (2/10).

2862

1853 $1 Liberty Octagonal 1 Dollar, BG-522, High R.6, XF45 PCGS. An appreciably worn yet mildly lustrous example of this very rare variety, yellow-gold overall with few abrasions. Considerable eye appeal. Population: 1 in 45, 12 finer (1/10).

2863

1869 25C Liberty Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-712, High R.4, MS65 PCGS. Generally well struck with greenish-gold luster emanating from both sides. A hair-thin mark is located under AR of DOLLAR.

2864

1871 25C Liberty Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-720, R.7, MS65 PCGS. A beautiful honey-gold Gem that is free from any abrasions or planchet defects. The very rare BG-720 variety is notable for its oversized head of Liberty and fragmented stars, which were partly lapped away during the obverse die preparation. Population: 2 in 65, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: New England Rare Coins, 5/1978; Jay Roe Collection (Bowers and Merena, 9/2003), lot 164.

2865

1872 25C Washington Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-722, Low R.4, MS66 PCGS. Part of the popular Washington portrait subset of California small denomination gold, which is a change of pace from the usual Indian and Liberty heads. This is a fully prooflike, sharply struck, and pristine Premium Gem. A minute lintmark between stars 4 and 5 provides an identifier. Population: 29 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).

2866

1873 25C Liberty Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-728, R.3, MS66 PCGS. A high-end example of this relatively available (though still scarce) octagonal quarter dollar issue. Strongly struck with bold yellow-gold luster and impressive preservation. Population: 24 in 66, 2 finer (2/10).

2867

1871 25C Liberty Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-767, R.3, MS61 NGC. Incorrectly certified as BG-766 by NGC. A flashy yellow-gold Gem with exceptional eye appeal. Nicely struck, especially on the portrait. The obverse die is shattered with several die cracks, at the border and internally.

2868

1875 25C Indian Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-797, Low R.4, MS64 PCGS, a beautiful undipped khaki-gold example, one minute aqua speck above the 7 in the date, housed in an old green label holder; and an 1871 Liberty Round 25 Cents, BG-864, R.5, MS63 PCGS, lemon-tinged and satiny with impressive surfaces for the certified grade.

2869

1874 25C Indian Octagonal 25 Cents, BG-799Q, High R.5, MS67 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. Attributed by a widely repunched third star, while the right leg of the R in DOLLAR points to a berry. Well struck with dazzling prooflike fields. Struck with medal turn. This beautiful Superb Gem is the highest-graded example at either of the major services. Census: 1 in 67 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: FUN Signature (Heritage, 1/2007), lot 6816, which realized $4,025.

2870

1872 25C Liberty Round 25 Cents, BG-814, High R.5, MS65 Prooflike NGC. A decidedly reflective Gem whose strike is exemplary aside from slight incompleteness on the denominator. As of (2/10), the single finest example certified by NGC.
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 2/2007), lot 6256.

2871

1873 25C Liberty Round 25 Cents, BG-817, R.3, MS66 NGC. A flashy high grade sun-gold example of this popular variety, which loosely imitates the Federal Type One gold dollar. Well struck for BG-817, which is usually softly brought up at the centers. Census: 4 in 66, 0 finer (2/10).

2872

1872 25C Washington Round 25 Cents, BG-818, Low R.4, MS64 PCGS. A lovely canary-gold near-Gem whose only deficiency is an incomplete strike on a few of the central reverse letters. The Washington type is popular, since most Period Two varieties exhibit a Liberty or Indian portrait. Population: 30 in 64, 26 finer (2/10).

2873

1872 25C Washington Round 25 Cents, BG-818, Low R.4, MS65 NGC. A semiprooflike canary-gold Gem that exhibits smooth fields and pleasing eye appeal. A few letters in the reverse legends lack an absolute strike, as is customary for the variety. Listed on page 380 of the 2010 Guide Book, where it is priced above all other round quarter types. Census: 2 in 65, 1 finer (2/10).

2874

1876 25C Liberty Round 25 Cents, BG-854, Low R.5, MS65 Prooflike NGC. The so-called "Baby Head" variety. The low relief engraving of Liberty has a naive expression. Light peach toning visits this flashy and unabraded Gem. As of (2/10), the single finest certified by NGC.

2875

1876 25C Liberty Round 25 Cents, BG-855, R.7, MS65 NGC. An extremely rare "Baby Head" variety in high grade. Rose-red and autumn-gold fills the borders, while the centers are yellow-gold. The present example is the plate coin for the BG-855 variety in the Second Edition of Breen-Gillio, which also confirms it belonged to Jay Roe, the best-known collector of California fractional gold. Census: 2 in 65, 0 finer (2/10).
Ex: Harmer-Rourke, 2/1978, lot 76; Jay Roe Collection (Bowers and Merena, 9/2003), lot 339.

2876

1872/1 25C Indian Round 25 Cents, BG-869, Low R.4, MS65 Prooflike NGC. A beautiful pumpkin-gold Gem with an exemplary strike and pristine preservation. A prominent vertical die crack bisects the reverse. Census: 4 in 65 Deep Mirror Prooflike, 1 finer as MS66 Prooflike (2/10).

2877

1874 25C Indian Round 25 Cents, BG-876, Low R.4, MS66 Prooflike NGC. A prominently mirrored Premium Gem that has a bold strike and a pristine appearance. The reverse displays two lengthy and spindly die cracks, usual for the variety. Census: 2 in 66 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).

2878

1875 25C Indian Round 25 Cents, BG-878, R.3, MS67 Deep Mirror Prooflike NGC. Magnificent field reflectivity ensures the eye appeal of this outstanding California small denomination gold piece. This variety appears with some regularity at auction in MS62 through MS64 grades, but an example of the present superlative quality may not emerge again for many years. Census: 2 in 67 Deep Mirror Prooflike, none finer (2/10).

2879

1852 25C Indian Round 25 Cents, BG-891, Low R.5, MS65 PCGS. The well struck obverse is immaculate and has the look of a cameo proof. The reverse is also prooflike and has a slightly concave center that shows traces of the planchet surface. The sole 1852 round quarter Period Two variety. Population: 12 in 65, 1 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.

2880

1859 50C Liberty Octagonal 50 Cents, BG-902, Low R.4, MS66 Prooflike NGC. Undisturbed, prominently mirrored fields and sharply struck devices confirm the lofty third party grade. The consignor of this lot has many outstanding Condition Census lots in the present auction, all of which likely will prove impossible to upgrade by even the most dedicated specialist. Census: 2 in 66 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).

2881

1871 50C Liberty Octagonal 50 Cents, BG-912, R.3, MS65 Prooflike NGC. Dazzling field reflectivity ensures the eye appeal of this nicely struck and nearly pristine Gem. An available variety, but usually seen in lesser grades. Census: 3 in 65 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).

2882

1872 50C Liberty Octagonal 50 Cents, BG-914, R.4, MS66 Prooflike NGC. A thoroughly lustrous apricot-gold representative that boasts a good strike and obvious eye appeal. One hair-thin mark rests on the lower left obverse. Census: 2 in 66 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).

2883

1872 50C Indian Octagonal 50 Cents, BG-940, R.4, MS65 Prooflike NGC. Yellow-gold surfaces yield a degree of field-motif contrast over each side. Well struck for the issue and devoid of mentionable impairments. Census: 2 in 65 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).

2884

1873 50C Indian Octagonal 50 Cents, BG-942, Low R.5, MS65 Prooflike NGC. This alertly struck piece has impressive reflectivity and attractive preservation. Minor laminations bookend the fraction and separate CAL and DOLLAR. The finest example of BG-942 certified by NGC (2/10).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 2/2007), lot 6268, which realized $1,495.

2885

1876 50C Indian Octagonal 50 Cents, BG-950, R.7, MS64 PCGS. Flashy mirrored fields and a pristine reverse demonstrate the eye appeal of this rare variety octagonal half. The central reverse shows minor incompleteness of strike, although DOLLAR is more clear than on the Breen-Gillio Second Edition plate coin. Population: 3 in 64, 2 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.

2886

1860/56 50C Liberty Round 50 Cents, BG-1014, High R.4, MS65 PCGS. Struck by Robert B. Gray & Co., described by Breen-Gillio as "successors to Antoine Louis Nouizillet." This yellow-gold piece is well struck and nearly devoid of contact. The reverse has a network of fine die cracks. This is one of two Gems graded by PCGS, with none finer (1/10).

2887

1871 50C Liberty Round 50 Cents, BG-1027, R.3, MS64 Prooflike NGC. A nicely mirrored and typically struck straw-gold near-Gem. One inconspicuous thin mark above the portrait barely merits mention. The single finest NGC-certified example (2/07).

2888

1876 50C Indian Round 50 Cents, BG-1038, R.4, MS65 Prooflike NGC. An unabraded canary-gold Gem that has good reflectivity and a consistent strike. A slender retained lamination at 9 o'clock on the reverse will pedigree this high grade example. Mildly wavy, as made. Tied with one other NGC example as finest certified (2/10).
Ex: Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 2/2007), lot 6273, which realized $1,380.

2889

1871 50C Liberty Round 50 Cents, BG-1046, Low R.7, Genuine PCGS. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. In our opinion, this coin has the details of an Uncirculated specimen that has had an obverse spot tooled. Aside from misguided attempts to scratch away a spot in the lower left obverse field, this is a bright, unworn yellow-gold example of an elusive die pair.

2890

1873/2 50C Indian Round 50 Cents, BG-1050, Low R.6, MS65 Prooflike NGC. An immaculate Gem with excellent field reflectivity. Perfect aside from the minute mint-made strike-throughs usual for this issue. A rare variety noteworthy for its crude conversion of the 2 in the date into a 3. The Indian appears to be wearing a nose ring, another diagnostic for BG-1050. Census: 2 in 65 Prooflike, 1 finer (2/10).

2891

1875 50C Indian Round 50 Cents, BG-1056, High R.4, MS66 Prooflike NGC. A lovely orange-gold Premium Gem, crisply struck and flawless aside from faint mint-produced roller marks on the central reverse. A network of spindly die cracks criss-crosses the reverse. Census: 3 in 66 Prooflike, 0 finer (2/10).

2892

1880 50C Indian Round 50 Cents, BG-1068, High R.5, MS63 Prooflike NGC. Fantastically reflective surfaces shine with pale yellow-gold luster. Lightly abraded across the reverse but a desirable example of this rare variant nonetheless.

2893

1868 $1 Liberty Octagonal 1 Dollar, BG-1105, High R.4, MS60 PCGS. Bright green-gold and prooflike with a typical light strike in the centers. Struck from a shattered reverse die. A pleasing example of the only Period Two 1868 octagonal dollar variety.
Ex: Central States Signature (Heritage, 4/2002), lot 7582; Long Beach Signature (Heritage, 6/2005), lot 8318.

2894

1868 $1 Liberty Octagonal 1 Dollar, BG-1105, High R.4, MS62 PCGS. A prooflike orange-gold Period Two octagonal dollar that has the usual incompleteness of strike at the centers, due to the high relief of the portrait. Both fields display faint hairlines. Population: 12 in 62, 18 finer (2/10).

2895

1875 $1 Indian Octagonal 1 Dollar, BG-1126, R.5, MS62 PCGS. Green-gold overall with hints of lilac on the highpoints. Evenly struck and unblemished. A scarce octagonal dollar pairing. Population: 8 in 62, 9 finer (2/10).
From The JTR Collection.

2896

1876/5 $1 Indian Octagonal 1 Dollar, BG-1129, R.4 MS64 PCGS. This decidedly prooflike near-Gem has a good strike, and is essentially pristine save for a single hair-thin diagonal mark on the field in front of the forehead. The maker performed the overdate by engraving a crude, thick upright to the 5 in the date. Encapsulated in an old green label holder. Population: 12 in 64, 0 finer (2/10).

2897

1871 $1 Liberty Round 1 Dollar, BG-1201, High R.6, MS63 PCGS. An important example of this rare Period Two variety. The luster is between satiny and prooflike, and the lemon-gold toning is highly attractive. Well struck with clean surfaces. Round dollars are a challenging entry in a Guide Book type set of the series. Population: 2 in 63, 0 finer (2/10).

2898

1870 $1 Liberty Round 1 Dollar, BG-1203, Low R.5, AU55 NGC. A lustrous example that is softly struck but shows little if any evidence of mishandling. One faint pinscratch passes through the AR in DOLLAR. Period Two round dollars are scarce, as there are only eight varieties. Census: 1 in 55, 3 finer (2/10).

Session 5

Colonials

7001

(1694) TOKEN London Elephant Token, Thick Planchet--Rim Damage--NGC. Good Details. NGC Census: (1/31). PCGS Population (1/149). (#55)

7002

(1694) TOKEN London Elephant Token, Thick Planchet--Damaged--NGC. Fair Details. NGC Census: (1/30). PCGS Population (4/140). (#55)

7003

1723 PENNY Rosa Americana Penny Fine 15 PCGS. PCGS Population (2/66). NGC Census: (0/14). (#125)

7004

1723 FARTH Hibernia Farthing, D:G:REX XF40 NGC. NGC Census: (0/2). PCGS Population (1/36). (#173)

7005

1723 FARTH Hibernia Farthing, D:G:REX AU58 PCGS. PCGS Population (5/29). NGC Census: (0/2). (#173)

7006

1723 FARTH Hibernia Farthing, DEI GRATIA AU53 PCGS. PCGS Population (9/118). NGC Census: (4/29). (#176)

7007

1723 1/2P Hibernia Halfpenny VF25 PCGS. PCGS Population (21/349). NGC Census: (3/93). (#180)

7008

1723 1/2P Hibernia Halfpenny XF45 NGC. NGC Census: (14/65). PCGS Population (25/247). (#180)

7009

1723 1/2P Hibernia Halfpenny XF45 NGC. NGC Census: (15/65). PCGS Population (25/247). (#180)

7010

1773 1/2P Virginia Halfpenny, Period--Damaged--NCS. VF Details. NGC Census: (0/80). PCGS Population (2/239). (#240)

7011

1760 1/2P Hibernia-Voce Populi Halfpenny Fine 12 PCGS. PCGS Population (5/232). NGC Census: (3/68). (#262)

7012

1760 1/2P Hibernia-Voce Populi Halfpenny, VOOE POPULI XF45 NGC. NGC Census: (2/5). PCGS Population (3/6). (#265)

7013

1788 1C Massachusetts Cent, No Period--Rim Damage--NCS. VF Details. NGC Census: (0/0). PCGS Population (0/2). (#293)

7014

1787 COPPER Connecticut Copper, Mailed Bust Left VF30 NGC. NGC Census: (6/19). PCGS Population (6/30). (#349)

7015

1787 COPPER Connecticut Copper, Draped Bust Left VF20 NGC. NGC Census: (5/38). PCGS Population (70/293). (#370)

7016

1787 COPPER Connecticut Copper, Draped Bust Left VF25 PCGS. PCGS Population (74/219). NGC Census: (8/30). (#370)

7017

1786 COPPER New Jersey Copper, Narrow Shield VG8 NGC. NGC Census: (4/40). PCGS Population (4/171). (#496)

7018

1786 COPPER New Jersey Copper, Narrow Shield Fine 12 PCGS. PCGS Population (9/153). NGC Census: (2/38). (#496)

7019

1786 COPPER New Jersey Copper, Narrow Shield VF30 NGC. NGC Census: (4/23). PCGS Population (22/63). (#496)

7020

1787 COPPER New Jersey Copper, Large Planchet, Plain Shield VF35 PCGS. PCGS Population (21/56). NGC Census: (1/23). (#509)

7021

1787 COPPER New Jersey Copper, Camel Head--Corrosion--NGC. Fine Details. Overstruck. NGC Census: (0/5). PCGS Population (1/55). (#515)

7022

1783 COPPER Nova Constellatio Copper, Pointed Rays, Large US VF25 PCGS. PCGS Population (6/62). NGC Census: (1/21). (#804)

Federal Contract Coinage

7023

1787 1C Fugio Cent, STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils, Pointed Rays--Damaged--NCS. Good Details. NGC Census: (2/248). PCGS Population (3/935). (#883)

7024

1787 1C Fugio Cent, New Haven Restrike, Copper MS64 Brown NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (7/1). PCGS Population (18/6). (#916)

Colonials

7025

(1792-94) TOKEN Kentucky Token, LANCASTER Edge AU58 NGC. NGC Census: (5/27). PCGS Population (23/71). (#623)

7026

1783 1C Washington & Independence Cent, Large Military Bust--Environmental Damage--NCS. AU Details. NGC Census: (4/31). PCGS Population (21/69). (#667)

7027

1783 1C Washington Unity States Cent--Environmental Damage--NGC. VF Details. NGC Census: (1/86). PCGS Population (10/256). (#689)

7028

1783 1C Washington Unity States Cent--Rev Scratched--NGC. VF Details. NGC Census: (1/86). PCGS Population (10/256). (#689)

7029

1793 1/2P Washington Ship Halfpenny, Copper, Lettered Edge AU55 NGC. NGC Census: (7/6). PCGS Population (32/19). (#734)

Half Cents

7030

1794 1/2 C PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surfaces as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. Mintage: 81,600. (#1003)(Registry values: P7, N7)

7031

1794 1/2 C PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. Mintage: 81,600. (#1003)(Registry values: P7, N7)

7032

1794 1/2 C --Corroded--ANACS. Fine 12 Details. NGC Census: (10/114). PCGS Population (20/251). Mintage: 81,600. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in Fine 12: $1,225. (#1003)(Registry values: P7)

7033

1795 1/2 C Lettered Edge PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .97 suggests Environmental Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. Mintage: 81,600. (#1003)(Registry values: P6, N6)

7034

1795 1/2 C Plain Edge PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. Mintage: 139,690. (#1018)(Registry values: P6, N6)

7035

1795 1/2 C Plain Edge VG10 PCGS. PCGS Population (18/148). NGC Census: (2/63). Mintage: 139,690. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VG10: $1,038. (#1018)(Registry values: P6)

7036

1797 1/2 C Plain Edge PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. Mintage: 127,840. (#1036)(Registry values: P6, N6)

7037

1797 1/2 C Plain Edge--Corrosion--NGC. VG Details. C-2. NGC Census: (0/6). PCGS Population (6/103). Mintage: 127,840. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VG8 : $600. (#1036)(Registry values: P6)

7038

1800 1/2 C VF30 PCGS. PCGS Population (17/120). NGC Census: (5/100). Mintage: 202,908. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VF30: $334. (#1051)
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P5)

7039

1800 1/2 C --Scratched--ANACS. VF35 Details. C-1. NGC Census: (0/0). PCGS Population (12/108). Mintage: 202,908. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VF35: $383. (#1051)(Registry values: P5)

7040

1802/0 1/2 C Reverse of 1802 PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. mintage: 20,266. (#1057)(Registry values: P7, N7)

7041

1804 1/2 C Plain 4, No Stems--Obverse Double Struck--PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .94 suggests Altered Surface as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. Ex:JL Brobston. Mintage: 1,055,312. (#1063)(Registry values: P4, N4)

7042

1804 1/2 C Plain 4, No Stems VF30 PCGS. PCGS Population (36/490). NGC Census: (27/611). Mintage: 1,055,312. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VF30: $219. (#1063)(Registry values: P4)

7043

1804 1/2 C Plain 4, No Stems VF35 NGC. NGC Census: (1/178). PCGS Population (43/446). Mintage: 1,055,312. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VF35: $247. (#1063)(Registry values: P4)

7044

1804 1/2 C Plain 4, No Stems--Environmental Damage--NGC. XF Details. C-13. NGC Census: (37/557). PCGS Population (53/394). Mintage: 1,055,312. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in XF40: $300. (#1063)(Registry values: P4)

7045

1804 1/2 C Plain 4, No Stems XF40 PCGS. PCGS Population (53/393). NGC Census: (37/557). Mintage: 1,055,312. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in XF40: $300. (#1063)(Registry values: P4)

7046

1804 1/2 C Crosslet 4, Stems VF30 PCGS. PCGS Population (19/156). NGC Census: (0/0). Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VF30: $235. (#1069)(Registry values: P4)

7047

1804 1/2 C Spiked Chin--Scratched--ANACS. AU50 Details. C-8. NGC Census: (22/80). PCGS Population (23/57). Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in AU50: $615. (#1075)(Registry values: P4)

7048

1805 1/2 C Small 5, No Stems VF35 NGC. NGC Census: (7/75). PCGS Population (10/78). Mintage: 814,464. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in VF35: $251. (#1081)(Registry values: P5)

7049

1809 1/2 C AU50 PCGS. PCGS Population (18/105). NGC Census: (11/161). Mintage: 1,154,572. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in AU50: $225. (#1123)(Registry values: P3)

7050

1811 1/2 C PCGS Genuine. The PCGS number ending in .98 suggests Damage as the reason, or perhaps one of the reasons, that PCGS deemed this coin not gradable. Mintage: 63,140. (#1135)(Registry values: P7, N7)

7051

1825 1/2 C XF45 PCGS. PCGS Population (24/134). NGC Census: (12/147). Mintage: 63,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in XF45: $229. (#1141)(Registry values: P3)

7052

1825 1/2 C MS61 Brown NGC. NGC Census: (9/52). PCGS Population (1/47). Mintage: 63,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS61: $625. (#1141)(Registry values: P3)

7053

1826 1/2 C XF45 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population (25/142). NGC Census: (11/173). Mintage: 234,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in XF45: $155. (#1144)
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P3)

7054

1828 1/2 C 12 Stars MS61 Brown NGC. C-2. NGC Census: (16/29). PCGS Population (0/31). Mintage: 606,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS61: $575. (#1150)(Registry values: P1)

7055

1829 1/2 C MS63 Brown PCGS. PCGS Population (31/29). NGC Census: (27/54). Mintage: 487,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS63: $460. (#1153)(Registry values: P3)

7056

1833 1/2 C XF40 PCGS. C-1. B-1. R-1. PCGS Population (17/382). NGC Census: (7/349). Mintage: 120,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in XF40: $94. (#1162)(Registry values: P1)

7057

1834 1/2 C XF45 PCGS. CAC. C-1. R-1. B-1. PCGS Population (32/291). NGC Census: (18/349). Mintage: 141,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in XF45: $102. (#1165)(Registry values: P1)

7058

1834 1/2 C MS64 Brown NGC. NGC Census: (78/28). PCGS Population (50/12). Mintage: 141,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS64: $535. (#1165)(Registry values: P1)

7059

1835 1/2 C MS64 Brown NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (110/53). PCGS Population (105/22). Mintage: 398,000. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS64: $550. (#1168)(Registry values: P1)

7060

1835 1/2 C AU58 PCGS. PCGS Population (0/190). NGC Census: (1/119). Mintage: 398,000. (#1169)(Registry values: P1)

7061

1850 1/2 C MS63 Brown PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population (34/22). NGC Census: (24/16). Mintage: 39,800. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS63: $635. (#1221)(Registry values: P3)

7062

1851 1/2 C AU55 PCGS. PCGS Population (57/238). NGC Census: (18/398). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in AU55: $150. (#1224)(Registry values: P2)

7063

1851 1/2 C AU55 PCGS. PCGS Population (57/238). NGC Census: (19/398). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in AU55: $150. (#1224)(Registry values: P2)

7064

1851 1/2 C MS62 Brown PCGS. PCGS Population (55/96). NGC Census: (101/169). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS62: $250. (#1224)(Registry values: P2)

7065

1851 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. B-1. NGC Census: (16/1). PCGS Population (0/1). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS65: $800. (#1224)(Registry values: P2)

7066

1851 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. NGC Census: (16/1). PCGS Population (0/1). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS65: $800. (#1224)(Registry values: P2)

7067

1851 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. B-1. NGC Census: (16/1). PCGS Population (0/1). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS65: $800. (#1224)(Registry values: P2)

7068

1851 1/2 C MS65 Brown NGC. NGC Census: (16/1). PCGS Population (0/1). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS65: $800. (#1224)(Registry values: P2)

7069

1851 1/2 C MS63 Red and Brown PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population (50/14). NGC Census: (27/16). Mintage: 147,672. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in MS63: $380. (#1225)
From The Classic Collection.(Registry values: P2)

7070

1853 1/2 C AU50 PCGS. PCGS Population (29/514). NGC Census: (8/668). Mintage: 129,694. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC/PCGS coin in AU50: $120. (#1227)(Registry values: P1)

7071